“How often is it that the lamp of the wicked is put out? That their calamity comes upon them? That God distributes pains in his anger?
Zophar has just insisted that the triumph of the wicked is short, so Job throws the claim back as a question: how often does God really put out the lamp of the wicked? The answer decides whether the world we can see is really God settling His accounts.
A Question Aimed at a Rule
Job does not deny that God sometimes strikes an evil man down in plain sight. He denies that such cases are the rule.
William KellyZophar looked only at the particular cases where God deals in judgment with some especially wicked men. And there are such cases every now and then. A man takes God's name in vain and swears to a downright falsehood — perhaps about theft, or some other offence. Now and then such a man drops down dead after it. Well, that is a very unusual thing. Other people swear to it and keep their money, and try to keep their character. But all the while they are heaping up wrath against the day of wrath.
"How Often" Means "How Seldom"
The question is not asking for a number. It is a way of saying "hardly ever," and some translations put it that way outright.
Samuel RidoutAgainst Zophar, he reminds him that verse 17 has also been translated "how rarely is the lamp of the wicked put out." How seldom does calamity break in on them, when God scatters "snares" or "lightnings" in His wrath! The psalmist tells us that the ungodly are "like chaff that the wind drives away" (Ps. 1:4). That is true. But Job reminds his hearers that this seldom takes place in the present life; it is kept for the "judgment."
Job Grants the Other Side
Job does not simply contradict his friends. He allows what is true in their words and refuses what is false.
William Kelly"How often is the lamp of the wicked put out!" Here, as you can see, he acknowledges the other side; and it is no less true that God does not leave Himself without witness. He insists that the present world is no expression of God's moral government. But he acknowledges that a divine blow falls on men in the middle of their apparent prosperity. In a moment their lamp is put out. So he admits there are exceptional dealings.
Where the Friends Went Wrong
His friends had built their whole case on one rule about how God governs the world.
J. N. DarbyThey urge the doctrine that God's government of the earth is a full measure and display of His righteousness, and of the righteousness of man that would match it. That doctrine proves total ignorance of what God's righteousness is, and of His ways... He shows that God does make His disapproval of the wicked known. Yet the circumstances the wicked are often found in overthrow the arguments of his friends.
Why the Lamp Is Left Burning
If judgment is so rare now, why the delay?
J. N. DarbyThis was what Job found so hard to understand — how those who did evil prospered, while the righteous were persecuted. This is just because the time of judgment has not come. The time of mercy is going on now, and we cannot have mercy and judgment at once. So all is a riddle now.
The Practical Warning
Job answers his own question, and then warns his friends what not to do with the answer.
William KellyHow often, he asks, does their lamp go out, and destruction break on them, as God is pleased to deal out in His displeasure? It may be now and then, hardly often; it is false to say always... Let none then misjudge God's ways, or draw unfounded conclusions from His government at present. Look at these two men, each with a full cup, one of happiness, the other of misery; both lying dead together. Appearances prove nothing but the haste and folly of those who judge before the time.
Summary
- The question: Job's "how often" really means "how seldom." God does not snuff out the wicked like clockwork in this life.
- The concession: it does happen at times, so God is not without witness. Job only denies that it happens always.
- The error: his friends made God's present dealings the full display of His righteousness. The facts overthrow them.
- The reason: the time of mercy is running now, not the time of judgment, and the two cannot run at once.
- The result: judge nothing before the time. Two men die with opposite cups, and appearances settle nothing.