(To the chief Musician. Of the sons of Korah. An instruction.) O God, with our ears have we heard, our fathers have told us, the work thou wroughtest in their days, in the days of old
Psalm 44 opens with a nation telling God what it never saw: a report passed down from their fathers about what He once did. The rest of the psalm sets that memory against defeat and scattering, and asks if He is still the same God.
A summary of the whole psalm shows what that memory does, and why the speakers call Him God and not Jehovah:
Psalm 44 gives a full and vivid picture of the state of the nation, as it stands in the conscience of the faithful few. They had heard with their ears. Faith rested in the memorial of all the old mighty deliverances God had worked. He had put them in possession of the land by His power, not theirs (v. 1-8). … In this psalm we still have God, not Jehovah; for they are outside.
The verse names a sense: hearing. These people did not watch God act; their fathers told them about it:
Psalm 44 goes back in spirit, "We have heard with our ears," and so on. They did not see, because they were driven out; but they hear. It is the past set against the present desolation.
The content of the report matters as much as the fact of it. What the fathers handed down was no record of national strength:
The godly remnant are cast out of the land and under the oppression of their enemies. Still they cling in simple faith to what they have heard from their fathers about God's mighty works for His people in the past. In those days God's people did not enter the land by their own power, and they did not drive out their enemies by it. It was God's right hand and God's arm that brought them into blessing, because God was favourable to His people and delighted in them.
This opening verse carries a rule for anyone whose life looks nothing like God's promises:
This psalm unfolds deeply important principles that apply to God's people in any day of ruin. First, in an evil day we should always judge the power and goodness of God by the way He acted for His people at the beginning. Beware of judging God by the low condition their own failure has brought them into (vv. 1-3).
The memory of verse 1 is not nostalgia. It becomes the ground of the psalm's closing plea, and the next psalm gives the reply:
In Psalm 44 the faith of the remnant rests on the memorial of God's past deliverance of His people. … Their present condition was the complete opposite: "But you have rejected us and disgraced us and have not gone out with our armies." Still, in the middle of all the soul-searching this caused, faith cries, "Rise up; come to our help! Redeem us for the sake of your steadfast love!" (v. 26.) Psalm 45 answers this cry by bringing in Messiah. He brings deliverance from enemies, and His kingdom is for ever and ever.
Four psalms later the same voices speak again, and pick up the wording of this verse:
The psalm refers back beautifully to the beginning of Psalm 44. There, in their distress, they had said, We have heard with our ears … the mighty works of the fathers' days. Now they say, As we have heard, so have we seen in the city of the LORD of hosts, in the city of our God.
One writer draws a line from this psalm to the state of the church:
It opens deep views of the wisdom of God's disciplinary dealing with the vessels of faith and mercy. He makes them hold more closely to Himself under a pressure they can see He has appointed by His will. … So this psalm offers plenty of material for fruitful meditation to the Christian who enters in spirit into the present broken and dishonoured state of the Church.
- Heard — the psalm begins with a report, not a scene they saw. They hear because they have been driven out, and the past stands against the present desolation.
- Not their sword — the fathers passed on that God's right hand and arm won the land, because He delighted in His people. Their own power did not do it.
- Measured — judge God's power and goodness by how He acted at the beginning. Never judge Him by the low state His people have fallen into.
- Answered — the memory becomes a plea: rise up and redeem. The next psalm answers it by bringing in Messiah, whose kingdom lasts forever.
- Seen — the hearing of Psalm 44 turns into sight in Psalm 48: as we have heard, so have we seen in the city of the LORD of hosts.
Thou, by thy hand, didst dispossess the nations, but them thou didst plant; thou didst afflict the peoples, but them didst thou cause to spread out.
God's people look back past their own defeat to the day God gave them the land. Every step of that memory is something God did: His hand drove out the nations and planted Israel in their place. The question under the verse is whether the God who acted then will act now, when the same people lie scattered and shamed.
The psalm opens with a memory. One writer hears in it the conscience of a faithful few, speaking when the nation has lost everything.
Psalm 44 gives a full and vivid picture of the state of the nation, as it stands in the conscience of the remnant. They had heard it with their ears. Faith rested on the record of all the mighty deliverances God had worked long ago. It rested on how He had put them in possession of the land by His power, not theirs (v. 1-8). Verses 9-16 recount their present state. They are cast off and scattered.
The verse says the same thing twice: God removed one people and planted another in their place. Neither half was within Israel's strength.
God had driven out the nations who occupied the land of promise (v. 2), and Israel certainly did not have the power to do such a thing. It was God who planted Israel in the land. It was God who afflicted those who had seized the land He meant to give to Israel. Israel did use their swords in the conquest, but their swords did not win the victory (v. 3).
Going back to the start of their national story does more than stir feeling. It settles two facts that still held in the day of defeat.
God had dispossessed the nations and planted them; He had broken up races, and cast them out. His right hand, His arm, and the light of His face had shown that He accepted them. All this stayed with them as wisdom for the present. Man's nothingness was just as certain; God's sufficiency was just as perfect.
Israel's lack of military strength was not an accident of history. God designed it, so that the people would always know whose arm had won them the land.
Jehovah designed outward weakness as the mark of Israel's national life. The people were meant to know that they did not win the land by their own sword. Their own arm never saved them at any time. It was God's right hand and His arm, and the light of His face, because He had shown them favour.
Everything in the first part of the psalm rests on taking the old accounts as true. One writer traces the reasoning as a chain. Its first link is belief in what they had heard.
In the first place, they have heard and believed the news of God's mighty intervention for their fathers in the days of old. They are not the type who believe in nothing miraculous. Such people reject even the well-attested facts of their own national history. These accept them with their whole heart.
The second link is that this God has not changed hands.
Then, in the second place, they know that the God who worked in ancient times is their God today. They can say, "You are MY King, O God;" and He is ever the same. So they should trust Him now, just as He was trusted long ago.
Verse 2 is not nostalgia. It is the opening move of an argument addressed to God.
In view of these past works, faith pleads the present dreadful condition: God has cast them off and put them to shame, and He no longer goes out with their armies. Our God will never refuse to answer such appeals. But He must work very deeply in the hearts of the people, to bring them to a true sense of their own sin.
Remembering how God has acted before is strength for the road still ahead.
The blessed knowledge that the Lord is with us must always prove the true secret of strength as we move onward. So must the memory of His gracious ways with us in days gone by. The same mighty hand that had already defeated the kings Sihon and Og could subdue all the kings of Canaan.
- Hand. The land changed owners by God's hand, not Israel's sword — He drove out and He planted.
- Design. God kept Israel weak on purpose, so no one could mistake whose arm had saved them.
- Memory. Believing the old accounts is the first link in the chain; the second is knowing that God is the same today.
- Plea. That remembered work becomes an argument in prayer. God never refuses such appeals, though He first works deep in the heart about sin.
- Result. Two facts stand: man can do nothing, and God is enough for whatever comes next.
For not by their own sword did they take possession of the land, neither did their own arm save them; but thy right hand, and thine arm, and the light of thy countenance, because thou hadst delight in them.
Psalm 44 opens with a nation in trouble. It looks back at the one event every Israelite knew by heart: how a slave people came to own Canaan. Verse 3 gives the verdict on that conquest. It takes the credit out of Israel's hands and puts it in God's. That raises the question the rest of the psalm presses: will the God who did that do it again?
The psalm is not a victory song. It is the voice of a scattered people, reaching back to what they were taught.
Psalm 44 gives a full and vivid picture of the state of the nation, as it stands in the conscience of the remnant. They had heard with their ears. Faith rested on the memory of all the old mighty deliverances God had worked. It rested on how He had put them in possession of the land by His power, not theirs (v. 1-8). Verses 9-16 describe their present state. They are cast off and scattered.
Israel did fight. Real swords were drawn in Canaan. The verse does not deny the fighting. It denies that the fighting explains the outcome.
God had driven out the nations who occupied the land of promise (v. 2). It is certain that Israel did not have the power to do such a thing. It was God who planted Israel in the land. He afflicted those who had taken over the land He purposed to give to Israel. Israel used their swords in conquering the land, but their swords did not win the victory (v. 3). This would have been impossible if God had not been their strength. It was God's right hand, His arm, and the light of His countenance that made all the difference, because of His sovereign favour to Israel.
The verse names three things that did the work: His right hand, His arm, and the light of His face. The first two speak of strength. The third speaks of favour: a face turned toward them.
His right hand, His arm, the light of His countenance, had shown His acceptance of them. All this stayed with them as wisdom for the present. Man's nothingness was just as certain; God's sufficiency was just as perfect.
The final clause of the verse gives the reason for all of it — He delighted in them. That pleasure and that shining face belong together.
God raises His countenance upon those in whom He takes pleasure. This was David's prayer in Psalm 4: "Lift up the light of your face upon us, O LORD!" (Ps. 4:6).
Israel was never built to be a strong military power. That was not an oversight. God designed it that way, so that the nation would keep singing the right song.
Outward weakness was the character God designed for Israel's national life. The people were meant to know that they did not take the land by their own sword. Their own arm never saved them. It was God's right hand and His arm, and the light of His face, because He had favour toward them. And this song should always have been heard among them: "You are my King, O God; ordain salvation for Jacob!... For not in my bow do I trust, nor can my sword save me. But you have saved us from our foes and have put to shame those who hate us."
Verse 3 is not nostalgia. It is the first move in an argument. The arm that won Canaan was God's, never Israel's. So Israel's present weakness cannot rule out a fresh deliverance.
Psalm 44 is the voice of the remnant. They argue, from the faithfulness of faith, that it was the Lord and not their own arm which had delivered them, and that the same arm could deliver them in any circumstances. It is spoken at a time when they seem to be completely deserted.
- Not their sword. Israel fought for Canaan. The fighting is not what won it. God drove out the nations and planted His people there.
- His hand. The verse names three things: His right hand, His arm, and the light of His face. Together they showed that He accepted them.
- His delight. The reason is God's own favour, not Israel's merit. He lifts His face on those in whom He takes pleasure.
- Weak by design. God kept them weak on purpose. They were never to trust a bow, and never to forget who saved them.
- Therefore, again. The arm was always His, never theirs. So the same arm can deliver them now. That is the argument the rest of the psalm makes.
Thou thyself art my king, O God command deliverance for Jacob.
Psalm 44 opens with the memory of victories the people never earned. God's own hand drove out nations and planted Israel in the land. Verse 4 is the hinge. The singer stops telling what God did for the fathers and speaks to Him directly as King, asking for salvation now.
The first three verses look backwards. Verse 4 refuses to leave God in the past.
They know that the God who worked in ancient times is their God today. They can say, "You are MY King, O God"; and He is ever the same. So they should trust Him, just as He was trusted long ago.
To call God King is to accept that He governs directly. That same relationship reaches believers today, under a different title.
In this psalm the faithful one recognises that divine favour and power alone had given them their blessings. Those blessings, the signs of God's favour, were now taken from them. Here the faithful one acknowledges that God governs directly. "You are my King, O God," is the language of Israel, but it is always true. His authority now is no less absolute, yet it is far sweeter. He is our Lord by redemption. We do not deny the Lord who bought us.
The Hebrew behind "You are" is itself close to a name of God.
There is another word which can serve as a descriptive term, yet can hardly be kept out of the names of God. Hu, Atta Hu, "you are the same," the unchangeable One (see Deuteronomy 32:39); "I am He, the same, and besides Me no god." It carries the sense of the unchanging One who simply is, and that is true of God alone.
The name "Jacob" points to weakness, not strength. Older translations quoted below read "command deliverances for Jacob" where the ESV has "ordain salvation for Jacob."
And so now they claim and proclaim this God as theirs. "You are He" — You are the same — "my King, O God: command deliverances for Jacob." Yes — Jacob is a worm of the dust. Only He who can command deliverances for him can deliver him. And then, leaning on that arm of strength, confidence breaks out at once. Counting on Him like this has no element of deception in it.
The prayer rests on the title, not on any confession of sin.
One striking feature of this psalm is the absence of any confession of national sin. The ground taken is one of pure faith, appealing to the name of Jehovah as Jacob's God. "You are my King" is the keynote of the song. When Jehovah's name as Jacob's King sounds in the believer's heart, that heart echoes back, "Command deliverances for Jacob." He must act as King. By the power of His might He will make good His covenanted words in righteousness.
The verses on either side rule out any second source of help.
Jehovah designed outward weakness into Israel's life as a nation. The people were to know that "not by their own sword did they win the land, nor did their own arm save them, but Your right hand and Your arm, and the light of Your face, because You delighted in them." And this song should always have sounded among them: "You are my King, O God; command deliverances for Jacob… For I will not trust in my bow, nor will my sword save me."
The cry of this psalm does not hang in the air. One writer reads the next psalm as its answer.
The theme of Psalm 45 is the King. He is not viewed as in Psalm 21, where He has experienced a great salvation. Here He comes out with His sword strapped on His thigh to set up His kingdom. This psalm is the divine answer to the cry of the distressed remnant in the previous one. They own Him as "King" (Psalm 44:4). They beg Him to arise and "command deliverances for Jacob," and to show favour as of old.
The psalm's lesson outlives its own moment.
This psalm unfolds deeply important principles, which apply to God's people in any day of ruin. First, in an evil day we should always judge God's power and goodness by the way He acted for His people at the beginning. And beware of judging God by the low state their own failure has brought them to.
- Same — "You are" carries the sense of the unchanging One. The God of the old victories has not moved on.
- King — the singer claims the title now, and in the singular: my King, my direct Governor. Believers today live under the same authority, in a Lord who bought them.
- Command — God does not negotiate deliverance; He orders it. Jacob, a worm of the dust, needs a King whose word settles the matter.
- Weakness — God designed Israel's weakness, so that no sword or bow could take credit for the land or the rescue.
- Answer — in Psalm 45 the King comes out to fight, answering the cry of Psalm 44. In a ruined day, judge God by His beginnings, not by our present state.
Through thee will we push down our adversaries; through thy name will we tread them under that rise up against us.
Psalm 44 looks back on victories God won for Israel long ago, and at verse 5 that memory becomes a claim about the future. Everything turns on who does the pushing: that small word "we" carries both the psalm's confidence and, later, its heartbreak.
The verse is not a lone boast. A people who have lost their land look back to the God who gave it to them, and draw a conclusion for their own day.
The enemy holds the land again, and God's people are shut out of it. So the believing remnant claim God as their King. They look to Him to rescue them from their enemies once more by His power. Their trust will not be in their bow or sword, but in the God who saved them from their enemies in times past. God will be their boast, and they will praise His Name for ever.
Their reasoning moves in steps, and the second step carries the weight.
Then, in the second place, they know that the God who acted like this in ancient times is their God today. They can say, "You are MY King, O God," and He is always the same. So they should trust Him, just as He was trusted long ago.
The second half of the verse rests everything on God's name. That name stands for who God is, and different psalms draw different things out of it.
The name of Jehovah signifies what He is in Himself, the revelation of His character, and also that of His relationship with His people. His name (or glory) and His people's blessing go together, but putting His glory as our first object is the only true way to secure our blessing… "glory and strength" are in that name (Ps. 29:1); "mercy and truth" (Ps. 115:1); "goodness" (Ps. 25:7); "loving-kindness" (Ps. 138:2); "righteousness" (Ps. 143:1); when faith counts on the revealed name there is "trust" (Ps. 9:10); we get "victory" through that name (Ps. 44:5).
The psalm sets bow and sword aside. One writer shows what is left standing when they go.
They admit that they are helpless. They complain that the enemy's oppression is unjust. But they keep God in faithful remembrance as a Saviour. He would deliver them when He pleased, as He had always done (verse 3). Sword and bow count for nothing. They will push down the enemy when Jehovah Himself rises and hurries to their help.
Is that confidence realistic? One commentator says the sums add up.
And then, leaning on that arm of strength, confidence bursts out at once: "Through you we push down our foes; through your name we tread down those who rise up against us." This is where that past history is applied. A reckoning like this has nothing false in it.
Commentators differ. Another writer reads the same words as an explanation of defeat.
When we suffer defeats in the battle against the spiritual forces of evil, verse 5 of our Psalm goes a long way to explain them… The idea there is that we win a victory by using the power of God. That is not God's idea for them, and we think we may say it is never His idea for any. His power is not placed at our disposal for us to use as best we may. Instead, we are to be at His disposal, for Him to use us… He has the primary place, and the plan of campaign must be His. Our places are very, very secondary — just instruments that He is pleased to use.
That correction is not despair; it is the door to real deliverance.
When we realize this, we stop relying on ourselves, our plans and our efforts, and we cast ourselves completely on God… As long as our attitude is, "How shall I deliver myself?" difficulties and defeat follow us everywhere. When at last our cry becomes, "Who shall deliver me?" then we discover the delivering power of Jesus Christ our Lord.
- Heard — the verse grows out of verses 1–3. God's past acts are the evidence faith reasons from, because the God who acted then is the same God now.
- Claimed — "Your name" means what God is in Himself and toward His people. This psalm draws victory out of that name, as other psalms draw trust, mercy and righteousness out of it.
- Disarmed — bow and sword count for nothing. The people admit they are helpless and wait for God Himself to rise and help them.
- Misplaced — commentators differ. One calls the reckoning sound. Another says defeat begins when we treat God's power as ours to use. God's power is not handed to us; we are handed to Him.
- Delivered — the question "How shall I deliver myself?" keeps you in defeat. The question "Who shall deliver me?" is where deliverance begins.
For I will not put confidence in my bow, neither shall my sword save me.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
For thou hast saved us from our adversaries, and hast put them to shame that hate us.
Psalm 44 begins with the memory of victories God won for Israel long ago. Verse 7 turns that memory into a confession: every rescue was His work, not theirs — yet later in the psalm the same people are defeated.
This line belongs to the psalm's confident opening. One writer sets out where that confidence rested.
Psalm 44 gives a full and vivid picture of the state of the nation, as it stands in the conscience of the remnant. Faith rested on the memorial of all the old mighty deliverances God had worked, and how He had put them in possession of the land by His power, not theirs (vv. 1-8). Verses 9-16 describe their present state: cast off and scattered.
The verse says "saved us." One writer notes who is speaking, and when.
In Psalm 44 we hear the voice of godly Jews, who will be a true remnant of Israel in the coming day of trouble. All through the psalm it is "we" and "us," with the exception of verse 6. This stands out, because nearly every psalm before it speaks in the singular; the plural is rare.
Verse 6 rules out bow and sword; verse 7 names who actually saved them. Both come from people who have lost their land.
The enemy is again in possession of the land, and God's people are cast out. So the believing remnant claim God as their King, and look to Him to deliver them once again by His power. Their trust will not be in their bow or sword, but in the God who in times past had saved them from their enemies. In God will be their boast, and they will praise His Name for ever.
Israel's lack of military strength was no accident. God designed it, so the people could never claim a rescue as their own.
Outward weakness was the characteristic Jehovah designed for Israel's national life. He meant the people to know that "they did not win the land by their own sword, nor did their own arm ever save them; but Your right hand and Your arm, and the light of Your face, because You favoured them." And the song should always have been heard among them: "You are my King, O God; command deliverances for Jacob… But You have saved us from our foes and have put to shame those who hate us."
The second half of the verse turns to those who hate God's people. Their hatred ends in shame, and one writer says the same holds for us.
Israel will not trust in his own weapons, for they would prove useless in the end (v. 6). By depending only on the living God they have been saved from their enemies (v. 7). Those enemies are fully put to shame with all their opposition and hatred. It will always be so when we depend simply on the God of Jacob, and we, as well as they, have reason to boast in God all day long, and praise His name for ever (v. 8).
Remembering rescue is not nostalgia here. It shapes the people who remember, and it ends in worship that never runs out.
The remembrance becomes fruitful in producing character. With the same self-distrust as their fathers, the children of those old conquerors declare their descent: "I will not trust in my bow, nor shall my sword save me." Deliverances all through their history proved God's sufficiency, and only His hand could have accomplished them. It is their one constant boast, and His name shall be their praise for ever. This is what He works for — that His people may know Him, to their unending joy.
In verse 5 the same people expect to push down their enemies through God. One writer finds a mistake in the way they put it.
The idea is that we achieve victory by using the power of God. That is not God's thought for them, and we think we may say it is never His thought for anyone. His power is not placed at our disposal for us to use as best we can. Rather, we are to be at His disposal, for Him to use us. If God placed His power at our disposal, it would leave us in the primary place, with the responsibility of planning the campaign. No — He has the primary place, and the plan of campaign must be His.
- Not their arm. God's right hand won the land, not Israel's sword; verse 7 says the same of every rescue since.
- Weakness designed. God kept Israel weak on purpose, so bow and sword could never take the credit.
- Enemies shamed. Depending on God does more than rescue His people; it leaves the hatred against them in shame.
- Character formed. Remembering who saved them keeps the people distrusting themselves and boasting in God alone.
- Boast forever. It all ends in worship: God saves, His people praise Him and come to know Him — which is what He was working for all along.
In God will we boast all the day, and we will praise thy name for ever. Selah.
Psalm 44:8 is the high point of a song that is about to collapse. It closes the opening section, where a people recall victories they never won by their own strength. One line later the song turns bitter: they are cast off and scattered.
The boast of verse 8 rests on history the singers never saw. They had it from their fathers.
The godly remnant are cast out of the land and under the oppression of their enemies. Still they cling in simple faith to what they have heard from their fathers about God's mighty works for His people in the past. In those days God's people did not enter the land by their own power, nor did they drive out their enemies by it. God's right hand and God's arm brought them into blessing. He did this because He was favourable to His people and delighted in them.
Two verses earlier the singer refuses his own weapons. That refusal is what makes the boast of verse 8 possible. One writer traces the line from distrust of self to praise that never ends.
The remembrance produces character. In self-distrust like theirs, the children of those old conquerors declare their ancestry: "For not in my bow do I trust, nor can my sword save me." Deliverances all through their history confirm this, and only His hand could have achieved them. God's sufficiency is their only and constant boast, and His name will be their praise forever. This is what He works for: that His people may know Him, to their unending joy. That joy in Him is the spring of power in them, and it unites His creatures to Himself forever. The worship of eternity is the seal of its blessing and its perfection too. God is in His place, and the creature in his happy place with God.
Darby reads the psalm as the voice of a faithful group in Israel who no longer hold what their fathers received. Even the name they use for God marks where they stand.
Psalm 44 gives a full and vivid picture of the state of the nation, as it stands in the conscience of the remnant. They had heard with their ears. Faith rested on the memory of all the old mighty deliverances God worked. He had put them in possession of the land by His power, not theirs (v. 1-8). Verses 9-16 recount their present state. They are cast off and scattered... We still have God, not Jehovah, in this psalm; for they are outside.
Verse 8 is not the end of the song. What follows sounds like its opposite.
The second section of the psalm gives a vivid picture of their failure and disillusionment. Instead of victory, all is defeat. They are put to shame, plundered, scattered. They become a scorn, a mockery, a byword, a shaking of the head among the peoples. The move from verse 8 to verse 9 is very striking. From confident boasting in God and the praise of His name they fall, as with a crash, into dejection and shame.
This verse does not condemn boasting; it redirects it. The heart will boast in something, and the question is what.
Grace brought them all to glory in the Lord — to boast in Him! They had nothing in themselves to boast in. The heart needs something to boast in — or rather someone, a worthy object. So He is the One provided for this purpose. He who glories in men is not wise, and he who boasts in himself is a fool. There is so much of that kind of boasting that the very word boast sounds a little out of place at first. But it is the word the Spirit of Truth has used for our building up, and we do well to take hold of its force and health as it is used here — "Let the one who boasts, boast in the Lord."
The verse is not only about Israel. The same dependence gives the same reason to boast today.
Israel will not trust in his own weapons, for they would prove useless in the end (v. 6). By depending only on the living God they have been saved from their enemies (v. 7), who are fully put to shame with all their opposition and hatred. It will always be so when we depend simply on the God of Jacob. We, as well as they, have reason to boast in God all day long and praise His name forever (v. 8).
- Heard. The boast starts with what the fathers reported: God's right hand and arm won the land, not their own power.
- Emptied. Self-distrust comes first: no trust in the bow, no salvation by the sword. That emptiness leaves God as the only and constant boast.
- Boasted. The heart needs an object, and God is the One provided. Boasting in Him is not pride but the right use of the heart.
- Tested. From this confident boasting the psalm falls, as with a crash, into defeat and shame at verse 9. The boast comes from people already cast off and scattered.
- Forever. The praise of His name outlasts the crisis. The worship of eternity seals the blessing: God in His place, and the creature happy with Him.
But thou hast cast off, and put us to confusion, and dost not go forth with our armies;
Psalm 44 opens with a nation remembering God's victories and boasting in His name. Verse 9 is the hinge: the God who once won them the land now stays back while their armies march out and lose.
One writer traces how the singers fall from confidence to collapse in the space of a single line.
The second section of the psalm paints their failure and disillusionment in vivid detail. Instead of victory, all is defeat. They are shamed, plundered, scattered... The move from verse 8 to verse 9 is striking. From confident boasting in God and the praise of His Name they fall as with a crash into dejection and shame.
Commentators read the psalm as the cry of a faithful few within Israel. They speak from outside the land. One writer notes that even the name used for God here marks that distance — God, not the covenant name Jehovah.
Psalm 44 gives a full and vivid picture of the nation's state, as it stands in the conscience of the faithful remnant. Their faith rested on the memory of the great deliverances God worked long ago, and on how His power, not theirs, put them in possession of the land (v. 1-8). Verses 9-16 tell their present state. God has cast them off and scattered them... We still have God, not Jehovah, in this psalm, because they are outside.
One clear reason God stays back is sin that has never been dealt with. A commentator finds that reason in an old defeat, when Israel carried the ark — the sacred chest that stood for God's presence — into battle against the Philistines.
We see the ark misused when, in the days of the judges, the people bring it out to meet the Philistines (1 Sam. 4:3). Israel was in a terrible condition, and the state of the priests was dreadful. People despised the holy things of God, and open sin was flaunted before God and man. Will a holy God link His name with that? Impossible... Need we wonder that when sin is not judged, "You have not gone out with our armies"?
Commentators differ on whether the people in this psalm are at fault. One writer takes up the question by looking at how God disciplines His own.
We learn this lesson from it: in the Lord's discipline we cannot work out the cause of the chastening from the nature of the chastening... But the same trouble may fall on a saint who can still say with the apostle, "I know nothing against myself." No doubt there is a reason for the suffering... This is instructive. The Lord may have our general state before Him, and that state may need correcting by chastisement. Yet there may be perfect integrity of heart, and the path a person is on when the suffering comes may be the right one.
The boast in verse 5 helps explain the defeat that follows. The singers assumed God's power was theirs to use.
The idea is that we win a victory by using God's power. That is not God's idea for them, and we believe it is never His idea for anyone. He does not put His power at our disposal, for us to use as best we can. We are to be at His disposal, for Him to use us. If God put His power at our disposal, He would leave us in first place, holding the responsibility for planning the campaign. No, He has the first place, and the plan of campaign must be His. Our places are very, very secondary — just instruments that He is pleased to use.
One writer describes what faith does when God leaves His people to defeat.
God can, as far as His government goes, leave us to defeat and scattering for a time. In such conflicts this is the deepest kind of chastening... But when it is cast down like this, faith does not lose its courage, even while it staggers with shock. It looks to God. It judges the evil if evil is there. It still looks to God, owning that there must be some evil even if it cannot find it. But God has spoken in His holiness. His nature never changes and allows no evil, and that makes it certain He will keep His word for them.
- Crash — The psalm falls from boasting in God's name straight into shame, and verse 9 is the exact point of the drop.
- Cause — Sometimes the reason is plain. Where sin goes unjudged, a holy God will not attach His name to the effort, however sacred the objects carried into battle.
- Caution — The nature of the chastening never tells you its cause. A believer may suffer this and still say, "I know nothing against myself."
- Correction — The deeper flaw is assuming God's power is ours to use. He is not at our disposal; we are at His, and the plan of campaign is His alone.
- Courage — Cast down, faith still looks to God. It judges evil if it finds any, and owns there must be some if it finds none, because God's unchanging nature guarantees His word.
Thou hast made us to turn back from the adversary, and they that hate us spoil for themselves;
Verse 10 sits at the low point of the psalm: the speakers have just boasted in God, yet now they trace their retreat and their stolen goods back to God's own hand. They ask why a people who kept faith should find God fighting against them.
This verse belongs to the second section, where the confidence of the opening collapses.
The second section of the psalm paints their failure and disappointment in vivid detail. Instead of victory all is defeat. They are shamed, plundered, scattered. Among the peoples they become an object of scorn and ridicule, a byword, a shaking of the head. The change from verse 8 to verse 9 is striking. From confident boasting in God and the praise of His Name they fall, as with a crash, into gloom and shame.
The verse stacks one loss on another. First the army runs; then the very people who hate them carry off their goods.
In total contrast to the verses before, this section turns back, as the earlier psalms do, to the painful circumstances that test the faith of the godly. Israel, despite God's previous kindness to her, has left the path of simple faith. The godly must feel the results of that, because they love their own nation. They feel God has cast them off and put them to shame. He does not support their armies, but leaves them to flee from the enemy (v. 9). Then, on top of that humiliation, the enemy has taken spoil from them (v. 10).
Commentators differ on the cause. One traces the defeat to a nation that left the path of simple faith, while the godly suffer alongside. Another points to the remnant — the faithful few left in Israel — who kept their integrity, and to the name for God used here, which marks how far outside they stand.
Psalm 44 gives a full and vivid picture of the state of the nation, as the conscience of the remnant sees it… Verses 9-16 tell their present state. They are cast off and scattered. The enemy and the avenger are among them; they are scattered among the nations, sold by God for nothing… Yet they have in no way turned aside from their integrity. On the contrary, they are killed all day long for His sake, and counted as sheep for the slaughter… We still have God, not Jehovah, in this psalm; for they are outside.
Paul later quotes this psalm, and that turns the losses into comfort. Scripture records these sufferings in advance, so those who go through them know God has not rejected them.
Paul quotes it as evidence of what belongs to the remnant (v. 22 with Rom. 8:36). The Holy Spirit recognizes it as the portion of the accepted remnant, the voice of the Spirit in their mouth. So it was evidence of anything but their rejection. In this way the record of evil becomes the evidence of acceptance. It steadies the faith of those on whom the evil falls, when it comes… The written sufferings prove that God accepts those on whom they fall, at the very moment their faith might be shaken. So even here they can say, "we are more than conquerors."
Verse 5 shows where the confidence went wrong. The plan was theirs; God was to supply the power.
What they say is, "Through You WE push down our foes; through Your name WE tread down those who rise up against us." The idea is that we win a victory by using the power of God. God does not put His power at our disposal, for us to use as best we can. Instead, we are to be at His disposal, for Him to use us. If God put His power at our disposal, it would leave us in first place, responsible for planning the campaign. No, He has the first place, and the plan of campaign must be His. Our place is very, very secondary — just instruments that He is pleased to use.
Faith looks back at past works of God, then lays the present defeat before Him. God answers such prayers, but His answer includes showing the people their own sin.
In view of these past works, faith pleads the present dreadful condition: "But You have rejected us and disgraced us and have not gone out with our armies. You have made us turn back from the foe, and those who hate us have gotten spoil." Our God will never refuse to answer such appeals, though He must work most deeply in the hearts of the people, to bring them to a true sense of their own sin.
- Crash. Verse 8 boasts in God; verse 10 has them running and stripped. Praise falls into shame in two lines.
- Cause. Defeat is not random. One reading traces it to a nation that left the path of simple faith, so even the godly feel the loss.
- Hand. The prayer says You have made us turn back. Enemies carry off the spoil, but the speakers name God as the One who stopped going out with their armies.
- Flaw. The earlier confidence put God's power at their disposal. His way is the reverse: He plans, and we are the instruments He uses.
- Comfort. Paul quotes this psalm as the portion of the accepted. The recorded suffering proves acceptance, not rejection — and the plea it teaches is one God never refuses.
Thou hast given us over like sheep [appointed] for meat, and hast scattered us among the nations;
Psalm 44 is the voice of a defeated people. This verse is the low point of their account. They are scattered, and handed over like animals bound for the butcher. What makes the line so hard is not the enemy's cruelty but the pronoun — they say God did it.
The picture is not of an animal that wandered off. It is one handed over to someone else's table. One writer draws out both halves of the verse — what sheep are, and where the flock ended up:
They were like sheep, dependent and helpless, given up as food for the enemy (v. 11), and scattered among the nations. This came true in the plainest way, for Israel has now been a people scattered in every direction for centuries.
They do not blame politics, armies, or bad luck. The psalm names God Himself as the one acting:
They are cast off, defeated, robbed by their enemies, and scattered among the nations. But more than that: it is God Himself who has cast them off, turned their backs before their enemies, and scattered them — the same God who once acted for them. They admit that God's governing hand is upon them.
Verse 11 is not an isolated complaint. It sits in a list that grows darker line by line. One writer traces the order of the losses, and notes that God gains nothing from them either:
First, their armies still march out, but God is no longer with them as He once was. Defeat and plunder must follow. Then they become nothing but sheep for the slaughter, scattered among the nations that beat them. God gains no glory either by giving up His people: those who should have been for His honor have become a reproach.
The fall from the psalm's opening confidence is sudden:
The transition from verse 8 to verse 9 is very striking. From confident boasting in God and the praise of His Name they fall as with a crash into dejection and shame.
Commentators read the psalm as the words of a faithful group within Israel. One summary sets verse 11 inside the shape of the whole psalm, and links it to a line Paul later quotes:
Verses 9-16 tell their present state. They are cast off and scattered. The enemy and the avenger is among them, and they are scattered among the nations, sold by God for no price. Yet they have in no way turned away from their integrity. On the contrary, it is for His sake they are killed all day long, and counted as sheep for the slaughter. (Note: the moment Messiah was rejected, this began in principle: compare Rom. 8:36.)
The obvious reading of a slaughtered, scattered flock is that God has finished with them. The same writer argues the opposite. His ground is that Scripture recorded these sufferings ahead of time:
Paul quotes it as evidence of what belongs to the remnant (v. 22 with Rom. 8:36). The Holy Spirit owns it as the portion of the accepted remnant — the voice of the Spirit in their mouth. So it was evidence of anything but their rejection. In this way the testimony of evil becomes the evidence of acceptance. It steadies the faith of those on whom the evil falls when it comes... The sufferings written down beforehand are the evidence that God accepts those on whom they fall, at the moment their faith might be shaken.
Being counted as a sheep for slaughter is not only loss. Their loyalty holds even when they cannot see what God is doing:
They may be broken and overthrown, as Job once was, yet God sustains their faith and it holds fast... They may not have grasped what God's plan is, yet they are wholly devoted to Him: killed all day long like sheep. And in being counted as sheep for the slaughter, they come to look like their Lord.
The psalm is not only history. It sets a pattern for any time when God's people are broken:
In a day of failure, God's people should bow under the correcting hand of the Lord. They should look beyond every lesser cause and recognize that God Himself has allowed them to become a reproach and a byword.
- Sheep — helpless and dependent, given up as food for the enemy and scattered among the nations. This flock was handed over; it did not stray.
- Hand — the psalm names God Himself as the one who scattered them. Faith looks past every lesser cause to that governing hand.
- Gloom — the losses come in order: God no longer going out with them, then defeat and plunder, then slaughter and scattering, then reproach. Yet God will be honored in the end, not shortchanged.
- Likeness — the same title that marks them for slaughter makes them look like their Lord.
- Acceptance — Paul quotes this suffering as the portion of the accepted remnant. So the evidence of evil becomes evidence of belonging, not of rejection.
Thou hast sold thy people for nought, and hast not increased [thy wealth] by their price;
Psalm 44 turns a corner at verse 9: a people who once boasted in God now describe defeat, plunder and exile. They trace it all to God Himself, and verse 12 puts it in market terms — He sold them off and got nothing for them.
This is not one man's private grief. Commentators read it as the voice of the remnant, the faithful few left in Israel, looking at the wreck of the nation.
Psalm 44 gives a full and vivid picture of the state of the nation, as it is in the conscience of the remnant. Faith rested on the memory of all the old mighty deliverances God worked. He had put them in possession of the land by His power, not theirs (v. 1-8). Verses 9-16 recount their present state. They are cast off and scattered. The enemy and avenger is among them. They are scattered among the nations, sold by God for no price. Yet they have in no way turned aside from their integrity. On the contrary, it is for His sake they are killed all day long, and counted as sheep for the slaughter.
The complaint never blames chance or the enemy's strength. It names God as the one who handed them over.
They are cast off, defeated, plundered by their enemies, and scattered among the nations. And it is God Himself who has done it — the same God who once worked on their behalf has cast them off, turned their backs before their enemies, and scattered them. They acknowledge that God's hand in government is upon them. He has sold His people into captivity, and made them "a reproach," "a scorn," "a derision" and a "byword."
The second line of the verse says God set no high price on them and made no gain by the sale. The loss was not only theirs.
Then they become mere sheep for the slaughter, scattered among the victorious nations. God too gains no glory by giving up His people. Those who should have been for His honour have become a reproach — far and wide, an evil proverb and a shaking of the head.
The worthless price was not just a figure of speech. History records what the market paid for God's people after Jerusalem fell.
After the destruction of Jerusalem in the year 70, the very thing happened that the prophet spoke of. Nearly a million and a half people died in Jerusalem and the land in that terrible war. Over 100,000 were taken prisoner. Jews were sold for as small a price as a measure of barley, and thousands were disposed of in this way. And what else could we add from the history of centuries? God's heritage suffered cruel and terrible persecutions — thousands upon thousands massacred, tortured, outraged and sold as slaves.
The people felt God was selling them and getting nothing back. What they could not see was where the story ends.
They were like sheep, dependent and helpless, given up as food for the enemy, and scattered among the nations. That is literally true, for Israel has now been a scattered people for centuries. They felt God was selling them, but receiving no payment for them. They little understood that God would gain great honour and glory through the dreadful experiences Israel endures. Their restoration at the end will mean that God has profited enormously.
The sale brought in nothing, and the buy-back will cost them nothing either. One thing comes first: a broken spirit in place of national pride.
When God sets His hand to this great work, He will bring about a change of heart in His chosen ones. They will recognise their Kinsman-Redeemer. He will claim them as His own again when national pride gives way to a broken spirit and humble repentance. They will repent of their own sinfulness and of the blindness of their fathers. Though they sold themselves for nothing, He will redeem them without money. He will give them the land that is Immanuel's, according to His own decree.
- Seller. They do not blame the nations or the enemy. They name God Himself as the seller.
- Price. The word "nothing" was not just a figure of speech. Jews were sold for as little as a measure of barley.
- Reproach. The loss was God's too. People meant to carry His honour became a byword instead, and the sale added nothing to His glory.
- Return. They felt pure loss. Commentators read an unfinished story: Israel's restoration will show God's profit.
- Redemption. Sold for nothing, they will be redeemed without money. First their national pride gives way to a broken spirit.
Thou makest us a reproach to our neighbours, a mockery and a derision for them that are round about us;
Psalm 44 is the prayer of a people who once knew God's victories and now know only defeat. They are scattered among the nations, and their neighbours laugh at them. The psalm does not blame the mockery on enemies alone. It traces the mockery back to God's own hand.
The verse does not say the neighbours seized their chance; it says God made His people a taunt. One writer traces every part of the disaster back to Him:
They tell God the present condition of God's professing people, and God's ways with them. Those ways are the complete opposite of His former ways. They are cast off, defeated, robbed by their enemies, and scattered among the nations. But more than that, it is God Himself who has cast them off. He once worked on their behalf. He has turned their backs before their enemies, and He has scattered them. They own that God's hand in government is upon them. God has sold His people into captivity, and made them "a reproach," "a scorn," "a derision" and a "byword." So the godly soul is always face to face with the confusion and shame of God's people. The voice of those who reproach and blaspheme is always raised against them.
Just before this, the psalm was confident praise in God's name. The change is abrupt:
The second section of the psalm describes their failure and disillusionment very vividly. Instead of victory all is defeat. They are put to shame, spoiled, scattered. They become a scorn, a derision, a by-word, a shaking of the head among the people. The move from verse 8 to verse 9 is very striking. From confident boasting in God and the praise of His Name they fall as with a crash into dejection and shame.
The scorn is close at hand. It comes from neighbours, from those standing round about. One commentator sees the same thing today:
Meanwhile, Israel feels the reproach of neighbours. It does not come only from distant enemies. Those around them scorn and deride them. The nations made her a byword, shaking their heads in derision. Today this is clearly true, for there are many who even dare to claim that Israel is the cause of all the trouble and terror the world is suffering. Of course this is stupid ignorance, but Satan inspires it in his hate toward God.
Israel had known defeat and shame before. That earlier case was different. One writer compares this psalm with the day Joshua lay on his face before the ark after Israel lost a battle:
These words might have suited Joshua's lips when he lay on the ground till the evening before the ark, with his clothes torn and dust on his head. But notice the difference. Israel had sinned then, and so prayer was useless; what was needed was self-judgment... But in Psalm 44 there is nothing of that sort; on the contrary, they can, by the Spirit, plead before God their conscious rightness... This Joshua and the elders could not have said. Here Israel can; yet the chastisement is much the same.
The same disgrace looks different from inside. From outside it is a nation under discipline. To hearts still loyal to God it is something else:
The reproach they bear is tied to national sin, and it is the result of God's chastening. Yet it is the reproach of Christ to those whose hearts are loyal to the Hope of Israel. By faith they can call out of the low place of affliction on the name of Jehovah as the redeemer of His own. So this Psalm gives rich material for fruitful meditation to the Christian who enters at all in spirit into the present state of the Church, broken and dishonoured.
The scorn is not the end of the story. Faith still calls out in the middle of it:
In Psalm 44 the faith of the remnant rests on the memorial of God's past deliverance of His people... Their present condition was the complete opposite: "But you have rejected us and disgraced us and have not gone out with our armies." Still, faith cries out in the middle of all the exercises of soul this caused: "Rise up; come to our help! Redeem us for the sake of your steadfast love!" (v. 26.) Psalm 45 gives the answer to this cry in the introduction of Messiah, who brings deliverance from enemies, and whose kingdom is for ever and ever.
- Whose hand — The psalm traces the taunting to God's own governing hand, not just to the enemies' success.
- Whose mouths — The scorn comes from neighbours close by. It makes Israel a byword among the nations.
- Whose conscience — Unlike Joshua's day, there is no hidden sin to put away. The sufferers plead their integrity, and still the chastening goes on.
- Whose reproach — To hearts loyal to God, this shame is the reproach of Christ. It speaks to any who feel the broken state of God's people.
- Whose answer — The next psalm answers the cry "Redeem us for the sake of your steadfast love" with Messiah Himself, whose kingdom has no end.
Thou makest us a byword among the nations, a shaking of the head among the peoples.
Psalm 44 opens with the memory of God's great victories for Israel, then drops into the present: defeat, plunder, and scattering. Verse 14 shows where that fall lands — the nation's name has become a taunt in other people's mouths.
The psalm says "we", not "I". Commentators hear in it the cry of a faithful group within Israel.
In Psalm 44 we hear the voice of godly Jews, who will be a true remnant of Israel in the coming day of trouble. Right through the Psalm it is "we" and "us" with the exception of verse 6. This stands out, because almost all the psalms before it speak as "I". "We" appears only rarely.
The psalm's shape carries that voice from memory to appeal, with the scattering at its centre.
Psalm 44 gives a full and vivid picture of the state of the nation, as in the conscience of the remnant. They had heard with their ears. Faith rested in the memorial of all the old mighty deliverances wrought by God, and how He had put them in possession of the land by His power, not theirs (v. 1-8). In verses 9-16 their present state is recounted. They are cast off and scattered.
Verse 8 ends in praise. Verse 9 begins the collapse.
Instead of victory all is defeat. They are put to shame, plundered, scattered. They become a scorn, a derision, a byword, a shaking of the head among the people. The transition from verse 8 to verse 9 is very striking. From confident boasting in God and the praise of His Name they fall as with a crash into dejection and shame.
The psalm does not blame the nations for the mockery. It traces the whole thing back to God.
They are not only cast off, defeated, plundered by their enemies, and scattered among the nations. It is God Himself who has done it — the same God who once acted for them. He has cast them off, turned their backs before their enemies, and scattered them. They admit that God's governing hand is on them. He has sold His people into captivity, and made them "a reproach," "a scorn," "a derision" and a "byword."
The sting in the verse is not only what Israel suffers but what God appears to gain — nothing. A people meant to display His honour now display His defeat.
The account grows darker as it goes on. First, their armies still march out, but God is no longer with them as He once was. Defeat and plunder must follow. Then they become mere sheep for the slaughter, scattered among the nations that beat them. God Himself gains no glory by giving up His people. Those who should have been for His honor have become a reproach — worse, far and wide, an evil proverb and a shaking of the head.
But that loss is not the end of the story.
They little understood that God was going to be highly honored and glorified through the dreadful experiences Israel goes through. Their restoration in the end will mean that God has gained a great deal.
The word "byword" was not new. Moses had used it over the nation centuries earlier.
More than 3000 years ago Moses warned them that if they rebelled against God's will they would "become a horror, a proverb, and a byword among all the peoples where the LORD will lead you away" (Deut. 28). The closing words of his warning describe their long suffering so exactly, and are so moving, that you can hardly read them without tears.
(Mawson quoted an older translation; the wording above follows the ESV.)
Commentators say this is still going on today.
Meanwhile, Israel feels the reproach of neighbors, not only by distant enemies, but being scorned and derided by those around them. The nations made her a byword, shaking their heads in derision. Today this is clearly true, for there are many who even dare to claim that Israel is the cause of all the trouble and terror the world is suffering.
There is a right way to carry that shame.
In a day of failure God's people should bow under the Lord's chastening hand. They should look beyond every other cause and recognize that God Himself has allowed them to become a reproach and a byword (vv. 9-18).
Those who stay loyal give that shame another name.
The reproach they carry is tied to the nation's sin, and it comes from God's discipline. Yet to those whose hearts stay loyal to the Hope of Israel, it is the reproach of Christ. Out of that low place of suffering, faith lets them call on the name of Jehovah as the redeemer of His own.
- Reproach named. Byword, laughingstock, scorn, derision — this is what the nations make of a people God once honoured.
- Reproach sent. The psalm looks past the mocking nations to God's own governing hand: He cast off, He scattered, He made them a byword.
- Reproach foretold. Moses warned that rebellion would make them a proverb among all the peoples. The psalm shows it happening.
- Reproach shared. God gains no glory while the people who should have honoured Him become a reproach.
- Reproach reversed. Their restoration will show God greatly honoured. Until then the loyal bow under His hand and call the shame the reproach of Christ.
All the day my confusion is before me, and the shame of my face hath covered me,
This verse sits in the middle of a song about national defeat. People who once boasted in God now describe scattering and mockery, and ask why God let it happen.
The psalm opens with confidence and then drops without warning.
The second section of the psalm describes their failure and disappointment very vividly. Instead of victory all is defeat. They are shamed, plundered, scattered. The change from verse 8 to verse 9 is striking. From confident boasting in God and praise of His Name they fall, as with a crash, into dejection and shame.
What makes the shame constant is that the sufferer traces it back to God's own hand, not to bad luck or a stronger army. (Older translations read "my confusion is before me," so the writers speak of "confusion of face.")
They are cast off, defeated, robbed by their enemies, and scattered among the nations. But it is God Himself who has cast them off, turned their backs before their enemies, and scattered them — the same God who once acted for them. They admit that God's governing hand is on them. God has sold His people into captivity and made them "a reproach," "a scorn," "a derision" and a "byword." So the godly soul stands face to face, day after day, with the confusion and shame of God's people. Those who reproach and blaspheme never stop speaking against them.
There is a further sting. God Himself gains nothing from it either.
God gains no glory by giving up His people. Those who should have been for His honour have become a reproach — more than that, far and wide they have become an evil proverb and a shaking of the head.
The shame is not self-generated. Someone is talking, and the talking does the covering.
The endless dishonour and confusion troubles the soul to its depths (v. 15), and he says, "shame has covered my face." It comes from the reproach and insults of the enemy (v. 16), who is also called an "avenger." A man like this has no real reason for hostility, yet he likes to think he is right to avenge what he imagines to be wrong.
Faced with that voice, the sufferers have no reply. Yet the silence is not surrender.
Those are the circumstances. Now they speak of their inward state. All of it has tried them, and they feel it sharply. Shame covers them, and confusion covers their faces. They can answer nothing in front of those who reproach and blaspheme, in front of enemies and vengeful men. Yet despite everything, they hold fast to God, and neither their heart nor their steps have turned aside from Him... Had they forgotten Him, they ask, could they hide it from Him? They appeal to the One whose knowledge is perfect.
Commentators identify the singers as a faithful few within Israel, speaking about the state of the whole nation.
Psalm 44 gives a full and vivid picture of the state of the nation, as the faithful remnant feel it in their conscience... Verses 9-16 tell their present state. They are cast off and scattered. The enemy and avenger is among them... Yet they have not turned aside from their integrity in any way. On the contrary, it is for His sake that they are killed all day long, and counted as sheep for the slaughter. (Note: the moment Messiah was rejected, this began in principle: compare Romans 8:36.)
The psalm ends in a cry, and the next psalm takes it up.
In Psalm 44 the faith of the remnant rests on the memory of how God delivered His people in the past... Still, through all the soul-searching this brings, faith cries out, "Rise up; come to our help! Redeem us for the sake of your steadfast love!" (v. 26). Psalm 45 answers that cry by bringing in Messiah, who delivers them from their enemies, and whose kingdom lasts for ever and ever.
Believers today may have to make the same confession when their own failure has dishonoured the Lord.
There is no place for us, my friends, but Bochim. We have all failed badly — we must all be "weepers" before the Lord. "TO US belongs shame and confusion of face." If we had been faithful — if we had walked with the Lord like a weaned child with its mother — none of this sorrow would have come on us, and we would have brought none of this dishonour on the Lord.
- Cast off. They trace the shame to God's own hand — the hand that once gave victory has now handed His people over.
- Covered. What covers the face is not private guilt alone. It is the voice of an enemy who reproaches and blasphemes, and who thinks himself an avenger.
- Speechless. Before that voice they can answer nothing; their only appeal is to the One who knows perfectly whether they have forgotten Him.
- Clinging. They have nothing to say to men, yet they hold fast to God — heart and steps have not turned aside.
- Answered. The next psalm answers the cry that ends this one: Messiah comes in, and shame gives way to a kingdom that lasts for ever.
Because of the voice of him that reproacheth and blasphemeth; by reason of the enemy and the avenger.
The shame of the previous verse has a cause: a voice keeps taunting, and an enemy keeps watching. Two questions follow — who is this taunter and avenger, and why does God leave His own people exposed to him?
One writer, reading the older wording "him that reproaches and blasphemes", ties both descriptions in this verse to figures in the book of Revelation:
Verse 16 mentions an individual: "him that reproaches and blasphemes." The same verse speaks of "the enemy and avenger." Both these expressions may refer to the coming of the "beast." The first one clearly does so, in the light of Revelation 13:6-7. The second expression also occurs in Psalm 8:2. It may refer instead to the false prophet, the second beast of Revelation 13, who exercises the power of the first beast and avenges among the Jews all resistance to his authority. However that may be, we have here an unmistakable reference to the great antichristian powers of the last days.
The word "avenger" describes a persecutor who believes he is putting a wrong right:
The continual dishonour and confusion causes the deepest distress of soul (v. 15). He says, "the shame of my face has covered me." This comes from the reproach and reviling of the enemy (v. 16), who is also called an "avenger." One of this kind has no real reason for hostility, but he likes to think he is right in avenging what he imagines to be wrong.
Part of what makes the taunt unbearable is that the sufferers cannot answer it. Yet their silence is not surrender:
These are the circumstances. Now they speak of their inward state, worked on by all this. They feel it keenly, covered with shame and confusion of face, able to answer nothing in the presence of those who reproach and blaspheme, of enemies and vengeful men. Yet despite it all, they cling to God, neither their heart nor their steps turned aside from Him.
The psalm does not blame the enemy alone. Verses 9 to 16 trace the whole humiliation back past the persecutor to God Himself:
They lay before God the present condition of God's professing people, and God's ways with them. These ways are completely unlike His former ways. They are cast off, defeated, plundered by their enemies, and scattered among the nations. But it is God Himself who has cast them off, turned their backs before their enemies, and scattered them — the same God who once worked on their behalf. They acknowledge that God's hand in government is upon them: God has sold His people into captivity, and made them "a reproach," "a scorn," "a derision" and a "byword." So the godly soul lives face to face with the confusion and shame of God's people. The voice of those who reproach and blaspheme is always raised against them.
The same pressure falls on Christians, and one writer follows this psalm into the New Testament:
But the same principle is good for the Church now. From this point of view it is beautiful to see that Psalm 44 appears in Romans 8. Being given like sheep for the slaughter for Christ's sake is one of the things that cannot separate us from the love of Christ. The heart might fail under prolonged pressure. "No," says the Spirit, "the love of Christ is unchanged. This chastisement is of the Father, that we may be partakers of His holiness."
Christ says almost the same words in Psalm 69. Commentators separate that suffering from His suffering for sin:
The sufferings in this Psalm are not those connected with His soul being made an offering for sin. His atoning sufferings were from God, as we see in Psalm 22. Here He endures the sufferings for God. Verse 7 states it plainly: "For Your sake I have borne reproach." All through, this is the dominant note.
- Reproach named. The taunting, blaspheming voice and the watching "enemy and avenger" point to the antichristian powers of the last days — the first of them the beast of Revelation 13.
- Reproach twisted. The persecutor calls himself an avenger; he has no real cause for hostility, but likes to think he is righting a wrong.
- Reproach felt. The sufferers can answer nothing in front of those who insult them. Shame covers the face — yet neither their heart nor their steps turn aside from God.
- Reproach permitted. Faith looks past the taunter to God Himself. In His government He sold His people into captivity and made them a reproach and a byword.
- Reproach redeemed. Romans 8 takes up this psalm: being given like sheep for the slaughter cannot separate us from the love of Christ. And "for Your sake I have borne reproach" was first true of Christ, who bore that suffering for God.
All this is come upon us; yet have we not forgotten thee, neither have we dealt falsely against thy covenant
Psalm 44 is the voice of God's people at their lowest — scattered, mocked, and seemingly abandoned by the God who once fought for them. In verse 17 they search their own hearts for the cause of the disaster and find none.
Commentators set this verse beside another defeat in Israel's history. Joshua lay face down before the ark of the covenant after Israel lost a battle at the small town of Ai. There the cause was hidden sin in the camp. Here it is not.
Israel had sinned then, so prayer did no good. What was needed was self-judgment. They had to put away the actual sin that had defiled them... But in Psalm 44 there is nothing of that sort. On the contrary, by the Spirit they can plead before God that they know they are upright... Joshua and the elders could not have said this. Israel can say it here — yet the discipline is much the same.
This is not a boast. They know what the nation has become, so they have no reply for their mockers. Yet the lips that are silent before men can still speak to God.
Still, in the middle of all their confusion and shame, the godly can plead their integrity. They have not forgotten God. Faced with the insults and blasphemy of the enemy they can say nothing, because they know the nation has completely failed. But in the presence of God they can still plead that they have not forgotten Him, and have not turned aside from His covenant or His ways.
The verse names two loyalties: memory of God Himself, and honesty about His covenant. One writer shows which loyalty is tested when the covenant blessings stop coming.
They would rather suffer anything for owning the true God. Whatever they had to suffer, they would bear it for His own sake, out of their heart's attachment to Him, and for what He was when they got no blessing. The God who was in covenant with His people was the true God. So they would be tested, not only over the covenant blessings, but over their heart's attachment to what He was in His nature. And the same principle holds for us.
Ai and Psalm 44 look the same from the outside, yet the causes are opposite. So you cannot read the suffering backwards into a verdict on the sufferer.
We surely learn this lesson from it: in the Lord's discipline we cannot work out the cause of the chastening from the kind of chastening it is... The same trouble may fall on a believer, and yet he can say with the apostle, "I know nothing against myself."... This is instructive. It shows us that the Lord may have our general state before Him, needing correction by chastening, while the heart may still be perfectly upright. The path a person is walking when the suffering meets him may be the right one.
That innocence does not soften the blow — it sharpens it. And the trial still has something left to teach them.
They feel the pain of the trouble more sharply because they do not feel they deserve it... yet they found themselves badly broken and covered with the shadow of death (vv. 18-19)... But they must learn a deeper lesson.
A few verses later the psalm calls them sheep for the slaughter, killed all day long — words Paul takes up in Romans 8. That quotation changes what the suffering means for the remnant, the faithful few.
Paul quotes it as evidence of what belongs to the remnant (v. 22 with Romans 8:36). The Holy Spirit recognizes it as what belongs to the accepted remnant, the voice of the Spirit in their mouth. So it was evidence of anything but their rejection. In this way the witness of evil becomes the proof of acceptance, to steady the faith of those on whom the evil falls when it comes... The sufferings written down beforehand prove that those who go through them are accepted, at the very time their faith might be shaken. So "out of the eater comes forth sweetness": "we are more than conquerors."
- Not Ai. At Ai the defeat exposed hidden sin, and self-judgment was the cure. In Psalm 44 there is no such sin — yet the discipline looks much the same.
- Silent, then vocal. Before mocking enemies they can say nothing, because the nation has failed. Before God they can still plead that they have not forgotten Him.
- Attachment, not arrangement. Tested beyond the covenant blessings, they hold to what God is in Himself — even when no blessing came.
- No backwards reading. You cannot read the cause of the discipline from the kind of discipline it is. The path a person is walking when suffering meets him may be the right one.
- Evidence, not verdict. Paul's use of this psalm makes the suffering proof of acceptance, not rejection.
Our heart is not turned back, neither have our steps declined from thy path;
Psalm 44 is the voice of a people crushed in battle and scattered among the nations, with no sin they can name to explain it. At their lowest point they still claim a loyal heart and a straight path — so how can people suffer like this while knowing they have been faithful?
These sufferers do not make this claim to the enemy. They make it to God, and the two settings call for different answers.
In the middle of all their confusion and shame, the godly can plead their integrity. They have not forgotten God. In the presence of the reproaches and blasphemy of the enemy they can say nothing, for they are conscious of the complete failure of the nation. But in the presence of God they can still plead that they have not forgotten Him, nor turned aside from His covenant or His ways.
The verse names two things — the inward heart and the outward walk — and holds them together.
But the heart of the believing remnant was sound. "Our heart has not turned back, nor have our steps departed from your way" (verse 18). Faith in God always produces practical holiness. That faith marks the people whose cause the Spirit of Christ seems here to be pleading, with truthful intercession, before Him who tests hearts.
Knowing you have not wandered does not soften the blow. It sharpens it.
They feel the pain of the adversity more deeply because they do not feel they deserve it. In heart they had not turned back. In their steps they had not faltered from the path of truth. Yet they found themselves badly broken and covered with the shadow of death (vv. 18-19).
Israel was once defeated at Ai because sin was hidden in the camp, and Joshua lay on the ground before God until evening. One writer sets that defeat beside this psalm and finds the outward blow the same and the cause completely different.
These words might have suited Joshua's lips when he lay on the ground until evening before the ark, with his clothes torn and dust on his head. But notice the difference. Israel had sinned then, so prayer did no good; what was needed was self-judgment. But in Psalm 44 there is nothing of that sort. On the contrary, they can, by the Spirit, plead before God their conscious uprightness... This Joshua and the elders could not have said. Here Israel can — yet the chastisement is much the same.
That comparison leaves a warning for anyone reading their own trouble.
We surely learn this lesson from it: in the Lord's discipline we cannot work out the cause of the chastisement from the nature of the chastisement... The same thing may fall on a man, and yet the saint be able to say with the apostle, "I know nothing against myself"... The Lord may have our general state before Him, and that state may need correcting by chastisement. Meanwhile the heart may be perfectly upright, and the path one is walking in when the suffering comes may be the right one.
If blessing always followed faithfulness, no one could tell whether the heart loved God or loved the gift.
They preferred to suffer anything, whatever it might be, for owning the true God. They would do it for His own sake, out of the attachment of their heart to Him, for what He was when they got no blessing... God would test them, not only over the covenant blessings, but over their heart-attachment to what He is in His nature. And so it is in principle with us.
So what does a believer do when the trouble has no explanation?
The same principle is good for the church now. It is beautiful to see that Psalm 44 appears in Romans 8. That passage lists being given up like sheep for the slaughter for Christ's sake among the things that cannot separate us from the love of Christ. The heart might fail under long pressure. "No," says the Spirit, "the love of Christ is unchanged"... If there is no conscious guilt, the chastisement may still be for correction, and we must bow to it and wait on God for explanation and deliverance... Let us look for deliverance only from Him. Let us not turn aside to seek it elsewhere.
- Turn — the heart has not turned back, and the feet have not left the road. Inward loyalty and outward walk stand together.
- Test — God withdraws the blessings, so that love for Him proves to be love for Him alone, not for His gifts.
- Trace — you cannot read the cause of a trial from the shape of it. Two troubles can look alike outside and be opposite inside.
- Tell — say nothing to the accuser, who can point at the nation's failure. Say everything to God, who tests hearts.
- Trust — Romans 8 lists sheep for the slaughter among the things Christ's love outlasts. Bow, wait for God, and seek rescue nowhere else.
Though thou hast crushed us in the place of jackals, and covered us with the shadow of death.
Psalm 44 is the cry of a godly company beaten down for no fault of its own. Verse 19 says how far the crushing went, and it tells God plainly that He is the one who did it. The words come right after their claim that their hearts have not turned back, so the wound and the loyalty stand side by side. (The commentators below say "place of dragons." That is an older translation of the phrase the ESV renders "the place of jackals.")
So who are the "us" who were broken?
In Psalm 44 we hear the voice of godly Jews, who will be a true remnant of Israel in the coming day of trouble. All through the psalm it is "we" and "us", except in verse 6. That stands out, because nearly all the psalms before it speak as "I", and the plural is very rare. So Psalm 44 is the voice of a company, though verse 6 shows the psalm is the work of one man, whom God inspired to speak the thoughts of many.
The phrase sounds like dying. The word behind it means something else.
The word translated "shadow of death" means darkness, or dangers that may threaten death — but not actual physical death. It carries the same sense elsewhere in the Psalms (44:19; 107:10, 14), and also in Isaiah 9:2 and Jeremiah 2:6.
Being struck down in a wasteland looks like abandonment. One commentator reads it as gain.
This shows their condition compared with what it was under earlier enemies. Now they are a separated, faithful remnant, not mixed up with the sin of the nation, though struck down "in the place of dragons." That is the happy effect of God's judgments there — better than being joined with sinners.
Verse 19 is the price of the loyalty claimed in verses 17 and 18. The test is not obedience for reward, but love for God Himself.
This upright soul had not forgotten God, and had not been unfaithful to His covenant, though struck down in the place of dragons... They would rather suffer anything, whatever it might be, for owning the true God. They would do it for His own sake, out of the attachment of their heart to Him, for what He was when they got no blessing... God would test them not only about the covenant blessings, but about their heart-attachment to what He was in His nature — and in principle it is the same with us.
A crushing defeat can point to hidden sin. Israel once learned that. Psalm 44 is a different case.
Israel had sinned then, so prayer got no answer; what was needed was self-judgment. They had to put away the sin that had defiled them. Joshua did not know of it at the time, but if they had asked God before going up to Ai, He would surely have told them... In Psalm 44 there is nothing of that sort. On the contrary, they can plead before God, by the Spirit, that they know they are upright: "All this has come upon us, though we have not forgotten You, and we have not been false to Your covenant... yet You have broken us in the place of jackals and covered us with the shadow of death." (vv. 17-19.) Joshua and the elders could not have said that. Here Israel can — yet the discipline is much the same.
That innocence makes the pain worse. One commentator writes on verses 18-19 that they "feel the pain of the adversity more deeply because they do not feel they deserve it" (L M Grant).
The psalm is not locked in Israel's past.
Sometimes a Christian is crushed by persecution and no rescue comes. Then the psalm fits even more closely. The Apostle makes that very application in Romans 8:36, where he quotes verse 22. We may live sheltered lives in these favoured lands, but in the last few years many believers have suffered even to death, and their cry seemed to go unheard.
- Broken — God's own hand did the crushing, yet "shadow of death" means threatening darkness and danger, not death itself.
- Not for sin — unlike the defeat at Ai, there is no hidden fault to find here. These sufferers can plead their integrity before God.
- But for loyalty — God tests them, not about covenant blessings, but about their attachment to what He is when no blessing is left.
- Better broken than blended — the desolate place marks them out as separate from the nation's sin, not joined with sinners.
- Ending in God alone — with no hope of victory left on their side, rescue "must be as the fruit of God's redeeming mercy... His work alone" (F. B. Hole).
If we had forgotten the name of our God, and stretched out our hands to a strange god,
Psalm 44 is the prayer of a people crushed by defeat who cannot find the sin that explains it. Verse 20 is their self-examination, spoken out loud before God. If hidden idolatry were the cause, God would already know it. So what else explains the ruin?
The verse names two things the sufferers have not done: forgotten God's name, or turned in prayer to another god. One writer reads it with the next verse as one argument, resting on God's knowledge:
They are badly broken, and they lie under "the shadow of death." Still, they have not forgotten the name of God, and they have not stretched out their hands in appeal to a strange god. Had they done so, God would have known it, for "He knows the secrets of the heart." So they appeal to the perfect knowledge of God. Far from turning to a strange god, they suffer all day long and face death because they hold fast to the true God.
The plea is risky. A person claiming innocence normally hopes no one looks too closely; here the sufferers invite the looking. They stake everything on the fact that concealment is impossible:
Yet in spite of all, they cleave to God, neither their heart nor their steps turned aside from Him, though crushed in the place of prowling jackals, covered with the shadow of death. Had they forgotten Him, would they, they ask, be able to conceal it from Him? Their appeal is to One perfect in knowledge.
This is what makes the psalm unusual. One writer sets it beside an earlier defeat, when Israel's own sin was the cause:
These words might have suited Joshua's lips when he lay on the ground before the ark until evening, with his clothes torn and dust on his head. But notice the difference. Israel had sinned then, so prayer did no good; what was needed was self-judgment... But in Psalm 44 there is nothing of that sort. On the contrary, by the Spirit they can plead before God that they know themselves to be upright: "All this has come upon us, though we have not forgotten you, and we have not been false to your covenant."... Joshua and the elders could not have said this. Israel can say it here, yet the chastisement is much the same.
Older translations say "a strange god" where the ESV says "a foreign god."
The same suffering can fall on the guilty and on the upright. So the shape of the trouble tells you nothing about its reason:
We learn this lesson from it: in the Lord's discipline, we cannot work out the cause of the chastisement from the nature of the chastisement... Think of the defeats of righteous Israel by sinful Benjamin, in Judges 20. There was a reason for Israel's repeated humiliation, yet it was not a lack of integrity... The Lord may have our general state before Him, and that state may need correcting by chastisement. Yet there may still be perfect integrity of heart, and the path a person is walking when the suffering comes may be the right one.
Relief does not come at once, and there is a purpose in the delay. Strip away the visible blessings, and the real test of integrity begins:
To test that integrity fully, and make it real suffering for God, the blessings that belong to His power must not be there. So the upright are left for a time to the oppression of the enemy. This searches the heart for any false way, and it makes their trouble suffering for what God is. Then, when they cry for mercy, He brings in the answer in due time. For He cannot leave what matches His own nature — integrity towards Him — needlessly in the power of evil.
The psalm does not stay in the past. One writer points to where it appears again:
The same principle is good for the church now, and from this point of view it is beautiful to see that Psalm 44 appears in Romans 8. Being given up like sheep for the slaughter for Christ's sake is listed among the things that cannot separate us from the love of Christ. The heart might fail under long pressure. "No," says the Spirit, "the love of Christ is unchanged."... If there is sin on the conscience, we cannot take this comfort... But if there is no conscious guilt, the chastisement may still be for correction. We must bow to it, and wait on God for an explanation and for deliverance... Let us look for deliverance from Him alone. Let us not turn aside to look for it somewhere else.
- Test. The verse puts the worst possible explanation on the table first: forgotten name, hands spread to another god. Loyalty that refuses to hide is loyalty worth having.
- Witness. The whole plea rests on God knowing the secrets of the heart, so no cover-up is even attempted.
- Distinction. In Joshua's day, defeat meant hidden sin. Here it does not, and the chastening itself never tells you its cause.
- Purpose. God removes the visible helps so that the suffering becomes suffering for what He is, and so searches the heart for any false way.
- Answer. He does not leave integrity in the enemy's power forever. Wait for deliverance from Him, and do not go looking for it anywhere else.