“As for you, my flock, thus says the Lord GOD: Behold, I judge between sheep and sheep, between rams and male goats.
Up to now the chapter has accused Israel's shepherds. They fed themselves and let the flock scatter. Here the Lord turns and speaks to the sheep themselves. The question now is what the strong have done to the weak.
Judgment Beyond the Shepherds
Now God says He will sort out the flock itself, sheep by sheep.
Numerical Bible NotesThe search the Lord begins goes deeper than certain leaders of the people. "Behold," says the Lord, "I judge between sheep and sheep" — not only between sheep and shepherds.
The same writer sees the two named animals pointing in different directions:
Numerical Bible Notes"The rams and the male goats" do not seem to speak of the same kind of people under His judgment. The rams belong to the flock itself, but the male goats are strangers to it. In the Lord's own picture of judgment, the goats stand for those whom the Son of Man puts on His left hand, while He puts the sheep on His right.
Strength and the Weak
Commentators differ here. Another writer sees a contrast of size and strength rather than of belonging. (Older translations read "between cattle and cattle," where the ESV has "between sheep and sheep.")
A J PollockNext the Lord would judge between cattle and cattle (the margin of the Bible says: small cattle, that is, lambs and kids), and between rams and male goats (the margin says: great he-goats). It was a question between the strong and the weak. What is the right use of strength but to protect the weak?
The chapter goes on to show what these strong ones did with their strength.
A J PollockHow did they use their strength? Sadly, not only to keep the good pasture for themselves. They also trampled the rest with their feet and made it unfit to eat. They drank the deep waters, then fouled the rest with their feet. Does it end there? No. There is One who judges.
Judged One by One
Belonging to the flock hides no one. God weighs each sheep on its own, and the judge of the dead is the judge of the living too.
William KellyEzekiel 33 teaches us that a person's own state before God will carry a weight in Israel that it never had under the first covenant. The same will be true here, when He judges between sheep and sheep, between the rams and the male goats. He will call up the reckless cruelty of those who destroyed what they could not use, and so harmed the flock. He will judge the living no less than the dead.
The Same Warning Today
God spoke these words to Israel, but the behaviour they describe is not limited to one nation.
Julius A Von PoseckThese are solemn words! They are not only for false shepherds. They are also for those in the flock who trample the pasture and so spoil it, instead of lying down quietly and enjoying it together with their fellow Christians. Such people stir up and dirty with their feet the still waters of comfort and peace — waters that come from feeding on the "tender herbs" of Scripture.
Often the people who do the damage think they are being faithful.
A J PollockDo we not tend to treat with coldness and harshness those we can label "diseased"? Do we not keep our distance from those we might call weak and feeble? It is not wise to ignore the facts. What cruelty and injustice people have done in the name of Christ! Not willingly or on purpose, perhaps, but often through mistaken ideas of faithfulness.
A Day to Long For
For anyone who has suffered under all this, the coming judgment is a relief, not a threat.
A J PollockWhat a day that will be, when the troubles, difficulties and divisions are judged rightly, once and for all! What a day that will be! The hard spirit will come under judgment. So will the softness that makes no faithful stand for the truth. We look forward to that day with eagerness.
The sorting also has a purpose. God is watching the ones who came off worst.
Numerical Bible NotesBut God is going to judge between the fat sheep and the lean sheep. The lean sheep are His concern now — the people who have suffered from these things, and whom He sees suffering. So He will save His flock, they will no longer be a prey, and He will judge between sheep and sheep.
Summary
- Deeper. The judgment does not stop with bad shepherds; it goes down into the flock, "not only between sheep and shepherds."
- Personal. Each sheep stands on its own footing — individual state before God, with no hiding inside the group.
- Strength. The rams and goats are the strong ones. Strength exists to protect the weak, not to shove them aside.
- Ourselves. The charge fits anyone who spoils the pasture for others — above all when we mistake harshness for faithfulness.
- Welcome. His day settles every division rightly, judges both hardness and soft compromise, and saves the lean sheep from being prey again.