The standard of the camp of the children of Judah set forward first according to their hosts, and over his host was Nahshon the son of Amminadab;
Israel's camp sets out on the march, and Judah goes first with Nahshon at its head. Two questions follow: why this tribe at the front, and why does the tabernacle travel just behind it?
The march followed no one's convenience. God set the whole order, from the leading tribes to the men carrying the holy vessels, so that each part arrived when it was needed.
F. B. HoleEverything, we notice, was regulated; and the order was God's order. Judah led the first three tribes. After them came the bearers of the tabernacle. After the second group of three tribes came the bearers of the sanctuary — the ark and other holy vessels. So in the new spot the tabernacle was set up before the ark arrived. Ephraim led the remaining six tribes. These arrangements held good for all the journeys of the children of Israel, according to verse 28.
The instructions given earlier in the book had placed the tabernacle in the middle of the camp. Here it travels right behind Judah's three tribes, and commentators read that shift as practical rather than arbitrary.
J. N. DarbyThe order followed in the march differs from the order God had prescribed. The tabernacle, with its curtains, went after the first three tribes, so that they could set it up to receive the ark, which followed the second division. Still, this was only a detail in the arrangements, so that everything would be ready when the ark arrived. But God appears in a remarkable way in grace, outside the whole order He had prescribed; for it is the ark itself which goes before the whole camp.
The name of the tribe explains its place at the front.
Samuel RidoutJudah means praise. It was the leading tribe of Israel. It took the front place in the march through the wilderness (Num. 10:14), and it led the fighting in Canaan (Judges 1:1-2). The kingship belonged to this tribe — in the family of David — and Jerusalem, the city of the great King, stood on its border. But the meaning of the name suggests what we have been seeing already. "Judah is My lawgiver." Praise, flowing from a satisfied heart, occupied with the glories of God — this is His sceptre!
The ESV renders that line from the Psalms "Judah my scepter"; the writer quotes an older wording.
Putting praise in the lead is not decoration. One writer points to a later battle where the singers went first.
Numerical Bible NotesBut why is Judah foremost, the leader of all Israel in this way? His name and what we have seen of his history account for this... We have read his motto too in the words of Jacob: "The spirit of praise is the spirit of power." Judah is foremost here for the same reason that Jehoshaphat, in a later day, put his singers and trumpeters at the front of the battle against the enemy. When they began to sing and praise, the Lord went out against the foe and struck them down. (2 Chron. 20.) So it is here.
The same writer draws out a further link. A heart full of God obeys, which is why the tribe named praise is also the lawgiver.
Numerical Bible NotesFor the spirit of praise is also the spirit of obedience, and so Judah is qualified to be the lawgiver (Ps. 60:7). Wherever the heart is filled with God, His throne will be in the heart. And what an irresistible power there is in this spirit of obedience to the all-wise "Captain of salvation"! Who or what can defeat the King's army, so long as it obeys orders?
The tribe at the head of the column points past itself. One writer looks from Judah to the One who came from Judah.
Samuel RidoutHere then we have a hint of the power that is to meet the opposition in the world and lead God's people on in victory to the coming day. The spirit of praise must come first... From Judah, too, has come the One who is our Lord Jesus, the leader of our praises, the captain of the Lord's host.
- First — order. God regulated every detail of the march. The order was His order, and it held good for every journey Israel made.
- First — praise. Judah means praise, and the tribe that carried that name marched at the head of all Israel.
- First — power. The spirit of praise is the spirit of power; singers belong at the front of the battle, as Jehoshaphat later proved.
- First — obedience. Praise and obedience go together. That is why the praising tribe is also the lawgiver. An army that obeys orders cannot be beaten.
- First — Christ. From Judah came the leader of our praises and the captain of the Lord's host, who goes ahead of His people to the coming day.
and over the host of the tribe of the children of Issachar was Nethaneel the son of Zuar;
The camp at Sinai breaks up for the first time, and the tribes move off in the order God gave them. This verse names the captain of the second tribe in the column, and it raises a plain question: why does God record such names at all?
This verse sits inside a roll call, because a whole nation moves off at once.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinWhat a magnificent spectacle it must have been when the camp of Israel moved for the first time in its divinely arranged order! The cloud moved and advanced towards the wilderness of Paran. Judah with his flowing standard, led by Nahshon, comes first.
Issachar does not lead. He marches behind Judah, and one writer reads that order as instruction.
Numerical Bible NotesThe full heart flows out toward people in service, as it flows out toward God in praise. The spirit of praise is what banishes legalism and makes the life a true offering to God. Then, indeed, Issachar may follow, and the farmer who labours share in the fruit. Zebulun speaks of that open, recognised bond between God and us, which is the seal on true labour.
The order of the tribes was not decided on the morning of the march. It followed a plan, and it rested on words spoken long before.
C E StuartIn each camp the younger tribe followed the elder, with one exception: Manasseh. No one could justly complain of that, for Jacob had settled Ephraim's place ahead of Manasseh when he blessed them. Judah led the way; not Reuben the firstborn, though the latter tribe was chief of the second camp. Reuben had lost his place as the eldest before Jacob died... No tribe, then, could complain of its place in the order of march. No jealousy over it could have grown in anyone's heart. Jacob's dying words and dying act settled questions which might otherwise have arisen.
One writer gives the meaning of each name in this group of tribes.
Samuel RidoutJudah means "praise."... Issachar means "hire," and his prince Nethaneel, "the gift of God," whose father is "little." Zebulon means "dwelling," and his prince Eliab, "God is a Father."
Those meanings pull against each other. A tribe named for wages is given a captain named for a gift, and one writer takes that as God's answer to Issachar's weakness.
Numerical Bible NotesIssachar's prince is Nathaniel, the "gift of God" — a name exactly suited to the man whose own name speaks of hire, and whose tendency is to bend his shoulder to foreign yokes and to pay his tribute out of love of ease. The spirit of legalism takes up such strange service readily, because what it really serves is self, and a bribe will turn it from its true Master. This Nathaniel is a true overcomer. He has learned that no one can buy the "gift of God." Here too the family line shows very simply how grace is received: he is the son of Zuar, that is, "Little." A man who thinks of wages is bound to rate himself too highly. A man who counts himself truly "little" is ready to value the gift of God.
The same writer does not cancel the thought of reward. He draws a line between reward received and reward bargained for.
Numerical Bible NotesYet there is a right thought of recompense — a reward, of "mercy" (2 Tim. 1:18) which love will not be denied in giving — which is really just the gift of God. For the soul, this can never become a wage, the motive for service. The reason is that it is the reward of true devotedness alone, not of self-seeking. To work for the reward is to lose it. Issachar's captain must in this way also be Nathaniel.
A list of tribes and captains can look like old record-keeping. One writer reads it as a picture of order among God's people now.
Leslie M. GrantThe standard of Judah included two other tribes, Issachar and Zebulon, one camped on each side of Judah. All of this pictures how God keeps spiritual order in the church. It is not a precise physical order. It is an order that glorifies His name through the submissive obedience of His people, united and devoted to His name.
- Place. Issachar marched second, under Judah's standard. Jacob's dying words had settled that rank long before, so no tribe had cause to envy another.
- Praise. Judah, whose name means praise, goes first. Praise to God comes before service to people.
- Labour. Issachar means "hire" — the name warns of a man who will bend under any yoke for the sake of ease and pay.
- Gift. His captain's name, Nethanel, means "the gift of God" — what a hireling tries to earn is exactly what cannot be bought.
- Little. Nethanel is son of Zuar, "little." The man who counts himself small is ready to receive the gift. Reward chased as wages is reward lost.
and over the host of the tribe of the children of Zebulun was Eliab the son of Helon.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And the tabernacle was taken down; and the sons of Gershon and the sons of Merari set forward bearing the tabernacle.
Israel's first march from Sinai has begun, and the sons of Gershon and Merari take down God's dwelling place and carry it. Why does the tent travel ahead of the holy vessels it houses?
The marching order was not the order God first laid down. The change was practical.
J. N. DarbyThe order followed in the march differs from what had been prescribed. The tabernacle, with its curtains, went after the first three tribes, so that it could be set up to receive the ark, which followed the second division. Still, this was merely a detail in the arrangements, to have everything ready when the ark arrived.
The verse says they carried the tabernacle — not the holy vessels. Each family had its own load.
George DavisonKohath had the honour of carrying the holy vessels, which speak of the personal, moral and official glories of our Lord Jesus Christ. Gershon's task was to carry the curtains, the tabernacle, and the tent. These made up the house where those vessels stood in their places before God. Merari's task was to carry the boards of the tabernacle and the pillars of the court, which held up the curtains of the tabernacle and the hangings of the court. This speaks of what is practical.
Gershon's load looked plain — skins and curtains. Yet carrying it set the Levite in his right place in the world.
C. H. MackintoshHere was Gershon's work: to carry the tabernacle and its coverings through the waste and howling wilderness. This was true Levite service, but it was most blessed service. What matches it in the Church now is something we should seek after. It alone puts the Christian into his right place in the world — the place of a stranger. There was little that looked attractive in the rams' skins and the badgers' skins. But little as there was, it was the high privilege of the Gershonite to take them all up and carry them cheerfully on his shoulders across the trackless sands.
His name carries the same lesson.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinGershon means exile, a stranger. The fine linen is a picture of righteousness. The coverings and hangings divided off and separated the different parts of the tabernacle, so they must carry the meaning of separation. His service points us to this: we are separated ones and strangers in the world. Practical righteousness must bear witness to this separation.
Merari carried the framework — boards, bars, pillars, pins and cords. The name matches the work.
Frederick W GrantHis name — Merari, "bitterness" — speaks of the painful character of such service. Self-love breaks down at this work, or runs off into some odd path that is less of a burden to flesh and blood. In our day the family of Merari has shrunk to a very small number, and they have done their work very badly. Who cares about these boards and bars, and pillars and pins and cords? Who thinks about God's plan and pattern, and all the fine details of His appointment? The pattern is old, and will not adapt itself to the fashion of changed times. It leaves no room for human invention to show itself off. It needs only steady accuracy and diligent obedience.
Neither the stranger's walk nor the workman's sorrow would exist in a world at rest.
C. H. MackintoshThere was no need of a Merarite in Canaan, nor of a Gershonite either; for the Merarite was happy there, and the Gershonite was at home. But the world is not the Levite's home. So if anyone will carry the curtains, he must be a stranger. If anyone will carry the sockets and boards, he must be a man of sorrow. For when He who was a true Gershonite and a true Merarite came into the world, He was truly the Man of sorrows. He had nowhere to lay His head.
Gershon and Merari moved when the cloud lifted. Each man carried the load God gave him.
C. H. MackintoshIt must have been a beautiful sight to watch God's workers in the wilderness. Each one was at his post, and each moved in the sphere God had appointed him. So the moment the cloud lifted and the order came to strike camp, every man knew what he had to do. He gave himself to that and to nothing else. No man had any right to think for himself; the Lord thought for all. Seen in this light, it made no difference at all whether a man carried a pin, a curtain, or a golden lampstand. The great question for each and for all was simply, "Is this my work? Is this what the Lord has given me to do?"
- Carried, not settled. The Levites took God's house down and carried it, because His people were on the move.
- Carried early. The tent goes ahead of the holy vessels, so the dwelling stands ready when the ark arrives.
- Carried apart. Gershon takes the curtains, Merari the framework, Kohath the holy vessels. Each family has its own load.
- Carried at a cost. Gershon means exile; Merari means bitterness. One name marks the stranger, the other the cost of the work.
- Carried before by Christ. The true Stranger and true Man of sorrows walked this road first, having nowhere to lay His head.
And the standard of the camp of Reuben set forward according to their hosts, and over his host was Elizur the son of Shedeur;
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
and over the host of the tribe of the children of Simeon was Shelumiel the son of Zurishaddai;
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
and over the host of the tribe of the children of Gad was Eliasaph the son of Deuel.
Israel's camp is on the move at last. The record of that first march reads like a roll call, and this verse names Eliasaph son of Deuel at the head of Gad's men — the last tribe to march under Reuben's standard.
Gad did not travel wherever it wished. God fixed the order of the march, and one writer traces it through this verse and past it.
Leslie M. GrantThe tribes set out on the journey in the order God had prescribed, Judah first. When these had moved, the tabernacle was taken down, and the sons of Gershon and the sons of Merari set out, carrying it. The tribe of Reuben was next, with Elizur son of Shedeur leading. Then came Simeon and its leader, Shelumiel the son of Zurishaddai. Then Gad, with Eliasaph the son of Deuel leading. Following Gad were the Kohathites, carrying the furniture of the tabernacle, so that when they arrived the tabernacle would already be set up for them. So the Kohathites were in the middle of the procession, with the holy things in a central place.
Gad had no banner of its own at the head of a camp. It marched under another tribe's standard.
C. E. StuartBehind them would be seen the standard of the camp of Reuben, setting forward according to their hosts. Joined with Reuben were the host of the tribe of Simeon and the host of the tribe of Gad. Together they numbered 151,450 men who could go to war.
Both names in this verse speak of God. One writer sets them side by side.
Numerical Bible NotesAnd now we have Gad, whose prince is Eliasaph — "God has added"; he is the son of Deuel — "known of God." How good a thing it is to be known of God! This does not mean, of course, merely the knowledge God has of everything. It means the knowledge we have of someone we are close to, and it implies approval. And this is truly the secret of spiritual increase such as Eliasaph speaks of. Do we need to be told that we should expect increase in a child of God? And when it is missing, what a sad proof that closeness with God is lacking!
Numbers 2:14 gives the father a different name.
Morrish Bible DictionaryFather of Eliasaph, "prince" of Gad. In Numbers 2:14 he is called Reuel. This is plainly an instance where the letter ד (D) has been mistaken for the letter ר (R).
Gad stands for two things at once, and they belong together.
Numerical Bible NotesGad lies next to Reuben: Gad, the type of spiritual increase, and of a militant condition too. Spiritual increase can hardly happen without conflict in a world like this. In David's time the men of Gad stood out as warriors.
This list of names rests on a principle that runs through the whole camp. Nobody chose his own post.
C. H. MackintoshEach had to know his post and keep it — to know his standard and stay by it. So they moved on together; so progress was made, work done and warfare carried on. Each had his family line, and each had his post. Neither was according to their own thoughts; all was of God. He gave the family line, and He assigned the standard. There was no need to compare one with another, and no ground for jealousy. Each had his place to fill and his work to do. There was work enough and room enough for all. There was the greatest possible variety, and yet the most perfect unity.
Gad closed the second camp — and what came next explains why the order was arranged as it was.
H. L. RossierThe tabernacle, taken down and carried by Gershon and Merari, two of the Levite families, goes between Judah and Reuben. The sanctuary, carried by Kohath, the third Levite family, goes between Reuben and Ephraim.
- Order — God set the marching order; the tribes did not choose it. Gad's turn came after Reuben and Simeon.
- Place — Gad had no standard of its own. It marched under Reuben's, with Simeon: 151,450 fighting men in all.
- Name — Eliasaph means "God has added." His father Deuel means "known of God." Being known by God is the secret of increase.
- Increase — Gad stands for growth and for warfare at once. In a world like this, growth comes with conflict.
- Centre — the Kohathites followed straight behind Gad with the holy things, so the sanctuary travelled in the middle of the nation.
And the Kohathites set forward bearing the sanctuary and [the others] set up the tabernacle whilst they came.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And the standard of the camp of the children of Ephraim set forward according to their hosts, and over his host was Elishama the son of Ammihud;
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
and over the host of the tribe of the children of Manasseh was Gamaliel the son of Pedahzur;
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
and over the host of the tribe of the children of Benjamin was Abidan the son of Gideoni.
This verse names the last of three tribes that marched together: Benjamin, led by Abidan the son of Gideoni. One line of a roll call raises the chapter's big questions — who set this order, and what do these names mean?
Every man in the camp knew two things: which family he came from, and where he belonged in the line. One commentator shows what would have happened without that.
C. H. MackintoshIf a man did not know his family line, he could not recognise his standard. Everything would then have collapsed into hopeless confusion. Instead of keeping rank and making steady progress, they would have been in each other's way, treading on one another. Each had to know his post and keep it — to know his standard and stay by it. So they moved on together, made progress, did the work, and carried on the warfare. The Benjaminite had his post, and the Ephraimite had his, and neither was to interfere with the other or cross his path... Each had his family line, and each had his post. Neither of these came from their own ideas — all was of God.
The tribes did not settle this order among themselves. A better idea of their own would not have helped.
F. B. HoleWe notice that God commanded the order in which the tribes were to march when they set out on their journeys. He commanded the order of their tents in the same way when they rested. The arrangements were not left to their discretion or their wishes. Had they disobeyed, under the mistaken idea that they knew of a better order, they would simply have produced disorder.
One commentator moves from this marching column to how believers meet today.
Leslie M. GrantEphraim next began their journey ... then Manasseh ... then Benjamin with its leader Abidan the son of Gideoni. ... All of this shows that God is a God of order. In the Church of God there is no physical order like this at all. Yet God's instructions in Scripture are plain enough — for instance in 1 Corinthians. We have no excuse if we do not do all things decently and in order (1 Cor. 14:40). No man is in charge to control the saints; the Lord is in authority. Each individual has the Spirit of God, and by His influence all may be subject to the Lord, so keeping godly order in spiritual unity.
Ephraim, Manasseh and Benjamin travelled immediately after the holy things were carried out. That detail is picked up centuries later in a psalm of appeal.
J. N. DarbyThe smallest details in the word deserve to be noticed. The position of the tribes opens up the whole of Psalm 80. In the last days of Israel's desolation the psalmist asks God to lead them. He asks God to show His power as He did when He led them through the wilderness. He asks for the power of His presence on the ark of testimony, as God showed it at the moment Israel set forward and it was said, "Arise, O LORD, and let your enemies be scattered." Ephraim, Benjamin, and Manasseh were the three tribes nearest the ark in the camp of Israel. That is why verse 2 of the psalm says, "Before Ephraim and Benjamin and Manasseh."
Some writers find teaching in the meanings of the three names in this verse.
Samuel RidoutBenjamin, "the son of my right hand," speaks of the dignity of our position. That position is to be marked by the prince Abidan, "my father is judge," the son of Gideoni, "the one who cuts down." Here we have the sense of adoption together with that godly fear which removes pride from us.
Benjamin was given two names on the day he was born. Writers see Christ pictured in both.
Morrish Bible DictionaryThe youngest son of Jacob by his beloved wife Rachel. She died at his birth and named him BEN-ONI, meaning "son of my sorrow," but his father named him BENJAMIN, "son of the right hand" (Gen. 35:18, 24). He is a picture of Christ in both names. Benjamin pictures Him exalted at God's right hand. Ben-oni pictures Him rejected, and so the occasion of Israel's tribulation in the last days, with Rachel picturing Israel.
- Assigned — God gave Benjamin its place in the line. He commanded the order of the march and the order of the camp alike.
- Kept — each tribe held its own post, so no one got in another's way. God is a God of order, and Scripture still calls for all things to be done decently and in order.
- Near — Benjamin marched with Ephraim and Manasseh nearest the ark. Psalm 80 later appeals to that place.
- Named — Benjamin, "son of the right hand"; Abidan, "my father is judge"; Gideoni, "the one who cuts down" — adoption joined to a fear that removes pride.
- Christ — Benjamin's two names picture Him: exalted at God's right hand (Benjamin), and rejected, the occasion of Israel's sorrow (Ben-oni).
And the standard of the camp of the children of Dan set forward, the rear-guard of all the camps according to their hosts, and over his host was Ahiezer the son of Ammishaddai;
Israel's long column moves at last. The final standard to rise is Dan's — three tribes closing the march behind everyone else. Being last looks like the least honoured spot. So why does God give it to one of His largest camps, and what does a rear guard do?
Nobody chose his own place in this march. Each man knew where to walk because God had told him. That one fact removed confusion and rivalry from the camp.
C. H. MackintoshEach had to know his post and keep it — to know his standard and stay by it. That is how they moved on together. That is how they made progress, did the work and carried on the fight. The Benjaminite had his post, and the Ephraimite had his, and neither was to interfere with the other or cross his path. Each had his pedigree, and each had his post; and neither the one nor the other was according to their own thoughts. All was of God. He gave the pedigree, and He assigned the standard. There was no need of comparing one with another, and no ground of jealousy one of another. Each had his place to fill and his work to do, and there was work enough and room enough for all.
Dan was the son of a servant woman, not of one of Jacob's wives, yet he heads a camp — the camp that goes last. One writer traces how that order was settled long before the march began.
C. E. StuartDan, the chief of the last camp, had Asher and Naphtali attached to his standard . All three were children of servant women. But Dan was the eldest son of the three, so it was fitting that he had the leading place among them. No tribe, then, could complain of its position in the order of march. Nothing in it could stir up jealousy in anyone. Jacob's dying words and dying act settled questions which might otherwise have arisen.
The rear was not where the leftovers went. Count the fighting men, and you find strength massed at both ends of the column.
C. E. StuartBehind them, forming the rear guard, flew the standard of the camp of the children of Dan. With it went the host of Asher and that of Naphtali, and Naphtali closed the long procession. The rear guard amounted to 157,600 fighting men. So of the two largest hosts, one led the way and the other brought up the rear.
The job at the back is not only marching — it is watching. Two dangers wait there: people who fall behind, and an enemy who knows it.
Samuel RidoutLast, on the north, forming the rear guard on the march, we have the camp of Dan. With him are the tribes of Asher and Naphtali. There is a military ring about some of these names, suited to the place they occupy. Those who bring up the rear must guard against stragglers, and against sudden attacks like that of Amalek, who caused loss to those at the back of the children of Israel.
Elsewhere the same writer names the moment it happened.
Samuel RidoutThere were some who lagged behind; they were the stragglers, the camp followers. Amalek fell upon the rear. Such attacks are always upon the rear. The attack drew all the children of Israel into a conflict that would have been unnecessary if everyone had been pressing forward diligently.
The captain named in this verse has a name that matches the task. It also stands in sharp contrast to what Dan later became.
Leslie M. GrantThe prince of Dan was Ahiezer, meaning "brother of help." This is a sharp contrast to the character of Dan described in Genesis 49:17: "Dan shall be a serpent in the way." Instead of giving brotherly help, he would give satanic harm. Again, God makes a wonderful change by His pure grace, so that Dan would be a help in conflict.
Dan's own name means judgment — the right to rule. In human hands that right rarely stays what God meant it to be.
Numerical Bible NotesDan, "judgment," the spirit of rule, which, as Dan's origin points out, is really service. Yet how readily it is turned from this in man's hand! ... But God has a remedy for this, as for everything else. Dan is here in his place with his captain Ahiezer — "brother of help," the son of Ammishaddai — "the people of the Almighty." Let that relationship become real, and the ruler becomes what God designed: the "helping brother" of the people he is set over.
- Order — God gave every man his post and his pedigree. No one chose. That alone left "no ground of jealousy one of another."
- Place — Dan went last by a settled rule, not a snub. Jacob's dying words had fixed the order, so no tribe "could complain of its position in the order of march."
- Weight — God strengthened the back rather than abandoning it — 157,600 men, one of the two largest hosts, placed there to close the march.
- Watch — A rear guard watches for stragglers and for the enemy who hunts them. Amalek struck the back, and "such attacks are always upon the rear."
- Help — The man set over that post is "brother of help," son of "the people of the Almighty." Rule becomes service, and grace turns the serpent of Genesis 49 into a helper.