Philippians 4:11–13

Philippians 4:11

Not that I speak as regards privation, for as to me *I* have learnt in those circumstances in which I am, to be satisfied in myself.

Paul writes from prison, and he has just thanked the Philippians for a gift. Now he makes clear what he does not mean by the thanks — and how a man beaten, stoned and jailed learned to be content.

The Thank-You That Asks for Nothing

Paul is grateful. But he takes pains that his thanks should not sound like a request for more.

In the corrupt heart of man, a word of thanks can be a veiled hint that more help would be welcome. The Apostle cuts off all thought of this by the words, "I have learned in whatever situation I am to be content."

William Kelly

Writing about money is delicate work. One commentator points to the care Paul takes:

Paul would not want them to think he was speaking out of covetousness. He did not want to suggest that he had been suffering because they had not sent sooner to meet his need, as though he hoped they might send further gifts. It is not easy to write about such things. You have to express the deep gratitude that is in the heart, and at the same time avoid any suggestion of covetousness.

G C Willis

What "Content" Means

The Greek word behind "content" carries a picture. It describes something that has all its supplies within itself.

"Not that I speak on account of want, for I have learned in whatever circumstances I am, to be content." (Literally, to be self-sufficing, as a country that needs no imports, but supplies everything it requires.)

G C Willis

Heard Is Not Learned

Paul does not claim he was told this truth. He claims he learned it — and one writer presses hard on the difference.

"I have learned." The Apostle does not say, "I have heard that in every state I should be content." He says, "I have learned." It is not enough for Christians to hear their duty, they must learn their duty. It is one thing to hear, and another thing to learn; as it is one thing to eat, and another thing to digest food. Christians hear much, but, it is to be feared, learn little.

Hamilton Smith

Nothing Natural About It

If contentment had to be learned, then Paul once did not have it. One writer traces it back to the place where Paul's will broke.

It is a high attainment in the school of Christ to be able to say, "I have learned in whatever situation I am to be content" (Phil. 4:11). Paul had to learn this. It was not natural to him; and most surely he never learned it at the feet of Gamaliel. Saul of Tarsus would never have been content with the very highest attainments in this world. He had to be thoroughly broken down at the feet of Jesus of Nazareth, before he could say from his heart, "I am content."

C. H. Mackintosh

A Real State, Not a Slogan

The words are often quoted as a general principle about what any Christian can do. One commentator objects that Paul is saying something far more personal.

He meant that he could do all things; he had learned it. It was a real state for him, not an abstract proposition. "I am instructed both to be full and to be hungry." If I am full, He keeps me from being careless, indifferent and self-satisfied. If I am hungry, He keeps me from losing heart and growing dissatisfied. With him it was not "a man can," but "I have found Christ so sufficient in every circumstance that I am under the power of none." He had been beaten with rods; five times he received from the Jews forty lashes less one; he had been stoned, and he had gone through all sorts of things; but he had found Christ enough in them all.

J. N. Darby

Independence Built on Dependence

Paul is free from his circumstances, but he is not free-standing. His freedom rests on something.

This is the great design of the letter: not truth simply made known, but experience grown into… At the same time he shows how he valued their love. He takes care that his independence was founded on dependence — an independence of circumstances that finds its strength in simple and absolute dependence upon God.

William Kelly

Summary

- Heard. You can hear your duty and never learn it. Hearing is like eating; learning is like digesting.

- Learned. Contentment is not natural to anyone. Paul had to learn it, broken down at Christ's feet.

- Content. The word means self-sufficing — like a country that needs no imports, because it supplies everything it needs.

- Owned. Paul is not stating a theory anyone could claim. It was a real state for him, and no circumstance held power over him.

- Dependent. His independence of circumstances rested on absolute dependence upon God. The gift was welcome, but it was never what he lived on.

Philippians 4:12

I know both how to be abased and I know how to abound. In everything and in all things I am initiated both to be full and to be hungry, both to abound and to suffer privation.

Paul writes from prison to thank a church that had just sent him help, and he adds that his thanks are not a hint that he needs more. The verse describes a capacity he did not always have: meeting plenty and poverty with the same settled heart.

A Lesson, Not a Temperament

Paul does not claim he was born calm, or that he rose above trouble by force of will. One commentator points out that the phrase rules out any natural gift:

This is not natural to human nature. Even Paul may not always have known it; he had learned it.

William Kelly

The same writer notes that the whole letter runs on this line: not truth simply announced, but truth learned by living. Another writer rules out two easy explanations:

Stoical indifference did not harden Paul against the ups and downs of life. Natural strength of character did not make him superior to the burdens that crush ordinary people. What he was practising he had first learned through a secret initiation into his Teacher's ways.

A. Pridham

The Word Behind "Instructed"

Older translations render the second half of the verse as "I am instructed." The word behind it means to be let in on something.

"I have been initiated" is another word found nowhere else in Scripture. It comes from the same root as our word mystery. People used it for the secret religious rites of paganism, and for initiation into them. They guarded these rites closely from common knowledge... Paul's use of this word to supply language for Christian experience is very suggestive. The knowledge of the peace of God, of utter contentment, is indeed an open secret, open to "whoever will learn of Him." But it is a secret, a mystery, none the less.

G. C. Willis

Two Different Exams

Paul names four conditions, and one small word governs them all. He does not say he has been brought low; he says he knows how. The writers below quote an older translation, which says "abased" where the ESV says "brought low."

Let us note his emphasis on the word "how." For it is all too possible to be abased and to take it in a wrong spirit. Not so with the apostle: "how to be abased" implies a cheerful acceptance of God's will in it. On the other hand, "how to abound" is in some ways a harder test for many of us. It calls for a right and godly use, according to the will of God, of the things in which He has made us abound.

Leslie M. Grant

Plenty carries its own risk, and two kings show it:

It is easier for some to be abased than to abound. David, when hunted like a partridge on the mountains, trusted God; when living at ease in Zion, Satan lured him into the foulest sins. Jehoshaphat, when weak, counted on God, saying, "We do not know what to do"; when strong and rich, he allied himself with Ahab and helped the ungodly.

W. W. Fereday

Why God Takes the Props Away

If contentment is taught, then the hungry seasons are the classroom, not an accident. One writer gives the first reason God allows it:

There are many reasons why the servant of God should walk this path. Perhaps the first is that we then learn, as perhaps in no other way, the faithfulness, the love, and the power of God. When the earthly props are removed, then we find out what a wonderful thing it is to lean on the Father's arm.

G. C. Willis

Independence Built on Dependence

The result sounds like self-sufficiency, but it is not. One commentator names the paradox:

At the same time he shows how much he valued their love. He is careful that his independence was founded on dependence. It was an independence of circumstances that finds its strength in simple and absolute dependence upon God.

William Kelly

That is why a chained prisoner can write such words. Kelly notes that in the judgment of others Paul could do nothing. Yet he was the very one who could say he had strength for everything in the One who strengthened him.

Summary

- School. Contentment is learned, not natural. God does the teaching, through the circumstances He allows.

- Secret. The word behind "instructed" means initiated into a mystery. Yet it is an open secret, open to anyone who will learn from Him.

- Two lessons. Knowing how to be low means accepting God's will cheerfully. Knowing how to abound means using the plenty rightly, and that exam is the harder one.

- Proof. David and Jehoshaphat trusted God while weak and failed while strong. God removes the earthly props to teach us to lean on the Father's arm.

- Strength. Freedom from circumstances rests on dependence on Christ. That is why a prisoner in chains could claim strength for everything.

Philippians 4:13

I have strength for all things in him that gives me power.

Paul writes this from prison, at the end of a thank-you note for a gift the believers in Philippi had sent him, and right after saying he had learned to be content whether he had plenty or nothing. The words are often quoted as a promise of unlimited personal achievement — so the questions worth asking are what "all things" actually covers, where the strength comes from, and whether an ordinary Christian can say the same sentence.

Where the letter has been heading

Commentators point out that each stage of the letter has held up a different view of Christ, and this verse is the last of them.

How wonderfully Christ is kept before us from the beginning to the end of this beautiful letter. In the first chapter it is Christ our Life, leading the believer to view everything in connection with Him. In the second chapter it is Christ our Pattern in lowliness, to unite us together in one mind. In the third chapter it is Christ our Object in the glory, to enable us to overcome all opposition. In the last chapter it is Christ our Strength, to meet all our needs.

Hamilton Smith

Learned, not assumed

Paul does not state a general principle about Christians. He reports something he had been through.

People say, "Oh, we can do all things through Christ," as a kind of absolute truth. I say, can you? You cannot. Oh, you say, a person can — and this is perfectly true as an absolute statement, but it is not what the apostle meant. He meant that he could do all things; he had learned it. It was a real state for him, not an abstract proposition… With him it was not "a man can," but "I have found Christ so sufficient in every circumstance that I am under the power of none."

J. N. Darby

The One who gives the power

The source of the strength is named, and the word Paul uses for it is worth weighing. (Older translations read "through Christ"; the ESV reads "through him who strengthens me.")

"I have strength for all things in the One empowering me." What wonderful words to come from a man in prison, who was apparently in the most miserable circumstances, and in no small danger: one who was unable to do anything, as people would say. But faith speaks according to God, and the one who could do nothing, in the judgment of others, is the very one who could say he had strength for all things — not in himself, truly, but in the One empowering him. The word translated "empowering" is the word from which we get dynamite and dynamo… Our Lord Jesus said truly, "Apart from me you can do nothing." But here we have the other side.

G. C. Willis

Enough when full and when hungry

The "all things" is measured by what came just before it — plenty at one end, hunger at the other.

Christ was the apostle's strength. When he was full, with no need, he could praise the Lord. When he was hungry and feeling the pinch of the bare necessities of life, no complaint passed his lips, and no criticism of God's care for him passed through his mind. The testimony of this must have been very impressive. Christ was the source of his quietness and calm. It was as if he lived on an island and needed to import nothing from the mainland in the way of moral support. Christ was enough at all times.

A. J. Pollock

The same supply is open to us

If this was Paul's experience, one writer asks what actually keeps it from being ours.

Don't say that if your circumstances were different you could be better Christians; don't plead that it is impossible to witness for Christ where you are; remember the sufficiency of the Lord, and count on Him… there is no reason why we should not have the same wonderful experience Paul had — except our own selfishness and cowardice and unbelief — for Christ is as much at our disposal as He was at his. He is the same for you and us.

J. T. Mawson

How the supply is kept flowing

Power held in Christ has to be drawn on, and the same writer shows what interrupts that.

It is only as our souls are kept in secret communion with Christ that we shall be able to make use of the power that is in Him. This being so, all Satan's power will be aimed at putting our souls out of touch with Christ… It may be that he will try to draw us out of communion with Christ by the cares and duties of everyday life, or by sickness and bodily weakness… If, however, instead of letting all these things come between our souls and the Lord, we make them occasions for drawing near to Him, we shall learn what it is to be strong in the Lord while realising our own weakness.

Hamilton Smith

Summary

- Source — the sentence is not about human capacity; the strength is in "the One empowering me," and apart from Him we can do nothing.

- School — Paul had learned this. It was a proven state, not a slogan; saying "a Christian can do all things" as a general truth is not what he meant.

- Scope — "all things" is set by the verse before it: full or hungry, plenty or need, with Christ enough at all times.

- Sharing — Christ is as much at our disposal as He was at Paul's; what usually blocks the same experience is selfishness, cowardice and unbelief.

- Sustaining — the power is drawn through communion with Christ, so pressures and cares should be turned into reasons for drawing near rather than allowed to come between.