Then Satan answered the LORD and said, “Does Job fear God for no reason?
Job 1:9 · ESVView all translations

God has just praised Job, and Satan cannot deny a word of it. So he attacks the reason behind Job's goodness — a charge that lands on God as much as on Job, since it says this fear of God has been bought.

The Accusation Aimed at Motive

God had described Job's life. Satan says nothing against that description; he goes underneath it.

True to his character, Satan can only accuse. He cannot deny Job's righteousness, but attacks his motives. Having no motive himself but selfishness, he declares that Job is driven only by that. Why should he not be righteous? Does it not pay? He is prosperous, blessed in every way, and God lets nothing come near him to hurt him.

Samuel Ridout

Where does such a reading of another man come from? One writer answers that Satan judged Job by himself, and draws a warning from it.

"Then Satan answered the LORD and said, 'Does Job fear God for no reason?'" It is nothing but selfishness; it is only for his own ends. How did he judge that? From himself. It is a dangerous thing to judge anything from ourselves. It is a blessed thing to judge from God's word.

William Kelly

The Real Target Is God's Verdict

The words about the hedge are not simply an observation about Job's comfortable life. They are a challenge to the fairness of God's own assessment.

God has pronounced. Is that not enough? Sadly, sin has brought in distrust of God Himself. He too is on trial, and Satan's reasoning in Job's case almost openly takes that ground. God pronounces about Job, and Satan takes exception to it. "Have You not made a hedge about him, and about his house?" he says. He means: "This sentence is not given upon proper trial." Man, to his own ruin, has accepted Satan's malice as truth. Yet God, in His very mercy to man, does not retreat behind His privilege. He is, and must be, sovereign in what He does, so that "none can stay His hand, or say to Him, What are You doing?" Even so, He will allow the question, and let everything come into the fullest light.

Numerical Bible Notes

Satan Admits the Hedge

The accusation contains an unintended confession. In naming the protection, the adversary admits it had held.

Satan, the adversary, had watched Job for a long time, and Job's God-fearing, upright life clearly annoyed him. If he could have destroyed him he would have done it. But he had to admit that God had put a hedge around him, and he could not break it down or climb over it.

J. T. Mawson

Even when God opens the hedge, He sets how wide the opening is.

The thought of this is very solemn. It should lead us to walk humbly and watchfully through a scene where Satan rules. Satan has no power at all over a soul who stays in the place of dependence and obedience. And, blessed be God, he can never go one hair's breadth beyond the limit God sets.

C. H. Mackintosh

The Lie That Godliness Pays

The question is not only about Job. It is a charge against anyone who claims to fear God.

Satan's vile suggestion is that no such thing as godliness exists. If a man claims to be godly, it is not that he fears God, or cares for God. It is simply that he knows it pays and is to his worldly advantage. Satan says to God, "Stretch out Your hand and touch all that he has, and he will curse You to Your face." The Lord allows this horrible lie of the devil to be fully exposed. He lets Satan strip Job of all that he has, and the outcome proves Satan a liar. Instead of cursing God, Job fell down before the LORD and worshipped, saying, "The LORD gave, and the LORD has taken away; blessed be the name of the LORD."

Hamilton Smith

Why the Charge Stings

The charge was a lie about Job. Yet one writer warns that it can be partly true of us.

The gifts become a snare to us, and Satan's charge against us is often true in a measure. Our ground for rest and quietness of spirit before God is His kindness and mercies to us, and not simply the knowledge of His love. You can see this in the violent grief and despair many of His people fall into when God takes away any particular mercy. They had rested in the gift more than in God. The gift was to them the evidence of His love; the love itself was not the rest of the heart.

The Bible Treasury

Summary

- Charge. Satan cannot deny that Job is upright, so he attacks Job's motive — a motive he reads out of himself.

- Hedge. The words that accuse Job also admit that God's hedge had held. Satan could not break it down or climb over it.

- Limit. When God opens the hedge, He sets the width. Satan cannot go one hair's breadth beyond what God commands.

- Trial. God does not hide His verdict behind His power. He allows the question and brings everything into full light.

- Answer. Job lost everything and worshipped. The man who blessed the God who took away exposed the lie that godliness is only a paying arrangement.

Reviewed by Orion on August 31, 2026