And they told Mordecai what Esther had said.
Esther 4:12 · ESVView all translations

This verse is one line of reporting: the servants carry Esther's answer back to Mordecai. Her words describe a closed door and admit her fear, and they draw an answer of faith out of him.

The message she sent back

What the servants carried back was a legal impossibility. One writer shows how thin the remaining hope was.

There is still one ray of hope, although it is very weak. It is that Esther should go in to the king and plead with him for her people. Mordecai commands her to do this. But what use is his command when even the way into the king's presence is closed? Esther charges her messenger to tell Mordecai this fact... If Esther goes to Ahasuerus without an invitation, she will be put to death. And he has neglected her for thirty days. She has one feeble hope left: the king may be pleased to hold out the golden scepter to her. So the only way of escape is the grace of the one who holds sovereign authority. But can Esther count on this grace? Not at all. Everything depends on the king's good pleasure. Can anyone count on the good pleasure of a man who has just erased a whole people from the land of the living with a single word?

H. L. Rossier

Speaking from her circumstances

Esther's report is honest. One commentator refuses to blame her for speaking out of her situation, while still naming what it lacked.

She sees difficulty, and feels dangers; and she speaks, for a time, from her circumstances. Nothing wrong in this. She tells Mordecai of the risk she would run if she went into the royal presence uninvited. Nothing wrong, I say again, in speaking this way out of her circumstances, though there may be weakness. But Mordecai counsels her as a stronger vessel. In the cause of God and His people, he appears as one above both circumstances and affections.

J. G. Bellett

The reply her words drew out

Once her words reach him, Mordecai answers with a certainty that never names the One he counts on.

Mordecai sends her a very clear but severe message. "Do not think to yourself," he said, "that you will escape in the king's house any more than all the Jews. For if you keep completely silent at this time, then relief and deliverance will arise for the Jews from another place." Not a word about God. He is hidden. He means God. But God's secrecy is kept so perfectly that he gives only a vague hint of it in this remarkable way. God would look down from heaven, but Mordecai speaks of the place and not of the person.

William Kelly

Not a plea for himself

Mordecai could have asked Esther to save him and his own family. He asked for something larger.

It would have been quite natural for Mordecai to say, "If you cannot save all the people, at least save me and the house of your father, for you belong to the king's own house, which no one can touch." He does not think of his own interest and safety. The salvation of his people is what is on his heart. He knows that Esther is in a position not only to be saved herself, but also to save her people.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

Faith passed from one to the other

The message of danger did not end there. Mordecai's answer changed the queen who sent it.

He had warned her faithfully and solemnly of certain ruin to herself and her father's house if she stayed silent. But at the same time he expressed the fullest certainty that relief and deliverance would come from another place. This is the victory that overcomes, even faith, as we may surely apply here. Its effect was as clear in Esther as Andrew's was on his own brother Simon. The queen is ready to perish in such a cause, if need be. The unseen hand that sustains the universe strengthened her, and that same hand would turn the king's heart at His will.

William Kelly

The larger picture

One writer reads the whole story as a picture of what comes later.

In all the history we have considered, we cannot help seeing the working of God, as will be the case in the Great Tribulation period. Mordecai is a type of Christ, the chief object of the enemy's hatred, yet finally triumphant. Esther is a faint picture of the intercessory work of Christ on behalf of Israel.

Leslie M. Grant

Summary

- Report. Esther's answer, carried back in this verse, reports a closed door. No one enters the king's inner court uninvited and lives, and the king had not called for her in thirty days.

- Resource. The only opening left is the king's grace — the golden scepter held out at his pleasure alone.

- Weakness. Speaking out of her circumstances was not wrong, though it was weak. Mordecai, the stronger vessel, stood above both the danger and his own affections.

- Word. Mordecai's reply names no name, yet rests on God: deliverance will arise "from another place." He asks for his people's rescue, not his own.

- Result. Faith passed from one heart to another. The queen who had sent back an impossibility became ready to perish for her people.

Reviewed by Orion on September 5, 2026