Psalms 77:2–6

Psalms 77:2

In the day of my trouble, I sought the Lord my hand was stretched out in the night, and slacked not; my soul refused to be comforted.

Asaph prays all through a night of trouble, and nothing lifts him. Many honest believers meet his question: why does seeking God sometimes leave you more troubled, not less?

Faith Underneath the Distress

The words that open the verse are not despair. One commentator finds the foundation of the whole passage in this turning to God.

In the earlier verses (2-9) we hear the language of a soul humbled under the mighty hand of God. There it learns the bitter lesson of the creature's emptiness and wretchedness under sin, and learns it deeply and thoroughly. Yet the groundwork of this soul-exercise is faith: "I sought the Lord." But a person who has wandered from the presence of God must pass through self-judgment on the way back. That process overshadows faith's proper action in the heart, and for a while it paralyzes it.

A. Pridham

The Hand Stretched Out

Older English Bibles read the middle phrase as "my sore ran in the night." That puzzled readers. Writers noted a better reading, and the ESV now carries it.

Psalm 77:2, "My sore ran and ceased not." What is the meaning of the word translated "sore"? A better translation has been proposed: "my hand at night was stretched out, and does not cease" — that is, he continued in prayer.

The Bible Treasury

So the picture is hands lifted to God hour after hour.

His hand (not his sore) had been stretched out in the night, and did not slacken; his soul refused to be comforted. He remembered past times of joy. They served only to contrast his present state with days when singing in the night was fitting. Songs were all banished now. Nothing but prayer, earnest continued prayer, suited him. But prayer seems unanswered.

C. E. Stuart

Why the Soul Refused Comfort

Seeking God and searching yourself can feel like the same activity. One writer says Asaph confused the two, and that this is why remembering God troubled him.

We think that in doing so we are seeking the Lord, as Asaph did, for he says, "In the day of my trouble I sought the Lord." In fact, though, he was looking for some point of rest and comfort in himself. He goes on to tell us, "I remembered God, and was troubled." Think of that! You would expect that a believer could not think of God without a song on his lips. No, he remembered God, and was troubled. He did remember God, but what filled the vision of his soul was himself.

F. B. Hole

Another writer explains why that state of mind leaves the verse without comfort.

There is no comfort here, because God is remembered only as a witness, in holiness, to His creature's guilt and helplessness. Self is the subject that absorbs the thoughts. So God, when remembered, becomes the disturber of the soul instead of its light and confidence, because He is seen through a burdened conscience.

A. Pridham

Who Ends Up Here

This is not a verse for the careless. It describes the believer who cares enough to be shaken.

How many of us have had an experience like Asaph's? The easy-going and the worldly-minded among believers are not troubled in this way. They are not eager enough to please the Lord, not earnest enough, to face things. The careful and conscientious believer is the one plunged into these distresses. They are the ones who look within their own hearts, and are filled with grief at what they find.

F. B. Hole

Where Comfort Comes From

If looking inward cannot produce comfort, comfort must come from outside. One writer asks whether Asaph had left the Scriptures unread: "If we neglect that Word, how do we expect God to comfort us?" (L. M. Grant). Another points to where grace is found.

The fountains of grace are in God; they flow out to meet the sinner in the word of His grace. What the tried soul needs for its relief is "contained in Scripture." The battered Christian knows this well. Light and joy return to the sin-burdened spirit of the self-condemned believer only when the heart turns away from dissecting itself. It must look instead at Him in whom the brightness of the Father's glory shines in loving mercy on us, as the effect of His atoning work.

A. Pridham

The Turn in the Psalm

Asaph does not stay in verse 2. Watch which word he uses, and the recovery shows itself.

In verses 2 to 6, it was all "my" — my this, that and the other. In verses 10 to 20, it is all "Your" — Your years … Your wonders … Your work … Your way … Your strength … Your arm … Your path … Your footsteps. Look at God's things, and there is deliverance, blessing and strength — after the weakness and humiliation of looking at our own.

F. B. Hole

Summary

- Faith prays. The turning to God — "in the day of my trouble I seek the Lord" — is the groundwork of the whole passage. Good feelings are not what make it faith.

- Faith persists. Asaph's hand stayed stretched out all night. That is prayer kept up when prayer seems unanswered.

- Faith stalls. Asaph looked for comfort in himself. That is why remembering God troubled him instead of gladdening him.

- Faith is tested. The easy-going escape this distress. The believer who faces what is in his own heart is the one plunged into it.

- Faith recovers. Grace flows to us in the word of His grace, and the psalm's own cure is the change from "my" to "Your."

Psalms 77:3

I remembered God, and I moaned; I complained, and my spirit was overwhelmed. Selah.

Asaph is in the day of trouble, and he does the one thing that should settle him — he turns his mind to God. Instead of rest, the memory brings a groan. The more he thinks, the more his spirit sinks. Why can the thought of God leave a believer worse, not better?

Remembering God without comfort

Asaph tells us he sought the Lord in his day of trouble. But where was he looking for rest? (Older translations render the line "I remembered God, and was troubled.")

We think that in doing so we are seeking the Lord, as Asaph did, for he says, "In the day of my trouble I sought the Lord." In fact, he was looking for some point of rest and comfort in himself... Think of that! You would expect that a saint could not think of God without a song on his lips. No. He remembered God and was troubled, because even while he remembered God, what filled the view of his soul was nothing but himself.

F. B. Hole

Why the thought of God disturbs

So why does remembering God bring no comfort? One writer points to the lens Asaph was looking through.

Here there is no comfort at all, because God is remembered only as a witness, in holiness, of His creature's guilt and helplessness. Self is the one subject that fills the thoughts. So God, when remembered, no longer gives the soul its light and confidence. He becomes the one who disturbs it, because the man sees Him through a burdened conscience. The soul does feel that power belongs to Him. But that sense only completes its collapse of heart.

A. Pridham

Where grace is found

If self-inspection caused the trouble, more of it cannot be the cure.

When the self-judging spirit thinks of God apart from the word of His grace, God is not, and cannot be, the object of hopeful faith. He is where the conscience ends, in fear. Nothing drives fear out of the heart of a born-again man except the enjoyment of grace, really known. And grace can never be worked out from the inward experience of a heart that judges itself by the truth. The fountains of grace are in God; they flow to meet the sinner in the word of His grace.

A. Pridham

Crying out, or talking to yourself

The psalm holds two activities side by side, and they produce opposite results.

Note the difference between crying out loud to God and talking things over in your own heart. While the second went on, his spirit was overwhelmed. The first gave up self and owned its dependence, and God listened to the cry. Everything that went on inside him before was genuine, yet it produced trouble — his earlier song, and his thinking of the Lord alike. But when the cry brought God in, His ways of old reassured the heart.

J. N. Darby

Where an overwhelmed spirit ends up

Brooding does not end in humility. It ends in suspicion of God.

You might have imagined that it would lead him to a deep and complete distrust of himself. But verses 7, 8 and 9 show him tangled in a loss of all confidence in God. In his mind he argued from himself to God, from his own feelings to God's feelings. That, of course, is the principle of law and not of grace. He felt that if he had slid shamefully away from God, then God would be likely to cast him off.

F. B. Hole

The turn: from "my" to "Your"

The psalm does not stay here. Watch which word fills the psalm before verse 10, and which one fills it after.

In verses 2 to 6, it was all, "my" — my this, that and the other. In verses 10 to 20, it is all "Your" — "Your years… Your wonders… Your work… Your doings… Your way… Your strength… Your arm… Your arrows… Your thunder… Your path… Your footsteps." What deliverance, what blessing, what strength there is in looking at God's things, after the weakness and humiliation of looking at our own.

F. B. Hole

Summary

- Look in — Asaph sought the Lord, but he hunted for rest inside himself. Self filled his sight, so even the memory of God brought a groan instead of a song.

- Look wrong — seen through a guilty conscience, God becomes only the holy witness of our guilt and helplessness, and the sense of His power completes the collapse instead of relieving it.

- Look further in — digging deeper into self breeds doubt of God, not of self. Asaph argued from his own feelings to God's, and lost all confidence in Him.

- Look out — you cannot work grace out from what you find inside. It flows to meet us in the word of His grace. Crying to God is not the same as talking to your own heart.

- Look up — from verse 10 the psalm turns from "my" trouble to "Your" wonders, works and ways. That is where strength and deliverance return.

Psalms 77:4

Thou holdest open mine eyelids; I am full of disquiet and cannot speak.

Asaph's night has no sleep and no words in it — his eyes stay open, and the trouble inside is too heavy to put into speech. Two questions follow. Who is holding those eyelids open? And why can a believer find no words at all?

Who Holds the Eyes Open

The psalmist speaks as though God Himself keeps him from sleeping. One writer looks behind that impression to what was keeping him awake.

Clearly, when Asaph wanted to sleep, he thought that God was holding his eyes open. But it was his own worry that caused this. He was in effect fighting with himself, so troubled that he could not speak (v. 4).

L M Grant

Trouble Too Deep for Words

The wakefulness and the silence belong together. Both come out of a load he cannot carry.

"I complained, and my spirit was overwhelmed." He felt crushed beneath a load that he could not support. "You hold my eyelids open; I am so troubled that I cannot speak." He could find no words to express his inward misery.

F. B. Hole

What Was Filling His Mind

What filled those hours? One writer answers by following the pronouns.

He details his miserable experience. He analyses his miserable feelings. He looks back with longing to the brighter experiences of earlier days. He speaks of "my trouble … my sore … my soul … my spirit … my eyes … my song in the night [which he used to sing] … my own heart." It is all himself.

F. B. Hole

Another writer points to a wider subject on his mind — the long history of God's dealings with people.

"You hold my eyelids open," he says: "I am so troubled that I cannot speak." His mind is full of the history of man, of "the days of old — the years of ancient times." God's dealings with men are working on him. From these he turns to review his own experience. He remembers his "music in the night," but he is not in the mood for music now.

Numerical Bible Notes

Why the Thought of God Hurt

This is the strange part of the night. Thinking about God adds to the distress instead of easing it.

Take a spirit that is only judging itself, and thinks of God apart from the word of His grace. To that spirit God is not, and cannot be, the object of hopeful faith. He is only where the conscience ends, in fear. Nothing drives fear out of the heart of a person born again except the enjoyment of grace, actually felt. And you can never work grace out from what a heart finds inside itself when it judges itself by the truth.

A. Pridham

Not the Careless Believer

Nights like this do not fall on every believer.

The easy-going, the worldly-minded among believers are not troubled in this way. They are not keen enough to be well pleasing to the Lord, not earnest enough to face things. These distresses fall on the careful and conscientious believer. They are the ones who look within their own hearts, and are filled with grief at what they find.

F. B. Hole

Left alone, this searching settles nothing.

Searching our own hearts will only lay bare how helpless and sinful those hearts are. That work ends up raising the questions of verses 7-9.

L M Grant

The Turn at Verse 10

The psalm does not end in the dark. The change comes when Asaph renames his condition.

He puts the matter very briefly — "And I said, This is my infirmity" (v. 10). It seems he had been treating it as a virtue. He acted as though there was something pious, and almost holy, in this constant moaning over his own faults. But now he became conscious that it was in no way a virtue but an infirmity, a weakness. A great discovery this, for it broke the kind of spell it had cast on his mind.

F. B. Hole

What breaks the silence of verse 4 is not better feelings but a better subject.

Once he had to say, "I am so troubled that I cannot speak." He looked back to a song in the night that had once been his, but which now was only a dim memory. Now, meditating on all the work of the Lord, he found his tongue once more. He had found something that gave him a worthy theme. "I will … talk," he said, "of Your doings."

F. B. Hole

Summary

- The night. Asaph feels that God is holding his eyes open. One writer traces the real cause to his own worry, fighting with himself until no words came.

- The silence. The load is heavier than any words he can find, so a man who cried out in verse 1 is now speechless.

- The mirror. The psalm opens full of "my" — his trouble, his soul, his spirit, his eyes. Looking inward only uncovers more helplessness.

- The infirmity. The spell breaks when he stops treating this brooding as devotion and calls it what it is: weakness.

- The voice. After verse 10 he turns from himself to all the work of the Lord, and the man who could not speak finds his tongue.

Psalms 77:5

I consider the days of old, the years of ancient times.

Asaph lies awake at night, worn out and unable to speak. His mind travels back into history, to the long stretch of years before his own trouble began. Is that backward look faith, or another form of despair? Commentators find both in it.

(The quotations below use the older wording "the years of ancient times" where the ESV reads "the years long ago.")

A Mind Turned to the Past

This verse describes thinking, not praying. One writer sees a common habit in it: weighing today against a remembered past. He warns that long-time Christians fall into it easily:

He tells us in verses 5 and 6 the things that had been occupying his thoughts. "I have considered the days of old, the years of ancient times." I have been thinking about history long past. Older Christians often get troubled like this. They think the earlier days were far better than these… We find that Asaph had known brighter days himself. His circumstances had been better, and his soul had been brighter too.

F. B. Hole

His thoughts reach wider than his own lifetime. They take in God's dealings with people in general, and still they give him no rest:

He is taken up with the history of man, with "the days of old, the years of ancient times." God's dealings with men are working on him. From these he turns to look over his own experience. He remembers his "music in the night," but he has no heart for music now. He is busy talking with his own heart, and his spirit searches hard. Yet through all of this he still finds no rest.

F. W. Grant

Why the Memory Brought No Relief

The memory stings because of the comparison. God stepped in for Israel long ago, and He seems not to step in now. One commentator supplies the question Asaph never asks out loud, and shows where searching your own heart ends:

Yet he had considered the days of old, the years of ancient times, no doubt wondering why God did not step in for him as He did for Israel long ago (v. 5)… If he had meditated on the truth of the Word of God, how much more fruitful that would have been! Searching our own hearts only exposes how helpless and sinful those hearts are, so this kind of searching ends up raising the questions of verses 7-9.

L M Grant

The Pronoun That Runs Through These Verses

Read the first six verses and count how often Asaph says "my". He runs everything, even history, through himself:

We have only to read the first six verses to see that Asaph began this Psalm completely taken up with himself. He spells out his miserable experience. He analyzes his miserable feelings. He looks back with longing to the brighter days of earlier times. He speaks of "my trouble … my sore … my soul … my spirit … my eyes … my song in the night [which he used to sing] … my own heart." It is all himself.

F. B. Hole

One writer marks a difference between crying out to God and talking to your own heart. Only one of the two let the past reassure Asaph:

Note that there is a difference between crying out to God with the voice and talking things over with your own heart. While the second went on, his spirit was overwhelmed. The first gave up all claim on self and admitted dependence, and God listened to the cry. Everything that went on inside him before, though genuine, produced trouble — his earlier song, and his thinking about the Lord alike. But when the cry brought God in, His ways of old reassured his heart.

J. N. Darby

The Turn Later in the Psalm

The same backward look returns at verse 10, but the years now belong to someone else:

Before, he had "the years of ancient times" in front of him, clearly tied to his own experiences. Now he has "the years of the right hand of the Most High" in front of him. We spend our years like a story that is told, whether in ancient times or today. His years run through all generations, for from everlasting to everlasting He is God.

F. B. Hole

History Studied Rightly

Read the right way, the old record is evidence, not nostalgia. What God once did settles what He will not do now:

God stepped in for Israel long ago, and that is a lesson to study right to the end. That nation once experienced redemption by power. Could God drop those whom He has redeemed? Impossible. By redeeming power at the Red Sea, God became their God, and they became His people… He was a saint, and one of that redeemed nation, so how could God forsake him? He should expect deliverance, even if he could not see how it would come.

C E Stuart

Summary

- Backward. Asaph's mind runs back to former days and older history. The memory of brighter times only sharpens his present distress.

- Inward. His search is genuine, but it turns inward. His own heart shows him only helplessness and sin.

- Downward. Self-searching brings no rest. It only raises the questions of verses 7-9.

- Outward. Crying out to God is not the same as talking to your own heart. The cry brings God in, and His ways of old steady the soul.

- Upward. "The years of ancient times" become "the years of the right hand of the Most High." Read that way, the past shows God's proven redemption, and He will not drop those He has redeemed.

Psalms 77:6

I remember my song in the night; I muse in mine own heart, and my spirit maketh diligent search.

Asaph cannot sleep, and in the dark he reaches back for the music he once sang and turns his search inward. Can looking inside yourself ever bring the comfort you want?

The word behind "song"

The Hebrew word here is not just singing. It comes from a root used for playing on strings.

Job 30:9, "I am their song"; Psalm 69:12; 77:6, song; Isaiah 38:20; Lamentations 3:14 and 5:14, music. "On my stringed instruments" (margin, neginoth) shows the meaning clearly enough. The verb is to strike the strings.

G. V. Wigram

So the song he reaches for is music he can no longer make.

The direction of the search

He searches hard. But every search has a direction.

We find that Asaph had known brighter days himself. When his circumstances were better, his soul was brighter too. "Let me remember my song in the night." I was so happy. I remembered when I could lie awake on my bed and sing to God. "Let me meditate in my heart." "Then my spirit made a diligent search." Yes, but in what direction? Clearly within.

F. B. Hole

Who ends up here

This night is not the mark of a shallow believer. It is the opposite kind of person who lies awake like this.

The easy-going and the worldly-minded among believers are not troubled in this way. They are not keen enough to please the Lord, and not earnest enough, to face things. It is the careful and conscientious believer who is plunged into these distresses. They are the ones who look inside their own hearts, and they grieve at what they find.

F. B. Hole

What the diligent search actually turns up

The searching does not fail for lack of effort. It fails because of what is there to be found — and the verses that follow show the result.

Like Job, he meditated in his heart, but this brought no answer to a distressed heart. How much more fruitful it would have been to meditate on the truth of the Word of God! Searching our own hearts will only expose how helpless and sinful those hearts are. So this work leads to the questions raised in verses 7-9.

L M Grant

Why remembering God only troubled him

Earlier in the psalm he says he remembered God and was troubled. That reaction has a cause: God thought of apart from His promise meets a self-examining conscience as a judge.

When a self-judging spirit thinks of God apart from the word of His grace, God is not, and cannot be, the object of hopeful faith. He is where the conscience ends in fear. Nothing drives fear out of the heart of a born-again person except the enjoyment of grace. And grace can never be worked out from the inward experience of a heart that judges itself by the truth. The springs of grace are in God, and they flow out to meet the sinner in the word of His grace.

A. Pridham

Where a night song comes from

Asaph treats his old song as something that belonged to happier days. But there is singing in the dark that does not depend on conditions at all.

Can we not say that it was the sense of the Lord's presence in the Philippian prison that made Paul and Silas sing "songs in the night"? If the Lord was not the object of their praise here, He was the subject of it, as He always must be. So they sang aloud, making melody in their hearts. They were not like those who sing "songs to a heavy heart". The presence of the Lord makes even "the tongue of the mute sing for joy."

The Bible Treasury

The pronoun that changes everything

The psalm does not end in the night. From verse 10 onward one small word replaces another.

In verses 2 to 6, it was all "my" — my this, my that and my other. In verses 10 to 20, it is all "Your". "Your years… Your wonders… Your work… Your doings… Your way… Your strength… Your arm… Your arrows… Your thunder… Your path… Your footsteps." What deliverance, what blessing, what strength there is in looking at God's things, after the weakness and humiliation of looking at our own.

F. B. Hole

Summary

- Search — the word for "song" means striking the strings. He remembers music he can no longer make, and searches inside himself instead.

- Direction — the effort was real and diligent; the problem was that it went the wrong way, into his own heart.

- Result — searching your own heart only exposes how helpless it is. The doubting questions of the next verses follow from it.

- Supply — you will not find grace by inspecting yourself. It comes to you in the word of God's grace. Apart from that word, thoughts of God only frighten the conscience.

- Turn — songs in the night come from the Lord's presence, not from better circumstances. Relief comes when "my" gives way to "Your."