And the seed of Israel separated themselves from all foreigners, and stood and confessed their sins, and the iniquities of their fathers.
Israel cut every tie with outsiders, then stood and named their sins before God. Two questions sit inside the verse: why does separation come first, and why confess their fathers' sins too?
One writer links their sorrow back to the joy that came before it.
William KellyThe heart enters the word in a spiritual way. It bows to the word, and the bright hope of the people of God fills it with joy. Only then can we have a deeper sorrow. It is the greatest mistake to think that one truth works against another... Fill the hearts of God's people with God's future for them, and they will feel their present shortcomings all the more.
Some translations open the verse with the phrase "the seed of Israel." One commentator finds a reason behind that word.
Edward DennettThere is a reason for the use of the word seed here. It points out that they were a holy people, set apart to God. They were born of His people Israel, whom He had redeemed to Himself on the ground of the blood of the Passover Lamb. They were therefore a "holy seed," and they were to keep that holy character. God had brought them into this place. So to tie themselves to strangers denied it. It also broke down the barriers God Himself had set up between them and other peoples.
The verse joins two acts, and neither works alone.
Hamilton SmithIt is still required of all who name the Name of the Lord to depart from iniquity. But real separation calls for confession. The very fact that we have to separate at all proves we have been in wrong company, and that wrong calls for confession. And confession without separation would be unreal — for how can we continue in the evil we confess? So true separation and honest confession will always be found together.
Another writer notes which act came first, and why waiting is never an option.
Edward DennettNotice that separation came before confession. The word showed them they had sinned by joining themselves to strangers. They acted on what they saw, and then confessed their guilt before God. This is always God's order. The moment we see that something we have allowed, or are joined to, is condemned by the word of God, we must refuse it or separate from it. No circumstances can justify delay... To confess our sin while still holding on to it is only mockery.
They did not stop at their own generation. One writer explains why they named the older guilt too, and how deep the work went.
Edward DennettThey also confessed the iniquities of their fathers. They did so because the Lord's hand had been on them for this very reason. Their fathers' sins were why they had suffered captivity in Babylon. God's tender mercy had now restored them to their own land, yet they were still in bondage to a Gentile king. So they went down to the root of all the evil... Their humbling on this day was no shallow work.
Separation like this is easy to misread as coldness. One writer answers that charge, then names the hard part.
C. H. MackintoshThis was not sectarianism, but real obedience. Their separation was essential to their existence as a people. They could not have enjoyed the divine presence on any other ground... The great difficulty is to combine a spirit of intense separation with a spirit of grace, gentleness, and patience. As another has said, the aim is "to keep a narrow circle with a wide heart."
You might expect a separated people to grow proud. The chapter moves the other way.
C StanleyYou might think that separation from others would produce a feeling of self-superiority. But no, it did not... And then there is reading, confession, and worship. Ah, this is of God: it is the divine order. Separation from evil brings us to abhor ourselves before God. And the more we read His word, the more we have to confess; and, wonderful to tell, the more we confess, the more we worship.
Humbling ourselves as a group is easy. Confessing our own sins is what we avoid.
H. L. RossierWhen we are called on to judge an obvious evil, we will agree easily enough to humble ourselves as a group. We agree so long as the act does not force each of us, one by one, to confess our own sins and the wrongs we have committed. We will accept any compromise rather than that.
- Word first. Joy in God's word came before the fasting. That joy gave them the strength and the clear sight to judge themselves.
- Separate first. Confessing a sin while still holding on to it is mockery — they acted on what they saw, then spoke.
- Confess fully. They named their fathers' sins too. They went down to the root of the evil instead of treating the surface.
- Narrow circle, wide heart. Their separation was obedience, not a party spirit. The hard part is holding that narrow circle with a wide heart.
- Worship last. The divine order runs: read, separate, confess, worship. The more they confessed, the more they worshipped.
And they stood up in their place, and read in the book of the law of Jehovah their God a fourth part of the day; and a fourth part they confessed, and worshipped Jehovah their God.
The people have just separated themselves and owned their sins and the sins of their ancestors. Now the assembly settles into a long day with the book open, and this verse shows why reading and confessing belong together.
The phrase "a quarter of the day" is not vague. One writer explains how the Jewish day worked, and what that means for the length of this gathering:
Edward DennettThe Jewish day had four periods of three hours, starting at six in the morning. So they read the Scriptures for three hours, and confessed and worshipped for three hours. And what more blessed work could they have been doing? No doubt God Himself taught them and led them in this.
Six hours in all, and they stood through it.
The verse puts reading before confessing, and gives each the same span of time. One commentator draws out why the order matters and why the amounts match:
H. L. RossierNo confession can be complete without the Word. It is only through the Word that we learn what God is, what does not fit His character, and what we ourselves have been. What is more, the confession of the people was in direct proportion to what the Word revealed to them. One fourth of the day went to reading the law, and one fourth of the day went to confession. They had come to know the source of their strength in the book of the law. In this same book they now learn to judge their condition, so that they can confess it without holding anything back.
Standing apart from others could easily breed a sense of being better than them. One commentator traces what actually followed, starting from the separation in verse 2:
C. StanleySomeone might think that separating from others would produce a feeling of self-superiority. But no; it did not... And then there is reading, confession, and worship. Ah, this is of God: it is the divine order. Separation from evil brings us to loathe ourselves before God. And the more we read His word, the more we have to confess. And, amazing to tell, the more we confess, the more we worship... Self-judgment produces dependence on God, and faith in God.
Confession and worship look like opposite moods — one downcast, one exalted. A commentator points to the single cause producing both:
Hamilton SmithIt does not matter whether the people are giving praise to God or humbling themselves because of their failure. Either way, all of it is the outcome of the word of God applied to the conscience.
Reading did not stop at reading. It changed what the people said and did. One writer sums up chapters 8 and 9: "The word was having a practical effect upon them" — George Davison.
Commentators read this verse not only as history but as a template. One lists the three results the reading produced in verses 2 and 3:
F. B. HoleFirst, they separated themselves from every tie with foreigners that they had been allowing. Second, they confessed their own sins, as well as the wrongs their fathers had been involved in. Then third, they honoured their God by worshipping Him. They recognised that the word of the Lord, which they read, demanded obedience.
The same writer holds up the scene as the remedy when spiritual life runs cold:
Edward DennettOn every side we hear complaints of coldness and indifference, and of how little we feel our real condition... Look, then, at the example of these children of the captivity — the divine remedy, the true way of a real revival. In some places there may be only two or three who feel the present evils. But let these two or three get together. Let them test themselves, and everything else, by the Word, and confess their sins and the sins of their fathers. They would soon rejoice as God stepped in and delivered them... Even if we did no more than confess that we have no power to pray, it would be the dawning of hope in many an assembly.
- Read. The Word came first and filled a quarter of the day. Only through it do we learn what God is and what we ourselves have been.
- Confess. Confession took as long as reading. It ran in direct proportion to what the Word had revealed.
- Worship. The more they read, the more they had to confess; and the more they confessed, the more they worshipped. That is the divine order, not a downward spiral.
- One source. Praise and self-humbling both came from the same thing: the word of God applied to the conscience.
- Repeatable. Separation, confession, worship, obedience. Commentators call this pattern the true way of a real revival, open even to two or three who feel the need.