Hear now my argument and listen to the pleadings of my lips.
Job 13:6 · ESVView all translations

Job has just told his three friends that silence would be their best wisdom. Now he asks for a fair hearing, and behind it lies a hard question: can anyone honour God with arguments that are not true?

A hearing, not more advice

Job is not asking for sympathy here. He is asking them to stop talking and follow his argument. Their mistake was to speak about what they did not understand, and to call it service to God.

"Oh that you would keep silent, and it would be your wisdom!" And it often is a man's wisdom when he sits quiet and holds his tongue. But the moment he begins to speak about what he does not understand — well, what then? That is exactly where they were. "Hear now my argument, and listen to the pleadings of my lips. Will you speak falsely for God and speak deceitfully for Him?" That is what they had been doing. They pretended this was for God.

William Kelly

The hearing he wants from God

Job has already given up on his friends. He wants to bring his case before God. He is sure God will not back their version of it.

It was with God he wished to speak, not with such quacks as they, whose wisdom would be to hold their peace. What they had said, he counted as spoken wickedly and deceitfully for God. God had given them no such authority, and He would surely reprove them — as in fact He did.

William Kelly

Pleading that falls on deaf ears

Job is making his defence before men who have already stopped listening.

He was seeking to reason and to plead with them, but they were not listening. Instead they were speaking wickedly on God's behalf, using deceit in claiming to speak for God. Job knew that God was fully aware that the charges of his friends were not true. So God was certainly not backing them up.

Leslie M. Grant

Why God refuses that kind of defence

The friends thought they were protecting God's reputation. They were defending Him by accusing an innocent man — and that trade is one God will not make.

God does not accept honour at the expense of truth. It is His glory that all His attributes blend in one harmonious light. Can He then accept a defence of His character and ways that rests on a false charge? Can He accept one that stamps wickedness and hypocrisy on Job? Of him God Himself had said, "There is none like him on the earth, a blameless and upright man, who fears God and turns away from evil." Can He let so monstrous a theory of suffering pass? These men had worked it out this way: suffering is always the unerring finger pointing at wickedness. That it is all in anger? What then becomes of His testing of His own, and of the sanctifying effect of discipline?

Samuel Ridout

Caught in the same false theory

Job is not standing on clear ground himself. He rejects their verdict, but he still holds the rule behind it. That pushes him toward blaming God.

Job boldly charges his friends with being false witnesses for God... They presume to lie for God! For are they not falsely accusing an innocent man? Are they not afraid to trifle with truth, and will God not deal with them? — for they are only men. Poor Job, he is the victim of the same false theory, and is in danger of blasphemy — of charging God with injustice. He seems to feel his danger, but he must speak; so he turns from man's unjust guesses to God.

Samuel Ridout

The ear that was never opened

Job asks them to hear. From the beginning that is what they would not do.

Their ear was not open... But the three friends! — they first kept this dead and distressing silence toward Job. He soon had to learn, with much bitterness, what came out of that silence. Though he began, they followed; but it was their own thoughts and not the mind of God.

William Kelly

Summary

- Silence — Job first asks them to stop speaking. Keeping quiet about what you do not understand is real wisdom.

- Hearing — he asks for a hearing, not pity. Their ear had never been open to him.

- Reasoning — Job is presenting a defence. He wants his argument followed, not his motives guessed at.

- Falsehood — his friends spoke deceitfully on God's behalf. God had given them no authority to do it.

- Verdict — God does not accept honour bought with a false charge, and He did in the end rebuke them, just as Job warned.

Reviewed by Orion on September 20, 2026