Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, for ye make clean the outside of the cup and of the dish, but within they are full of rapine and intemperance.
The Lord is partway through a series of "woes" spoken over the religious leaders of Israel. Here He picks a picture from an ordinary kitchen. A cup is scrubbed on the outside while what is inside stays foul. Can a life kept clean for public view ever satisfy the God who sees inside it?
Two words carry the charge: "greed and self-indulgence" (older translations read "extortion and excess"). One appetite reaches for what belongs to other people. The other reaches for its own pleasure. A spotless religious surface hid both.
The fifth woe rebukes the Pharisees for a purity that was only on the outside. They kept the correct forms of religion, while inside they were full of extortion and excess. They dealt dishonestly with others and gave themselves to lustful self-indulgence. So He tells them to clean the inside of the cup and dish first, since that matters most. Then He adds, "that the outside also may be clean." He does not mean that washing the inside of a cup makes its outside clean. He means that a clean outside follows when a person cleanses his inner motives. True spiritual cleansing inside will have a proper result outside.
The problem was not one bad habit. It ran through the whole system these men had built.
Whatever they claimed, their religion was a religion of the outside. Far from being clean, they were full of plunder and wickedness — they plundered others and were wicked themselves… They had forgotten Him. They cared only about what men could see. The Lord looks upon the heart. They did not think of this. Unbelief is always blind. Where things differ in importance, it fixes on the least important. The reason is clear: it seeks the praise of men and not that of God.
The clean outside was not just a failure to deal with the inside. It worked in the inside's favour.
They cleansed the cup and dish on the outside. Inside they could keep them full of plunder and indulgence. With a correct outside, they kept the lusts within and approved them.
A well-kept surface can satisfy an audience. The question is what God makes of it.
Is this going to satisfy God? He is not deceived. It deeply offends God when someone indulges evil in the heart and keeps a fair exterior. There is no real happiness apart from holiness… But we need to be holy inside. The word of God is our standard for judging everything… If the word of Christ lives in us richly, we should be quick to judge an evil thought. Believers know so little of spiritual joy because they leave these things unjudged.
This habit is not limited to one group. It grows where inward life is fading.
A soul that has drifted from God often keeps up the outward forms of religion, sometimes with even more zeal. As life decays, attention turns to rites and ceremonies. The soul deceives itself this way and slides into ignorance of its real condition. It loses all sense of its relationship with God and leans on performing the required ceremonies exactly. The Pharisees, for example, took great care to clean the outside of the cup and the dish. They were completely indifferent about being cleansed inside.
Behind the habit sits a hope: that a clean surface will make the heart clean, and that God will accept the result.
He hopes that cleaning the outside of the cup will make the inside clean. He wants to be "not like other men," to stand out by some superior religiousness and good works, and by these things make himself acceptable to God.
The rules the Pharisees loved could reach the rim of a cup and no further.
In the law there were many ceremonial defilements, each with its appointed purification. The scribes and Pharisees added more, such as washing the hands before eating, and washing cups and plates (Mark 7:2-8). They were very zealous about these things, while inside they were full of extortion and excess. In Christianity the purification required extends further: to the heart (Acts 15:9; James 4:8), to the soul (1 Peter 1:22), and to the conscience through the blood of Christ (Hebrews 9:14).
- Outside — They kept the correct forms of religion. The clean surface covered dishonest dealing with others and self-indulgence.
- Inside — The clean surface did more than leave the evil alone. It kept the lusts within and approved them.
- Deceived — Appearances satisfy onlookers. God is not deceived, and a fair exterior over an indulged heart offends Him.
- Decay — Zeal for forms rises as inward life falls. The soul then slides into ignorance of its true condition.
- Cleansed — The Lord's order is inside first. Real cleansing reaches heart, soul and conscience through the blood of Christ, and then shows on the outside.
Blind Pharisee, make clean first the inside of the cup and of the dish, that their outside also may become clean.
The fifth of the Lord's woes ends not with an accusation but with an instruction: start at the other end. He calls the man blind, tells him what to clean first, and adds a promise: deal with the inside, and the outside will follow.
The Pharisees were not careless. Their care ran the wrong way, and the Lord turns the order around.
The fifth woe condemns the outward purity the Pharisees put on. They kept up correct, formal religion, while inside they were full of extortion and excess — dishonest dealings with others, and lustful self-indulgence. So He tells them to clean the inside of the cup and plate first, which is by far the most important; but He adds, "that the outside also may be clean." He does not mean that literally washing the inside of a cup will make the outside clean. He means that a clean outside follows when a person cleanses his inner motives. True spiritual cleansing inwardly will have a proper outward result.
Cleaning only the outside of a vessel is not just incomplete work. It protects what is inside from any real change.
They cleaned the cup and dish on the outside; inside they could keep them full of plunder and self-indulgence. With a correct outside, they held on to the lusts within and approved them.
The concern behind it is how a man looks to others.
Next He exposes their effort to look right on the outside, whatever the impurity within. This showed in their work, and in their own lives and persons, which were full of deceit and self-will.
Washing the rim of a cup does nothing to the water it holds. The same holds in a person: the outside only shows what the heart is already producing.
The Pharisees made the outside of the cup and plate clean, but that did not cleanse the inside. What comes from within is what defiles a man. The stream was bitter because the fountain was bitter; and the fruit was bad because the tree was bad. The fountain of a man's defilement lies in his own heart. Going through a religious ritual could be of no value. Doing that alone only made men hypocrites. The Pharisees could wear an appearance of holiness and goodness like an outer garment — and they had — while the seat of the disease stayed untouched.
A clean outside may satisfy onlookers. God is another matter.
Is this going to satisfy God? He is not deceived. Giving in to evil in the heart while keeping a fair outside offends God deeply. There is no real happiness apart from holiness. God was living among them, so He required holiness. But we need to be holy inside, and we have the word of God as our standard to judge everything by.
Since the trouble is inside, the cure cannot be a change of clothes.
The cleansing is not an outward change, as a Pharisee might cover the blackest of hearts with a white robe and blue fringe; but an inward work that truly judges evil and forms new desires. The man must be born again.
Where faith is real, the cleansing reaches both sides of the vessel. That is the promise in the second half of the verse.
This faith cleanses within; it makes the inside of the cup and plate clean. It also beautifies the outside; it makes the outward conduct and the inner motive clean. So the man, if his faith is true and real, becomes from then on a different man from what he was before.
A dish exists to be used. That is where this lands for the reader today.
You and I — and we want to make this practical — would rather drink from a clean penny clay mug than from a filthy gold goblet covered with diamonds. So we get in 2 Timothy 2, "If anyone cleanses himself from what is dishonorable, he will be a vessel... useful to the master of the house." There is something very blessed in this. I, a poor weak thing, yet He will stoop to use me if I am clean!
- Blindness. The Pharisees kept the outside correct while they held on to the lusts within. It was a double life, with the polished surface guarding the filth it hid.
- Fountain. Scrubbing the rim never reached the water. The stream was bitter because the fountain was bitter, and outward religion left the seat of the disease untouched.
- First. The Lord's word "first" turns the order around. Cleanse the inner motives, and a proper outward result follows.
- Inside. That inner cleansing is not a white robe over a black heart. It is an inward work that judges evil and forms new desires. The man must be born again.
- Useful. A clean penny mug beats a filthy jewelled goblet: the clean vessel is the one the Master will use.