Mark 15:42–47

Mark 15:42 · Darby

And when it was already evening, since it was [the] preparation, that is, [the day] before a sabbath,

Mark stops the story to name the day. That short note explains the rush in everything that follows. It also raises two questions: what was the day preparing for, and why did a man who had stayed silent now step forward?

The name of the day

The day was a Friday. What the "preparation" was for is another question.

All four Gospel writers fix the day of the Crucifixion as a Friday, and the tradition recorded in the Talmud agrees. Wellhausen at Mark 15:42 renders paraskeuē as "Friday," in line with old Syriac and also modern Greek. This leads us to ask what the "preparation" was for. Westcott and others have answered, for the Passover in the narrow sense of the word. But Purves holds that it was for the Sabbath, so that "preparation of the Passover" would stand for "the preparation in Passover week."

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Working against the clock

The sabbath began at sunset. That left only hours between the death and the burial.

Remember that our blessed Lord was crucified on the Friday, and that the sabbath began at sunset that same evening. If the ninth hour was three o'clock in the afternoon, Joseph must have acted fast. He had to get Pilate's permission, take the body of Jesus down from the cross, and prepare it for burial, all to finish the entombment before the sabbath began.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

The man the cross made brave

Everything about that hour should have frightened Joseph into silence. It did the reverse.

The disciples were not there. They, sadly, left Him and fled; at any rate, they are not mentioned. They were so far out of their true place that God could say nothing about them. Yet one who up to this time had held back from openly confessing Jesus was now brought forward... God used the very circumstances that might have been expected to fill him with fear and make him shrink from the consequences. Instead they brought out a boldness that had never visited Joseph's heart before. He identified himself with Jesus. He did not have the precious place of following Him while He was alive. But the death of Jesus brought him to a decision. It took hold of his affections and so made him come forward with courage and ask for the body of his Master.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

God's care for the body

Isaiah had foretold His burial place, and there was a reason it could not be a criminal's grave.

"They made His grave with the wicked and with a rich man in His death." So Isaiah had predicted long before, and now we have the fulfilment of it. A death on the cross would normally end in the criminal's grave. That grave could not be His. He had finished the substitutionary work that alone had made Him to be numbered with transgressors. In that character He could appear no more. The righteousness of God, which He had declared in His death, now claimed divine intervention on His behalf. While He still slept He must sleep in honour. As it has been well said, only a virgin tomb could rightly honour the One born of a virgin womb.

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

What the day was preparing for

The day was preparing for more than one week's sabbath.

The preparation day, then, began on the Thursday evening at sunset and lasted until Friday evening sunset. But what was it the preparation for? It was God's preparation day for man — poor, lost, guilty man — to bring him into eternal rest with Himself: the eternal sabbath based on redemption... The sabbath, or rest of creation, had long been lost. Now God set out the sabbath of redemption. It can never be lost while God is faithful to the claims of the redemption-blood of His Lamb.

Modernised from C. StanleyOriginal wording

Then came the sabbath itself. Look at where the Lord spent it.

Christ had no Sabbath at all while He was on this earth. True, He finished His work — finished it gloriously — but where did He spend the Sabbath day? In the tomb! Yes, this was the Lord Christ, God revealed in flesh, the Lord of the Sabbath, the Maker and Sustainer of heaven and earth. He spent the seventh day in the dark and silent tomb. Has this nothing to say to us? ... The grave of Jesus gives us all the proof we need: no one could keep a Sabbath.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Preparation. The verse names the day before the sabbath — Friday. Writers differ over whether "preparation" looked to the Passover or to the sabbath.

- Pressure. Sunset ended the day. Joseph had only hours to reach Pilate and finish the burial.

- Boldness. The death that scattered the disciples brought a hidden believer into the open. The cross drew out of Joseph a courage he had never shown.

- Honour. He did not get the criminal's grave. Isaiah had said He would be buried with a rich man, and He was — in a tomb never used.

- Rest. The whole day prepared a rest man could not lose. Meanwhile the Lord of the sabbath spent that sabbath in the tomb — proof that the old rest was gone and the new one rests on redemption.

Mark 15:43 · Darby

Joseph of Arimathaea, an honourable councillor, who also himself was awaiting the kingdom of God, coming, emboldened himself and went in to Pilate and begged the body of Jesus.

Mark names the man who steps forward after Jesus' disciples have fled: a rich, respected member of the Sanhedrin, Israel's ruling council, who had kept his faith secret. The verse turns on two things — what he was waiting for, and where he found the nerve to ask a Roman governor for the body of an executed man.

Who Joseph was

The word translated "counsellor" is not a vague compliment. It marks his office.

Joseph is spoken of as an "honourable counsellor" — that is, a member of the Sanhedrin, who was waiting for the kingdom of God. He went in "boldly" to Pilate, who wonders that the Lord is dead, and first asks the centurion, as would be natural for a Roman, if such is the case.

Modernised from Samuel RidoutOriginal wording

Each Gospel writer adds a different line to his portrait, and put together they explain both his long silence and his sudden move.

All four Gospels mention him, and each gives us some special detail about him. Matthew tells us that he was rich and a disciple. Mark calls him an honourable counsellor who waited for the kingdom of God. Luke says he was a good and just man, who had not agreed with the plan and the act of the great majority of the Sanhedrin in putting Jesus to death. John admits that he was a disciple, but a secret one for fear of the Jews… Yet, wonderful to say, in this darkest hour, when everything seemed hopelessly lost, Joseph found his courage. He went to Pilate to ask for the body of Jesus.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Where his courage came from

The death of Jesus is what produced his courage.

You would expect these circumstances to fill him with fear and make him shrink from the consequences. Instead God used them to bring out a boldness that had never visited Joseph's heart before. He identified himself with Jesus. He did not have the precious place of following Him while He was alive. But the death of Jesus brought him to a decision and took command of his affections. So he went in courageously and demanded the body of his Master.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The exact reverse of the disciples

His timing is the opposite of everyone else's in the story, and that is what makes his faith worth copying.

He missed the chance to be identified with Christ in His life, but he did identify himself with Him when He was dead. This is remarkable, for it is the exact reverse of what the disciples did. They stood with Him during His life, and failed badly when He died. The apparent defeat of Jesus had the effect of emboldening Joseph. It stirred the smouldering embers of his faith into a sudden blaze. He was "looking for the kingdom of God." We may be sure that in the day of the kingdom God will not forget Joseph's faith and works. His faith is just the sort we need today — the sort that blazes up when defeat seems sure.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

What the request cost him

His rank made this confession harder, not easier.

Then came Joseph, and he was an honourable man and a counsellor. If he had thought about his reputation among his fellows, he would have stayed at home that day. But he drops all thought of self. The secrecy of his discipleship must end — and at the very time we would have expected him to hide it most. If the Lord had come down from the cross when the priests challenged Him, Joseph might have been bold and said, "I knew all the time who He was." Instead he steps out when Christ hangs dead and seems utterly defeated, and when Peter and the other disciples have forsaken Him and fled. This nobleman comes forward and asks for His body.

Modernised from J. T. MawsonOriginal wording

God's man, held in reserve

God had prepared him in advance, and Isaiah's word about the grave came true.

God had His servant ready for the great honour of taking the body of the Lord Jesus to its burial… Now he openly identifies himself with Christ rejected and crucified! Precious energy of faith! This was clearly God's work in his soul. Though men had appointed Christ's grave with the wicked, this was not to be so: He was with the rich in His death (Isa. 53:9).

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

That single act is the whole of what Scripture tells us about him.

God always has the needed man for His work. Joseph was born into the world to fulfil that one line of Scripture! That one act covers all that we know of Joseph. In doing it he served the will of God.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Summary

- Waiting — Joseph sat on the council and had long been looking for the kingdom of God. His hope was real before it was public.

- Wakened — the cross scattered everyone else. It stirred the smouldering embers of his faith into a sudden blaze.

- Bold — God used the very things that should have frightened him to bring out a boldness he had never known.

- Costly — thinking of his reputation would have kept him home. Instead he asked for the body after Peter and the rest had fled.

- Placed — men appointed Christ's grave with the wicked. Through the man God kept in reserve, He was with the rich in His death.

Mark 15:44 · Darby

And Pilate wondered if he were already dead; and having called to [him] the centurion, he inquired of him if he had long died.

Joseph of Arimathea asks Pilate for the body of Jesus, and Pilate is surprised: the man crucified only hours ago is already dead. Mark alone records what the governor did next — he called for the officer in charge to confirm the death.

Why Pilate Was Surprised

Pilate had good reason to doubt. Crucifixion killed slowly, and the two men crucified beside Jesus were still alive.

The burial now followed. Joseph, a rich man of Judea (Luke 23:51), was one of the Sanhedrin and a disciple of the Lord Jesus. He went to Pilate and asked for the body. Had He died so soon? The thieves were still alive. Death by crucifixion, though cruel, was generally slow. Pilate wondered if He was already dead. He did not know that in the counsel of God our Lord would lay down His life Himself, no man taking it from Him (John 10:18). He called for the centurion, as Mark alone has noticed, and asked if He had been dead for some time. Then he granted the body to Joseph.

Modernised from C. E. StuartOriginal wording

The Sanhedrin was the Jewish ruling council, and Joseph sat on it. William Kelly gives the usual timescale:

Pilate, astonished, asks if Jesus was already dead. Crucifixion is naturally a slow death. A person in ordinary health sometimes lingers even for days. But in the case of Jesus it was only a few hours.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

What the Surprise Proves

What Pilate could not explain, Scripture is careful to state. Jesus did not die because the cross wore Him out.

Notice how carefully Scripture rules out the thought that His death was the result of anything from outside, including the crucifixion. Crucifixion truly went with His death, but it was only that, and not its cause. For we read that they came to Him meaning to hasten His death by breaking His legs. They found Him already dead, but not the two criminals (John 19:31-33). And so Pilate wondered if He was already dead (Mark 15:44). No! He laid down His life Himself, as He had said (John 10:17-18). With a loud voice He cried, "It is finished," and He gave up His spirit, saying, "Father, into Your hands I commit My spirit."

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

His last cry carries the same message.

No exhaustion under suffering, no pressure of the cross, led Him to death; but He yielded up His life of Himself. As a sign that He was in full possession of what He was giving up, "He cried with a loud voice," and then gave up His spirit.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

A Prophecy Kept

Because Jesus died early, the soldiers had no reason to break His legs as they broke the others'. The timing that puzzled Pilate kept a written word intact.

Yet He did not die by the death of the cross, though He died upon the cross. His suffering was cut short before the usual time. One reason among others was this: the Scripture had to be fulfilled, "Not one of his bones will be broken."

Modernised from G. V. WigramOriginal wording

Pilate Demands a Witness

Pilate does not take Joseph's word, or his own impression. He sends for the officer who had charge of the crucifixion.

Pilate was amazed that He was dead already. He would not believe it; he had to satisfy himself about it. He had not spent long enough on the cross for it to drain His life away. That is why the legs of the others had to be broken. But He was dead already, and Pilate had to make inquiry, and call for the witness, before he would believe it.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

The Death on Record

Pilate was not the only one who could speak to the death. Several men were close enough to the cross to know for certain.

There were too many witnesses to His death for anyone to doubt it. The centurion had charge of the crucifixion. The Roman guard carried it out. Above all, one soldier pierced His side. Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus brought the body down from the cross, and they would surely have found signs of life if there had been any. All of them were witnesses of our Lord's death.

Modernised from A. J. PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Surprise. Crucifixion killed slowly, and the two criminals were still alive. Pilate could not believe Jesus had died in a few hours.

- Reason. Scripture explains what Pilate could not. Nothing outside Him took His life. He laid it down Himself.

- Strength. The loud cry just before He died shows He still held His life in full. He gave it up; suffering did not drain it away.

- Fulfilment. Dying early meant His legs were never broken, keeping the written word that not one of His bones would be broken.

- Record. Pilate would not take the report without the centurion's word. So the men who carried out the execution are the ones who confirmed the death.

Mark 15:45 · Darby

And when he knew from the centurion, he granted the body to Joseph.

Pilate will not release the body of Jesus on Joseph's word alone; he sends for the officer in charge of the execution. Only when that report comes back does the body pass from Roman hands to a man who loved Him.

Why Pilate Was Surprised

Joseph was a member of the Sanhedrin, the Jewish ruling council. Crucifixion killed slowly, and the two criminals beside Jesus were still alive, so Pilate doubted the news.

The burial now followed... And who was to undertake the office of placing the body in a grave? One of the Sanhedrin, a rich man of Judea (Luke 23:51), Joseph by name, a disciple of the Lord Jesus, went to Pilate and asked for the body. Had He died so soon? The thieves were still alive. Death by crucifixion, though cruel, was generally slow. Pilate was amazed at the thought that He might already be dead. He did not know that in the counsel of God our Lord would lay down His life Himself, no man taking it from Him (John 10:18). Calling for the centurion, as Mark alone has noticed, he asked whether He had been dead for some time, and granted the body to Joseph.

Modernised from C E StuartOriginal wording

Commentators read Pilate's astonishment as evidence rather than a puzzle.

In Pilate's astonishment that He had died so soon we have additional evidence that the Servant "gave His life." Death by crucifixion, perhaps so often witnessed by the centurion, is a lingering death.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

The Centurion's Testimony

Mark alone reports that Pilate first took the centurion's testimony.

All four gospel writers testify that Joseph of Arimathea buried the body of Jesus. John adds that Nicodemus helped Joseph in this last act of loving service and devotion to his Lord. Mark adds to the account by telling how Pilate sought and obtained the centurion's testimony to Christ's death before he granted Joseph's request. The centurion was in charge of the crucifixion.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Some claim Jesus never really died on the cross. Too many people handled the body for that to stand.

But this theory will not hold together. There were too many witnesses to His death to make it possible. The centurion had charge of the crucifixion. The Roman guard carried it out, above all the soldier who pierced His side. Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus brought the body down from the cross, and they would surely have found signs of life if there had been any. All of them were witnesses of our Lord's death. There were also the women who were present at the burial, including those who loved Him tenderly and knew Him closely — among them His own mother.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

The Handover as God's Intervention

Once Pilate released the body, the hands that touched Jesus changed. Cruel hands had finished their work.

So the will of God was done. From that moment the sacred body was out of the hands of the unbelievers. Hands of love and faith cared for the body and laid Him in the tomb.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Behind Pilate's decision, writers see God directing the outcome.

It was God who moved Pilate then to give Joseph permission to take the body; for the Romans had appointed His grave to be with the wicked. Precious it is that God allowed no unholy hands to touch Him after He had died. They had done their worst: only after that did God intervene. With what reverent affection we may be sure Joseph handled that body.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

A Line of Prophecy Fulfilled

The Jews had one plan for the body. God had recorded another long before.

The Jews had certainly intended to throw the blessed holy body of the Son of God into the common pit. They planned to throw in the bodies of the two criminals who died at His side too. God's answer to this insult to His Son was already on record. "His grave was appointed with the wicked, but He was with the rich in His death."... and the rich man of Arimathea, Joseph, stepped in and secured His body.

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

Joseph's Courage

To ask for the body was to identify himself with Jesus. Joseph had held back until then.

You might expect those very circumstances to fill him with fear and make him shrink from the consequences. Instead God used them to bring out a boldness that had never visited Joseph's heart before. He identified himself with Jesus. He did not have the precious place of following Him while He was alive. But the death of Jesus brought him to a decision, took hold of his affections, and so made him go in boldly and claim the body of his Master.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Marvel. Crucifixion killed slowly, so Pilate was amazed that Jesus died within hours. He had laid down His life Himself.

- Verified. Mark alone records the check: Pilate called the centurion and acted only on his report.

- Attested. Soldiers, Joseph, Nicodemus and the women all handled or saw the body. The claim that He never truly died cannot stand.

- Granted. Once Pilate handed the body to Joseph, unbelieving hands never touched Him again. Love and faith carried Him to the grave.

- Fulfilled. Men meant Him for a criminal's common pit, but God's answer stood on record: He was with the rich in His death.

Mark 15:46 · Darby

And having bought fine linen, [and] having taken him down, he swathed him in the fine linen, and laid him in a sepulchre which was cut out of rock, and rolled a stone to the door of the sepulchre.

Evening had come, the Sabbath was near, and the body of Jesus still hung on a cross outside Jerusalem. Then a man who had never openly stood with Him steps in, buys linen, takes the body down, and lays it in a rock tomb behind a stone.

Love That Acted When Faith Was Weak

Two women stayed to watch where Joseph laid the body. Their love ran ahead of their understanding.

Two of the Marys saw where He was laid. Here at least, then, we have genuine affection. They may not have had the understanding of faith, but they had the love that lingered over the Lord they adored, with true feeling. That love was the fruit of faith, and it honoured Jesus even in His death.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Prepared Beforehand

God improvised none of it — not the tomb, not the linen, not the willing hands. Two forces are at work at once: God stirring hearts, and God arranging circumstances.

The death of Jesus did not tear Him from the hearts of those feeble ones who loved Him... and Joseph too. His conscience had been touched, yet he had not followed Him until now. At the last, the testimony of the grace and perfection of Jesus strengthened him... This body — the tent the Son of God had just left — did not go without the services that man owed to Him. Moreover the providence of God, as well as His operation in their hearts, had prepared for all this.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

A Grave Fit for Him

Crucifixion normally ended in a criminal's grave. Instead He rested in fresh rock — prophecy fulfilled, and honour due to who He is.

"They assigned Him His grave with wicked men; but with the rich man when He had died." So Isaiah had predicted long before, and now we see it fulfilled. The criminal's grave that normally followed death by crucifixion could not be His. That substitutionary work was now finished — the work that alone had numbered Him with transgressors... While He still slept, He must sleep in honour. As it has been well said, the One born of a virgin womb could only be honoured fittingly in a virgin tomb. He who could not see corruption could not lie in a tomb which corruption had defiled.

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

(The wording of Isaiah 53:9 above is the writer's own. The ESV reads: "And they made his grave with the wicked and with a rich man in his death.")

Only Reverent Hands

Men had been free to mock and crucify Him. From the moment He died, that freedom ended.

Joseph begged Pilate for the body of Jesus. Pilate was surprised that He had died so soon, so he called the executioner to be sure that He was really dead. It was God who then moved Pilate to give Joseph permission to take the body; for the Romans had appointed His grave to be with the wicked. Precious it is that God allowed no unholy hands to touch Him after He had died. They had done their worst: only after that did God intervene. With what reverent affection we may be sure Joseph handled that body... Joseph had bought fine linen in which to wrap the body, which he laid in a new tomb hewn out of the rock. Then he rolled a large stone slab over the entrance.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Why the Burial Is Preached

The burial is not just a funeral detail. It is the second of three facts, set between His death and His resurrection.

First, Christ died for our sins, in accordance with the Scriptures. Secondly, Christ was buried. This is the complete evidence of His death, and the solemn fact that all His links with man after the flesh are cut off. Thirdly, He was raised on the third day, in accordance with the Scriptures. This is the everlasting witness that the power of death is broken, the devil defeated, and God glorified.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

But there is a limit. The suffering that paid for sin belongs to the cross, not to the grave.

He died "for our sins" (v.3). He took them up in His death as our Substitute, but no such thought belongs to His burial. Scripture simply says that He was buried. It never connects such a thought with His burial. It nowhere presents His burial as "part of His substitutionary work."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Summary

- Love acts. Joseph did not grasp what was coming, but his love honoured Jesus in death. Faith showed itself in service, not in understanding.

- God prepares. God had the tomb, the linen and the willing heart ready in advance. He works on circumstances and on hearts at the same time.

- Honour restored. He never got a criminal's grave. The tomb was new and undefiled, fitting for the One who could not see corruption.

- Hands restrained. Once He had died, no hostile hand touched Him again. Men had done their worst; then God stepped in.

- Proof sealed. The wrapped body behind a stone proves His death was real. That is the ground the third-day resurrection stands on.

Mark 15:47 · Darby

And Mary of Magdala and Mary the [mother] of Joses saw where he was put.

Mark ends his account of the crucifixion not with the disciples, but with two women. They stay to see where the body goes. The verse is one line long. Yet commentators find in it who these mourners were, what their love was worth, and why it mattered that someone knew the place.

Who the two women were

Mark names the second woman by her son, Joses. Set the Gospel lists side by side, and she appears elsewhere under other names.

By comparing together the following passages, Matthew 27:56, 61; Matthew 28:1; Mark 15:40, 47; Mark 16:1; and Luke 24:10, it appears probable that "the other Mary," and "Mary the mother of James (or James the less) and Joses" refer to the same person, and she may have been the wife of Clopas. In John 19:25 this Mary is called the sister of the Lord's mother, if we let the word "and" separate the people named. That is the most obvious sense, and it would mean three Marys stand in that verse, not four.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The smallest funeral

The crowds are gone. Scripture can name only four people at the grave, and two of them are these women.

Two men to bury, two women looking on, mourners in the truest sense — these only can we name as present at the funeral of the Lord Jesus Christ.

Modernised from C E StuartOriginal wording

Love that lingered

What is left at the tomb is love without much understanding. One writer says this still counts for something real.

Two of the Marys saw where He was laid. So here at least we have genuine affection. If there was not the intelligence of faith, there was the love that lingered over the Lord they adored with true feeling — the fruit of faith which honoured Jesus in this way, even in His death.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Another writer turns that lack of understanding back on the reader.

In love they had followed the Lord through His life of service. They clung to Him in His death on the cross. They watch as His body is laid in the grave. It is easy to dwell upon their lack of intelligence, while falling far behind them in their devoted love.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Why the place mattered

Their watching was more than grief. They now knew the spot, and one writer sees God's providence behind all of it.

God's providence, as well as His work in their hearts, had prepared for all of this. The body of Jesus is laid in the tomb, and they all wait for the end of the sabbath to perform their service to it. The women had taken note of the place.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Witnesses to a real death

Some have claimed that Jesus only fainted on the cross. One writer answers that far too many people saw Him die.

There were too many witnesses to His death to make that theory possible. All of these men saw our Lord die: the centurion in charge of the crucifixion; the Roman guard who carried it out; above all the soldier who pierced His side; and Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus, who brought the body down from the cross. Those two would have found signs of life if there had been any. The women were there at the burial too, including those who loved Him deeply and knew Him well.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

What their watching reveals

One writer reads this verse with Luke's account and finds three things in these women at once.

First, their affection for Christ. Second, they had no expectation of the resurrection. Last, their devout piety, seen in their submission to the word of God. They longed to pour out the signs of their eager love on the dead body of their Lord. But the sabbath began at once. So these holy women, with Mary Magdalene the most prominent among them, waited and rested in obedience to the commandment before they carried out their plan.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Summary

- Watching. Two women stayed to see where the body went: Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of Joses. She is probably the woman called "the other Mary" elsewhere.

- Loving. They understood little and expected no resurrection. Yet one writer calls their love genuine — the fruit of faith, honouring Jesus even in His death.

- Marking. They took note of the place, and God's providence stood behind it. Their service to the body could wait until the sabbath was over.

- Testifying. They saw the burial. So did the centurion, the guard, the soldier with the spear, Joseph and Nicodemus. Jesus truly died.

- Rebuking. It is easy to point out what these women failed to understand, and to fall far short of their love.