And the seven angels who had the seven trumpets prepared themselves that they might sound with [their] trumpets.
The seventh seal has opened, heaven has fallen silent, and the prayers of God's people have gone up with incense. Verse 6 is the turning point: the seven angels get ready, and the judgments that follow flow from this moment.
The order matters. The angels get ready to sound right after the prayers of the saints go up.
Specific judgments were ready to follow, and the seven angels prepare to sound. This is how God's ways and dealings with His saints connect. Everything is ready for judgment. But they, however weak, represent God on the earth. So the wicked aim their wickedness at them, and that wickedness must be judged. Their cry brings the judgment. Christ offers up that cry with all the value of the incense He can add to it.
The instrument itself carries meaning drawn from Israel's national life.
But why trumpets? No wind instrument was more widely used in the national life of Israel than the trumpet. It called them together in public assembly. Its loud blast called them to war. It told them when to advance and when to retreat… Its loud warning notes announced that danger or an enemy was near… Both Joel and John speak of the blast of the trumpet. It shows that God is about to punish the sin before Him, openly and in front of everyone — a public and loud announcement that He is about to do so. "The seven trumpets" mean a complete and full announcement.
Commentators draw a sharp line between the seals and what now begins.
In general the seals seem to reach further, but the blows were not so severe. With most of the trumpets it is a third part that is struck. So the trumpets may reach less far, but they prove more intensely judicial than the seals… The very name shows a difference. The trumpet represents a loud and solemn call of God. It is God summoning men; for if they have rejected His grace, they must hear — even if they forget — these sharp warnings of His judgment. Unless God had told us beforehand, we might not so readily have seen the seals as acts of God… But with the trumpets there is less need to say that they are judgments sent from heaven. Their sound or summons is quite plain and urgent. They appeal to men far more unmistakably.
The angels who sound are not the same as the angels who carry out what the sounding announces.
"Now the seven angels who had the seven trumpets prepared to blow them." These seven angels do not themselves carry out the judgments they announce. The four judgment angels (Rev. 9:14) are not the same as the seven trumpet angels.
The silence and the preparing both say something about the character of God's action.
God's judgment, when it falls, is not only certain but swift. Yet it is never hurried. During this silence the seven angels "prepared to blow" their trumpets. There is a calm serenity about God's action in judgment. He puts it off to the last possible moment.
The scenes these trumpets bring need careful reading.
We are not to take these things only in their obvious or physical sense. Suppose you take something like a mountain falling into the sea (verse 8) literally. Would that ever turn the water into blood? Nothing of the sort. The fact is that these were pictures that passed before the eyes of the prophet. What the figures meant we have to gather from the general tenor of the word, by the teaching of the Spirit.
This verse opens a section that ends in triumph, not ruin.
We can also look at the sounding of the seven trumpets as a section of its own. It runs from the sixth verse of chapter 8 to the end of chapter 11… Notice too what happens at the seventh trumpet. There are lightnings, voices, thunderings and an earthquake. The Lord Jesus comes out in glory with His saints, to take the kingdom and judge the world in righteousness. The voices in heaven say, "The kingdom of the world has become the kingdom of our Lord and of His Christ, and He shall reign forever and ever."
- Prayer — the trumpets begin where the incense ends. Christ makes the cry of His suffering people acceptable, and that cry sets the judgments moving.
- Summons — in Israel a trumpet gathered the people, warned them and called them to war. Here God announces out loud that He is about to deal with sin.
- Plainness — the seals could look like ordinary trouble. The trumpets are plain warnings to people who have refused His grace.
- Deliberation — the angels prepare, and God puts judgment off to the last possible moment. He is never in a hurry.
- Kingdom — the series runs to the seventh trumpet. There Christ takes the kingdom and reigns forever, so the warning ends in His glory.
And the first sounded [his] trumpet and there was hail and fire, mingled with blood, and they were cast upon the earth; and the third part of the earth was burnt up, and the third part of the trees was burnt up, and all green grass was burnt up.
The seventh seal opens into silence, and then seven angels take up seven trumpets. At the first blast, judgment falls on land, trees and grass. No weather system could produce this storm, because blood is mixed into it.
Commentators see the change of instrument as a change in how God addresses the world. The seals could be mistaken for ordinary history. No one can miss a trumpet blast.
The trumpet sets forth a loud and solemn call of God. It is God summoning men. If they have rejected His grace, they must hear these sharp warnings of His judgment, even if they forget them. We might not so easily have seen the seals as God stepping in, unless He had told us beforehand that this is what they were... With the trumpets there is less need to say that they are heaven-sent judgments. Their sound or summons is quite plain and urgent.
The two series also differ in reach and force.
The seals in general appear to have a larger extent, but the blows were not so severe... The trumpets, then, may be less extensive in their range, but it will later be clear that they are more intensely judicial than the seals.
Each element has a settled meaning elsewhere in Scripture. The writers read them there, not as weather.
Hail signifies a sudden, sharp, and overwhelming judgment from above, with God carrying it out (see Isa. 28:2, 17; Rev. 11:19; Rev. 16:21). Fire is the expression of God's wrath... Fire stands for thorough, unsparing, agonising judgment... Blood signifies death, both physical and moral. Moral death would take the form of apostasy — a complete abandonment of revealed truth, all religious profession given up.
Hail and fire are strange partners: cold and heat do not usually arrive together. One writer draws out what the pair pictures about God.
Hail with fire is one of the most solemn pictures of God's judgment that nature gives us. It was one of the plagues of Egypt... Cold, like darkness, stands for God withdrawing. Fire, which is both heat and light, stands for the glow of His presence — and against sin that presence is wrath. The two can come together, however contradictory they seem: "hailstones and coals of fire" poured out at once. When God forsakes, it is always in anger. So what would have refreshed becomes a storm of judgment. There is a concord of contraries against those that cast off God; as for those who love Him, all things work together for good.
The verse does not say the storm fell. Something threw it down, and writers take that word as deliberate. "The earth" it lands on is a symbol too.
In both cases (vv. 5 and 7) the term "cast" implies irresistible power behind. The judgment of the hail and fire with blood cannot be traced to natural causes. They were cast down. They did not fall from the heavens in an ordinary way — an unseen but powerful arm drove them... The earth here means the part of the world that is civilised and under settled, established government.
The fraction marks out which part of the world is struck. Writers have not all agreed on which part.
You will notice that the third part keeps coming up in these divine visitations. What is the prophetic meaning of "the third"? The answer seems to be given us in Rev. 12 (that is, the distinctively Roman or western empire)... If this is so, "the third" would mean the varied wasting away of the Roman empire in the west... One able writer contends for the Greek or Eastern Empire, because the Macedonian was the third of the four great empires of Dan. 2 and Dan. 7. But "the third part" is quite another thought and phrase.
None of this is literal farmland. Notice the difference in the verse: the trees lose a third, the grass loses everything.
This clearly does not refer to the literal earth, trees, or grass. In Scripture grass is the symbol commonly used for man in his weakness, his very glory being like the flower of grass. Human prosperity, then, would be set forth by green grass. Here we have a judgment of God upon it. Not a certain part only, however large, but the whole of it is destroyed. The trees represent those who are high and exalted among men... So the blow falls on one marked-off part of the scene of God's moral dealings. All the lowly feel the ruin, and the higher classes feel it to a large extent.
Commentators differ on the grass. Another reading keeps two possibilities open.
The burning up of "all green grass" may refer to the withering of the means of support; or, if grass is here used as a figure of man in his frailty, it indicates a destruction of the choicest and most vigorous portion of the human race, such as the wholesale slaughter of young men called out to serve in war.
- Summons. The trumpet is God calling men who have refused His grace. It is too loud to mistake for ordinary history.
- Sharper. Compared with the seals, the trumpets cover less ground but strike harder.
- Supernatural. Hail is judgment from above, fire is wrath, blood is death. The blood puts this storm outside nature. "Cast" shows an unseen arm behind it.
- Limited. "A third" fences the judgment into one region, not the whole globe. Most writers point to the Roman west, though not all agree.
- Levelling. Trees are the great, grass the ordinary and prosperous — and all the grass goes, so no rank escapes.
And the second angel sounded [his] trumpet and as a great mountain burning with fire was cast into the sea, and the third part of the sea became blood;
The second trumpet does not strike solid ground. It falls on open water, and what lands there is something like a burning mountain. The picture raises two questions at once: which power is falling, and why the damage stops at a third.
The verse does not say a mountain, but something like one. One writer sets the first two trumpets side by side:
In the first trumpet, we see hail, fire, and blood cast on the earth, and some trees and all green grass burnt up. In the second trumpet, a great mountain, as it were — that is, something similar to a great burning mountain — is cast into the sea. In the first trumpet, the earth, trees and grass are affected; in the second, the sea, its creatures and its ships. Both are fiery, burning judgments.
So why hit objects, when it is people God is dealing with?
The judgments fall on things rather than men. Yet the things listed — earth, trees, grass, sea and creatures in it, ships, rivers, fountains, sun, moon, stars — are not moral beings, and so are not accountable to God. Man is the rebel sinner who has to be dealt with. The things are symbols of man and of what is connected with him.
Jeremiah calls Babylon a mountain marked for burning, and that gives the key:
"Behold, I am against you, O destroying mountain, declares the LORD, which destroys the whole earth; I will stretch out my hand against you, and roll you down from the crags, and make you a burnt mountain." The LORD speaks against the Chaldean kingdom. It looked so firmly established in its might and greatness that no one could overthrow it. Yet He threatens it with consuming judgment, a "burnt mountain." … A mountain as a symbol represents a kingdom or a firmly established power. The key idea in these prophetic symbols is a strong, solid, established power. And this power is itself the target of God's governmental vengeance.
The mountain does not just collapse where it stands. It is thrown, and where it lands others suffer:
A mountain is the usual symbol of high, settled power. But here it is thrown into the sea, because it becomes the means of judgment to others, and not just the object of judgment itself.
The verse names three things: a mountain, fire, and the sea it lands in. One writer takes each in turn:
A great mountain speaks of a great governing power, while burning with fire points to a fearsome character of oppression. Thrown into the sea speaks of God's own sovereign power inflicting this scourge upon the nations (the sea of the Gentiles). The waters of the sea speak of "peoples and multitudes and nations and languages" (Revelation 17:15).
Commentators differ on what the blood and the dying creatures mean. One takes the dying to be a spiritual death:
First, all through the peoples (the sea) of the Roman earth, the "blood," the "deathful power of evil," prevails. A third part of the creatures in the sea that had life died. As another writer has put it, "I take dying here to be departure from the profession of association with God, public separation from Him, or apostasy." Unbelief and atheism always flourish in times of great disturbance, social earthquakes and revolutions.
Another holds that both senses are present at once:
Does blood here symbolise a violent natural death, or does it refer to the spiritual death of apostasy? In our judgment these two forms of death are here combined.
The third loss touches how people make a living:
This trumpet seems to foretell the overwhelming destruction of a great world power. In its fall it will bring ruin and death on a third part of the nations. The destruction of the ships brings trade to a standstill, and so they lose their means of living.
Each of these trumpets stops at the same fraction:
The language is still highly symbolic. A feature common to each is that the judgments only fall on a third part of the things affected. This shows that for the moment the effects are not universal but limited. The phrase "the third part" occurs again in Revelation 12:4, where the Roman Empire is in question. So here it points to the Roman earth: practically the western European powers, or, we may say, Christendom.
- Symbol — The verse says something like a mountain. Earth, sea, creatures and ships stand for people and what belongs to them, because objects cannot answer to God.
- Mountain — In prophecy a mountain is a kingdom or a firmly established power. Jeremiah's "burnt mountain" is Babylon: it looked unshakeable, yet God condemned it.
- Cast — The throw makes this power both the object of judgment and the tool of it. It falls, and its fall wrecks others.
- Sea — The mountain lands in the sea of the nations: "peoples and multitudes and nations and languages." The sovereign power of God sends it there.
- Third — Blood, death and lost shipping follow, yet each stops at a third. The judgment is severe, but not yet universal.
and the third part of the creatures which were in the sea which had life died; and the third part of the ships were destroyed.
The second trumpet has sounded, and a burning mountain falls into the sea. Verse 9 counts the cost — so what is that mountain, who are the creatures, and why does the damage stop at a third?
Scripture sets the pattern. A mountain stands for a settled power, and God once used that picture of Babylon.
In the judgment of the second trumpet John saw "something like a great mountain, burning with fire," thrown into the sea. In Scripture a mountain pictures a great and long-established power. So Scripture calls Babylon a "destroying mountain," and the LORD says to her, "I will roll you down from the crags, and make you a burnt mountain" (Jer. 51:25). The sea never stops moving, so it often pictures the nations in a state of unrest (see Rev. 17:15).
History has already staged smaller versions of this scene.
It is a power that is mighty, seated firmly and lifted high, yet full of volcanic forces in conflict. These will tear out her own insides and spread ruin all around. Thrown into the sea of the nations — already in commotion, as the word "sea" implies — this power produces death and disaster beyond that of the previous trumpet. It attacks human life more directly. Such a state of eruption was in France at the end of the eighteenth century, and it may well illustrate what seems intended. History is full of such warnings of what is coming, and we do well to take note of them. We may expect this all the more as the end approaches. Things grow towards it, and at last it takes by surprise those who have not heeded the warning.
In this vision the sea is not water.
The ever-restless sea is here the chosen figure for the peoples of the earth in terrible anarchy. They have no strong controlling power or firm hand over them. God ordains civil and governmental authority (Rom. 13:1). So the prophetic sea stands for the general state of the nations with no civil or spiritual government. Into these seething masses of mankind this burning power is cast.
Commentators differ over the death meant here. Some argue from the word "creatures" that individual people are in view, and that the death is moral, not physical.
Persons, and not peoples or nations in general as in the first judgment, are in question. The term "creatures" would imply as much... Moral, spiritual death is the undoubted force of the judgment carried out here. It is death towards God, and death towards the principles of truth and righteousness. In fact, it is moral death in its widest sense.
Others read the death as physical, and see the falling power itself as the instrument of it.
A great power that seemed settled is removed from its place. That power is not so much shattered itself as made the means of suffering to others. It is burning with fire, and the result is destruction to a third of the living creatures and ships in the sea. The whole thing is a figure taken from what a volcano would do if it were cast into the sea. In this way the Lord fills out the picture of destruction. A great consuming power falls on confused masses of people, and the result is human slaughter and political anarchy.
The wrecked ships carry trade, and trade feeds nations far from the disaster.
This trumpet appears to foretell the overwhelming destruction of a great world power. Its fall will bring ruin and death on a third of the nations. The destruction of the ships brings commerce to a standstill, and so destroys the way they make their living.
The same fraction runs through these judgments. It sets both a limit and a place.
A feature common to each is that the judgments fall only on a third part of the things affected. This shows that for the moment the effects are not universal but limited. The phrase "the third part" occurs again in Revelation 12:4, where the Roman Empire, energised by Satan, is in question. This leads to the conclusion that here it shows the Roman earth — in practice the western European powers, or perhaps we may say, Christendom.
A narrower blow is not a lighter one.
The trumpets may reach less far than the seals. But it will appear later that they strike with heavier judgment.
- Mountain — a great, long-standing power. God once pictured Babylon this way: rolled down and left burning.
- Sea — masses of people with no firm government. The mountain falls into a crowd already in turmoil.
- Death — a third of the creatures die. Some read this as death towards God and truth; others as real slaughter and anarchy.
- Ships — trade stops, and the loss of livelihood spreads ruin far beyond the point of impact.
- A third — the damage is limited, not universal. The trumpets hit a smaller area than the seals, but hit it harder.
And the third angel sounded [his] trumpet and there fell out of the heaven a great star, burning as a torch, and it fell upon the third part of the rivers, and upon the fountains of waters.
The third trumpet does not strike the land or the sea but the fresh water — the rivers and springs people drink from. What falls is a "great star" — a picture of authority — and its name tells you what it does.
The picture comes from government. A star ranks below the sun, so it stands for a power that answers to someone higher, yet still rules and still shines. One writer traces the height it held and the strange fact that it keeps glowing after the fall:
A star is the symbol of authority in government. It is not supreme authority — the sun stands for that — but authority held under another. So the very picture used shows a man who should have been a source of light and order to people. But he falls "from heaven," from the place where God had set him, for God appoints the powers that rule. By that fall he is now cut off from all connection with God. Yet he still burns — not as a star now, but as a lamp — and so he still attracts people by his light and brightness.
Where he falls from matters, and so does the word for the fall:
The Heaven is the source of authority, a fixed position; all spiritual, civil, and political authority has its source above… Under the two trumpets before this, the instruments of judgment were "cast" upon the earth and the sea. Here this apostate ruler "fell" out of the Heaven. "Cast" would imply that an unseen actor used irresistible power, and that the judgment was violent. "Fell" points rather to a sudden, unexpected downfall.
Where the star lands is as symbolic as the star itself. Water in these visions stands for peoples. Springs and rivers stand for what refreshes them and shapes their course:
Waters are the symbol of peoples with no settled shape. Fountains are the sources of their refreshment, and a river stands for what marks the course they take… This blow seems less political than the judgment before it. It is rather the poisoning of everything that ought to bring blessing to people and that touches their ordinary life.
Wormwood is a bitter plant. The star's name describes its effect, and that effect reverses an old mercy: God once turned bitter water sweet for Israel.
The name "Wormwood" shows his character… Everyone under the withering influence of this fallen being shares his character, "Wormwood." There is a reference here to that striking event in Israel's history told in Exodus 15:22-25. There God made the bitter waters sweet; here the sweet waters become bitter… It poisons their springs of action — their motives, principles, and moral life.
Commentators differ. Some read a civil ruler, others a religious teacher, others the Antichrist himself. The case for a fallen teacher rests on where the star lands:
The heavens are the sphere of government, whether civil or spiritual, so this could point to a ruler of either kind… Yet the fall from heaven and the poisoning of the sources of refreshment seem to point much more strongly to an apostate teacher. His fall turns the springs of spiritual truth bitter, and people perish… They refused to love the truth and so be saved, so God sends them a strong delusion and they believe what is false. Here would seem to be the beginning of this.
Another writer narrows it further, to a man who first claimed God's authority and then abandoned it:
It is some person who claimed authority and then becomes an apostate. His fall produces the awful results given here. It may be the final Antichrist. He may first have claimed to be a great teacher for Israel with divine authority, and then he takes the awful plunge.
The deaths come by drinking, not by disaster. One writer reads them as the death of the soul, not of the body:
He corrupts the truth of God by his poisonous teaching (1 John 2:22). Many die through it — not in body, but by falling away, so that they become dead to any recognition of the living God.
Judgments like this leave hearts where they were. Only one thing changes them:
One would think that such mighty displays of divine power would soften people's hearts. But it is not so… Love, God's own love to man as a sinner, in the cross of Christ, alone breaks and captivates the human heart.
- Height. A star is subordinate authority, set in place by God to give light and order to others.
- Fall. Falling "from heaven" means being cut off from God — yet the star keeps burning like a lamp, so it still attracts.
- Poison. It lands on rivers and fountains, so the sources that refresh and guide people's lives turn bitter.
- Name. "Wormwood" names its character, and it reverses an old mercy: God once made bitter waters sweet; now sweet waters go bitter.
- Death. Many die from drinking. One writer reads this as moral death — people dead to the living God through false teaching. Only God's love in the cross breaks a heart that judgment only hardens.
And the name of the star is called Wormwood; and the third part of the waters became wormwood, and many of the men died of the waters because they were made bitter.
The third trumpet drops a burning star on the rivers and springs — the water people drink, not the land or the sea. Its name is its verdict, and what should refresh now kills.
The star stands for a person, not a lump of rock. In this book a star pictures someone set in authority under God, and this one has come down from his place.
A star, as we saw in an earlier chapter in another connection (Revelation 1:20), pictures someone who holds a lower place of authority. He may give light to others. He is under another himself, but he still rules. Here it is a degraded ruler, a dignitary fallen from his place of authority. Waters are the symbol of peoples not yet formed. Fountains are the sources of their refreshment, and a river is what gives their course its character.
He has lost his standing yet keeps his shine, and that is exactly what makes him dangerous.
But he falls "from heaven," out of the place where God had set him — for God appoints the powers that exist. His fall now cuts him off from all connection with God. Yet he still burns, not as a star but as a lamp, so he still attracts people by his light and brightness. He falls on all the sources of life, the moral sources, pictured by the rivers and fountains of waters. You can often see this when someone prominent in the church of God turns unfaithful or apostate and morally destroys his hearers by unbelieving teaching.
"Wormwood" is an Old Testament word. Earlier passages explain what the name means here.
His name was Wormwood. Deuteronomy 29:19-20 speaks of the man who hears the curses of the law and says, "I shall have peace, though I walk in the stubbornness of my heart, to add drunkenness to thirst." Scripture compares him to a root that bears gall and wormwood. See also the immoral woman of Proverbs 5:4, and Jeremiah 23:15. In Jeremiah 9:15, wormwood seems to be the bitter result of disobedience — even the scattering among the nations. Here, as in Amos 5:7, "You who turn justice to wormwood," it seems to mean the corruption of the waters, and the death of those who drank them.
Everything the star touches takes on its flavour. Israel's history shows the exact reverse of this scene.
The name "Wormwood" points to character... The fountains, the sources of national life, are poisoned. All who come under the withering influence of this fallen being share his character, "Wormwood." There is a clear reference here to a striking incident in Israel's history, told in Exodus 15:22-25. There the bitter waters were made sweet; here the sweet waters are made bitter.
Commentators differ over who this ruler is. One reading sees the poisoning of the springs as a matter of teaching, not politics.
The heavens are the sphere of government, whether civil or spiritual, so a ruler of either kind might be meant here... Yet the fall from heaven, the poisoning of the sources of refreshment, and the connection with the sixth trumpet — a parallel, if not something deeper — seem to point much more strongly to an apostate teacher. His fall would embitter the springs of spiritual truth and cause men to perish... People have not received the love of the truth so that they might be saved. So God will send them a strong delusion, so that they believe a lie. Here would seem to be the beginning of this.
Others name a candidate. "It may be the final Antichrist. He may first have claimed to be a great teacher for Israel with divine authority, and then he takes the awful plunge" (Arno Clemens Gaebelein).
Many die from the water. Several writers read this death as spiritual, not bodily: "not physically, but by apostasy they become dead to any recognition of the living God" (L. M. Grant). The damage is terrible, but it has a limit — "a third," not everything.
The language stays highly symbolic. One feature is common to each judgment: it falls only on a third part of the things affected. This shows that for the moment the effects are not universal but limited.
The passage records no repentance. Judgment on this scale does not soften anyone:
One would think that such mighty displays of divine power would soften people's hearts. But it is not so... Love, God's own love to man as a sinner, in the cross of Christ, alone breaks and captivates the human heart.
- Fall. The star is no rock from space. It is a ruler who leaves the place God gave him — still shining, and so still attractive.
- Poison. He lands on rivers and springs: not the surface of life but its sources, the moral wells people drink from.
- Name. "Wormwood" is Scripture's word for the bitterness of turning from God. Whatever he touches takes his character.
- Reversal. In Exodus God made Israel's bitter water sweet. Here sweet water turns bitter — that mercy run backwards.
- Limit. A third, not all. The death is mainly moral. The judgment warns, yet leaves room for the love that alone melts hearts.
And the fourth angel sounded [his] trumpet and the third part of the sun was smitten, and the third part of the moon, and the third part of the stars; so that the third part of them should be darkened, and that the day should not appear [for] the third part of it, and the night the same.
The fourth trumpet strikes the sky itself. Is this astronomy, or a picture of human authority collapsing over a limited part of the earth?
Commentators read the three lights as three ranks of rule. Edward Dennett sets out that order, then names what happens when it falls:
It is the governments of the earth that are affected by the sound of the fourth trumpet (v. 12), and no form of it escapes. As pointed out before, the sun is a symbol of supreme authority. The moon stands for authority derived from the supreme, just as the moon takes her light from the sun and reflects it. The stars just as plainly speak of what is subordinate. Sun, moon, and stars, therefore, express every order of human authority in government… The effect is that confusion and darkness reign instead of peace and security. Little do men realise how much they owe to orderly and stable governments.
The wording itself resists a physical reading. One commentator starts from the strange detail that the day itself loses a third of its light:
The day does not shine in a third part of the sphere of its rule, and neither does the night, in its moon and stars. This would certainly not be the natural result of darkening a third part of sun and moon. It shows us that we do not have here a literal event of the kind described, but figures of other things. Royal or imperial authority has collapsed, along with all the lesser powers that depend on it, within such limits as a "third part" may mark out; and with this, the first series of the trumpets ends.
F. B. Hole reads the repeated fraction as a limit, and finds its meaning in a later chapter of the same book:
The language stays deeply symbolic. A feature common to each is that the judgments only fall on a third part of the things affected. For the moment the effects are not universal but limited. The phrase "the third part" occurs again in Revelation 12:4, where the Roman Empire, energised by Satan, is in question. This leads to the conclusion that here it means the Roman earth.
Walter Scott compares this verse with an earlier vision where no such limit appears:
Under the sixth Seal (Rev. 6:12-13) the same symbols express a total collapse of all governing authority on earth. There, however, nothing restricts the breakdown of the whole social fabric and the overthrow of every seat of power… Here under the fourth Trumpet the judgment and its effects reach the "third part" of the prophetic scene, the western part of the revived empire. The term "third part" occurs five times in this one verse (v. 12). The effect of this judgment is that moral darkness settles down on the empire like a funeral shroud.
The night loses its light as well as the day. J. N. Darby sees that loss reaching into private life:
The public course of things was thrown into confusion and darkness, the day darkened in its sunlight. But more than that, the private and hidden life of man lost the light that guided it. There was darkness and stumbling. There was no perception of God's will, and no way or light to walk by that human understanding could use.
Most read the lights as ranks of government. One writer takes the darkening as loss of light of another kind:
Of course this cannot be literal. The sun (which is the supreme source of light to the earth) speaks of the light of the glory of God. So this darkening speaks of people being plunged into the darkness of atheism, not seeing the sun. They become closed even to the reflected light of the moon and the stars. The light of heavenly testimony is gone from the whole kingdom of the beast.
This verse closes a set of four. William Kelly marks how the three that follow differ:
We have had the preliminary judgments brought in by the first four trumpets… and last of all, the whole fabric of political rule, both supreme and subordinate, has to suffer a notable eclipse. So it was a judgment of circumstances, not a judgment falling on people themselves. But we also see a closing hint of still deeper blows. They are marked off in the clearest way from the series that came before: "Woe, woe, woe to those who dwell on the earth!"
- Lights — Sun, moon and stars stand for the top rank of authority, the rank derived from it, and the ranks below. Strike them, and every level of government falls at once.
- Limit — The fivefold "third part" fences the judgment in: not universal, but the Roman earth, and only part of it.
- Figure — A third of the day going dark is not how a dimmed sun works, which shows the scene is a symbol, not an eclipse.
- Reach — Day and night both go dark. Public order collapses, and private life loses the light it walked by.
- Warning — This judgment strikes men's circumstances, and it ends the milder four. The three woes that follow strike men themselves.
And I saw, and I heard an eagle flying in mid-heaven, saying with a loud voice, Woe, woe, woe, to them that dwell upon the earth, for the remaining voices of the trumpet of the three angels who are about to sound.
Four trumpets have already sounded. Now the vision pauses for one cry that carries across the whole sky. A single creature announces that the worst is still ahead. It names its victims not by nation or region, but by where their hearts have settled.
Some older English versions read "angel" here instead of "eagle." One writer explains how the mistake crept in, and why "eagle" fits:
I believe John saw an eagle here. In Revelation 14:6 it is an angel, and our verse may have been made to match that one. Or perhaps the two words were simply confused by carelessness. The eagle's flight in mid-heaven was the dark and most fitting herald of coming woe. Nor is there any real difficulty in its loud utterance; for the altar itself is, in the true text, made to speak in Revelation 16:7.
The "mid-heaven" of these writers is what the ESV calls flying "directly overhead." This eagle is not the only messenger to fly there:
Both the eagle and the angel are messengers. Both are seen flying across the sky so as to scan the earth, even to its farthest bounds, and to proclaim their message aloud. The flying eagle is a herald of judgment, the flying angel is a messenger of mercy.
The choice of creature says something about the speed of what is coming.
Judgment is about to fall on these "inhabitants of the earth." The eagle that announces the woes probably stands for the speed with which the blows will descend. For "while people are saying, 'There is peace and security,' then sudden destruction will come upon them." When God begins to judge, He makes short work of the earth.
This verse marks a break in the run of seven trumpets. The change is not only in force but in target:
The first four trumpet judgments dealt mainly with the circumstances of life. The trees, the rivers, the sun, moon, and stars stand for these. The last three trumpet judgments are more severe and terrible, since, as we shall see, they fall on people rather than on their circumstances. They bring woe to that special class called dwellers upon the earth. These are the people who, like Cain, go out from the presence of the Lord and try to build a world without God.
The phrase does not cover everyone alive. It marks out a settled attitude, and one writer defines it by its opposite:
Woe is then announced. It falls above all on those who had their settled place on earth, unlike those with the heavenly calling. The judgments on the earth neither woke them nor moved them. They clung to the earth as their home despite everything. Threefold woe! The term "dwellers on," or "inhabitants of," the earth has not appeared before this, apart from the promise to Philadelphia and the cry of the souls under the altar. Both of those stood in contrast with such people. After all these dealings of God they are a distinct and clearly marked class.
What makes this class so serious is that they are not ignorant. They have heard, and stayed put:
It is a class who profess the light outwardly. They even admit that the testimony in the word of God is true, both to the present grace of the gospel and to the coming judgment on the world. Still, their interests lie entirely on the earth. There may be an actual crisis, as there surely will be, when this is plainly shown. Yet as a principle it is of the deepest practical importance to see how God regards "dwellers on the earth."
The eagle's cry sets out what the last three trumpets will bring. One writer traces the three woes like this:
Then the fifth trumpet, or first woe judgment, falls on a Judaism that has turned away from God. It is the subject of Revelation 9:1-11. The sixth trumpet, or second woe judgment, deals with the guilty inhabitants of the Roman earth, who have also abandoned God. That is the burden of Revelation 9:12-21. The final blast of the trumpet, or third woe, touches the whole world. In the end it reaches to the close of the thousand-year kingdom reign, even to "the time for the dead to be judged."
- Warned. The cry comes before the trumpets sound, not after. The eagle announces the woes in advance, high overhead, where everyone can hear.
- Eagle. The true reading is "eagle," and the bird is the point. It heralds judgment, and its speed pictures how fast the blows will fall.
- Contrast. The same high sky later carries an angel with good news. One messenger brings judgment, the other mercy.
- Named. The last woes strike people, not circumstances — and one sort of person above all: those who have heard the light and still made earth their home.
- Settled. "Dwellers on the earth" are the opposite of the heavenly calling. Not even God's judgments moved them, and that marks them out as a class.
And the fifth angel sounded [his] trumpet and I saw a star out of the heaven fallen to the earth; and there was given to it the key of the pit of the abyss.
The fifth trumpet brings a strange sight: a star fallen from heaven, lying on the earth, holding a key. Two questions decide the meaning — who is this star, and who gave him the key?
The wording matters. John does not watch a star drop. He sees one that has already fallen.
At the sound of the fifth trumpet a star appears — not falling, as the older common translation puts it, but already fallen from heaven to earth. This seems to connect him with the apostasy under the third trumpet. And no one else's apostasy is likely to be as notable as the apostasy of the man whose course is recorded here. In any case, it is certainly an apostate who stands before us, and to him is given "the key of the abyss."
A star stands for someone in high place. The wording here echoes a taunt against a fallen king.
The star fallen from heaven to earth is a dignitary in an apostate state. This points to a real person, as the next words show — "to him was given the key of the pit of the abyss." The allusion to Isaiah 14:12 seems clear. There the king of Babylon is taunted: "How you are fallen, O Lucifer [that is, day-star], son of the morning… Yet you shall be brought down to hell, to the sides of the pit." What is in view here is not his doom, but the authority he was permitted to exercise over the abyss. The abyss is the expression of the source of satanic evil and misery.
Kelly quotes Isaiah 14:12 from an older English translation. Commentators differ on who the star is. Some read him as a fallen human leader. Others read him as the devil himself, cast out of heaven:
The star fallen from heaven with the key of the pit of the abyss is Satan himself, cast out of heaven. The details of this event we learn in the twelfth chapter.
The phrase is not a poetic way of saying "hell." It describes a prison, and the Bible's own usage fixes its meaning.
In the Old Testament a "pit" is often another word for a dungeon, and everything points to that meaning here. The "abyss" is not something other than the pit itself. It only defines it further — the dungeon which is the abyss. So the demons beg not to be sent into the deep, or "abyss" (Luke 8:31), and in the twentieth chapter Satan is shut up there… The abyss is not "hell," the "lake of fire." We can see this from one passage (Romans 10:7), which uses the word in connection with the Lord: "Who will descend into the abyss?" — that is, to bring Christ up from the dead… The literal meaning ("bottomless") must not be pressed, as our own use of the word shows.
The verse never says who handed over the key. But the handing over itself settles who is in charge.
Revelation 9:1 makes it clear that Satan does not have absolute control to do as he pleases, for the key of the bottomless pit is not in his hand. The star that fell from heaven was given the key for the time being, but the key did not belong to him. For a limited time this star — some great intellectual or spiritual leader — was allowed to bring up influences from the regions below. Those influences would bring delusion and trouble on all who did not have the seal of God on their foreheads.
God gives such permission elsewhere too, and it serves very different ends.
The key of the bottomless pit was given to him. God permits Satan to act. Sometimes this is for the good of His children. Sometimes it is to let His judgments fall on His enemies. Satan and his angels are glad to seize an opportunity to do evil. God is coming here to chastise the wickedness of men.
This woe goes further than the four trumpets before it, and it has a named target.
Under the fifth trumpet this fallen ruler is about to let loose the malignant and darkening power of Satan on the apostate part of Judah. Apostate Gentiles are the ones judged under the third trumpet; apostate Jews are the sufferers under the fifth. The state of things under this first woe goes beyond anything we have seen so far. Direct satanic influence and power drive the agents and instruments of evil.
- Fallen. The star is not falling but already down — an apostate who once held high place, now on the earth.
- Given. The key is handed to him; it was never his. Even at the mouth of the abyss, nothing moves without permission.
- Unlocked. The abyss is a dungeon, a prison — the place demons begged not to be sent, and where Satan is later shut up — not the lake of fire.
- Darkened. What comes up out of the pit is delusion — influences that darken and trouble men.
- Limited. The star holds the key only for a time, and those sealed by God are out of reach. The key that opens also locks.
And it opened the pit of the abyss; and there went up smoke out of the pit as [the] smoke of a great furnace; and the sun and the air were darkened with the smoke of the pit.
The fifth trumpet turns a corner. A shaft opens from below, and the smoke that pours up is thick enough to blot out the light people live by.
One writer works out what "bottomless pit" means from the way Scripture uses the words elsewhere:
In the Old Testament a "pit" is often a word for a dungeon, and everything here points to that meaning. The "abyss" is not something other than the pit itself. It is only a further definition of it — the dungeon which is the abyss. So the demons pray that they may not be sent into the deep, or "abyss" (Luke 8:31). In the twentieth chapter Satan is shut up there... The abyss is not, however, "hell" — the "lake of fire." ... The literal meaning, "bottomless," must not be pressed. We use the word loosely ourselves, and the Greek word was used in the same way. The Greek Old Testament uses it for the "deep" over which darkness lay on the first day.
Another writer names who is held there:
He has "the key of the pit of the abyss." This is the unfathomable or bottomless pit, where evil is held back until it receives its final doom. Here "the spirits in prison" are kept (1 Peter 3:19). Here Satan will be shut up for a thousand years, before his last rebellion and everlasting punishment. Here too the angels who sinned are "committed to chains of gloomy darkness to be kept until the judgment." (2 Peter 2:4.)
The four judgments before this one worked in another way. This one still does not slip out of God's hand:
If the four earlier judgments were providential, though God inflicted them as acts of judgment, this one is different. It is still under God's control, but its origin and its nature are satanic.
Another writer explains why God allows it:
God permits Satan to act sometimes for the good of His children, sometimes to let His judgments fall on His enemies. Satan and his angels are glad to seize an opportunity to do evil. God is coming here to chastise the wickedness of men.
Smoke blinds. One writer names what this smoke stands for:
The smoke rising like the smoke of a great furnace is the symbol of a delusion which darkens the mind of man.
One writer takes the furnace image as a measure of sheer volume, and sees the smoke as the parent of what follows:
Here, in Revelation 9, I take the smoke to express two things. First, that the place it comes from is under judgment. Second, the darkening tendency of what will proceed from there, as the parent or nurse of the locusts issuing from it. The smoke is "like the smoke of a great furnace," which I take to express the fullness of its volume. The result was that the sun and the air were darkened by it.
One writer reads the sun and the air as symbols, and names what each stands for:
This means a satanic delusion bred in the abyss, marked by the way it blinds and withers people morally. It is probably the same delusion to which Christendom will be given over, which Paul speaks of (2 Thess. 2:11-12). The smoke is the darkening influence and power of Satan. Its effect will be to blight the supreme government (the sun). It will also darken and corrupt the whole social life and principles of men (the air).
One writer, who admits the picture is hard to pin down, points to where this smoke is at work now:
What the smoke exactly represents may be hard to say, but its source and effect are clear. It shuts man off from all that he needs for his moral and spiritual welfare. It is Satan's smoke today that hides the word of God from the souls of men. They breathe it instead of the pure influences of the Scriptures, and so become morally poisoned and tormented.
- Source. The pit is a dungeon where evil is held until its final doom. It is not the lake of fire, and it does not open unless God permits it.
- Permission. The key is given. This judgment is satanic in its origin and nature, yet it stays under God's control from first to last.
- Substance. What rises is smoke: a delusion that darkens the mind, poured out with the fullness of a furnace.
- Reach. Sun and air both go dark: the smoke blights supreme government and corrupts the whole social life of people.
- Result. The smoke is the parent of what comes next. The delusion comes first, and it breeds the torment that follows.
And out of the smoke came forth locusts on the earth, and power was given to them as the scorpions of the earth have power;
The fifth trumpet brings a swarm out of the smoke of the pit, armed not for crops but with the sting of scorpions. Where do these creatures come from, and what power do they receive?
The text is careful about origins. One writer begins with who holds the keys:
Christ has "the keys of Death and Hades" (Revelation 1:18). We cannot imagine that He would hand over any part of His own authority to an apostate, whether man or spirit… In fact, the text does not even say that the locusts come out of the pit. Nothing comes out of it but the smoke that darkens the sun and the air. The locusts come out of the smoke… The smoke here is not the smoke of torment, as it is elsewhere. It is the fumes of harmful spiritual influences that darken the air and the supreme source of light itself. We can easily understand that the locusts are bred out of that darkness.
The strongest argument against real insects lies in the command that follows the verse:
The locusts that come out of the smoke are a picture of aggressive robbers, and they are clothed with a remarkable power of torment, like the scorpions of the earth. The command given shows very plainly, I think, the error of those who take the locusts literally. They were not to hurt the grass of the earth, and so on — that is, their natural food, if real locusts were meant.
Everything turns on the creature chosen for the comparison:
The intense anguish caused by these hordes of satanic instruments and agents is like the torment of a scorpion's poisonous sting. The scorpion shuns the light, and the native peoples of Africa and the Arab tribes of Asia rightly dread it. The sting is not often fatal, but the suffering is dreadful… In Luke 10:19 the Lord connects serpents, scorpions, and the power of the enemy with the fall of Satan. Here, in the same way, scorpions are linked with the fallen star.
The verse says the power was given to them. Walter Scott takes that word strictly: these agents are "powerless, unless authority is given them to act." Another writer compares this plague with the four that came before:
If the four earlier judgments were providential, though inflicted judicially by God, this one, while still under God's control, is diabolical in its origin and nature.
The swarm is limited twice over — in what it may eat, and in whom it may reach:
Their power fits their origin: it is pictured as the power of the scorpions of the earth — that is, their poisonous sting. Their difference from natural locusts shows here. They do not touch the locusts' food. They are a plague only on men, and only on the unsealed among them. Since it is in Israel that the sealing is found, the fair inference is that these unsealed ones are Israelites, and the place of this plague is in the east.
One writer names what the locusts stand for, and where their poison lands:
This evil teaching is pictured as a swarm of locusts that sweeps everything before it with irresistible power, leaving misery in its trail. Natural locusts would destroy the grass and every green thing, and strip the trees. But the evil influence set out by these symbolic locusts will not touch people's circumstances in life, or even their bodies. It poisons their minds, just as a scorpion poisons the body.
- Source — nothing comes out of the pit but smoke. The locusts are bred from that smoke, the fumes of harmful spiritual influence that blot out the light.
- Symbol — these are not insects. They are forbidden the grass and green things that real locusts live to eat.
- Sting — the picture is a scorpion, not a killer. Its sting is rarely fatal, but the suffering is dreadful.
- Sanction — the power is given; the agents are diabolical in nature yet act only within limits God sets.
- Scope — they may reach only those without the seal of God, which is the one shelter in the whole scene.
and it was said to them, that they should not injure the grass of the earth, nor any green thing, nor any tree, but the men who have not the seal of God on their foreheads
The fifth trumpet lets loose a swarm like no swarm ever seen. It ignores every green thing and goes straight for people. One line is drawn across the whole scene: a mark on the forehead. Everything in this judgment turns on who has it and who does not.
Real locusts strip a land bare. These are forbidden to touch the very thing locusts live on. Commentators read that ban as the key to the whole picture.
The command given shows, I think very plainly, the error of those who take the locusts in a literal way. They were not to hurt the grass of the earth, and so on — that is, their natural food, if real locusts were meant. Men were to be the objects of these symbolic raiders — men, except God's sealed ones.
Another writer gives a second reason for sparing the fields.
The whole description shows that the locust army is a symbolic picture of judgment of a superhuman kind. So does the ban on injuring the grass and trees, their natural food. There is a further reason why the plant world was to be spared. The grass, "any green plant," and trees point to a general state of prosperity in men's circumstances and position.
Read this command together with chapter 7, and the target of the plague comes into focus.
Their power is limited. This command settles two things. First, as already said, these are moral, not real, locusts. Natural locusts ravage exactly the plants and trees of the earth. Second, the target of this dreadful visitation is apostate Jews. Revelation 7 tells us that the servants of God, sealed on their foreheads, are the elect of the twelve tribes. So those not sealed would be Jews outside that elect number. Later parts of this book make it clear that these unsealed Jews will be, mostly if not entirely, in Jerusalem and Palestine. That fixes both the sphere and the character of the judgment.
Commentators differ on how far the plague reaches. One reads the double name in the chapter as a hint of wider scope:
Perhaps the double name in Hebrew and Greek shows that their power will be over Jews and Gentiles.
So what does this seal do for the person who carries it?
With the seal we have the idea of God's property, His ownership, and it also carries the meaning of security. If God has put His seal on a man, everyone can see it, because it is on the forehead. Then even these evil powers will not touch him. This mark is the exact opposite of the mark of the beast. People will accept the mark of the beast in order to survive, and that is the opposite of faith.
The seal carries one more promise, and leaves one question open:
"The seal of the living God" implies safety from death. The seal on the forehead is a public, open acknowledgment that those sealed belong to God. What the seal is, we are not told.
The sealing in chapter 7 happens first, and the judgment waits for it. One writer draws out what that order shows about God's rule.
We learn, second, that God governs the world with His people in view. The angel coming up from the east told the four angels not to hurt the earth, the sea, or the trees, "until we have sealed the servants of our God on their foreheads." It was the same when judgment was about to fall on Jerusalem. The Lord had a mark set on the foreheads of the men who sighed and cried over all the detestable things done in it. He kept this faithful remnant safe while the punishment swept through.
The unsealed are not killed. One writer describes what they suffer instead, and for how long.
These locusts have the poison of scorpions. The natural locust feeds on every green thing, but these were only to afflict the unsealed among men. Their torment is like the sting of a scorpion, which is very sharp but does not usually kill. There is a limit to the length of this affliction — five months.
- Sealed first. God holds judgment back until He has marked His servants. He did the same in Jerusalem, marking those who grieved over its sins before the blow fell.
- Sealed means owned. The mark on the forehead is public. It declares who a person belongs to, and it is the exact opposite of the mark of the beast. What the seal looks like, we are never told.
- Sealed means spared. Ownership brings security. Even these evil powers may not touch a sealed man.
- Unsealed means exposed. Most writers name the victims as Israelites outside the sealed number. One sees the reach going wider, to Gentiles too.
- Unsealed means tormented. The plague spares the grass and strikes people. It brings five months of anguish that stops short of death.
and it was given to them that they should not kill them, but that they should be tormented five months; and their torment [was] as [the] torment of a scorpion when it strikes a man.
The fifth trumpet releases a swarm out of the bottomless pit, and the striking thing about it is what it is not allowed to do. They may torment but not kill, and even the torment is capped at five months — so who sets the limit, and what kind of pain is this?
The verse turns on one word: the locusts were "allowed." Someone above them fixes how far they can go. One writer finds the same pattern in the book of Job.
Second, we have the extent to which the judgment can go. Satan was allowed to persecute Job, but not to take his life. In the same way these symbolic locusts, these agents from the bottomless pit, are not allowed to take the lives of their victims. They may only put them through such extreme torture for a limited period (five months) that their victims will long for death and not get it.
Another writer ties the scorpion image to satanic power, then names the limit on these agents:
In Luke 10:19 the Lord connects serpents, scorpions, and the power of the enemy with the fall of Satan. But these hellish instruments of vengeance, let loose on guilty Israel, have no power unless they are given authority to act.
A scorpion's sting brings agony, but it does not usually kill. That is the shape of this judgment.
They do not kill, just as the scorpion in general does not. They inflict torment so bad that death would be better. Their power lasts five months.
Ordinary locusts eat grass and trees. These are banned from touching them, and one writer reads that as proof they are a symbol.
The whole description shows that this locust army is a symbol of judgment of a superhuman kind. So does the ban on injuring the grass and trees (v. 4), their natural food.
Not everyone is a target. One writer traces the seal that spares some back to an earlier chapter.
These had the poison of scorpions. The natural locust preys on every green thing, but these were only to afflict people who had no seal. This points us back to the opening verses of Revelation 7. There we find that those who were sealed were the servants of God out of the tribes of Israel.
The verse does not say where this pain is felt. One writer admits that, then draws a conclusion from what these locusts are.
The next two verses (vv. 5, 6) give the nature, duration, and effect of this judgment. The "locusts" were not permitted to kill, only to torment... We are not told what kind of torment this is, whether mental or otherwise. But if, as we conclude, these "locusts" are demonic agents, the seat of the torment would be the soul rather than the body.
Read that way, the sting poisons the mind, not the body.
The evil influence pictured by these symbolic locusts will not affect the circumstances of life, or even the bodies of men. It poisons the minds of men just as a scorpion poisons the body. Men will fall into such mental misery that they will seek death and not find it.
Why five months? One writer ties the number to the life-span of the natural locust, and reads it as a short, limited stretch.
We believe that the "five months" of torment points back to the ravages of the natural locust, which usually last five months. A limited and brief period is meant, one that may not go beyond five months.
One long-standing reading counts each day as a year. One writer sets out that view and rejects it:
Those who apply this prophecy to the Saracens have to adopt the "year-day" theory to explain the five months. Take a day to stand for a year, and the five months stretch out to one hundred and fifty years. That, they claim, matches the length of Saracen rule. Unfortunately for those who hold this view, the year-day theory finds no support whatever in this book.
- Permission — the locusts act only on authority given from above. Like Satan with Job, they may not take life.
- Restraint — they may torment but not kill; their victims long for death, and it is kept from them.
- Target — the plague falls on the unsealed. One writer links the sealed to the tribes of Israel in Revelation 7; those marked by God are passed over.
- Torment — a scorpion's sting brings agony without killing. Writers who read these locusts as demonic agents put the wound in the mind and soul, not the body.
- Term — five months, the span of a locust's ravages and a short, limited period. It is not to be stretched into 150 years by a year-day scheme.
And in those days shall men seek death, and shall in no way find it; and shall desire to die, and death flees from them.
Under the fifth trumpet a swarm of scorpion-like tormentors is let loose on the earth. The strangest detail is that they may not kill. So the one exit men have always counted on is shut. Why does God hold death back, and who is left to suffer?
The limit on these tormentors is deliberate. They may inflict agony, but they cannot end a life — and their victims cannot end it either.
The "locusts" were not permitted to kill, only to torment, and this for the space of five months. The torment makes those who suffer it weary of their lives. They want to die, but death flees from them. Death would be a relief from their agony. But they suffer by God's appointment, and however much they long for death, they are not permitted to find it.
The verse names no wound and no weapon. What makes life unbearable here is suffering inside a person.
Death would be a welcome release from the torment — the anguish of soul these servants of Satan inflict. But that last refuge of despair is denied them: "death will flee from them." The gnawing anguish and horrible torment of a guilty and sin-defiled conscience is beyond all telling. Only those enduring it can weigh and measure it.
These creatures carry their power in their tails. One writer finds the key to that image in Isaiah, where the tail stands for a teacher of falsehood.
Isaiah 9:15 throws light, we believe, on this statement: "the prophet who teaches lies is the tail." So the sting in the tail, we believe, is the twisting of truth by these demonic agents. It produces such anguish of spirit in those affected that life becomes unbearable.
Not everyone alive goes through this. One writer traces the limit back to who carries God's seal, and draws a narrow boundary around the sufferers.
They resemble locusts in their overwhelming numbers and power, but they have stings like scorpions. Their torment is so dreadful that men desire death. Death, however, "will flee from them," for this is not a plague of slaughter and destruction, but only of intense suffering. The people harmed are "only those people who do not have the seal of God on their foreheads." Since the sealing was not for people outside Israel, but only for a select number from the twelve tribes, we may infer that it is only the unbelieving part of Israel who suffer the dreadful, though not fatal, anguish inflicted by this army of tormentors from the bottomless pit.
Today death is the thing people run from. Here that fear turns inside out.
You know how people fear death now, if they are not saved. They would run away from it if they could. But a dreadful time is coming, when the Lord comes to punish people who would not obey the gospel. Then men will be so tormented that they will beg for death. But they shall not die; death will depart from them.
The torment does not soften anyone. Suffering on this scale still produces no change of heart.
What a solemn picture of how hardened man's heart can become against God! Even this dreadful visitation produces no good effect. They are given up to "a strong delusion, so that they may believe what is false." Those who once despised God in His grace will at last despise Him in His government. Each new stroke of His judgment will only make them more callous and defiant, until at last, like Pharaoh, they walk blindfolded into the very flood that swallows them up. Such is man. How marvellous the grace that could stoop to the fallen state of creatures so degraded and ruined, and buy them for glory at so priceless a cost!
- Death withheld. The tormentors are not allowed to kill. Men look for death and cannot find it — God's appointment, not chance, keeps that release from them.
- Death as refuge. Dying has always been man's last escape hatch from unbearable pain. Here that final refuge closes, and the sufferers have nowhere to run.
- Death inside. The verse pictures a scorpion's sting, and the power sits in the tail — lies taught, truth twisted, a guilty conscience with no relief.
- Death targeted. This plague touches only those who lack God's seal. It passes over the sealed number out of the twelve tribes of Israel.
- Death that teaches nothing. Even this does not bend anyone to repentance. Those who once brushed aside God's grace end by defying His government. So grace, offered now, is the thing to take now.
And the likenesses of the locusts [were] like to horses prepared for war; and upon their heads as crowns like gold, and their faces as faces of men;
Revelation 9:7 belongs to the fifth trumpet, where a swarm rises from the smoke of the pit to torment people, not to strip the fields. The verse pictures that swarm — war horses, gold-like crowns, human faces — and the question is what it describes: insects, armies, or something else.
Commentators point to the command given in the earlier verses as the decisive clue. Real locusts eat grass. These must leave the grass alone.
The command given shows, I think very plainly, the error of those who apply the locusts in a literal way. They were not to hurt the grass of the earth, and so on — that is, their natural food, if real locusts were meant. The targets of these symbolic raiders were men — all except God's sealed ones.
The verse gives three images, and each one carries its own weight.
The locusts are shaped like horses prepared for battle (v. 7). This speaks of their strength in conquest: they subdue men. "Crowns like gold" speaks of a dignity they have assumed, one that deceives people. Their faces, like the faces of men, add to the deception with a boastful, humanistic approach.
The verse does not say they wore crowns of gold. It says they wore what looked like crowns of gold. One writer presses that difference.
The crown of gold adorns the head of the Son of Man (Rev. 14:14), and also those of the triumphant elders or redeemed (Rev. 4:4). But these satanic invaders from the smoke of the pit are not really crowned, nor is real gold in question. They lay claim to a dignity God never gave them. "On their heads were what looked like crowns of gold." Their claim to royal authority is false.
Another writer reads the crowns not as royal headgear at all, and ties the human face to the mind behind the attack.
The crowns they wear are not royal crowns. They are victory wreaths, which they have taken for themselves. To the eye they looked like gold. But they were not what they appeared to be — only "as it were." The face of a man speaks of intelligence.
The front view is not the whole truth. Another writer turns the swarm around and looks at it from behind.
To those who met them they looked like military imperial power — crowned, and full of masculine energy. But seen from behind, with the secret uncovered, they were subject and weak: their faces were like human faces, their hair like the hair of women.
The same writer calls them "crowds of moral locusts with the sting of false doctrine in their tail." Their work was not to destroy prosperity on earth, but to harass and torment.
Many have read this passage as a picture of the Arab armies that swept the East. Commentators differ on how much weight that reading carries, and several object that the details do not fit.
We may admit that in history this foreshadows the swarms who overran the East under the satanic inspiration of Muhammad. But this is only a secondary fulfilment of the prophecy, and far from a complete one. The reason is clear: Muhammad's conquests were carried out with great bloodshed, while Scripture says plainly that these locusts do not inflict death.
The alternative is to read every feature as a description of character, not of physical looks.
To my mind the meaning is moral, not geographical. This kind of teaching takes away from the real force of Scripture. Is it not almost trifling to take the faces of men, the hair of women, and crowns like gold, and draw out of them a hint of a beard or moustache, with long flowing hair and a turban on top? Taken as emblems of character, the word of God keeps its dignity, and we feel it. The likeness to horses prepared for battle expresses their aggressive attitude, and the crowns like gold seem to hint at their boasted confidence that God had righteously sent them to conquer. Their faces like men's, but with women's hair, may show that, for all their claim to act with authority in God's name, they were subject to mere human authority after all, and not to God.
- Appearance. Every phrase in the verse is a comparison — like horses, like gold, like human faces. The swarm is a symbol: these locusts must leave alone the very food real locusts eat.
- Claim. The war-horse shape claims conquest. The crowns claim royal dignity. The human faces claim intelligence.
- Reality. The crowns are not real crowns, and the gold is not real gold. God never gave them that dignity. What looks like strength of their own is really subjection to a darker power.
- Target. The attack is not on fields or bodies but on minds. The sting is false doctrine, aimed at those who lack God's seal. It torments; it does not kill.
- Reading. When readers point to past armies as the fulfilment, the details resist them. Above all, this swarm may not kill. Read as marks of character, the description keeps its force.
and they had hair as women's hair, and their teeth were as of lions,
John's fifth trumpet vision describes a swarm of locusts part by part, and each part carries a meaning. Here two features stand side by side: hair like a woman's and teeth like a lion's. How can weakness and ferocity belong to the same creature?
Scripture already sets a pattern for this. Long hair marks a person's place, not a person's strength.
The New Testament speaks of long hair as the natural covering of a woman. It owns her subjection to the man, and it is a glory to her. But nature teaches that if a man has long hair, it is a shame to him. He must not cover his head in that way, for "he is the image and glory of God." 1 Corinthians 11:6-15. "Hair as the hair of women" is a symbol of subjection to a head, and of effeminacy. Revelation 9:8.
The same detail carries other associations, and the mention of women may point to something besides obedience.
"They had hair like the hair of women" (length of hair) — perhaps the badge of luxury, or of beauty (2 Samuel 14:26; Isaiah 3:24). The mention of women may assert the appearance of weakness (Isaiah 3:12; Isaiah 19:16). Or, taking 1 Corinthians 11 where the hair serves as a veil, it may assert apparent subjection.
If hair means submission, the question becomes whose orders these creatures take. Commentators differ. One answer points to the ruler named later in the chapter:
Their effeminacy and subjection come next. They are subject not to God, but to Satan their leader: "They had hair as women's hair."
Another sees the detail as puncturing a religious claim: they speak as though sent from God, yet answer to men.
Their faces are as of men, but with the hair of women. This may show that, for all their claim to act with authority in the name of God, they were subject to the lowest human authority after all, and not to God.
The verse before gives these creatures human faces; this verse gives them women's hair. Read together, the outside and the inside do not match.
"Their faces were as faces of men" also — they had the dignity and apparent independence of men. And yet "they had hair as the hair of women." They were in the fullest subjection to the dark and dreadful power that ruled over them.
The teeth tell a different story from the hair.
Teeth as those of lions exposes their actual character of greed and tenacity: they catch a person and do not let go.
One writer traces the same emblem across Scripture. The lion carries a fixed sense, whichever side it stands on.
"Their teeth were as the teeth of lions." This shows their readiness for consuming. The lion stands for courage and power, whether the word is applied to Judah, to Messiah, to Satan, or to the animal in nature. (Proverbs 28:1; Proverbs 30:14, 30; Daniel 7:7, 19; Joel 1:6.)
Some readers have taken the hair and faces as clues to a particular nation's appearance. One writer rejects that approach as too small for the passage.
To my mind the intention is moral, not geographical... Does it not seem almost trifling to take the faces of men, the hair of women, and crowns like gold as a hint at beard or moustache, with literal flowing hair under a turban? Taken as emblems of character, the dignity of the divine word is vindicated and felt. The locusts naturally point to countless swarms, devouring within set limits, but they are marked out more by the tormenting sting of false doctrine.
Writers also admit where a symbol defeats them. One rejects the idea that this hair stands for joy, then owns the limit of his own reading.
That a woman shaving her head may signify grief, I understand — it is a shame, and her ornament is gone. But why a man putting on woman's hair should be joy is, I confess, beyond me. I am not prepared to argue against it, because I am not clear about the point myself.
- Face — the human face gives them dignity and apparent independence; it is the impression they make, not the truth about them.
- Hair — women's hair is a symbol of subjection to a head, drawn from 1 Corinthians 11. It cancels the independence the face claimed.
- Master — commentators differ on whose subjects they are. Some say Satan their leader; others say the lowest human authority, hidden behind a claim to speak for God.
- Teeth — the lion's teeth show what they are for: courage, power, and a grip that catches a person and does not let go.
- Reading — the details are emblems of character, not clues to beards and turbans. Their real sting is false doctrine. Where a symbol stays unclear, saying so is better than forcing it.
and they had breastplates as breastplates of iron, and the sound of their wings [was] as the sound of chariots of many horses running to war;
The fifth trumpet has released a swarm of locusts to torment people on the earth. Verse 9 shows what protects them and what announces their coming.
The verse says the breastplates were like iron. Writers read this as a picture of character, not metalwork: a heart nothing can reach.
They know no pity. Neither force nor entreaty has any effect in turning them from their purpose. Their hearts are hard, their consciences like steel — "they had breastplates like breastplates of iron."
The same iron works the other way too. Nothing gets through it from outside.
Breastplates of iron symbolise that they could not be wounded when attacked. We also see that they had tails like scorpions, with stings in their tails. That shows what harm they could inflict — even the instilling of untruth, which would produce sharp anguish of spirit and make life unbearable.
Scripture gives believers a breastplate too. Side by side, the two could not be more different.
They have breastplates imitating iron (v. 9). The believer wears the "breastplate of righteousness" (Ephesians 6:14). This is the opposite: a hardened conscience, with no proper feeling left. The sound of their wings inspired terror, like an army of war-horses on the run. When people have rejected God outright, this leaves room for a great and awesome infestation of demons. They will make their power felt.
The second half of the verse is pure sound. You hear this army before you see it.
The satanic host swept on with unstoppable energy, striking fear and terror into their victims. This sound announces their approach: "The noise of their wings was like the noise of many chariots with horses rushing into battle" (compare Joel 2:5).
The noise also marks speed. It grips the mind at once, and the grip is fierce.
Whatever its outward attraction to the minds of men, "the teeth of lions" would imply that it will lay hold of men with fanatical ferocity. "The breastplates of iron" may show that it will harden the affections and seize the minds of men with incredible swiftness. "The noise of their wings," likened to "the noise of many chariots with horses rushing into battle," pictures that speed.
Some readers hunt for the exact nation and place these locusts describe. One writer warns that this search costs more than it gives.
To my mind the intention is moral, not geographical. This kind of teaching takes away from the real force of Scripture. It fills the mind with what may be partly true in a natural way, but is not, I believe, what the Holy Spirit intends. … Taken as emblems of character, these figures uphold the dignity of God's word and make it felt. … I take the iron breastplates, the lion-teeth and the sounding wings as a figure of unflinching fanatical courage. That is their strongest armour.
The armour and the war-noise picture an army, but the harm it does is not physical.
The war horses and crowns seem to point to unstoppable fury and a show of power. … The teeth of lions point to destructive violence. The breastplates of iron point to a conscience steeled against pity and remorse. Their advance causes a mighty commotion, like war-chariots hurrying to battle. … It is not a material but a moral plague that the followers of Apollyon, "the destroyer," inflict. … there is no destruction of physical life.
One writer allows that past invasions match part of the picture. He then gives the reason they cannot be the whole answer.
We may admit that in history this foreshadows the swarms who overran the East … But this is only a secondary and far from complete fulfilment of the prophecy. Those conquests shed great blood, while the text plainly says these locusts do not kill. The main application is therefore to something quite different, and still future.
- Armour — the iron breastplate is a conscience hardened past pity. No appeal gets through it.
- Noise — the roar of wings, like war-chariots, marks an advance that is fast, loud and unstoppable.
- Character — the details are emblems of character, not a map of any one nation or army.
- Wound — the plague is moral, not physical. It strikes the conscience and kills no one.
- Counterfeit — it copies the believer's breastplate of righteousness (Ephesians 6:14). One armour guards the heart; this one hardens it.
and they have tails like scorpions, and stings; and their power [was] in their tails to hurt men five months.
The fifth trumpet has released a swarm from the abyss. This verse says where their strength lies: in their tails. Two questions follow: what does a scorpion's tail stand for, and why is the damage capped at five months?
The picture borrows a familiar insect, but it does not describe one.
They are clearly not the literal insects. One reason alone proves it: Scripture says plainly that they do not feed on the natural food of locusts. The well-known creature, with alarming qualities and powers added, becomes the sign that describes these raiders from the abyss.
These raiders fight with fury and claim God's backing. Their worst weapon comes last.
They were not mere plunderers. They had warlike energy, and they claimed God's righteous approval for their headlong career, carrying His image and glory on the outside, though in truth they were completely subject to man and to Satan too. Ferocity is theirs, and hearts steeled against every feeling of pity as they rush on. But their worst power was the venom of falsehood which followed. It was the energy of false doctrine, represented by the scorpion sting in the tail. And we know from elsewhere, "the prophet who speaks lies, he is the tail."
One writer traces this back to Isaiah, where a tail stands for a lying prophet. If the sting is a lie, the wound is inward.
Isaiah 9:15 throws light, we believe, on this statement: "The prophet who teaches lies, he is the tail." The sting in the tail, then, we believe to be the twisting of truth by these demonic agents, producing such anguish of spirit in those affected that life becomes unbearable.
One writer finds a signal in the grammar of the passage.
In the next part of this extraordinary description the past tense gives way to the present. Surely this is deliberate. It marks off the worst and most typical feature from what has gone before: "they have tails like scorpions, and stings." Then again, "and their power was in their tails to hurt men five months." This points back to verses three and five.
Scott quotes an older translation here; the ESV wording stands at the top of this page.
The victims here are not everyone. The plague has a target, and a limit.
Their power matches their origin. It is the power of the scorpions of the earth, that is, a poisonous sting. They differ from natural locusts in this: they do not touch the locusts' food. They are a plague only upon men, and these men are the unsealed. Since we find the sealing in Israel, it seems fair to infer that these unsealed ones are Israelites, and that this plague falls in the east. They do not kill, as a scorpion generally does not. They inflict torment so bad that death would be better, and their power lasts five months.
The stings are real. But something limits how far they may go.
God's purpose is not yet to kill men. Satan, whatever his power and his malice, can do nothing except what is in the purpose of God. It is a moral, diabolical power over men who have not the mark of God on their forehead.
Commentators differ on the length. One reading takes it from the habits of the insect itself:
The locust judgment under the sounding of the fifth angel is a terrible one. Despite Hengstenberg's claim to the contrary, we believe the "five months" of torment points to the ravages of the natural locust, which usually last five months. A limited and brief period is meant, one which may not exceed five months.
Others have counted each day as a year and looked for a fulfilment already past:
Many take the five months of torment (Rev. 9:10) to mean 150 years of unchecked conquest by the Muslim hordes, on the year-day theory.
- Symbol — These are not real insects. They are kept from the food real locusts eat, so a familiar creature pictures raiders from the abyss.
- Sting — Their power sits in the tail. In Scripture, the tail is the prophet who teaches lies. The weapon is false doctrine.
- Wound — A twisted truth brings anguish of spirit. It makes life unbearable, yet leaves the body alive.
- Scope — The plague strikes only those without God's seal, understood as the unsealed of Israel. It cannot kill them.
- Limit — Satan can do nothing outside God's purpose. Five months marks the leash: a short season like the locust's, or 150 years on the year-day theory.
They have a king over them, the angel of the abyss his name in Hebrew, Abaddon, and in Greek he has [for] name Apollyon.
John has described the fifth trumpet swarm in detail — its shape, its sting, its five-month limit. Only now does he name its head. This plague is no blind accident of nature. It is an army under command. Its commander carries a name in two languages, and both mean the same thing: ruin.
These locusts have a king. One writer takes that single word as a window into the organisation of the unseen world.
The book of Daniel gives us a passing glimpse of the organisation of the underworld. There we read of demons of special ability, put in charge of Satan's interests in Persia and Greece. They are called the Prince of Persia and the Prince of Greece. Later we read in Revelation 9:11 of the king over the bottomless pit, named Abaddon. A king is the head of an organised dominion. He has officers to carry out his government, and subjects to obey him.
The king is named twice over, once in Hebrew and once in Greek, and the order is not thought to be accidental.
Abaddon is Hebrew, and literally means destruction. Apollyon is Greek, and means the destroyer. Why does this difference, small as it looks, appear in these meaningful titles? And why does the Hebrew name come before the Greek? The Jew is more guilty than the Gentile. So the Hebrew title Abaddon, destruction, asserts judgment on Judah in its revolt against God. It states that judgment with force, and states its certainty and finality… The order in grace as in judgment is the Jew first, then the Gentile. The Greek name Apollyon, the destroyer, shows Satan's character toward the Christian world, as his other title shows his link with Judaism.
The Hebrew name is not new in Revelation. It already runs through the Old Testament, tied there to death and the grave.
Revelation 9:11 shows that this name means the same as Apollyon, "the destroyer." The same verse describes him as "the angel of the bottomless pit." The name is perhaps not so much one of the names of Satan as his character personified. It occurs six times in the Old Testament. Three of those link it with hell (sheol): Job 26:6; Proverbs 15:11; Proverbs 27:20. One links it with death — "Destruction and Death say," Job 28:22. One links it with the grave, Psalm 88:11. In all these passages, and in Job 31:12, it is translated "destruction."
Commentators differ here. Some read the title as Satan's own character in person. One writer instead sees an angel serving under Satan, set loose on people who once carried the name of God's people.
John reveals that their king and leader is the angel of the bottomless pit (the abyss)… Satan's chief angel, the angel of the abyss, governs this destructive army. The vengeance falls on those who bear the name of the people of God (Jews), but who now, sadly, have turned away from Him. Satan's tricks and temptations made them fall from their high position. Now he, whose servants they have become, is their vengeful enemy and tormentor. So it always goes when his cunning traps his prey. Yet he is only a blind instrument carrying out the just judgment of God.
These locusts do not kill. So the ruin their king brings takes another shape.
These symbolic locusts were under the direction of a king whose name means "The Destroyer." He is described as "the angel of the bottomless pit." This shows that these locusts are an organised force. A controlling destructive power directs them, just as in nature the locust swarms of countless millions act like a well-directed army. The destroyer directs this woe, yet it does not bring men to death, for death flees from them. It brings instead the destruction of everything that makes life on earth worth living. It means darkness and torment of a spiritual kind.
Some take words like "destroy" to mean that the lost stop existing. One writer answers from this verse.
But the word does not mean ceasing to exist. The angel of the bottomless pit bears the name Apollyon, or Abaddon, the destroyer. But he can destroy nothing. It is written, "O Israel, you have destroyed yourself, but in me is your help."
That line follows an older translation. The ESV reads, "He destroys you, O Israel, for you are against me, against your helper."
The Destroyer's name has an opposite. One writer sets it beside the name of Jesus.
In Revelation, Satan, or one of his chief agents, carries the name Apollyon, that is, the Destroyer (Revelation 9:11). The meaning of that name stands in contrast to the name of Jesus, the Saviour of men. Satan destroys what is good, but Jesus destroys nothing except what is evil.
- King. The swarm has a head, and a king implies a government — officers, subjects, orders obeyed. Evil is organised, not random.
- Named. Abaddon in Hebrew means destruction; Apollyon in Greek means destroyer. Hebrew first, then Greek: the Jew first, then the Gentile.
- Disputed. Is he Satan himself, Satan's chief angel, or Satan's character in person? Commentators differ.
- Limited. His army can torment, but it cannot kill. It destroys what makes life worth living, not life itself.
- Answered. He bears the name Destroyer, yet he can destroy nothing. Jesus destroys nothing but evil.
The first woe has passed. Behold, there come yet two woes after these things.
This short line sits between two trumpet judgments: the locust plague has ended, and two more woes are still coming. It reads like a countdown, and it raises two questions — what has just finished, and why God stops to tell us how many are left.
The last three of the seven trumpets stand apart from the first four, and a herald announces them before the first one sounds.
The trumpets fall into two clear groups. The first four, which we have already looked at, share much the same character. The other three are of a completely different kind, and they are marked out as "woe trumpets." A proclamation comes before them, announcing ahead of time the solemn and dreadful weight they carry...
The shift is one of target, not only of severity.
Notice that the first four trumpet judgments dealt mainly with the circumstances of life, pictured by the trees, the rivers, the sun, moon, and stars. The last three trumpet judgments are far more severe and terrible, because, as we shall see, they fall on people themselves rather than on their circumstances. They bring woe to that special group called the dwellers on the earth — those who, like Cain, go out from the presence of the Lord and try to build a world without God.
The woe now declared past was the locust torment of verses 1–11. Commentators read its damage as inward rather than bodily.
The plague that the followers of Apollyon, "the destroyer," bring is not physical but moral. The locusts leave a spiritual desert behind them, and the scorpions torment the heart and conscience, but they destroy no physical life. This hellish swarm harms only the unbelieving Israelites, and its time is limited too, as the five months show.
This short line also marks structure. With the matching notice in Revelation 11:14, it brackets a long stretch of the vision as an inserted scene.
Notice that in Rev. 9:12 we are told the first woe has passed and two more are still to come. Then the sixth angel sounds, and we get the description of the horsemen from the Euphrates. But not until Rev. 11:14 are we told that the second woe has passed, which clearly points back to those same horsemen in Rev. 9. So the whole scene — the mighty angel coming down from heaven, the little book that John takes and eats, the temple and worshippers measured, the court and city given up for forty-two months, the two witnesses with their testimony, death, resurrection and ascension — all of this forms part of the striking episode.
"Two woes are still to come" is not a promise of relief.
So far, the sad results of each blast have been worse than those of the one before. Each one lays bare the hand of God more clearly and declares that He is at work. The coming trumpet will be the same.
There is no gap. The very next verse has the sixth angel sounding, and the voice that starts the second woe comes from the altar itself.
The golden altar is the one mentioned in Rev. 8:3, the altar of incense. The voice that comes from its four horns is, without doubt, the voice of God Himself. Because it comes from the four horns, it means that all the strength of the altar — a horn is a symbol of power — stands against the targets of the woe that follows... All that God is stands for His people who come to Him through Christ. But all that God is stands against His enemies, and men see it when He makes His judgments fall on the earth.
Announcing the remaining woes before they fall fits how God deals with people generally.
God always warns before He judges. He is giving you your warning tonight, friend. You will do well to be wiser than Belshazzar. He had his warning, but he did not listen to it; still, he had it. If he had listened, I think it might have ended differently for him, because God, although He does judge, loves mercy. Scripture calls judgment "His strange work" (Isa. 28:21). He loves mercy, He loves blessing. He loves to bless the soul.
- Counted. Scripture marks the last three trumpets as "woes," announces them ahead of time, and now calls the first one finished.
- Aimed. The earlier trumpets damaged the surroundings of life; the woes fall on people themselves — on those who try to build a world without God.
- Ordered. The notices in 9:12 and 11:14 bracket a long inserted scene: the angel, the little book, the two witnesses. The woes come one after another.
- Escalating. Each blast has been worse than the one before, and "two woes are still to come" points the same direction.
- Merciful in warning. God tells what is coming before it comes; the warning is real mercy to anyone who will heed it.
And the sixth angel sounded [his] trumpet and I heard a voice from the four horns of the golden altar which [is] before God,
The sixth trumpet sounds, and a voice speaks from the golden altar in heaven. What it commands is not mercy but the release of judgment on the earth.
Nothing here breaks loose on its own. A word from God's presence calls the angel out, and the same control runs through every trumpet.
A voice from the golden altar before God calls forth the sixth angel, or second woe judgment. This again reminds us that heaven directs all these judgments, and that God holds back evil in its full force until the moment for judgment has come.
Israel's tabernacle had two altars. One stood outside in the court for the sacrifices; the golden one stood inside for the incense. The inner altar drew its whole value from the outer.
In the tabernacle of old there were two altars. One stood outside in the court; the other inside in the holy place. … Now the golden altar derived its force and value from the brazen altar. Incense (the merits of Christ) burned on the golden altar every morning and evening, except on the yearly day of atonement. On that special day in the history of Israel, as on other occasions, the blood of the sacrificial animals was put on its four golden horns.
That inner altar is the altar of intercession. The voice from it shows what Christ is doing while He stays out of sight.
The angel sounds at the summons of Christ. The Lord is still hidden; but He is already occupied with the earth, where He has a people for whom He is interceding. (Compare Isaiah 30:18.) A voice is heard from the four horns of the golden altar, or the altar of incense (Exodus 40:26-27), from the altar of intercession. … The intercession does not apply to the moral condition or to the spiritual conflicts of those who profit by them. It applies to the display of God's judgments, which will in time bring about the deliverance of an earthly people.
The voice comes out of the altar's horns. A horn stands for power.
The golden altar is the one mentioned in Revelation 8:3, the altar of incense. The voice that comes from its four horns is, without doubt, that of God Himself. Coming out from the four horns, it will mean that all the strength of the altar (a horn is a symbol of power) is against the objects of the coming woe… All that God is, is in favour of His people who approach Him through Christ; but all that God is, is against His adversaries, and He shows it when He causes His judgments to fall upon the earth.
The verse says this altar stands before God. One writer ties that place to the prayers offered there earlier, and to the timing of the judgment.
"The golden altar" is the altar of incense, or intercession. It stood before the throne of grace, the mercy seat, with only the veil between. In the picture it is the same place where the angel offered up the prayers of the saints. It is from the horns of this altar, showing that it is in answer to the prayers, that the command to loose the angels in the river Euphrates goes out. This surely shows that the fulfilment primarily in view is future. … No saint could ever have desired such a scourge. Nor could the prayers of the saints in the present age ever have taken such a form. But when Christ is judging the earth, and the saints cry to God to avenge them of their enemies, such a scourge fits their requests exactly, and may be let loose in answer to them.
Commentators differ here. Another writer ties the horns not to prayer but to the blood of atonement, and so to guilt.
The horns had no special connection with the offering of incense. They were for the blood of atonement. That blood was put on them either to make atonement for the altar itself, or for the sin of the high priest or of the congregation of Israel. A voice of judgment from these horns … is so different from the usual pleading on behalf of the sinner. It speaks of the altar being defiled, or of guilt for which no atonement could be found.
Whatever the exact force of the horns, the shock stands: an order to slay comes out of the very furniture of mercy.
It is the voice of the Lord, no doubt, that is heard from the horns of the golden altar. But what a solemn sound this is — above all, coming from there? For ordinarily that altar is the special witness of His all-prevailing intercession. From there the incense rose up before God.
- Altar — the golden altar stands inside for incense, and it drew all its value from the blood shed at the altar outside.
- Intercession — Christ is still hidden, and He intercedes at that same altar. Here His intercession takes the form of judgment that will deliver an earthly people.
- Horns — a horn means power. All the strength of the altar now stands against God's adversaries, as all of it stands for those who come to Him through Christ.
- Answer — the command comes from the place where prayer went up, so the fulfilment in view is future. Commentators differ: others read the horns as blood and guilt.
- Restraint — the angel sounds only at heaven's summons. Evil in its full force stays chained until God gives the word.
saying to the sixth angel that had the trumpet, Loose the four angels which are bound at the great river Euphrates.
The sixth trumpet opens with a command, not with a blast of destruction. That command comes from the golden altar, the place of prayer. A voice tells the trumpet angel to release four angels held at the Euphrates. Who are these bound angels? Why that river? And why does the order for judgment come from the place of prayer?
Earlier in the vision, an angel offered the prayers of God's people at this same altar. Where the order comes from shapes how one writer dates the whole scene:
"The golden altar" is the altar of incense, the altar of intercession. It stood before the throne of grace, the mercy seat, with the veil between. In the picture it is the same place where the angel offered up the prayers of the saints. The command to loose the angels in the river Euphrates comes from the horns of this altar, which marks it as an answer to the prayers. That surely shows the fulfilment mainly in view is future… No saint could ever have wanted such a scourge. The prayers of saints in the present age could never have taken such a form. But when Christ is judging the earth, and the saints cry to God to avenge them on their enemies, such a scourge may fittingly be let loose in answer to their requests.
The voice comes from the four horns of the altar, not from the altar itself. Both details carry weight:
"Four" expresses universality. "Horn" denotes power. God's answer to the mingled prayers and incense that gathered around this altar puts forth the whole strength and power of the altar of intercession.
Commentators differ here. Another writer doubts this is an answer to prayer at all. He points to what the horns were used for:
The horns had no special link with the offering of incense. They were for the blood of atonement, which the priest put on them either to make atonement for the altar itself, or for the sin of the high priest or of the people of Israel. A voice of judgment from these horns… is so different from the usual pleading on behalf of the sinner. It speaks of a profaned altar, or of guilt for which no atonement could be found.
Earlier in the book, four angels hold back the winds of judgment. These four are not those angels:
The Lord first gives the word, and gives it to the holy angel. That angel then looses the four bound at the Euphrates. Evil can only act when and as far as the good allow. Some identify these four with the angels who held back the winds in Revelation 7. That idea is strange, because the contrast stands out, not the likeness. Here they are not restraining but restrained, which is nowhere said of the holy angels. There they stood at the four corners of the earth, as separate as they could be; here all are bound in the same spot.
Whatever these four are, they are not free. They wait — and the waiting has a reason:
These angelic ministers of judgment are under divine control; they cannot act without express command. The very hour when the Lord would deal in just retribution with the peoples who had turned away from Him… is noted with care, for that hour the angels were ready. We are not told what kept these angelic servants of God's providence from acting earlier. The hour of vengeance in the prophetic plan had not arrived.
The river is not named at random. It marks a border between two worlds:
Revelation names the Euphrates as the place where four angels are, or will be, bound. They will be loosed at the sixth trumpet. That lets loose the Eastern forms of satanic wickedness held in check until then. Viewing Palestine as the centre of God's dealings with the earth, the Euphrates was the barrier between East and West.
The previous woe tormented; this one kills. Yet even the killing runs on a clock set in heaven:
This time it is not the priest's offering of incense with the prayers of saints. This time a voice of divine authority comes from the altar. It commands the loosing of the four angels that had been bound in the Euphrates. They were ready to bring death upon men — not torment now, but death… This woe is limited, not merely to the day but even to the hour when it is carried out.
- Ordered. The command starts at the altar of incense, the place of prayer. Judgment begins with a word from God, not with the angels.
- Answered. One writer reads the voice as God's answer to the cries of suffering saints. Such a prayer belongs to the time when Christ judges the earth, not to now.
- Bound. These four are restrained, not restraining. They are the opposite of the angels who hold back the winds earlier in the book.
- Released. Evil moves only when God permits it, and only at the hour already fixed. The set time had not yet come.
- Limited. Loosed at the great river between East and West, this woe kills. Yet God measures it to the very hour.
And the four angels were loosed, who are prepared for the hour and day and month and year, that they might slay the third part of men;
The sixth trumpet does not bring a new evil into the world; it releases one that was already there, tied up at the Euphrates and waiting. This verse raises three questions: what held it back, why it is loosed now, and what "a third of mankind" means.
Older translations read "for an hour, and a day, and a month, and a year." That wording led readers to calculate how long the woe would last. One commentator corrects the wording and the sums built on it:
The destroying army was prepared beforehand, but held back until this time. The four angels were loosed, and they were prepared not "for an hour," but for the hour, and day, and month, and year, to kill the third part of men. Some have made clever calculations on the theory that in prophecy each day stands for a year. They try to show how long this woe lasted, and to fit it to recorded events in history. But "the hour, and day, and month, and year" do not mean how long the woe lasts. They mark the time when it begins. The outbreak of this woe had been fixed even to the very hour when it was to start.
If the hour was fixed, something was keeping the angels back before it struck. Scripture does not say what, but it does say why the hour has now come:
These angels who carry out judgment are under God's control. They cannot act without a direct command. The very hour is marked out when the Lord, in just retribution, would deal with the peoples of the revived Latin empire who had abandoned the faith. For that hour the angels were prepared. We are not told what held these servants of God's providence back earlier. In the plan of prophecy, the hour of vengeance had not yet come. The sin of the empire had not yet risen to the height Scripture foretold. Now it has, and judgment, sharp and overwhelming, can wait no longer.
Four angels appear earlier in Revelation, holding back the winds. These four are their opposite, and the contrast shows where control lies:
The angel again looses the four bound at the Euphrates. The evil can act only when the good allow it, and only as far as they allow. And the good, however much they may excel in strength, only do His commandments, listening to the voice of His word. It is strange to think that these four are the same as the angels who held back the winds in Revelation 7. What stands out is the contrast, not the likeness. Here they are not restraining but restrained, and that is never said of the holy angels. There they stood at the four corners of the earth, as far apart as they could be. Here all are bound in the same spot.
Writers take "a third of mankind" as a sphere rather than a bare fraction. One ties the phrase to a region named elsewhere in Revelation:
The first woe fell upon those in Israel who were not sealed. Scripture says this second woe falls upon "the third part of men." That expression is used in Revelation 12:4 for the sphere of the Roman Empire, which would take in professing Christendom.
One writer takes the killing here as more than the end of physical life:
The killing of the third of men does not mean the end of physical life only. It means the destruction of every confession of relationship with the only true God. What a dreadful picture of people who had once received the gospel, at least in name, and who stood out as God's church on earth!
A verse about slaughter turns out to be a verse about God's steady hand:
Notice also that God has fixed the exact time of this "woe." The angels are prepared for the hour, day, month, and year. What striking proof that God always holds the reins of governments in His own hand, and that man can do nothing without His permission! How calmly then the believer may rest at all times!
- Bound. These four angels are restrained, not restraining. Unlike the angels of Revelation 7, they show that evil acts only as far as the good allows.
- Timed. The four units of time mark when the woe starts, not how long it lasts. Day-for-a-year calculations miss the point.
- Delayed. Scripture does not say what held them back. It says only that the appointed hour had not come, and the empire's sin had not yet reached the height Scripture foretold.
- Loosed. The reach is "a third of mankind" — the sphere of the Roman Empire, which takes in professing Christendom.
- Result. The death is more than physical. It is the loss of all confession of relationship with the only true God. And because the same hand fixes every hour, the believer can rest.
and the number of the hosts of horse [was] twice ten thousand times ten thousand. I heard their number.
Under the sixth trumpet the sixth angel looses four angels held at the Euphrates river. What follows is an army so vast that no one counts it — John simply hears its number. The number raises two questions at once: what does such a figure mean, and who is holding the reins of a force that big?
One writer gives the arithmetic, and also the direction the invasion takes:
A voice from the horns of the golden altar tells the sixth angel to loose the four angels held at the Euphrates. As a result a countless company of horsemen is set free. (Greek: twice ten thousand times ten thousand, that is, 200 million. The number points to the immense, countless hordes.) ... This river was both the boundary line of the old Roman Empire and the land of Israel. Forces had held back the flood of nations on the far side of the river. That restraint is now removed, so a great invasion takes place. Since the land of Israel is nearest, it will suffer first, but the revived Roman Empire is the target of these invading hordes.
The figure is too big to picture. Yet Scripture uses the same scale for God's own unseen forces:
This immense host is a number too vast for the human mind to take in. The mind is bewildered when it tries to grasp such an army. In number it goes far beyond anything ever seen on earth. God's unseen chariots are numbered in the same way (Ps. 68:17). May this lesson be written on our hearts: the seen and unseen powers of good and evil are all under the direct control of God.
The word is plural — hosts, not one host. The same writer draws a conclusion from that:
It is not one army, but "armies," not a host, but "hosts." The plural is used rather than the singular because more than one invasion of the Beast's territory from beyond the Euphrates will be attempted, and will succeed.
Commentators differ here. Several read the number as a picture of scale rather than a headcount:
The crowd of horsemen is given as the huge number of 200,000,000. This is clearly not a literal number. It shows the huge size of the armies used.
Others are slow to dismiss the figure, because John does not only see the host. He hears how many there are:
At the same time as these angels are loosed, that river is to be dried up "to prepare the way for the kings from the east." An army of 200,000,000 horsemen will then pour into Palestine, most likely meaning to invade and conquer Europe. We question whether the number given for this amazing army is only symbolic, for John says, "I heard their number."
A third reading takes the horsemen as a picture of spiritual ruin rather than battlefield slaughter:
The symbol of a mighty army of horsemen points to some unstoppable delusion of the devil. "Their power in their mouth" may show that this delusion will come with all the persuasive power of speech. ... As a result a third of mankind are killed. This probably does not mean physical death. It means that men are led into all the misery of apostasy — moral death to God.
However the number is read, the army is not out of control:
The immense host, 200,000,000 in number, is completely in the hand of a Master. Its time, its work and its limit are measured out by eternal Wisdom, so that evil at its fullest development is servant to the good. The number is given special emphasis: "I heard their number." And yet it seems impossible for it to be literal, unless we take it, as some would, as describing angelic hosts — where, of course, all our reasoning is lost.
after-note: DELETE
One writer turns the scene straight on the person reading:
And a vast army of horsemen, a terrible display of human power and strength, pours in from the east across the scene of prophecy. ... And, my reader, if you are not caught up to meet Christ and be for ever with the Lord, you may see all this, and feel it in your own terrified soul!
- Counted. John hears the count: 200 million — a number beyond anything ever seen on earth.
- Controlled. God numbers His own unseen chariots the same way; both good and evil powers move under His direct control.
- Contracted. The host has its hour, its work and its limit already measured out. Evil at full strength still serves good ends.
- Contested. Commentators differ. The number may be literal, a symbol of vast scale, or a picture of a delusion that brings moral death.
- Coming. The scene is still future. The call is to be caught up to meet Christ before it arrives.
And thus I saw the horses in the vision, and those that sat upon them, having breastplates of fire and jacinth and brimstone; and the heads of the horses [were] as heads of lions, and out of their mouths goes out fire and smoke and brimstone.
Revelation 9:17 gives John's close-up of the army released at the sixth trumpet. He describes the horses and their riders: their armour, their faces, and what pours from their mouths — and every detail carries a meaning about the judgment and about who directs it.
John says he saw the horses "in my vision." Commentators read the whole description as picture-language for forces at work, not as a battlefield report.
The description of the horsemen and the horses must be symbolic. The horsemen had breastplates of fire, and of jacinth and brimstone, speaking of satanic energy and power and direction. The horses are one with their riders, for out of their mouths went fire and smoke and brimstone, and by these spiritual poison gases men were killed.
The armour itself explains why this trumpet counts as a woe. Commentators also say where the blow lands.
It is indeed a woe. A breastplate is normally a piece of armour that is wholly defensive. But these are of fire and jacinth and brimstone, so they bear an offensive character… This woe falls on the Gentile nations and the proud Roman Empire, which in its revived form will be the dominant political power on the earth in the last days.
Older translations say "jacinth" and "brimstone" where the ESV has "sapphire" and "sulfur." Jacinth names a colour.
The Greek word here means hyacinth, and as a colour that is a deep purple. In Rev. 9:17 the horsemen had breastplates of fire, jacinth, and brimstone, which seem to imply flashes of coloured light.
The creature changes from the last woe, and with it the character of the judgment.
In the previous Woe we had locust and scorpion together, which stood for destruction and agony. Here horses take the lead — the aggressive and military agents of plunder and slaughter. Their heads "as heads of lions" give this army a certain majesty, courage, and boldness — the well-known marks of "the king of the forest."
Commentators trace both the armour and the weapons back to one source.
These military expeditions are under Satan's direction. Out of the pit he supplies his agents with a defensive armour that no weapon of war can overcome. Here he arms the host with three offensive, destructive forces. Under that empire Christ was crucified, Jerusalem destroyed, and the Jews scattered. Its people are to suffer on earth, as far as men can, the agonies and torments of the lake of fire. Fire and brimstone are the symbols of unimaginable anguish (Rev. 14:10; Rev. 19:20; Rev. 21:8). With them comes "smoke," the moral darkness and delusion of the pit.
The mouth is what separates this woe from the one before it, where the sting was only in the tail.
Here the "mouth" stands out, and not their tails only as in the locust judgment… Their breastplates are not as iron but of fire and jacinth and brimstone, carrying the very character of the lake of fire.
The order of the description points to where the real power lies.
The horses appear to matter most, and the text dwells on them, though it describes their riders first — and only "breastplates of fire and hyacinth and brimstone." These match the "fire and smoke and brimstone" out of the horses' mouths. They are instruments of divine judgment, and that makes them invincible while they carry out their work. The horses have heads like lions; destruction comes with an open front — the judgment of God. So the human hands that direct it matter less: divine wrath is sure to find those who will carry it out.
To the watching world this will look like nothing more than politics and armies.
Unbelief will discover nothing in it apart from man; but faith will connect all with God.
These weapons kill in two ways at once.
Fire and brimstone are the extreme form of judgment, the symbols of eternal punishment. Smoke, with its darkening power, works alongside them. These are the instruments of destruction… There is not only moral death, but physical. Vast destruction of life marks this woe, along with Satanic poison poured into souls. The wise will understand the details when it happens; for now we can only see them in outline.
- Vision. John saw the horses "in my vision." The riders, armour and colours are symbols of energy, power and direction, not a literal cavalry.
- Armour. Fire, jacinth and brimstone turn defensive gear into a weapon. Jacinth is a deep purple, so the breastplates flash with coloured light.
- Terror. Lion heads give the army majesty and boldness. Fire, smoke and brimstone from the mouths make men taste on earth, as far as men can, what the lake of fire means.
- Master. The riders are invincible only while their work lasts. They are instruments of divine judgment, and the human hands directing them matter less than the hand above them.
- Sight. Unbelief will see only human causes in this woe; faith traces the whole of it back to God.
By these three plagues were the third part of men killed, by the fire and the smoke and the brimstone which goes out of their mouths.
Under the sixth trumpet, three plagues come out of the mouths of the horses, and a third of mankind falls. Two questions follow: what do the fire, smoke and sulfur stand for — older translations say "brimstone" — and is this killing of the body or of the soul?
Walter Scott points out that the verse names the three plagues twice. Both times they come out of the horses' mouths.
The fire, smoke, and brimstone are separate plagues, but here they work together in the slaughter. Satan's judicial power inflicts the death that the mass are doomed to, and that makes it more dreadful than a sudden death by the sword. This is not simply human slaughter by the scientific methods of warfare, ancient or modern. The destructive forces of the pit are let loose on a "third part of men" who are killed. They are probably the worst in the empire, since a remnant is spared (v. 20) who still do not repent. Twice the three plagues are named, and twice as going out of the mouths of the horses. That repeated mention presses home two things. Satan's judicial power is at work. And the agents are not mere hired soldiers: Satan energises them, and they delight to kill. "Out of their mouths" shows the heart's diabolic pleasure in the work.
Fire, brimstone and smoke each do their own work in this picture.
Fire and brimstone are the extreme form of judgment and the symbols of eternal punishment. Smoke has a darkening power. All three are the instruments of destruction... There is not only moral death, but physical. Vast destruction of life, besides Satanic poison poured into souls, marks this woe. The wise will understand its details when it happens; for now we can only gather them in outline.
The first woe brought torment. William Kelly marks what changes in this one.
As to the character of the second woe itself, it is not torment like the first, but destruction of life. ... It is the judicial power of Satan, as far as God permits that. It also goes far beyond the earlier woe in energy and in aggressive, destructive warfare.
Commentators differ on what this death is. Baines reads both a moral and a physical ruin. Hamilton Smith reads it mainly as men cut off from God while still alive.
The symbol of a mighty army of horsemen points to some irresistible delusion of the devil. "Their power in their mouth" may mean that this delusion will come with all the persuasive eloquence of speech. But behind the delusion is the power of Satan, symbolised by their tails being like serpents. The result is that a third part of men are killed. This probably sets out not physical death, but men led into all the misery of apostasy — moral death to God.
The blow does not fall on everyone. F. B. Hole notes that "the third part of men" has appeared before in these judgments.
The "third part of men" appears again here, so we gather this woe from the east falls especially on what we have called the Roman earth. ... If the earlier woe applied more to the apostates of Israel who were not sealed, this one falls rather on the Gentile nations and the proud Roman Empire. In its revived form that empire will be the dominant political power on the earth in the last days.
Terrifying as this army is, its time and its limits are fixed.
The immense hosts, two hundred million in number, are perfectly in the hand of a Master. Eternal Wisdom has carefully apportioned their time, their work and their limit. Evil at its fullest development is a servant to the good... The riders' breastplates of fire and hyacinth and brimstone answer to the "fire and smoke and brimstone" out of the horses' mouths. They stand for divine judgment, of which these hosts are the instruments, and that judgment makes them invincible while their work is done. The horses have heads like lions. Destruction comes with an open front — the judgment of God. So the human hands that direct it matter less: divine wrath is sure to find its executioners.
- Ordered — the two hundred million are "perfectly in the hand of a Master." Eternal Wisdom measures out their time, work and limit. Even evil at full strength is "a servant to the good."
- Limited — the stroke falls on "the third part": the Roman earth and the Gentile nations, not the whole globe.
- Satanic — the plagues come out of the horses' mouths. The agents are "energised by Satan" and "delight to kill." Behind the army stands a delusion, not just an invasion.
- Deadly — fire and brimstone are the extreme form of judgment and the symbols of eternal punishment, and smoke darkens. Commentators differ over whether the killing is physical, moral, or both.
- Unrepentant — a remnant is spared, and still does not repent. Judgment this heavy does not soften a heart that will not turn.
For the power of the horses is in their mouth and in their tails for their tails [are] like serpents, having heads, and with them they injure.
The sixth trumpet has released a huge army of horsemen, and this verse shows where their power to kill lies — in their mouths, and also in their tails. Two questions follow: why name two sources of harm, and what does a serpent-shaped tail with a head on it mean?
The verse names two sources of harm, and the wording itself carries meaning. Older translations read mouth in the singular here, where the ESV has mouths, and one writer builds his point on that singular:
Notice that mouth here is singular, though the word appeared twice just before as a plural, and that tails is plural. Mouth and tails, singular and plural, would say that one spirit drives them all, but that the teachings and lies of Satan are many and varied. "The power of the horses is in their mouth and in their tails." There is not only the open power of Satan, but in addition his secret, malicious and soul-destroying influence. Both are in view here. In the previous woe the power to injure was in the tail (v. 10). Here the power to destroy is in the mouth and tails (v. 19). There he is the liar. Here he is both murderer and liar.
The same writer treats the opening clause as a hinge, not a fresh statement. Verses 17 and 18 already described the mouth, so this clause carries the reader on to something worse:
The clause that puts the power in their mouth serves only as a link to what is still to be said about their tails. What comes out of the mouth of the horses did not show enough of their harmful and dreadfully destructive drive. That drive takes further shape in the symbol of the serpent — tails.
The serpent has its own history in Scripture, and that is the shape given to the tails:
"Tails like serpents." The serpent was the creature the devil chose to hide in when he deceived Eve (Gen. 3:1). It is probably the only creature in the animal world condemned to stay degraded for ever, even during the long, worldwide blessing of the millennial days (compare Gen. 3:14 with Isa. 65:25). The serpent is another word for craft, deceit, trickery and cunning. The "tail" of the serpent expresses malignant influence, falsehood, mischief (Isa. 9:15; Rev. 12:4).
The tails also have heads, and that detail is not decoration:
Further, the tails have "heads," showing that something intelligent directs this harmful influence. It pursues its purpose to injure with relentless, intelligent activity.
Another writer reads the heads as harmful teaching gathered into one power:
They killed by what they proclaimed, wherever it reached. It cost people their lives. They also had harmful teachings. Those teachings formed one power by which they did harm on the earth — they had heads on their tails.
Chapter 9 describes two woes, and the tails are the point of comparison between them. The first brought torment; this one brings something heavier:
As for the character of the second woe itself: it is not torment like the first, but destruction of life… That is, they spread poisonous error and left it behind them, and they did this with a more settled plan than in the locust-woe. The locusts in the first woe had scorpion-like tails and stings. The horses in the second had serpent-like tails, and those tails had heads. But they had power in their mouth also… It is the judicial power of Satan, as far as God permits that.
Two forces run together here, and the survivors are no better off:
God's judgment comes first in this punishment, but Satan's power is in it too. The horses' tails are like serpents, and have heads, and with these they do hurt. Poisonous falsehood marks this time, when men are given up to believe a lie. Death, physical and spiritual, work together, and the destruction is terrible. But those who escape are not delivered from their sins.
Commentators differ over the killing of a third of mankind. Some see real death; the next writer sees ruined souls instead:
"Their power in their mouth" may show that this delusion will come with all the persuasive eloquence of speech. But behind the delusion is the power of Satan, pictured by their tails being like serpents. As a result the third part of men are killed. This probably does not mean physical death. It means that men are led into all the misery of falling away from God, or moral death to God.
- Two weapons. Power sits in the mouth and in the tails — open force in front, poison left behind.
- One spirit, many lies. One mouth but many tails — one spirit drives them all, and its lies take many forms.
- Serpent shape. The tail borrowed from the serpent stands for craft, falsehood and soul-destroying influence.
- Heads that aim. Heads on the tails mean a mind aims the harm; it is not scattered at random.
- Death and delusion together. Judgment from God and the power of Satan run side by side, and the survivors are left unrepentant.
And the rest of men who were not killed with these plagues repented not of the works of their hands, that they should not worship demons, and the golden and silver and brazen and stone and wooden idols, which can neither see nor hear nor walk.
The plagues of the sixth trumpet have killed a third of mankind. This verse turns to the survivors, and the shock is not the plague but their answer to it: they keep bowing to gods they made with their own hands.
This verse stands at the end of a long chain of blows. It measures their effect on the human heart, and that effect is nothing.
A humbling lesson, and one we need to remember! God has been sending judgment upon judgment. First He struck men's circumstances, then the men themselves — in this last case torment, and finally death itself. But it is in vain. Such is man after all this, that he repents not of his evil, either religiously or morally. Satan's last effort remains.
This is not a one-off. One writer traces the same pattern from Egypt through to the judgments still to come.
We never find that God's dealings in judgment produce reformation. In Egypt God dealt with Pharaoh, making His blows harsher and harsher. Did that soften his heart? No, it hardened it. Of judgment still to come, Revelation 16:11 tells us more. Men will curse the God of heaven because of their pains and their sores, and will not repent of their deeds.
The phrase is not a general description of human effort. It carries a settled meaning.
"The works of their hands," of which they did not repent, is a phrase peculiar to heathen idolatry (Isaiah 2:8; Jeremiah 1:16; Psalm 115:4-7).
How could educated modern nations ever end up there? One writer says the drift is already under way.
Here and elsewhere we learn a humbling truth. What "the progress of the age" is drifting towards, in the end, is the setting up of idolatry, in some shape or other, among the civilized nations of the earth. No doubt it will take some plausible and intellectual form, appealing to natural religious feelings, as it always does in its early stages. But God simply classes it with other heathen abominations.
The verse names two objects of worship, and commentators keep them apart. (Older translations read "devils" where the ESV has "demons.")
"That they should not worship demons," not "devils" as older translations have it. Demon worship here is different from the worship of lifeless idols made of various materials. Demons are living spiritual beings who dread a judgment to come (Matthew 8:28-29). The abyss is their proper home (Luke 8:31). They are a class of wicked spirits (Revelation 16:14). Satan is their leader, "the angel of the abyss" (Revelation 9:11). In the lands called Christian, people will yet practise, openly and everywhere, the Gentile idolatry Paul condemned so sternly (1 Corinthians 10:20-21).
The verse ends by listing what the idols cannot do. The point of that list is what it does to the worshipper.
What were they, these idol-images? Simply matter — silver and gold — shaped by men's hands! Mouth and eyes are there all right... But the idol gives no response to his worshipper by word or look. He takes in nothing. He does not hear the voice that cries to him. He does not smell the incense or the sacrifice. He can stretch out no hand to help, and no foot of his will stir to bring relief. What can these senseless deities do but degrade the men who bow before them into beings as senseless?
The materials listed run from gold down to wood, and the list is read as covering the whole of society. Verse 20 gives their religion; the crimes of verse 21 follow from it.
Idolatry has taken over the whole scene. The rich have their gods of gold and silver. The middle class have theirs of brass and stone. The poor have their own as well: idols of wood. The worship and the conduct of the worshippers must always match. If people give up God, who is light and love, for Satan, a murderer and a liar, Satan stamps his own character on his followers and worshippers. Verse 20 gives their religion; verse 21 shows their deeds.
One writer draws the line from this verse to our own day.
We must not think that demon activity has stopped. The call is: "Do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God." 1 John 4:1. This agrees with the statement that "in later times some will depart from the faith by devoting themselves to deceitful spirits and teachings of demons." 1 Timothy 4:1... The world and the professing church are plainly ripening for these things.
- Plague — Judgment falls again and again, first on people's circumstances, then on the people themselves. It produces no repentance. Scripture never shows God's blows reforming anyone.
- Survivors — "The rest" are the ones the plagues leave alive. They see the judgment fall and still will not turn.
- Religion — What they will not give up is "the works of their hands," a phrase the prophets keep for idolatry. Gold, silver, bronze, stone, wood — one for every class of society.
- Reality — Behind the lifeless images stand living spirits. Their home is the abyss and their leader is Satan. The worshipper takes on the character of what he worships.
- Result — Verse 20 gives their religion, verse 21 their deeds. The same drift runs on today, so the call to test the spirits still stands.
And they repented not of their murders, nor of their witchcrafts, nor of their fornication, nor of their thefts.
Plagues have just swept away huge numbers of people. This closing line records what the survivors still refused to give up, and forces one question: why did suffering on that scale change nothing?
Idolatry runs through every level of this society, from the rich to the poor.
The whole scene is given over to idolatry. The rich have their gods of gold and silver. The middle class have theirs of brass and stone. Even the poor have their idols, made of wood. The kind of worship and the behaviour of the worshippers must always match. reason
The word translated "sorceries" is not the usual New Testament word for magic.
Revelation uses another word for sorceries: pharmakeia. It refers to drugs — "to stupefy with drugs" — and then to any system of sorcery by spells... Sorcery ranks with the grossest of sins, and the same word describes the professing church in mystical Babylon. Galatians 5:20 translates it "witchcraft."
The last of the four crimes is theft. One commentator traces what happens once every restraint is gone. (Where older translations read "fornication," the ESV has "sexual immorality.")
"Thefts." The bonds of society are loosened. All mutual respect for each other's rights is completely gone, even in the most sacred relationship. What follows? Greed will lure on the mass of men "not killed" to enrich themselves at the expense of society. "Each one for himself" is the order and motto of these coming days. Some respect for property and for other people's goods may still exist, but theft will be part of the settled life and history of these terrible times. A world without God, given up judicially by Him, and Satan received as its prince and ruler!
The words "did not repent" close both verses. Kelly draws the lesson from the whole run of judgments behind them.
"The rest of mankind, who were not killed by these plagues, did not repent," and so on. A humbling lesson, and one we most need to remember! God has been sending judgment after judgment. First on men's circumstances, then on the men themselves — torment in this case, and at last death itself. But it is in vain. After all this, man is still what he is: he does not repent of his evil, in religion or in morals. Satan's last effort remains.
This collapse does not belong to a backward age. It comes at the peak of everything men count as progress.
Notice, too, the awful moral condition that will characterise the people of this day. God is refused, idols are accepted in His place; all ties between man and man are broken, and the flesh runs riot in every kind of abominable sin. And this is the outcome of modern progress and civilisation! This is what perfected methods of education produce, and enlightened laws meant to improve government and reform society! Remember, this revived Roman empire, where this "woe" falls, is the expression of man's highest ideal — the outcome of all his striving to perfect the human race. Look at the result!
The chapter ends in flat refusal. What God does next matters.
The close of Revelation 9 showed us rebellious men whose depravity and self-will could hardly go further. Chapter 10 opens with a vision of an Angel of unusual majesty and glory. He announces a speedy end to God's mysterious dealings with the earth. So before the final blow falls, God in His mercy gives solemn and ample warning.
- Repent — the missing word. The word closes both verses. Verse 20 names what they kept in worship; verse 21 names what they kept in daily life.
- Worship shapes conduct. Give up God, Who is light and love, for a murderer and a liar, and you take on the character of what you worship.
- Sorceries means drugs. The word is pharmakeia. It means to stupefy with drugs, and then any system of sorcery by spells. Elsewhere the same word appears as "witchcraft."
- Judgment cannot soften. Blows to circumstances, then torment, then death itself — all fall in vain. Judgment shows what man is; it does not change him.
- Warning still follows. Even after this refusal, the next chapter opens with an announcement. God gives full warning in mercy before the final blow.
And I saw another strong angel coming down out of the heaven, clothed with a cloud, and the rainbow upon his head, and his countenance as the sun, and his feet as pillars of fire,
Revelation 10 breaks into the series of trumpet judgments like light through storm clouds. The first question every reader asks is who this "mighty angel" is, and the details of his appearance answer it.
This chapter pauses the trumpet judgments. The vision comes at the darkest moment.
Things are drawing to a close. The half-week of sorrow (three and a half years) is nearly over. Its last hours show the world in mad, open rebellion against God. They also show His saints, on whom the Beast and the Antichrist pour out their fury. But before the Gentile and Jewish apostates and those they have fooled drink the last dregs of the Lord's vengeance, this comforting vision breaks through the dark clouds of judgment. It is a stern reminder to the world. Despite the rage of the wicked, the government of the earth is the Creator's just claim, and He is about to make that claim good in power. The vision is also well fitted to strengthen and comfort believers, especially suffering saints. The same power that will crush the enemy lifts the sufferers to honour.
The description itself gives the answer.
This is the personal description of this mighty angel. Several of its details point us to the Lord Jesus Christ Himself. He is clothed with a cloud. A cloud is often connected with the divine presence, and so with our Lord... On the mount of transfiguration a cloud overshadowed both Him and His disciples (Matt. 17; Luke 9); and when He ascended up into heaven a cloud received Him out of the sight of His own (Acts 1)... In Revelation 4 the rainbow is around the divine throne; here it is on the angel's head. The rainbow is the symbol of God's everlasting covenant with the earth (Genesis 9:12-13). None, therefore, but a Divine Person could wear the rainbow on His head. The last two features, the face like the sun and the feet like pillars of fire, are almost exactly the same as those given in Revelation 1:15-16. There can be no doubt, then, that this mighty angel is Christ.
An earlier chapter also spoke of a "strong angel." The shared word can mislead.
"Another strong angel" takes our thoughts back to Revelation 5:2. The only thing the two have in common is the word "strong." The earlier text speaks of a created being given great might. This passage shows us an uncreated Being of divine majesty and power. It is the Lord Himself. We have had already a vision of the Lord in angelic, priestly intercession (Rev. 8:3); here He asserts in angelic power His undisputed claim to the dominion of the earth.
Each feature says something about the One who wears it and about what He comes to do. Older translations read "feet" where the ESV has "legs."
A mighty angel comes down out of heaven, the source of His action. He is clothed with a cloud, the special sign of Jehovah's majesty (Isa. 19:1). None but He has the right to come clothed like that. Further, the rainbow is on His head. He occupies Himself with divine mercy toward the creation. It is no longer a matter of the rainbow around the throne. Here a further step is taken. He approaches the earth. He asserts His undeniable claim to all creation, because it is His by right. "And His face was as the sun," with supreme authority; "and His feet as pillars of fire," with firmness of divine judgment.
If this is Christ, why does John see Him in an angel's form at all? The answer lies in the timing.
The tenth chapter clearly shows that Christ is soon to assert His own rights in the earth. He will declare that He is the only Potentate, the King of kings and Lord of lords... John saw a mighty angel standing for Christ in this way because the time for Christ's actual return had not yet come. The vision surely tells us this: however hardened, unbelieving and unrepentant men may be, Christ is Lord of all. He is soon to lay claim to all, and so events will move fast.
Of all the emblems, the rainbow is the strangest to find on a figure who comes to judge.
The strong angel's descent to earth signals the close of God's providential dealings. The scene of action is now openly on earth, not in heaven... The rainbow on his head is the same rainbow John saw before (Rev. 4:3). There it encircled the throne and its majestic Occupant; here it rests on the head of the angel, with all its many colours and glories. In the middle of these scenes of judgment God's remembrance of mercy is constant and unfailing. The bow in the cloud, that ancient token of divine goodness (Gen. 9), reappears here, just at the time and season when it is most needed.
- Timing — The vision breaks in at the darkest hour: comfort for suffering saints, warning for a rebellious world.
- Identity — Cloud, rainbow, face like the sun, legs like pillars of fire: marks of a Divine Person. Commentators agree the angel is Christ.
- Contrast — The "strong angel" of chapter 5 is a created being. This One is uncreated. They share only the word "strong."
- Meaning — Cloud: Jehovah's majesty. Rainbow: mercy toward creation. Face: supreme authority. Feet: firm judgment.
- Mercy — The rainbow rests on the head of the Judge. God remembers His goodness at the very moment He claims the earth in power.
and having in his hand a little opened book. And he set his right foot on the sea, and the left upon the earth,
A mighty figure comes down from heaven, holding an open scroll, one foot on the sea and one on the land. Before He says a word, His stance already stakes a claim — and the verse leaves us asking who He is, and what He claims.
The description just before this verse tells us whose hand holds the book.
From Revelation 10 to 11:14 is a parenthesis. It begins with a Mighty Angel, clothed with a cloud, a rainbow on His head, His face like the sun, and His feet like pillars of fire. In this description there can be no mistake. Here we have the Lord Himself in angelic form. When He appears it is indeed the beginning of the end.
Earlier He appeared as a priest. Here that has changed.
So we have again the Lord in angelic appearance. Before, He appeared as high priest; here He is the angel with royal claim… He approaches the earth, and He asserts His undeniable claim to all creation as His by right… It is no sealed-up book now, but a little one and open: sea or earth are alike His.
Five chapters earlier a scroll appeared that no one could open until the Lamb broke its seals. This one is open, and it is small.
In Revelation 5 the Lord holds a closed, seven-sealed book in His right hand. Here the angel holds an open book. Why closed in the one and open in the other? In the first, the Lamb discloses the purposes of God one by one, purposes never revealed before. In the second, "the book is open as part of well-known prophecy, and now brought to a direct issue on known ground." This is also a "little" book, small compared with the larger book of chapter 5, which was so full that it was written on both sides.
Nothing here is sealed. Its contents already stood written in older prophecy.
It is not a sealed book like the one in Revelation 5, whose contents no one could know until the seals were broken. This book is open, and its contents were already known. Christ's action in taking possession of the earth and the sea — and all that earth and sea represent — is pictured by His right foot on the sea and His left foot on the earth. The prophetic writings had surely made this known already. (See, for example, Psalm 72; Isaiah 11; 25; 60; Zechariah 14, and countless other passages.)
The two feet cover two different sorts of humanity.
The angel set His right foot on the sea, and His left foot on the earth. In Scripture the sea often pictures the mass of nations in an uncivilised state. The earth speaks of the ordered part of the world that has had the light of God, whether in Judaism or Christendom. So the earth is the part of the world that prophecy applies to above all. This leads us on to the time when Christ will publicly assert His rights over the whole world.
Which foot goes where is not accidental.
Three times in this vision the angel stands on the sea and the earth, and each time the sea is named before the earth, while elsewhere in this book the order is reversed. Is it chance or divine precision that the right foot comes down on the rebellious nations and peoples, and the left on the professed scene of light and government? How firm the tread of the angel! How complete the action! How thorough the subjugation of all to Him!
The stance is one of ownership, but the world does not yet see it.
The Angel stood with His right foot on the sea and His left on the earth. That is, He dominates the whole world — both the unstable, turbulent masses and the more stable, organized kingdoms. So He dominates the entire scene, though for a short time yet He does not display His supremacy, and men do not acknowledge it.
Later in the chapter John is told to eat this same open book. That instruction teaches anyone who handles God's word.
Notice the thought underneath: what the servant of God gives out as prophecy or teaching, he must first eat, digest and absorb himself. Nothing does more spiritual harm than to proclaim and parade our knowledge of truth that we have not yet really made our own in meditation, in prayer, in experience. Gaining fresh truth is sweet and thrilling as honey. But once we digest and absorb it inside, it always displaces flesh and self and the world, and that is a bitter process.
- Owner — the figure holding the book is the Lord Himself in angelic form. He no longer acts as priest; He comes down with royal claim to all creation.
- Open — this book needs no unsealing, unlike the sealed scroll of Revelation 5. Its contents are prophecy already written, now brought to a head.
- Reach — the right foot covers the sea: the turbulent, unformed nations. The left covers the earth: the ordered world that has had God's light. Nothing lies outside the two feet.
- Firmness — the two feet planted on sea and land picture complete subjugation. For now, men neither see nor admit His supremacy.
- Digestion — the servant must eat the same open book before he preaches it. Fresh truth tastes sweet as honey, but absorbed truth displaces self, and that is bitter.
and cried with a loud voice as a lion roars. And when he cried, the seven thunders uttered their own voices.
A mighty angel stands with one foot on the sea and one on the land. He shouts like a roaring lion, and seven thunders answer. Who is calling out? Why does the cry sound like a lion? And what do the thunders say?
Commentators identify this cry as the voice of Christ. They hear in it a note struck earlier in the book, where He appears as both Lion and Lamb.
Along with the act of the angel we have His voice of majesty and power, causing intense terror throughout the whole earth (Hosea 11:10; Joel 3:16). It is the voice of Christ. "He sends out His voice, His mighty voice" (Ps. 68:33). We have here the roar of the lion of the tribe of Judah. Chapter 5 names Him this way alongside the Lamb, in that magnificent heavenly scene. But there we see the Lamb acting; here the Lion.
One commentator reads the image through the prophet Amos, where a lion roars only when it already has prey.
"Does a lion roar in the forest, when he has no prey? Does a young lion cry out from his den, if he has taken nothing? … For the Lord God does nothing without revealing His secret to His servants the prophets. The lion has roared; who will not fear? The Lord God has spoken; who can but prophesy?" (Amos 3.) I cannot help seeing this passage from the prophet as an illustration, in several ways, of the vision before us. Again, in the Old Testament thunder always stood for God's authority in judgment. We are called to hear this dreadful announcement of God's judgments.
The thunders are described as uttering "their own voices," and that wording is pressed: this is speech, not noise.
The angel's cry was a cry to Jehovah, and it is answered at once. The answer is one of power and judgment. Thunder is God's voice in judgment, the expression of His authority in it (1 Sam. 7:10; Ps. 18:13; Job 26:14). "The seven thunders" indicate a full and perfect response to the angel's cry. "The seven" gives precision and definiteness to the answering voices of the thunders. This was not a crash like natural thunder. These thunders gave clear expression to the mind of the God of judgment; they "uttered their own voices."
Another writer places the roar just before the blow falls.
It is the voice that comes first, the voice of Judah's Lion, as "suddenly His anger kindles." The seven thunders answer it — the full divine voice, the whole government of God in action. But what they say must find its meaning at a later time.
John hears the thunders, but a voice from heaven stops his pen.
His voice, too, was of the highest power and majesty. Its echo was the seven thunders, which surely speak of further acts of judgment. God makes the seals, the trumpets and the bowls all public, but by express command the thunders go unrecorded. It is a solemn thought. Many details of the divine judgments are revealed, yet there will be judgments beyond anything made known to us.
Commentators differ on the reason. Some say the meaning waits for a later time. Another writer draws a practical lesson from the ban itself.
The thunders spoke clearly, but John is not allowed to write their words (v. 4). So we do not need to know what was said.
This vision arrives at the darkest point of the story. It speaks to more than the guilty.
Things are drawing to a close. The three and a half years of sorrow are nearly spent, but their last hours show the world in mad and open rebellion against God, and against His saints, on whom the Beast and the Antichrist unleash their fury. Before the Gentile and Jewish apostates and those they have fooled drink the last of the Lord's vengeance, this comforting vision breaks through the dark clouds of judgment. It is a stern reminder to the world that, despite the raging of the wicked, the government of the earth is the just claim of the Creator. He is about to make that claim good in power. But the vision is also perfectly fitted to strengthen and comfort believers, and especially suffering saints. The same power that will crush the enemy raises the sufferers to honour.
- Lion. The one who cries is Christ — the Lamb of chapter 5 now acting as the Lion of Judah, claiming the earth as His own.
- Roar. A lion roars when the prey is already taken. The cry announces judgment that is settled, not threatened.
- Thunder. Seven thunders answer the roar. This is the full, exact voice of God's authority — words with meaning, not noise.
- Sealed. John understood the words, but heaven told him not to write them. God keeps judgments in reserve beyond all He has revealed.
- Comfort. The same power that crushes the rebel lifts the suffering believer. This vision breaks like light through the darkest hour.
And when the seven thunders spoke, I was about to write and I heard a voice out of the heaven saying, Seal the things which the seven thunders have spoken, and write them not.
Between the sixth and seventh trumpets, a mighty angel stands on the sea and the land and roars like a lion — and seven thunders answer Him. John reaches for his pen, and a voice from heaven stops him: why speak, only to seal the words away?
The thunders are not an interruption. They are God's own authority answering the cry of the One who claims the earth. Their number speaks of completeness.
The "seven thunders" are the perfection of God's intervention in His judgment, answering the voice of the angel. God keeps sealed those things which John then sees; He will not allow John to write. God allows the thunders to speak, to show that all His power must intervene in answer to this cry of Christ.
Thunder carries a fixed meaning across Scripture. The roar that sets it off has an echo in the Old Testament too.
"The lion has roared; who will not fear? The Lord God has spoken; who can but prophesy?" (Amos 3). I cannot help seeing this passage from the prophet Amos as an illustration, in several ways, of the vision we are examining. Again, in the Old Testament thunder was constantly how God expressed His authority in judgment. God calls us to hear this dreadful announcement of His judgments. John was about to write, but a voice from heaven forbids it. He was not to communicate the details of what God was going to do now.
The silence is not John's ignorance. He was ready to write because he had taken the words in.
The prophet was about to record the words of the thunders. He heard and understood. This vision is full of voices. That of the angel of the thunders, and another "out of heaven." This was a voice of authority... Those communications, unrevealed to us, were to be sealed. It was not the time to make them known. The exact meaning of these revelations remains undisclosed; probably they appear in the later communications that deal directly with the end.
The order comes in two parts: seal, and do not write. Daniel received the same kind of command. From that comparison comes a rule that runs through all prophecy.
The seer receives two commands: first, to seal up the sayings of the thunder; second, not to write them (compare Dan. 8:26; 12:9)... Sealing these prophetic revelations supposes that the end is a long way off. If the end is near, then the prophecies are not to be sealed. In one case the words are sealed, for the end is far off (Dan. 12:9); in another the sayings are not sealed, for the end is near (Rev. 22:10).
The roar has a name behind it. The thunders' message is held back, not cancelled.
It is the opening voice of the Lion of Judah, whose anger is quickly kindled. The seven thunders answer it — the full divine voice, the whole government of God in action. But what they say has to find its meaning at a later time.
A sealed message can feel like being shut out. One writer found the opposite: this closed door is what sets the reader free in the rest of the book.
I know of nothing that gives the soul more freedom in reading this book than this sealing up. It speaks of the care and love and foresight that has shut away in the book all we were not to see... But how sweet it is to rest in the love that sealed them to us and opened them to John. How sweet to be free of jealousy or grudging against Him who has made the difference.
This verse is one instance of a wider pattern. The Bible does not contain everything God ever said; it contains what He chose to preserve for us.
It is a selected revelation. We have not recorded in it all that God has revealed during these 4,000 years to His people... Paul writes of having heard unspeakable words, which it is not possible for a man to utter (2 Cor. 12:4). John heard the voice of the seven thunders, but was forbidden to record what they said (Rev. 10:4). And the same apostle tells us that Jesus did many other signs in the presence of His disciples, which are not written in this book. But these are written so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that by believing you may have life in His name.
- Cry — the lion's roar is Christ claiming sea and land, and the thunders are heaven's answer to it.
- Seven — the number marks God's complete intervention in judgment. Thunder in Scripture is His authority speaking.
- Sealed — two commands, not one: seal the sayings, and do not write them. Daniel's visions were shut up in the same way until the end.
- Timing — a sealed message means the end is still far off; an open one means the end is near (Rev. 22:10).
- Trust — the silence is love, not loss; God's word to us is a chosen record, written that we may believe and have life.
And the angel whom I saw stand on the sea and on the earth lifted up his right hand to the heaven,
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
and swore by him that lives to the ages of ages, who created the heaven and the things that are in it, and the earth and the things that are in it, and the sea and the things that are in it, that there should be no longer delay;
A mighty angel stands on the sea and on the land, lifts His hand to heaven, and swears by the God who lives forever and made all things. Does that oath announce the end of time itself, or the end of God's waiting?
The one who takes the oath is identified by commentators with Christ Himself, which makes the words a self-oath rather than an appeal to a higher authority.
The angel lifts up His hand to heaven and swears by the living God, the Creator of heaven, earth and sea and everything in them, that there should be delay no longer (v. 6). He is one with God, so that this is really God swearing by Himself. He had done this when showing grace to Abraham and his seed (Hebrews 6:13-14); now He does so when executing the judgment that subdues all things under Him.
The same oath-form serves two opposite errands, and neither can be revoked:
If we are right to identify this "mighty Angel" with our Lord, then in swearing "by Him who lives forever and ever" He was swearing by Himself, just as when God gave the promise to Abraham. That was an oath for blessing. This is an oath for judgment. Both are equally unchangeable.
Older translations read "that there should be time no longer." That wording has misled many readers.
Many imagine it means that time was then to end and eternity to begin. But that is not the sense at all... The meaning is that God would no longer let time run on before He stepped in and dealt with the course of this world. Eternity was not to begin at once. There was simply to be no more passing of time before His last summons to the world.
A long stretch of history still lies between this oath and eternity:
It is not "no longer time," as the Authorised Version has it and the Revised Version keeps it. The translators corrected their blunder by putting "delay" in the margin instead of "time." Either the text or the margin is right, for both cannot be. After the angel's oath is fulfilled, at least a thousand years run their course before time ceases and eternity opens. So it cannot mean that there will be no longer "time."
The oath names God as the maker of heaven, earth and sea — the very three realms the angel has just planted His feet upon.
It is Christ come down, after His long season of patience at the right hand of God, to take possession of His rightful inheritance. Notice this too. He gained the title through His redemption work, yet He takes possession by right of the Creator's sovereign claim. That is why He lifts up His hand to heaven and swears by the eternal God, the universal Creator. It is creation's Lord who has given the title, and now He comes to make it good.
That explains why the picture here differs from the vision of the Lamb earlier in the book:
He takes the earth, not by right of His work on the cross, which is not mentioned here. He takes it as the One whom God has resolved to set over the works of His hands — God acting in His sovereign rights as Creator and "possessor of heaven and earth." In the fifth chapter, where God appeared as Judge, Christ was seen as the Lamb slain. In the fourth chapter, where God appeared as Creator, the Lamb was not seen.
God's patience held the judgment back. What brought the waiting to an end came from man's side:
God's patience and long endurance had held back the full stroke of divine judgment. But the evil was appalling, and chapter 9 ends by exposing a complete lack of repentance. This was now hastening the climax, which would come when the seventh trumpet sounded. At last the cup of man's iniquity was full.
The end of delay is not only a stop. It opens the way for a reign.
Now, however, this mystery of God is about to be finished. God, by His Son, the Heir of all things, will wrench the government of the world out of Satan's iron grasp and shut him up as a prisoner in the abyss for 1000 years... Evil is tolerated and allowed today, despite many checks that keep it from reaching its full height. Then God will punish it openly. The mystery is at an end. Christ is about to reign.
- Delay, not time. The oath does not end time. It says God will no longer let the world run on before He steps in.
- Delay had a reason. God's patience held judgment back. Evil that refused to repent brought the waiting to its end.
- Delay ends by oath. Christ swears by Himself, just as God did when He promised blessing to Abraham. The same unchangeable oath now pledges judgment.
- Delay ends on Creator's ground. He swears by the One who made heaven, earth and sea, and takes possession by the Creator's right, not by the cross.
- Delay ends so a reign can begin. When the waiting ends, Christ shuts Satan away, punishes evil openly, and takes the government of the world.
but in the days of the voice of the seventh angel, when he is about to sound the trumpet, the mystery of God also shall be completed, as he has made known the glad tidings to his own bondmen the prophets.
The angel's oath ends with a promise about timing. When the seventh trumpet is about to sound, something long hidden is finished. So what is "the mystery of God"? And why has God waited so long to end it?
The word does not mean a puzzle no one can solve. Here it covers long ages of silence on God's part.
In this passage the mystery of God is this: for long ages God has not stepped in publicly in the affairs of men. The wickedness of men has grown, with no public check from God. God has let men indulge their desires, reach their ambitions, and grow in their rebellion against Him and in their persecution of His people. During the ages God's people have been tortured on the rack, banished from their homes, and martyred at the stake, and God, it might seem, has not interfered. All this — which has been called the silence of God — is a great mystery. But it can be explained. In Scripture a "mystery" is not something that no one can explain. It is something known only to those let in on it. While this mystery lasts, believers have the open book of prophecy, foretelling the blessing that will come when God steps in publicly. So the lamp of prophecy has lit up the darkness of the ages and let the believer into the mind of God.
Scripture uses the word "mystery" for several different things. This verse is not about Christ and the church.
We must in no way connect the mystery in Revelation 10:7 with the mystery that filled so much of Paul's ministry. That one is the heading up of all things in Christ. Its present aspect is that God has given Him to be head over all things to the Church, which is His body, the fulness of Him who fills all in all (Ephesians 1, 3; Colossians 1, 2). There are other mysteries, such as that of godliness (1 Timothy 3:16), and of lawlessness (2 Thessalonians 2:7). In Revelation the mystery is God staying passive while evil goes on and prospers. That would be a still greater mystery if revelation had not told us this: His silence, which He speaks of in Psalm 50, and His holding back will come to an end.
Evil is not left completely unchecked even now. That makes its success even harder to understand.
God does check evil to some extent, partly through human government and partly through His own providential dealings. It is a great mercy that such restraints exist. Still, no government can root out the influence of evil, and good is misrepresented, so it has little influence. That is what seems so mysterious a thing to us, when we know God and how He hates evil.
One writer weighs the older wording "when he shall begin to sound," and shows how it fixes the time.
The real force of the words "when he shall begin to sound" is "when he shall sound, as he is about to do." This, with the expression "there shall be no longer delay," fixes the time. It is just before the seventh trumpet, when "the kingdom of the world has become the kingdom of our Lord and of his Christ" (Revelation 11:15). Then "the mystery of God" will be finished.
The verse ties this ending to a message God gave the prophets. Notice which way that message ran.
This is indeed glad tidings proclaimed to His prophets of old, not declared by them (although they did that too, as their books testify), but to them: "For the Lord GOD does nothing without revealing his secret to his servants the prophets" (Amos 3:7). This is God's decree: He will step in publicly for His afflicted saints. He will crush the power of evil. He will drive the usurper Satan out of the earth, which he has so far been allowed to ruin morally and physically. And He will set up the world in more than its first beauty and order. The same blessed hope, with added glories, is our strength today.
The ending does more than stop the delay. It explains it.
There has been an apparent long delay. Now there will be "no more delay." Man's day has run to its end. Though in cloud and storm, the day of the Lord is dawning at last. Then the mystery of God is finished... Meanwhile evil keeps on and seems to win, and by this the heirs of glory are disciplined. Now at last all is cleared up. The mystery of God had to be a mystery while patience did its perfect work. Now it is finished forever. The glory of God shines like the sun. How fully faith is justified! The murmur of doubt is silenced forever.
- Silence — the mystery is God's long public silence, while evil runs on and seems to win.
- Not Paul's — this is not the mystery of Christ and the church; Scripture uses the word for several different things.
- Told — God gave the good news to His prophets first, so the end is a promise kept, not a surprise.
- Timed — the silence ends as the seventh angel is about to sound, just before the kingdom of the world becomes Christ's.
- Cleared — then faith is justified, and every murmur of doubt is silenced for good.
And the voice which I heard out of the heaven [was] again speaking with me, and saying, Go, take the little book which is opened in the hand of the angel who is standing on the sea and on the earth.
The seven thunders have been sealed, and the strong angel has sworn that God's long delay is nearly over. Now the same voice from heaven sends John down to the angel on sea and land, to take the open book from his hand.
The voice comes from heaven to a prisoner on a rocky island.
The prisoner of Patmos again hears the voice from "the Heaven," the dwelling of God. John's limbs may have been chained, and the waves may have dashed against his rocky prison. But the island was no lonely place for a man whose soul was taken up with the visions of God... He is commanded to go to the angel and take the little opened book out of his hand. He obeyed at once. The Speaker was none other than God Himself, and so his obedience was prompt and unquestioning. The majesty of the angel held no terrors for John.
Older translations call this scroll a little book. Both words, little and open, are set against something seen earlier: a great book sealed with seven seals.
Notice the clear contrast. The prophet here takes and eats a little book. We have already seen a great book sealed with seven seals... Why a little book? And why open? It is little, because it deals with a narrower sphere, one already familiar in the prophets. It is open, because things are no longer described in the mysterious dress that the Seals, and even more the Trumpets, put on them. Everything is going to be plain in what comes out here.
The angel stands on the sea and on the land, and the book's contents match that ground.
The book has been shut up until now, but it is shut up no longer. Its contents are clearly connected with what the angel does here. They have to do with the earth alone, not with heaven as well, as the seven-sealed book does. This should lead us to see what the book is. Old Testament prophecy has just this character: it opens up earthly things to us, not heavenly ones. Its promises belong to Israel, the earthly people (Rom. 9:4), and it deals fully with the millennial kingdom and the upheavals that are its birth-pains.
John is told to eat the book, not just to carry it.
What is in the opened book will become the subject of John's testimony to peoples, nations, tongues and kings. But if God sends His servant to prophesy, He will first make him fit for the service. So John must first eat the book (compare Ezekiel 3:1-3). He must take in and digest these divine communications before he can rightly pass them on to others. Surely a lesson for God's servants in every age.
Another writer warns what happens when that order is broken.
Note the thought underneath it all. What the servant of God gives out, as prophecy or as teaching, he must first eat, digest and absorb himself. Nothing is more spiritually ruinous than to announce and show off knowledge of truth we have not yet made our own in meditation, in prayer, in experience.
Prophecy tastes sweet at first. Living by it costs something.
There is no sweeter passage in all Scripture than what God has revealed about the showing forth of His blessed Son. Prophetic truth is usually sweet and attractive to those whose interest in it is just waking up. But if it is followed through, if the book is really eaten, it leads to self-judgment and to separation from evil. That will always be bitter. There is not one of us who readily takes the place God's Word would put him in during this time of Christ's rejection. So the point here is that God's truth makes demands.
The book leads on to a fresh stretch of prophecy.
The meaning of this soon becomes clearer. There is something like an appendix of prophecy, where he takes up his course again for special reasons. We may call it the second volume of "the things which are about to be after these," and it starts at Revelation 12.
- Voice — God Himself speaks from heaven, and John obeys at once. The angel's majesty holds no terror for him.
- Open — the book is small and unsealed. Its sphere is narrower and its language plainer than the seven-sealed book. What follows is meant to be understood.
- Earth — its contents concern the earth, not heaven. That is the ground the angel stands on, and the ground Old Testament prophecy covers.
- Eaten — God fits the messenger before He sends him. Truth must be taken in and digested before it is passed on. Showing off truth we have not digested ruins us.
- Bitter — sweet in the mouth, bitter inside. Truth taken honestly leads to self-judgment and separation from evil. Only then is John ready to prophesy again.
And I went to the angel, saying to him to give me the little book. And he says to me, Take and eat it up and it shall make thy belly bitter, but in thy mouth it shall be sweet as honey.
John goes to the mighty angel and asks for the small scroll. The angel tells him to eat it, and warns him what it will do inside him. That raises two questions. What does eating a book mean? And why does one message taste sweet, then turn bitter?
Prophecy speaks in symbols. One writer compares John's act with earlier prophets and explains what eating stands for.
We are dealing with symbols here. The prophet eating the book is no harder to understand than Jeremiah eating the words of the LORD (Jer. 15:16). To eat is to make the thing one's own, to take it into one's being (John 6:49-58). The Christian prophet eats the scroll and finds it both sweet and bitter. This reminds us of a similar symbolic act by the Jewish prophet (Ezek. 2:8; Ezek. 3:1-3). The first effect of the prophetic message, the scroll in the mouth, was sweetness — the sweetness of honey. But then you weigh the revelations and think over the judgments they announce, and the next effect is bitterness and sorrow. Prophecy both gladdens and saddens. It announces both joy and grief.
Two details stand out: the book is little, and it lies open. One commentator ties the taste to its contents, then explains both.
Notice the clear contrast between two books. Here the prophet takes and eats a little book. Earlier we saw a great book sealed with seven seals. It was sweet as honey to the taste that the true and all-worthy King should reign. But how bitter to the feelings that unsparing judgment should fall on most of the Jews, and still more on proud Christendom, both apostate and worse. Why a little book? And why open? It is a little book, because it deals with a fairly narrow field, already familiar from the prophets. It is open, because things are no longer described in the mysterious disguise that the Seals, and still more the Trumpets, put on them.
The order matters. Sweetness comes first. The pain comes when the truth goes deeper than the mouth.
How sweet it is to our taste when God communicates some new truth to us! We rejoice in it like people who have found hidden treasure. But all truth is death to the natural man. So when the Holy Spirit applies it inside us, we find it bitter in its working and effects.
Commentators differ on where the bitterness comes from. Scott traced it to sorrow over the judgments announced. Others place it closer to home, in what the truth does to the person who takes it in.
Notice the thought underneath. Whatever the servant of God gives out as prophecy or teaching, he must first eat, digest and absorb himself. Nothing does more spiritual damage than to announce and parade knowledge of truth we have not yet made our own in meditation, in prayer, in experience. Gaining fresh truth is sweet and exciting as honey. But once we digest and absorb it, it always displaces flesh and self and the world, and that is a bitter process. This is so even when, as here, the little book concerns judgment that is to fall on others and not on oneself.
Another writer names what the bitterness does, and what it costs in daily life.
If the book is really eaten, it leads to self-judgment and to separation from evil, and this will always be bitter. God's truth makes demands. If you set out in earnest to walk in the truth revealed, you too will know something of its bitterness. Receive the prophetic testimony, walk in the power of what is revealed there, and you can no longer enjoy the things you used to enjoy.
Eating comes before speaking. One writer turns that order into a rule for anyone who passes Scripture on to others.
The Bible — to widen the application — is not a book of information to gather and then repeat. It is the voice of God to the soul that reads it. So you must hear it for yourself before you can rightly pass on what you have heard... Take Ezekiel and John as examples: we are not qualified to be living channels of divine truth until we have made it our own.
- Take. The scroll is small and open. Its subject is limited and already familiar from the prophets, no longer hidden in the symbols of the seals and trumpets.
- Eat. To eat is to take a message in and make it your own — the same picture used of Ezekiel and Jeremiah.
- Sweet. New truth tastes like honey: the coming reign of the rightful King, and the joy of discovering treasure.
- Bitter. Digestion hurts. Some writers trace the bitterness to sorrow over the judgments. Others trace it to the cost in the one who swallows it: truth displaces flesh, self and the world, and leads to self-judgment.
- Then speak. Eating comes first. Truth repeated before you have absorbed it is not testimony. No one is a living channel of what he has not made his own.
And I took the little book out of the hand of the angel, and ate it up; and it was in my mouth as honey, sweet; and when I had eaten it my belly was made bitter.
John obeys, and the little scroll does two different things to him. Why should God's own word be honey on the tongue and bitterness inside?
The picture is symbolic, and prophets before John acted it out. One writer explains what eating stands for, and why the mouth tastes one thing and the inside another.
The prophet eating the book is no harder to understand than Jeremiah eating the words of the Lord. To eat is to make the thing one's own, to take it into one's own being. The Christian prophet eats the scroll and finds it both sweet and bitter. This reminds us of a similar symbolic action by the Jewish prophet Ezekiel. The first effect of prophetic communication — the scroll in the mouth — was sweetness, the sweetness of honey. But when you weigh the revelations and think about the judgments they announce, the next effect is bitterness and sorrow. Prophecy both gladdens and saddens, as it contains announcements both of joy and grief.
The two words attached to the scroll — which older translations call a little book — are deliberate. One writer explains what makes it little, what makes it open, and what makes it sweet and bitter.
Notice the clear contrast between the little book which the prophet here takes and eats, and the great book we have already seen sealed with seven seals. It was sweet as honey to the taste that the true and all-worthy King should reign. But how bitter to the feelings that unsparing judgment should fall on the mass of the Jews, and still more on the proud Christian world. Why a little book? and why open? It is little because it deals with a fairly narrow sphere, already familiar in the prophets. It is open because things are no longer described in the mysterious dress that the Seals, and still more the Trumpets, wrapped them in.
Commentators differ on where the bitterness lands. Some place it in the judgments announced. Others place it closer to home, in what the truth does to the person who swallows it.
Does this not show that the truth of all God is going to bring in — the unfolding of coming glories — is indeed sweet to our taste? And yet it involves the setting aside of the flesh, and the utter judgment of all that the flesh craves. We have to discover that as believers the flesh is still in us. So the truth, however sweet to the taste, brings bitter exercises as it uncovers the true character of our own hearts.
The bitterness is not just about the future. Follow the truth through, and it begins to ask something of you.
If followed up, if the book is really eaten, it leads to self-judgment and to separation from evil. This will always be bitter. Not one of us finds it easy to take the place that God's Word would put him in during this time of Christ's rejection. And so the point here is that God's truth makes demands.
The order matters: the book goes in first. One writer draws out the lesson for anyone who passes God's word on to others.
If God sends His servant to prophesy, He will first make him fit for his service; and so John must first "eat" the book. He must take in and digest these divine communications before he can pass them on to others in the right way… The truth must first become our own by inward application. Only then can we be taken up and used to testify of it to others. To try to "prophesy" before we have "eaten" and "digested" will only expose our nakedness in front of the enemy.
Both tastes stay with the believer who looks ahead. One writer shows where that mixture leads.
So the thought of the end of God's ways is sweet to the taste and glorious to think about. But men are wilful and blind, and Israel in particular. That is what makes judgment necessary before God can reach His end, and the thought of it gives sorrow to the heart. We look ahead, and it is "with joy and sorrow mingled," and so we enter to some degree into the spirit of our Lord Jesus Christ.
- Eat — to eat the book is to make it your own, not just to read it; John does what Jeremiah and Ezekiel did before him.
- Sweet — the honey is the coming reign of the rightful King. The scroll is little and open because its sphere is narrow and its meaning now plain.
- Bitter — once swallowed, the truth sets the flesh aside and calls for self-judgment and separation. It makes demands.
- Then speak — speak only what you have eaten and digested; undigested truth exposes the servant before the enemy.
- Mingled — joy and sorrow travel together, and the servant who carries both enters something of Christ's own spirit.
And it was said to me, Thou must prophesy again as to peoples and nations and tongues and many kings.
John has just eaten the little book — honey in his mouth, bitterness inside him. Only then does a voice give him a fresh commission, and its wording raises three questions: what "again" means, whom he prophesies to, and why God feeds a messenger before He sends him.
The order matters. John is not told to prophesy and then feed. He feeds, and the commission follows.
Notice the thought underneath this. What the servant of God gives out, whether prophecy or teaching, he must first eat and digest himself. Nothing does more spiritual damage than to announce and parade our knowledge of truth. It is truth we have not yet made our own in meditation, in prayer, in experience.
The same order applies to anyone God sends. Speaking before the truth has done its inward work exposes the speaker, not the message.
If God sends His servant to prophesy, He will first qualify him for that service. So John must first "eat" the book (compare Ezekiel 3:1-3). He must take in and digest these divine communications before he can rightly pass them on to others. This is surely a lesson for God's servants in every age... To try to "prophesy" before we have "eaten" and "digested" will only expose our nakedness in front of the enemy.
The bitter part is not wasted. It is what makes a man usable.
As believers we have to discover that the flesh is still in us. So the truth, however sweet to the taste, brings bitter exercise with it. It shows us the true character of our own hearts. We must judge not only the world around us, but the flesh within us... When we have judged the flesh, the Lord can use us as witnesses to others. So John, after passing through these exercises, is told, "You must again prophesy about many peoples and nations and languages and kings."
There is also a bitterness that belongs to the work itself, not only to the worker.
This is work with a deeply felt bitterness about it, because most people will not believe. Yet for a true prophet there is a sweetness no one can dispute.
What John swallowed is what he must now deliver.
John was to use the knowledge he had gained. Until now his prophecies had been the contents of the sealed book, whose judgments Christ had then first unfolded. But the contents of the open book he had now eaten were to form at least a part of the prophecies he had still to deliver. He had received divine understanding of the book of prophecy, and now he was to be its interpreter.
Not everything John heard was his to publish. This short chapter sets two things side by side.
Twice the book is spoken of as "open." So in this short chapter we get things that were spoken and yet sealed, not to be published. We also get things which, though open, the prophet had to eat before he passed them on to others. Even in the solemn matter of judgment there is a time to keep silence and a time to speak.
One word here divides translations. Some render it "before many peoples," which would put John face to face with them.
If this is Old Testament prophecy that is now "open," we can see why John has at this point to "prophesy again" — not "before," but "over." That is, "concerning many peoples and nations and tongues and kings." He is to take up the theme of the old prophets. He does not simply echo their predictions; he adds to them a testimony that completes them and closes them.
So where does this renewed prophesying begin? Kelly places it in a fresh section later in the book.
There is an appendix of prophecy here, where he renews his course for special reasons. We may call it the second volume of "the things which are about to be after these." It begins with Revelation 12 and runs on from there.
This commission also has limits.
So in Revelation 10 it is God's prophetic testimony as to many peoples and nations and tongues and kings, but neither the gospel nor the church as now.
- Eaten — a servant must first take in what he hands out; parading truth he has not digested ruins him.
- Bitter — sweet at the taste, bitter in the digestion, as truth judges the flesh in the one who took it in.
- Qualified — God prepares His messenger before He sends him; the commission comes after the inward exercise.
- Sent — the book he swallowed becomes the material of his new prophecy; he takes up the theme of the older prophets.
- Wide — the reach is peoples, nations, languages and kings; the subject is God's prophetic testimony, not the gospel or the church.
And there was given to me a reed like a staff, saying, Rise, and measure the temple of God, and the altar, and them that worship in it.
The wide sweep of the trumpet judgments narrows to one city and one building, and John receives a measuring rod and a command. What does it mean to measure a temple, an altar, and — stranger still — the people standing in it?
Until now John has only watched. This command changes that.
"Rise and measure." John had been a passive but deeply interested watcher of the scenes shown under the earlier Trumpets. But now Israel, his own nation, is in question, and he is told to "rise." God's command stirs him into action. It is more than a mere question of posture.
The rod is named with two words that pull opposite ways: a reed, but firm as a staff.
The prophet now receives a reed like a staff, to measure the temple of God with it. A reed might suggest weakness, and in fact everything that is of God lies under that reproach at the time in view. But the words "like a staff" suggest the opposite thought. This measuring shows God's care for His people. To unbelief that care is a mystery, for His people seem exposed to the same ups and downs as other men. Yet it is a staff you may lean on with fullest confidence.
You cannot lay a measuring rod along a crowd of worshippers, and that impossibility is a clue to the meaning.
Once again the language is symbolic. A measure of length may suit a temple or an altar, but it cannot apply to worshippers in a literal sense. The thought seems to be that God examines these three and takes account of them. He ignores the outer court, since it lies under Gentile feet. This shows, we gather, that God is going to support what is of Himself among His people Israel here on earth.
The writers here read this as a real building in Jerusalem. A nation that still does not believe will put it up.
The events of this chapter concern the period after the church is gone and before the Lord's appearing. So the temple must be the one the Jews will build, while still in unbelief, after they return to their own land. Still, we find a true remnant inside the corrupt nation... The word used here for temple means the house itself, including the holy place and the most holy place. It is not the other word sometimes used, which covers the whole set of sacred buildings together with the court.
Scott adds a nuance: the picture holds even without a temple standing at that moment, yet he still expects one to be built.
The force of the figure does not require a material temple standing in Jerusalem at that time. Yet prophecy demands the building of a stone temple, and the rebuilding of Jewish life, both civil and religious, in that deeply solemn period between the church being caught up (1 Thess. 4:16-17) and the Lord's appearing (Jude 14, 15).
Which altar is meant? The answer tells you who these worshippers are.
The altar, I think, means the bronze altar outside; the golden altar stood inside the temple. "Those who worship there" are people marked by nearness to God. The altar was where a person truly came near to God, and they have come near Him. It was the place of the burnt offering, which marked the acceptance of the person. So here we see God owning a certain number of people on the earth as able to draw near to Him.
Dennett notes what these worshippers could not do, and what God counted them to be anyway.
In fact these worshippers had no access into the holy place. But we are taught here that God regarded them as belonging to it, even though they could not enter. So the remnant truly have a priestly character before Him.
One writer draws a clear line between this worship and the Christian's.
Jewish worship stopped in the past and will start again in the future. Christian worship comes in between. Christians have no place of worship on earth; they enter no temple here. Their one and only place of worship is the most holy place in the sanctuary above (John 4:21, 23, 24; Heb. 10:19-22). Their sacrifices are praise to God and practical kindness to others (Heb. 13:15-16).
- Rise — John stops watching and starts working when his own nation comes into view. The measuring is an act, not a posture.
- Reed — a fragile stalk that is also a staff. What belongs to God looks weak in that hour, yet His care is something you can lean your whole weight on.
- Measure — to measure is to claim. God takes account of temple, altar and worshippers and owns them as His, while the unmeasured court lies under Gentile feet.
- Altar — the altar of burnt offering marked the acceptance of the person. So those who "worship there" are people God owns as near to Him, given a priestly character even though they cannot enter the holy place.
- Contrast — Christians have no temple on earth. Their one place of worship is the sanctuary above, and their sacrifices are praise and kindness.
And the court which [is] without the temple cast out, and measure it not; because it has been given [up] to the nations, and the holy city shall they tread under foot forty-two months.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And I will give [power] to my two witnesses, and they shall prophesy a thousand two hundred [and] sixty days, clothed in sackcloth.
God promises to raise up two witnesses in a city held down by foreign power. Who they are, why they wear sackcloth, and why God counts their days one by one are the questions this verse raises.
What God gives is the power to make the testimony effective:
Here we have the same word as in chapter 8:3. God says, "I will grant authority to my two witnesses, and they will prophesy" — the word means power, or effectiveness. These things are not given in any order at all; but there is adequate testimony: two lampstands, two olive trees. These witnesses have the power of Moses and Elijah.
God does not leave the trampled city without a witness:
The hostile powers act without hindrance, yet God does not let them defile the city without raising up a witness against them. Verse 3 speaks of this witness... Outwardly the witnesses are marked by the deepest humiliation, shown by their sackcloth. Inwardly they are marked by a shining light, which God gives and keeps burning. The picture comes from Zechariah 4, except that here each witness is an olive tree and a lampstand. The olive tree supplies the oil, and the oil feeds the light. God is the God of the earth, and though the holy city is trampled down He has not given up His claim to the earth. So before He makes good that claim in irresistible power, He maintains His witness in the face of the enemy.
The period is not vague. It lines up exactly with the forty-two months of the previous verse, and both are anchored in a known prophetic timetable:
Note next how long their prophetic testimony lasts. It will be a thousand two hundred and sixty days... The two periods coincide, both being three years and a half... These three and a half years are the last half of Daniel's seventieth week (Daniel 9:25-27). This is the period of Antichrist's terrible rule in Jerusalem, backed and sheltered by all the power of the last head of the Roman empire. At the close of that period Christ will come in glory.
Elsewhere the same span appears as months. Here God counts days, and the change is deliberate:
The Lord speaks of days here, not of forty-two months. It seems He does this to mark how much He values their testimony. He makes as much of it as He can. He does not sum it up together, as He does when He speaks of the beast (Rev. 13:5). Lovingly He speaks of the time as days, as though He were counting them all out.
That counting also guarantees the testimony does not fail early, and does not run late:
Their days of testimony are counted one by one. Theirs is not an on-and-off testimony. It goes on daily till the allotted period is finished, and not a day longer.
Commentators differ here. Some expect named people to return; others take the number as a legal measure:
People have made countless guesses about the number of witnesses... Others, with more reason and with some support from Scripture, suppose that Moses and Elijah are the two witnesses... The number of the witnesses is meant to convey a full and adequate testimony... Jewish law, and here we stand in Jewish circumstances, called for two witnesses to give valid evidence (Deut. 17:6; 19:15).
Others reject personal identification outright while keeping the moral likeness:
I see no proof at all that either Elijah or Moses is one of the two witnesses. The two witnesses stand in the same moral position as those two men, but there is no proof that they are the same people.
In Israel, sackcloth was the everyday dress of grief and of turning back to God (Samuel Ridout). Worn here, it says something about both the message and the men:
Being clothed in sackcloth may show that their message is one that calls aloud for repentance.
Their sorrow is not for themselves. It is over what has become of the people they belong to:
They stand apart from everyone around them, mourning over the terrible falling away of the nation they love, and everyone rejects them. Sackcloth is a fitting emblem of their testimony.
- Given — the witnesses do not produce their own power; God gives it, and it makes their prophesying effective.
- Counted — God speaks of these years in days, but of the beast's time in months. He counts out the days of those who testify for Him.
- Clothed — sackcloth marks grief and a call to repentance. Outwardly they are humbled; inwardly God feeds their light.
- Enough — under Jewish law two witnesses made evidence valid. Commentators differ on whether Moses and Elijah return in person, but the witness carries their power.
- Timed — the testimony runs the full 1,260 days and not one day longer. Then God makes good His claim on the earth in power.
These are the two olive trees and the two lamps which stand before the Lord of the earth;
The scene is Jerusalem in the last days, near the end of the times of the Gentiles, where God raises up two prophets. Verse 4 says what these witnesses are, and the picture comes straight from a vision the prophet Zechariah once saw.
The verse gives two pictures. One speaks of what supplies the witnesses; the other of what they do.
They are compared to two olive trees and two lampstands. This reminds us of Zechariah 4, where the prophet sees a vision of a seven-branched golden lampstand fed by two olive trees. The two lampstands speak of their clear and capable testimony. The two olive trees show that the Spirit of God gives this testimony all the support it needs.
The link to Zechariah 4 is obvious, but so is the difference. Zechariah saw one lampstand; here there are two. Commentators read the change like this: there the work is finished, here there is only a witness to what has not yet come.
In Zechariah there is one lampstand, all of gold, with its bowl, its seven lamps, its seven pipes, and an olive tree on either side. That is perfect unity and full development... The two anointed ones the prophet saw point in their fullness to the offices of Christ as King and Priest. These are the great means of giving and keeping divine light in "the world to come." Here we have only a testimony to these things. So there were two witnesses, the smallest testimony the law would accept. The oil here goes with mourning, not with joy. And the witnesses wear the sackcloth of affliction, not the garment of praise.
That is why their light does not end the night around them:
In Zechariah the thing itself is done; here there is only testimony to it... They stand before the Lord of the earth, the One to whom the earth belongs, to maintain His claim on it. They wear sackcloth because people resist that claim. Theirs is testimony enough in the power of the Spirit, a spiritual light in the darkness — a light that does not drive the darkness away.
Two is the smallest number the law accepts to establish a case. It also measures how much light that day will have.
It will be a testimony given at Jerusalem during Israel's Great Tribulation, but not worldwide. God will acknowledge it, for "only on the evidence of two witnesses or of three witnesses shall a charge be established" (Deuteronomy 19:15). It will not be a full testimony, as Zechariah's was, because instead of seven lamps there will only be two... Their light will support the weak remnant still living in Jerusalem before Christ's reign.
Another writer ties the two witnesses to Israel's condition, and warns against pressing the number further:
It is an adequate testimony to the state of Israel according to God — "two witnesses." God will also be among the remnant, without acknowledging the people as His own... In the "two," I do not go beyond the idea that it is an adequate testimony.
Olive trees make them anointed men. Their message is about a King who is also a Priest.
They are anointed ones, for they are olive trees, and so they testify in the power of the Holy Spirit. They are the two lampstands, so their testimony is the light from God in the darkness of that day. Standing before the Lord of the earth shows what their testimony is about: the claims of the coming Messiah as the rightful Lord of the earth... They are also two anointed ones. Besides the power of their testimony, this points to how Christ will come and take possession — as King and Priest, a Priest on His throne, like Melchizedek.
The title is deliberate. God had handed the earth over to the Gentiles; here He takes back His own claim to it.
God is Lord over the earth. He will not let the times of the Gentiles last any longer... He had given the earth to the Gentiles (Daniel 2:37). His throne had judged Jerusalem and left it... But God will take back His place as Lord over the earth. The two witnesses testify to this lordship, to the Lord over the earth — not to the Father, or to the heavenly glory, or to the Lord of heaven.
Some older versions read "the God of the earth" here, but the reading is "the Lord of the earth." The phrase says whom they serve, and it also explains how they keep going.
The prophets stand before the Lord of the earth. They know whose presence they are in, and they endure because by faith they see Him, though human eyes cannot see Him.
- Source — The olive trees mark the witnesses as anointed men. The Spirit of God carries their testimony, not their own strength.
- Shape — Zechariah saw one lampstand and perfect unity. Here two lampstands mean testimony only, not the finished thing: the oil of mourning, not of joy.
- Sufficiency — Two is the smallest number the law accepts to establish a charge. It is light enough, though far less than Zechariah's seven, and it does not yet remove the darkness.
- Subject — They proclaim Messiah's double right: King and Priest, coming to take possession of what is His.
- Stance — They stand before the Lord of the earth, the place God takes back when the times of the Gentiles end. They know whose presence they are in, and they endure by seeing the One no eye can see.
and if any one wills to injure them, fire goes out of their mouth, and devours their enemies. And if any one wills to injure them, thus must he be killed.
The two witnesses of Revelation 11 prophesy in sackcloth, and this verse says what happens to anyone who tries to stop them. Fire from a prophet's mouth raises two questions: what is this power for, and why does it look nothing like the way God's servants act today?
The fire moves with their speech. What comes out of their mouth is testimony, and judgment travels with it.
The power of judgment comes out of their mouth. That is, their word brings judgment on their enemies, in line with their testimony, to devour those who would stop that testimony. They have great power in this way... This is great power. But they are in sackcloth — in sorrow and suffering. This power is only in their hand when they need it. And it is there only to secure and keep up their testimony, not to set aside the power of the beast itself.
The judgment is not sweeping. It falls on people one by one, and only on those who go from rejecting the message to attacking the messengers.
Death is the certain portion of anyone who wants to harm the witnesses. Some will receive the testimony, and it may be many. Others — by far the greater number — reject the message with pride and scorn. Another group will try to harm the witnesses by violence or slander. Stern judgment falls on this last group. It does not fall on the crowd, but on one person at a time, as the opposition to the witnesses turns violent.
The clause repeats twice for a reason: the attacker dies, the witness lives. God keeps them alive for as long as He wants them speaking.
God is the God of the earth. Though the holy city is trampled down, He has not given up His claim to the earth. So before He makes that claim good in unstoppable power, He keeps His witness going in the face of the enemy. So much so that, for the whole time of their testimony, no one can touch them. It is their attackers who die, not them.
The witnesses carry powers already seen in Israel's history.
Notice here that the power of the two witnesses in Revelation shows itself in two kinds of signs. They shut heaven so that no rain falls, and they bring down fire from heaven; and if anyone wants to harm them, that is how he must be killed. That is Elijah. They strike the earth with every plague as often as they want. That is Moses.
The Lord Himself refused to do this, and rebuked two of His disciples for wanting it.
This shows that it was not true Christian testimony... It was the very thing the Son would not do when He was on earth, and the thing He rebuked James and John for wanting (Luke 9:54-55). Here, instead, fire comes out of their mouth and devours their enemies. That is exactly right when God is about to take the place of Judge on earth. But the Lord does not take that place now. He is saving sinners... It would be foreign to Christianity, and against everything Christianity breathes, if a believer wished the death or injury of someone who opposed him with evil intent. Christianity shows that the victory grace gives us is to show love and kindness to an enemy.
This judgment is not cruelty. It comes after grace has failed to move people, and it aims at something beyond punishment.
This is not the grace of Christianity. It is the ministry of power in the manner of Elijah and Moses. The judgment must come because grace has had no effect, and its outcome will be blessing, for "when your judgments are in the earth, the inhabitants of the world learn righteousness" (Isa. 26:9).
Some push this fire forward to the final judgment at the end of the world. One writer answers that the power belongs to the witnesses now:
Some try to dodge the difficulty of the devouring fire that comes out of them by pointing to the final fiery judgment on God's enemies. But what could be weaker than such excuses? The true and full meaning is judicial power now, ongoing or occasional, against everyone who opposes them: like Elijah's among a people who had turned away from God, and like Moses' among a people oppressed and enslaved by the Gentiles. Their testimony is prophecy, not the gospel, so it is armed with judgment instead of breathing grace.
- Word — the fire comes out of their mouth. Their testimony carries the judgment against those who try to silence them.
- Guard — the power defends them. It secures their witness; it does not topple the beast. Whoever attacks them dies instead.
- Pattern — the signs are Elijah's and Moses': fire and shut heavens, and plagues on the earth.
- Contrast — Christ refused this and rebuked James and John for wanting it. Today the victory grace gives is kindness to an enemy.
- Purpose — judgment comes because grace had no effect, and it ends in blessing. When God's judgments are in the earth, people learn righteousness.
These have power to shut the heaven that no rain may fall during the days of their prophecy; and they have power over the waters to turn them into blood, and to smite the earth as often as they will with every plague.
In Revelation 11 two witnesses prophesy in sackcloth, and this verse hands them power over sky, waters and earth. Why does God back their testimony with drought, blood and plagues instead of the mercy heard in the gospel?
Each power named here belongs to a prophet Scripture already knows.
We may note here that the power of the two witnesses in Revelation shows itself in these two kinds of signs. They shut heaven so that no rain falls. They bring down fire from heaven. If anyone wants to harm them, he must be killed in this way. That is Elijah. They strike the earth with every plague as often as they wish. That is Moses.
The conditions of Moses' and Elijah's day come back. Israel returns to idolatry and to foreign rule.
In fact, those times match much of what you have in Moses and Elijah. There was idolatry in Israel then, and Elijah gave a remarkable testimony against it. God Himself punished His people, and the sky above them was like brass. So it will be again. The man who then controls Israel's future will turn away from God, and he will allow and enforce idolatry. Israel will again live under the authority of the nations, as they did in the days of Moses. Yet a little remnant will be set apart for God.
The two prophets also addressed different parties:
Elijah witnessed to a people in relation to God; Moses to a hostile power. In this way God would show how He will leave the people among whom the witness is given without excuse.
Some read this chapter as the literal return of those two men.
This does not mean that they are Moses and Elijah themselves. It means that their testimony has a similar character, and that God backs it as He backed the testimony of those two honoured servants long ago.
This kind of power returns when God's people are in disorder. The verse also names three spheres: sky, waters, earth.
Here we find again the power of Elijah and of Moses. It is the proof that God takes up His relationship with His people once more, but in a sovereign way, through prophets as in earlier days — when His people were in Egypt, or cut off from the temple, as in the time of Elijah. This is always what God does when His people are in disorder and He returns to His relationship with them. The witnesses shut the heavens; they have authority over the waters and over the earth. The three things which we have seen to be objects of judgment (chapter 8) are now in their power.
This power has a purpose and a limit.
Verse 6 gives them the same kind and extent of power that Moses and Elijah had. Elijah shut up heaven; Moses turned water to blood and struck Egypt with plagues. To this last there is no limit — every plague whenever they will. This is great power; but they are in sackcloth — in sorrow and suffering. This power is only in their hand in time of need. And it serves only to secure and maintain their testimony, not to set aside the power of the beast itself.
This way of working would be out of place in the Christian's calling today.
How useless to apply all this to witnessing Christians, in the West or the East, earlier or later! In practice their calling was not to resist evil, to love their enemies, to bless those who cursed them, to do good to those who hated them, and to pray for their persecutors. And the Lord Himself showed the pattern for this calling: their heavenly Father. He does not shut heaven so that no rain falls. He does the opposite, and sends rain in mercy on just and unjust alike, with no distinction between them.
Yet judgment is not the end of God's purpose.
This is not the grace of Christianity. It is the ministry of power in the manner of Elijah and of Moses. This judgment must come because grace has proved ineffective. And its outcome will be blessing, for "when your judgments are in the earth, the inhabitants of the world learn righteousness" (Isaiah 26:9).
- Two powers. Shutting heaven is Elijah's sign. Turning water to blood and sending plagues is Moses' sign. One testimony carries both.
- Two targets. Elijah spoke to a people in relation to God. Moses confronted a hostile power. Together they leave the hearers without excuse.
- Two men, not returned. The likeness is in the character and backing of the testimony, not in the identity of the witnesses.
- Power fenced in. The plagues fall as often as the witnesses choose. But the power is there to guard their testimony, not to remove the beast. They wear sackcloth while they hold it.
- Power for a different day. The believer's calling now is to bless enemies and mirror a Father who sends rain on just and unjust. Judgment comes in that day only because grace has proved ineffective. Its end is that the world learns righteousness.
And when they shall have completed their testimony, the beast who comes up out of the abyss shall make war with them, and shall conquer them, and shall kill them
Revelation 11 has just described two witnesses no one could touch. Fire came out of their mouths against anyone who tried to harm them. Verse 7 flips the picture. A beast rises from the bottomless pit, makes war on them, and kills them.
The order matters. The beast does not interrupt the testimony. He acts only once it is complete. One writer sets this beside Christ's own life:
God preserves them despite the beast, till their work is done. But as soon as their testimony ends, God allows the beast to overcome them. It is just as it was with the Lord. The greatest pressure came against Him in His service.
Some have tried to soften the word "finished," so that the witnesses could die partway through. One writer rejects that reading:
The truth is simple. Take the word in its regular meaning and in harmony with the context, and God protects the witnesses for the whole 1260 days of their testimony. Then, once their mission is complete, and not before, God permits the beast to fight them, overcome them, and kill them.
The "bottomless pit" is a specific place in this book — not the final place of punishment, but a prison:
The word is ἄβυσσος, literally 'without a bottom,' an abyss. The passages in Revelation show us that the abyss is where the Satanic powers are shut up. It is not where they will be punished. That place is the lake of fire.
Elsewhere this same beast rises out of the sea. The two pictures give two origins for one power:
This is the first mention of the Beast in these apocalyptic visions. He is named as one well known. In Daniel 7:2-3 and Revelation 13:1 the Beast, or Rome, rises from the sea. That is, it rises out of the struggling masses of mankind, out of a scene of anarchy and confusion... But our text says the Beast comes "up out of the abyss." So while its historical rise is human, its revival is satanic.
Some readers take the phrase as a time marker. One writer answers that it describes what he is, not when he comes:
Next it is assumed that Revelation 11:7, "the beast that rises from the bottomless pit," means the beast who then rises from the bottomless pit. There is no proof of this. It is a characteristic, and not a date. Isn't it better to believe that he takes this character when Satan is cast down from heaven and is full of rage, and that the dragon then gives him his throne and great authority?
Three verbs pile up: war, conquer, kill. One writer marks how new this outcome is for God's servants:
"It was allowed to make war on the saints and to conquer them." Some are killed — for example, the two witnesses. This could never have happened before. God never allowed His saints to be overcome.
Even so, the beast is not acting freely. Both what he does and how long he does it are held within limits:
The Beast has found his way from Rome to Jerusalem. Rome is the capital seat of Gentile power, both civil and religious. There he ravages and murders as he pleases. Yet both his power and the length of time he may use it are under divine control.
The time he is given is fixed, and killing the witnesses falls at the end of it:
The Beast continues for at least seven years, but his power to persecute is limited to 1260 days, or forty-two months of thirty days each. The Beast is then allowed, at the close of his active career, to enter Jerusalem and kill the witnesses — "his last political act," as one has said.
What the beast counts as conquest, heaven records the other way round:
Looked at from man's side, the beast had made war with them and "conquered them." Looked at from God's side, they have "conquered the beast."... God is always victorious in the end, and so are those who trust Him.
- Finished, then killed. The beast strikes only after the testimony is complete. Until their work is done, no one can touch them.
- Protected like their Lord. Christ faced the greatest pressure in His service. His hour came only when His work was done.
- Human rise, satanic revival. In Daniel and Revelation 13 the beast rises "out of the sea," out of the struggling masses of mankind. Here he rises "from the bottomless pit." His final power is satanic.
- Power on a leash. He murders at will. Yet God fixes both what he does and how long he does it. His power to persecute runs 1260 days, and killing the witnesses is his last political act.
- Conquered and conquering. From man's side the beast conquered them. From God's side they conquered the beast. Same event, read from heaven.
and their body [shall be] on the street of the great city, which is called spiritually Sodom and Egypt, where also their Lord was crucified.
The two witnesses have just been killed. Their bodies lie in the open street of a city that is never named, only described. God identifies it by three things: a title, two nicknames, and one crime.
One clause settles which city this is.
The words "where their Lord was crucified" make it clear that the scene of their testimony is Jerusalem. Whatever wrong has been done to the Lord's name at Rome, and however truly Rome may be pointed to in a secondary application, it would be an inexcusable twisting of the text to claim that any other city could be meant. It can only be the city where our Lord was actually put to death: Jerusalem.
The wording of that clause matters. Walter Scott points out that the better reading is "their Lord," not "our Lord."
"Where also their (not our) Lord was crucified." This clause rules out any symbolic application of the city to the Church. The Jerusalem of history is identified here by the crowning act of her guilt.
Earlier in this chapter the same city is holy. Here the title changes. The two views stand side by side on purpose.
Jerusalem is seen in two very different ways: by its place in God's purposes, and by its actual condition. This chapter gives us both views. When it speaks of God's purposes, and of the guilt of the nations who trample the city down, it calls Jerusalem "the holy city." But here the city is seen in its spiritual state, under the power of "the beast that ascends out of the bottomless pit," and it is described as sunk in the deepest moral darkness.
Greatness here is not a compliment.
Marked out for its lusts as Sodom, and for its cruelty to the people of God as Egypt, the city is no longer called the "holy" city but the "great" city — great even in its crimes.
The verse says the city is "symbolically" called Sodom and Egypt; older translations say "spiritually". The names describe character, not geography. Commentators fill each one out a little differently.
Sodom has become a symbol of the world in its unrestrained lust and wickedness. There man drags himself down below the level of the animals, so that the cry of it goes up for God to step in and judge. Egypt is a symbol of the world with its splendid outward show. It supplies everything that serves man's pleasures and the appetites of the flesh. Yet Egypt itself is ruled by a degrading idolatry, which even enslaves the people of God if they fall under its power. All this may be great in man's eyes but it certainly is not holy.
Refusing burial was a deliberate insult.
Their bodies lie in the street. The malice of their enemies leaves them exposed and refuses them burial. But God allows it, so that the bodies stand as an open charge against those who have now finally rejected His righteous rule.
There is calculation behind it too. J. A. Trench suggests they had learned from the burial of Christ:
In verse 9 they profit from past experience. Because they allowed Christ to be buried, they will not allow burial to these witnesses. So it all happens in the open, and not out of sight as Christ's resurrection was (verse 12).
The description is not only about the future. Bob Costen applies it to the land as it is now.
Jerusalem as it now is, the city we read about in the Bible and in our newspapers, is the city that "symbolically is called Sodom and Egypt, where their Lord was crucified" (Rev. 11:8). It is not a holy land. When people talk about going to "the holy land", we know what they mean. They want to go where Jesus walked and see Palestine. That is fine if they want to take a trip, but it is an unholy land.
- Named — God does not print the city's name. He prints its crime: the place where their Lord was crucified. That one clause makes it Jerusalem.
- Stripped — Earlier in the chapter it is the holy city. Here it is the great city. The first is what God purposes for it; the second is what it has become.
- Charged — Sodom stands for lust and corruption, Egypt for idolatry and the enslaving of God's people. The names describe character, not a place on a map.
- Exposed — Refusing burial was meant as contempt. God lets the unburied bodies stand as a public charge against the men who left them there.
- Warned — A city can keep its religious reputation long after God has renamed it. The words "their Lord" tie the verse to a real city and a real guilt, not to a symbol.
And [men] of the peoples and tribes and tongues and nations see their body three days and a half, and they do not suffer their bodies to be put into a sepulchre.
The beast has just killed the two witnesses. Their bodies lie in the open street of the city where their Lord was crucified. What follows is not a burial but a public show: a watching world, a refused grave, and a fixed span of three and a half days.
The verse names one crowd. Writers point out that the surrounding verses sort the scene into separate groups, each with its own guilt.
There are three classes in this dark picture: (1) The beast who murders the witnesses. (2) Those "of the peoples, and tribes, and languages, and nations." They look at the bodies of the prophets, thrown out onto the street or the public places of the city, open to everyone's stares. They also show their hatred and scorn by forbidding the burial of the bodies, a shameful act. (3) "Those who dwell on the earth," the worst of the peoples of that day who had abandoned the faith. All the groups named here really live on the earth, but that phrase carries a moral meaning. They have turned their backs on Christianity. They firmly rejected the heavenly calling and chose the earth instead.
The distinction matters. Refusing burial is the malice of the nations. And those who celebrate miss what is about to happen.
The Gentiles and "those who dwell on the earth" rejoice over the silencing of this testimony. They little suspect that, in spite of the death of the witnesses, the prophecy is on the very eve of fulfilment... Here two classes stand apart: the nations or Gentiles, and the dwellers on the earth. Of the first, "some" — no doubt a vast majority — rejoice, and in their triumph will not even allow anyone to bury the bodies... These people love the world and live for it. So the witnesses' prophecy of a coming kingdom of righteousness and judgment is unbearable to them.
In Jerusalem's past, leaving a body unburied was itself part of God's judgment.
One of the judgments announced against the people of Jerusalem was that they should not be buried. Birds and wild animals would eat their bodies. Jeremiah 16:4. With God's two future witnesses in Jerusalem, the wicked will rejoice over their dead bodies and will not let anyone bury them. Then their joy turns to terror. They see them stand on their feet alive again, and watch them go up to heaven. Revelation 11:9-12.
Writers take the three and a half days as ordinary days, like the other time periods named in this chapter.
The three and a half days mentioned twice (vv. 9, 11) are literal days. It is impossible to take them any other way. We stand on the eve of the events that close the last prophetic week. Probably not many days remain, much less years, before the Lord returns to take His power and kingdom to Himself. The four periods of time named in this chapter are literal and exact. They belong not to the historical past, but to the coming crisis.
The bodies lie in one city, yet nations far away see them. One writer suggests how, and insists the death is no illusion.
The two witnesses suffer bitter rejection and apparent shameful defeat. Murdering them is not enough for their enemies. They leave their dead bodies on the street in Jerusalem... Other nations also watch these dead bodies for 3½ days, perhaps by means of television. There can be no doubt of their actual physical death.
The refusal to bury is meant as a final insult. It becomes the very thing that puts the enemies in front of God's answer.
In the sight of their enemies the two witnesses are raised from death and stand on their feet (v. 11). If they had buried them, they would not have seen this great sight. But they take a morbid delight in staring at the dead bodies. So they expose themselves to the terror of seeing them come to life.
Commentators differ over whether the witnesses are two persons or a larger company. The wording of this verse itself is part of the argument.
The beast "makes war against them, and overcomes them, and kills them." The nations, peoples and languages see their bodies "in the broad street of the city." This wording inclines me to think that they are not only two persons, but a large body of people. Their power is of God (v. 3), and He places them as His witnesses.
- Seen — Their bodies lie in the open street. People from every tribe, language and nation stare at them. The death is real, not staged.
- Scorned — Refusing a grave is open contempt. It echoes the old judgment on Jerusalem, where bodies were left unburied (Jeremiah 16:4).
- Sorted — The scene divides the guilty into three. The beast kills. The nations stare and forbid a grave. The earth-dwellers are worst, for their name marks a settled choice of earth over heaven.
- Short — The gloating lasts three and a half literal days, as exact as the other time periods in this chapter.
- Sprung — The insult becomes a trap. Because they refused a grave, the enemies are standing there when the witnesses rise, and their joy turns to terror.
And they that dwell upon the earth rejoice over them, and are full of delight, and shall send gifts one to another, because these, the two prophets, tormented them that dwell upon the earth.
Two prophets lie dead in the street of the great city. The world does not fall silent. It celebrates, with a worldwide holiday and gifts sent back and forth. The verse gives the reason in one word: torment.
Everyone in this chapter lives on the planet. So the phrase marks out something in the heart, not an address.
This phrase does not simply mean people who live on the earth. It carries a moral force. It means people who are earthly-minded at the core, who do not rise above the earth in heart or in ways.
Does the phrase point to a place, or to a state of heart?
In Revelation, "the earth" seems to mean what we would call the civilised world — a region the light has reached and where it has at least outwardly stayed. Yet wherever the words "those who dwell on the earth" occur, they readily bear a moral meaning. They are a class who make an outward profession of the light. They even admit that the testimony in the word of God is true — both its witness to the present grace of the gospel and its witness to the coming judgment on the world. Still, their interests lie only on the earth.
Verse 9 shows people from every nation refusing burial to the bodies. Verse 10 names a group that goes further.
There are three classes in this dark picture: (1) The beast who murders the witnesses. (2) Those "from the peoples and tribes and languages and nations," who look at the bodies of the prophets thrown out on the street of the city, exposed to the crude stares of the crowd. They show their hatred and scorn by forbidding the burial of the bodies — a shameful act. (3) "Those who dwell on the earth," the worst among the apostate peoples of that day… Bad as the beast and his allies are, these dwellers on the earth are infinitely worse. The nations deny burial to the bodies of the martyred witnesses; the earth-dwellers keep high and joyful holiday, and exchange gifts and congratulations over the killing of the prophets.
The same writer explains the custom behind the celebration.
Sending presents or gifts on occasions of public joy is an old and universal custom (Proverbs 19:6; Esther 2:18; Esther 9:19-22). Death has silenced the voice of the witnesses, and this is the cause of the public rejoicing.
The word "torment" explains the whole celebration. So what did the two prophets actually do to these people?
Unbelief likes present enjoyment. Anything that gets in the way of it and makes the conscience uneasy is hated and unwelcome.
The torment came from lives lived close to God among people who had turned away from Him.
The testimony of holy consistency and prophetic nearness to God is a constant torment to those whom that testimony confronts about their apostasy. A prophet like this is always a witness that, for all their pride and self-satisfaction, they have fallen away from God. That is torment, because they really have no peace with God, whatever they pretend.
The message itself was the problem, not only the messengers.
These people love the world and live for it. The witnesses foretold a kingdom of righteousness and judgment, and to such people that prophecy is unbearable. So their joy is intense when news comes that the hated witnesses are dead and the dreaded testimony is silent.
This reaction is not only a future thing. It can be seen now.
The careless world opposes true witness to Christ in the gospel. But it stirs a specially fierce resentment and rejection in today's modernists, whose effort is to reduce the faith of Christ to a mere scheme for earthly improvement. They deny that it came from heaven, and that it leads to heaven. They simply cannot stand its truth; it torments them.
The celebration collapses almost as soon as the gifts arrive.
Their triumph is brief. Only three and a half days pass before a miraculous display of God's power terrifies them. It shows His acceptance of the fallen witnesses and His wrath against the men who destroyed them and gloated over it.
The witnesses stand up. A voice calls them to heaven, and they go up while their enemies watch.
- Choice. "Those who dwell on the earth" is a moral label more than a location. These people admit the light and still fix their whole interest on this world.
- Torment. That choice is why the witnesses tormented them. Nearness to God exposed people who had turned away from Him and had no peace with Him.
- Silence. Killing the messengers looks like the end of the torment. So the news brings a worldwide holiday and gifts.
- Degrees. The beast murders. The nations deny burial. The earth-dwellers throw a party — and commentators call them the worst of the three.
- Reversal. The party lasts three and a half days. Then the witnesses stand up and rise to heaven while their enemies watch.
And after the three days and a half [the] spirit of life from God came into them, and they stood upon their feet; and great fear fell upon those beholding them.
The two witnesses lie dead in the street of the great city. The world refuses them burial and sends gifts to celebrate their silence. Then God acts. What looked like the end of their testimony becomes its most public moment — and the watching crowd is gripped by terror, not joy.
The world's rejoicing is cut short. One writer reads the reversal as God's verdict on two parties at once — the men who were killed, and the men who killed them.
But their triumph is brief. Only three and a half days have passed. Then a miraculous display of God's power terrifies them. It shows His acceptance of the fallen witnesses, and His anger against those who destroyed them and celebrated over them.
They do not just revive; they stand. One writer sees in that standing a settled strength, and traces the onlookers' fear to what their own consciences now admit.
The energy of life, eternal life, from God is put forth, and the witnesses rise in its power and stand on their feet. Their witness is finished and their trials are past. They stand in the strength and stability of a life that death cannot touch. The whole world watches this act of resurrection. The Gentiles who have turned away from God see it, and their own consciences admit that it is from God. The effect is terror and alarm.
One writer weighs the wording closely. The ESV reads "a breath of life"; older translations have "a spirit of life" — and the writer asks why it is not "the Spirit of life."
This was what marked what entered them and set them on their feet — a Spirit of life. The point was not to present the Spirit as an object, but to show the character of this sudden event and its source. To say "the Spirit of life" here would have gone too far. That would have amounted to a declaration that the Holy Spirit came and dwelt in them; but that was not the point. It was simply that this living power, from God, changed the whole state of things.
Refusing burial was meant as the final insult. It backfires: the enemies are standing right there when the bodies rise.
However, this wicked folly of Israel's leaders makes them witness their own defeat. In the sight of their enemies the two witnesses are raised from death and stand on their feet (v. 11). If they had buried them, they would not have seen this great sight. But they took a morbid delight in staring at the dead bodies. So they expose themselves to the terror of seeing them come to life. These witnesses stand there long enough to impress men with the reality of their resurrection.
Commentators differ on how to take the time note. One takes every period of time in the chapter as exact and still future.
The three and a half days mentioned twice (vv. 9, 11) are literal days. It is impossible to regard them otherwise. We are here on the eve of the events that close the last prophetic week… There is no room or need to take the time as anything but literal. The four periods of time named in this chapter are literal and exact. They belong to the coming crisis, not to past history.
Another allows a literal fulfilment in the crisis, yet reads most of the language as symbolic. He also marks what has changed in the testimony itself.
There may be a more literal fulfilment of this in the crisis. Even so, nothing in the reviving of the witnesses makes it strictly literal. On the contrary, the terms are mostly symbolic. "A spirit of life from God," though it may be applied that way, does not strictly describe a mere giving of life. It was, however, something different from a simple renewal of prophecy in sackcloth. The testimony now was by their public exaltation, not by their faithfulness under trial.
- Cause: The world celebrates for three and a half days over two silenced prophets. Then God's power reverses it, showing that He accepts His servants and is angry with their killers.
- Gift: What enters them is life from God. The wording does not name the Holy Spirit as a person living in them. It marks a living power whose source is God, and it changes everything at once.
- Reach: They stand on their feet in a life death cannot touch. Their witness is finished, their trials are past, their strength is settled.
- Result: The insult of leaving them unburied backfires. The enemies stand there as eyewitnesses of the resurrection they never wanted to see.
- Reading: Commentators differ on the three and a half days. Some take every period in the chapter as literal and still future. Others read the language as mostly symbolic. Both agree on one thing: the testimony now speaks through public exaltation, not through suffering.
And I heard a great voice out of the heaven saying to them, Come up here; and they went up to the heaven in the cloud, and their enemies beheld them.
God's two witnesses lay dead in the street while their killers celebrated, and now breath returns to them and a voice calls them up. Three questions follow: whose voice is it, why does the text say the cloud, and why does God do this in front of the men who killed them?
Who is calling, and where does the call take them? One writer answers both:
John then heard "a loud voice from heaven." This was the voice of Jehovah, or of someone He empowered. It spoke to the witnesses, now raised in bodies that are immortal and cannot decay. They stood in front of their enemies, and their enemies were overcome with fear. "Come up here." In Heaven they are to find their place and portion. What an answer to earth's scorn, reproach, and murder!
Translations differ here: some read "in a cloud," others "in the cloud." One writer says the difference matters:
It is not merely in a cloud, as some translations read, but in the cloud. I think it was the cloud seen at the start of Revelation 10, the one that wrapped around the mighty angel. That cloud is the known, special emblem of Jehovah's presence. It received the witnesses. It proved that their Lord, the Lord of heaven as well as earth, was on their side. They went up to heaven right in front of their enemies.
Walter Scott adds a contrast with the hope given to believers:
We are to be caught up in the clouds; they went up in the cloud, not in a cloud. Only here and in Luke 9:34 do we read of people entering into the glory cloud, the cloud of the divine presence.
Nothing here is hidden. Commentators note how this differs from every other departure to heaven in the Bible:
The public saw both things: the witnesses raised, and their triumphant departure from the scene of their testimony and suffering. In these two ways they differ from Christ and from the heavenly saints. No human eye saw Christ come out of the tomb, and only His disciples watched Him go up. There is not a hint that anyone on earth will see our coming resurrection and removal to heaven.
The enemies' own cruelty put them in the front row:
If they had buried them, they would not have seen this great sight. Instead they took a sick delight in staring at the dead bodies, so they left themselves open to the terror of seeing them come back to life. These witnesses stand there long enough to convince people that their resurrection is real. Then a great voice from heaven calls them to come up.
They lose everything on earth and gain everything in heaven. One writer sets the loss against the gain:
Earth throws them out. In our Lord's prophecy they appear as brothers of the King: hungry and thirsty, strangers, naked and sick and in prison. Heaven welcomes them with delight as people the earth was not worthy of — a gleaning after harvest, as it were, of wheat for God's granary. They have lost the blessing on earth; they have gained the blessing in heaven. Their light was put out for a time, so that it may shine in a higher place forever.
after fix: restores "earth" (original), splits hard sentences
Their rise is not only their vindication. It also signals what is coming for the powers that killed them:
They suffer under the beast, but are caught up to a heavenly portion, not an earthly one. Their going up foreshadowed the speedy fall of the beast and his followers.
- Silenced. Their enemies killed them and left them unburied. The world thought it had won.
- Summoned. A great voice from heaven — Jehovah's own, or one sent by Him — calls them up, and heaven becomes "their place and portion."
- Sheltered. They rise in the cloud, the known emblem of God's presence. It proves the Lord of heaven and earth was on their side all along.
- Seen. No hostile eye saw Christ rise, and none will see the saints caught up. This departure happens in full view of the murderers.
- Signal. Their going up warns of what comes next. Earth cast them out, heaven received them, and the beast falls soon after.
And in that hour there was a great earthquake, and the tenth of the city fell, and seven thousand names of men were slain in the earthquake. And the remnant were filled with fear, and gave glory to the God of the heaven.
The two witnesses have just risen and gone up to heaven in full view of their killers. In that same hour, the city that had gloated over their dead bodies is shaken to pieces. What follows is a strange half-response. The survivors honour God, but only because they are terrified.
Earthquakes run through this book. Does this one shake the ground, or only society?
Under the sixth seal, the earthquake is without doubt a violent breakup of society, of all government and social order. But here, in the narrow and limited sphere before us, we judge that a literal earthquake is meant. It will destroy a part of the city and kill seven thousand — a complete number devoted to death. Jerusalem has been the scene of similar visitations in the past, as it will be in the future. An upheaval of the forces of nature, bringing destruction of life and property, exactly suits the case. It would press on the rest of the guilty inhabitants the solemn fact that God's intervention in judgment was a stern reality.
The timing is deliberate.
The hour of triumph for the witnesses was the hour when justice repaid the city where they had testified. That city had shed their blood without cause. We understand a "tenth" here as meaning a complete judgment. So the ten plagues on Egypt were the sum of God's completed judgments upon that land.
Seven thousand is a number with a history in Israel, and here its meaning is turned around.
God devotes seven thousand here to death. That number reminds us of "the seven thousand in Israel" whom God had reserved for Himself (1 Kings 19:18) — again a link, by contrast, to the times of Elijah. We need not think of an exact company of just seven thousand, any more than the numbers in Revelation 7:4-8 and 14:3 are literal. What is before us is simply a full and perfect number, whether large or small.
The text literally says "names of men." One writer hears an edge in that.
The earthquake killed 7,000 persons — "names of men," as the text puts it here. That wording fits a history of doom for people who are asserting their greatness upon the earth.
The survivors give glory to God. But writers here read that as terror, not a change of heart.
The judgment then becomes alarming. The Spirit of God raises up the witnesses, and they go up to heaven. Then the rest, frightened but not converted, give glory to the God of heaven. But it is too late. No wonder the Lord says of that time that it is such as never was, and that unless those days are cut short, no one will be saved. There is alarm at the judgments disclosed, but no reception of the testimony. There is zeal for God, but not according to knowledge.
Another writer allows that the shaking achieves something, but leaves the deeper question open.
The shaking does some good, however. Those who were not killed were at least terrified enough to give glory to the God of heaven. Whether they were really brought to God in faith is another question.
Notice which name for God they choose.
It will be easier then for men to acknowledge God above in a vague way. It is harder to own Him as the Lord of the earth, who concerns Himself with what men do here below. The first might be only to regard Him as One seen in the distance... The worldly man can well allow the thought of God far off from himself, and this is just what we have here. They were alarmed by what was near. But there was no reception of the testimony, no conversion.
Why would frightened people reach for that title and no other? Because of what it lets them avoid.
Until the conscience is thoroughly searched and the soul brought into the light, there can be no fellowship with God. They wish Him away from the scene of their interests. When terror overwhelms their souls, they are willing enough to "give glory to the God of the heaven," because that keeps Him at a distance. But the special testimony of this book is to God's right and title to the earth. That is the very question in dispute with these people who have abandoned Him. So until men recognise God's right and claim to the earth, further and severer judgment must come.
- Hour. God honours the witnesses and strikes the city in the same hour — one event with two faces.
- Measure. The "tenth" and the "seven thousand" are not statistics. Each marks a complete judgment: a full, defined number given over to death.
- Names. The text lists the dead as "names of men." Reputation is worth nothing in a record of doom for people who assert their greatness.
- Fear. Terror produces honour, not repentance. There is alarm at the judgments, but no reception of the testimony. Writers differ on whether it ever goes deeper.
- Distance. They grant God heaven but deny Him the earth. That is the very claim His witnesses died for, so further and severer judgment must come.
The second woe has passed; behold, the third woe comes quickly.
The line is a signpost. A long stretch of vision stands between the sixth trumpet in chapter 9 and the seventh in verse 15 — the mighty angel, the little book, the measured temple, the two witnesses. This one sentence tells the reader where all of that belongs in the order of events.
The announcement looks back as much as forward. It reaches over everything since chapter 9 and ties it to the sixth trumpet. That is what dates those events.
At chapter 10 we reach a pause in the prophecy of the seven trumpet judgments. The pause lets us see the ways of God in keeping a witness for Christ on the earth. That is during the solemn period of the sixth trumpet, the second woe. This parenthesis closes with the statement of Revelation 11:14 that the second woe has passed and the third woe is soon to come. This surely shows that the events described in it happen during the second woe, and that the third woe, the seventh trumpet judgment, follows at once. The details in this passage show that these events fall in the three and a half years just before Christ comes to claim His earthly kingdom.
A similar pause comes between the sixth and seventh seals. The two pauses do not do the same work.
The events shown between the sixth and seventh seals prepare the way for the seventh seal. The events in the parenthesis between the last two trumpets belong with the sixth trumpet and add to it. We see this because the announcement that the second woe has passed does not come until Revelation 11:14.
The three woe-trumpets do not repeat each other. Each has its own source and its own target.
The third woe will come from God Himself, just as plainly as the first came out of the abyss on the wicked Israelites, and the second came from the vast powers of the east on the faithless west. For it is the seventh trumpet. This matters for understanding how the book is built. The seventh trumpet carries us down to the end in a broad but final summary.
Another writer sets out the same three woes by who suffers under each.
The first woe was marked by Satan's power, and those who suffered it were Jews who had turned away from God. The second came through human hands, and it fell on the Roman empire. The last is God's own woe, and it falls on the nations in general, because it goes with the setting up of Messiah's kingdom.
The verse does not leave the timing open. Older translations read that the third woe "comes quickly," which is the wording the writers use. Either way, no gap is left between the scene just described and the end.
This episode closes the second woe, which is the sixth trumpet. We are told that the seventh trumpet and third woe follow quickly, for there is to be no more delay, as we saw in Revelation 10:6. So there is hardly any gap between the resurrection and ascension of the witnesses and the final act. That act closes man's day and brings in the kingdom.
Verse 13 has just described how the survivors of the earthquake responded. It can look like the start of repentance. Commentators read it another way, and that reading explains why a third woe still has to come.
Those who are not killed give glory to the God of heaven. This is the unacceptable product of mere human fear, and nothing comes of it. God is claiming the earth, not only heaven, and His witnesses have died to affirm that claim. Men can allow Him heaven while they deny Him the earth. And judgment takes its course.
The seventh trumpet brings the third woe, and it is not what the word leads you to expect.
The third woe is the coming of the kingdom!
Whether that is dread or joy depends on the one who hears it.
That great kingdom is no woe to the renewed heart. It will bring unspeakable blessing. But to the godless rebel it is the worst of all woes. Each such rebel must now face the exposure of all his stored-up guilt. The One he has despised and rejected will judge him — Jesus, the exalted Son of Man, the eternal Son of God.
- Marker. The verse is a bookmark. It closes the long parenthesis of chapters 10–11:13 and ties those events back to the sixth trumpet. That places them in the last three and a half years before Christ claims His earthly kingdom.
- Source. The three woes rise by source. The first came out of the abyss, the second through human hands, the third from God Himself.
- Speed. "Soon" means no gap worth measuring. Once the witnesses rise, the final act follows at once.
- Refusal. Terror made the survivors give glory to "the God of heaven," but they still would not give Him the earth He claims. Fear that changes nothing leaves judgment to run its course.
- Kingdom. The last woe turns out to be the reign of Christ. It is unspeakable blessing to the renewed heart. To the rebel it is the worst of woes, for he must now meet the One he rejected.
And the seventh angel sounded [his] trumpet and there were great voices in the heaven, saying, The kingdom of the world of our Lord and of his Christ is come, and he shall reign to the ages of ages.
The seventh and last trumpet sounds. No new plague falls on the earth. Instead, loud voices break out in heaven. Heaven announces a change of ownership, not a slow improvement of the world. Commentators ask two things: what the voices announce, and why heaven celebrates before earth's trouble ends.
The six trumpets before this one each brought a blow. The seventh breaks the pattern.
In these respects the seventh trumpet is very like the seventh seal. It too is brief. It closes the trumpet-series of judgment — in fact the three special woes. And it opens into another condition of things. That condition is not woe at all, but the time long looked for.
The older English wording speaks of "kingdoms" in the plural. Commentators say the right reading is singular, and the difference matters.
It may seem a small difference, but it is not. "The kingdoms of this world" at once suggests many kings, many conflicting interests, international jealousies, and the like. "The kingdom of the world (or world-kingdom) of our Lord and of His Christ is come" means something else: one universal kingdom covering the globe, with every part of the earth brought under the rule of the One reigning monarch.
Right now Christ's kingdom is a matter of faith. That changes here. One writer also answers a common objection: Jesus said His kingdom is not of this world.
For now the kingdom is open to faith, and only believers value it. Its portion on earth is tribulation and waiting for the Lord... Instead of this we have an entire change... Someone may object that the Lord Himself in John 18 says His kingdom is not of this world. I reply that this misses the point. This world is never the source of His kingdom. But is it not destined to be its sphere? It was not His kingdom then, and that does not prove it will never be His kingdom at some future time.
Some read the verse as a promise that missions will win the world over time. The trumpets and woes point the other way, as one writer says (quoting the older plural wording):
In current missionary writing, few phrases are more common than "the conquest of the world for Christ!" Yet Scripture never uses such a phrase. The kingdoms of this world are indeed going to become "the kingdoms of our Lord and of His Christ" — but as the result of woes and judgments, not of the preaching of the gospel. There is a great difference between subduing the world to Christ and gathering people out of the world for Christ.
The two titles are not decoration. They pick up Psalm 2, where rulers band together against God and His anointed King. Here that opposition meets its end.
This phrase reminds us of Psalm 2:2: "The kings of the earth set themselves, and the rulers take counsel together, against the Lord and against His Anointed." They have done this all along. But here their proud opposition is broken, and the reign of the Lord by His Anointed begins.
The same writer says the reign does not stop at the thousand years: "Once established, His dominion abides... From this point of view the millennium and the eternal state are considered as one."
Commentators differ on how far the announcement reaches. Some read it as the reign actually arriving. Others say only heaven celebrates, while earth still faces its worst suffering.
Heaven rejoices because the kingdom is near, not because it has actually been set up. When the kingdom is established in power, earth as well as heaven will unite in thanksgiving and song... Rejoicing marks the inhabitants of heaven — the angels and the redeemed. Meanwhile the earth is preparing to enter its last agony before the light of the millennial morning dawns and clears away the gloom.
Another writer explains why prophecy can speak this way: "Again and again it is the language of prophecy to speak of things as accomplished, which in fact are not yet come" (F. B. Hole).
One writer turns this future transfer into comfort for believers now.
This is not the brightest thought our souls can enjoy about the future. Still, the fact that the Lord Jesus is to take the throne of the world is a very great rest to the heart in all the present confusion... We shall not be subjects merely of Christ when He comes, but kings reigning with Him.
- Sounded — the seventh trumpet brings no new plague. It closes the series and opens onto the time long waited for.
- Singular — not many rival kingdoms handed out piece by piece, but one world-kingdom under one reigning King.
- Sphere — the kingdom never came from this world. This world is where it will be seen, and not by faith only.
- Seized — the change comes through judgment, not through preaching winning the world over.
- Settled — heaven sings it as done while earth still trembles. The reign runs on to the ages of ages, and that certainty steadies the heart now.
And the twenty-four elders, who sit on their thrones before God, fell upon their faces, and worshipped God,
The seventh trumpet has sounded and heaven has just announced that the world-kingdom now belongs to the Lord and to His Christ. Verse 16 gives the answer of the twenty-four elders: they leave their thrones and fall on their faces.
The elders appear again and again in Revelation. Their number and their clothing point back to the priests of Israel.
Revelation often mentions the twenty-four elders John saw in heaven. He saw them around the throne, sitting on thrones (not seats), dressed in white, with crowns of gold on their heads, and they worship God. In the Old Testament, when everything was in order, there were twenty-four courses, or groups, of priests. Each group had an elder as its head (1 Chronicles 24:7-18). The elders in Revelation are twenty-four in number, and may point back to them. The elders in heaven have harps and golden bowls full of incense, "which are the prayers of the saints" (Revelation 5:8). This shows that they act as priests. They are without doubt the redeemed, including both Old and New Testament saints.
In chapter 4 the elders sit round the throne. Here they sit before it, and one writer draws out what moves them from their seats.
"The kingdom of our Lord" here means the setting up of God's government in contrast with man's misrule. So in Revelation 11:16 we have "before" (enopion) the throne. This partly shows its moral force, for they were "round" the throne, chapter 4:4. In chapter 11 the elders are again in their own distinct place, as intelligent worshippers — not the living creatures... But the setting up of the governmental power of God draws them to prostrate worship, just as the celebration of creative glory had done in chapter 4.
Their seat is more than a detail of that moment. It says where they belong.
We are again reminded that they sat on their thrones before God. The point is not so much that they were sitting there at that moment, although they were. It is that this shows their place in the presence of God. It is characteristic; the elders occupied thrones before God. What a view this gives of the exaltation of the glorified saints! They are gathered around the Eternal Presence, and seated on thrones themselves, for they are kings as well as priests. They look on at God's ways in governing the earth as spectators — adoring spectators.
This is not the elders' first act of homage. Reading their prostrations in order shows what each one answers to.
"And the twenty-four elders fall down before Him who is seated on the throne and worship Him who lives forever and ever. They cast their crowns before the throne" (Revelation 4:10). That is in respect of creation. "And when He had taken the scroll, the four living creatures and the twenty-four elders fell down before the Lamb" (Revelation 5:8). That is in relation to redemption... Then Revelation 11:16... This one is the climax. The kingdom of this world has become the kingdom of our Lord and of His Christ.
The elders give thanks at a point when the earth below is anything but peaceful, and they do so knowing the cost.
So here the last trumpet sounds, and heaven announces "the world-kingdom of our Lord and of His Christ." At once the twenty-four elders are on their faces, giving God thanks, because He had taken to Him His great power and had reigned. It is true that this must come through much sorrow for guilty men. For the sword of judgment has to clear the way, so that the sceptre of righteousness may have free course... But they knew well that man must come down with a crash. They also knew that in the kingdom of our Lord and of His Anointed he will be lifted up in the only true and lasting way.
Commentators differ over how far the kingdom has arrived at this point. One writer reads the scene as heaven looking ahead of the event.
The anticipation of the kingdom, and not the actual setting up of it, is the cause of the rejoicing in heaven. When the kingdom is established in power, earth as well as heaven will unite in thanksgiving and song. We repeat: heaven alone celebrates the kingdom as come. Rejoicing marks those who live in heaven — the angels and the redeemed. Meanwhile the earth is getting ready to enter its last agonies, before the light of the millennial morning dawns and drives away the gloom.
- Who — the elders are the redeemed. They are pictured as twenty-four heads of the priestly groups, crowned, robed, and at home in God's presence.
- Where — they sit on thrones before God. They are kings as well as priests, watching how He governs the earth from the closest place of all.
- Why they move — creation moved them in chapter 4, redemption in chapter 5. Here God takes up His governing power, and that brings them off their thrones onto their faces.
- What it costs — they thank God knowing the price. The sword of judgment must clear the way before the sceptre of righteousness can rule.
- Where you hear it — this thanksgiving rises in heaven while earth enters its darkest hour. Heaven worships for a kingdom the world has not yet seen.
saying, We give thee thanks, Lord God Almighty, [He] who is, and who was, that thou hast taken thy great power and hast reigned.
Heaven has just announced that the world-kingdom of our Lord and of His Christ has come. The answer to that news is not a shout of victory but worship. The thanksgiving of the elders tells us who God is, what He has done, and why a reign still to come is spoken of as already past.
The thanksgiving answers an announcement made two verses earlier. One writer says the older wording of that announcement is far too weak:
As it stands now, verse 15 has been given a very weakened turn: "The kingdoms of this world have become the kingdoms of our Lord and of his Christ." The true force is: "The world-kingdom of our Lord and of his Christ is come." In my opinion this gives the verse a very different and weightier meaning. It is the world-kingdom; and why? Because this book has shown us from the very beginning that there was another order of kingdom altogether. In Revelation 1 John spoke of himself as a "brother and companion in tribulation, and in the kingdom and patience in Christ."
The elders who give thanks have a settled place of their own in God's presence.
It is characteristic; the elders occupied thrones before God. See how high a place the glorified saints are given! They are grouped around the Eternal Presence, and seated on thrones, for they are kings as well as priests. They watch God's ways in the government of the earth — and they watch as worshippers.
What they do here they do nowhere else in the book:
The elders, who represent the redeemed, answer the many voices of the heavenly host with an act of deepest worship. Their normal place is enthroned and crowned before God. Twice in chapter 5 the elders fall down and worship (vv. 8, 14). Only here is it said, "They fell upon their faces, and worshipped God." Nowhere else do the elders bow this low. The occasion demands it.
Three titles come together here, and one familiar phrase drops out. One writer explains both:
The elders give thanks to Jehovah (Lord) God Almighty, a strong combination of divine titles. Jehovah is the self-existing One. God (Elohim) is, as such, the Creator. He is Almighty too, in power and in resources. Then His Being is declared eternal: "Who is" (eternal existence), and "Who was" in relation to the past. The Authorised Version adds "and art to come," but it should be left out, as the Revised Version and other translations leave it out. "To come" would be out of place in this doxology, because the kingdom, in its time and its eternal features, is here regarded as present. That dropped phrase does belong in Revelation 4:8.
Why these particular titles here? Another writer ties them to the subject in hand:
They worship God as He was revealed in the Old Testament, that is, as Lord God Almighty (Jehovah Elohim Shaddai). The reason is that the question now is God's kingdom on earth.
The kingdom belongs to the Lord and to His Christ, yet the thanks go to one. The quote below keeps an older wording, "hast reigned," where the ESV has "begun to reign":
It is interesting to observe that while the kingdom is that of our Lord and of His Christ, or Anointed (Ps. 2), yet He takes it, not they. Jehovah and Christ are distinguished here, yet they are united in taking the kingdom and in the reign that follows. That is why the pronoun is singular where you might expect a plural. It may well be called "your great power." The fullness of divine power, the might of the Eternal God, is put forth. The kingdom in its widest sweep takes in the heavens and the earth, and stretches on through time into eternity. It has been wrested from the grasp of the enemy. And "hast reigned" is the term used — so sure that it is spoken of as past.
The kingdom the elders celebrate has not yet come in public power. One writer gives the reason:
This kingdom in its public power has been delayed, because Christ has been rejected (see Rev. 11:17). The delay lasts all the time that Christ is sitting at the right hand of God. It ends when He rises from the throne of His Father to judge. God has said, "Sit at my right hand, until I make your enemies your footstool," Psalm 110. Still, it is true that the kingdom had already come in mystery, according to Matthew 13.
- Announced — the true force of the news is that the world-kingdom of our Lord and of His Christ has come. That is weightier than kingdoms merely changing hands.
- Adored — the elders are kings and priests, enthroned before God. Only here do they fall on their faces. The occasion demands it.
- Named — the elders thank Him as Jehovah the self-existing One, God the Creator, the Almighty in power and resources; these are the titles for a kingdom on earth.
- Present — "and is to come" is left out here, because in this scene He has come. The kingdom is regarded as present.
- Delayed, not doubtful — the public kingdom waits while Christ sits at the right hand of God. Yet the reign is spoken of as past, so sure is it.
And the nations have been full of wrath, and thy wrath is come, and the time of the dead to be judged, and to give the recompense to thy servants the prophets, and to the saints, and to those who fear thy name, small and great; and to destroy those that destroy the earth.
Revelation 11 ends with the seventh trumpet. Heaven announces that the world's kingdom has passed to God and His Christ. The elders answer in one sentence. It holds rage, wrath, judgment, reward and the clearing of the earth, and it reaches from the start of Christ's reign to the very end of it.
Writers read it as a broad statement of all that follows Christ taking the throne, reaching to the far end of His kingdom:
This is a general statement, and only a general one, of what follows when the kingdom is set up in power. So it reaches down even to the close of that kingdom, since the dead will not be judged until then.
Another writer draws the same conclusion from the shape of the book itself, noting that the announcement is made before any of the details are shown:
The elders then come in, and, as usual, give the reasons for praise… Only now He had taken to Himself His great power and the kingdom. The nations were angry, but how uselessly! Jehovah's Messiah and Son would be set up in Zion; the dead would be judged, the prophets and the God-fearing rewarded, and the destroyers of the earth destroyed. It is the general statement of the close of God's ways; of judgment and of its effects; the government of God made good in its final results.
The nations do not welcome the kingdom. One writer presses how much that single fact settles:
When Jehovah and His Christ take the kingdom to reign forever and ever, "the nations raged." That statement alone is enough to demolish the false idea that the gospel is going to convert the world. On that idea, the kingdom would come as the fruit of gospel effort, and the nations would be delighted to see it! Instead, the kingdom will be set up as the result of God's wrath coming.
Another writer names what that anger may take in, at both ends of Christ's reign:
The anger of the nations may include the gathering together of the kings of the earth, with their armies, under the leadership of the beast (Rev. 19:19), to make war against Christ as He comes from heaven with His army. It may also include the nations from the four quarters of the earth, gathered together by Satan at the close of the thousand years (Rev. 20:7-9).
One writer weighs the phrase "the time for the dead":
The time of this world's activity is not the time of the dead. Among the dead there is no planning and no understanding. But when God's time comes, it is the time of the dead — and the time for them to be judged… I would not at all leave out those judged at the very end, the wicked dead.
Another writer sets this judgment apart from the earlier ones:
"The time for the dead to be judged" carries us on in thought to the close of the kingdom (Rev. 20:12). The judgment of the nations (Matt. 25:32) comes at the start of the kingdom reign. The judgment of the world, the inhabited earth (Acts 17:31), runs through its whole course. The dead are judged after the earthly kingdom has passed away (Rev. 20:11-12).
One writer points to what the verse does not say:
Not a word here speaks of the saints caught up to heaven; it is a later hour… This says nothing about taking them to heaven. It speaks of rewarding them. No one can give that reward until the Lord Jesus appears publicly.
And the reward does not come as one flat payment. It fits each life:
God gives the recompense of rest and glory to all His saints alike. But there are special crowns and rewards as well… So "the recompense" is not only God's answer to what His afflicted people go through here. It also takes in the different positions they will hold in the kingdom. That second kind of reward is measured by the faithfulness, suffering, and service of each saint.
The verse names three groups. The last is the widest. It reaches people whose stand for God was quiet or hardly noticed:
"Those who fear Your name, both small and great." This last group takes in everyone of that kind who owns the Name of the Lord. No doubt there are many hidden ones in every age whose moral separation from the world is so weak that it is genuinely hard to call them saints. But there are people who fear the Name of the Lord in every rank and class of society.
The last clause sounds like pure punishment. One writer hears something warmer in it:
The destruction of those who destroy the earth seems to be noted here not so much as judgment. It is noted rather to assure us that the damage will be repaired. That damage was done to what came out of His hands at the first, and He has never stopped caring tenderly about it, in spite of the evil He has allowed during "man's day."
The clearing has a purpose beyond itself — it makes room:
Destroying those who destroy the earth clears the earth of evil. It makes room for those who are to be rewarded to have their place in the coming kingdom. The flood did the same: it destroyed those who destroyed the earth, and so prepared the way for Noah's place in the new earth of that day.
- Rage — the nations meet Christ's kingdom with fury, not welcome. It arrives through wrath, not through a world slowly getting better.
- Wrath — once God's wrath comes, it runs its full course. It ends only with the judgment of the dead, after the earthly kingdom has passed away.
- Reward — rest and glory come to all God's people alike. Special crowns are measured by each one's faithfulness, suffering, and service.
- Reach — prophets, saints, and the God-fearing, "small and great." God counts the hidden ones nobody else counted.
- Repair — destroying the destroyers is not spite. God clears the earth of evil so the rewarded can take their place in it.