Then the people of Israel were divided into two parts. Half of the people followed Tibni the son of Ginath, to make him king, and half followed Omri.
Israel's northern kingdom had already broken away from Judah, and now it splits again behind two rival leaders. The four-year civil war that follows raises one question: what happens to God's people when His will no longer decides anything?
A Throne Passed Along by Murder
Tibni is the last name in a long run of murders and army takeovers — and all of it happened among God's own people:
W. W. FeredayJeroboam's son Nadab reigned only two years. One of his captains — Baasha — then murdered him, during the war with the Philistines at the siege of Gibbethon. Baasha occupied his bloodstained throne twenty-four years... Baasha's son Elah succeeded his father, but an officer named Zimri murdered him two years later. This man hoped to establish himself in Tirzah — the capital of the ten-tribe kingdom. But another captain — Omri — wanted the throne. Within a week he captured Tirzah. Zimri died in the flames of the royal palace, which he himself set on fire when he saw that his cause was hopeless. But even this did not settle the country. Yet another man reaching for the throne appeared — Tibni the son of Ginath... We are speaking, not of pagan nations, but of God's chosen people. He had done great things for them from Egypt onward, and He had made His holy will known to them. Israel had the Scriptures; no other nation was so privileged... A downward course is always slippery. Let us all beware of the first small step away from the revealed will of God.
Division Inside a Division
In this verse "the people of Israel" means the ten northern tribes. That half of the nation now splits again:
H. L. RossierAnother feature marks the decline of the kingdom. Israel is divided against itself: how shall it stand?
Older people alive at the time could remember something very different:
W. W. FeredayOnly a few years before — probably within living memory — the twelve tribes of Israel were one people. God's goodness had set them high among the nations, and all the kings around paid homage to their king. The country was wealthy and peaceful... Now — they were divided into two nations hostile to each other. Two ruthless military leaders were fighting for control in the Northern State.
When God's Will Counts for Nothing
The people picked their own king. Where God's will no longer decides, something else does:
H. L. RossierThe people, camped before Gibbethon on the day of Zimri's grab for power, choose Omri, the captain of the army, for their king. These facts always repeat themselves in the decline of empires. When a people is without God, His will is counted as nothing. What He established at the beginning is set aside. The one who has might reigns. Since might lies in the army, the empire is at the mercy of the military power. Conspiracy on one side, a soldiers' revolution on the other.
The Outcome Was Never in Doubt
The two halves were not evenly matched. One side had the army behind it:
C. KnappCivil war — the most terrible of all forms of armed conflict — followed Omri's taking of the throne of Israel... "All Israel made Omri, the commander of the army, king over Israel that day in the camp," it says — that is, the army camped against Gibbethon. But part of the tribes took up Tibni's cause. During the four-year contest Omri would be in the position of a military dictator. With the soldiers behind him, he was almost sure to win in the end against his rival. His rival's death probably ended the conflict.
Winning the War, Losing the Centre
Whichever man won, the deeper problem stayed. The ten tribes had walked away from the centre God had chosen:
Leslie M. GrantConfusion marked the whole history of Israel from Jeroboam on. Kings fell from power, and evil men fought over the throne. Tibni, the son of Ginath, challenged Omri, and both of them had large followings (v. 21). Omri's side prevailed, however, and Tibni died... Of course this was in opposition to God's decree that Jerusalem was the centre of the nation Israel. Judah recognised this, but the ten tribes had given themselves up to accept any substitute.
The Same Story in the Church
Israel is not the only people who lined up behind rival leaders:
Hamilton SmithIn the history of Israel the people failed. In their low condition they insisted on a king, and then the kings led them astray. So in the history of the Church. In 1 Corinthians 3 and 4, the Apostle Paul traces all division back to the low, fleshly condition of the people. That condition led them to line up under certain leaders. Paul also foresees that after his death leaders would arise who would bring about open division.
Summary
- Drift — for generations the throne had changed hands by murder. Tibni and Omri are the next step down.
- Divide — a nation once united and honoured is split in two, then split again, as rival leaders fight for control.
- Vacuum — where God's will counts for nothing, people set aside what He established, and the strongest man reigns.
- Force — Omri held the army, so the four-year contest could only end one way. Strength, not righteousness, decided who wore the crown.
- Substitute — the real loss was not Tibni's life. It was the centre God appointed in Jerusalem, traded for any substitute — the same low condition that later split the Church behind rival leaders.