Then rose up the heads of the fathers' houses of Judah and Benjamin, and the priests and the Levites, everyone whose spirit God had stirred to go up to rebuild the house of the LORD that is in Jerusalem.
Cyrus opened the door with a decree, but an open door moves nobody through it. Verse 5 records a second work, done inside the hearts of the leaders, priests and Levites, and it answers one question: what makes a small group leave a settled exile to rebuild a ruin?
Two Stirrings, Not One
The same phrase covers the Persian king in verse 1 and the returning families here. A decree, even a sincere one, could not produce a return by itself.
H. L. RossierThese were intellectual convictions, which might have nothing to do with a work of conscience or a living faith. Cyrus was even sure he was an instrument chosen to carry out God's purposes (v. 2). But all this was not enough to bring about the restoration of the captives. God intended to show that it was He Himself and no other who fulfilled His Word. That is why it says: "The LORD stirred up the spirit of Cyrus king of Persia" (v. 1). He also stirred up the spirit of the heads of the fathers' houses of Judah and Benjamin. And He stirred up the spirit of the priests and the Levites (v. 5).
One writer draws the general rule out of these two stirrings.
Michael HardtIt is remarkable how God works. First He "stirs up the spirit" of this pagan king, so that he passes a decree inviting the Jews to return to Jerusalem. He then stirs up the spirit of those who did so (1:5). Whatever men do, a true revival is always a work of God.
Who Rose Up
The verse names Judah and Benjamin, plus the priests and the Levites. That list is exact.
Edward DennettFirst, note that the heads of the fathers' houses who offered themselves for the work came from two tribes: Judah and Benjamin. There were also Levites, but they did not count as a tribe, for Levi had "no portion or inheritance with his brothers. The LORD is his inheritance" (see Deuteronomy 10:8-9). This and other Scriptures make it plain that only these two tribes were restored. Some people from other tribes may have come as well.
The Purpose Was the House
The stirring had one object, and the decree of Cyrus had the same one.
The Christian's FriendThe object of the people's return concerned the building of the house of the Lord. This was the subject of the proclamation of Cyrus, whom God raised up for this very purpose... And for this end God worked in the hearts of those who were made willing to return to the land of their fathers.
Inward Work, Outward Providence
God was not only at work inside these people.
F. B. HoleVerse 5 of the first chapter shows a real work of God in the souls of many, including leaders both civil and religious. It led them to seize at once the opportunity given for a return to the land of their fathers, and to re-establish the worship of God by rebuilding His house. In God's providence Cyrus himself promoted this. A providential work of God in the surrounding world matched the spiritual work of God in the souls of His people.
Those Who Stayed Behind
The stirring reached only a minority.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinBut not all were ready to go back; only a small remnant was willing. The great majority preferred to remain in Babylon. There was nothing to attract them to Jerusalem — the city of ruins, with the once magnificent temple in ruins. Those who returned loved Jerusalem, the place the LORD had chosen.
The Test of a Genuine Movement
The agreement reached further than the travellers.
Edward DennettAgreement of heart and object is produced in all concerned: in Cyrus, without whose permission the captives could not have returned; in the heads of the fathers' houses of Judah and Benjamin, who were needed for the actual work of building; and in those who stayed behind, who shared with their brothers through their freewill offerings and helped cover the necessary costs. Nobody held preliminary meetings to arrange matters and reach an agreement. The action of the Lord on the hearts of all alike, and nothing else, produced this union of heart and purpose. This distinguishes a divine work from a human one, and is the sure proof of a real action of the Spirit of God. Every needed instrument therefore comes forward at the right moment, for the work is of God, and it must be accomplished.
Summary
- Stirred, twice. God moved a pagan king to open the door. Then He moved His own people to walk through it, since the decree alone could not restore anyone.
- Stirred for a purpose. God stirred hearts with one object: to go up and build the house of the LORD in Jerusalem.
- Stirred inside and outside. God did a real work in the souls of civil and religious leaders, and arranged the world outside them to match.
- Stirred, but few. Only a small remnant responded. The majority preferred Babylon, since a ruined city held nothing to attract them.
- Stirred, therefore united. Agreement between king, travellers and givers came with no prior arrangement. That is the mark of a work that is God's, and such work must be finished.