Then two prostitutes came to the king and stood before him.
1 Kings 3:16 · ESVView all translations

Two women of the lowest standing in Israel come before the king with a quarrel over a child. What follows is a sample of Solomon's wisdom at work. Commentators see in it both how God judges and a picture of a far greater love.

Wisdom Asked For, Wisdom Tested

Solomon had asked God for the wisdom to carry out the duties of his throne. The next scene puts that gift to work in public.

Solomon knows he needs the help of Jehovah to fulfil the duties before him. Through the grace of God, he shows a state of heart about this which pleases Jehovah… The judgment he gives shows the wisdom he had asked for, and the people acknowledge that it comes from God.

J. N. Darby

A Case No Evidence Could Settle

Two claims, no proof, no witnesses, no distinguishing marks on the child. Their trade did not close the court to them.

Though it concerns prostitutes, nothing changes this judgment. Men always let the character of those who speak to them shape their judgments. It is not so with God. What matters to Him is the heart, not the outward character. Solomon's judgment rests on the affections the heart shows. Claims and denials were worth the same here, so judgment could not rest on them… The question was not which of the two women was more worthy — both were prostitutes. It was not whether the actions complained of were likely or had happened — there had been no witness. It was not whether the true mother could recognise her child by some outward sign — there were none.

H. L. Rossier

The Sword That Read Hearts

The order to divide the child sounded monstrous. No one in the room could have guessed where it was going.

No ruler better than Solomon shows that the heart of kings is unsearchable… Did one soul see into his heart when he called for a sword? He said, "Divide the living child in two, and give half to the one and half to the other." The false mother was as willing as the true one was not, but who could have anticipated it except the king? What sounded cruel turned out wise and kind.

William Kelly

The false claimant agreed to the sentence, and her agreement exposed her.

It was not love for the child that moved her, but jealousy toward the other woman. Solomon knew that if she was dishonest enough to steal the child, his test would reveal her motives.

Leslie M. Grant

Love Proved by What It Will Give Up

The real mother would rather lose her son than see him killed.

When the true mother saw the sword lifted over her child, "her heart yearned for her son." The object loved matters more to us than our love for it. This is how one tells what is real, and who the true mother is… Only divine wisdom can tell, by the state of the heart, whether a profession of faith is real. How often there is profession without reality! Where are the affections for Christ? Where is the devotion that sacrifices even its lawful advantages and rights for Him?

H. L. Rossier

The Verdict Points to the Cross

One writer draws out the principle behind the king's ruling and follows it to the cross.

The king's judgment was this: self-sacrificing love has the unbreakable right to hold and enjoy the object it loves. And all the power of his throne stood behind his judgment to make it good. Solomon's judgment declared the law of God's universe, and there is none greater than it.

J. T. Mawson

The sentence of death had been passed on us and the enemy of God claimed us as his; not that he cared for us at all. "He shall be neither mine nor yours; divide him," said the woman who was not the mother — let it perish. Satan would have been overjoyed if we had been buried for ever in the depth of hell. Then God and Christ would have lost us for ever. But the Good Shepherd gave His life for the sheep.

J. T. Mawson

Glory With a Flaw in It

One writer looks past the verdict to what such a case says about Solomon's reign, and about the greater King to come.

The king's action made a deep impression on the people generally. "And all Israel heard of the judgment that the king had rendered, and they stood in awe of the king, because they perceived that the wisdom of God was in him to do justice." But the incident reminds us that Solomon's glorious reign did not reach perfection. No one could ever bring such a sordid case before Solomon's greater Son, God's "Holy One."

W. W. Fereday

Summary

- Asked — Solomon asked God for wisdom to judge. This case is the public proof that God gave it.

- Impartial — the women's trade did not shut the court to them. God weighs the heart, not the speaker's reputation.

- Tested — there were no witnesses and no proof. The sword was not cruelty. It made hidden motives speak.

- Revealed — jealousy said, "divide him." Love would rather give the child up than see him die. Love shows itself by what it will surrender.

- Fulfilled — self-sacrificing love holds the unbreakable right to the one it loves. The cross proved that law.

Reviewed by Orion on September 4, 2026