Reproach hath broken my heart, and I am overwhelmed and I looked for sympathy, but there was none; and for comforters, but I found none.
Psalm 69 traces the sufferings of Christ at the hands of men. Verse 20 shows what those sufferings did inside Him: a heart broken by reproach, and eyes searching for one kind face. Why could the reproach of men break His heart, and why did no comforter come?
The wound was not just insult. It was love met with hatred. One writer contrasts it with the way our own hearts break:
Christ's heart was also broken, but in a way quite different from how our hearts are broken. His love was disregarded: this is what broke His heart. The more He showed His love, the more hatred rose up against Him. "Reproach has broken My heart." We need this breaking to lay our hearts bare; He did not. He was love itself. But the hatred of man made it impossible to show that love, and this broke His human heart. Man's only answer to so much grace was the shame and disgrace of the cross. And in spite of all this, His broken heart bore the curse and the whole weight of God's judgment, to save the very people who insulted Him and spat in His face.
Some take the words as more than a figure of speech. One writer sees in them the direct cause of Jesus' death:
In Psalm 69:20 we read, "Reproach has broken my heart"; and it seems as though this was in fact the immediate cause of the Lord's death. Sorrow upon sorrow had burst in on Him, when, having cried with a loud voice, He stopped breathing.
The verse records a search, not just an absence. That one word tells us how truly human He was:
The Lord Jesus felt the rebuffs. He would not have been truly man if He had not felt them. He could say, "I looked for some to take pity, but there was none; and for comforters, but I found none." Notice, "I looked." His loving human heart longed and "looked" for pity, but did not find it. He looked for comforters, but looked in vain. There was no pity for Jesus — no comforters for Him. He was left alone.
Commentators point to Gethsemane as the moment the words came true — and the failure came from His closest friends:
Then again, when reproach had broken His heart He had to say, "I am full of heaviness: and I looked for some to take pity, but there was none, and for comforters, but found none." This was fulfilled in His disciples. It was in Gethsemane that He was "sorrowful and very heavy," and even Peter, James and John failed Him completely.
These sorrows are of a different kind from the forsaking described in Psalm 22. They are real, they lasted to the very end, and they were not the payment for sin:
Some have raised special objections to the idea that this suffering continued until death. But the Psalms are witnesses of it. No doubt the cup of the wrath of God has, so to speak, almost blotted out all the rest. Yet it is no less true that these Psalms describe sufferings of Christ at the hands of men right up to death, and show that He felt them. We see them fulfilled word for word in the Gospels. Read Psalm 22:14-20, and notice the contrast between these sufferings and the forsaking of God.
With no comfort on earth, He turned to God alone. The next verse shows what men gave Him instead:
So He looks to God alone in the day when the reproaches of men had broken His heart. To look elsewhere for comfort was useless, for in this world there were none to take pity. He looked, indeed, for some to take pity, for some to comfort, but He found none. Far from pity and comfort, they only answered His cry with gall and vinegar.
He found no comforter, so He can comfort everyone who has none:
The bitter yet blessed waters of Marah lead to a deeper knowledge of Calvary. And the deep, painful need of a broken heart leads to deeper fellowship with His heart. He could say, as no one else ever could, "Reproach has broken my heart." His people enjoy the tender sympathies of fellow travellers freely. He had none of that. He had to add — "and I looked for some to take pity, but there was none; and for comforters, but I found none." Oh, what a refuge we have in the once broken and desolate heart of Jesus!
- Reproach. What broke His heart was love turned away — the more He showed it, the more hatred rose against Him.
- Looked. "I looked" is the mark of true manhood: His heart wanted pity and searched for it.
- None. Gethsemane gave the answer: even Peter, James and John failed Him, and men gave Him gall and vinegar.
- Distinct. These are sufferings from men, felt right up to death, and set in contrast with the forsaking of Psalm 22.
- Refuge. He found no comforter, so His broken heart is now the shelter of everyone left alone.
Yea, they gave me gall for my food, and in my thirst they gave me vinegar to drink.
Psalm 69 is a prayer of deep suffering. This line records the only refreshment the sufferer's enemies offered him. Older translations read "gall" and "vinegar" where the ESV has "poison" and "sour wine." The Gospels show these words fulfilled at the cross.
Not every line in this psalm has the same speaker. Commentators identify this one with Christ.
Only a few psalms apply wholly and entirely to the Lord in His personal sorrows. Psalm 22 is one, and Psalm 102… There are a great many in which some passages apply to the Lord and others to the faithful remnant in Israel. For instance, this line in Psalm 69 refers to Christ; but the subject of Psalm 69 is first Israel.
Both words name real substances that soldiers used at a crucifixion.
Gall (Hebrew rosh, Greek chole) is some extremely bitter or poisonous plant, not definitely identified. The word stands as a symbol of "bitterness."… Roman soldiers mixed gall with the sour wine, or vinegar, that they drank. They gave it to men about to be crucified, it is now supposed, to make them less sensitive to the torture. They offered it to the Lord, but He refused it. In Mark 15:23 myrrh is named instead of gall; the meaning would be the same.
The Gospels record two separate offers, and the difference is deliberate.
At the cross "they gave Him vinegar to drink mingled with gall" (v. 34). We must not confuse this with the moment in John, where the Lord says, "I thirst." In Matthew's account it was the numbing drink given to prisoners before they suffered. This the Lord would not drink. In John, the Lord, while on the cross, fulfils a Scripture… He did drink the vinegar then. But here in Matthew, on the contrary, "when He had tasted it, He would not drink" — He wanted no relief from man.
He tasted the drink before refusing it, and that had a purpose:
Of course He knew what it was before tasting it. But by tasting it He let His enemies know something. He was not simply refusing a drink out of defiance. He was refusing it because of the numbing gall added to it. He would bear His sufferings without this, and in full consciousness of all that was involved.
In John's account the Lord says "I thirst" — and He knew what those words would fulfil.
We now see Jesus Himself in that dark hour surveying the whole field of prophecy, and well aware that of all the predictions centring on His death only one remained to be fulfilled. In Psalm 69 David had written, "In my thirst they gave me vinegar to drink." A small thing in itself, but every word of God must come true in its season. In that hour of suffering He rose above His circumstances. He saw the one thing lacking, and He spoke words that at once brought it to pass. No mere man could have done either the one or the other.
Where does a sufferer turn when men answer his cry like this?
So He looks to God alone in the day when the reproaches of men had broken His heart. To look elsewhere for comfort was useless… He looked for some to take pity, for some to comfort, but He found none. So far from pity and comfort, they only answered His cry with gall and vinegar.
That response exposed the human heart:
Here was brought to light what men are: utterly, altogether sinful. No feeling of pity moved their evil hearts when they stood in the presence of absolute goodness in the extremity of suffering. It was as they would have it — goodness nailed to a cross, and evil enthroned. Jesus cursed, and Barabbas cheered.
Men inflicted these sufferings. Commentators set them apart from the forsaking of Psalm 22.
Without doubt, the cup of the wrath of God has almost blotted out all the rest. But it is no less true that these Psalms describe sufferings of Christ at the hands of men, right up to death, and show that He felt them. We see them literally fulfilled in the Gospels… Read Psalm 22:14-20, and notice the contrast between these sufferings and the forsaking of God.
- Voice. Psalm 69 speaks first about Israel. Yet this line belongs to Christ, and the Gospels show it fulfilled to the letter.
- Bitterness. Gall is a bitter, poisonous plant. Soldiers mixed it with their sour wine to numb men about to be crucified.
- Refusal. He tasted the drugged cup, then refused it. His enemies could see He turned down the numbing gall, not a drink. He would suffer fully conscious.
- Fulfilment. Later He said "I thirst." One prophecy still stood unfulfilled. From the cross He saw it and spoke the words that brought it to pass.
- Verdict. He looked for comforters and found none. Sour wine was man's answer to absolute goodness in extreme suffering. These wounds came from human hands — a different suffering from the forsaking of God in Psalm 22.