Now the Philistines were fighting against Israel, and the men of Israel fled before the Philistines and fell slain on Mount Gilboa.
Samuel had already told Saul how this day would end: the Philistine attack breaks Israel's line, and the dead lie on the ridge of Gilboa. Two questions follow: why does a whole nation fall with one man, and where is God while it happens?
Where Gilboa Lies
The verse names a real mountain range, and David later called down a curse on it.
Morrish Bible DictionaryMountain range where Saul and Jonathan were slain... When the news reached David he exclaimed, "You mountains of Gilboa, let there be no dew or rain upon you, nor fields of offerings." It is judged to be on the south-west of the valley of Jezreel.
A Battle Already Decided
Israel's flight was not a surprise reversal. A warning had been spoken beforehand, and the outcome matched it exactly.
William KellyBut the last chapter (1 Samuel 31) unveils a far different sight. It shows the sad signs of the Philistines' victory over Saul and his sons, who fell down slain on Mount Gilboa... "So Saul died, and his three sons, and his armour-bearer, and all his men, that same day together." How truly the prophet had warned! How exactly every word came true! So fell Saul and his house.
Strength of arms did not decide this day. One writer points to a famous soldier who learned that lesson at last.
Samuel RidoutIt is enough for us that disobedience here meets its doom under God's government. The word of Samuel about the outcome of the battle had to be fulfilled, whatever the strength of the two armies might be. Napoleon is reported to have said that God was on the side of the heaviest guns. Poor man, he lived to find out at last that God was not on his side.
When the Head Fails, the Body Runs
One writer traces Israel's panic straight back to the king's own state of mind.
Leslie M. GrantThe day has come for Saul to go down into battle and die. The Philistines fight against Israel and find no resistance. We know that Saul was completely demoralised. He could only expect that his armies would share the same hopeless fear. Israel fled before the enemy and the Philistines were able to slaughter them without restraint.
The loss did not stop at the battlefield.
Samuel RidoutThe victory of the Philistines is, for the time being, complete. The terrified Israelites leave their homes and their cities to the conquerors, who live in them. Every defeat by the enemy becomes an occupation of territory that ought to belong to the people of God.
The Reason Supplied Elsewhere
1 Samuel 31 reports the disaster without explaining it. The retelling in Chronicles adds the cause.
H. L. RossierAfter Saul's genealogy, we find only the account of his death, told almost word for word (1 Chron. 10:1-12) from 1 Samuel 31. But the Spirit of God adds a very remarkable extra passage in verses 13-14: "Saul died for his unfaithfulness against the LORD. He did not keep the word of the LORD. He also asked a medium for guidance, and did not ask the LORD; therefore He slew him." In this passage God explains the reason for His final judgment upon Saul, the same as that upon every sinful man: disobedience and departure from God.
The Experiment That Ended Here
Israel had asked for a king like the other nations. Gilboa is where that request finished.
C KnappSaul was the man of the people's choice, but he was a dreadful disappointment. His dishonoured death matches his unhappy life... As another has well described him, he was "the man after the flesh." That tells the whole story. In all his life he seems never to have truly been brought into the presence of God. His activities were all of the flesh. He saw everything only as man sees it, in the harsh light of man's day. Defeated on Mount Gilboa, he is a suicide at last.
The Man Kept Off the Field
While Israel was breaking on Gilboa, David was far away — and that absence was arranged, not accidental.
J. N. DarbyWhat grace that God prevented David from going with Achish! If he had laid his hand on Saul, he could not have uttered the lament he composed on the subject of his death.
Summary
- Word first. Samuel announced the outcome before the armies met. Gilboa matched his word to the letter.
- Cause named. Chronicles gives the reason this verse leaves out. Saul died for unfaithfulness, for not keeping God's word, and for asking a medium instead of the Lord.
- Nation follows. A demoralised king produced an army with no resistance left in it; Israel fled, and the enemy killed at will.
- Ground lost. Defeat cost more than lives. Israel left its cities, and the enemy moved into the land.
- Grace kept. The day that ended the people's king kept David far from it. That left him free to mourn, not to strike.