then let my shoulder blade fall from my shoulder, and let my arm be broken from its socket.
Job's last speech closes with a string of solemn oaths. Each one names a sin he denies. Then he calls down a punishment on himself if the denial is false. Verse 22 is one of those punishments. Job offers up the very arm he could have raised against an orphan, broken out of its socket.
The Charge He Is Answering
The arm comes into it because of a hand Job never lifted. He is thinking of a court case he could have won, and of the orphan he could have crushed by winning it.
Samuel RidoutWhile dwelling on his kindness, Job shows how he had not taken advantage of any legal technicality that would have cleared him in any harsh dealing with the needy. When he saw his "help in the gate" — the judges leaning to decide in his favour — he had not pressed his case against the orphans. They were not bribed; they were giving him his just dues. If he had lifted his hand against them, he says, "let my arm drop from my shoulder-blade."
(Ridout quotes verse 22 from an older translation here.)
Not Only What He Did
The oath covers things left undone as much as things done.
Leslie M. GrantIn verses 16-21 he speaks of sins of omission also. Suppose he had not helped the poor, or had ignored the plight of the widow, but had kept everything for himself, so that the fatherless went hungry. Suppose he had seen anyone perish for lack of clothing, or any poor man without covering. Suppose the heart of the poor had not blessed Job, because the fleece of his sheep had never warmed him. Suppose Job had not championed the cause of the fatherless in the gate, the place of judgment. Then, he says, let my arm fall from my shoulder.
Why the Oath Is So Severe
Job is not just listing good deeds. He is under attack. The self-curse denies that anything rotten hides under his decent surface.
William KellyHere, at the close of his last speech, Job makes the most solemn and complete protest of his innocence. He does not deny what he had already admitted about man's condition, his own included. But he flatly refuses the idea of grievous wickedness concealed under a fair exterior, which God could now be waging war against, as his friends had supposed. He lists his personal purity — and this as a married man too — his behaviour toward his servants, his remembrance of the poor and the exposed, his hatred of idolatry and greed, his generous and hospitable ways, his hatred of hypocrisy. If he is false in any of it, he prays to be put to utter shame.
What Held Him Back
The next verse gives the reason Job never lifted that hand.
Leslie M. GrantHe ends this section by showing that the fear of God was a vital matter with him (v.23). It was a terror to him even to think of the reality of God's destructive power against evil. He would not dare to offend One whose magnificence filled him with awe, to the point that he said, "I cannot endure."
That fear reached beneath behaviour to motive, and it did so long before any written law existed.
F. B. HoleThis chapter shows that before God gave the law, God-fearing men still held to a high standard of morality. That standard looked not only at the outward act but also at the inward motive that prompts it.
Where a Clear Conscience Stops
Everything Job swears here is true. The commentators still find something wrong with the swearing of it.
Samuel RidoutTo all of this we can only say: true and excellent — but why should he speak of it? Why not let his fear of God keep him from these things, rather than boast of them?
The record itself is not in doubt. The question is what it counts for before God.
F. B. HoleThis "righteousness," as Job 29 will show us, concerned his outward conduct, because God's searching light had not yet entered his soul. He had been charged with being a deceiver and a hypocrite. He knew he was not, and he was not going to plead guilty to it for a moment. We too know that he was not. But outward correctness does not in itself count for righteousness before God.
Summary
- Arm. Job offers to have broken the very limb he could have raised against orphans in court. The punishment fits the crime he denies.
- Omission. The oath covers the poor left unfed, the naked left unclothed and the orphan left undefended. The arm falls for what Job withheld as much as for what he struck.
- Fear. Dread of God's power against evil kept that arm down. That fear reached the inward motive, not just the outward act.
- Answer. The friends claimed hidden wickedness lay under Job's fair exterior. The whole self-curse answers them: shame me, if it is true.
- Limit. The record is true, yet outward correctness is not righteousness before God. God's searching light had not yet reached the man who boasts of it.