Who is this that cometh up from the wilderness, Leaning upon her beloved? I awoke thee under the apple-tree There thy mother brought thee forth; There she brought thee forth [that] bore thee.
The Song has asked before who is coming up from the wilderness, but now the watchers see two figures — a bride walking out of the desert, held up by the one she loves. The verse then looks back to an apple tree, where He first awakened her.
Hamilton Smith traces the bride's path to this point.
Hamilton SmithThe bride comes out of the wilderness leaning upon the arm of her Beloved, and the daughters of Jerusalem ask, "Who is this?" In the fourth song the bride had sought and found the Bridegroom. In the fifth song she had held sweet and secret communion with Him. But now, at last, she stands before the whole world in His company, and in dependence upon Him. The wilderness wanderings lie behind her; the glory shines before her.
The same question opens Song 3:6. Kelly asks what has changed.
William KellyIs He now only "like columns of smoke, perfumed with myrrh and frankincense, with all the fragrant powders of a merchant" (Song 3:6)? No. There is another object. It is now "Who is that coming up from the wilderness, leaning on her beloved?" Here we see that it is not now the Bridegroom. She has a vision of herself — of herself united to the Bridegroom. Before, it was more His coming to her, or for her.
Israel had come up out of the wilderness once before. Kelly finds the difference in what the people leaned on.
William KellyLong ago the people had come up out of it, and God showed wonders of goodness and power. But it was all in vain. They did not lean on the Lord or His Christ. They leaned on self and law, and for sinful man — which is what they were — that can only mean death and condemnation. It will be far different when the generation to come comes out of the wilderness leaning upon the beloved. What brings about so great a change? "Under the apple tree I awakened you. There your mother was in labor with you." Christ is meant by that tree. It is His to awaken her from her long sleep and give her the life that alone lives to God.
Leaning is not something the bride achieves. Hamilton Smith shows what stands in our way.
Hamilton SmithWe wander and fall, but grace brings us up out of our wanderings leaning upon Christ, just as the bride leans on her beloved. We fall, like Peter, because we lean on our own love for Christ. In tender grace He lifts us up and brings us to lean on His great love for us... Pride makes it hard to own our nothingness and His fulness, our weakness and His strength, and so to find all our resources in Him... "Leaning" is weakness clinging to strength. John leaned on Jesus' breast (John 13:23), and that is leaning on the love of One in whom all fulness dwells.
Another writer turns this into a test we can apply to our own past.
The Song of SolomonLook back over our past life. In every time of failure, straying or defeat, we were not leaning upon Him. The secret of all failure in the Christian's life can be traced to this. He has never failed anyone who leans upon Him.
The second half of the verse looks back to her beginning.
The Song of SolomonChrist is the apple tree, and grace is our mother. We owe our very existence as Christians to the sovereign grace of God... We are born again through His grace that has worked in our hearts in connection with Christ. No sinner can ever be saved until he flees to Christ for refuge. "There she who bore you was in labor." There under His shadow grace brought us forth and made us new creatures in Christ Jesus.
The debt is not the bride's alone.
Hamilton SmithNow the bride depends happily on the Bridegroom's love. She must never forget that she owes the Beloved every blessing she has, from the moment she was brought forth in weakness... Take a wandering believer brought back to fellowship and open service. Take wandering Israel brought back to glory on earth. Take a ruined and scattered church shown in perfect heavenly glory. All will owe their position to the sovereign grace of the Lord that awakened us, brought us out of our degradation, and joined us to Himself.
- Awakened — the journey starts under the apple tree. Christ is that tree, and no sinner is saved until he flees to Him for refuge.
- Leaning — leaning is weakness clinging to strength. Pride must go before we own our nothingness and His fulness.
- Contrast — the first generation came up from the wilderness leaning on self and law, and it was all in vain. The change is in who carries the weight.
- Displayed — after seeking, finding and secret fellowship, the world now sees her with Him, leaning on Him.
- Debt — restored believer, restored Israel, church in glory: grace awakened each one and gave it its place.
Set me as a seal upon thy heart, As a seal upon thine arm For love is strong as death; Jealousy is cruel as Sheol The flashes thereof are flashes of fire, Flames of Jah.
The Song ends with the bride asking for one thing: a place on the heart and arm of the one she loves, held there like a signet ring. Two questions follow. What does a seal secure, and why does she measure love by death and the grave?
This cry answers something the Bridegroom has just said. The whole book leads up to it.
Edward DennettThis last chapter takes up and sets forth all the principles of the whole song... In verse 5 comes the exclamation, "Who is this that comes up from the wilderness, leaning on her beloved?" Then the Bridegroom reminds His bride that she owes everything, wholly and entirely, to His grace — all the blessing she has entered into, and her very existence as the object of His affection and the companion of His joys. It is in response to this that she cries, "Set me as a seal upon your heart, as a seal upon your arm."
So whose love is she counting on?
Hamilton SmithShe does not doubt his love, but she realises that all her blessing depends on his love, not hers... So the restored soul delights to say of Christ: "My confidence is that my name is on His heart — I have a place in His affections. My name is on His arm — I have the protection and support of His strong arm." We can trust His heart and His arm, though we cannot trust our own.
The picture may come from Israel's high priest, who wore the nation's names cut into stone.
Edward DennettThe heart and the arm (probably the shoulder) are emblems of love and strength, as always in Scripture. They may refer to the names of the twelve tribes engraved on the breastplate, and on the onyx stones on the shoulders of the high priest. The meaning will then be: set me as a seal on Your heart and shoulders. The seal is a symbol of security, for a divine seal can never be broken. Set me there, so that Your divine love may always carry me and Your divine power uphold me.
Why measure love by death, of all things? Death is the strength no man has ever beaten.
Hamilton SmithThe Bridegroom's love is the ground of the bride's confidence, as the love of Christ is the ground of our confidence. This love has been proved, and found to be strong as death. Death makes sport of all man's puny strength. From the fall onwards men and death have been in mortal combat, and death has triumphed all along the line. Then at last love — love divine — went down into the dark valley and entered into combat with death. At the cross love came into conflict with death, and love triumphed. Death took away His life, but death could not take away His love. Love prevailed, because love yielded to death so that love might triumph over death.
The second comparison moves from strength to refusal to let go.
Andrew MillerIf death takes a strong hold of a person, the grave keeps it. It is unyielding... It holds fast its prey. Beg the grave on your knees, as earnestly as you like. It will never give you back the loved one torn from your heart and buried in its deep caverns.
The word "jealousy" sounds bad to us. Scripture uses it differently.
Hamilton SmithAlmost universally people speak of jealousy in an evil sense; Scripture hardly ever does. It even speaks of a godly jealousy. The Apostle can say of believers, "I feel a divine jealousy for you, since I betrothed you to one husband, to present you as a pure virgin to Christ" (2 Cor. 11:2).
The ESV calls this fire the very flame of the LORD. Older translations read "a flame of Jah."
Edward DennettThis love is so intense that it can only be compared to the consuming and purifying effects of fire — "a flame of Jah." That takes us back to the essence and greatness of its character, for love and light are the words used to express the divine nature.
That fire is not only His. It catches.
Hamilton SmithWe see the vehement flame of love carrying Paul through that remarkable life. He spent and was spent for the saints. He left home and ease, and faced hunger and thirst, cold and nakedness, dangers, persecutions and death, constrained by the love of Christ... The flame of love that glowed in the martyrs' hearts triumphed over the flame of the fire that burned their bodies.
- Grace first. The Bridegroom first reminds her that all her blessing, and her very place as His beloved, came from His grace. Only then does she ask for the seal.
- Sealed, not clinging. Heart and arm recall the high priest carrying Israel's names on his breast and shoulders. Her security rests on His love and His power, and a divine seal cannot be broken.
- Strong as death. Death had beaten everyone until love met it at the cross; it took His life and could not take His love.
- Cruel as the grave. The grave never gives back what it holds — so His jealous love tolerates no rival for the heart it has claimed.
- A flame that spreads. The same fire that burned in Him burned in Paul and in the martyrs, outlasting every flame set against them.
Many waters cannot quench love, Neither do the floods drown it Even if a man gave all the substance of his house for love, It would utterly be contemned.
The bride's plea in verse 6 ends with a claim about love itself: floods cannot put it out, and no money can buy it. Commentators read this as the love of Christ, tested at the cross, and they ask what it asks back from us.
These words close the Song. One writer sets them in the day when Israel returns to her Messiah, and reads both halves of the verse as one answer:
William KellyThen the prayer will be answered. Zion will be set as a seal on Messiah's heart and arm. How strong and jealous His love — and there is the answer to it in that day. Death and the grave only proved His love. The flame of the LORD tested it. Waters and floods could not quench it. It cannot be bought, and it is above all price, so that all a man can give is utterly despised beside it.
The "many waters" and "floods" are not left as poetry. One writer takes them to the cross, where love went under the water and came up unchanged:
Hamilton SmithNothing can quench divine love. The Lord Jesus faced the "many waters," but they could not quench His love. He faced the "floods," but they could not drown His love. At the cross "the floods lifted up their voice." Divine love proved mightier than the noise of many waters… All the billows and waves of God passed over Him (Jonah 2:3), but His love never passed from Him. His love has triumphed, and His love abides.
Verse 6 sets love beside death. One writer asks where we can find love like this, and gives only one answer:
Andrew MillerWhere shall we find love like this? Only in the heart of Jesus. What takes such a hold as death? What keeps it like the grave? What is so unsparing as the fierce flame? There is nothing to compare with love… When love and death met in fearful conflict on the cross, love triumphed, and death was forever defeated.
The second half of the verse moves from strength to price. A man may offer everything he owns for love and get only contempt. One writer sets what Christ gave up beside what He gave, then turns the question back on us:
Hamilton SmithLove cannot be bought. It is true that Christ gave up, as it were, the "substance of His house." He gave up kingdoms and thrones and crowns. But He gave more — He "gave Himself," and in giving Himself He proved His love… And in response to this great love He looks for love. Nothing but love from our hearts will satisfy the love of His heart. We may offer the work of our hands, our silver and our gold, our acts of charity, even our bodies to be burned. But if there is no love, it will be utterly despised.
It matters who first said this. One writer comments on Mary, who poured costly perfume over Jesus. He notes that the man who wrote these words could afford to test them:
William KellyThe love that prompted it was of God, and this is above all price. "If a man offered for love all the wealth of his house, he would be utterly despised." These are the words of the man who knew, better than anyone, how empty human love is. He had the greatest wealth ever given to the head of any house.
Love cannot be bought, and it cannot be worked up in us either. One writer says what to do when your love for Christ feels cold:
VariousIf He had only given all His possessions it would have been a wonderful gift. But He has not only given all that He has — He has given Himself, and all that He is, for us and to us… So never try to fan up the flame of your flickering love for Him by your own effort. It cannot be done that way. Instead, dwell on His intense, eternal and unchanging love for you, and you will find it warms your affections for Him.
One writer turns this into three exchanges to make when you fail Him:
J. T. MawsonWhen you have to mourn the coldness of your love, think of His love that the many waters could not quench. When you have to confess your forgetfulness and unfaithfulness, give thanks that He cannot forget, and that He loves His own to the end. When your selfishness and reserve fill you with shame, bless His name that He held back nothing, but sold all that He had, and gave Himself for you.
- Tested — the waters and floods were real. Christ went under them at the cross, and His love came up unchanged.
- Triumphant — love and death met in conflict at the cross; love won and death lost.
- Unbought — He gave up thrones, then gave Himself; no fortune offered in return can touch a love of that order.
- Unsatisfied by less — He looks for love back, and works, money and charity without it are worthless to Him.
- Answering — cold affection is not warmed by effort but by dwelling on the love that could not be quenched.
We have a little sister, And she hath no breasts What shall we do for our sister In the day when she shall be spoken for? --
The bride has just come to rest in love. Her first thought after that is not for herself but for a younger sister who is not ready. Two questions run through the verse: who is this little sister, and how do we help her before her day comes?
Where this verse sits matters. One writer traces the whole closing chapter as a single line of progress, and this verse is one step in it.
Hamilton SmithSo at last the soul is brought to rest. She has known the dark valleys and the mountain heights, the wanderings in the city and the delights of the garden. Now she rests in the eternal love of Christ (v. 5), in all its breadth and length and depth and height (vv. 6, 7). Now she thinks of others (vv. 8, 9), gladly owns that Christ will have universal sway (vv. 10, 11), and meanwhile holds every possession at His disposal (v. 12).
Concern for the weaker one is not a distraction from love; it is what settled love produces.
Several commentators read the Song as the story of God's people Israel. On that reading the little sister is Ephraim, the ten tribes. They were carried away captive long before Christ came, so the events that shaped Judah passed them by.
Andrew MillerThe "little sister" means Ephraim, the long-lost ten tribes; of this we have no doubt. Their captivity had taken place before the birth of Christ. So they know nothing of what Judah, the two tribes, has gone through over the birth, death, resurrection and return of the Messiah. Still, they come to enjoy the blessed results of His first coming in grace and of His second coming in glory.
On this reading the difference in history explains the difference in depth. Grace reaches both, but not by the same road.
William KellyThey suffered for their idolatry, as Judah did later. But they did not return from captivity as Judah did to refuse the Christ, and they are not to receive the Antichrist. So God's later dealings of grace with Israel do not take on the deep and punishing character that will be Judah's portion.
Commentators also apply the picture to believers today. No breasts means nothing in her has grown up yet, and one writer names what is missing.
F. A. HughesThe Scripture says, "We have a little sister ... and she has no breasts." One would want to treat this with holy delicacy! There is no developed affection for the Beloved! How often that might be said of the children of God! Their affections have not developed in response to Christ!
Others note the same unevenness through the whole book. Weakness in one believer draws something out of the mature, instead of pushing them away.
J. G. BellettIn the actions of this book we see souls at different levels — the betrothed one, and "the daughters of Jerusalem." Not all are fully formed. "We have a little sister, and she has no breasts." Such people draw out the sympathy of the saint who is established in the grace of God. He gives them careful concern and prayer, and he asks the Lord about them.
One writer weighs her exact words. She says we, not I, and she calls the girl our sister.
The Song of SolomonHow completely her beloved has come to fill her heart and life. Even her thoughts move in the awareness that she is one with him. She does not think of herself, or think to act apart from him, so it is not "I" but always "we." She also does not think of the girl as her sister only, but as his sister too. So she values the little sister all the more because of this link with him. We must not forget that however weak Christians may be, they all belong to the Lord. We must therefore respect them and treat them as His.
Her question looks ahead to a day, and to being ready for it. On the prophetic reading, that day is Ephraim's opportunity.
Hamilton SmithBut the day of opportunity is coming for Ephraim — the day when she is spoken for. And what will be done for her in that day?
Read as a pattern for helping the immature, the next verse rules out one method.
The Song of SolomonWe cannot produce growth by criticising, or by knocking and harping on their faults and failures. Instead we must seek to add something of beauty and value to them. We must build a palace of silver on the wall.
- Rested. Love that has come to rest in Christ is the love that starts asking about someone else. Verse 8 follows verse 7, not the other way round.
- Related. She is our sister, and his — the weakest believer belongs to the Lord, so we treat them as His.
- Unready. "No breasts" pictures affection for Christ that has never grown up. Commentators differ on whether this points to the ten tribes or to believers who have not matured.
- Reached. Grace comes to the little sister without the deep exercises her elder sister went through. She enjoys the results without the road.
- Built. The answer to immaturity is not criticism but building. Add something of beauty and value to her before her day comes.
If she be a wall, We will build upon her a turret of silver; And if she be a door, We will enclose her with boards of cedar.
The bride's brothers have just asked what to do for a younger sister who is not yet grown. This verse is their answer. The answer comes in two parts, each starting with "if": one gift for a wall, another for a door. What do the two pictures mean, and why does each need different care?
Commentators read the Song on two levels: a picture of God's people Israel, and a picture of Christian growth. On the first level, the little sister is the ten tribes of Israel. Their captivity happened long before Christ came, and the tribes who knew more teach them later.
Andrew MillerThe "little sister" means Ephraim, or the long-lost ten tribes — of this we have no doubt. Their captivity took place before the birth of Christ. So they know nothing of what Judah, the two tribes, has gone through about the birth, death, resurrection, and return of the Messiah. Still, they come to enjoy the blessed results of His first coming in grace and of His second coming in glory. And their more highly favoured sister Judah instructs them, builds them up, and establishes them in the doctrine of Christ.
A wall keeps things out. The first picture is a life closed to evil, and all growth starts there.
E. C. HadleyA wall speaks of separation. It encloses what is within and separates it from what is outside... All spiritual growth begins with what the Bible calls the fear of the Lord. That means having real reverential respect for Him, and recognising His power and authority over us. This leads to hating and forsaking evil. It enables one to stand like a wall against the evil influences around and not allow them any entrance within... Where it is lacking there is no foundation to build upon.
The ESV calls this a battlement of silver; older translations say turret, and the writers quoted here use that older word. Silver is not just decoration. It goes back to the atonement money Israel paid, and a turret is built to be seen.
E. C. HadleySilver speaks of redemption... This atonement money was used to make the silver sockets that served as the foundation of the tabernacle... The silver sockets show that redemption is the foundation on which everything rests. Without redemption we have nothing to stand on at all. In our passage the silver builds a turret on the wall. A turret is something that stands out conspicuously. It is costly and precious, and adds beauty and adornment. The turret of silver then would speak of redemption beautifully displayed before the eyes of others.
A wall shuts; a door lets people through.
E. C. HadleyA door is a means of entrance, a way by which one gains access to what is within... Every believer should be able, in some degree at least, to point the lost to the Saviour and show the ignorant the way of life. In this way he becomes a door... But some believers have not grown yet. They are not very clear themselves about the truth, so they can do this only in a clumsy way... Such people are like a rough, unfinished door in a stone wall. Someone who has reached spiritual maturity would do this work more effectively. He would be like a door beautifully enclosed with boards of cedar.
The wood matters too.
E. C. HadleyThe cedar is a fragrant, rot-resisting wood that grows on the heights of Lebanon. So it speaks of a character lifted high, fragrant and attractive, with power to withstand corruption and evil.
Commentators differ on the door. One writer reads it as Israel's heart opened to Christ.
Hamilton SmithWhen Israel is again established on a firm foundation like a wall, then she will be a monument of redeeming grace: "We will build upon her a turret of silver." When she becomes a door — when her heart is opened to Christ — she will come under His protection and care: "We will enclose her with boards of cedar."
The plan is to add, not to attack. That matters for anyone helping a weaker believer.
E. C. HadleyWe cannot produce growth by criticising, or by knocking and harping on people's faults and failures. We must seek rather to add something of beauty and value to them. We must build upon the wall a turret of silver.
The verse asks something of us too.
F. A. HughesWhatever the interpretation of this verse may be, let us apply it to ourselves like this. If our affections are not developed toward Christ, and our door is open to the world, one thing will hold us in responsive affection to Him: thinking on His redeeming love, His holy sufferings, and the unique greatness of His Person. "Silver" and "cedar wood."
- Diagnosis. The little sister is undeveloped, not unloved. Her family asks what she needs, not what she lacks.
- Foundation. "If she is a wall" — separation from evil, grown out of the fear of the Lord, is where everything else starts.
- Adornment. The battlement, or turret, of silver is redemption put on display — costly, and plain for others to see.
- Usefulness. "If she is a door" — a life others pass through into the light. Cedar makes that door fragrant, attractive, and proof against decay.
- Method. Growth comes by adding beauty, never by harping on faults. The same silver and cedar hold our own affections to Christ.
I am a wall, and my breasts like towers; Then was I in his eyes as one that findeth peace.
Her brothers have just asked what to do for their "little sister," who is not yet grown, and the bride answers by describing herself instead. Two questions follow: what do the wall and the towers stand for, and why does her growth show in the way her beloved sees her?
Chapter 8 sums up the whole book.
J. N. DarbySong of Solomon 8 stands by itself, and it seems to me to go back over the principles of the whole book… Prophecy announces the full satisfaction of every desire of the remnant, and marks out the path of their affections. But this picture is drawn to encourage those who are not yet enjoying it, and it expresses the longing to see it fulfilled.
So her confidence here is held out to encourage people still on the road.
Commentators read the two sisters as two parts of Israel. The little sister is Ephraim — the ten tribes carried off long before Christ came. The bride who speaks here is Judah, who has been through far more.
Andrew MillerTheir more favoured sister Judah teaches them, builds them up, and settles them in the doctrine of Christ… She is strong in the Lord, richly supplied, and in full favour with the King. God's Israel is restored! There are twelve tribes united in the Israel of God, not ten and two divided.
What separates the two sisters is what each has passed through.
J. N. DarbyThe "little sister" seems to me to be Ephraim, who never had the same growth that Judah received when Christ was revealed, and through all that happened after the ten tribes were carried away. All the moral affections of Judah were formed by their relationship to Christ, by His rejection, and by the feelings this produced when the Spirit made them felt. Ephraim has gone through none of this, but will come into the enjoyment of its results. Judah, when made complete, will enjoy the full favour of the Messiah; their affections were formed for Him by all their hearts went through about Him.
She claims strength — but the strength is not self-made, and the towers serve others too.
Hamilton SmithBy grace the bride can call herself a wall. Established in her relationships to the Bridegroom, her affection is the secret of her strength and the measure of her witness before others. A tower is a place of security as well as a landmark to others.
Read shortly, the picture is of someone fully grown, standing in contrast to the sister who still needs building up.
Morrish Bible DictionaryIf the little sister be a wall, she shall be built upon; if a door, she shall be enclosed; but the bride is a wall, and is grown to maturity.
Translations differ on the last line. Some read it "one who found favour." Others, including the ESV, read "one who finds peace." Peace is what love brings when the heart has come to rest in the right place.
Hamilton SmithThe believer whose affections are drawn out to Christ is truly the one who has found peace in the eyes of Christ. Mary's affections brought her to rest at the feet of Christ. In His sight she had found peace — a peace He will not let anyone disturb. "Mary has chosen the good portion, which will not be taken away from her."
Growth like this takes time. It shows in how she treats those still growing.
The Song of SolomonThe little sister who had no breasts shows someone who has not yet reached maturity. She stands for Christians who are saved but have not yet grown spiritually. The bride, by contrast, is well developed, and this is what makes her so beautiful in the eyes of her beloved. But no one reaches this spiritual growth in a day. She passed through many bitter experiences. Through them she learned to know herself better — her own failures and weaknesses — and to know more and more the faithfulness and depth of His love… Spiritual people never look down on those who are undeveloped. They long to see them grow to fuller maturity, and they are ready to give time and work to that end.
Assurance about herself and care for the weak sit side by side.
J. G. BellettShe takes account of the weakness of the weak. She wants them to have strength and to be built up in the fuller measure of Christ. All the time she owns them as fully one with her in Him. And she rejoices in her own certain, happy assurance… and so she knows her Lord's favour towards her, and His delight in her.
- Grace first. She can call herself a wall only by grace — the strength is given, not achieved.
- Grace grows slowly. Maturity came through many bitter experiences. Through them she learned her own weakness and the depth of His love.
- Grace makes a landmark. A tower is safety for her and a visible marker for others; her affection becomes the measure of her witness.
- Grace reaches the weak. The grown sister does not despise the undeveloped one but spends time and labour to see her built up.
- Grace ends in peace. Judah's heart was formed by all she went through with Christ. She stands at last in the King's full favour, with the twelve tribes united, not divided.
Solomon had a vineyard at Baal-hamon He let out the vineyard unto keepers; Every one for the fruit thereof was to bring a thousand silver-pieces.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
My vineyard, which is mine, is before me The thousand [silver-pieces] be to thee, Solomon; And to the keepers of its fruit, two hundred.
The song's closing scene sets two vineyards side by side. The King has a vast estate at Baal-hamon, let out to tenants. The bride has one she calls her own. Her answer settles the question the picture raises — who is the fruit for?
The name of that place, Baal-hamon, tells you how wide the scene is:
Andrew Miller"Baal-hamon" means Lord of a multitude. It refers to the multitude of nations — the whole earth, which now forms the vast vineyard of the Lord of glory. "The earth is the LORD's and the fullness thereof, the world and those who dwell therein" (Psalm 24). The millennium has come! The glory of the Lord fills the earth — every heart rejoices — Jesus reigns. A suitable return is now made to Him by the keepers of the vineyard. Everything is now under the eye of Christ, and according to the principles of His government… All will share in the riches of the fruitful, peaceful, joyful millennial earth. But Christ is Lord of all.
The bride speaks here. The King she calls Solomon is Christ come to reign:
William KellyIt is Christ come at last — Christ as King. That is what is spoken of here, and that is why He is called Solomon… "My vineyard, my very own, is before me." This is the language of the bride — of Jerusalem — because she, too, has a vineyard… She wants no vineyard apart from Him. She is identified with Him. The Jew will have no pleasure, no joy, no fruit, except in connection with Christ.
The vineyard is truly at her disposal. That is what gives the gift its weight:
J. N. DarbyThe vineyard of the bride was at her own disposal. But all its proceeds shall be for Solomon, and there shall be a portion for those who kept its fruits. This is a touching expression of her relationship to the King.
What she renders is no more than the amount owed. The difference lies in the spirit of it:
The Every Day Christian's HandbookHer vineyard is Israel, seen in their privileges and responsibilities before the Lord. He has set them in that place as head over all the nations. But she claims no returns for herself. Her love for Christ makes her desire that the full amount due from her vineyard should all be His. Those who labour as keepers, however, will also have what is due to them. Here we see more than living up to one's responsibility. We see love that counts it a joy.
The two hundred takes nothing from His honour. Others gain because He gets the whole:
Hamilton SmithBut the bride has her own vineyard. Restored Israel will have her special place, and she too will gladly own her subjection to Christ. But when she owns all to be His, others will get the blessing. If Solomon gets the thousand pieces of silver, others will get two hundred. Mary poured out her whole jar of very costly ointment on Christ. Yet others gained a benefit too, for "the house was filled with the fragrance of the perfume."
Earlier in the song the bride had not kept her own vineyard. Verse 12 undoes that failure:
J. N. DarbyVineyards were once entrusted to her, and she did not keep her own. Instead, Christ, as royal Prince of peace, now has a vineyard at Baal-hamon… But there was a special vineyard now, once not kept, which was now before the bride. That vineyard is Israel, who through grace would now keep her vineyard carefully. Her vineyard was before her.
She offers Him the full sum. His reply, in the next breath, asks for something the money cannot buy:
The Bible TreasuryAt the close of the song she takes the chance to show how much He is worth in her eyes… But is this what He cared for? Would the thousand pieces of silver satisfy Him? Listen to His answer: "O you who dwell in the gardens, with companions listening for your voice; let me hear it." Her voice was more refreshing to Him than any gift of money she could bring. He wanted to hear the sound of her voice. Nothing less would fully please Him… His last recorded wish is to listen to her voice. In Solomon there was no change, and in Him who is truly pictured here there is no change.
- Owned — the vineyard is truly hers, at her own disposal. No one forces this gift.
- Offered — she hands over the whole of it. The full thousand goes to the King, because love wants no vineyard apart from Him.
- Overflow — giving Him everything leaves no one poorer. The keepers get their two hundred, and Mary's ointment filled the whole house with its fragrance.
- Restored — the one who once failed to keep her own vineyard now keeps it carefully, and keeps it for Him.
- Asked for — the silver is not what satisfies Him. His closing word asks for her voice, and He asks for it still.
Thou that dwellest in the gardens, The companions hearken to thy voice Let me hear [it].
The Song of Solomon ends with the Bridegroom speaking one last time. He asks for no silver and no fruit — only the sound of her voice, which everyone around her can already hear.
In the verse before, the bride sends her vineyard's fruit to Solomon — the thousand pieces of silver. One writer weighs His answer against that offer.
The Bible TreasuryIs this what he cared about? Would the thousand pieces of silver satisfy him? Listen to his answer: "O you who dwell in the gardens, with companions listening for your voice; let me hear it." Her voice was more refreshing to him than any gift of money she could bring. It was the sound of her voice he wanted; nothing less would fully please him. What he had said in Song 2:14 is what he ends with here. His last recorded wish is to listen to her voice. "Let me hear it." In him there was — in Him who is really pictured here there is — no change.
He begins by naming where she now lives. One writer reads those gardens as the proof of what love has done for her, and as the only place a true witness can start from.
Hamilton SmithThe Bridegroom is heard for the last time. He delights to own what His love has done. The bride's wanderings are over: love has brought her to dwell in the gardens. How happy for us when the love of Christ draws us! Then we find our portion outside this poor world, in the company of His people — in the gardens of the Lord. Only from that happy place of fellowship can we bear a true witness to others. But the Lord is not content that others should hear our voice as witness. He Himself longs to hear our voice in worship, answering His own voice.
Who are the companions? One writer names them as the nations, and sets the scene beside the earlier picture of the bride coming up out of the wilderness.
The Christian's Friend and InstructorIn verse 5 we see the bride coming up from the wilderness, leaning on the arm of her beloved. Here we see her dwelling in the gardens. The wilderness with all its hard times is past forever, and the desert will have blossomed like a rose. The nations, her companions, listen to her voice. She gives them spiritual instruction and leads them in their worship and praise. The Lord delights in this, but He especially delights to hear her voice addressed to Him in personal and intimate communion with Him.
Another writer hears in these words an invitation to lead the praise, with the whole earth joining in.
Andrew MillerHe now addresses, for the last time in these songs of love, His beautiful and highly favoured spouse. He invites her praise. She is to sound the keynote for the companions — for the whole earth. Then all peoples, tribes, and tongues will catch the flying joy. They will roll out the glad hosannas, "from sea to sea, and from the River to the ends of the earth." Creation is filled with joy and gladness. Its long, loud anthems of praise and thanksgiving reach the ear of its glorious King. "Let ME hear it."
Christians talk about the Lord together. One writer hears this verse as the Lord's appeal for something more from us today.
J. T. MawsonThere is a very touching appeal in the Song of Solomon from the Bridegroom to the Bride. It is as though our Lord said to us, "You come together, and you talk to each other about Me. You are dwelling in the garden I planted by My grace, and you have sweet things to say. Let Me hear you talk to Me." The Lord chose the disciples so that they might be near Himself. He wanted them in His company as His friends, with the most intimate exchanges of love between them. It is the same today.
- The voice is wanted. She offered silver and fruit; the King asked for the sound of her voice instead — the same thing He asked for back in Song 2:14.
- The voice has a home. Love has ended the wandering and settled her in the gardens — and only from that place of fellowship can anyone bear a true witness.
- The voice teaches. The companions listen as she instructs them and leads their praise, and the Lord delights in this.
- The voice spreads. She sounds the keynote, and peoples, tribes and tongues take up the song to the ends of the earth.
- The voice must turn. Above all the talk about Him among His own, He asks for the one thing still missing: "Let Me hear you talk to Me."
Haste, my beloved, And be thou like a gazelle or a young hart Upon the mountains of spices.
The Song of Songs ends with the bride asking her beloved to hurry, not with the two of them together. Why does a book so full of love end in longing, and what are these mountains of spices?
The last line is a prayer, and what it asks for covers the church, Israel and the whole earth.
Andrew MillerOur lovely song has ended. Its last note is rich and full. The loving spouse fervently desires her Lord's speedy return. She asks that He may come without delay. The deep affections of her soul for Jesus show in the intensity of her desire for His glorious appearing. Oh, that all our hearts might be one heart, joining the deep, earnest, fervent prayer of the spouse! May He come quickly to our longing hearts. May He come for the rapture of the church, the glory of Israel, and the blessing of the whole earth.
Chapter 8 paints a scene of satisfaction, but it speaks to those still waiting for it: the faithful remnant of Israel.
J. N. DarbySong of Songs 8 stands by itself, and seems to me to sum up the principles of the whole book… Prophecy announces the full satisfaction of all the desires of the remnant. It also marks out the path of their affections. But this picture is drawn to encourage those who are not yet enjoying it. It expresses the desire for its fulfilment. So God puts His own approval on the eager desire of the remnant. They long to have Christ, and to have full liberty of communion with Him. The reply shows, with a clearness that is very precious, how it will come about… From Christ alone she draws her life. Only so can Israel give birth to this living remnant. At Jerusalem it will become the earthly bride of the great King. It desires to be, and will be, as a seal upon His heart, by the power of a love that is strong as death. That love spares nothing and yields nothing.
Her cry is an answer, not an opening. He had asked to hear her voice, and this is what He hears.
Hamilton SmithThe reply of the bride expresses the longing of her heart for the Bridegroom. He has His desire; He hears her voice as she says, "Make haste, my beloved." Those words fall on His ear with great delight, for they tell Him that love has finished its work in the heart of the bride. A love fills her heart that nothing apart from Him will satisfy, and that only His return can satisfy. So in our day love has taken us in hand. It bears with us patiently in all our wanderings, restores our souls, and revives our drooping affections. It brings us into the company of Christ in the garden of the Lord, opens up to us all the treasures of love, and tells us our Beloved is coming for us. And love has finished its work in our hearts when He says, "Surely I am coming soon," and hears His people answer: "Amen. Come, Lord Jesus!" (Revelation 22:20)
In chapter 2 she used the same picture of mountains. What changed by the last verse is what she asks Him to do.
The Christian's FriendWe may well echo the wish that ends the book. Before, in 2:17, it was "Until the day breaks … turn, my Beloved, and be … upon the mountains." Now it is "Make haste, my Beloved, and be … on the mountains of spices."
(In the ESV, 2:17 reads "until the day breathes and the shadows flee.")
The spices are not scenery she is describing but the effect of the One she is calling for.
Encyclopaedia of Christian Hymnody / CanticlesThe Song closes with the soul of the remnant going out in longing desire for the speedy return of the Lord to the mountains of Israel. His presence will turn the mountains of Israel, now for the most part waste and barren, into mountains of spices. So this prophetic book closes like the book of Revelation. It ends with an invitation breathed from the heart, asking the Lord to come quickly.
This same longing belongs to two different companies.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe Song of Songs ends with a prayer. This is how the remnant of Israel will plead in the future, that He may come and show Himself in His glory. But the bride of Christ, the Church, prays, "Come, Lord Jesus."
- Voice — the verse is an answer; He asked to hear her, and this is what she said back.
- Love — the cry proves love has finished its work; nothing but His return satisfies her now, and God approves that longing.
- Haste — she asks Him not to delay, but to come like a gazelle over the hills.
- Spices — barren mountains of Israel turn fragrant because He is there.
- Echo — Israel will plead this way for His appearing; believers pray the same in the words "Come, Lord Jesus."