Now when the virgins were gathered together the second time, Mordecai was sitting at the king's gate.
This short verse sits between a royal wedding and a murder plot. It raises two questions: what the second gathering was for, and why Mordecai sat at the king's gate.
The gathering "a second time"
The opening words have puzzled readers. One writer sets out the options and leans toward reading the second gathering as a move against Esther.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinCritics have called the opening words of verse 19 unclear: "Now when the virgins were gathered together the second time." Jewish interpreters have explained this as a plot. They say the enemies of the new queen collected more virgins so that Esther might somehow be overshadowed and pushed into the background. Others claim that the words "the second time" should be left out of the text, since there is some doubt about them. If they are dropped, the statement would refer to the gathering of the virgins in verse 8 of this chapter. But the idea that the second gathering was a plot may be the true meaning. It would show the aim of the unseen enemy, and it also explains why Mordecai was watching. He sat at the king's gate. By the custom of that part of the world, this was a public place where people heard news and talked with friends and others. Some say Mordecai sat in the king's gate because he was a government official, but that must be rejected as wrong.
Why the gate
Commentators differ on whether that seat was a government post or a spot open to anyone. One reads it as a right any citizen had, used by a man who wanted to stay near Esther.
Leslie M. GrantWe read that "Mordecai was sitting at the king's gate." It seems any citizen could do this, and Mordecai used that freedom to stay as near to Esther as he could. Esther had not told anyone her nationality, obeying Mordecai's instructions to her (vv. 19-20)... These circumstances too are part of God's working behind the scenes.
A captive with a post to keep
Mordecai was not a free man. Another writer says he stayed at court out of duty, not indifference, when Cyrus' decree opened the way back to Jerusalem.
H. L. RossierMordecai himself was not a free man. He had not used the decree of Cyrus to return to Jerusalem. This was not out of indifference. Like Daniel and Nehemiah, he had a duty to carry out at the king's court, and he could not leave without special permission — permission his position most likely barred him from asking for. He "was sitting at the king's gate." Daniel himself held this same place (Dan. 2:49), at the moment when he was raised in rank in Babylon. It was a lower post, no doubt, but a post of trust, and it called for special watchfulness over the person of the ruler.
Guarding, then stepping back
The same writer follows Mordecai into action at that gate. He guards the king's life, then steps out of sight and asks for nothing.
H. L. RossierIn his dealings with the royal court, he watches out for the king's welfare in the open. He sits at the gate to keep any danger away from the king's person. Esther's fortune hung on Ahasuerus staying alive, so Mordecai becomes the king's saviour. Then he withdrew without a word, asking nothing for himself, and let Providence — all that was left to his oppressed nation — direct him. It was Providence that had led those two officers of the court to reveal their plans in front of Mordecai.
The unseen hand
The man who saved the king's life got nothing for it. Another writer reads that delay as timing, not neglect, and links it to the whole chain of events in the book.
William KellySo the traitors were found guilty. But the man who had done the king good was forgotten, strange as that is, until the hour of real need came. In the end this made his reward all the more certain, and it left the enemy in confusion. Secret providence ordered everything rightly, however hard appearances might be. Here again, with the conspirators and Mordecai, the way the king was warned was no more a matter of chance than the fall of Vashti or the rise of Esther. It was all in His hand, and He ruled unseen.
Summary
- Gathering. The second gathering of virgins is disputed. One reading takes it as a plot to push the new queen aside — which explains why Mordecai was watching.
- Gate. The king's gate was a public place where people heard the news. On this reading it was not a government office. Mordecai used a right any citizen had, so he could stay near Esther.
- Guard. A man who stayed at court out of duty turned his seat into a watch post. He protected the king's life, because Esther's future hung on it.
- Gap. He saved the king, then withdrew and asked for nothing. He stayed forgotten until the exact hour when remembering him would ruin the enemy.
- God. Nothing here is chance. The fall of Vashti, the rise of Esther, the overheard plot — all of it was in His hand, and He ruled unseen.