On the third day, which was Pharaoh's birthday, he made a feast for all his servants and lifted up the head of the chief cupbearer and the head of the chief baker among his servants.
The third day came, just as Joseph had said. Pharaoh kept his birthday with a feast, and he brought two prisoners up from the dungeon in front of his whole court. The same royal act touches both men, yet it sends one back to the king's side and the other to the gallows.
The occasion
Kept birthdays are rare in Scripture, and Pharaoh's is the first one named.
Morrish Bible DictionaryScripture mentions only two kept birthdays. One is Pharaoh's, in Genesis 40:20. The other is Herod Antipas's, when John the Baptist lost his life (Matthew 14:6; Mark 6:21). Some think that Job's sons, who feasted "each on his day," did so on their birthdays, Job 1:4, 13. We do not read that the Israelites had any such custom. And the Preacher says the day of death is better than the day of one's birth (Ecclesiastes 7:1).
One phrase, two outcomes
Pharaoh "lifted up the head" of both officials — the same wording covers a restoration and an execution.
William KellyIn both cases the time was short, as the dream indicated and Joseph interpreted. On the third day, his birthday, the king lifted up the head of each official. But the chief cup-bearer rose to his post beside Pharaoh, and the chief baker rose to the gallows.
A prisoner's word proved true
The text never explains why the king decided as he did.
L. M. GrantThe third day arrived, and Joseph's interpretation of the dreams proved true. Being Pharaoh's birthday, he made a feast for his servants. Both the cupbearer and the baker were brought out into public view, but for opposite reasons (v. 20). The chief cupbearer was restored to his former position, while the baker was hanged (vv. 21-22). What influenced Pharaoh here is not mentioned. But the evidence of God's presence with Joseph was unmistakable.
Two men, one dividing line
Writers have read the two prisoners as a picture of Christ dividing people. Nothing visible marked one man out from the other.
The Bible TreasuryHere were two men in the same prison, both equally condemned. As far as we know, they were equally guilty — or equally innocent. They looked exactly alike in every outward way. Christ (Joseph) comes among them and pronounces one saved and the other lost.
What separated them
The difference lay in what each man's dream had put before him.
C. KnappWe see the gospel pictured in these dreams. The chief butler sees in his dream what speaks of the blood (the juice of the grape). And he was delivered. The chief baker, on the other hand, dreams of the white baskets. They remind us at once of human righteousness. He saw only what he had laboured to produce, the baked goods. And he is hanged... Here we have "the only two religions" pictured. One makes everything depend on the blood of Jesus. The other ignores the blood and trusts human righteousness.
The man nobody remembered
The restored cupbearer went back to palace life and left his interpreter in the dungeon. One writer sees God's hand even behind that failure.
F. B. HoleThe event proved that Joseph's interpretations were given by God. Pharaoh's birthday was on the third day, and he acted as the dreams had indicated. Yet the chief butler, in his renewed prosperity, forgot about Joseph. He has become a standing monument of human ingratitude. Still, we believe the hand of God was over even this. If the butler had remembered, Joseph's release would have come through grateful, and perhaps respectful, human arrangement. God intended to take him out, by reviving the butler's memory, in a far more striking way.
The application
Grant turns that forgetting into a warning for believers.
L. M. GrantMay the Lord preserve us from being like him. We who are believers have far more reason to remember the Lord Jesus than the cupbearer had to remember Joseph. He has not only foretold our deliverance. He has Himself delivered us from all our sins and our bondage, through the great sacrifice of Himself. Believers may too easily let this become almost forgotten in practice. That is a real reason why the Lord gave us the Lord's supper with the words, "Do this in remembrance of Me" (Luke 22:19).
Summary
- Word — Joseph's interpretation came true on the exact day. Nothing is said about Pharaoh's motives, so the one clear cause is that God was with Joseph.
- Feast — Scripture names only two kept birthdays, Pharaoh's and Herod's. At both, a man loses his life.
- Lifted — the same royal phrase covered both men: one head raised to the king's cup, one raised to the gallows.
- Divided — the two prisoners looked alike in every outward way. One dream pointed to the blood, the other to human effort; one man lived, one died.
- Remembered — the freed cupbearer forgot Joseph. Believers have far more reason to remember: "Do this in remembrance of Me."