And it came to pass in the month Nisan, in the twentieth year of Artaxerxes the king, [that] wine was before him, and I took up the wine and gave it to the king. Now, I had never been sad in his presence.
Four months after the news of Jerusalem's ruin reached him, Nehemiah is doing his usual job: handing the king his wine. The verse looks routine, but it raises two questions the whole book turns on: why did God make him wait, and why did his grief show now?
The dates in chapter 1 and chapter 2 are not decoration. They mark a long gap between prayer and answer. One writer reads that gap as God's training.
Edward DennettFour months had passed since he offered the prayer recorded in Nehemiah 1. He is careful to give us the dates. In the month Chislev (our November) he had prayed; and in the month Nisan (our March) the answer came. Through that whole period, man of faith though he was, he must have waited on God in daily expectation. He could not foresee how the answer would come; but he knew that God could step in when and how He would... It is in this way God both tests and strengthens the faith of His people. He waits while they wait. But if He waits, it is only to bring His people into fuller dependence on Himself, and so to prepare their hearts for the blessing He is about to give.
Another writer looks at what filled those months.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinHanani had visited his brother Nehemiah in the month Chislev, the ninth month. Nisan is the first month of the Jewish year. How many prayers he must have offered up during those months! How patiently he waited for the Lord's time!
We might expect prayer to lift the burden. Here it did the opposite.
William KellySuppose Nehemiah's sorrow had been only for outward misfortunes — the loss of possessions or any natural thing here below. Then his tears and gloom would all have disappeared in the presence of the Lord. But the presence of the Lord deepened them. The more he went before God and weighed the state of the Jews in Jerusalem, the more grieved he was... Nehemiah was in no way delivered from sadness by his prayer... There was confidence in going to God, and at the same time there was still the deep sense of the ruin.
Nehemiah adds that he had never looked like this before the king. His job was to serve pleasure; his face was serving something else.
Edward DennettThe chapter opens with Nehemiah busy in the duties of his office as the king's cup-bearer. He "took up the wine and gave it to the king." But his heart was on other things. It was weighed down by the unspeakable sorrow of his people's condition. Wine and sadness do not go together. Scripture tells us that wine makes a man's heart merry. So the king could not bear it when his cup-bearer wore a sorrowful face at such a moment. It spoiled his own pleasure.
The office itself explains the king's suspicion.
F. B. HoleThe king's cup-bearer of those days had to be a man of integrity. He had to make sure that nothing undesirable or poisonous got into the king's wine. The news he had just received had affected him so deeply that his sorrow showed in his face. Noticing it, the king was of course suspicious and asked what had made him sorrowful.
Nothing miraculous appears in the verse. A writer argues that this is exactly how God usually answers.
H. L. RossierFasting and sorrow had left their mark on his face. No one was allowed to appear before the king with a sad face... but God used this very thing to put words into the king's mouth that would give Nehemiah an opening for his request. God answers our prayers with miracles like this. They are so much a part of daily Christian life that we hardly notice them. Looking carefully, everything is a miracle in God's ways toward us. He turns aside certain dangers. He arranges certain meetings and prevents others. He gives us certain opportunities and closes certain paths to us.
The twentieth year of Artaxerxes is more than a background detail. One writer makes it the starting point of a prophetic count.
A J PollockWe can fix the date of the command to rebuild Jerusalem exactly. Nehemiah 2:1 states it clearly: the month of Nisan in the twentieth year of the reign of king Artaxerxes. Count four hundred and eighty-three years from then. A prophetic year is three hundred and sixty days, its established length. That makes 173,880 days. The count brings us to the tenth of the month Nisan... the very time when Christ entered Jerusalem riding on a donkey's colt.
- Burden. News of a ruined city settled on Nehemiah's heart and stayed there for four months, from Chislev to Nisan.
- Waiting. God waits while His people wait. The delay tests and strengthens faith.
- Deepening. Prayer did not remove the sorrow; going before God made the sense of ruin deeper, not lighter.
- Opening. The face he could not hide became the very thing God used to put the question into the king's mouth.
- Landmark. That ordinary day at the wine cup fixes a date: 483 prophetic years later, Christ rode into Jerusalem.
And the king said to me, Why is thy face sad, seeing thou art not sick? this is nothing else but sadness of heart. And I was very sore afraid.
Four months after Nehemiah prayed about Jerusalem's ruined walls, his grief shows on his face at work. The king sees it, and his question turns private sorrow into open danger — and into the answer to that prayer.
The gap between the prayer of chapter 1 and this scene was not empty time. One writer explains what the delay was doing in Nehemiah:
Edward DennettFour months had passed since he had offered the prayer recorded in Nehemiah 1... He could not foresee how the answer would come; but he knew that God could step in when and how He would... It is in this way God both tries and strengthens the faith of His people. He waits while they wait. But if He waits, it is only to bring His people into fuller dependence on Himself. That prepares their hearts more fully for the blessing He is about to give. And when He steps in, it is often as quiet and unseen as it was here. Only the eye of faith can detect His presence.
You might expect prayer about Jerusalem to lift Nehemiah's mood. One writer reads it the other way round:
William KellyIf his grief had been only about outward troubles — the loss of possessions, or anything else in this life — his tears and gloom would all have disappeared in the presence of the Lord. Instead, the presence of the Lord deepened them. The more he went before God and weighed the state of the Jews in Jerusalem, the more grieved he was... Nehemiah was in no way delivered from sadness by his prayer. There was confidence in going to God, but at the same time there was still the deep sense of the ruin.
Nehemiah was on duty, handing the king his wine. His face did not fit the occasion.
Edward DennettHe took up the wine and gave it to the king, but his mind was on other things. The terrible sorrow of his people's condition weighed his heart down. But wine and sadness do not go together. Scripture tells us that wine makes a man's heart glad. So the king could not bear his cup-bearer wearing a sad face at such a time. It destroyed his own pleasure.
The king rules out illness first. One writer traces the sadness back to its source:
George DavisonNehemiah's attitude came from a heart drawn out toward the condition of what was precious to God. The king could see that this was something deeper than a physical problem, for he says, "You are not sick." It went much deeper. What Nehemiah had heard about the interests of God in Jerusalem had burdened and troubled his spirit.
Nehemiah records his fear honestly. One writer names what a suspicious king could have made of a servant's gloom:
William KellyNehemiah tells us honestly how afraid he was, for it might have cost him his life. The king might have suspected treason. He might have suspected some dark plot, and that Nehemiah's conscience was at work. All sorts of things might have come into his mind as he tried to explain the unusual gloom on his servant's face.
One writer points to the king's mood, and to what it could have led to:
Edward DennettThe king was angry... Nehemiah might well have been afraid, for in such a mood Artaxerxes, the Persian king, could have had him executed on the spot. But though he was afraid, God kept his presence of mind.
The danger of this moment throws light on something better by contrast. Where an earthly ruler demanded that everyone match his mood, God invites the opposite:
J. G. BellettHe gives our hearts liberty to decide the character of our communion with Him. Let it be, He says, according to your condition. "Is anyone among you suffering? Let him pray. Is anyone cheerful? Let him sing praise." This is not the way of a master or a patron. The patron's pleasure or mood must set the tone of the scene around him. It was dangerous to spoil the presence of the Persian king with sadness. There was danger of death if one had a heavy face there... But God's presence gives room to the heart and its conditions, whatever they may be.
- Wait. God let four months pass after Nehemiah's prayer. The delay was not neglect but training in dependence on Him alone.
- Burden. His grief was not for himself but for a ruined city. Going to God about it made the sorrow deeper, not lighter.
- Exposure. The burden showed at the wine table, where it was least welcome. The king saw straight through it: not sickness, but sorrow of heart.
- Fear. His fear made sense. A king with absolute power could have read gloom as treason and ordered his death.
- Welcome. A royal court banned sadness from its presence. God's presence makes room for the heart in any condition.
And I said to the king, Let the king live for ever! Why should not my countenance be sad, when the city, the place of my fathers' sepulchres, lies waste, and its gates are consumed with fire?
Nehemiah serves wine to King Artaxerxes, months after he began mourning over the ruin of Jerusalem. The king notices his sad face, and Nehemiah answers by naming the city for its graves.
Nehemiah had already fasted and prayed. Yet he still stood before the king with a sad face.
William KellySuppose his trouble had been only outward: the loss of property, or any other natural thing here below. Then his tears and gloom would have all disappeared in the presence of the Lord. But the presence of the Lord deepened them. The more he went before God and weighed the state of the Jews in Jerusalem, the more grieved he was... Nehemiah was in no way delivered from sadness by his prayer. There was confidence in going to God, but at the same time there was still the deep sense of the ruin.
A cup-bearer served the king's pleasure, and a sad servant spoiled it. Speaking the truth here was dangerous.
Edward DennettWine and sadness do not go together. Scripture tells us that wine makes a man's heart merry. The king could not bear to have his cup-bearer wear a sad face at such a time. It destroyed his own pleasure... The king therefore was angry... "Then," says Nehemiah, "I was very much afraid." And well he might have been. In such a mood, Artaxerxes might have sent him out to be executed at once. But though he was afraid, God kept him calm. Out of the fullness of his heart, God led him to tell the plain truth about why he was sad.
Nehemiah could have named Jerusalem in many ways. The words he chooses show what ties him to it.
George DavisonHe emphasises "the place of my fathers' graves"; he does not say the place of my fathers' achievements. One generation had followed another on God's own land. Nehemiah seems to say that this is the place where he ought to be, keeping up what they kept up when they were there.
The same phrase reads as warmth rather than argument. It is how a man speaks of home he has never seen.
J. G. BellettAlong with this exercise of his spirit towards God, Nehemiah's heart was alive to his brothers. In deep affection, and in that eloquence that comes fresh from the heart and its promptings, he calls Jerusalem "the city of his fathers' tombs." All this presents to us a very attractive person.
Nehemiah names two ruins: the waste city and the burnt gates. The second is not a small detail, and the enemy knew it.
H. L. RossierOur work does not consist only in raising up the wall: we must also work on the gates. The enemy knew very well what he was doing when he burned the gates of Jerusalem with fire. The gates of a city are just as important as the wall, and even more so. Gates can open to let the people of the city come and go. They can also shut out anything foreign, sinful, contagious or criminal that tries to settle inside the city.
The face Nehemiah was not allowed to wear opened the door. It answered the prayer he had prayed months before.
H. L. RossierNehemiah's prayer was answered after he had mourned for days — that is, about four months. Fasting and sorrow had left their mark on his face. No one was allowed to appear before the king with a sad face. But God used this very thing to put words into the king's mouth, and those words gave Nehemiah his chance to ask. Such miracles come in answer to our prayers. They are so much a part of daily Christian life that we hardly notice them.
Nehemiah could have enjoyed the palace and forgotten the ruin. One writer turns that choice on us.
William KellySuppose we satisfy ourselves only with the mercies the Lord shows us. That would be just like Nehemiah blessing God for what he enjoyed in the great king's palace. He would be content without a thought, without a care, without a tear and without a prayer for the people of God. But not so. Of everything on earth, his whole heart was set on them. He grieved because that people of God was now falling short of what was due to His glory here below.
- Prayer deepened it. Prayer did not lift Nehemiah's sadness. He grieved over the ruin of God's people, not over personal loss, so time with God only deepened it.
- Sadness cost him. A sad face in that court could have cost him his life. He told the plain truth anyway, and God kept him calm.
- Graves, not glory. He names Jerusalem by his fathers' graves, not their achievements. That is a man saying where he belongs and what he must keep up.
- Gates, not only walls. The enemy knew what he was doing when he burned the gates. A gate lets the city's own people come and go, and shuts out what would corrupt them.
- The face opened the door. The sad face the court forbade became God's way of putting words into the king's mouth. Such answers look so ordinary that we hardly notice the miracle.
And the king said to me, For what dost thou make request? So I prayed to the God of the heavens.
Nehemiah is cupbearer to the Persian king, and the king has just asked him to name what he wants. In the moment before he answers, he speaks to heaven first.
The king's question demanded an answer on the spot. One writer draws out where Nehemiah turned first:
William KellyHere is what I want to show — how truly it is a question of faith. "Then the king said to me, 'What are you requesting?'" What does he do? Does he make a request to the king? No, he makes his request to God. "So I prayed to the God of heaven." It is not that he does not tell the king. But even at that moment, in the presence of the king himself, his heart was toward the Lord. No wonder he got his request. No wonder God listened and heard, and he could take it as from Him. Why? Because he prayed to the Lord first.
Another writer follows that order in Nehemiah's own record.
F. B. HoleThe record is, first, "So I prayed to the God of heaven," and then, "I said to the king…" God first, and the king second. This silent prayer must have shot up to heaven in two or three seconds, quite unknown to the king or anybody else. Heaven answered it just as fast, so the request he made was the right one, and it met with a favourable answer.
The king was waiting, so the prayer had to fit a gap no one noticed.
William J. HockingHere we have a prayer offered in the interval between the king's question and Nehemiah's reply. It must have been brief. Eastern kings were not in the habit of waiting long for their cupbearers to answer them. But there was time enough for the prayer to rise and for help to come. The case was urgent and the relief was instant.
There is a reason the answer did not come straight away.
George DavisonWhen the king asks, "What are you requesting?", Nehemiah does not reply at once. He first lifts his heart to God, and God puts into his heart what he should say to the king. That is like what the Lord said: "And when they bring you before the synagogues and the rulers and the authorities, do not be anxious about how you should defend yourself or what you should say, for the Holy Spirit will teach you in that very hour what you ought to say" (Luke 12:11-12).
A prayer that quick shows what a man does when no one is watching.
Edward DennettMost would have hurried to answer the king. They would have concluded that since he had stooped to ask the question, he was bound to grant the favour. Not so Nehemiah, and this brings out a special trait in him. … Before he answered his master he cast himself upon his God. He acknowledges that he depends on God for wisdom to say the right thing. He shows the special mark that another has called "a heart that habitually turned to God." We might well seek the same grace… When this is the case, the presence of God will be more real to us than the presence of men.
The title Nehemiah uses fits his moment in history. One writer explains what had changed.
The Bible TreasuryGod gave up Judah to the Gentiles for turning away from Him, as He had given up Israel before. He pronounced the sentence of Lo-ammi (not my people). He then stopped acting as God of the earth, the Jehovah of His people. As "God of the heavens" He granted world rule for a time to the four Gentile empires that followed.
Standing before the most powerful man on earth, Nehemiah reaches for the name that says who is really in charge.
George DavisonWe have little idea today of the splendour and greatness of that monarchy, but it was not this visible greatness that filled Nehemiah's mind — it was the God of heaven. He recognised that however great and important the circumstances around him were, it was the heavens that rule, and he was in conscious touch with the God of heaven.
The king agreed. Nehemiah credits none of it to himself.
Hamilton SmithAt once Nehemiah recognises that the king's ready agreement was the result of the good hand of God. … We may remember to turn to God in our difficulties and forget to acknowledge His goodness when they are met. It is well to enter a difficulty in a spirit of prayer, and to come out of it in a spirit of praise.
- Order. Nehemiah prayed before he answered — God first, the king second. He got what he asked because he prayed to the Lord first.
- Speed. The prayer filled the gap between question and answer. There was time enough for it to rise and for help to come.
- Supply. Nehemiah did not answer out of his own wisdom; God put into his heart what to say to the king.
- Habit. A prayer that fast comes from a heart that habitually turns to God — and then God's presence is more real to us than the presence of men.
- Praise. He entered the difficulty praying and came out praising — turning to God in trouble, and thanking Him when it is over.
And I said to the king, If it please the king, and if thy servant have found favour in thy sight, that thou wouldest send me to Judah, to the city of my fathers' sepulchres, that I may build it.
Nehemiah has carried a burden for four months. Now the Persian king asks him what he wants, and everything hangs on the reply. The pause before he answers, and the words he chooses, are the heart of this verse.
Nehemiah does answer the king. But he speaks to God first, and one commentator makes that order the whole point.
William Kelly"The king said to me, 'What are you requesting?'" What does he do? Does he make his request to the king? No, he makes his request to God. "So I prayed to the God of heaven." It is not that he fails to tell the king. But even at that very moment, standing before the king himself, his heart was toward the Lord. No wonder he got his request. No wonder God listened and heard, and he could take it as from Him. Why? Because he prayed to the Lord first.
Nehemiah could not step away to pray. As the king's cupbearer he had to answer at once, and that is what makes the moment instructive.
William J HockingHere we have a prayer offered in the interval between the king's question and Nehemiah's reply. The interval must have been brief. Eastern kings were not in the habit of waiting long for their cupbearers to answer them. But there was time enough for the prayer to ascend and for help to come. The case was urgent and the relief was instantaneous.
He could have simply named Jerusalem. He described it instead by its graves — not by anything his fathers had achieved there.
George DavisonHe emphasizes "the place of my fathers' tombs"; he does not say the place of my fathers' achievements. Generation had followed generation on divine territory. Nehemiah seems to say that this is the place where he ought to be, keeping up what they kept up when they were there.
The description also differs from the language he had used in private. Alone with God he had confessed the family failure; in front of Artaxerxes he speaks of the land God had given.
George DavisonHe did not say to the king, the place where my fathers have sinned. Before the king he speaks of divine territory; before God he says, "Both I and my father's house have sinned."
His request is short and plain. Months of carrying it had made it clear.
George DavisonThe city was clearly before Nehemiah. He had carried this burden for months. Is it not interesting and challenging that, when challenged about it, he could speak of it so clearly? He knew exactly what he wanted. He was not vague about the concern he carried. He could put four months of that concern into one sentence and say what he desired.
His request also settles who should go, and it shows how he weighed up the king he was asking.
Leslie M. GrantNehemiah intended to act. He would not only pray and leave it there. He did not pray that God would send someone to Jerusalem to help the suffering remnant. Since he knew and felt the sorrow of their condition, he considered he was the man to go. Though Artaxerxes was king, Nehemiah considered him simply a man in whose heart God could work as easily as in any man.
The permission Nehemiah asked for here was not only a personal favour. One commentator dates the start of a prophetic period — the seventy weeks of Daniel — from the king's word here.
William J HockingThis decree applied to the building of the city and its defences (B.C. 445). In the twentieth year of his reign, Artaxerxes gave letters, or warrants, to Nehemiah, allowing him to build the city of his "fathers' tombs." In this "word" of the Persian king lay the appointed sign that the seventy weeks of Daniel were beginning.
The king agreed readily. Nehemiah credits that answer to God, not to his own skill with words.
Hamilton SmithAt once Nehemiah recognises that the ready compliance of the king was the result of the good hand of God. Before he asked, Nehemiah had turned to God. Now that the king has granted his request, he acknowledges the good hand of God. We may remember to turn to God in our difficulties and forget to acknowledge the goodness of God when they are met. It is well to enter a difficulty in a spirit of prayer, and to come out of it in a spirit of praise.
- Prayer first. The king asked; Nehemiah asked God before he asked the man in front of him. That order is why he could take the answer as from God.
- Prayer brief. The whole prayer fitted into the seconds between a question and its reply; urgent case, instant relief.
- Request definite. Four months of burden came out in one clear sentence: send me, to that city, to build it — no vagueness.
- Sender sent. He did not ask God to send someone else; feeling the sorrow himself, he counted himself the man to go.
- Praise last. The king's ready agreement was the good hand of God; enter the difficulty praying, come out of it praising.
And the king said to me -- the queen also sitting by him, -- For how long shall thy journey be, and when wilt thou return? And it pleased the king to send me; and I set him a time.
The king answers with the queen seated beside him. His reply turns Nehemiah's request into a settled plan with a date attached. Behind this short exchange lie four months of waiting and a prayer offered in the king's own presence. The leave he agreed to here would one day run out.
Nehemiah had prayed in Chislev; the king speaks in Nisan. Writers note that the gap was not wasted time but training.
Edward DennettFour months had passed since he had offered the prayer recorded in Nehemiah 1. He is careful to give us the dates. In the month Chislev, which is our November, he had prayed. In the month Nisan, our March, the answer came. During this period, man of faith as he was, he must have waited in daily expectation upon God. He could not foresee how the answer would come; but he knew that God could intervene when and how He would... It is in this way God both tries and strengthens the faith of His people. He waits while they wait. But if He waits, it is only to shut His people up to fuller dependence on Himself. So He prepares their hearts for the blessing He is about to give. And when He steps in, it is often, as in this case, in such a quiet and unseen way — unseen by all but the eye of faith — that it takes faith to detect His presence.
Asked what he wanted, Nehemiah turned to God before he answered the king. Writers trace the granted request back to that order.
William KellyWhat does he do? Does he make a request to the king? No, he makes request to God. "So I prayed to the God of heaven." He does tell the king. But at that very moment, in the king's own presence, his heart was toward the Lord. No wonder he got his request. No wonder that God listened and heard, and he could take it as from Him. Why? Because he prayed to the Lord first.
Why did the king agree? The record never tells us what was in his mind, and one writer treats that silence as the point.
F. B. HoleWhat moved the king's mind is hidden from us. It is hidden so that we may see more clearly that, whatever it was, the power of God controlled him, in answer to Nehemiah's brief and sudden prayer.
The king's yes opened a door. Nehemiah walked through it with an exact list of what he needed.
Edward DennettThe queen was sitting with the king at that moment. The king asked how long Nehemiah planned to be away, and then granted his request at once. Nehemiah saw his opportunity — the opportunity God had given him. Strengthened by his faith, he grew bolder and dared to ask for royal letters... His aims were exact and clear: to restore the fortress that protected the temple, to rebuild the city walls, and to build a house fit for his own office.
The king wanted his servant back, and Nehemiah named a date. What that date was, the book never tells us.
Leslie M. GrantThe king made no objection. But he asked how long Nehemiah would need for the work, because he wanted him back. Nehemiah set him a time. We are not told what it was, and Nehemiah records nothing about his later return to Shushan. The wall was rebuilt in the short space of 52 days, however (ch. 6:15).
The agreed limit held. At the end of the book, evil crept into the temple rooms while Nehemiah was away with the king and not there to stop it.
H. L. RossierNehemiah had to return to put an end to this misuse of holy things. While these things were going on, he was with the king at Shushan, because his leave of absence had expired. But when he returned, a situation like this could not escape him. Although everyone else tolerated it, Nehemiah could not.
Nehemiah prayed his way into this meeting. He came out of it with a date and letters, and gave God the credit.
Hamilton SmithAt once Nehemiah recognises that the ready compliance of the king was the result of the good hand of God... We may remember to turn to God in our difficulties and forget to acknowledge the goodness of God when He meets them. It is well to enter a difficulty in a spirit of prayer, and to come out of it in a spirit of praise.
- Waited — Four months lie between the prayer of chapter 1 and this answer. God waits while His people wait, to deepen their dependence before He gives the blessing.
- Prayed — Nehemiah spoke to the God of heaven before he spoke to the king. That order explains the answer he got.
- Granted — The reasons in the king's mind stay hidden on purpose. That silence points us to the power of God behind his decision.
- Timed — Nehemiah took a leave with an end date. When it ran out he went back, and it was his absence that let evil creep into the temple rooms.
- Praised — He went into the difficulty praying and came out of it owning the good hand of God. That second half is the part we forget once the answer comes.
And I said to the king, If it please the king, let letters be given me to the governors beyond the river, that they may set me forward till I come into Judah;
The king of Persia has asked Nehemiah what he wants. Nehemiah prays a quick prayer, asks leave to go, and then asks for something practical: written permission to cross the provinces on the way.
Nehemiah asks for letters to the governors "Beyond the River". Which river, and why did those officials matter?
F. B. HoleThe king invited Nehemiah to make a request, and he asked respectfully to be allowed to go to Jerusalem with the king's authority to rebuild it. That authority would come in letters — one to Asaph, the keeper of the king's forest, and others to the governors beyond the river. The river here is almost certainly the Euphrates, so these governors ruled the lands toward Palestine. We are not told what moved the king's mind. That silence lets us see more clearly that, whatever the reasons were, it was the power of God that controlled him, in answer to Nehemiah's short and sudden prayer.
Nehemiah asked for one thing, then saw his chance and asked for more.
Edward DennettNehemiah saw his opportunity — the opportunity God had given him — and his faith made him bolder. He dared to ask for royal letters "to the governors of the province Beyond the River, that they may let me pass through until I come to Judah"… His aims were exact and clearly defined: to restore the fortress that protected the temple, to rebuild the city walls, and to build a house suitable for himself as he carried out his duties.
Everything Nehemiah asked for was in the king's power to give. But was the asking itself right?
George DavisonThe answer to this question comes at the end of verse eight: "And the king granted me what I asked, for the good hand of my God was upon me." The request was in line with God's wisdom. The resources were in the king's hand, but God was behind it all.
Commentators differ over this request. Years earlier Ezra made the same journey and refused an armed escort. Some writers read Nehemiah's letters as a step down from that.
Edward DennettWhen Nehemiah made the same journey some years later, captains of the army and horsemen went with him. His faith was not as active, though his heart was truly set on the Lord's interests. How much better to trust in the Lord than in a strength you can see!
Others weigh the same difference and reach the opposite conclusion.
H. L. RossierNotice an important difference between Ezra and Nehemiah, one that still puts no blame on Nehemiah. In Ezra, faith alone is at work. He was "ashamed to ask the king for a band of soldiers and horsemen to protect us against the enemy on our way" (Ezra 8:22). Nehemiah, by contrast, puts himself under the protection of the governors on the other side of the river… He leans on the power he serves, not because he lacks faith, but because in such low times faith no longer shows itself with the same simplicity… Nehemiah was alone, and his mission would not begin until he reached Jerusalem. Until then he had to recognise and accept that he depended on the Gentile power.
Later, enemies mocked the work and accused Nehemiah of rebellion. He had the king's letters in hand. Watch what he reaches for instead.
George DavisonWhen "Sanballat the Horonite, and Tobiah the servant, the Ammonite, and Geshem the Arabian" said with scorn, "What is this thing that you are doing? Are you rebelling against the king?", the striking thing is that Nehemiah does not fall back on the king's authority. He falls back on God Himself. He could have said, "See these letters I have from the king." Instead he said, "The God of heaven will make us prosper, and we His servants will arise and build."
- Pray, then plan. The quick prayer came first. The detailed request followed, and grew bolder as God opened the door.
- Plan in detail. Nehemiah knew exactly what he needed — safe passage, timber, walls, a house — not just a vague wish for help.
- Permission is God's work. The letters lay in the king's power to give, but God was behind it all, controlling the king's mind.
- Protection divides opinion. Some writers see weaker faith here than in Ezra, who refused an escort. Others see a man accepting the dependence his position forced on him.
- Point to God, not paperwork. Nehemiah held royal letters, but he answered his enemies with God.
and a letter to Asaph the keeper of the king's forest, that he may give me timber to make beams for the gates of the palace which [appertains] to the house, and for the wall of the city, and for the house that I shall enter into. And the king granted me, according to the good hand of my God upon me.
The Persian king has just asked Nehemiah what he wants. Instead of a small favour, he asks for state letters, safe passage, and timber from the royal forest. The verse ends by tracing the whole success of that request to a source outside the palace entirely.
Nehemiah had prayed before he answered the king. When the king agreed to send him, he asked for more. One writer traces his growing courage and the exactness of what he asked for.
Edward DennettNehemiah saw his opportunity — the opportunity God had given him. Strengthened by his faith, he grew bolder, and dared to ask for royal letters to the governors beyond the river... and a letter to Asaph the keeper of the king's forest. His aims were precise and clear: to restore the fortress that protected the temple, to rebuild the walls of the city, and to build a house fit for himself in his office... Before God he had poured out the desires of his heart — desires which God Himself had produced. He had looked to God for guidance and strength while he stood in front of the king. Now God showed that He had taken up His servant's cause.
The building named in the verse is not a royal home. The same writer explains the word and where the structure stood.
Edward DennettIt seems that the more exact translation of this word would be "fortress". This may have been the well-known fortress connected with the temple. Under Roman rule it was later called the tower of Antonia.
Commentators differ over the building. These writers use an older translation, which reads "palace" where the ESV has "the fortress of the temple". One writer takes the three things Nehemiah names as public life, worship, and the protection of both.
George DavisonThe palace would perhaps refer to what we would call the Town Hall. The house, of course, was the place of worship. The walls would safeguard both.
The first use he names for the timber is gates. That priority has a precedent.
George DavisonIn verse 8 Nehemiah says, "That he may give me timber to make beams for the gates of the palace". David lived in a very different day from this. When he was collecting material for the house of God, the first thing he had in mind was the doors. "Nails for the doors of the house". It seems to be an important point that the gates, or doors, should be set up in their right position.
The forest and the letters were the king's. Nehemiah's closing words look past all of that.
George DavisonThere is much detail between the two statements "I prayed to the God of heaven" and "The king granted me, according to the good hand of my God upon me". Nehemiah recognized where his resources were. He also recognized that God, in His sovereignty, used the secular power to give them to him. Nehemiah did not ask for them from the secular power, he asked of God, and he recognized that they came from God.
That acknowledgement after the fact is as telling as the prayer before it.
Hamilton SmithBefore he asked, Nehemiah had turned to God. Now that the king has granted his request, he acknowledges the good hand of God. We may remember to turn to God in our difficulties, and forget to acknowledge the goodness of God once He has met them. It is well to enter a difficulty in a spirit of prayer, and to come out of it in a spirit of praise.
One writer draws a wider principle from the way this door opened.
Edward DennettIf He puts within our hearts a desire for any service — a service for His glory — He will surely open the way to it before us. If our minds are really set on His work, He will enable us to do it in His own way and time. The door may seem closed and barred; but if we wait on Him "who opens and no one shuts," we will find that it suddenly opens to us.
Ezra the priest and Nehemiah the court official were not equal in understanding. Yet the phrase at the end of this verse belongs to both men.
F. B. HoleNehemiah was an official in the king's court. He clearly did not have the spiritual education and understanding that Ezra had as a priest, devoted to the law of his God. Yet both could speak in the same way of "the good hand of my God upon me." If the heart is right, God will guide and support His servant, whatever the measure of his intelligence and faith.
- Prayed: Nehemiah asked God before he asked the king; the desires he poured out were desires God had first produced in him.
- Precise: He knew what he wanted — the fortress guarding the temple, the city wall, a house for his office — and asked for the timber to build it.
- Granted: The forest and the letters were the king's. Nehemiah did not ask the secular power for them. He asked God, and traced them back to God.
- Opened: Where God puts a desire for His work in a heart, He opens the barred door in His own way and time.
- Shared: Ezra had greater understanding, Nehemiah less, yet both could say the same thing — the good hand of my God was upon me.