Psalms 73:1–17

Psalms 73:1 · Darby

(A Psalm of Asaph.) Truly God is good to Israel, to such as are of a pure heart.

Asaph opens with a settled conviction about God's goodness, before he says a word about himself. But he adds a limit at once — that goodness belongs to Israel, and then only to the "pure in heart."

First line, last line

The psalm's first line and its last line answer each other.

The writer opens this beautiful Psalm with a simple but blessed statement about God. He closes with a happy conclusion about himself. "Truly God is good" is the statement of the first verse; "it is good for me to draw near to God" is the conclusion of the last verse. Accept the statement and we must agree with the conclusion.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Not goodness in general, but goodness to His own

The verse says something narrower than "God is kind to everyone."

The statement, however, is not a general declaration of God's goodness toward all His creatures — true as that would be. It is the assertion that "God is good to Israel, to those who are pure in heart." The great object of the Psalm is to prove God's absolute goodness to His people. That goodness holds through the trying circumstances they may have to pass through, the sorrows they may face, and the sufferings they may have to endure.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Who counts as Israel

The second half of the verse decides who belongs. Descent from Israel is not the qualification; the heart is.

The Spirit looks at Israel as a people, but recognises only those "of a pure heart" as Israel. "A Jew is one inwardly." It is now clear that "not all who are descended from Israel belong to Israel"; still Israel's importance stands. "God is good to Israel, to those who are pure in heart." Yet he had almost slipped, and his feet had almost gone. He envied the foolish when he saw the prosperity of the wicked.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Mercy and holiness together

The verse names two things about God at once: mercy that stays faithful, and holiness He looks for in His people.

This Psalm has a very definite character of its own, besides its general application in principle to the circumstances of individual faith. That character shows in the opening verse, which contains the proper subject of the Psalm. The verse celebrates the name of Jehovah as the God of faithful mercy to Israel. He is the God of judgment too, who asks for truth and holiness in the hearts of His people — and in the mystery of His own grace He provides them. He is good to Israel, to those who are pure in heart (verse 1).

Modernised from A. PridhamOriginal wording

A truth easy to say and hard to keep

Verse 1 states the truth. Verse 2 shows the writer almost losing his footing.

"Truly God is good to Israel," the psalmist affirms. Then he adds that, in keeping with the holiness of God's nature, this is "to the pure in heart." That is the truth, but it is not always easy to grasp and hold. He had not found it so: his feet had almost gone, his steps slipped. The wicked boasted of their prosperity, and it moved him to envy them. The ways of God grew dark to him, while their lot seemed bright.

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

The day when the statement will be plain

One writer reads the verse forward, to the day when nothing in sight will contradict it.

When God is truly "good to Israel," their own law limits it to those of a "clean heart," or pure in heart (Psalm 73:1). Only then will He receive them to (or with) glory (verse 24)… His people are at last under the new covenant (Jeremiah 31:31-34), and will be all righteous (Isaiah 60:21).

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Commentators differ. Some read the psalm as Israel's future story; others as any believer's experience under pressure.

Summary

- Good — stated. The psalm opens with a verdict, not a question: God is good. Everything after verse 1 is the story of how the writer came to believe his own opening line.

- Good — to whom. Not a broad remark about God's kindness to all creatures. It is a claim about His goodness to His people while they suffer.

- Good — and holy. The clause "pure in heart" keeps the goodness consistent with God's character; He looks for the clean heart, and by grace He gives it.

- Good — contested. Asaph states the truth, then almost loses it. Envy at the prosperity of the wicked made his steps slip.

- Good — proved. What begins as "God is good" ends as "it is good for me to draw near to God." Accept the first and you cannot escape the second.

Psalms 73:2 · Darby

But as for me, my feet were almost gone, my steps had well nigh slipped;

Psalm 73 opens with a settled truth about God's goodness. Then the writer confesses how close he came to losing his footing on it — the sight of the world nearly took him off the path.

Where the psalm's story starts

Verse 1 states the truth. Verse 2 is where the psalm's action begins — an experience God's people have known again and again.

The action of the Psalm begins with the second verse. It seems to describe, as a prophecy, the inner conflict of soul that the faithful remnant of Israel will know. In some measure this has always been the experience of such people when a nation turns away from God. Then the long-delayed hope of God's afflicted people seems more than ever to be mocked by the untroubled prosperity of the ungodly.

Modernised from Arthur PridhamOriginal wording

Knowing the truth and keeping hold of it

The truth in verse 1 comes with a condition attached. Verse 2 shows how hard that truth is to hold.

"Truly God is good to Israel," the psalmist affirms. Then he adds that, in keeping with the holiness of God's nature, this is "to the pure in heart." That is the truth, but it is not always easy to grasp and hold. He had not found it so: his feet had nearly gone, his steps slipped.

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

A slip nobody else could see

"Almost stumbled" does not describe a public collapse. Nothing in his behaviour gave him away; we only know about it because he tells us.

The Psalmist tells us that as he passed through an evil world, there came a day when his feet were almost gone, and his steps had nearly slipped. It is written, "the gate is narrow and the way is hard that leads to life." That was as true for the godly Psalmist in his day as it is for the Christian today. A narrow path needs only a single false step on either side to miss the way. The Psalmist's path was not marred by any obvious failure that would have disgraced him in the eyes of the world. No angry or impatient words had passed his lips to betray the state of his heart, and yet he had nearly slipped. If we did not have his own confession, no one would have known this from his conduct and speech.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

What he lost his grip on

The same writer names what was really slipping, and how it happened.

Despite how things looked, he confesses that he had nearly lost confidence in God. His feet had almost slipped from the rock. He also lets us know how his confidence in God came to be so severely shaken. The secret comes out. He was occupied with evil while out of touch with God. So he had a limited and distorted view of the evil. He saw the prosperity of the wicked, and he saw the adversity of the godly. As a result he envied the portion of the wicked, he undervalued the portion of the godly, and he nearly lost confidence in God.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Envy, examined

Another writer presses past the envy to the motive underneath it.

Though the evidence was perfectly clear that God is good to Israel, Asaph himself was in a quandary. Why? Because he saw the prosperity of the wicked. Though he believed in the goodness of God, he was envious of those who could boast of wealth and prominence. Many have followed his lead in this natural tendency. What is the motive behind this envy? It is plain, obvious selfishness!

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

The same danger today

What happened to Asaph still happens. One writer turns it straight on the reader.

Still, we often do exactly what Asaph did. We look around, and seeing the prosperity of the wicked we envy them. As a result our feet are almost gone, our steps have nearly slipped. In this we disobey the instructions of Psalm 37. We fret because of evildoers, we envy those who do wrong, and we end by fretting in a way that leads us to do evil. Asaph could find no clue in this world to explain God's dealings, and neither can we. We shall have to do what Asaph did.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Who was really on slippery ground

Later in the psalm the picture turns inside out. Seen from the sanctuary — the place of God's presence — the slipping belongs to the other side.

It looked as if the Psalmist had been in the slippery places, for had not his steps nearly slipped? The wicked, on the other hand, seemed to stand firm on a rock, for did they not prosper and increase in riches? In fact the godly soul was on the rock, though shaking; and the wicked were in slippery places, though prospering. Away from the sanctuary, the prosperity of the wicked cast the godly man down. From the sanctuary, he sees that in the end they will be cast down.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Summary

- Look — the slide starts with the eyes. He saw the wicked prosper and the godly suffer, and judged God by what he could see.

- Slip — the fall is inward before it is anything else. No harsh word, no public failure; only a confession we would never have guessed from his conduct.

- Root — under the envy lies selfishness, and under the perplexity lies a heart busy with evil and out of touch with God.

- Reversal — the shaking man was on the rock; the prospering man was on the slippery ground. Only the sanctuary shows which is which.

- Return — this world holds no clue to explain God's dealings. In the sanctuary the psalmist sees how it ends for the wicked; we must do what Asaph did.

Psalms 73:3 · Darby

For I was envious at the arrogant, seeing the prosperity of the wicked.

Asaph opens this psalm by admitting that his feet had nearly slipped. Verse 3 names the reason: he looked at people who live without God and saw them doing well. The sight bred envy, and envy shook a man who trusted God's goodness.

The words: arrogant, wicked, prosperous

The people Asaph envies are not just rich. Another translation brings out both their pride and their ease. Set beside the verses that follow, it shows what he was staring at:

For I was envious at the arrogant (fools), seeing the peace of wicked (men). For there are no pangs in their death, and their strength is firm... Therefore has pride enchained them, a garment of violence covers them.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

One writer names exactly what caught him:

What was the snare? He describes it. It was the prosperity of the wicked, and their unabashed arrogance. Things it seems were flourishing with them, having more than heart could wish (3-9). All of that had a terrible effect on others. It drew people aside into a seemingly easier path — people who should have resisted the temptation.

Modernised from C E StuartOriginal wording

What envy really is

Asaph believed in God's goodness and envied wealth at the same time. Commentators press the question of motive:

Though he was a believer in the goodness of God, he was envious of those who could boast of wealth and prominence. This is a very real test for everyone. What is the motive behind this envy? It is plain, obvious selfishness! How much better to weigh this matter from God's viewpoint rather than our own.

Modernised from L M GrantOriginal wording

The same trap is described in Psalm 37, where fretting and envy are twins:

Alas, it is this envy that lies at the bottom of the fretting. We are under trial, and the worker of iniquity seems to be having such an easy time. We cannot bear it! We are like a child in a nursery who pouts and frets because the other child has an apple a size larger than the one given to it — and the owner of the big apple was the naughty child of the nursery! Oh, what mischief envy can work in the heart of a saint! And what misery too it can produce, and what sin!

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Why the sight unsettles a believer

Grief at evil is right. Envy shows something else has crept in alongside it:

We see the ungodly having their way, so that God seems to have forgotten, and the heart is envious. But too often it shows that our heart still wants its portion here — at least a portion here as well as one to come. Sorrow at the power of evil in the world is right. But in our minds it mixes with a liking for our own way and our own judgment in setting that evil aside. When our own will mixes into the sense of evil's success, we grow irritated or discouraged. Then we give up persevering in good.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

The prosperity itself is not the strange part. Our reaction is:

It is no great surprise that in a world without God the ungodly prosper. The surprise is that godly people are so often upset when they see it. There was some excuse for Asaph, for he lived in a day when heavenly things were not clearly revealed... We live in a day when heavenly things are clearly revealed. As Christians we have been plainly told that "through many tribulations we must enter the kingdom of God."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Discipline, not favour

Asaph read his own daily discipline as evidence against him. The New Testament reverses the reading:

There is also the solemn reminder: if we go without the discipline that all sons share, then we are illegitimate children and not sons... Asaph did not understand this, and so he says, "I was envious of the arrogant when I saw the prosperity of the wicked... They are not in trouble as others are; they are not stricken like the rest of mankind." But of himself he says, "All the day long I have been stricken and rebuked every morning."

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

God's dealing with a person is a sign of relationship, not rejection:

The fact that God dealt with those people shows that they were His saints. God doesn't deal with the world in that way. That is the great thing in Psalm 73.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Where the riddle breaks

Verse 3 raises a problem the world cannot solve. The psalm itself shows where Asaph found the answer.

Asaph stepped away from the world and its confusing circumstances so that he might get in touch with God. Looking around, he nearly stumbled. It looked as if God were favouring the ungodly and punishing the righteous. But in the sanctuary he caught a glimpse of things that lie far outside this world, and his perplexities ended.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Summary

- Look — Asaph's slip begins with a sideways glance at people marked by arrogance as much as by ease. Their pride was on open display, and he envied them anyway.

- Envy — the motive underneath is plain selfishness: the heart wants a portion here as well as one to come.

- Distortion — when our own will mixes in with the sight of evil succeeding, we grow irritated or discouraged and stop persevering in good.

- Correction — the untroubled life is not the favoured one. God's discipline marks out sons, and He does not deal with the world that way.

- Sanctuary — the riddle has no answer inside this world. Asaph stepped out of his circumstances into God's presence, and there his perplexity ended.

Psalms 73:4 · Darby

For they have no pangs in their death, and their body is well nourished;

Psalm 73 opens with a man whose feet nearly slipped. Verse 4 is the first item in his case against God's fairness. The wicked die without pain and stay strong, while the godly are worn down. Is that picture even true? And if it is, why should it trouble anyone?

Note: the writers below quote an older translation of the whole verse: "there are no bands in their death: but their strength is firm."

The viewpoint behind the picture

The description that starts here is honest reporting. But it comes from a man who has drifted from God's presence. That changes what he can see.

In verses 4 to 12 he draws a solemn picture of the wicked. But we must remember this: it is a description of the wicked as seen by a believer who, for the moment, is out of communion with God. So everything he says is true, but it is not the full truth.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

What made his view a half-truth was where he was looking.

He was taken up with evil while out of touch with God. So he had a limited and twisted view of that evil. He saw how well the wicked were doing, and he saw the hardship of the godly. As a result he envied the lot of the wicked, he looked down on the lot of the godly, and he almost lost confidence in God.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Real, but not a rule

Some wicked people go through life and out of it without the shocks that hit everyone else. The verse describes a pattern, not a law.

Even in the death of the ungodly there seems to be no suffering like that of many others (v. 4). They seem to stay as firm in their rebellion against God as they have been all their life... Of course, this is not true of all the wicked. Some suffer great trouble because of their sins even on earth. But many keep God out of their lives and live in selfish pleasure with almost no trouble. Job spoke of this to his three friends (Job 21:7-17), and none of them could tell him why such men were left to live out their whole lives in selfish pleasure.

Modernised from L M GrantOriginal wording

The endings vary. So no one can read a person's standing with God from their circumstances. Job's friends tried.

One man dies quietly surrounded by wealth, as the psalm says, "The wicked have no bands in their death." Another is cut off in misery. Both reach the same end in the grave. Since that is so, how wrong it is for his friends to lay down a fixed rule: that trouble in this life is always a sign of sin in the person who suffers it, and prosperity always a sign of righteousness.

Modernised from Samuel RidoutOriginal wording

A calm deathbed

The calm this verse describes can be a symptom, not a blessing.

If a wicked man seems to have peace at death, it is not from the knowledge of his happiness, but from the ignorance of his danger.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

So the quiet end may only mean the alarm stopped working.

You who have neglected the gospel may well come to your deathbed with no word of warning from your conscience. For the wicked have "no bands in their death, but their strength is firm." Yes, you may come to your deathbed with no fear of dying, and still be without Christ and unsaved. Why? Because you have silenced your conscience so long that at last it gives you no warning cry. Then mourning friends dry their eyes and say, "He died like a lamb, died like a lamb!"

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

Why the believer gets the harder road

Asaph envied a life with no trouble. Hebrews reads that same freedom as a sign of not being a son.

There is also the solemn reminder that if we are without the discipline all sons share, then we are illegitimate children and not sons... Asaph did not understand this truth, and so he says, "I was envious at the foolish, when I saw the prosperity of the wicked. For there are no bands in their death: but their strength is firm."... His difficulty went away when he went into the sanctuary of God, and the Holy Spirit also answers and explains it in this scripture. (Heb. 12:8.)

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Asaph had less light than we do, which makes our version of his envy harder to excuse.

There is nothing very surprising in the fact that in an ungodly world there should be worldly prosperity for the ungodly: it is rather surprising that the godly should so often be upset as they behold it. There was some excuse for Asaph, for he lived in a day when heavenly things were not clearly revealed... We live in a day when heavenly things are clearly revealed, and when we have been plainly told as Christians that "we must through much tribulation enter into the kingdom of God."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The place where the picture changes

The facts of verse 4 never change. What changes is the timescale.

Outside the sanctuary he looks at evil without God. Inside he sees everything, and everyone, with God. What a difference this makes! Outside, he had seen everything in relation to time. Inside, he sees everything in relation to eternity... Man is always short-sighted and can take only a short view. God, whose sight reaches far, sees the end from the beginning.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Summary

- Viewpoint. A believer out of touch with God draws this picture. Everything he says is true, but it is not the full truth.

- Limits. Many wicked people escape ordinary trouble and die without pain. Not all do. So comfort is no scorecard of who stands right with God.

- Danger. A painless death may show a silenced conscience, not a safe soul. Peace at the end can come from not knowing the danger.

- Reversal. Asaph envied a trouble-free life. Hebrews calls that the mark of not being a son. The discipline he resented proved he was one.

- Sanctuary. The facts stay the same; the frame changes. Outside, he weighs evil by the passing moment. Inside God's presence, he weighs it by eternity, and the envy dies.

Psalms 73:5 · Darby

They have not the hardships of mankind, neither are they plagued like [other] men

Asaph looks at people who ignore God and sees a sheltered life. They seem free from the ordinary knocks that wear everyone else down. It raises a sharp question: if trouble skips the wicked and lands on the godly, has God's government of the world failed?

What Asaph Sees

One writer sums up the picture Asaph paints, from their death to their daily comfort:

The psalmist goes on to describe the prosperity of the wicked. Apparently they are better off than the people of God. Death causes them "no pangs," and life has for them no plagues. They treat pride as an ornament, and everyone can see their violence, which they wear like a garment. Their eyes show their self-satisfaction and the gratification of every wish.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

A Real Observation, Not a Rule

What Asaph describes does happen. But it is not a law that every godless person escapes hardship:

Their character is plainly wicked, yet so often they escape the troubles that afflict other people. Of course, this is not true of all the wicked. Some suffer great trouble because of their sins even on earth. But there are many who keep God out of their lives and live in selfish pleasure with almost no hardship. Job spoke of this to his three friends. Not one of them could tell him why such men were allowed to live out their whole lives in selfish pleasure.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

True, But Not the Whole Truth

But there is a limit to what this picture shows:

We must remember, though, who is describing them. This is the wicked as seen by a believer who is, for the moment, out of communion with God. So all that he says is true, but it is not the full truth.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The Slip That Nearly Happened

The danger is not their comfort but what watching it does to us:

Still we often do exactly what Asaph did. We look around us, and seeing the prosperity of the wicked we become envious of them, and as a result our feet are almost gone, our steps have nearly slipped. In this we disobey the instructions of Psalm 37. We fret ourselves because of evildoers. We are envious of wrongdoers, and we end by fretting ourselves in such a way as "to do evil." Asaph could find no clue in this world to explain God's dealings, and neither can we.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Why the Godly Are Chastened and the Wicked Are Not

One writer turns the question around: being left without correction is no privilege.

There is also the solemn reminder about chastisement, which all sons share. If we are without it, then we are illegitimate children and not sons… God chastises His children. "To be without chastisement therefore," says the Spirit, "is a sign that you are illegitimate and not sons." Asaph did not understand this truth, and so he says, "I was envious of the arrogant when I saw the prosperity of the wicked… They are not in trouble as others are." But of himself he says, "All the day long I have been stricken and rebuked every morning." His difficulty vanished when he went into the sanctuary of God.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

The Sanctuary Reverses the Picture

Asaph's answer came in God's presence. There he found he had the two parties the wrong way round:

It looked, indeed, as if the psalmist was the one in the slippery places. Had not his steps nearly slipped? The wicked, on the other hand, looked firmly settled on a rock. Did they not prosper in the world and increase in riches? In fact the godly soul was on the rock, though shaking; and the wicked were in slippery places, though prospering… Away from God, the prosperity of the wicked looked very real and lasting. In the sanctuary it was only an evil and passing dream.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Reckoning by the End

The end of each life settles the matter. A life free of trouble is no prize, and the afflicted believer is not forsaken:

They may not be in trouble like other people, and very possibly have no plagues in their death… till at last they "pass away" altogether, and are not. They reach their end in time. They may die rich, only to spend a poor eternity… Oh, the wisdom of knowing and enjoying the favour of God day by day! Oh, the wisdom of seeking, by grace, to walk in godliness and practical righteousness! Then, if we are persecuted for Christ's sake, or afflicted and tried by the good and unerring hand of God our Father, we may at least realise that we are "not forsaken."

Modernised from J. Wilson SmithOriginal wording

Summary

- The look. Asaph sees people without God escape the troubles that wear everyone else down. It is real in many cases, but not true of every wicked person.

- The limit. The description is true but partial. It is the view of a believer who is, for the moment, out of communion with God.

- The slip. Watching untroubled sinners breeds envy. Envy is what nearly took Asaph's feet out from under him.

- The correction. Chastening marks out sons. A life with no correction is not proof of God's favour.

- The end. In God's presence the positions swap. The wicked stand in slippery places; the shaken believer stands on the rock.

Psalms 73:6 · Darby

Therefore pride encompasseth them as a neck-chain, violence covereth them [as] a garment;

Asaph is watching people who ignore God, and life keeps rewarding them for it. Verse 6 is his summary of what that comfort does to them: it comes out as ornament and clothing. The verse opens with "therefore." That one word makes their swagger the result of their easy lives.

Ease that breeds pride

The link with the verse before is cause and effect. God holds back judgment, and the delay makes them bolder instead of softer.

Because God is patient in not bringing swift judgment on their ways, their pride only grows, like a necklace to adorn their stiff necks. They mistake God's patience for indifference, and violence is a major part of their life (v.6).

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Worn, not hidden

Both pictures in the verse are about display. A chain hangs where everyone can see it, and a garment is the first thing anyone notices about you.

Yet this blessing did not bless them: it only confirmed them in their evil. They displayed pride as if it were an ornament on their necks, holding themselves erect with self-consciousness. Their violence sought no hiding place. It was like the clothing they wore, visible to everyone.

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

The eyes behind the picture

This portrait is accurate. But one commentator adds a caution about the man who drew it.

In verses 4 to 12 he draws a solemn picture of the wicked. But we must remember who is drawing it. This is the wicked as seen by a believer who, at that moment, was out of communion with God. So everything he says is true, yet it is not the full truth. Still, it is true that the wicked are marked by "pride" and "violence," "corruption" and "oppression."

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Success that pulls a crowd

This kind of success does not stay private. It pulled others in, including people who counted themselves among God's own.

Their prosperity did not intoxicate only them. People from among the professing people of God went over to them and, encouraged by what they saw, gave themselves up to loose living. For, they argued, how can God know? How can the Most High have any knowledge? Are not these admittedly the "wicked," whom He condemns? and yet, see how they live at ease, and their wealth increases?

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

Where the puzzle finally breaks

The answer never came from staring harder at the scene. It came when Asaph entered the sanctuary and saw how each life ends.

In the light of the sanctuary everything became clear to him. He saw that he could only judge the path of the godless rich, and the path of the plagued and downtrodden believers, rightly once the end of each came into view. A few moments before, he had almost fallen himself, because envy at the prosperity of the wicked had eaten him up. Now he exclaims, "How they are destroyed in a moment!"

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The mirror turned round

The verse is easy to aim at other people. One writer turns it back on the reader, treating violence and corruption as tests for our own behaviour rather than labels for theirs.

The statements "They have corrupted themselves," "Destruction and misery are in their ways," "Violence covers them as a garment," are still true. But the question for us Christians is this: are these things absent from our walk when we deal with the world? If we are wronged or slandered, if we have personal grievances against others, what do we show? Is it a peaceful or a violent spirit?

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Summary

- Cause — Untroubled comfort breeds the pride. They mistake God's patience for indifference, so the delay of judgment hardens them instead of softening them.

- Costume — Pride hangs on the neck like a chain, and violence covers them like clothing. They wear both in the open. They hide neither, and neither shames them.

- Contagion — That display draws followers, even from among God's professing people. They watch it and decide that God does not notice.

- Correction — The picture is true but partial. A man out of touch with God drew it, studying evil instead of God.

- Conclusion — Only the sanctuary ends the confusion. There the end of each life comes into view, and the wicked fall in a moment.

Psalms 73:7 · Darby

Their eyes stand out from fatness, they exceed the imaginations of their heart

Asaph describes men who have everything. Their success shows in their faces and runs past every wish of their hearts — which raises two questions: what does such plenty do to the people who hold it, and why does the sight of it shake those who fear God?

Fatness as the Bible's picture of plenty

The verse pictures wealth as fat. One writer shows where that picture leads in the Bible.

In Scripture fat is always the symbol of a prosperous condition. But it can be the kind of earthly prosperity that leaves the soul in the opposite state. In his last prophetic song the lawgiver says: "Jeshurun grew fat, and kicked; you grew fat, stout, and sleek; then he forsook God who made him and scoffed at the Rock of his salvation." The Psalmist's description of the wicked is connected with this.

Modernised from Frederick W GrantOriginal wording

Success that outruns the imagination

Translations differ on the second line. ESV reads "their hearts overflow with follies"; others read "they exceed the imaginations of their heart." One writer takes verses 6 and 7 together and shows what the plenty did to these men.

Yet this blessing did not bless: it only confirmed them in their evil. They displayed pride, as if it were an ornament on their necks, held erect with self-consciousness. Their violence sought no concealment, but was like a garment on them, plain to everyone. Their insolent eyes stood out with fatness. They exceeded even their own imaginations of success.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Mercies turned into hardness

God's mercies can be turned into hardness. One writer explains why growing richer does not bring a man nearer to God.

Men corrupt themselves under His mercies. Feeding their hearts as in a day of slaughter, they store up treasure for the last days. The progress a man can make in worldly improvement and prosperity never fails to harden his heart against God. It is impossible to be rich in one's own esteem and rich toward God at the same time.

Modernised from A. PridhamOriginal wording

Abundance as a test

Why does all this giving not soften them? One writer says God allows the abundance for a reason.

God is patient and does not bring swift judgment on their ways, so their pride only grows, like a necklace to adorn their stiff necks. They mistake His patience for indifference, and violence fills much of their life. "Their eyes swell out through fatness; their hearts overflow with follies." No doubt God allows this as a test. They never see it, so they fail the test completely.

Modernised from L M GrantOriginal wording

Who is describing the wicked

Verses 4 to 12 are Asaph's own report. His state of soul at the time matters.

But remember: this is a description of the wicked as seen by a believer who, for the moment, is out of communion with God. So everything he says is true, yet it is not the full truth. Still, "pride" and "violence," "corruption" and "oppression" do mark the wicked.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Why the sight unsettles believers

The surprise, one commentator suggests, is not that the wicked do well but that the godly find it so hard to watch.

In a world that ignores God, it is no surprise that those who ignore Him prosper. The surprise is that godly people are so often upset as they watch it. Asaph had some excuse. He lived in a day when God had not yet made heavenly things clear, and when He did speak of blessing Israel, His people, in their basket and in their store. We live in a day when God has made heavenly things clear. He tells us plainly as Christians that "through many tribulations we must enter the kingdom of God."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Where such men end up

The psalm answers the problem only when Asaph goes into God's sanctuary and sees where these men are heading.

Asaph saw this too. He records it in Psalm 73:3-9, and in verses 16-17 he adds that it "seemed to me a wearisome task, until I went into the sanctuary of God; then I discerned their end." He learned that God does not settle His accounts in this life. There is a future to consider.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Summary

- Fullness. In Scripture fat pictures prosperity. Here the plenty is so large that it shows in the face and overflows the heart.

- Swelling. The plenty did not bless them. It confirmed them in their evil, and their success ran past even what they had imagined.

- Hardening. Mercies received without God harden the heart; no one can be rich in his own esteem and rich toward God at once.

- Testing. They mistake God's patience for indifference. The abundance is a test, and they fail it without ever noticing.

- Ending. Verses 4-12 show how life looks to a believer out of communion: true, but not the whole truth. In the sanctuary Asaph saw their end, and learned that God settles His accounts later.

Psalms 73:8 · Darby

They mock and speak wickedly of oppression, they speak loftily

Asaph is looking at people who do wrong and still do well, a picture that runs from verse 4 to verse 12. Verse 8 focuses on how they talk: mockery, malice, and threats spoken from a great height.

Success Without Limits

One writer traces this talk back to success that went beyond anything they had imagined:

They exceeded even their own imaginations of success. This put them beyond all bounds. They scoffed at the idea of anyone checking them, and poured out malicious thoughts in violent words, as if they were above all other men. "They set their mouth in heaven," so lofty are they. "Their tongue goes through the earth," as if they owned all of it. Yet this delusion only made their emptiness plain.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Oppression As A Joke

They aim their malice downward, at the poor. They treat the wrong done to them as a joke:

God is patient and does not bring swift judgment on their ways, so their pride only increases, like a necklace to adorn their stiff necks. They mistake God's patience for indifference. No doubt God allows this as a test. They do not realise it, so they fail the test completely. They scoff at the oppression of the poor instead of feeling that attitude to be wickedness (v. 8). They speak with contempt of those they consider lower than themselves. They even speak "against the heavens," as though they were superior to God (v. 9).

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Where Such Talk Ends

One writer follows this kind of talk to where it finally leads:

People often try to bend God's word to fit what they want, so that conscience will approve aims that are purely selfish. Human nature tries this at a certain stage of turning away from God. But this is not its final form. The goal of unbelief is atheism… A human will that accepts no restraint always goes together with a complete denial of God. This is how the Spirit of Christ views the character and conduct of the ungodly, who prosper in the world and increase in riches.

Modernised from A. PridhamOriginal wording

A Portrait Drawn From The Wrong Angle

One writer adds a caution. Asaph speaks the truth here, but he speaks it while out of touch with God:

In verses 4 to 12 he draws a solemn picture of the wicked. But we must remember who is speaking. This is a description of the wicked as seen by a saint who is, for the moment, out of communion with God. So all he says is true, yet it is not the full truth. Still, "pride" and "violence," "corruption" and "oppression" do mark the wicked. Not only do they persecute the godly, but they are blasphemers who "set their mouth against the heavens."

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

What Watching It Does To You

Staring at loud, unpunished evil has a predictable effect on a believer, and it is not only sadness. It quietly pulls the watcher toward the very thing he disapproves of:

Watching evil go unpunished makes a believer fretful, unless his soul rests on God day by day. That feeling often produces a willingness to go along, more or less, with what his conscience still judges to be against God — and he does it for the sake of ease and personal advantage. So much evil makes love grow cold even in a saint, while his heart is filled with the evil rather than with Him who is above it.

Modernised from A. PridhamOriginal wording

Asaph did not settle this by argument. He settled it in the sanctuary:

Faith looks further on, and with Asaph says, "Until I went into the sanctuary of God; then I discerned their end."

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Summary

- Full — Success went past anything they expected, and it left them "beyond all bounds."

- Loud — Then it comes out of the mouth. They pour contempt on the poor below them and set their mouth against heaven above them.

- Empty — Their tongue ranges over the earth as if they owned it, and the delusion only shows how empty they are.

- Catching — Watching evil go unpunished makes a believer fretful. Then he starts to go along with it, for the sake of an easier life.

- Answered — The picture is true, but it is not the full truth. Asaph saw the rest in the sanctuary, where he discerned their end.

Psalms 73:9 · Darby

They set their mouth in the heavens, and their tongue walketh through the earth.

Asaph has been describing men who prosper while ignoring God. Here he reaches their speech. The verse raises two questions: what sort of pride talks like this, and why God lets such talk run on.

The reach of their speech

The two halves of the verse mark two directions: upward and outward. One writer sees their prosperity as a test they are failing, then takes each half in turn.

No doubt God allows their prosperity as a test, and they do not realize it, so they fail it completely. They speak with contempt of those they consider lower than themselves, and even "against the heavens," as though they were superior to God! (v. 9). "Their tongue walks through the earth," free to go where it pleases in mockery and self-will.

Modernised from L M GrantOriginal wording

Loud, and empty

Their success outran even their own hopes, and that is what loosened their tongues.

They exceeded even their own imaginations of success. This put them past all restraint. They laughed at the thought of being held back in the malicious thoughts they poured out in violent words, as if they stood above all other men. "They set their mouth in heaven," so lofty are they; "and their tongue goes through the earth," as if they owned it all. Yet this delusion only showed how empty they were.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Blasphemy, and a warning about the picture

Speech aimed at heaven has a name. But another writer adds a caution about the picture as a whole.

In verses 4 to 12 he draws a solemn picture of the wicked. We must, however, remember this is a description of the wicked as seen by a saint when, for the moment, out of communion with God; so that, while all that he says is true, it is not the full truth. Still it is true that the wicked are characterized by "pride" and "violence," "corruption" and "oppression." Not only do they persecute the godly, but they are blasphemers who "set their mouth against the heavens." They say God takes no notice of what men do, and that there is no knowledge in the Most High — and yet they still prosper and increase in riches.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Where such talk ends

This proud talk is not just bad manners. It goes with a will that refuses every limit.

A human will that allows itself no restraint always goes together with a complete denial of God. This is how the Spirit of Christ judges the character and conduct of the ungodly, who prosper in the world and increase in riches.

Modernised from A. PridhamOriginal wording

A face to put on the words

One writer names men who talked this way: Sennacherib, king of Assyria, and his officer, who taunted Jerusalem in Hezekiah's day.

Proud and cruel Sennacherib, and his arrogant, blaspheming captain were of that generation spoken of in Ps. 76. "They set their mouth against the heavens and their tongue walks through the earth." Surrounded by such strong and ruthless enemies, God's people might well fear the outcome of so unequal a fight. But, in answer to Hezekiah's prayer, as also in reply to the enemy's taunts, God Himself intervened in power.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Seen from the sanctuary

The psalm does not leave the boasters unanswered. Everything depends on where a man stands when he looks at them.

The godly man was perplexed at the prosperity of the wicked, and his feet almost slipped. In the sanctuary of God, where His mind was revealed, all became plain. As a dream when one awakes, so all their pretensions would disappear when once God awoke.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Commentators differ in emphasis. Pridham reads the passage as the Spirit of Christ's own verdict on such men. Smith holds that the picture is true, yet not the whole truth, since it came from a saint who was, for the moment, out of communion with God.

Summary

- Direction — Pride runs two ways here: mouths lifted against heaven, tongues loose over the whole earth.

- Cause — Success beyond their own hopes put them "past all restraint." Wealth did not soften them. It loosened their tongues.

- Content — This is not bragging but blasphemy. It comes with the claim that God takes no notice of what men do.

- Emptiness — Talk that claims heaven and earth only shows how small the speakers really are.

- End — Their pretensions vanish like a dream when the sleeper wakes. That becomes plain in the sanctuary. God's answer to Sennacherib outside Jerusalem was an early sample of it.

Psalms 73:10 · Darby

Therefore his people turn hither, and waters in fulness are wrung out to them.

The psalmist has just described the wicked at full stretch — proud, violent, mouths set against heaven. Now he turns to the harm that sight does to God's own people.

Where the people turn

The ESV ends the verse with God's people finding "no fault" in the wicked. Older translations read instead, "waters of a full cup are wrung out to them." The writers quoted here work from that older wording. Their word "hither" means "toward them" — toward the prosperous wicked just described. One writer treats this drift as a live danger today, not an old one:

This is a great danger even for the Christian in these days of ruin. Asaph put it like this: "Therefore His people return hither [towards the wicked] and waters of a full cup are wrung out to them." He wrote this when times of affliction came upon him, in contrast to the growing prosperity of the world.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The bait in the cup

The full cup is not neutral. It catches people, and it asks a price:

All of that had a dreadful effect on others. It drew those who should have resisted the temptation into a path that looked easier. The psalm describes both the bait that trapped them and the thoughts of their heart. The bait was waters out of a full cup. They preferred present ease to faithfulness to God. It is the state of mind which will land many in a coming day in apostasy.

Modernised from C. E. StuartOriginal wording

Drinking without a thought of God

One writer traces the move from what people see to what they think about God:

When people see the prosperity of the wicked, it makes them bold to follow them in their evil ways. It happened even among God's people Israel. "Waters of a full cup are drained by them." They seize the chance to drain a full cup of water. They care only for their own welfare, and they think that God does not know (v. 11).

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

From the crowd to the argument

The drift does not stop at behaviour. It hardens into an argument:

The wicked were not the only ones their prosperity intoxicated. Its effect was that people from among those who professed to belong to God went over to them. Encouraged by it, they threw off all restraint. For, they argued, how can God know? How can the Most High have any knowledge? Are not these admittedly the "wicked," whom He denounces? And yet, see how they live at ease, and their wealth increases?

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

Why a believer conforms

The drift begins inside. Watching evil go unpunished works on the heart first, and conduct follows:

For a believer, the effect of constantly watching evil go unpunished is fretfulness. That holds true unless the soul is kept habitually resting on God. This feeling quite often produces a willingness to conform, at least in part, for the sake of ease and personal advantage. The conscience still judges that thing as contrary to God.

Modernised from A. PridhamOriginal wording

One more thing is worth adding. The man who describes the wicked in verses 4-12 has slipped himself. One writer cautions that everything said here is true, but it is not the whole truth. It is the world as seen by a believer who is, for the moment, out of touch with God (Hamilton Smith).

A picture of days still ahead

One writer sees the same conditions returning on a larger scale, and gives the same answer:

In that day those who apostatise will be outwardly prosperous, having more than heart could wish, and the waters of a full cup wrung out to them. (Psalm 73:3-12.) How truly then will it be a word in season, "O Israel, trust in Jehovah. He is their help and their shield."

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Where the tangle comes undone

Verse 10 is the low point of the drift. The psalm shows the way out, and it is a change of place:

When the Psalmist sought to know all this, he says, it was too painful for him. "Until I went into the sanctuary of God, then I understood their end." God's presence restores the right perspective.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Summary

- Sight. Watching evil prosper unpunished breeds fretfulness in a believer. Only a soul resting on God escapes it.

- Turn. God's own people turn "hither," drifting toward the wicked. The danger is not ancient history; it is live today.

- Bait. The full cup offers present ease in exchange for faithfulness to God — the first step toward apostasy.

- Denial. The drift ends in an argument: if the wicked live at ease, "how can God know?" Conduct hardens into unbelief.

- Sanctuary. More watching never clears the tangle. God's presence does, and there the end of the wicked becomes plain.

Psalms 73:11 · Darby

And they say, How can God know, and is there knowledge in the Most High?

Asaph watches proud and wicked people thrive, and he repeats their sneer: God does not see and does not know. He quotes their words without agreeing with them, and the psalm shows who else picks them up and what finally silences them.

The taunt itself

The reasoning behind the question is simple. No judgment falls, so they decide God knows nothing about their evil.

They take the chance to drain a full cup of water. They care only for their own comfort, and they think that God does not know (v. 11). They ask with contempt, "Is there knowledge in the Most High?" God does not step in to show His displeasure, so they shamelessly think they are getting away with evil. They imagine God is no wiser than they are!

Modernised from L M GrantOriginal wording

Who repeats it

The sneer does not stay with the wicked. God's own people take it up.

This verse uncovers a hard situation. The enemies of God boast without shame. The foolish and the wicked are full of prosperity, and nothing has touched them yet. So God's people (Israel is viewed here as a whole) join the wicked, their heart not being for God, and they say, "How can God know?"

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Comfort draws them across, not argument. The same drift still lies ahead for many.

The bait was water out of a full cup. They chose present ease over faithfulness to God. This state of mind will lead many, in a coming day, to fall away from God. God is shut out of their thoughts. "How can God know?" they say, "and is there knowledge in the Most High?" For a time the wicked prosper and grow richer.

Modernised from C E StuartOriginal wording

True as far as it goes

The picture of the wicked in verses 4 to 12 is accurate. But the man who draws it has, for the moment, lost touch with God.

But we must remember this. It is a picture of the wicked, seen by a believer who for the moment is out of communion with God. So everything he says is true, yet it is not the whole truth. It is still true that the wicked are marked by "pride" and "violence," "corruption" and "oppression." They persecute godly people, and they also blaspheme: they "set their mouth against the heavens." They say God takes no notice of what people do, and that there is no knowledge in the Most High — and all the while they prosper and grow richer.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Prosperity proves nothing

Reading God's verdict off a person's circumstances is a mistake the Bible exposes repeatedly.

Neither prosperity nor hardship in this world proves whether a man or a cause is from God. The wicked often prosper. Job's friends made this mistake badly. It left Habakkuk deeply puzzled, and Asaph, who wrote Psalm 73, had to follow the wicked in his thoughts beyond the grave to understand.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

There is a reason why judgment waits.

God has always allowed a large part of the world to seem to prosper in their evil. The reason is that the time of judgment has not yet come.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The answer found in the sanctuary

The question of verse 11 gets its reply in verse 17, when Asaph steps into God's presence and the hidden machinery becomes visible.

This is not all, for in the sanctuary we learn many truths. So he sees a second great truth. God seems to take little notice of the prosperity of the wicked, or even of the sufferings of the godly. Yet God and His government are really at work behind it all (verses 18-20)… It looked as if the Psalmist was in the slippery places, for had not his steps almost slipped? And the wicked looked firmly settled on a rock, for did they not prosper in the world and grow richer? In truth the godly soul was on the rock, though it shook; and the wicked were in slippery places, though they prospered.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

What held him back

One restraint kept Asaph from saying out loud what his heart was thinking: other believers would have been damaged by it.

Sadly, men might speak like this who never knew what it really means to be with Him! But if I joined them in this speech, says the psalmist, what a wrong I would do to the generation of Your children!

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Summary

- Sneer — no judgment falls, so the wicked decide that God does not see and does not know.

- Spread — the taunt does not stay with the wicked. Comfort draws God's own people to repeat it and to fall away.

- Half-truth — evil really does thrive, but the man who reports it has lost touch with God, so his account is true without being the whole truth.

- Delay — prosperity proves nothing either way. The wicked thrive only because the time of judgment has not yet come.

- Sanctuary — in God's house the picture flips. The shaken believer stands on rock; the prosperous stand on slippery ground.

Psalms 73:12 · Darby

Behold, these are the wicked, and they prosper in the world they heap up riches.

Asaph has been watching people who ignore God. They sail through life untouched. Verse 12 is his verdict on the whole scene. Underneath lies a hard question: does God still run the world, and is a clean heart worth anything?

The Portrait Verse 12 Closes

The verse is a summary line. It gathers up everything Asaph has described since verse 4.

(vv. 4-12) The psalmist goes on to describe the prosperity of the wicked. Apparently they are better off than the people of God. Death causes them "no pangs," and life has no plagues for them. They count pride as an ornament, and their violence, like a garment, is on show to all. Their eyes show their self-satisfaction and the gratification of every wish. In heart they are corrupt. In words they speak with lofty contempt of others. In their arrogance they pass judgment on things "in the heavens" as well as things on earth. The mass of the people follow them and give themselves over to license. They scorn God, and say He has no knowledge of the ways of men. Such are the ungodly, "who prosper in the world" and "increase in riches."

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

(Where this older translation says "prosper in the world," the ESV reads "always at ease.")

Prosperity Is Contagious

The danger is not only in the wicked themselves. Their success makes an argument, and others believe it — even people counted among God's own.

It was not only them whom their prosperity intoxicated. Its effect was that people from among the professing people of God fell away to them. Encouraged by it, they gave themselves up to license. For, they argued, how can God know? Are not these admittedly the "wicked," whom He denounces? and yet, see how they live at ease, and their wealth increases? So what use is it to have cleansed my heart and washed my hands in innocence? It only brings a life under God's constant stroke, chastised every morning.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Accurate, But Not the Whole Truth

Everything Asaph reports is real. But notice where he stands as he reports it.

In verses 4 to 12 he draws a solemn picture of the wicked. But remember who is describing them. It is a saint who is, for the moment, out of communion with God. So all he says is true, yet it is not the full truth. Still, "pride" and "violence," "corruption" and "oppression" really do mark the wicked. They persecute the godly, and they blaspheme: they "set their mouth against the heavens."

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The Riddle It Creates for Faith

Asaph's difficulty is not an ancient one. It presses on anyone who wants God's honour and sees evil rewarded.

We see the ungodly having their way. God seems to have forgotten, and the heart is envious. But too often this shows that our own heart would still like its portion here — at least a portion here as well as one to come… What a riddle! Where is God's government? What is the use of good?

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Asaph also lived before the fuller light we have now. That changes what a believer should expect.

It is no surprise that in an ungodly world the ungodly prosper. The surprise is that the godly are so often upset as they watch it. Asaph had some excuse. He lived in a day when heavenly things were not yet made clear… We live in a day when God has made heavenly things clear, and has told us plainly as Christians that "through many tribulations we must enter the kingdom of God."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

What the Riches Are Worth

The "increase" in this verse is real by one measure and empty by another.

Every step forward a man makes in worldly progress and prosperity always hardens his heart against God. No one can be rich in his own eyes and rich toward God at the same time. In the eyes of Christ, what nature counts as wealth and increase is poverty, nakedness, blindness and wretchedness… Wealth makes a man all-powerful — but only inside the circle that death draws around this present life.

Modernised from A. PridhamOriginal wording

Where the Riddle Breaks

The psalm turns at verse 17. It is a change of place before it is a change of mind.

Outside the sanctuary he looks at evil without God; inside he views everything, and everyone, with God. What a difference this makes! Outside, he had judged everything by time. Inside, he judges everything by eternity… The momentary prosperity and passing triumphs of the wicked fade from his view, and he sees instead the fearful end they are hurrying towards.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

That place is now open to anyone.

There is no earthly sanctuary today. There is no place of special holiness we must travel to… The Son has revealed the Father to us. We have received the indwelling Spirit and the full Word of God. So each of us may withdraw from the world. We can shut our door, know that God is present, and receive the blessing and lift His presence brings.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Summary

- Look. Verse 12 closes an eight-verse portrait: ease, arrogance, contempt for God, and money that keeps growing.

- Angle. Nothing in the picture is false. But a believer out of communion drew it, so it is true as far as it goes and no further.

- Drift. Prosperity preaches. Others fall in behind the wicked, concluding that God does not know and that a clean heart pays nothing.

- Weigh. No one can be rich in his own eyes and rich toward God at once; wealth is only power inside a circle that death draws.

- Enter. Outside the sanctuary, time measures everything; inside, eternity does. You need no journey today — only a shut door and the presence of God.

Psalms 73:13 · Darby

Truly have I purified my heart in vain, and washed my hands in innocency

Asaph has just described the easy life of people who ignore God. Now he turns the comparison on himself: keeping his heart clean looks like wasted effort. Commentators treat this honest complaint as both a real temptation and a verdict the Psalm will later overturn.

A clean heart and clean hands

The two images — a cleansed heart and washed hands — cover the inward and the outward side of a godly life. One writer puts the complaint into everyday speech:

In verses 13 and 14 he describes the solemn effect on a godly soul of dwelling on evil while out of communion with God. He is tempted to think it is all in vain to have a clean heart and innocent hands. What profit is there in restraining my thoughts and keeping away from wickedness? After all, the wicked prosper, while I am plagued and chastened every morning.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The view from outside communion with God

The complaint is not a neutral report on the world. It is how things look from one particular position. The same writer sums that position up in three strokes:

This then is the picture presented by a soul out of communion. The wicked prospering, the godly suffering, and God indifferent. The government of God apparently completely gone from the earth.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Honest feeling, wrong words

Feeling this way is natural. Saying it out loud is another matter, and Asaph himself decides against it:

How natural this seems to anyone who knows anything of his own heart! But is it right to give way like this by contrasting one's own lot with the flourishing wicked? No, says the Psalmist, it is not. He would not speak like that, however great the temptation. If he really did, he would offend against the generation of God's children.

Modernised from C E StuartOriginal wording

Why looking harder brings no relief

The complaint starts with what the eye takes in, and the mind then reasons from it. That process cannot give the sufferer what he needs:

The eye affects the heart, naturally, for joy or grief. But the result of the heart's reasoning about what the eyes see is always profitless and empty. There is nothing there capable of giving relief and compensation to a troubled spirit under the pressure of an evil day. Light is to be found in God alone.

Modernised from A. PridhamOriginal wording

The self-interest hidden in the question

Distress at evil is right in itself. But something else can travel alongside it — a wish for our portion now:

We see the ungodly having their way, so that God seems to have forgotten, and the heart is envious. But too often in our case it shows that the heart would still like its portion here — at least a portion here as well as one to come. The sorrow at the power of evil in the world is right. But in our minds it mixes with a liking for our own way and our own judgment in setting the evil aside… The ungodly prosper in the world. What a riddle! Where is God's government? What is the use of good?

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

The plagues he counted as loss

Asaph reads his daily chastening as evidence that his clean heart bought him nothing. Others read the same daily dealing as the mark of a son:

There is also the solemn reminder that if we are without chastisement, which all share in, then we are illegitimate children and not sons… God chastises His children. Asaph did not understand this truth… His difficulty ended when he went into the sanctuary of God, and the Holy Spirit also answers and explains it in Hebrews 12:8.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

One writer adds a purpose for the trial. God sent it as "a necessary 'trial of faith' — a faith that will triumph no matter how severe the trial" (L M Grant).

Why a Christian has even less excuse

God had promised Israel prosperity in this life. So the contradiction hit Asaph hard. Our case is different:

It is not very surprising that in an ungodly world the ungodly prosper. What is surprising is that the godly should so often be upset as they watch it. There was some excuse for Asaph. He lived in a day when heavenly things were not clearly revealed. Back then God spoke of blessing His people Israel in their basket and in their store. We live in a day when heavenly things are clearly revealed. As Christians we have been plainly told that "through many tribulations we must enter the kingdom of God."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Summary

- The look — the complaint starts at the eye. He watches the wicked prosper, then reasons from what he sees.

- The loss — out of touch with God, he loses his confidence. The wicked prosper, the godly suffer, and God looks indifferent.

- The lie — that a clean heart and clean hands bring no profit. Natural to feel, but wrong to say aloud, since it would offend God's children.

- The light — relief is not found in the scene at all but in God alone, and Asaph's difficulty ended in the sanctuary.

- The lesson — the daily chastening he counted against himself is the mark of a son. The trial is meant to produce a faith that triumphs.

Psalms 73:14 · Darby

For all the day have I been plagued, and chastened every morning.

Psalm 73 records a man who kept his heart clean and found that it bought him nothing but pain. Meanwhile, people who ignored God lived at ease. Verse 14 adds up his side of that account. It raises the question the whole psalm exists to answer: is God good to His own?

The Weight of the Words

The verse measures suffering by the clock. One writer notes that the trouble filled the day, then began again at daybreak:

"All the day long" he had been plagued, not only during the day, but again when a new morning broke (v. 14). It seemed never-ending, but God sent it to be a necessary "trial of faith" — a faith that will triumph no matter how severe the trial.

Modernised from L M GrantOriginal wording

The Complaint Underneath

Verse 14 is not a bare report. It is evidence in an argument against the worth of his own godliness:

The outward prosperity of the wicked stands beside the suffering of the godly. So the soul is tempted to think that it is useless to have cleansed his heart and washed his hands. What benefit is there in having a pure heart and clean hands, if one is plagued all the day and chastened every morning, while those who are wicked prosper?

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

What Twisted His View

Everything the psalmist describes is accurate as far as it goes. What warped it was where he stood when he looked:

He lets us know how it came about that his confidence in God was so badly shaken. The secret comes out. He was occupied with evil while out of touch with God. So he had a limited and twisted view of the evil. He saw the prosperity of the wicked, and he saw the adversity of the godly. As a result he envied the portion of the wicked, he thought little of the portion of the godly, and he almost lost confidence in God… All that he says of the wicked is true, but it is not the full truth. It is the wicked as seen by a saint who is, for the moment, out of communion with God.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Whose Voice Is Speaking

Commentators differ over who is talking in verses 13 and 14. Most read it as the psalmist's own private thought. Others read it as the words of a whole people who counted themselves God's and drew the obvious conclusion from their circumstances:

The enemies of God boast on unhumbled. The foolish and wicked are full of prosperity, untouched so far. So God's people (Israel is here viewed as a whole) join the ungodly, their heart not being for God, and say, "How does God know?" They compare what came of their being, as they supposed, God's people — that is, chastisement — with the untouched prosperity of those who did not care for God. "They say" reaches, I judge, to the end of verse 14.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

The Blows of a Father

The daily correction the psalmist resented was the very thing that proved he belonged. One writer states the rule behind it:

God never disciplines or strikes us unless there is something in us that requires it… So it is; God disciplines His children. "If you are left without discipline," says the Spirit, "then you are illegitimate children and not sons." Asaph did not understand this truth. So he says, "I was envious of the arrogant when I saw the prosperity of the wicked… They are not in trouble as others are; they are not stricken like the rest of mankind." But of himself he says, "All the day long I have been stricken and rebuked every morning." (Psalm 73:3-14.) Going into the sanctuary of God removed his difficulty.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Where the Complaint Finds Its Answer

Have these words ever been your own complaint? One writer says the complaint itself shows where you stand:

"Nature shrinks," as we often say… "All the day long I have been stricken and rebuked every morning," may be its sore complaint. But what does that prove, except that we are outside the "sanctuary"? That is the one place where we can grasp what all this means. There we learn to see our nearness to God as the very thing that makes all this painstaking care and love necessary. That nearness also secures it to us.

Modernised from Frederick W GrantOriginal wording

Summary

- Sight. The believer measures his life against the comfort of the ungodly. He sees unbroken trouble, morning after morning, and no return at all for a clean heart.

- Slip. The fault lies in the viewpoint, not the facts. A soul taken up with evil while out of touch with God sees a limited and twisted picture, and almost loses confidence in Him.

- Speaker. Commentators differ on whose words these are — the psalmist's own, or those of a whole people who compared their chastening with the untouched ease of the wicked and asked, "How does God know?"

- Sonship. The daily correction he resented was the proof he wanted. God disciplines His children. A life without that discipline marks someone out as no son at all.

- Sanctuary. The complaint of verse 14 shows a man standing outside God's presence. Inside it, the same dealings read as nearness, care, and a trial of faith that will triumph.

Psalms 73:15 · Darby

If I said, I will speak thus, behold, I should be faithless to the generation of thy children.

The check that held his tongue

Asaph has just said that keeping his heart clean was pointless. Verse 15 is the moment he catches himself. He stops, not because anyone had answered his argument, but because of who would hear him. One writer sees this as the first sign that faith was still alive in him:

However, in this the darkest moment of his experiences, divine affections assert themselves (verse 15). This proves that, though his steps had nearly slipped, divine life was working in his soul. Hot and angry thoughts were rushing through his mind. But love for the people of God held his lips, and that love is the proof of faith in God.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The doubt itself did not go away. Love for God's people is what kept it unspoken.

What the words weigh

The ESV calls the danger betraying "the generation of your children." Older translations read "offend against." Either way, Asaph measures his words by the harm they would do to others, not by how honest they would feel to say.

But if I joined them in this speech, says the psalmist, what injustice would I not be doing to the generation of Your children! He speaks of Israel according to their birthright, for God had said, "Israel is my son, even my firstborn."

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Who "the generation of your children" are

The word "generation" here does not mean everyone alive at one moment. Across the Psalms it marks out a kind of person — a family defined by character, not by date. One writer traces this through several psalms, quoting them in an older wording:

Parkhurst, in his Lexicon, gives one meaning of genea as "Men of like quality and disposition, though of neither one place nor age". The Psalms bear this out: "You will keep them, O LORD, you will preserve them from this generation forever" (Ps. 12:7)... "God is in the generation of the righteous" (Ps. 14:5). "The generation of them that seek you" (Ps. 24:6)... These verses imply a certain moral character or kind of person.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

So the people Asaph would have hurt are not just those alive with him. They are God's people in every age — which is why his private complaint was never private.

The cost of standing apart

Silence solved nothing for him. He would not talk like the wicked, and that choice left him with his problem and without their success:

Could Asaph possibly join, as others did, with the wicked in their endeavours? — that is, if he spoke as the ungodly spoke, he realised he would be untrue to the generation of God's children. How painful was his predicament! His conscience and his faith in God would not let him take the attitude of the ungodly. Yet by standing apart from them, he could not expect to prosper as they did.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Verse 15 restrains him, but it settles nothing. The turmoil goes on into verse 16, and only the sanctuary ends it.

Judging by natural eyes

What set the crisis going was the way he measured life — by what his own eyes could see:

When Asaph went into the sanctuary of God it was as though he got a pair of new eyes... Before he went in he was a miserable and restless man, and as ignorant as a beast, as he afterwards confessed. He understood nothing, and everything appeared wrong... And this is the subtle and serious thing about judging things by the natural powers. The man who does so, whether Christian or infidel, becomes a discontented man and a murmurer.

Modernised from J. T. MawsonOriginal wording

The verse as a rule for speech

The verse also works as a rule for anyone who teaches or writes. One writer applies it to himself:

To offend in any way against the generation of God's children will always be distressing to a true witness of God (Ps. 73:15). But all who seek His glory in their work must surely care first about this: to put His words out boldly, and, as far as it is known, to set the way of pleasing God openly before the feet of those "who will walk godly in Christ Jesus."

Modernised from A. PridhamOriginal wording

Another draws the practical caution about circulating a half-formed doubt:

Let me add this. On so serious a subject as God's Word, it would be well to hold back the publication of a doubt until we have examined the matter on all sides. The natural mind is sceptical enough without help or encouragement. A mere question might raise doubts, and those doubts could trouble many a soul despite the clearest light given in answer, for the heart loves darkness.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Envy — the crisis starts when a believer judges God's dealings by natural eyes. That turns him into a discontented murmurer.

- Love — what stops the complaint is not a better argument. It is love for God's people, and that love is itself proof of divine life in the soul.

- Family — "the generation of your children" means a people of one character in every age, not just those alive at the time.

- Silence — holding your tongue spares others, but the pain stays. Verse 15 restrains; only the sanctuary explains.

- Caution — speak God's words boldly. But weigh a doubt on all sides before you publish it, because the natural mind needs no help to doubt.

Psalms 73:16 · Darby

When I thought to be able to know this, it was a grievous task in mine eyes;

Asaph has just admitted he almost slipped. He envied the easy lives of people who ignore God, and here his own reasoning about it hits a wall.

The knot he could not untie

Asaph had already refused to speak his doubts out loud, for the sake of others. The silence, though, solved nothing inside him.

Hot and angry thoughts were rushing through his mind. But love for the people of God, the proof of faith in God, held his lips... But though he puts a seal on his lips, a turmoil of painful thoughts still disturbs his inner peace. He does not know how to reconcile God's goodness to His people with the suffering they live in. And all the while the wicked prosper.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Thinking it over by himself

"When I thought how to understand this" describes a conversation with himself. One writer explains what that kind of thinking is, and why it left him stuck.

The meaning of the word "meditation" is "to talk to oneself" about the subject filling the mind... In Psalm 73 we find that Asaph was troubled in his meditations on the prosperity of the wicked. He talked it over with himself, and could not see any way out of his difficulty. It was a stain, he was tempted to think, on the government of God, and he was filled with perplexity... The lesson is this. If meditation is to be of value and for blessing, we must carry it on in the presence of God, depending on Him and on the ministry of His Spirit. Otherwise we would be lost in the maze of human thoughts and speculations.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

What reasoning alone does to a person

The trouble was not only in his head. Judging life by our own powers works on the heart as well.

Before he went into the sanctuary of God, he was a miserable and restless man, and as ignorant as a beast, as he afterwards confessed. He understood nothing, and everything seemed wrong. His whole soul was in rebellion against the state of things, and so against God, who is behind everything. And this is the subtle and serious thing about judging things by our natural powers. The person who does so, whether Christian or unbeliever, becomes discontented and a grumbler. Nothing offends God like those two things, for they show a soul at war with the will of God.

Modernised from J. T. MawsonOriginal wording

A new measure in the sanctuary

The next verse gives the answer. It is not new facts, but a new place to stand.

Outside the sanctuary he looks at evil without God; inside he views everything, and everyone, with God. What a difference this makes! Outside, all had been viewed in relation to time; inside, all is viewed in relation to eternity. The wickedness of men, the goodness of God, the prosperity of sinners, the sorrows of the saints — he no longer sees these in connection with the passing moment. He sees them in relation to the great end towards which everything is moving.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Another writer says what the one who enters finds there.

That is, in the sanctuary of God everything is understood, no matter how difficult, trying and painful it may be, whether about ourselves or others. Once we enter there, we are in the place of God's light and God's love; and then, whatever the difficulty may be, we understand it.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The same door, open to us

One writer asks what answers to that sanctuary now.

Is there anything in the New Testament that answers to the sanctuary where Asaph found the key to all his difficulties? Yes, there is. We have a sanctuary in the New Testament, and the Minister of it. Hebrews 10 tells us that we have boldness to enter the Holiest — that is, the very presence of God. It also tells us of Jesus who is there. He is our great High Priest, and He delights to lead us in and keep us in that place of light and blessing.

Modernised from J. T. MawsonOriginal wording

A Christian, another writer adds, has less excuse than Asaph for being shaken by the sight.

It is no surprise that an ungodly world brings worldly prosperity to the ungodly. The surprise is that the godly are so often upset when they see it. There was some excuse for Asaph, for he lived in a day when heavenly things were not clearly revealed... We live in a day when heavenly things are clearly revealed. As Christians we have been plainly told that "through many tribulations we must enter the kingdom of God."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Summary

- Outside — reasoning on his own, Asaph cannot square God's goodness to His people with the prospering of the wicked.

- Alone — his thinking was talking it over with himself. Away from God's presence, that ends in a maze of guesses.

- Souring — judging by our own powers leaves a person discontented and grumbling, at war with God's will.

- Inside — in the sanctuary the same facts belong to eternity, not to the passing moment. There everything is understood.

- Open — that sanctuary is now God's own presence. We enter with boldness, and Jesus our High Priest leads us in.

Psalms 73:17 · Darby

Until I went into the sanctuaries of God; [then] understood I their end.

Asaph did not doubt that God exists. He doubted that God is fair. The wicked prospered, while he kept his heart clean and suffered every day. Verse 17 is the hinge of the whole psalm — one word, "until," marks where the reasoning stopped and the seeing began.

The Turning Point

Before this verse, Asaph does his sums outside God's presence. He keeps getting the wrong total. One writer traces what changed the moment he stepped inside.

There is a limit to the conflict of his soul. It goes on "until" he returns to the secret place he had wandered from in spirit — "Until," as he says, "I went into the sanctuary of God" (verse 17). The sanctuary speaks of the presence of God. Outside the sanctuary he looks at evil without God. Inside, he views everything, and everyone, with God. What a difference this makes! Outside, he had viewed everything in relation to time. Inside, he views everything in relation to eternity.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

"Then I Discerned Their End"

What he saw inside reversed what he had assumed outside.

It looked, indeed, as if the Psalmist had been in the slippery places, for had not his steps almost slipped? The wicked, on the other hand, seemed to stand on solid rock. Did they not prosper in the world and grow rich? In reality the godly soul was on the rock though shaking; and the wicked were in slippery places, though prospering. Away from the sanctuary, the godly man looked at the prosperity of the wicked and was cast down. From inside the sanctuary, he sees that in the end they will be cast down.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The same measure applies to the desires that pull at our own hearts.

The tendency of the human heart and affections is always downward — always toward earth and the things of earth... But let us think of the end! The end alone is the true test by which to judge in such matters.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The Light Turns Inward

The sanctuary did not only expose the wicked. It exposed Asaph himself.

If the sanctuary exposes the character of the sinner, it will also uncover the hidden springs of evil in the heart of a saint. The light of the sanctuary lays everything bare. "When my heart was in a ferment," he says, "then I was brutish and ignorant, I was as a beast before You" (verses 21, 22). A beast acts without the slightest reference to God. The saint comes to admit this: if he leaves God out of his thoughts, he will not only sink below what is proper to a natural man; he will fall to the level of a beast.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

That self-discovery is not the end of the visit but the doorway to the best part of it.

The discovery of what is in us opens the way for the revelation of what is in Him... He can say, "I was as a beast before You, nevertheless I am continually with You." When hot and bitter thoughts were raging in his heart, even then God's tireless care never left him.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Two Endings Set Side by Side

By the end of the psalm, the sanctuary has produced not one conclusion but a contrast.

He saw that you can only judge the course of the godless rich, or of the plagued and downtrodden saints, when the end of each comes into view... Asaph himself was one of the godly, plagued all the day long and "chastened every morning." Yet in the sanctuary he lifts his eyes to God with joy and confesses, "You will guide me with Your counsel, and afterward receive me to glory." The end of the one: brought into desolation. The end of the other: received to glory. The contrast is complete!

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Where the Sanctuary Is for Us

For Israel the sanctuary was a place set apart. Commentators point out that for Christians the way in has changed.

To us the sanctuary does not speak so much of God's hidden ways as it did to Israel. This is what marks Christianity: the veil of the sanctuary is torn from top to bottom, and we have "confidence to enter the holy places by the blood of Jesus" (Heb. 10:19). It is a blessing to know this! But it is a far greater blessing to truly draw near because we know it!

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Summary

- Until — The whole psalm turns on one word. Asaph's questions were not answered by better reasoning but by entering God's presence.

- Inside — Outside the sanctuary he judged by time; inside he judged by eternity. Same facts, opposite conclusion.

- End — There the wicked's firm ground proved slippery and the shaking believer proved to be on the rock. The end is the only fair test of any life.

- Exposed — The same light that showed their end showed him his own heart as brutish. Only then could he learn that he had never left God's care.

- Open — For the Christian the veil is torn and the way in stands open. Knowing this is a blessing; drawing near is a far greater one.