For let this mind be in you which [was] also in Christ Jesus;
Philippians 2 opens with a call for believers to be of one mind. This verse names the standard for that unity: the mind of Christ Jesus Himself. The commentators below work from an older wording, "Let this mind be in you, which was also in Christ Jesus." They press two questions. What is "this mind"? And how far can anyone follow it?
Paul has already asked the Philippians to be of one mind. This verse answers the question that raises.
We will certainly reach the 'one mind' of verse 2 if the lowly mind of verse 3 takes shape in us all. But we would still find it hard if that lowly mind were only an abstract idea to us. We want it to be a living reality before our eyes, and we have it in Christ Jesus. If there is to be only one mind, whose mind is that one mind to be? — 'Let this mind be in you, which was also in Christ Jesus' (v. 5).
The wording itself repays attention. The word "mind" is bigger than it looks, and in Greek the second half of the verse has no verb at all.
'Let this mind be in you' or, Have this for your mind — your principle of thought and feeling — 'which (was, and is,) also in Christ Jesus'. There is no verb in the second half of the verse, but English needs one. We usually use the word 'was'. Yet nothing in the Greek limits the meaning to past or present. Even now, exalted to the highest glory, He is 'this same Jesus' (Acts 1:11)… And what was 'this mind'? Was it not an utter and absolute self-forgetfulness? Here is the cure for all our quarrels and divisions, our misunderstandings and difficulties with one another.
This chapter does not set Christ in glory before us as a goal to chase. It points the other way.
In chapter 2 you do not get Christ in glory as the One the believer runs after. You get Christ coming down, not Christ gone up. He is the One I am to be like in the grace of the walk He showed. And that walk is always going down — from the form of God down to death… Paul is taking up the truth of lowliness, but the moment he begins he must bring out Christ.
The verses that follow describe a descent no one else could start. So the call to copy Christ needs care.
He has been urging them to humility and self-denial. Now he sets before them, and before us, the pattern of what we are called to copy — though not the measure of it. The pattern: as children of the Father we are to aim at nothing short of His perfection, and since we share the Spirit of Christ His ways should be ours too. Not the measure: the very first step of His humility was one that only His equal by nature could have taken, if such a person existed.
This call is tested in ordinary moments, when someone wrongs us.
We know how we feel when someone says an unkind word to us. We know how we feel when someone denies us our rights, tramples on us, or will not treat us fairly. We know how upset our spirits get at such times, do we not? But it was never so with the Son of God's love. The apostle says, let His mind be in you. Do not let the sun go down on your anger; do not quarrel among yourselves; do not let your angry feelings rise.
Kelly names both the standard and where the power to follow it comes from:
The Apostle goes on to urge lowliness in love, by setting the way of the Lord Himself before their eyes. Since Christ appeared, this is the true "rule of life" for the believer. It is not even the whole written Word by itself, but that Word seen alive in Christ. And the Holy Spirit makes Christ a spring of power to the soul that stays occupied with Him.
- One mind — unity needs one standard. Christ Jesus supplies it, and the mind believers share is His lowly mind.
- This mind — the word covers your whole way of thinking and feeling. In Him it showed as complete self-forgetfulness.
- Downward mind — chapter 2 does not show Christ gone up as our goal, but Christ coming down as our way. His path was always going down.
- Pattern, not measure — we are to aim at His perfection, yet the first step of His humility was one no one else could take.
- Mind at work — it shows itself when others wrong us, and it grows as the soul stays occupied with the Christ the Word displays.
who, subsisting in the form of God, did not esteem it an object of rapine to be on an equality with God;
This verse stands at the highest point of the letter. Before Paul traces how far Christ came down, he shows us where that descent began. Two questions follow. What does "in the form of God" mean? And why was equality with God not something for Him to grasp at?
The phrase is about His nature, not His appearance.
Christ was in the form of God. That was not mere appearance: He had that form, and not a creature's. The form of God means that He has God's own form and no other. He was in that nature of being, and nothing else. He had no created nature at all. He was God the Son, and nothing besides.
Paul picks three Greek words here. Only one of them fits God.
Three words in this passage express the general idea of resemblance: Form (morphē), Fashion (schēma), Likeness (homoiōma). Only the first applies to God. It alone means essential quality, not outward appearance.
The verb behind "being" is also chosen with care, and it points backward.
This passage has three words for existence: to be (einai), to exist beforehand (huparchein), and to begin to be (ginesthai). The second one is the word the Spirit uses here: "who subsisting in the form of God." It tells us that Christ Jesus was "in the form of God" before He came to this earth as Man. It may not say as much as the first verse of John's Gospel — "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" — but it fully agrees with it. It states plainly that He existed beforehand in the form of God, though it does not say in so many words that He existed from eternity. Other Scriptures bring that out, such as Psalm 90:2: "from everlasting to everlasting You are God."
You can only grasp at what you do not already have.
He was in the form of God. Our first parents were tempted to grasp at something far above them — at becoming as gods, as Genesis 3:5 shows. That place was not for them, and their grasping at it was sheer robbery. But there was nothing of that with our Lord. In His case equality with God was not something to be grasped at. It was His to start with, for He was God. He could not be higher than He was. Only two paths lay before Him: to stay as He was and where He was, or to come down into humiliation.
Equality with God was never a claim He had to press.
Self-assertion is unnecessary to any being who is conscious of an undisputed right by nature… To be equal with God — in other words, to act as God only and always — was no lawless or aggressive thought in the Son, who dwelt in equal glory with the Father from eternity. It was simply the unbroken continuance of the communion of the Godhead with itself, which no words can express.
Adam stands behind this verse as its opposite.
The first clause means that although He existed in the form of God, He did not use it to exalt Himself… It is surely a contrast to Adam, who fell into Satan's trap of trying to exalt himself, to be "like God, knowing good and evil." Adam being a man sought to exalt himself; Christ being God humbled Himself. How blessed the contrast!
The verse leads straight into the self-emptying of verse 7, and writers are careful about what that emptying did and did not touch.
Here is One existing in the form of God — plainly God Himself, so that there could be no question about Him at all. Yet He gave up this form of God. He did not give up the divine reality, which was necessarily His at all times, but the outward display of it. He did not treat this equality with God as "an object to be grasped."
Paul does not stop at describing Christ. He asks the same mind from us.
The Apostle shows that this happens only when "lowliness of mind" marks us. To have the lowly mind, he says, "Have this mind among yourselves, which is yours in Christ Jesus." His was the lowly mind that led Him to make Himself nothing so that He could serve others in love. Self likes to be served, and thinks it is exalted when others serve it; but love delights to serve.
- Height. "Form of God" states essential quality, not outward look — He was God the Son, with no creature nature at all.
- Already. From that height there was nothing to reach for; equality with God was His to begin with, so He could not rise, only stoop.
- Reversal. Adam, a man, grasped at being God; Christ, being God, humbled Himself — Eden run backwards.
- Given up. He gave up the outward display of that glory, never the divine reality, which was always His.
- Yours. Paul asks this same mind from ordinary believers — the lowliness that serves instead of demanding service.
but emptied himself, taking a bondman's form, taking his place in [the] likeness of men;
Paul points the Christians at Philippi to the mind of Christ Jesus. That mind shows itself in a downward path. It starts here: One who was in the form of God takes the form of a servant. Two questions follow. What did He empty? And what did He become?
Older translations read "made Himself of no reputation." The ESV reads "emptied himself." One writer prefers the second wording, and says what that emptying meant in practice.
This revelation by the Spirit of God about the Son of God becoming man shows one outstanding feature. It was His making Himself of no reputation, or emptying Himself. The second is the better translation of the Greek text. The apostle teaches that Christ Jesus, who was in "the form of God," freely took on Himself "the form of a servant (or bond-slave)," and in this way He "emptied Himself." Being "in the likeness of men," He did not use the rights of His deity apart from the will of the One who sent Him. This act of self-denial expressed "the mind which was in Christ Jesus" — the mind the apostle wanted believers to have too.
If He emptied Himself, what did He pour out? One writer answers that He emptied Himself by taking something, not by giving anything up.
How do you think He made Himself of no reputation? By taking a form He never had before. In Darby's translation, "Taking a bondman's form." He gave up nothing. He gave up nothing that belonged to Him as God, but He emptied Himself by taking a form He never had before.
How far down did He come? The place He chose at the bottom shows it.
He set aside all His glory. He did not stoop to become a servant in angelic majesty, but in the likeness of men. Here we have the form of a servant as well as the form of God, but that does not in any way mean that He was not really both. Just as He was truly God, so He became the truest servant that God or man ever saw.
One writer finds this servant's form pictured in an old law from Exodus 21.
He was to serve for six years, but in the seventh year "he shall go out free for nothing." But the Hebrew servant (and the word means a slave) might say: "I love my master, my wife, and my children; I will not go out free." Then his master shall bring him to the judges, and to the door or the doorpost, and shall pierce his ear with an awl; and he shall serve him forever. That pierced ear was the pledge and the proof that he would be his slave forever. And those pierced hands and feet and side tell the same story of "Christ Jesus: who … emptied Himself, and took upon Him the form of a slave."
Verses 6 to 8 use three words: form, likeness and fashion. Each one adds something.
The word "form" refers to His body, but the One who was in that body had every feeling and sensibility of a Man. He was not just God in a body… People saw Him in that body, but there was more. The word "likeness" in verse 7 carries the thought of moral qualities. The word "fashion" or "figure" in verse 8 shows that He was in the actual physical likeness of a Man. Both of these matter greatly… We read of Him weeping and hungering. If we miss this truth, we may read these verses as describing a kind of Manhood we could never reach. He was in every respect a real Man.
Critics have also used this verse against the One it honours. The Greek word for "emptied" gave them a name for their theory.
Kenosis is a word coined from the Greek word used in this passage. It literally means "emptied," though the older translation reads "made … of no reputation." The theory pictures Christ as emptying Himself so completely of all that was divine that He became a Jew, as ignorant as most Jews of His day. So the critic who puts this theory forward, armed with modern learning, feels quite able to contradict or correct the Son of God.
One writer sets this verse beside an older story. A man in the form of man grasped at being God.
He always was God, but He laid aside the form of God, the outward glory, and "took the form of a servant, being born in the likeness of men." He will never stop being a servant, though He is Lord of all. He will never give up this service of love that blesses us… Adam was in the form of man, and he grasped by robbery at being equal with God. He was the first example of "everyone who exalts himself will be humbled." The last Adam humbles Himself and is exalted. He lays aside His glory and takes a servant's form.
- Height. He always was God, in the form of God. That is where this downward path starts.
- Emptying. He emptied Himself by taking a form He never had before. He gave up nothing that belonged to Him as God.
- Form. Not angelic majesty but a servant's place: real manhood, with a man's body, a man's feelings, a man's hunger and tears.
- Forever. Like the servant who loved his master and chose the pierced ear, He will never lay the servant's form down.
- Mind. Adam grasped upward and was brought low. The last Adam went down, and God exalted Him. The apostle wants that same mind in us.
and having been found in figure as a man, humbled himself, becoming obedient even unto death, and [that the] death of [the] cross.
A single verse traces the last stretch of a descent that began in the form of God and ends at a criminal's cross. Writers ask three things here: why being found in human form was not the end of His stooping, how the eternal Son could take up obedience at all, and why the verse names the cross.
Verse 7 and verse 8 are not the same move repeated. One writer tells them apart: one He did as God, the other as man.
Emptying Himself as God, He humbled Himself as man, instead of making Himself anything.
Becoming man did not settle what place He would take among men. That was a further choice.
This is a further step downward than being found in human form. As we said, He could have been found in human form and yet chosen to be an emperor or a mighty king. He could have chosen honour and wealth. But no: "He made Himself low." "He humbled Himself."
No obedience has ever matched this one. What sets it apart is who was obeying.
There never had been, and never could have been, such obedience on earth, or even in heaven... The surpassing dignity of His Person is what lifted this obedience beyond compare. And that is before we mention the harsh and painful circumstances in which He gave it, right up to death — and what a death! As the eternal Son, He ruled over all. From the lowest creature on earth to the archangel on high, nothing moved except at His command.
The older wording can be misread as though death itself gave Him orders. Writers correct that reading.
The older English translation might be misread to mean that He was obedient to death itself. But it was obedience to His Father's will, all the way to death... And His death at Golgotha showed not only His matchless love, but also His devoted obedience.
Dying was not a debt His nature owed. One writer argues that from this verse.
"Being found in human form," He did not have to die. He died because of the purposes of grace: He "humbled himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross." He died for our sins. So, for Him, death rested on a completely different basis and served purposes that were supremely divine. Adam, the man who failed, disobeyed and died; Christ became obedient as far as that point of death, the death of the cross.
Many have said the obedience that makes us righteous was Christ's keeping of the law through His life. One writer points instead to this verse.
The death on the cross showed in fullest measure what our sin and disobedience deserved. It was also the crowning act of a life of perfect obedience. The letters of the New Testament dwell on this: "For as by the one man's disobedience the many were made sinners, so by the one man's obedience the many will be made righteous" (Romans 5:19). Many have thought this means our Lord's law keeping during His life. It does not. It means His obedience "to the point of death, even death on a cross."
Death looks like the lowest step. The verse names a lower one.
He did not only become obedient to the point of death. That death was death on a cross. That last step tells out the awfulness, the horror, the shame and the anguish of the death He became obedient to... Perhaps no death makes a person shrink back like "death on a cross." The Lord of Glory went down to this, the lowest step anyone could take.
What men did to Him was not the worst of that death.
People dwell on the disgrace He suffered: the insults, the injustice, the abuse and the rejection He received from men. All of this wounded His heart deeply. Yet the suffering and sorrow of His holy soul went far deeper, when He bore the wrath of God until it was spent in the righteous judgment He endured for our sins.
The call to copy Him has a limit. One writer marks where it lies.
We cannot follow all His steps. We were never in the height from which He came, and we are not asked to travel into the depths He went. But we are urged to have His mind as He took these steps.
- Down, freely. Two stoops, not one. As God He emptied Himself; as man He made Himself low. He could have chosen an emperor's place instead.
- Down, as obedience. The eternal Son entered obedience; He never owed it. Who He is makes that obedience beyond compare.
- Down, to the limit. Not obedient to death, but obedient as far as death — proof that dying was never a debt His nature owed.
- Down, past the floor. "Even death on a cross" adds the shame men heaped on Him and the judgment God laid on Him.
- Up, and ours. By this one obedience many are made righteous; and the one step asked of us is not His depth but His mind.