For this [cause], even as by one man sin entered into the world, and by sin death; and thus death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned
Read Full Chapter →Commentary for this Verse
Here Paul's letter turns from the wrong things people do to the ruined condition they are born in. It traces that ruin back to one man. Two questions follow: why does everyone die, and what does "because all sinned" mean?
From sins to sin
One writer draws the line between what is personal and what everyone shares:
J. N. DarbyAt Romans 5:12 the apostle begins his teaching about sin. The difference is clear. If it is a question of sins, you, my reader, have yours, and I have mine. If it is a question of our nature, of our flesh, we are only one, one single nature, one single mass. So the apostle turns to the heads or sources of our nature, whether for good or for evil: Adam and Christ.
This shift meets a real problem. Believers who are sure their sins are forgiven often still find something wrong at the root:
C. StanleyMany souls are greatly perplexed. Though they believe their sins are forgiven, they still find the root, sin, in the flesh. Much of this confusion comes from failing to notice carefully the distinction between sins and sin, as in this letter. As we have seen, verse 11 closes the question of sins. Verse 12 takes up sin.
What "sin" means here
The word has a specific weight in this part of the letter. A word count shows the change of subject:
Hamilton SmithThe outcome of "sin" must be sins, but it is "sin" that the Apostle especially speaks of in this portion of the Letter. In chapters 1 to 5:11 the word sin occurs only twice; in this division, 5:12 to 8, it occurs thirty-four times. "Sin" is the evil principle of "lawlessness", or the creature doing his own will... Sins can be forgiven. But "sin", the evil principle that leads to sins, can only be met by death — a death that ends the life governed by sin.
One man, and a changed source
"Through one man" points back to the moment when human nature changed at its source:
H. Forbes WitherbyGod made Adam free from evil, without the knowledge of sin. This was the starting point of man's existence on earth — a life whose moral character was nothing like our life now. But Adam preferred disobedience to obedience. By exercising his will, his nature became evil. With that, the character of the source of human life changed. Innocence disappeared from the earth, and sin entered the world. This is where our sinful nature comes from. We received it through our parents, and we were born with it.
This happened at the start of human history. So no nation stands outside it, not even Israel with its law:
William KellySo the most solemn change ever to affect the world came in long before the Jewish people existed, and therefore before God gave their boasted law... Adam was before them both and affects all mankind, the Jews not excepted... It was not outside man, but on the contrary "by one man"; yet its effect, death, spread through the world.
Death as the evidence
The verse does not argue from how people behave. It argues from death:
PridhamHere (verse 12) the sinner's case rests not on the moral evidence of personal evil, but on the decisive testimony of death. Death is God's widespread and undeniable witness that sin, which produced it, is present throughout the world... Death is never separable from sin. So sharing in a sinful nature produces death as its necessary effect.
"Because all sinned"
Commentators differ over this final clause. Some reject the old marginal reading, "in whom all have sinned." They deny that God charges Adam's guilt to each person:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinWe are not responsible for the sin of Adam. God does not hold us responsible for a sinful nature either. We are responsible for how that nature works out, that is, for our own sins... Death comes upon us because of our sins, as this verse states.
Others keep both sides together, refusing to let either one crowd out the other:
William KellyNo one doubts that infants and those without understanding die, and this through Adam's sin. But the Spirit does not exclude the consequence where personal guilt can apply. The fall left the race in ruin, and that ruin goes together with the evil workings of the fallen nature now in all men. Adam's sin is the cause, but it is not the sole account and whole case of man's bitter lot.
The answer God brings
Sin's reign is not the last word:
H. Forbes WitherbyDeath took its throne, and sin its rule over the world, by Adam's one act. His disobedience was the key that opened the door for them to enter the world. Sin still reigns, its kingdom is as wide as the world, and its end is death. But God has an answer even to this. He does not reform the old ruler or alter the kingdom. God brings in something altogether new — something so noble that the believer's heart rejoices.
Summary
- One man. One act of disobedience let sin in. It changed the character of the source of human life, and everyone since inherits that nature.
- One principle. "Sin" here is the evil principle of doing one's own will — the root — as distinct from "sins," the acts that grow out of it.
- One proof. Death is God's public, undeniable witness that sin is everywhere, and it was at work long before the law.
- One debated clause. Commentators differ on "because all sinned". Some read it only of each person's own sins, and deny that God charges Adam's guilt to us. Others hold cause and personal guilt together.
- One answer. God does not reform the old ruler or alter the kingdom. He brings in something altogether new: a second Head, Christ, set over against Adam.