To every one that asks of thee, give; and from him that takes away what is thine, ask it not back.
Luke 6:30 sits inside the Lord's teaching on how His followers meet personal wrong. It sets two demands side by side: give to anyone who asks, and do not chase what someone takes. Does that mean a disciple must hand over whatever anyone asks for, and never seek back what a thief took?
The saying does not measure how sinful or sinless a person is. It sets the rule a disciple lives by.
This passage has nothing to do with the presence or absence of sin. It is about the principles of the believer's conduct — that is, about taking his Master's principles completely as his rule of conduct. Here again the Christian is not to act on the law of retaliation, or on the principles of the Jews. He is to act on the principles of Jesus Christ Himself.
The two halves of the verse train two habits. An open hand meets need. Letting go of stolen goods shows where the disciple's life rests.
It is no question of foolish extravagance, but of an open hand and heart to every call of need. "From one who takes away your goods do not demand them back." This matters greatly. There should be patient endurance of personal wrong. There should also be the testimony that our life does not consist in the things we have.
Behind the command stands what the disciple has already received.
He did not stop there. He told the disciple to give as a habit to the one who asked. For what had the disciple himself not received from the divine Giver, beyond everything he asked? As the object of countless and rich mercies, was he to turn away from someone who would ask or borrow?
Commentators differ over how far the word "everyone" reaches. One writer sees no limit set here, and measures the command against the law and against the way God gives.
Even under the law, a Jew was not allowed to lend to his brother at interest. Instead, he was to open his hand wide to him. The Lord Jesus here sets no limits on giving and lending. For God, the great Giver, did not spare His own Son, but gave Him up for us all. He who freely gives us all things along with Him loves a cheerful giver.
Others hold that the disciple must weigh the request, and that real need is what the verse has in view.
Giving to everyone who asks from us must be subject to sober wisdom. Someone may ask for a large sum to spend on a questionable project, and concern for his own good might be reason to refuse. We must also draw a firm line when people who claim to be the Lord's servants urge us to give to their own work. Too many take advantage of Christianity to make money. But if one is in need and asks for something to relieve that need, we ought to be ready to give him what is necessary... The Lord is seeking in all of this to draw out the genuine faith of His people. He is certainly not bullying His own... Also, if someone has taken away what belongs to us, faith will make no demands for its return. But if someone borrows and forgets to repay, it would be only right to remind him — not because we want our rights, but to help him become dependable.
Both agree the heart must stay open. They differ on whether the disciple weighs the request.
Christ first gave this instruction to those walking with Him on earth. Its spirit did not end with them.
These instructions fitted exactly the people called to follow Christ during His time on earth. Their spirit applies just as much to those called to follow Him while He is absent in heaven. This is the day of grace, when the gospel of grace is preached. So it matters greatly that the spirit of grace should mark us. How often, sadly, our conduct has contradicted the cause we belong to. A little ungracious practice by the preacher or his friends can cancel out a great deal of gracious preaching.
- Received — The disciple gives because the divine Giver gave to him first, beyond all he asked.
- Rule — His rule is not his own nature but his Master's principles, which replace the law of retaliation.
- Open — Giving here is not extravagance but an open hand and heart to every call of need, weighed by sober wisdom.
- Loosened — Letting stolen goods go proves that life does not consist in the things we have.
- Reflected — Ungracious practice cancels gracious preaching, so the spirit of grace must mark those who preach it.
And as ye wish that men should do to you, do *ye* also to them in like manner.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And if ye love those that love you, what thank is it to you? for even sinners love those that love them.
Jesus has just told His disciples to love their enemies. Now He asks what our ordinary love is worth. If we only love people who love us, He says, we have done nothing that bad men do not already do.
The question turns on a single word. Older translations put it as "what thank is it to you?" — and one writer traces that word back to the Greek:
"Thank," or "grace" (χάρις). Matthew (Matt. 5:46) has "reward," where Luke in verse 24 has "consolation."
The word is grace. So the Lord is not asking what we gain. He is asking what grace there is in love like that.
Luke's choice of word carries weight. One commentator weighs it against the parallel account in Matthew:
To love those who love us is not the point for a Christian; it is only a human principle. As the Lord says here, "even sinners love those who love them." Luke does not say tax collectors or Gentiles, as Matthew does. He says "sinners," which matches his usual moral tone. This was true of people everywhere, and the word "sinner" is both fitting and forceful. Not only men, but bad men, may love those who love them. Doing good to those who do good to us is also only a fair return, and even evil people can make it. The same goes for lending, when they hope to borrow later or to be paid back. Sinners do just as much. But for us the word is "love your enemies, and do good, and lend, expecting nothing in return, and your reward will be great."
If returned love proves nothing, what does? The line falls between two kinds of love altogether:
The spirit of grace stands out in verses 27-38. The love that can go forth and even embrace an enemy is not human but Divine; whereas any sinner can love the one who loves him. The disciple of Jesus is to be someone who loves, blesses, and gives.
So where does this higher love come from? One writer links the verse to the new birth:
God is love in His nature, and all love finds its source in God. So those who belong to God should show their love to one another — the love that belongs to God and His children. It is impossible for someone who has not been born again to show divine love, for "everyone who loves has been born of God and knows God" (1 John 4:7). Men love with natural love, and "even sinners love those who love them" (Luke 6:32). But only those born of God can display the divine nature, loving with the same love seen in Jesus.
The standard here is not a better grade of human decency. One writer traces it back to the start of the passage:
From verse 27 He shows how His disciples must live. They were to show God — to unfold what was displayed in Him... "Love your enemies." God loved us when we were His enemies, and now we have to show in practice what God is... Flesh can love for love (v. 32, 33), but the disciples of Christ are called to imitate God and walk in love.
Does our love wait for a signal before it moves? One writer catches the excuse we often make:
Notice how independent grace is. Rain and dew wait for no one. God acts on His own, out of His own heart, when He gives His gracious blessing. Those who drink in His grace act from Him in the same way, without first waiting to see signs of worthiness. We are often ready to say, "If only we could see some return for our love!" That is not it. If only we were a little more conscious of God's infinite love and grace to us, we would be more like a dew from Him to others.
- Grace measured. The word behind "benefit" is grace — Jesus is asking how much grace there is in love that only answers love.
- Grace absent. Returned love proves nothing. Bad men manage it, and they can do good and lend as well.
- Grace received. Love that reaches an enemy is divine, not human, and only those born of God can show it.
- Grace copied. God loved us while we were His enemies. So the disciple's pattern is not a better human standard. It is God Himself.
- Grace flowing. Like dew that waits for no one, grace moves first — it does not hold back until it sees a return.
And if ye do good to those that do good to you, what thank is it to you? for even sinners do the same.
Jesus is showing His disciples how they are to live. He weighs the kindness that answers good with good, notes that sinners do as much, and sets the disciple's standard elsewhere.
The word Luke uses is not about thanks but about grace. Matthew's parallel uses a different word.
Luke 6:32. — "Thank" here is the word for "grace" (charis); the Latin Vulgate has "gratia." Matthew (Matt. 5:46) has "reward"; the matching word in Luke, in verse 24, is "consolation."
Kindness repaid with kindness is a fair exchange, and bad men manage it. Matthew names tax collectors and Gentiles; Luke says "sinners," and that takes in everyone.
Loving those who love us is not the point for a Christian. It is a merely human principle — as the Lord says with emphasis here, "even sinners love those who love them." Matthew names tax collectors or Gentiles; Luke says "sinners," which matches his ordinary moral tone. This was true of people everywhere, and the word "sinner" is fitting and forceful. Not only men, but bad men, can love those who love them. In the same way, doing good to those who do good to us is only a right return, and even evil people can make it. The same is true of lending, when they hope to borrow or to be repaid. Sinners do just as much.
Two habits can look alike from outside. One writer marks the difference: whether you expect anything back.
This stands in contrast with the way of the world. The world is quite capable of returning love for love, of doing good to those who do good to them, and of lending in the hope of getting back as much. But to love and do good and lend with no hope of return — that would be conduct fit for the sons of the Most High, because He is kind to the unthankful and the evil.
Law can tell me to love my neighbour as myself. What Jesus asks here goes further, and it reaches down into pride and selfishness.
And here I find what is entirely beyond law. Law tells me to love others as myself; grace tells me to give myself up entirely for my neighbour or for anybody. Did not God forgive you? You go and forgive your enemies. Is He kind to the unthankful and the evil? You go and be the same. It tests all the fibres of our hearts, all the pride and vanity and selfishness that are in us.
Human nature can already return love for love. The disciple has another pattern in front of him: God Himself, shown in Christ.
From verse 27 He shows what the conduct of the disciples must be. They were to make God known, to unfold what was displayed in Him. The grace that was in Him in fullness and perfection should show itself again in them — that is the principle of our path, sadly as we all fail in it… Human nature can love in return for love (v. 32, 33), but the disciples of Christ are called to imitate God, and to walk in love.
These questions build to a closing call. Luke words it differently from Matthew, and his wording suits readers with no Old Testament background.
So the call in this Gospel does not run as in Matthew, "You therefore must be perfect, as your heavenly Father is perfect," but "Be merciful, even as your Father is merciful."… The disciple, taught by Jesus, had the Father's Name made known to him, and his perfection is to show his Father's character in grace that makes no distinctions — not in the spirit of law. Writing for non-Jewish readers, Luke simply calls them to be merciful as their Father was merciful. This would be clear even to people who had no detailed knowledge of the Old Testament.
- Grace, not thanks. The word behind "benefit" is the word for grace; Matthew's parallel uses "reward." The question is not whether people thank you, but whether grace is there.
- Grace missing. Doing good to those who do good to you is only a fair return. Even bad men make it — Luke calls them "sinners," a word that takes in everyone.
- Grace beyond law. Law says love your neighbour as yourself. Grace says give yourself up entirely, because God forgave you and is kind to the unthankful.
- Grace reproduced. Human nature can love in return for love. The disciple is to unfold what was displayed in Christ, so that the grace full and perfect in Him shows in us.
- Grace for all. The call here is not "be perfect" but "Be merciful, even as your Father is merciful" — clear to any reader, with or without an Old Testament background.
And if ye lend to those from whom ye hope to receive, what thank is it to you? [for] even sinners lend to sinners that they may receive the like.
Jesus has been teaching His disciples to love their enemies. Here He tests a respectable kind of generosity: the loan made with an eye on repayment. His question is not whether such lending is wrong, but whether it earns any credit, since bad people already do the same.
Verses 32–34 give three examples that work the same way. Love repays love. Good repays good. Money goes out where the lender counts on getting it back. One writer notes that Luke does not say "tax collectors" or "Gentiles" here. The word he chooses carries weight.
Loving those who love us is not the point for a Christian. It is only a human principle. As the Lord stresses here, "even sinners love those who love them." Matthew has tax collectors or Gentiles; Luke has "sinners," which fits his usual moral tone. This was true of people everywhere, and the word "sinner" is fitting and forceful. Not only ordinary people, but bad people, can love those who love them. In the same way, doing good to those who do good to us is only a fair return, and evil people are capable of it. So is lending, when they hope to borrow or to be repaid. Sinners do just as much.
The world can do everything this verse describes. One writer marks the point where a Christian's conduct parts from it.
The way of the world stands in contrast with this. The world is quite able to return love for love, to do good to those who do good to them, and to lend in the hope of getting back as much. But to love, do good, and lend with no hope of return — that would be conduct fit for the sons of the Most High, because He is kind to the ungrateful and the evil.
The next verse tells us to lend and expect nothing in return. Some translations render that phrase as "never despairing" instead. One commentator argues that verse 34 settles the question, because it states the very thing verse 35 reverses.
So the question turns mainly on what the context requires. When you weigh verses 30-34 with care, it is surprising that such an unnatural sense should be given to the word in verse 35. Look above all at the verse just before it: "And if you lend to those from whom you expect to receive, what credit is that to you? Even sinners lend to sinners, to get back the same amount." What could be simpler than the opposite call of grace — love, do good, lend, "hoping for nothing again"? (Compare Luke 14:12.)
The standard here is not fair exchange. One writer points to what God Himself has already done.
And here I find what is entirely beyond law. Law tells me to love others as myself; grace tells me to give myself up entirely for my neighbour or for anybody. Did not God forgive you? You go and forgive your enemies. Is He kind to the unthankful and the evil? You go and be the same. It tests all the fibres of our hearts, all the pride and vanity and selfishness that are in us.
If nothing comes back, is the money simply lost? One writer answers from Psalms and Proverbs.
"The wicked borrows but does not pay back, but the righteous is generous and gives" (Psalm 37:21). That is in beautiful harmony with the God who is rich in mercy. He showed us that mercy by making us alive when we were dead in our sins (Ephesians 2; see also Luke 6:30-36). Again, "whoever is generous to the poor lends to the LORD, and he will repay him for his deed" (Proverbs 19:17).
What about a borrower who never means to repay? One writer takes up that case.
There are people who would not ask for a gift, but would not hesitate to ask for a loan, though they have little intention of paying it back. It would be wrong for us to encourage dishonesty in anyone. Yet as far as we ourselves are concerned, it is better to suffer wrong than to demand our rights. Faith on our part can leave such things in the hand of God.
- Return — A loan made with repayment in view is only an exchange, and the Lord asks what credit that earns.
- Sinners — Luke's word is deliberate: even bad people manage this much, so it cannot be the mark of a disciple.
- Nothing back — The call is to love, do good, and lend with no return in view. That is the plain sense of the words, and the reverse of what this verse describes.
- Beyond law — Law says love your neighbour as yourself. Grace says give yourself away, because God is kind to the ungrateful and the evil.
- Repaid — What looks like a lost loan is a loan to the LORD, who repays; faith can leave the account in His hands.