Have the gates of death been revealed to you, or have you seen the gates of deep darkness?
Job 38:17 · ESVView all translations

God's questioning of Job moves down from the springs of the sea to the one place no living person has ever explored — the realm of the dead. This is not a riddle about geography. Job has been arguing about God's ways, so God asks him one thing: does he know where death takes people?

What the Gates Are

Where the ESV has "the gates of deep darkness," older translations read "the shadow of death." One commentator explains what lies behind those gates:

Now He goes down lower still. Sheol, or Hades, as we have it — that is, the place where departed spirits are kept — is pictured here as the heart of the earth, and it may in fact be so. It is not the same thing as the lake of fire. But here we have a prison for those who have died.

William Kelly

The Force of the Question

Another writer weighs the question against all the dead the world has already swallowed:

Had the gates of death been opened to him? (v.17). Of course the seas have swallowed countless millions of people, including those drowned in the flood of Noah's day. But apart from this, did Job understand where death had taken all those it had claimed through the years?

Leslie M. Grant

Why God Asks

God's questions come in a long chain. One commentator explains what they were doing to Job:

The first thing God does is to overwhelm him. This man claimed to sit in judgment on God's moral ways. So God fills him with a sense of his utter ignorance and helplessness before the least works of divine power, even in creation… A man whose understanding was baffled by such a question was in no position to judge God's deep things… Had the gates of death been revealed to him?

William Kelly

Another writer names the aim behind the whole series:

What is the aim of the Lord in putting these questions? To show that God is greater than man and to humble man, to bring Job to the needed true knowledge of himself and to deliver him from the pride of his heart.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

Still Addressed to Us

One commentator ties this question to the "secret things" that belong to God, and puts it to readers now:

Does he know the secret things — those "which belong to God"? The hidden depths of the sea with its countless dead; the gates of death and what lies beyond. Has Job searched this out?… Does modern science truly know it?… Jehovah addresses these questions not only to Job, whose knowledge was limited to his own time, but to people today.

Samuel Ridout

The same writer points to where the answers lie:

What is the key to all these questions? It is God, the true knowledge of Himself. Knowing Him, we know the Author and Source of all knowledge. Leave Him out, and the sum of all science is a blank wall, with the hidden truth still lying beyond it.

Samuel Ridout

What the Questions Produced in Job

The questions had an effect. Job answered God twice:

Job had dared to sit in judgment on Jehovah and His ways. So God tests whether he is fit for it: what does he know? What can he do?… Job's two answers show the effect. In the first, he humbles himself and lays his hand on his mouth. In the second, he fully confesses his sinful pride and hates what he is. This prepares the way for his outward recovery and return to prosperity.

Samuel Ridout

The Gates Finally Opened

No man could answer God's question — but One has since passed through those gates and come back:

In no other way could the gates of death be opened for us than by His resurrection from the dead. He has opened them, and He holds their keys, as the One who lives forever. To all who put their faith in Him He says, "Fear not, I am the first and the last, and the living one. I died, and behold I am alive forevermore, and I have the keys of Death and Hades" (Rev. 1:17-18). He is Master of death and the grave… He has flooded the darkness of death with the light of hope.

J. T. Mawson

Summary

- Gates. The question points to Sheol, where departed spirits are kept. It is a prison for the dead, and it is not the lake of fire.

- Locked. Job had never been through them. He could speak about death, but he did not know where death had taken the millions it had claimed.

- Purpose. God asks what Job cannot answer. The aim is to humble a man who sat in judgment on His ways and to free him from the pride of his heart.

- Ours. The questions still stand. They reach people today, and without the knowledge of God all our science ends at a blank wall.

- Opened. Job laid his hand on his mouth. We have the answer he never got: Christ has opened the gates of death by rising, and He holds the keys of Death and Hades.

Reviewed by Orion on September 6, 2026