Romans 6:1–4

Romans 6:1 · Darby

What then shall we say? Should we continue in sin that grace may abound?

Paul has just said that where sin increased, grace abounded all the more. Here he puts the objection that statement invites into words. Does a salvation given apart from any works of ours leave a person free to go on sinning?

Where the Question Comes From

The objection grows out of the closing words of chapter 5, and Paul refuses it outright.

The Apostle's statement at the end of Romans 5 — that "where sin increased, grace abounded all the more" — raises the subject of death to sin. That statement at once leads the mind ruled by the flesh to ask the foolish, if not wicked, question, "Are we to continue in sin that grace may abound?" The Apostle rejects this unholy suggestion completely. He will not allow that the believer — who is true to the position in which God has set the Christian — can continue living in sin.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

What the Objection Proposes

The suggestion is that a believer should sin on purpose, so that grace has more to cover. It is not a harmless idea:

Shall we take advantage of the abundance of grace, and by our self-indulgence make a fresh occasion for its display? The more we sin, the more grace will bestow. Those who talk or think in this way, whether intentionally or not, are liable to turn, as we read, "the grace of our God into sensuality" (Jude 4). And history shows that many gross evils have arisen in Christendom from such abuses of God's abounding grace.

Modernised from William J HockingOriginal wording

The objection also exposes those who make it:

They show that they have no idea how hateful sin is. They assume that punishment is the only thing to fear. So the moment the fear of punishment is gone, all restraint is gone.

Modernised from VariousOriginal wording

A New Subject

This verse opens a new section, with a different subject from the chapters before it.

As we enter this branch of the Gospel of God, we find that sin, not sins, is the subject before us. Fruitfulness for God, not peace of conscience, is an end in view. It is the sinful nature, and not the acts — what we are, our condition, not what we have done — that has now to be considered. So attention goes to the death of Christ, not to His blood. His blood is not named once throughout this section of the letter.

Modernised from C E StuartOriginal wording

Impossibility, Not Disapproval

Paul does not reply by scolding. He replies with a fact:

In chapter 6 he goes on to notice that some will say, "Oh, if Christ has done all, it does not matter what I do. If it is righteousness without works, then we may walk as we like." The answer is not "That ought not to be," but "That cannot be." For we are speaking of death: I have part in righteousness by death. If the thing is real, I cannot live in what I am dead to, and that makes it impossible. If I live, being dead in this way, it is by being alive to God, in Jesus Christ our Lord.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

And the answer he gives is not the law:

The question in Romans 6 is the usual objection of the flesh, that sovereign grace seems to allow living in sin. The apostle answers this, not by asserting the law as the Christian's rule as if we were Jews. He answers by declaring that in our very baptism we died with Christ to sin. Buried with Him, we now have to walk in newness of life. He argues, not from a motive, but from the blessed fact of Christ's death and resurrection, in which the baptised profess to have a part.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Only One Way of Deliverance

That answer also rules out every other route to freedom from sin.

Here, then, is that principle of deliverance from sin so greatly ridiculed — deliverance from sin by death. Nor shall we find any other deliverance from sin in the word of God. For centuries, many sincere people sought deliverance by fasting and by shutting themselves away in monasteries. Many sincere people now seek it by trying to reach a false perfection of the flesh. But here is the full truth of God — deliverance from sin by death.

Modernised from C StanleyOriginal wording

And the question is practical: we stand between grace at the start and glory at the end.

Grace took us up at the start — grace is going to glorify us at the end; but we are not yet glorified. What are we going to do in between, since we are the recipients of such grace? Continue in sin? "By no means!"

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Summary

- Grace provokes — grace abounded all the more where sin increased, and that truth draws out this objection.

- Grace exposes — those who propose sinning so grace may abound show they fear punishment, not sin itself.

- Grace redefines — the subject is now sin the nature, not sins the acts. The goal is fruitfulness for God, not peace of conscience.

- Grace kills — the reply is not "that ought not to be" but "that cannot be"; you cannot live in what you have died to.

- Grace holds — grace took us up at the start and will glorify us at the end. In between, the answer is death with Christ, not law and not self-effort.

Romans 6:2 · Darby

Far be the thought. We who have died to sin, how shall we still live in it?

The objection behind the question

Paul has just said that where sin increased, grace increased all the more. Someone will always twist that into a licence to sin, and this verse is his reply. The reply is striking for what it does not say: it does not appeal to our feelings or to the Saviour's love.

May we continue in sin, so that His grace may be displayed more richly? Away with such a thought. Here the apostle deals with the wicked charge. He answers it not because the thought is appalling in itself, nor because it slanders the character of God, as in Romans 3:8, but because it contradicts the first principles of Christianity. He does not use a motive drawn from our sense of our Saviour's love. He is not asking here how we could so wound His heart or grieve the Holy Spirit of God.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Not a prohibition but an impossibility

Notice the form of the sentence. Paul does not give a command. He asks a question.

Later in the chapter the apostle will show how the believer is dead to sin. But at the start he assumes that the only possible attitude for the believer to take towards sin is that he is "dead to sin." So he asks, "How can we who died to sin still live in it?" His question does not suggest that we ought not to live in it. It says that, having died to sin, we cannot live in it. The principle behind his words is plain: we cannot die to something and live in it at the same time.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

What "died to sin" means

One small word changes everything.

The matter stands like this. He died FOR our sins, making atonement for them. He died TO sin. Taught by the Spirit, we recognise that we are identified with our great Representative, and faith takes His death as ours. We too, then, are "dead to sin," and cannot go on living in it without contradicting ourselves.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Some have wanted to read the dative here as "dead by sin" — that is, killed by our sins, and therefore frightened to go on in them. Commentators differ, but one writer argues the whole chapter rules this out:

The desired translation is the result of misunderstanding the whole passage. It makes it a motive drawn from a previous evil result and nothing more; whereas it is perfectly certain that the passage is about our dying when we become Christians, not our dying by our sins... the doctrine of the chapter is dying out of our old man and living in newness of life — not our dying by our sin so as to be afraid of living in it now.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

We died — sin did not

Many read the verse as a claim that the sinful nature is gone. But the verse says that we died.

Scripture points to death itself as the barrier to sin's activity... Note carefully what the verse says, for people often misunderstand it. They misquote it or misread it. Paul does not say that sin itself is dead. He does not imply that the evil nature has disappeared altogether. It is we ourselves who have died to sin. How then can we go on living in sin? It is a dangerous deceit to think that believers no longer have sin within them.

Modernised from William J HockingOriginal wording

True of every Christian, held by faith

Some believers hesitate here, because their own experience does not match the words. Paul is not describing experience at all.

This settles the matter at once against the so-called perfectionists. Paul is not saying that any believer has the experience of being dead to sin. He is certainly speaking of all Christians, and this is not the universal experience... His words later on are, "consider yourselves dead to sin" (older translations read "reckon"), and that reckoning rests on this: Christ "died to sin, once for all." So it is a reckoning of faith, not an experience.

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

The only route out of sin's power

If freedom comes by death, then every other method is a detour.

Here, then, is that principle of deliverance from sin which is so much ridiculed — deliverance from sin by death. We shall not find any other deliverance from sin in the word of God. For centuries many sincere souls sought deliverance by fasting. Many shut themselves away in monasteries. Many sincere souls now seek it by striving after a false perfection of the flesh. But here is the full truth of God — deliverance from sin by death.

Modernised from C StanleyOriginal wording

Where practice begins

This truth is not the finish line of the Christian life. It is where obedience starts.

A dead man is free, or justified, from sin. I cannot charge a dead man with the evil of his past life. Death has taken him right out of it altogether... Death is the starting point for practice. We are set free as dead to sin, and so the apostle says, "Let not sin therefore reign in your mortal body, to make you obey its passions."... I can say to sin now: I am no longer your slave. I belong to someone else. God has set me free from sin and given me a life to yield to Him.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Summary

- Question — The verse answers the charge that grace encourages sin. It does not scold. It shows that living in sin contradicts what a Christian is.

- Death — Christ died for our sins to atone; He died to sin, and faith takes that death as ours.

- Distinction — We died to sin; sin did not die in us. Anyone who claims the sinful nature is gone is deceived.

- Faith — This reckoning is true of all Christians. It rests on Christ's death, not on a level of experience a few have reached.

- Freedom — Death is the only deliverance from sin's power that Scripture offers. It is also where practice begins: a dead man owes his old master nothing.

Romans 6:3 · Darby

Are you ignorant that we, as many as have been baptised unto Christ Jesus, have been baptised unto his death?

Paul has just said that grace overflows where sin abounded. Someone is bound to twist that into a licence to keep sinning. His reply is not a warning but a reminder. He points the Roman Christians back to their own baptism, and to what that act said about them.

The Argument Behind the Question

The question in verse 3 is not new information. It points to something every believer has had since the day they confessed Christ.

The apostle answers from the starting point of every person who confesses Christ. Not only did He die for our sins, laying us under an infinite obligation, but we died to sin: how then shall we go on living in it? This is the meaning of our baptism. Are you ignorant of so plain a truth? It is not a special blessing that only a few Christians enjoy; it is the common property of all the baptized.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The Force of the Word "Into"

Here the commentators part company with many modern versions. Several argue the Greek preposition should read "to" or "unto" rather than "into." The difference matters, because it guards against the idea that the act itself does the work.

The Greek preposition means "to" or "unto" as often as "into." Which one it is depends on the context, or on the nature of the case. It is impossible to think that the Israelites in 1 Corinthians 10:2 were baptized into Moses; there the word must be "unto."… Baptism is the symbol of profession. Reality depends on faith, and faith might or might not be true of the person baptized… To say "into" therefore goes beyond God's word. It claims for the act a life-giving power that Scripture does not grant and does not allow… Not everyone has faith, and baptism will no more save an unbeliever than a dead faith will.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

What the Water Pictures

Baptism pictures a funeral, and a funeral has two obvious effects on the person concerned.

In the figure of baptism we were identified with the death of Christ. This was so that we might share, here and now, in the position His death gives us in relation to sin and the world. Baptism is a figure of death and burial. It is clear that a dead man has finished with the life of self-will he once lived. And a buried man has passed out of the sight of the world he once lived in.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The Christ We Were Baptized To

Baptism points to a particular Christ, and that is why it carries this meaning at all.

They were baptized to a Christ who had died to sin, and we are buried with Him by baptism to death. John baptized to a living Messiah on earth; Christian baptism is to a Christ who has died and risen again. This is why the disciples of John in Acts 19 had to be baptized again in the name of the Lord Jesus. He had died and risen, and God had made Him Lord and Christ.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Separation from the World

If the meaning is burial, then the effect is a clean break with everything on this side of the grave.

Now baptism is, in one word, dissociation. It is only an outward ordinance, yet it has a meaning, and that is its meaning. It is based on the death and resurrection of Christ, for we are baptized to His death, and so we are "buried with Him." Nothing cuts our links with the world, and separates us from the present order of things, more effectively than death and burial.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

That break is easy to admire and hard to accept, which is why the argument turns into a searching question for anyone who has been baptized.

Every passage of Scripture that speaks of baptism sets out death, not life. Baptism marks a definite separation from the whole world-system. From now on we count its aims, its pleasures, its politics, its honours and rewards among the "things that lie behind." But are we really prepared for such a clean sweep as this? This is what our baptism means — but do we mean it? It is easy to boast about a correct mode, while in the heart refusing all that baptism stands for.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Where It Leads

Death is not the end of the argument. Baptism commits a Christian to a Christ who is alive, and that life has one direction.

The one baptism is Christian baptism. It commits us to all that is bound up in the truth of Christ Jesus. It announces our identification with the death of our Lord Jesus Christ in all its bearings, and implies our obligation to walk in newness of life. The water we pass under is a picture of death. Understanding our identification with Christ dead and risen again teaches us that we are no longer free to be under sin's dominion, no longer available for sin's control. He — Christ — lives to God. Every pulse, every movement of His risen manhood is Godward, to accomplish God's will and pleasure.

Modernised from W. H. WestcottOriginal wording

Summary

- Death answers the question. Grace does more than give a Christian better motives against sin. It ends the old life, and no one lives in what he has died to.

- Death is what baptism pictures. Not new life, but burial — burial with Christ, the One who died and rose.

- Death separates. A buried man is out of the world's sight, so baptism cuts the links with its aims, pleasures and rewards.

- Death professed must be death meant. Baptism goes no further than profession. Reality rests on faith, and the right form without the heart is empty.

- Death opens onto life. Christ raised lives wholly to God, and baptism commits us to walk in newness of life.

Romans 6:4 · Darby

We have been buried therefore with him by baptism unto death, in order that, even as Christ has been raised up from among [the] dead by the glory of the Father, so *we* also should walk in newness of life.

Romans 6 opens with a question: does grace leave us free to keep sinning? Paul answers with a fact, not a rule. The believer has died with Christ, and baptism pictures that burial. This verse then looks past the grave, to a resurrection by the Father's glory and a new way of living that matches it.

Grace and Continuing in Sin

The verse answers an objection raised at the start of the chapter.

Is this the conclusion to draw from the gospel of God? May we continue in sin, so that His grace may be displayed more richly? Away with such a thought. The apostle answers this wicked inference, not by showing how evil it is in itself, but by showing that it flatly contradicts Christianity in its first principles. He replies from the starting point of every believer in Christ. Christ did not merely die for our sins, laying us under an infinite obligation; we died to sin. How then shall we go on living in it? This is the meaning of our baptism. It is not some special blessing that only a few Christians have. It is the common property of all the baptized.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Notice how the apostle frames his answer.

He rejects the thought outright and puts it away with another question: "How can we who died to sin still live in it?" Asking it as a question shows how unanswerable he thinks it is. And unanswerable it is, if the premise is taken rightly. If we are dead to sin, then we cannot live in it. That consequence cannot be denied.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Buried With Him — What Baptism Pictures

One writer stresses what baptism points to, and what it does not do.

Notice, then, that deliverance from sin is not the improvement of self, or of an evil nature — the flesh. Instead, "We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death." We are not baptised to the work of the Spirit in us. We are baptised to His death, who died for us and rose again. So the death that delivers from sin is not a death to sin that we reach by ourselves. It is the death of Christ on the cross, and our identification with it — "buried with him." And notice, there is no thought that baptism gives life. Baptism is to death, and life in the risen Christ is beyond it.

Modernised from C. StanleyOriginal wording

The meaning of this burial is for daily life.

A buried man has died to the scene where he once lived. Now suppose a man goes to his own funeral by his own choice. This is exactly what happens to the believer, and he surely believes he will gain by it. What a loss the believer suffers when he leaves the inner meaning of his baptism out of his daily life!

Modernised from A. J. PollockOriginal wording

Raised by the Glory of the Father

The verse traces the resurrection to the Father's glory. One writer explains why glory is named.

In relation to God, every attribute of His has been perfectly glorified by the atoning death of our blessed Lord. So the resurrection is said to be "by the glory of the Father." It is as though that glory, which the Son had vindicated and displayed so perfectly, waited for the very first moment at the tomb on the first day of the week. It waited to call the perfect obedient One out from death.

Modernised from Samuel RidoutOriginal wording

Newness of Life

The verse ends by describing how the Christian now lives.

Let us notice the closing words of verse 4, "newness of life," for they give a brief answer to the question the chapter opened with. Instead of continuing in sin, which is in effect continuing to live the old life, we are to walk in a life which is new.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

One writer draws out what this new walk aims at.

This suggests to me that there is a realm where everything matches the glory of the Father. That is the realm Christ is in. He has been raised from among the dead by the glory of the Father... It suggests to me that if I am walking in newness of life, the goal before me is the glory of the Father.

Modernised from George DavisonOriginal wording

Buried, but Not Yet Risen

Romans speaks of burial with Christ, but not of rising with Him. One writer marks the difference.

He does not say we are risen with Him. That would in itself assume full redemption, with life, and a place and condition before God. Here it is practical — a new character of life. We are to walk in newness of life.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Summary

- Died — A fact answers the objection, not a warning: those who died to sin cannot go on living in it.

- Buried — Baptism points to Christ's death. It does not point to self-improvement, and it does not give life. Life lies beyond it, in the risen Christ.

- Raised — Christ came out of the tomb by the Father's glory, because His atoning death had glorified every attribute of God.

- Walking — The new life is practical and present. The glory that raised Christ is now the goal the believer walks towards.

- Not yet risen — Romans stays with burial and a new walk. To say we are risen with Christ would assume more: full redemption and a settled place before God.