The elder to the elect lady and her children, whom I love in truth, and not only I, but also all who know the truth,
No other letter in the New Testament is like this one. It goes to a woman and her family, from a man who signs himself only "the elder." That opening line raises three questions. Who was this lady? Why does the writer choose such a modest title? And why is love here bound to truth?
A letter to one household
Her name never appears in the letter. One writer sees kindness in that silence.
William KellyEvery careful reader of Scripture should find it remarkable that we have an apostolic letter openly addressed to a lady and her children. In the Third Epistle John names the man he writes to. But in the Second Epistle before us he speaks of the lady simply as such, without any mention of her name. In this we may see a delicate fitness. The letter no doubt met her need, yet it spared her needless pain and publicity. Yet the letter itself is inspired and of the greatest value, for God's people then and at all times.
Who the elect lady was
No name appears, so readers have long guessed. One writer lists the main options and rejects the most popular one.
Arend RemmersThe Second Epistle of John is addressed to "the elect lady" (Greek eklekte kyria). There has been much speculation over this greeting. Was it the simple greeting of a Christian widow, or of a lady with an unbelieving husband, or was it simply her name? Or was it, as various researchers have assumed — probably incorrectly — the greeting of a local church?
Why "the elder"
The writer had every right to open with his apostolic title. He chose the lower one.
William Kelly"The elder," says the apostle. So he steps down from the first place in the church of God, a place he had every right to fill. But love naturally takes the more excellent way, and here the Holy Spirit inspired it for the special need.
Why he calls her "elect"
He does not address her by rank or wealth. His one word points to God's own choice.
William KellyHe does not slight her position, but what both of them valued was the title of divine grace, not what she owed to providence. She was elect of God, one chosen in Christ by and for God Himself. God had chosen her out of all her natural connections, and the apostle delights to see that God brought her, even on earth, into new and divine ones.
Love measured by truth
The phrase "whom I love in truth" is not a warm flourish. It names both the source of the affection and its boundary.
The Christian's FriendThe truth formed the love John had for this godly saint and her children, and the truth set its limits — if we can speak of limits when the subject is infinite. That truth is the revelation of God in Christ. Outside this blessed circle the apostle's heart did not, and could not, flow, so far as the Holy Spirit controlled him. We see this at once when John adds, "but also all who know the truth." Every heart that cherishes the truth must love those who are also under its power.
Warmth with restraint
One writer compares these words with how John greets Gaius, the man he writes to in his next letter.
Leslie M. GrantNotice the moral fitness of the words chosen here. In writing to a lady, John does not use the words "well beloved" and "beloved" as he does to Gaius. It is certainly not that he loved her less, but John is careful to give no one any occasion for wrong impressions. Yet she is "the elect lady" whom he says he loves "in truth." Her being chosen by God is the reason for his love toward her, a love shared by all those who have known the truth.
A household holding ground
This letter to a mother and her children matters far beyond one home. It matters because of what that home was doing when others gave way.
J T MawsonVery early in the church's history the citadel had fallen to the enemy, and the flag of truth had been hauled down and laid in the dust. Had it? Perhaps that was true of the majority, who had yielded to some other authority than the Lord's and had compromised the truth. But this lady and her children had not given in to the adversary. They were keeping the flag flying. When the church failed, the Christian household stepped into the breach. Its answer to the enemy was "No surrender!" and it held the fort for the Lord and the truth.
Summary
- Elder, not apostle — John sets aside the highest title in the church. Love takes the lower path when a special need calls for it.
- Elect, not named — John leaves her name out to spare her publicity. The title he gives her points to God's choice, not her social standing.
- Chosen out, brought in — God chose her out of her natural connections and placed her, even on earth, in new and divine ones.
- Loved in truth — the truth shapes this love and sets its bounds — the revelation of God in Christ. Everyone who knows that truth shares it.
- Holding the truth — commentators differ over who this lady was. They agree on what her household did: it refused to surrender the truth when many around it had.