For to this end we toil and strive, because we have our hope set on the living God, who is the Savior of all people, especially of those who believe.
Paul has just said that godliness holds promise for this life and the life to come. He now gives the reason he keeps working under insults, and it turns on one disputed title for God.
Why the Apostle Toils and Takes Reproach
The verse opens with "for." It gives the reason for what came just before:
William KellyThe apostle had been showing how little profit there is in bodily exercise. Godliness, by contrast, is valuable for all things. It carries the promise of the life that now is, and of the life to come. This he calls a faithful word, and worthy of all acceptance. The reason appears in our verse. The question here is of His preserving care, and not of salvation only. The apostle shows this to be most true of those who are most tried because of their faithfulness.
Older translations read "labour and suffer reproach" where the ESV has "toil and strive." Reproach is no accident here. It comes when the motive behind the work is real:
Hamilton SmithThe apostle can say, "For this we labour and suffer reproach," because of his piety. We may be willing to work and be prominent before others. We may work to gain applause, or work to exalt ourselves. But if piety is behind our labour, it will inevitably mean labour and reproach.
"Savior" Means Preserver Here
Many commentators read the word here as "Preserver." It points to God's care over His creatures, not the saving of souls:
William KellyIn my view, this is not a question of Christ's work in saving lost people who believe. It is of the living God as such that the apostle speaks — of God in His character of preserver of men, as Job also speaks (Job 7:20). God's providential care and government are before us. Nothing escapes His notice. So He clothes the grass of the field and feeds the birds of heaven, which do not sow or reap. So He makes His sun rise on evil and good, and sends rain on just and unjust.
Others point to places where Scripture already uses "save" this way — of rescue in this life, not of the soul:
A. J. PollockMost agree that the word "Saviour" in this passage refers to temporal salvation — that is, providential preservation. A glance at the context will prove this. Scripture uses the word this way elsewhere. 2 Kings 13:5 and Nehemiah 9:27 refer to the judges of Israel as saviours. In Acts 27:31, "Paul said to the centurion, Unless these men stay in the ship, you cannot be saved" — most evidently referring to temporal salvation.
Not a Promise That All Will Be Saved
Does the verse promise that everyone will be saved in the end? One writer answers no. Read it that way, he says, and the verse loses its comfort:
William KellyThe reference is not to Christ's work, but to God's faithful care of His creatures, His children especially, in providence day by day... Why read the salvation of men's souls into the terms of this verse? Other scriptures declare that only those who believe shall be saved, and that the mass, unrepentant and unbelieving, must perish. Apply it to the salvation of the soul, and the comfort disappears. Everything falls into confusion and uncertainty. Suppose those who are Christ's are only saved to a greater degree than those who reject Him and perish. Then theirs would be a small and sorry salvation... Indeed it would be nonsense to speak of saving the souls of all men, especially of the faithful.
What "Especially" Gives the Believer
The word does not create two classes of saved people. It marks a closer relationship inside a care that already covers everyone:
Leslie M. GrantAll men are dependent upon His preserving care in the very details of their lives: if so, how much more should believers depend on Him fully; for whatever the reproach they may bear, they will be unfailingly preserved by God.
Trust in the Living God as the Spring of Godliness
Piety, or godliness, has to run on something:
Hamilton SmithThe apostle goes on to show that the spring of piety is confidence in God... Piety is that individual confidence in God that takes up every circumstance of life in relation to God. The unregenerate man leaves God out of his life; the believer recognises Him in all the details of life and thankfully receives and uses every mercy that He places within his reach.
Great Privileges Do Not Cancel Small Mercies
A believer can be so full of eternal things that he forgets God's daily care:
William KellyNo Christian could forget for a moment the infinite privilege of eternal life and redemption, of heavenly hope and everlasting glory. But faced with these unseen and eternal things, he might overlook the constant daily and special care of God in the ordinary matters of this life. That would be his own great loss, and it would dishonour the Lord. This verse, and the context before it, guards the soul against such an error. The highest privileges do not set aside or weaken this unchanging truth at its most everyday level.
Summary
- Cause — Paul works and takes insults for one reason: his hope rests on the living God. Real godliness behind the work draws reproach.
- Preserver — "Savior" here means Preserver. It is God's daily care, the care that feeds birds and sends rain on just and unjust alike.
- Reach — That care covers every person alive. So the verse is no promise that every soul will be saved in the end.
- Especially — Believers are not saved by degrees more than others. God's preserving care is truest toward those most tried for their faithfulness.
- Result — Trust in the living God is the spring of godliness. Bring Him into every ordinary detail, and heaven's hope never crowds out today's mercies.