Now the Lord is the Spirit, but where the Spirit of [the] Lord [is, there is] liberty.
Paul has just set two ministries against each other: the letter that kills and the spirit that gives life. Now he sums that contrast up in one sentence. Two questions sit inside it. In what sense is the Lord the Spirit? And what is the freedom — older translations say "liberty" — that His Spirit brings?
Christ as the spirit of the old covenant
Kelly reads "spirit" in the first clause as the opposite of "letter":
I have no doubt about the meaning. The Lord Jesus is the spirit of the forms, figures and other messages of the old covenant. These, if taken in the letter, killed; if in the spirit, gave life. "The Lord" was their real scope; and now this comes out into the fullest evidence.
Hamilton Smith takes the same line and shows what it does to the way we read the older Scriptures:
The meaning would appear to be that the Lord Jesus is the spirit, or essence, of the old covenant. All its forms, sacrifices and ceremonies pictured Christ in different ways. The law had a shadow of good things to come, but Christ is the substance (Heb. 10:1; Col. 2:17). Unbelief fails to see Christ in all the Scriptures. Faith grasps the Lord in every part of the Word, and nowhere more clearly than in the tabernacle, its sacrifices and services.
Why the second half speaks of the Holy Spirit
The verse moves from "the Spirit" to "the Spirit of the Lord." Dennett explains the shift:
The apostle teaches us that the Spirit that runs through and underlies "the letter" is a glorified Christ. But in the next clause he says, "And where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty." Here he speaks of the Holy Spirit. He is now speaking of the power by which we grasp Christ glorified, and of the liberty this brings us into.
The character of the freedom
Kelly describes the Spirit's own character, and the two errors this freedom stands against:
The apostle means the presence and power of the Holy Spirit now. He is not a spirit of bondage leading to fear, but of power, and of love, and of a sound mind. He is not a spirit of bondage, but the Spirit of the Son, whom God sent into our hearts, crying, Abba, Father… "Where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty," as opposed to Gentile license as much as to Jewish bondage.
Why life and freedom belong together
Hole shows why rules belong to one order and freedom to another:
Life and liberty go together, just as law and bondage are associated. The divine life is not to be held back or tied up by legal restraints… Legal restraints are necessary and suitable enough when the flesh or the world are in question. They are not effective, for the flesh and the world break through them and transgress. In another way the law is effective, for it curses and brings death in upon the transgressor. All is changed once the Spirit has given life. Then liberty can be safely given, for the Spirit of the Lord holds sway.
Freedom shows itself in where we look
What occupies the mind tells the two apart. Hamilton Smith sets teachers who turn people in on themselves against the Spirit's work:
Those referred to in 2 Cor. 2:17 would bring the saints into bondage by occupation with themselves: the Spirit brings into liberty by turning the soul to Christ in the glory. Such people are not afraid of the glory of the Lord. They can look at the glory seen in the face of Jesus with no veil over it. The One in whose face that glory shines has met the claims of glory.
Freedom you are meant to know
Wolston presses the verse as a personal question:
Bondage marks the soul under law; liberty is the portion of the one who has the Spirit. Are you in liberty? I find many dear children of God groaning, and moaning, and bowed down like bulrushes. This should not be… You are not only to know that you are forgiven. You are to know, by experience, that you are out of bondage.
Summary
- Key — The Lord Jesus is the spirit of the old covenant. Its forms and sacrifices killed when taken as bare letter. They gave life when faith saw Him in them.
- Power — The second clause turns to the Holy Spirit. He is the power by which we grasp the glorified Christ, and liberty follows.
- Freedom — This liberty comes from the Spirit of the Son, crying "Abba, Father." It stands against Jewish bondage and Gentile license alike.
- Safety — Rules restrain the flesh, and the flesh breaks through them. Where the Spirit has given life, liberty is safe, for the Spirit rules.
- Proof — A free soul stops watching itself and looks at the glory in the face of Jesus. Know that freedom by experience, not by belief alone.