and she conceived and bore a son, and he called his name Er.
Genesis 38:3 · ESVView all translations

Genesis 38 leaves the story of Joseph to follow Judah, who has left his brothers and married into a Canaanite family. Two questions follow the son born here: what grows from a step away from God, and what God will do with such a family.

An Interruption in Joseph's Story

One writer sees Judah's story placed here as a contrast to Joseph and the temptation he faced:

Genesis 38 completely interrupts the story of Joseph. Genesis 39 takes it up again and at once tells of the great temptation he faced. It seems the shameful story of Judah is told here to sharpen our sense of how firmly Joseph stood under a temptation of the same kind. Judah seems to have been one of the better behaved sons of Jacob. Yet the practices that marked him and his family were evil, and were clearly accepted as nothing unusual.

F. B. Hole

Decline by Easy Stages

Judah's fall did not happen in one step. One writer shows how people let go of God's principles, a little at a time:

How this warns us of our tendency to drift from God's principles! What happened in the same chosen family, generation after generation, may happen in the same chosen person, year after year. People may desert the principles of God by easy stages. They may first relax them, then forget them, then despise them. Those principles may pass from a firm hand into an easy one, then into an indifferent one, until at last a rebellious hand flings them away.

J. G. Bellett

The Naming of Er

Judah himself gives this first son his name. One writer takes up the meaning of that name and what the boy made of it:

Er was the firstborn of Judah's strength. His father named him, and the meaning of his name may be "watchful". Er clearly became watchful for chances to do evil... Jehovah saw his wickedness, and he reaped the due reward of his actions... It is not easy to bring up children in an evil world. When parents introduce their children to the things of this present evil age, those children will throw themselves into the world with all its ruin and its turning away from God.

Edwin N. Cross

The Three Names as a Picture

Commentators differ on what Er's name means. Another writer takes it as "enmity" and reads the three brothers as a picture of the nation that came from Judah:

Right at the start Judah separates himself from his brothers and joins himself to the Canaanite — the "merchant" — by marrying the daughter of Shuah (or "riches"). These names tell us plainly what has marked the nation in the centuries since the cross! His seed still continues on the earth, though God's wrath rests on the first two sons. Their names speak: Er of "enmity", Onan of "iniquity". The third son, Shelah ("sprout"?), speaks of divine power in resurrection, bringing out of death. So a remnant is preserved.

Frederick W. Grant

Jehovah Named in Both Chapters

In this chapter God is called by His covenant name, "Jehovah", not by the general word for God. The same name runs through the next chapter, where it does the opposite work:

This chapter needs few words to press home its proof of how low Judah had sunk, just as the next needs few to show Joseph blessed and a blessing. Both chapters mark the name "Jehovah", not just "God". In Genesis 38 that name judges the open breaking of His will. In Genesis 39 it makes Joseph prosper, because he sought to please Jehovah.

William Kelly

The Line of Grace

Judah's story only gets worse from here. Yet one writer points to what came out of this family line:

In Judah's history we find his utter wandering and misery. Yet in it, and out of it, comes the genealogy of grace. He marries Canaanites. Sin is in his family. He commits immorality with his own daughter-in-law. Everything had gone wrong. Yet out of this sprang the One in whom men would bless others.

J. N. Darby

One writer follows this line into the record of Jesus' family in Matthew's Gospel:

The Tamar of this chapter is the first of the women named in the genealogy of our Lord in Matthew 1... Such names would never have appeared in that record if it were not for the grace of God — the grace that triumphs over human sin.

F. B. Hole

Summary

- Departure. This son is born after Judah walks away from his brothers. Principles go by stages: first relaxed, then forgotten, then despised, then thrown away.

- Household. Judah named this son himself. Children throw themselves into whatever their parents show them.

- Names. Commentators differ on Er's name: "watchful", or "enmity". Set beside Onan's "iniquity" and Shelah's "sprout", the three sons picture a nation judged and a remnant preserved.

- Judgment. The covenant name Jehovah runs through both chapters. Here it judges the breaking of His will. In the next it blesses Joseph.

- Grace. Out of this wandering and misery comes the genealogy of grace — the line that runs on to the One in whom men would bless others.

Reviewed by Orion on September 10, 2026