Romans 8:19–23

Romans 8:19

For the anxious looking out of the creature expects the revelation of the sons of God

The whole created world is watching for a moment that has not yet come. Who is waiting, why does creation depend on God's sons, and when does the wait end?

The Picture in the Word "Eager Longing"

The words "eager longing" translate one Greek word. It carries a picture of straining forward.

"Earnest expectation" is only one word in Greek. It means "watching for something you expect, with your head stretched out." This word appears only here and in Philippians 1:20... One writer says it means "to expect on and on, to the end."

G C Willis

Why Creation Looks to Us

Creation's ruin came through man, so its rescue hangs on man too.

Creation did not fall into emptiness by its own choice, of course. It happened because of the one who subjected it. Man was set by God as the head of the lower creation. When he fell, creation shared his ruin. When Christ appears and the sons of God are revealed, we shall have proof that God made creation depend on them, and that its hope of freedom is not empty. If it was right that creation fell into emptiness when its head fell, then see how fitting it is, and how worthy of God: He redeems His children and heirs, and creation's glorious recovery follows!

William Kelly

Another writer looks at the same fall from God's side.

The creation fell with its head Adam... But God had His eye on everything, and the fall of man did not take Him by surprise... If the creation fell under one head, He knew how to recover it under Another.

James Boyd

The Sons, Not the Son

The verse does not say creation waits for the revealing of the Son of God.

Notice: creation does not wait for the revealing of the Son of God, but of the sons of God. He has already been revealed; they have not. When the sons of God appear in glory, the groaning creation will find relief. That will be the signal for its full deliverance. Its time of bondage runs on until then.

Andrew Miller

Right now nothing marks believers out to the eye. That is why the verse says "revealing": what is true but hidden will come into the open.

On the outside, His sons look no different from other people in body, power, or glory. They may be weak, they may suffer, and they fall asleep or die while the Lord waits on high. But at His coming, after the resurrection or the change, they will appear in glory with Christ when He appears too. Creation also awaits this happy moment. Its deliverance from its present misery depends on them and their revealing.

William Kelly

What Creation Receives — and What It Does Not

Creation is not offered what believers already have. Its need is different.

Creation lies in the misery and corruption that came from the fall. It will stay that way until the sons of God appear in bodies of glory. For creatures the question is not souls that need redeeming, but bodies that decay... Creation cannot receive grace, but it will share in the glory that brings outward blessing to this world of sorrow.

Hamilton Smith

The Timing This Verse Settles

So when does the relief come? This verse rules out two answers.

Preaching, profession, or even the real faith of believers will not free creation from the emptiness it has lain under since the fall... How will this be brought about? If the deliverance of the creature depends on the manifestation of God's sons, the answer is certain. It is not in this age; for all through, our life is hidden with Christ in God. It cannot be in eternity; for that will not be until the heavens pass away with a great noise... It is between the two.

William Kelly

One writer sums up the two waits in a single line.

We wait to go in; the creation waits until we come out.

James Boyd

Summary

- Cause. Creation did not choose this. It fell with Adam, its appointed head, and shares his ruin.

- Word. "Eager longing" pictures a neck stretched out, watching — a waiting that keeps on to the very end.

- Waiting. Creation watches for the sons, not the Son. He has been revealed; they are still hidden, and they look like everyone else.

- Gift. Creation cannot receive grace as we do. It will share the glory, and with it freedom from corruption.

- Result. The groaning ends when the heirs appear. That release comes neither in this age nor in eternity, but between the two.

Romans 8:20

for the creature has been made subject to vanity, not of its will, but by reason of him who has subjected [the same], in hope

Paul turns from the believer's coming glory to the world outside the window. He explains why nature is not what God made it to be. Two questions sit at the centre: who put creation under futility, and why does the verse end in hope?

Not the Original Design

The word "futility" (older translations read "vanity") does not describe how God first made the world. One writer finds the proof in the way every living thing fights to stay alive:

Creation was not made (as it now is) in decay, degradation, suffering, death. It would be hard to accept that God first designed it to be in such confusion and misery. The Scriptures teach the opposite. Creation lies under its present disorder because of man's guilt and ruin. Yet it does not long in vain for deliverance. It waits in hope for His revelation in glory. The very struggle of everything for life and against sickness witnesses that it is fallen to rise.

William Kelly

"The Creation": The World Below Man

The verse is not about the human race. The phrase "not willingly" is the clue. It fits creatures that never had a choice, and it never fits man, who did:

It is not "in relation to man generally" that the apostle tells us "he is a captive not by any choice of his own." Man is, sadly, a willing captive. It is still the lower creatures who have fallen with man, not of their own will, but as linked to him who was appointed the head of creation.

Frederick W Grant

Another writer traces the cause back to man:

But the creation did not of its own accord — "not willingly" — become subject to vanity. It was not a moral question, as it was with man. All creation has suffered because of man's sin; the subjection is "by reason of" man, "who has subjected it."

L. M. Grant

Who Subjected It — Two Readings

Commentators read "him who subjected it" in two ways. One reading points to man, the appointed head, whose fall pulled everything under him down too:

Man was set by God as the head of the lower creation. When he fell, creation shared his ruin. If it was righteous for creation to fall under vanity with its head, how worthy of God that its glorious recovery should follow the redemption of His children and heirs!

William Kelly

Others answer the question directly with "God," and explain the act as a matter of keeping order between a head and what is under him:

It was God. Someone has said it would have been unthinkable for the head to fall and the creature to stand above him. So when Adam fell, God subjected the creature to the same vanity as its fallen head. Its freedom will be public when the sons of God are revealed in glory, and it must wait until that time.

George Davison

A Fall With Recovery in View

"In hope" is the hinge of the verse. The fall was allowed with a second head already in view:

Its fall, because of the transgression and fall of its head, has not been beyond remedy or beyond hope. It has been allowed to fall under one head so that it may be recovered under another. It has been made subject to vanity in the hope of being delivered from the bondage of corruption into the liberty of the glory of the children of God.

James Boyd

Not the Liberty of Grace, But of Glory

Its freedom will not come the way ours does:

It was not by the will of the creature that it became subject to vanity, but through the folly of man. But the glory is coming, so if the creature is subject to vanity, it is so in hope of deliverance from the bondage of corruption. If it cannot share in the liberty of grace, which sets free from sin and judgment, it will share in the liberty of glory. That liberty lifts every pressure from these bodies.

Hamilton Smith

The Limits of Human Effort

What then of the work people do to relieve the world's suffering? One writer answers plainly:

People around us form themselves into associations for the benefit of the creature, seeking to improve its lot and lessen its woes. All this may be praiseworthy enough from a human standpoint. But I say the creature expects nothing from such means. It waits for the moment when the heavens will open and the sons of God will appear with Christ. Then its woes will end, but until that day its groans must continue.

James Boyd

Summary

- Not original. Decay, suffering and death are not how God designed the world; creation is fallen — and fallen to rise.

- Not guilty. Creation had no will in the matter. Man was the willing captive; the world under him simply went down with its head.

- Not settled. Was it Adam or God who subjected creation? Commentators differ. Both agree it followed the fall of creation's head.

- Not final. It fell under one head so it could be recovered under another — hope was written into the sentence itself.

- Not by us. Creation cannot share the liberty of grace; it waits for the liberty of glory, when the sons of God are revealed.

Romans 8:21

that the creature itself also shall be set free from the bondage of corruption into the liberty of the glory of the children of God.

Paul has just spoken of a coming glory, and now he widens the view: the world itself is waiting. Two questions sit under this verse: how did creation fall into a bondage it never chose, and what will set it free?

How Creation Came Into Bondage

The chain runs through man. God set man over the lower creation. When man fell, everything under him fell with him. That same link now works in reverse.

There is no reason to be surprised at such a link with men. Creation was made subject to vanity, not by its own will, of course, but because of him who made it subject. God set man as the head of the lower creation. When he fell, creation shared his ruin. The sons of God will be revealed when Christ appears. That will prove God made creation depend on them, and that its hope of freedom is not in vain. It was righteous that the fall of its head should bring creation under vanity. So how fitting and worthy of God that its glorious recovery should follow the redemption of His children and heirs!

William Kelly

Liberty of Grace, Liberty of Glory

Older translations read "the glorious liberty of the children of God." The ESV keeps the word order of the original: the freedom of the glory. That freedom belongs to a glory not yet displayed.

"The glorious liberty of the children of God!" People talk of glorious liberty now. And it is indeed wonderful, blessed liberty, into which grace has now brought us. But the passage before us is literally, "The liberty of the glory of the children of God." It is the liberty of grace in which we believers stand at present. The glory revealed in us will show that we are the sons of God. That happens when Christ appears, and we appear with Him in glory. It is into the liberty of this glory — the liberty which the glory of Christ and His saints will give to the world we will reign over — that the creation itself will be delivered.

W. Trotter

Creation did not sin. Man's sin dragged it into corruption, so its rescue takes a different form.

So it is not grace that the creation needs, but the redemption of power... Then creation, which was forced into corruption by man's sin, will be identified with the glory of the children of God.

L. M. Grant

The Heirs Come First

The order is fixed. Creation is the inheritance. Believers are the heirs. An inheritance is not handed over before the heirs arrive.

It is God's honour for Christ in this creation. As man's sin dragged it down with himself into ruin, so will the Second Man raise it out of its degradation and misery. But the inheritance cannot be delivered before the heirs.

The Bible Treasury

The Final Jubilee

Israel had a law for every fiftieth year. Liberty went out to everyone in the land, and forfeited property came back to its family. That law was a picture.

And when will its hopes be fulfilled? We answer: when the sons of God are revealed. When the children of God step into their glory, the whole creation will step with them into the liberty of that glory. Then a proclamation of liberty will go out through all the land to all its inhabitants. Then the forfeited land will be redeemed. Then men's toil and labour will cease and they will eat what the field produces (see Lev. 25:10-13). It will be the true and final year of Jubilee.

F. B. Hole

Two Groans, One Hope

Believers are not spectators of this waiting. We are inside it, because our bodies still belong to the creation that groans. Two waits run side by side, and one day ends both.

Creation will also be delivered. Now it groans, and travails in pain. Now we groan also — we who have received the firstfruits of the Spirit, we groan within ourselves... Creation waits, and we wait. Creation waits to enter into the liberty of the glory of the children of God. We wait for adoption, the redemption of our body... But God's purposes will not be fully accomplished until creation gets full deliverance. And that cannot happen until the new heavens and the new earth appear.

C E Stuart

Summary

- Through us, in. Creation did not choose its ruin. God set it under man, and when man fell, creation fell with him.

- Through us, out. The same link that dragged it down will lift it up — its release is tied to the day the children of God are seen in glory.

- Not grace, but power. Man's sin forced creation into corruption, so what it needs is not grace but power — the liberty of glory.

- Heirs before inheritance. The world is not freed first and the saints later. Christ appears, His own appear with Him, and then the land is redeemed — the true Jubilee.

- Two groans, one hope. Creation groans; we groan with it, still in bodies of this creation — and the same day answers both.

Romans 8:22

For we know that the whole creation groans together and travails in pain together until now.

Paul turns from the believer's hope to the world outside, and calls its pain childbirth, not chaos. Three questions follow: how do we know this, how far does the groan reach, and when does it stop?

"We Know"

Paul does not say creation feels this; he says believers know it. That knowledge comes by the Spirit. It sets the Christian apart from every other account of the world's misery.

So the Christian is not in ignorance of the misery of the groaning creation. Led by the Spirit, believers have the mind of Christ and can say, "We know that the whole creation has been groaning together in the pains of childbirth until now." Those who reject the fall blame all the misery of a groaning creation on natural causes. In their folly, they imagine they can remove the misery by their own efforts.

Hamilton Smith

The Whole Creation

The word "whole" leaves nothing out. Man stood at the head of a system, so his fall dragged everything below him down.

First of all, "the whole creation" groans together in the pains of childbirth. The first reference here is to the lower creation, which the fall of man dragged down. God gave Adam dominion over all, and by his sin he ruined all. He was, so to speak, the top link, joined to the Creator with understanding, and every other link in the chain hung on him. When he fell, all creation fell with him; animals became wild and destructive. We may not have ears to hear the groan of the lamb as the leopard pounces on it, or of the fly caught in the web as it feels the spider's bite. But the groaning is there.

F. B. Hole

That groan is not lost. It has a hearer:

There rises up to God a moan from His suffering creatures on this earth, a chorus of sorrow from its four quarters, as day by day passes by.

H. Forbes Witherby

"Until Now"

The phrase runs from the fall to Paul's day — and past it. Nothing since has silenced the groan, not even the coming of Christ or the spread of the gospel.

As Christians we are not fooled by appearances, nor by the mind and will of man. Man would like to hide the evidence of his own guilt and ruin in the wretchedness of a creation dragged down by his fault. For we know that it is all in groans and pains until now. Neither Christ's coming in grace and humiliation, nor the gospel preached in the power of the Spirit sent down from heaven, set this aside. Instead they called believers to glory above it, and to virtue despite it.

William Kelly

The groan runs to this hour. That rules out any claim that the world's golden age has already come:

The passage states plainly that this universal groan will only cease at the time spoken of here. Then, and not until then, creation itself will be set free from its bondage to corruption into the glorious freedom of the children of God. … How, my friends, can the world enjoy a time of universal rest, and peace, and freedom from evil, while the whole creation groans in the pains of childbirth? Impossible!

W. Trotter

Pains of Childbirth

The verse calls this pain childbirth. Birth pains point forward: something new is coming.

The Lord gives wars, famines and earthquakes a very significant character: they are the beginning of birth-pains. It is as if nature were pressing on toward the birth of a new and better time, and could not rest content with the present evil. … Everywhere there is an unrest that cries out for Him. He alone has said — He alone could dare to say — "Come to me, and I will give you rest." And the cry sounds in His ears, and will find its answer.

Numerical Bible Notes

The Believer Groans With It

The next verse joins us to the sound, and the link is physical: our bodies still belong to the old order. Yet the Christian's groan has a different quality.

But our groaning is not a complaint, the fruit of discontent, but the work of the Holy Spirit in the heart. The Spirit directs our eye to the glory, where we shall have no more reason to groan. He leads us to feel, according to the love of God, the suffering of a creation under bondage. At the same time we feel it ourselves, because by our bodies we still belong to it.

J. N. Darby

The Way Out

The same link that brought creation into ruin will bring it out.

What brought creation into the bondage of corruption? How did it get in? Through us. And how will it get out? Through us, when the glory comes! It is a beautiful thought! … We brought them into it, and shall bring them out of it.

J. N. Darby

Summary

- Cause. The fall explains the misery, not natural causes — which is why human effort can relieve symptoms but never remove the groan.

- Reach. "Whole" is exact: man was the top link of the chain, and every link below him fell when he did.

- Clock. "Until now" runs unbroken from the fall to this hour; neither Christ's first coming nor the gospel has yet ended it.

- Character. The pain is labour, not death — creation is straining toward the birth of a better world, and the cry reaches God's ear.

- Cure. Creation came into bondage through man. It will come out through man, when the children of God appear in glory.

Romans 8:23

And not only [that], but even *we* ourselves, who have the first-fruits of the Spirit, we also ourselves groan in ourselves, awaiting adoption, [that is] the redemption of our body.

Paul has just described a whole creation groaning under the weight of sin. Now he turns to those who have God's Spirit — and says that they groan too. So why do the people who have God's Spirit long the hardest? And what is still missing, if sins are already forgiven?

The Firstfruits of the Spirit

Writers point to Israel's harvest offerings to explain what the Spirit is to us now:

The firstfruits were offered up in Israel as the pledge and foretaste of the coming harvest (see Lev. 23:10, 17, 20), so in the Firstfruits of the Spirit we have the pledge and foretaste of the redeemed body and the glory that is ahead.

F. B. Hole

Why Having the Spirit Makes Us Groan

The groan does not come despite the Spirit. It comes because of Him. The very taste of what is coming sharpens our sense of what is not here yet:

The firstfruits of the Spirit suggest that what we have in this way is only a pledge of what is still to come. So we who have the firstfruits of the Spirit groan for that very reason. Our hope of a state so different from the present only makes us groan more over the present.

Numerical Bible Notes

One thing still ties the believer to the world around him:

You see, the Christian is still linked to the old creation, and the link with it is his body.

W. T. P. Wolston

Not the Groan of a Troubled Conscience

This is not the groan of a soul unsure of God. It belongs to a soul already settled with Him:

It is the groaning of those who are justified by faith and have peace with God. It is the groaning of those who have the Holy Spirit living in them, bearing witness with their spirit that they are children of God. It is the groaning of adopted children who long deeply for the full results of adoption.

William Kelly

There is also a limit set on what this groaning may become:

This groaning is not a complaint that comes from discontent. It is the work of the Holy Spirit in the heart. God permits a groan, but never a grumble.

Hamilton Smith

Some writers go further. They say the groan is not for ourselves at all, but for others:

Only the delivered soul groans, or can groan for others. We feel what is all around us, and we feel it as God feels it. That is why it says, "We groan inwardly" (not for ourselves — I do not groan for a dead thing I have been delivered from) "as we wait eagerly for adoption as sons."

The Christian's Friend

Waiting for the Adoption We Already Have

The verse says we are waiting for adoption as sons. Yet believers are already sons. Commentators solve this by separating what is ours by faith from what everyone will one day see:

In one sense we have received the adoption (Gal. 4:5-7), becoming sons of God by faith. In this case we wait for the adoption, the redemption of the body. Our bodies will be delivered from this world of sin and corruption and conformed to the image of Christ. Then everyone will see that we are sons of God. By faith we have the adoption now; in glory it will be seen.

L. M. Grant

Redemption Still Outstanding

The word "redemption" here points forward, not back:

As the order shows, this means not the forgiveness of sins, which we already have, but the complete deliverance from the effects of sin in our bodies. We wait for that at the coming of our Lord Jesus.

William Kelly

That double position makes the Christian hard for the world to read:

The Christian is always in that sense a riddle. He has Christ as his life, but not yet fully as Saviour (Phil. 3:20); he has, and he has not, salvation; he is waiting for redemption, not as regards the forgiveness of sins (Eph. 1:7), but as to the body (Rom. 8:23).

J. N. Darby

Summary

- Pledge — The Spirit is the firstfruits, a real first portion of the coming harvest. He is God's pledge of the glory ahead.

- Ache — Because that portion is real, it makes us long for the rest. The more we taste of the Spirit, the more the present grieves us.

- Link — Our body is the one remaining tie to the groaning creation, which is why our groan joins its groan.

- Not guilt — This is the groan of the forgiven and the free, not of an unsettled conscience. God allows a groan, never a grumble.

- Finish — Forgiveness is already ours. What remains is the redemption of the body at Christ's coming. Then our sonship will be seen by all.