And Saul's servants said to him, “Behold now, a harmful spirit from God is tormenting you.
1 Samuel 16:15 · ESVView all translations

Saul's servants name the trouble out loud: a spirit from God is tormenting their king. Their reading is right, but can music fix what Saul's own conduct caused?

The Spirit Withdrawn, a Spirit Sent

This verse leans on the one just before it. The same moment that brings the Spirit on David takes Him from Saul.

Hardly is David called to the throne when Saul's moral condition changes completely. Until that day the Spirit of God had been with the king according to the flesh, and this explains each of Saul's successes against the enemies of Israel. Now the Spirit of the Lord comes upon David (v. 13) and departs from Saul, who is left in the power of "an harmful spirit from the LORD" (v. 14). This is a judgment from God, a chastisement upon the king.

H. L. Rossier

"From God" — What the Phrase Allows

The servants say the spirit is from God. How far does God's hand reach in this?

Evil as well as good has its commission from God — not its existence, but its liberty to act, and the limits of its action. So we see with Job in early times, and in Ahab's case later; and it is a real comfort to know this. This is how the wrath of man is made to praise Him, and the remainder of it He restrains. Nothing can escape from the divine government by the fact or the claim of being evil. How could it? Only in this way can we be at peace, sure that no waves can rise higher than the footstool of His throne.

Numerical Bible Notes

Commentators also separate this from a believer's suffering. What struck Saul reached his heart.

A "messenger of Satan" may be sent out from the presence of God upon either the flesh or the heart of man. An evil spirit from the Lord came upon Saul, and a lying spirit came upon the prophets of Ahab. The Lord was beginning solemn acts of judgment, and so these messengers of Satan were sent out upon the heart of those who were rightly under judgment. But other messengers of Satan reach only the body or the circumstances, as with Paul and our patriarch. And this is discipline only, and not judgment.

J. G. Bellett

No Neutral Ground

What happens to a man once the Spirit of God leaves?

God allowed Saul to take his own headstrong way. More than that: since Saul had refused the Spirit of God, he lay open to the opposite, an evil spirit. God let that evil spirit trouble Saul, to wake him up to the folly of his own self-will. Disobedience to God does not leave us in a merely negative state, but in a state of positive evil.

Leslie M. Grant

Commentators reject the idea that Saul was simply mentally ill.

It has sometimes been said that king Saul was afflicted with insanity. This is not the truth. Sadly, it was not insanity, but the demon of evil to which he had yielded himself and which now asserts itself as his master.

Samuel Ridout

Treating the Symptom

Saul wanted the torment eased. Commentators point out where he should have looked instead.

The desire of Saul, the rejected king, was not a godly one; he should have looked in his own conduct for the cause of his trouble.

The Bible Treasury

The Harp and Its Limits

David comes in with his harp. The relief is real, but it has a limit.

David's harp does not act directly on Satan, but on Saul. It has a strange power to soften and subdue the savage temper of the rejected king, though only for a time. By that means it drives back the power attacking him and shuts it out. For the time, he is set free.

Numerical Bible Notes

That short-lived relief carries a warning. Comfort is not the same as cure.

There is a solemn thought here. Some ministry of Christ is so soothing that it can partly relieve a soul's fears and distress without working any real cure. David is clearly a type of Christ here. By His Spirit, Christ ministers His word in the ordinary way — its sweet story of God's love and care, of His power over evil, of the comfort He brings to His own. That word gives relief even to those whose hearts are estranged from God.

Samuel Ridout

Summary

- Cause. Saul refused the Spirit of God. The Spirit left him and an evil spirit came — two halves of one judgment.

- Commission. Evil does not get its existence from God. Its liberty and its limits do come from Him. No wave rises higher than His throne.

- Vacuum. Refusing the Spirit leaves no neutral space. Disobedience puts a person in positive evil, not in emptiness.

- Misdiagnosis. The servants named God as the source, then sent for a musician. Saul should have looked at his own conduct.

- Relief without cure. The harp soothed Saul but never cured him. A soul can hear the sweetest truths about Christ and stay estranged from God.

Reviewed by Orion on September 15, 2026