Luke 19:43–44

Luke 19:43

for days shall come upon thee, that thine enemies shall make a palisaded mound about thee, and shall close thee around, and keep thee in on every side,

The King has just entered His own capital to cheers, and now He looks at the city and pictures the army that will one day surround it. He speaks in tears, which leaves two questions: did this happen, and why did it have to?

Grace in the Voice That Pronounced the Doom

The prediction is unusual in that the one who makes it is weeping while He makes it. One writer sets the exactness of the outcome side by side with the heart of the Speaker.

Every word of the warning was exactly fulfilled in the siege of Titus. But what grace shone out of that heart! He was overwhelmed with grief for a people who were blindly refusing, to their own ruin, the very One who wept over them. He wept in a love at once truly divine and perfectly human.

William Kelly

The Barricade Was Literally Built

The barricade, the encircling, the hemming in on every side — these were not vague images of trouble. A history of the Roman assault records how the decision was reached. (Older translations render the ESV's "set up a barricade" as "cast a trench," which is the wording quoted here.)

The Romans discussed three plans: to storm the city at once, to repair the works and rebuild the siege engines, or to blockade the city and starve it into surrender. They chose the last, and set the whole army to work "to cast a trench" around the city. But the siege was long and difficult. It lasted from the spring till September.

Church History

Why the Days Came

The sentence does not end at verse 43. It runs on to name the cause: the city did not know the time of its visitation. One writer explains what the phrase means here, and what it means elsewhere in Scripture.

The words in Luke 19:44, "the time of your visitation," undoubtedly mean the day of grace for Jerusalem. That grace came through the presence and testimony of our blessed Lord. It was the opportunity for blessing, and this is why the Lord laments... When, however, we come to Peter's words, "the day of visitation," the thought is rather that of judgment, and not of grace.

The Christian's Friend

The Alternative to Peace

Verse 42 names what would have brought Jerusalem peace. Verse 43 says what came instead.

Men wanted peace, but were so blinded that they did not recognise what peace required. These things centred in the person of the Lord Jesus, the Prince of peace. But because of unbelief the things necessary for peace were hidden from Israel's eyes (v.42). Prophetically the Lord pronounced on Jerusalem the terrible alternative to peace. Its enemies would make it their prey, and subject it to oppression, siege and destruction.

Leslie M. Grant

Whether AD 70 Exhausts It

Commentators differ here. Kelly, quoted above, treats the words as fully discharged in the Roman siege. Another writer reads them as having a further stage still ahead.

Those days did come. Yet I admit the Lord's prophecy was only partly fulfilled, and that it will have a fuller accomplishment later on. If you want to read a dark and bloody page of history, sit down and read the account of the sack of Jerusalem by the Romans under Titus. You will look on horrors that will strike to the very bottom of your soul. Only that time of terrible tribulation still to come will exceed them.

W T Turpin

Wider Than One City

Some read what happened to Jerusalem as a pattern, not a one-off event.

Jerusalem is only a sample of the world in general. Because Christ was rejected, the world will have to go through a very different history than if it had been prepared for Him... The world is not prepared for Him, and the earth must pass to its rest through the judgments that will cleanse it of its defilements.

J. G. Bellett

The Warning to Willing Ignorance

One writer turns the ground of that sentence — not knowing — on readers today.

They had had the opportunity of learning the things that belonged to their peace, but these were "now hidden from their eyes"... And note, ignorance is the ground of its condemnation. That is a solemn warning to those who remain willingly ignorant now.

The Christian's Friend

Summary

- Visitation. "The time of your visitation" means Jerusalem's day of grace. The Lord's own presence and testimony gave the city its chance of blessing.

- Blindness. What made for peace was centred in Christ Himself. Unbelief hid it, and the barricade came in place of the peace they refused.

- Barricade. The words were not just images. The Romans chose blockade over assault, and set the whole army to work casting a trench around the city.

- Fulfilment. Every word came true in the siege of Titus. Commentators differ on whether that siege completed the prophecy, or points on to a greater tribulation still ahead.

- Warning. Ignorance was the ground of the city's condemnation. That makes it a warning to anyone who stays willingly ignorant while grace is still speaking.

Luke 19:44

and shall lay thee even with the ground, and thy children in thee; and shall not leave in thee a stone upon a stone because thou knewest not the season of thy visitation.

Crowds have just welcomed the King into Jerusalem. Now He tells the city what is coming, and why. The sentence falls on a single charge — she did not recognise the moment God came to her.

What "the time of your visitation" means

The word "visitation" does not mean the same thing everywhere. Here it points to opportunity, not doom.

In Luke 19:44, "The time of your visitation" certainly means the day of grace for Jerusalem. That grace came through the presence and testimony of our blessed Lord. It was the opportunity for blessing. This is why the Lord laments: "If you had known, even you, at least in this your day, the things that make for your peace! But now they are hidden from your eyes." But when we come to Peter's words, "The day of visitation," the thought is judgment, not grace.

The Christian's Friend

Grace refused, and the city set aside

The visit was God's own coming in the Person of Jesus. Not knowing it cost Jerusalem more than a blessing.

It is the hour of her visitation, and she has not known it. If only she had, even now, listened to the call of the testimony of her God! She is given up into the hands of the Gentiles, her enemies, who will not leave her one stone upon another. In other words, she did not know this visitation of God in grace in the Person of Jesus. So she is set aside. The testimony goes no further, and she gives place to a new order of things.

J. N. Darby

Sentence passed in tears

The verse is a verdict, yet the One who announces it weeps as He speaks.

This was the alternative, which His lament over the city brings fully out: it was the Saviour or the destroyer, Christ or the dreaded and hated Roman. In fact, they had already made their choice, and could only be left to it. But the Judge weeps as He gives sentence. She and her children within her would be destroyed — not a stone left upon a stone.

F. W. Grant

Darby weighs what that day could have been for Israel.

Oh, "If you had known, at least," all would have been pardoned then — "in this your day" — what a day for Israel! For if all her sin was piled up, all grace was piled up too... but now they were hidden from their eyes. The joy and acclamation of His disciples was right, yet it gave occasion to the tears of Jesus rather than wiping them away. All as to Jerusalem hung on this: "You did not know the time of your visitation."

J. N. Darby

Fulfilled to the letter

The warning was not vague. Roman armies under Titus later besieged the city.

Every word of the warning came true to the letter in the siege of Titus. But what grace shone out of that heart, overwhelmed with grief for the people! They were blindly refusing, to their own ruin, the very One who wept over them in a love that was truly divine and perfectly human.

William Kelly

Ignorance as the charge

The charge is ignorance. That is what makes it a warning for people now.

They had the opportunity to learn the things that belonged to their peace, but these were "now hidden from their eyes." So the Lord, still yearning over darkened Jerusalem, speaks ahead of time as Judge and pronounces her doom. And note, ignorance is the ground of its condemnation, which is a solemn warning to those who remain willingly ignorant now. There are many like this. They will even plead ignorance as the ground of forgiveness. But God takes pains to enlighten them, so such a plea is only evidence of the most glaring stubbornness.

The Christian's Friend

The ruins are held up as evidence that a window of opportunity really can close.

It was said of Jerusalem that she did not know the time of her visitation (Luke 19:44). Her capture by the Romans, and the desolation that followed, are standing witnesses of her folly in that respect.

C. E. Stuart

A future welcome

The ruin of the city is not the end of her story.

He now sees it as lost to Him, and soon to be laid level with the ground, because she had not known this, the time of her visitation!... The people would not see Him among them again, offering Himself to them as their King, until by repentance and faith they learn to join with His disciples in calling Him "Blessed."

J. G. Bellett

Summary

- Visit — "The time of your visitation" was Jerusalem's day of grace. God Himself stood among them in Christ, offering peace.

- Blindness — The charge was not that she fought the visit. She never recognised it, and not knowing was the ground of her condemnation.

- Tears — The Judge passes sentence weeping; the same love that announces the ruin had come to prevent it.

- Ruins — Every word came true under Titus: the city levelled, her children with her, not one stone left standing.

- Return — Being set aside is not the end: the city that missed His visit will yet greet Him as blessed.