Book
Chapter
Verse
Bible Translation
But we *do* know that all things work together for good to those who love God, to those who are called according to purpose.
"And we know that all things work together for good to them that love God, to them who are the called according to his purpose."
The Connection: From Not Knowing to Knowing
The verse stands on a deliberate contrast with what precedes it. The apostle has just said that "we do not know what we should pray for as we ought" (v. 26) — but now, with equal certainty, he declares what we do know.
F. B. Hole draws this out with characteristic clarity:
F. B. HoleWe must not miss the connection between verses 26 and 28, though it is not very clear in our version. It is, "We do not know what we should pray for as we ought … but we do know that all things work together for good to them that love God." This thing and that thing may appear to work evil, but together they work for our spiritual good. This must be so, inasmuch as the Spirit indwells us, helping our weaknesses and interceding in our perplexities; and also in the light of the fact that God has taken us up according to His purpose, which nothing can thwart.
William Kelly makes the same point, and insists that the verb is present tense — not merely shall work, but do work:
William KellyEven Paul, in 2 Corinthians 12, did not know what to pray for as he ought; but the Lord was faithful and made the sufficiency of His grace known — an answer far better than the prayer. And yet not Paul only, but even we know that all things work together for good — not merely shall, but do now, and this for others as well as ourselves, for those that love God. Otherwise sorrows irritate. Here they are twice blessed, blessed to those exercised by them, blessed to other children of God; in short, to those that love Him and to those that are called according to purpose, for this is here carefully stated, lest the love of God on our part might enfeeble the thought of grace on His. Hence purpose and calling according to it are put forward.
Kelly also sounds a careful note about the scope of "all things":
ROM_PT2It seems harsh, however, with Augustine and others to drag in sins here among the "all things;" for though no doubt grace can turn everything to account, scripture is the more careful to guard against the least real appearance of dealing lightly with that which is morally offensive to God.
"All Things Work Together for Good"
Hamilton Smith unfolds the verse as marking a transition from the Spirit's inward work to God's outward operations on our behalf:
Hamilton SmithThe Apostle has shewn how blessedly the Holy Spirit works in us by the new life in Christ, and the indwelling Holy Spirit, producing spiritual experiences. Now we learn that not only is God the Holy Spirit in us, but that God is for us in "all things" that are taking place around us. In regard to all the circumstances of life, the trials, the sorrows, the conflicts and the difficulties, we may not know how to pray as we ought; but this we do know, "That all things work together for good to them that love God". We may not always see how this loss, or that trial, is working for our good, but faith knows that good will be the result in time and eternity. To understand the way in which all things work for good we may have to wait, even as the Lord said to Peter, "What I do thou knowest not now; but thou shalt know hereafter". Another has said, "The sorrow may not be remedied, but the sorrow is blessed".
"To Them That Love God"
Norman Anderson emphasises that the "things" in view include both the pleasant and the painful — and that the experience is inseparable from sonship:
Norman AndersonWe do now however that all things work together for good — things pleasing and otherwise. The things which beset saints in their journey here are allowed of God. We are sons of God and are being educated as sons for the day of glory. Rejoice then that we are among those who love God, who are called according to His purpose.
"The Called According to His Purpose"
Hamilton Smith shows how "the called" secures what "those who love God" might leave uncertain:
Hamilton SmithTo assure our hearts that all is working for good, we are reminded that we are "the called" of God; and, if called, God has a purpose for us. God saves us because we need saving; God calls us because He wants us. All God's ways with us in the present have in view the fulfilment of His purpose for us in the future.
J. N. Darby opens out the full sweep of God's purpose that flows from this verse:
J. N. DarbyWe know not what we should pray for as we ought; but we do know that all things work together for good to them that love God; and the source and security of all is set forth; they were called according to His purpose; He foreknew them, predestinated them to be conformed to the image of His Son, called them, justified them, glorified them. God (says the apostle, in the name of all the saints) is for us; who can be against us?
William Kelly highlights the unbroken chain from purpose in eternity to glorification for eternity:
William KellyThe chain is thus complete from His own purpose in eternity to their glorification for eternity. It is the activity, extent, and scope of the grace of God for its objects apart from all circumstances, and, as we shall see later, in spite of them, let them be what they may, because they are but creature causes or effects, whilst God is for us and supreme above all, not a mere causa causata, but the one causa causans.
The Practical Force: Trials and Testing
F. B. Hole, in a separate address on testing and trials, links Romans 8:28 to 1 Peter 1:6 and stresses that there is always a need behind each trial:
F. B. HoleIt is very like that scripture in Romans 8, where it says we do not know what we should pray for as we ought. The verse which follows should begin with a "but." "But we know that all things work together for good to them that love God, to them who are the called according to his purpose." There is a need. Let us remember that.
The author of The Happy Life draws out the attitude this truth should produce:
A Christian knows he is a beloved child of God, and that His Father has all circumstances under control, allowing only those things that are for our greatest good: "We know that all things work together for good to those who love God" (Rom. 8:28). This is true, without qualification.
And further:
HAPPYLIFShould we dread His irresistible power and sovereign will when we know that He is making all things work together for our present and eternal good? How narrow-minded of us to complain about our circumstances in the face of such plain statements!
William Kelly, writing elsewhere on tribulation, ties the verse back to the believer's daily wilderness experience:
William KellyIt is therefore not only in His counsels going on to glory through redemption that He blesses and we boast, but in His ways through this wilderness world. Sometimes the believer is at his wit's end: difficulties so thicken. We do not know how to pray as we ought, but the Spirit Himself makes intercession with groanings unutterable; and He that searches the hearts, knows what is the mind of the Spirit, because He intercedes for saints according to God. But we do know that, to those who love God, all things work together for good.
Romans 8:28 is not a bare promise that things will "turn out all right." It rests on the deepest possible foundation: the eternal purpose of God. The verse pivots on a contrast — we do not know how to pray, but we do know that God is working all circumstances together for our good. The "good" in view is nothing less than conformity to the image of Christ in glory (v. 29). The guarantee is not our love for God (though that is the mark of the persons in question), but His calling according to purpose — a purpose that, as Kelly says, forms an unbroken chain from foreknowledge to glorification. The trials are real; the groaning is real; but they are being woven by a sovereign hand into a design whose end is glory. As Smith puts it: "The sorrow may not be remedied, but the sorrow is blessed."