yet at the scent of water it will bud and put out branches like a young plant.
Job looks at a felled tree and finds a strange comfort in it. The stump lies dead for years, then water reaches the root and green shoots appear. Then he turns the picture against himself: a man does not come back the way that tree does.
The picture behind the words
Job is not inventing a symbol. He had watched it happen, and the change came from outside the stump.
F. B. HoleHe took the analogy of a tree, which had been felled, when its root had been in the earth for a long time. He had seen the years pass, so that the stump left behind had begun to decay. Yet a change had come. Something had happened. Perhaps an earth-tremor had cracked the rocks and opened a fresh channel for water to reach its roots. Then, as a result, the dead tree came to life and sprouted again. Job's hope was that something like that lay ahead for mankind.
The contrast that follows
The tree is only half the argument. Job puts it beside man, and the comparison collapses at once.
William Kelly"But man dies, and wastes away." There is no hope for him in this earthly life; he dies and that is the end of it. A plant, on the other hand, may be brought down to the worst state and show nothing. Yet it can shoot up again, especially if there is water to help it. "Yes, man gives up his spirit, and where is he?"
How far Job could see
In this chapter Job reasons from what he can see, and no further.
J. N. DarbyIn Job 14 he clearly does not go beyond this present world of sight. In his bitterness of spirit he has no sense of resurrection. The tree sprouts now, and it sprouts in plain sight in this present world. Man does not, and in fact never will, unless by a miracle, as Lazarus was raised. Death has wholly passed upon him as an inhabitant of this world, a child of Adam. Such life he never recovers. Job was right; only he did not see beyond, nor did he know here the One who is the resurrection and the life.
Why the tree troubled him
A tree's revival can be seen. A buried man shows nothing. That gap is where Job's question comes from.
An Outline of Sound WordsThere was no mystery about the tree, but there was about the human race. Like the tree stump, the body of man wasted away in the ground. But there was no evidence of continuing life, as there was when young shoots sprang from the old roots of the tree. Still, Job realised that man is made of more than body. He spoke of his spirit, and this was what perplexed him. The body of the man wasted away, but where was the man who lived in that body?
The answer Job never received
Job's question waited a long time for a plain answer. It came from the Lord Jesus.
An Outline of Sound WordsClear, plain teaching about the place a man enters when he dies came only with the Lord Jesus. Job's question was plainly answered by the Lord in Luke 16, where He speaks about the rich man and Lazarus. There we learn what happens to a person who lives without any thought of God. He enters the place of torment when he leaves this world.
The stump that still has a root
Writers also apply the picture to Israel.
Hamilton SmithThe root is the hidden source of life. Christ is the source of spiritual life for every saint of God, and the blessing is sure because the root is perfect. Israel has indeed failed; the tree has been storm-swept and torn among the nations, but the root remains, and so Israel will bud and bring forth branches again.
Another writer names what that reviving water turned out to be in history.
The Bible TreasuryThe holy seed was in the people, but they had dwindled to a very small number when the Lord Jesus came. Among them were Zacharias, Elizabeth, Anna, Mary and others who followed Him. But the grace and truth that came by Him was like the scent of water that Job speaks of. There were fine boughs shooting from the stump of Judah.
Summary
- Cut down — Job's picture is a felled tree. Its stump has decayed in the ground for years, with nothing showing above the surface.
- Water — what revives it comes from outside: water reaching the root, not strength left in the stump.
- Contrast — the tree sprouts again in this world; man dies and does not. Job's comfort turns into his complaint.
- Question — a stump shows evidence of life; a grave shows none. Job knew man has a spirit, so he asks where the man himself has gone.
- Answer — Job reasoned from nature and could see no further. Clear teaching about life after death came with the Lord Jesus, who is the resurrection and the life.