At the same time Tattenai the governor of the province Beyond the River and Shethar-bozenai and their associates came to them and spoke to them thus: “Who gave you a decree to build this house and to finish this structure?”
Work on the temple had just restarted under the preaching of Haggai and Zechariah. At once a Persian official arrives with a legal question: who gave you permission? The verse raises the issue behind the whole chapter. What do God's people do when God tells them to build and the government has said no?
Opposition the Moment Work Resumes
The words "at the same time" tie the challenge to the restarted building. One writer contrasts it with the quiet years before:
Edward DennettSatan is still working behind the scene. Whenever God acts on the earth through His people, Satan at once works against it. This is the force of the words, "At the same time." We do not read of any persecution while they were building their own houses, the time Haggai speaks of. But at once, when they take up their work on Jehovah's house again, they are met by new tricks — in fact, open opposition.
The same writer applies it to believers today:
Edward DennettIf believers settle down in the world, mind earthly things, and become "dwellers on earth" — using that phrase in its moral sense — Satan will leave them alone. But the moment the Spirit of God works in them, so that they grasp His mind and go out in living testimony, the adversary will try to turn them aside. He will use any art or device likely to achieve his purpose.
A Fair Question From an Honest Official
Tattenai is not written off as a villain. He is the regional governor, and a royal order stopping the work was on record:
Edward DennettIn making this enquiry the governor was certainly within his rights. He was acting in the interests of his king, since a decree had gone out forbidding the building of the city, if not of the temple. He could know nothing of any commandment except that of his own king. The children of this world can never understand the claims of God upon His people. It always seems foolish to them that anyone should risk a ruler's anger to please One they themselves do not believe in.
God's Claim Above the King's
The builders had not waited for a fresh permit from Persia:
Edward DennettNo doubt they were subject to the powers ordained by God, and a decree forbidding them to build had been obtained. But God Himself had spoken. So if they were to render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, they were also to render to God the things that are God's. When God stoops to speak, His claims are supreme. They stand above every other consideration, whatever the consequences.
The Law on Faith's Side
The builders also had an answer within Persian law. One writer weighs the two royal orders against each other:
William KellyIf Artaxerxes had forbidden the building of the temple at the start, they might have been in difficulty. God's direct claim would have stood on one side and the kingdom's claim on the other. The principle would then apply that we must obey God rather than men. But in fact the case lay between two kings. There was one difference, and a very great one: the first and greatest king, the founder of the Persian monarchy, was the very one who had commanded the building of the temple.
The Eye of God on His People
God did not leave His people to face the enemy alone:
Edward DennettThe eye of God was on His beloved people, seeing their danger. He would supply the courage they needed in the presence of the enemy. He would give them the sense of His presence and shelter, and so stir them to persevere in their work. And it is a wonderful thing for our souls when we realise in any measure that the eye of God is upon us. It produces in us that holy fear which makes us fearless of man.
The Enemy's Enquiry as God's Instrument
The question went up to Darius, and the reply went further than the builders asked:
The Christian's FriendTo faith it was clear that God was working behind the scenes, using the power of the enemy to carry out His own purposes... When their adversaries interfered, Darius did more than confirm the decree of Cyrus. He issued another decree: all the provision needed for the house of God was to be supplied at his own expense.
Summary
- Obedience — The people restarted the work on God's word, not on a royal permit. When God speaks, His claim outranks every other.
- Opposition — Nobody troubled them while they built their own houses. The challenge came the instant they obeyed.
- Question — Tattenai's demand was fair in law. The world cannot see why anyone would risk a king's anger for a God it does not believe in.
- Protection — The eye of God was on the elders. That watching eye kept the enemy from stopping the work.
- Outcome — The enemy's own enquiry went to Darius and came back as a confirmed decree with royal funding. Opposition became the means of finishing the house.