Whoever is among you of all his people, may his God be with him, and let him go up to Jerusalem, which is in Judah, and rebuild the house of the LORD, the God of Israel — he is the God who is in Jerusalem.
The seventy years of exile are over. A Persian king's decree opens the road home. But it names no one and commands no one. It leaves the door open to whoever will walk through it.
A Gentile King's Proclamation
Cyrus was not a worshipper of Israel's God, yet his edict speaks with unusual confidence about what God had charged him to do. Commentators note how much this pagan ruler was willing to say out loud.
F. B. HoleIt was no small thing for Cyrus to acknowledge the supreme glory and power of God in this striking way. It was no small thing that he obeyed what God had commanded. It is not surprising that God should have spoken of him as "His anointed."
The proclamation as a whole holds three separate things together, and it is worth keeping them distinct.
Edward DennettThree things are announced here: the commission which Cyrus himself had received about the Lord's house; his royal permission for any of the Jews to return to Jerusalem in order to build the temple; and lastly, his invitation to those Jews who would stay in his territories to have fellowship with those who left, by giving freewill offerings toward the goal they had in view.
No Names, Only a Question
The decree singles out nobody. That silence did its own sorting work.
F. B. HoleThe proclamation did not name any person or persons who were to go to Jerusalem and build the house. Instead it threw the door open for any Jew whose heart stirred him up to go. Such a man had the assurance that he would receive generous help in the project ahead of him. Worded this way, it meant that those who responded would mostly be men of piety, whose hearts were alive to the glory of God and to the place of His Name. The more worldly-minded and selfish would prefer to stay in their comfortable homes, built up during the seventy years of captivity. They would leave the task to others who were ready to face the difficulties and hardships.
An Invitation That Tested Everyone
It was an invitation, not an order. So it showed what people really loved.
Hamilton SmithThis proclamation became a test of the moral condition of the people of God. On one side, it raised a question. Were their affections so set on their land, their God, and the house of God that in simple faith they were ready to face trials and difficulties, opposition and reproach? Were they ready to answer to the mind of God and carry out His will? Or on the other side, did they prefer to stay in Babylon with its ease and material comforts?
"He Is the God"
The verse pauses to say whose house this is. That short phrase carries weight, and so does the practical help attached to it.
Leslie M. GrantNotice, he does not give any honour to the idols of Persia, but says of the God of Israel, "he is the God" (v. 3). He also gave instructions to the neighbours of anyone concerned about taking this journey to Jerusalem. They were to "help him with silver and gold, with goods and with beasts, besides freewill offerings for the house of God that is in Jerusalem" (v. 4). This was not only a matter of setting slaves free, but of enriching them. So Cyrus was rightly representing a God of grace.
The House Before the City
The goal here is a building project, and a narrow one. The ruined city walls are not yet on the agenda.
F. B. HoleWhat Cyrus had in view was the building of "the house of the LORD," and he was not concerned with the desolate state of the city. Later, Nehemiah became deeply concerned about the ruined and desolate condition of Jerusalem. He obtained permission from Artaxerxes to restore and build the city. It was a case of God's house first, the city where men dwell second. This is a principle of lasting significance.
Who Actually Went Up
The ones who answered were a minority, and their reasons were not practical ones.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinNot everyone was ready to go back; only a small remnant was willing. The great majority preferred to stay in Babylon. There was nothing to attract them to Jerusalem — a city of ruins, with the once magnificent temple in ruins. Those who returned loved Jerusalem, the place the LORD had chosen. There, and nowhere else, the people could bring the appointed offerings and sacrifices. They belonged to those who sat by the rivers of Babylon and wept when they remembered Zion. They said, "If I forget you, O Jerusalem, let my right hand forget its skill! Let my tongue stick to the roof of my mouth, if I do not remember you, if I do not set Jerusalem above my highest joy!" (Ps. 137:5-6).
The Call Still Sounding
Writers read the open-ended question of this verse as one that has never been withdrawn.
Michael HardtIn a sense, King Cyrus is still alive. The same call still goes out. Who is there among you? Who is there who is not content with Babylon? Who is there who values Jerusalem? Who is there who takes an interest in the house of God?
Summary
- Charged — Cyrus did not worship the God of Israel, yet he acknowledged His glory and power and obeyed what God had commanded. God called him "His anointed."
- Opened — The decree names no one and drafts no one. It opens the door to "whoever is among you of all his people."
- Tested — An invitation, not an order, exposes the heart: comfort in Babylon, or the trouble and reproach of going up.
- Built — The stated object is the house of the LORD, not the city walls. God's house comes first; the city where people live comes second.
- Answered — Only a small remnant went up. They loved Jerusalem more than comfort, and the same call still asks who will go.