for then shall there be great tribulation, such as has not been from [the] beginning of [the] world until now, nor ever shall be;
Jesus is describing the time of the end, and here He reaches its darkest point. A trouble is coming that no earlier age has matched and none after it will. That raises three questions: what starts it, who goes through it, and where does it leave us?
The word "then" ties this trouble to a sign given a few verses earlier. That sign warns one particular group to run.
F. B. HoleAt the time of the end, the abomination of desolation that Daniel 12:11 speaks of will stand in the holy place. Jerusalem is in question, as verse 16 shows... The setting up of this abomination will be the signal to the godly that the great tribulation He foretold has begun. Their safety lies in fleeing from Jerusalem and Judaea, where the suffering will be fiercest... The Lord was speaking to His disciples, who at that moment were godly Israelites gathered around their Messiah on earth. So at that moment they represented the godly remnant of Israel, not the church.
Daniel had already described a time of trouble like no other. The Lord quotes him and adds something Daniel never said.
The Bible TreasuryWhen the Lord quotes Scripture, He gives further light... So here the Lord goes beyond Daniel by adding "and never will be." It will never be repeated. It will be the most trying experience any nation has ever had. There is that idolatry, and they will be forced to take the mark of the beast either openly or secretly. Publicly or privately, they must own it, or else be put to death and cut off from every privilege of society.
History has no shortage of atrocities. What makes this one unmatched is not the scale of human cruelty but who is acting.
F. B. HoleNothing has ever matched the great tribulation, and nothing will ever equal it, let alone go beyond it. The Lord says this in verse 21. The reason, as the book of Revelation shows, is that heaven will send down wrath at that time — the pouring out of the bowls of judgment. It will not just be men afflicting men, or one nation punishing others, as we see so plainly today. It will be God punishing the nations as He settles His accounts with them.
Many read this verse as already fulfilled when the Roman general Titus destroyed Jerusalem. Commentators here say the timing rules that out. Look at what follows the tribulation, and at what comes before it.
Hamilton SmithThe destruction of Jerusalem, with all its horrors, may have foreshadowed the future, but in no way fulfils the prophecy of this time of trouble. This passage tells us that right after the great tribulation the Lord will come to earth. Yet after the destruction of Jerusalem He plainly did not come. Moreover, there cannot be two times of tribulation "such as never were."
J. N. DarbyNote too that the tribulation comes after the setting up of the abomination of desolation. If you apply it to Titus and the destruction of Jerusalem and the temple, then setting it up closed the tribulation.
Four passages of Scripture describe this period. They show where its weight falls and how long it lasts.
J. N. DarbyTwo passages in the prophets (Jer. 30:7 and Dan. 12:1), as well as two passages in the gospels (Matt. 24:21 and Mark 13:19), tell us of this great tribulation. There we notice that it will fall chiefly on the Jews, though the Gentiles may also suffer from it... The tribulation will take place during the second half of the last week mentioned in the book of Daniel (chap. 9), and will last until the Lord's appearing.
If this hour is coming on the whole world, no hiding place on earth is enough. The promise held out to believers is of another kind.
William Kelly"Because you have kept the word of My patience, I also will keep you (not during, but) out of the hour of trial that is about to come upon the whole habitable earth, to try those who dwell upon the earth."... The refuge is not just a matter of place, because that hour of trial will fall on the whole habitable world. The heavenly saints will be caught up before that crisis comes. That crisis repays the lawlessness of the Jews and the Gentiles. It is a wholly different trouble from the one that falls to us as Christians.
Those days are cut short for the sake of the elect. What that rescues is life on earth, not the soul.
William KellyAll this is plain enough. It is not a question of the soul but of the salvation of the body. They will then live and be the subjects of the blessed reign and glory when the Lord comes. It is earthly glory here, not in heaven. For the sake of the elect those days will be shortened.
- Signal. The word "then" is not vague. An idol set up in the holy place starts the clock, and the godly are told to run.
- Severity. Daniel said nothing had ever equalled it; the Lord adds that nothing ever will. It happens once and is never repeated.
- Source. What makes it unmatched is not men afflicting men but God settling His accounts with the nations.
- Sphere. It falls chiefly on the Jews, centred on Jerusalem and Judaea, and it runs until the Lord appears.
- Shelter. The hour covers the whole earth, so the promise is not a safer place inside it. The heavenly saints are caught up before it comes.
and if those days had not been cut short, no flesh had been saved; but on account of the elect those days shall be cut short.
These words fall at the darkest point of the Lord's picture of the future. Human life itself is at stake, and two questions decide the meaning: what "saved" means here, and who the elect are.
Commentators place these days in the last part of Daniel's prophecy of seventy weeks. The older translation they use reads "shortened" and "no flesh," where the ESV has "cut short" and "no human being."
Samuel RidoutThe last week of the seventy predicted in Daniel (9:24–27) is divided into two parts. Only the second half is the time of the great tribulation. Then the suffering is so great that unless the days had been shortened no flesh could be saved (Matt. 24:22). In connection with this passage, one writer finds that the appearing of the Son of Man follows "immediately after the tribulation of those days."
Does this describe the Roman capture of Jerusalem? One commentator allows a partial early fulfilment there, but points further:
J. N. DarbyHere the Lord's mind rests on the great fulfilment. There may be a partial early fulfilment in the capture of Jerusalem by the Romans, which Scripture does not record as history. But the mind of the Spirit rests clearly on the great final catastrophe of God's house and people and city.
The threat is deliberate extermination, aimed at everyone who takes a stand for God:
W. W. FeredayAll the might of the Roman Empire, energised by the Dragon, will be used to wipe out everyone who dares to make a stand for God. The godless mass of people in Judea will be in full sympathy with the persecutors.
The danger is not only from outside. One writer hears in these words a verdict on the people's own hearts:
J. N. DarbyThis is a remarkable statement even about the evil of their own hearts. The spirit of death and evil is among them. They would destroy themselves, and this has been seen in Jerusalem and elsewhere. It comes from within and from without; but for the sake of the elect, who were to be spared in the flesh, those days were shortened.
"Saved" here is not the rescue of souls from sin. It means staying alive on earth:
J. G. BellettI confess this is the strongest indication to me that the Lord was not thinking of His heavenly people but of His earthly people. Later He speaks through His Spirit in the apostles about His heavenly ones. There He tells us plainly that the saving of the flesh was, and could be, of no importance. The reason is that flesh and blood can never inherit heaven. Saved flesh must be for the inheritance of the earth. The elect of this verse are, I am sure, the Lord's earthly remnant.
That reading also guards the verse from being turned into a rule about how a sinner is forgiven:
F. B. HoleThese words come in the course of His prophetic teaching recorded in Matthew 24 and Mark 13. They do not refer to the way sinful men may receive the salvation of their souls. The Lord was not addressing sinners but men already brought into relationship with Himself — His disciples.
Commentators take the "elect" to be a chosen group among the Jews. God's own choice marks them out, and a testimony from Him brings them to light:
J. T. MawsonThat tribulation will beat harder on the Jews than on any other people. Yet in the middle of it the Lord will have His elect, and for their sake the days will be shortened (v. 22)… They are elect, which means the sovereign mercy of God has chosen them. But how will they be distinguished from the rest of the rebellious people? God's way has always been to bring such people to light by a testimony from Himself.
Shortening does not mean trimming hours off a calendar day. It means God fixes a limit on evil that would otherwise run on and on:
J. N. DarbyI understand the shortening of the days to mean that they are held strictly to the 1260 days. Man's will and passions would otherwise carry them on without end. But the Lord would come as a thief in the night and close it all.
The same God who has been unhurried in mercy will be swift in judgment, and both reveal His goodness:
F. B. HoleToday God is dispensing mercy through the gospel. He has made a very long work of it, stretching over nineteen centuries. When He dispenses wrath He will make swift work, cutting it short in righteousness. A brief three and a half years will cover it, as other scriptures show. So the goodness of God will be shown both in mercy and in wrath.
- When — the days are the second half of Daniel's seventieth week. The Son of Man appears right after them.
- Why — attack from outside and evil from within would leave no one alive.
- For whom — for the elect, a remnant chosen by God's sovereign mercy and brought to light by His own testimony.
- How far — not a trimmed day, but evil held to a fixed limit. Man's will would run on without end.
- What is saved — flesh, life on earth, not the soul. The verse is about survival, not about how a sinner is forgiven.