Thou shalt not kill.
Four words forbid murder. Yet they raise questions people still argue over. Why does God guard human life? May the state ever take life? How far does the command reach into the heart? Commentators answer in two directions. One looks outward, to government and the death penalty. The other looks inward, to anger and hatred.
Life Belongs to God
The command starts with who gave life.
F. B. HoleThe sixth commandment guards human life, and God is the Source of that life. Man cannot give life, and he has no right to take it away, except when he does so as ordained by God.
Murder attacks more than the victim.
The Bible TreasuryThe murderer does more than wrong a man and injure him to the last degree. He also defaces God's image by killing a man, and God sentences him to die. Murder is an unwarrantable seizing of what belongs to God.
Not Every Killing Is Murder
Israel had fought wars at God's command, and would fight more. So what exactly does it forbid?
Leslie M. GrantThe sixth commandment, "You shall not murder," must be considered from the viewpoint God intends. Israel had already killed many enemies that God had told them to kill. In the land of Canaan God would require them to kill the inhabitants too. God commanded this because the inhabitants were given up to idol worship. In the same way, when justice demands the death of a criminal, it is not murder for the authorities to put him to death. But no individual is free to kill another as he sees fit. Scripture makes a distinction between murder and manslaughter.
Does that authority still hold today? One writer answers bluntly:
Edward DennettThe word of God gives no support to the modern humanitarian movement to abolish the death penalty. It puts human ideas in the place of God's original law. In fact, it lifts man above God.
A Command Conscience Already Knew
This law told Israel nothing their conscience had not already whispered. The proof is in the very first murder, committed long before any commandment was written.
L. M. GrantThe sixth law, "You shall not kill," finds an echo in everyone's conscience. A man knows this is wrong without being told. Cain, though he had no law, knew he was doing evil in killing his brother, because he lied about it afterward.
What the Law Could Not Reach
Judges in Israel could only reach the deed. That limit lay in the courtroom, not in the command.
Numerical Bible NotesThe executive law in Israel could go no further than this. It could not deal with the state of the heart, but only with the outward act. Yet the law as expressed on the tablets of stone applied to more than the outward act.
Then Jesus took the same commandment further back, to where the deed begins.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinMurder was the first terrible fruit after the fall, springing as it did from envy in the heart. The penalty of murder is the judgment. This, then, is the letter of the law. It dealt with the outward deed, but it did not touch the heart itself. Now He speaks: "I say to you that everyone who is lightly angry with his brother shall be subject to the judgment." The word "lightly" belongs here: it means not outward anger only, but even the faintest feeling of displeasure. … But the words lay the heart bare and show that man cannot stand before God, who judges the heart, in a righteousness of his own.
Hatred Counted as Murder
Hatred, then, is no smaller thing than the deed.
William KellyIt is not merely someone who does not love, but the active work of hating. … He is a murderer in principle. … God deals with the heart, and not only with outward things.
Fulfilled Only by Love
That leaves one debt still owed.
William KellyThe debt of love is the only debt that is legitimate and honourable, good among men and acceptable to the Lord — the debt we should always be paying and can never pay off. Grace alone gives the power, but by it law is fulfilled, and indeed only so. Law kept claiming love but never found it.
Summary
- Source. Life belongs to God; man cannot give it, so he has no right to take it.
- Image. Murder defaces God's image in man, which is why God treats it as robbery of what is His.
- Limits. Not every killing is murder. Lawful authority may take life, and Scripture separates murder from manslaughter.
- Reach. Courts could only judge the act; the Lord traced the command back to anger and hatred in the heart.
- Fulfilment. Love owed to a neighbour is the one debt that satisfies this law — and grace alone supplies the power to pay it.
Note: older translations read "You shall not kill" here. The ESV reads "You shall not murder." Several quotes above use the older wording, and one follows an older reading of Jesus' words that includes the word "lightly."