And to Abiathar the priest the king said, “Go to Anathoth, to your estate, for you deserve death. But I will not at this time put you to death, because you carried the ark of the Lord GOD before David my father, and because you shared in all my father's affliction.”
Solomon has just taken the throne, and his first acts settle old scores. The man he sends away is the priest who carried the ark and shared David's hardships — so what had Abiathar done, and why does he keep his life?
A reign of righteousness begins
Solomon's judgments open his reign, and they fall on people who had God's patience and did not use it:
H. L. RossierSo the reign of righteousness begins with judgment. It falls on all those who were placed under the grace and patience of God, but did not use it to bring their hearts and their actions into line with this rule. Abiathar was all the more guilty because he had carried the ark of the Lord before David, and had also shared his afflictions from the beginning (1 Sam. 22:20). He had had a part in the testimony of the Lord's anointed, and had suffered for it. Solomon recognises this. But there was one case where Abiathar's faithfulness was tested, and where the glory of the son of David was at stake. In that case he failed completely and abandoned his master.
The one test he failed
Abiathar had backed Adonijah's grab for the throne. That single choice exposed him:
Leslie M. GrantAbiathar the priest had earlier seemed true to David (2 Sam. 15:24-29). But Adonijah's defection tested him and proved him lacking, so he could no longer be trusted as a faithful priest. Solomon did not put him to death, though he told him he deserved it (v. 26). Instead he banished him from Jerusalem and sent him to Anathoth, his home.
Mercy for past faithfulness
Carrying the ark is what stood between Abiathar and execution. It also makes his part in the plot harder to explain:
An Outline of Sound WordsAbiathar had carried the ark of God, and this saved him on the day Solomon convicted him. It was very sad that a priest of God should be caught up in a plot to set aside the will of God. God had clearly told David that Solomon was to succeed him as king. If Abiathar had been living close to the king, he would have known the mind of God.
The move he made to secure his position destroyed it:
An Outline of Sound WordsNo doubt Abiathar thought that following Adonijah would secure him the priesthood. He was flattered that Adonijah had consulted him. But instead of being confirmed in the priesthood, Solomon thrust him out. Only his earlier faithfulness saved him from death.
A sentence passed generations earlier
Abiathar's removal also closed a case God had opened long before against the house of Eli:
C. KnappAbiathar followed David in his wanderings, and he stayed in office all through David's reign. But for his part in Adonijah's conspiracy, Solomon banished him to the priests' town of Anathoth, where he most likely died in disgrace. "So Solomon expelled Abiathar from being priest to the LORD, thus fulfilling the word of the LORD that he had spoken concerning the house of Eli in Shiloh" (1 Kings 2:27). He was the fourth high priest from Eli, and the last of the line of Ithamar to hold this office of dignity and honour. God had announced His judgment on the family nearly a century before. It did not come quickly, but it still came exactly as God had said.
The priest now stands under the king
Abiathar's removal also marks a change in where the priest stands:
J. N. DarbyAfter the king is brought in, the position of the priesthood changes. It stops being the usual link between the people and God. When God sets Eli aside, He says, "I will raise up for Myself a faithful priest… and he shall go in and out" — not before Me, but "before My anointed forever" (1 Sam. 2:35). Here I have a royal person, another link between God and the people, set above priesthood. So Solomon was quite right in thrusting out Abiathar.
Faithful once is not enough
Abiathar had stayed loyal when Absalom rebelled. That earlier test did not cover the later one:
An Outline of Sound WordsAbiathar should have known that if it was wrong to follow Absalom, it was also wrong to follow his brother Adonijah. It is not enough for us to be faithful in one crisis: we ought to be faithful in every crisis — yes, at all times and in all things.
Summary
- Word spoken. God's sentence on Eli's house waited nearly a century. Then it fell just as He said. Delay is not cancellation.
- Test applied. Abiathar looked loyal for a lifetime; Adonijah's plot was the one trial that measured him, and he failed it.
- Grace refused. His guilt was greater, not smaller. He had carried the ark, shared David's sufferings, and had every means of knowing God's mind.
- Mercy given. Past faithfulness did not save his office. It did save his life: he went to his own fields instead of to the sword.
- Order settled. With the king in place, the priest now serves before the anointed one. Righteous rule begins by removing those who will not bend to it.