Now therefore, please let your servant remain instead of the boy as a servant to my lord, and let the boy go back with his brothers.
Judah once made his younger brother Joseph suffer, and here he offers to suffer in Benjamin's place. The offer answers the question Joseph's long testing has been driving at: have these men really changed?
The old jealousy pulled up by the root
Joseph had suffered from his brothers' envy of a favoured son. Judah's offer tells him what has become of that envy.
William KellyThe immense change God had worked in his brothers was now made clear to Joseph. Their envy and selfish cruelty had given way to tender love for their father and for his affection toward the younger son of Rachel. The old jealousy was torn up by the roots. The one who took the lead was ready to become a slave to the governor, so that Benjamin might return and be his father's joy and comfort, instead of his father's death if Benjamin stayed a slave.
Repentance measured by what a man will do
Judah's speech was moving. But how can anyone know that a change of heart is real?
Hamilton SmithThis is excellent, but these are words, and words may be empty profession. Words must be proved by deeds. So Judah comes forward on behalf of the brothers, and proves the reality of their words by what they are prepared to do. What is more, the pleading love that breathes through Judah's touching appeal proves how deep the repentance is that has been worked in their souls. The heart of stone has indeed been changed into a heart of flesh.
A promise kept
Before the journey, Judah promised Jacob that he would answer for Benjamin himself. This verse is where he keeps that promise.
The Bible TreasuryJudah makes no large offers at the expense of his sons; the offer he makes is far more moderate, and at his own risk. "Send the boy with me … I will be a pledge of his safety." Jacob trusts him at once and lets Benjamin go. In doing so, Jacob showed again that he could read character. Judah nobly made his pledge good: he stood forward in Egypt and offered himself in Benjamin's place.
Nothing held back, nothing excused
Judah is the one asking for mercy, which gives him every reason to play down his part in the crime.
Michael HardtThis determination proves that Judah is not trying to protect himself from the consequences of his crime. He does not try to soften what he did or what it caused. He vividly describes Jacob's grief, which implies their guilt — the guilt of Joseph's brothers. He does not tone the account down to improve his own situation.
The spirit that marks real pleading for another
Standing in for someone else is not unique to Judah. Others in Scripture asked to bear the cost themselves, and one did.
The Bible TreasuryJudah's appeal is no empty rhetoric; he offers to give himself up to save Benjamin. This spirit of self-sacrifice marks all true intercession. "Please blot me out of your book," said Moses. "I could wish that I myself were accursed," said Paul. "Let me be a slave instead of Benjamin," says Judah, in effect. All of these said what they were willing to do: the wounds of Christ show what He has done.
Exactly what Joseph had been waiting for
Set the offer beside the way Judah once treated Joseph, and the change is unmistakable.
L. M. GrantThe last words of Judah to Joseph are refreshing in the way they reach the root of the whole matter. He asks Joseph to let him take Benjamin's place as a slave, and to let Benjamin return to his father. What a contrast to the way Judah had once treated his younger brother Joseph! This was the very end Joseph had been seeking: to see in Judah a genuine repentance that was willing to suffer as he had made his brother suffer. This is the repentance seen in the criminal crucified beside the Lord Jesus. He said that he and the other man deserved the punishment they received.
The moment the brother reveals himself
One commentator reads the scene as a pattern of something still ahead for Israel. The turning point is Judah's willingness to enter the sorrow himself.
Here the repentance is tied directly to the rejection of Joseph, and it comes home to the conscience of Joseph's brothers. So it will be in the end with Israel. It is not a question of the law here; the repentance points to the Messiah. … In the end Judah comes into prominence in connection with Benjamin. He takes his father Israel's sorrow to heart — the sorrow over Benjamin and the loss of Joseph — and puts himself into it. Then Joseph, in his glory, reveals himself to them as their brother.
after It is a lovely scene.
Summary
- Uprooted. The envy that once turned on Joseph is gone. Judah now pleads for the favoured younger brother instead of resenting him.
- Proved. Repentance that stops at words proves nothing. Judah's offer to take Benjamin's place proves his words by deeds.
- Honest. He shields himself from nothing. He does not play down the crime or its cost to his father.
- Kept. Judah promised Jacob he would answer for Benjamin. He makes that promise good by standing in Benjamin's place.
- Revealed. Once Judah enters his father's sorrow, Joseph makes himself known. One commentator sees here a pattern of Israel's future meeting with the Messiah.