So the king commanded this to be done. A decree was issued in Susa, and the ten sons of Haman were hanged.
In one short verse the king agrees, the order goes out in Susa, and the bodies of Haman's ten sons are hung up in public. Two questions follow. Why hang men who were already dead? And why is a scene like this in the Bible at all?
What the gallows was
The "gallows" here is not what a modern reader pictures. A Bible dictionary explains the word behind it:
Morrish Bible DictionaryThe word is ets, often translated "tree" and "wood," and it gives no idea of the form of the gallows. It was some framework made or set up on which Mordecai was to have been hanged. Haman no doubt wanted the great height (about 23 yards) to make the hanging of his victim plain to the whole city. People could see it from the palace — and under God's providence, Haman was hanged on it himself.
So the frame built to shame Mordecai became the place where Haman hung, and then his sons.
Hanging after death
Haman's ten sons had died the day before (v. 10). So why hang the bodies?
Leslie M. GrantShe asked for another day to rid Susa of the Jews' enemies, and asked that Haman's ten sons be hanged (v. 13). Of course, they had already been killed, so the hanging was meant to impress on the people how great Haman's guilt was. The king gave his consent to this.
Why a second day in the capital
Five hundred enemies had already died in Susa. So why ask for another day there? The answer turns on a difference of place:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinBut had they not already killed 500 in Susa? Those 500 died in the palace — or, as that word should be translated, the citadel or fortress. The extra day was to continue the work of punishment in the city itself. The king granted the request, and the ten sons of Haman were hanged. The Jews did not touch the spoil, the goods and possessions of those killed, probably to avoid false accusations, even though the decree let them plunder their enemies. In orthodox synagogues, when Jews read the book of Esther, they read the names of Haman's ten sons in one breath, as fast as they can. This shows that all of them were wiped out at one and the same time.
The enemy's line, and the king who consents
One writer reads the fall of Haman's whole family, and the extra day for Susa alone, as a picture of a judgment still to come:
H. L. RossierThe oppressor of the Jews is judged, and his race with him (vv. 6-10). In the same way the apostate race of the Antichrist will perish in a future day, for the hour of vengeance has struck. Only, the people "laid no hand on the plunder" (vv. 10, 15, 16), in keeping with what had been laid down about Amalek or the enemies of Israel. It is only a matter of carrying out God's judgment, without any profit for those who carry it out. Ahasuerus accepts this vengeance as a necessity. The plot against the Jews had been hatched in his capital. So his capital is given over to the judgment of God one day longer than the other cities of the kingdom.
Not a model for Christians
Many readers find this chapter impossible. One writer traces the trouble to a wrong starting point:
William KellyThere are many who cannot understand this. And no wonder! They take Esther as a picture of the Lord's dealings with the church. You can see at once what deep confusion that creates. It is not so. It is the Gentile cast off and the Jew called in. But righteousness will be the character of the kingdom's reign by and by. Grace is what suits the church now. So it would make no sense at all for Esther to represent the church now. Carrying out righteous vengeance would be completely at odds with the calling of the Christian — with the church's place.
The repeated blow
The same writer turns the hanging of the ten sons from a problem into the point:
William KellyOnce this is understood, the execution of the ten sons of Haman is no difficulty at all. The Lord will not only strike at the beginning; the blow will fall a second time. There will be a thorough clearance of the adversary, and of all who give only pretended obedience.
Summary
- Gallows — The word means a tree or timber frame. Haman built his high so the city would watch. The city watched him and his sons hang there instead.
- Display — The ten sons were already dead; the hanging was to impress on the people how great Haman's guilt was.
- Distinction — The first 500 fell in the fortress. The extra day cleared the city itself, and the Jews still took no plunder.
- Line — The oppressor falls, and his whole race with him. The king accepts it as necessary and gives his capital one day more than the provinces.
- Clearance — Grace marks the church's calling now. Righteousness will mark the kingdom, and the blow falls twice so the clearance is complete.