And the children of Israel did evil in the sight of Jehovah; and Jehovah delivered them into the hand of Midian seven years.
Judges 6 begins the story of Gideon. It opens with the cause of everything that follows: Israel's evil, and seven years under Midian. Two questions matter here. Whose hand was really the strongest? And how did the people who conquered the land end up hiding in it?
The verse names the cause before it names the oppressor.
First of all, we are reminded that the unfaithfulness of God's people is what puts power into any enemy's hand. No might of Midian could have prevailed if the Lord had not permitted it. And He would not have permitted it if Israel's condition had not made it necessary. Those who will not learn in communion with God, must do so in the hands of the enemy. "Your evil will chastise you, and your apostasy will reprove you. Know and see that it is evil and bitter for you to forsake the LORD your God." (Jer. 2:19.)
The raiders had no idea that God was using them. One writer sets them beside Assyria, which God called the rod of His anger.
The Midianites did not know that the LORD had delivered Israel into their hands. In reality they were only the rod with which it pleased Him to punish His people. As with the Assyrian (Isa. 10): "Ah, Assyria, the rod of my anger; the staff in their hands is my fury!" When He has finished with His rod, He can break it or burn it. "Shall the axe boast over him who hews with it, or the saw magnify itself against him who wields it?" Satan himself is very often the rod used by God for the discipline of His children.
Set this chapter next to Israel's entrance into the land and the reversal is stark.
What a humiliating picture! What a reverse for the Israel of God! What a contrast to the conquering army that had crossed the Jordan and walked across the ruins of Jericho! How sad, how humbling, to think of Israel hiding in the dens and caves of the mountains, in terror of the Midianites!
The same writer names the evil and what it cost Israel.
Israel's power and glory consisted simply in having the presence of God with them. Without that, they were as water spilled on the ground… But they could not enjoy God's presence while they allowed evil among them. So when Israel forgot their Lord and wandered away from Him into the forbidden paths of idolatry, He had to bring them to their senses by stretching out His governmental rod.
This oppressor was not a stranger. He was family, and God had already told Israel to fight him.
Midian was a near relative of Israel. He descended from Abraham through Keturah, his second wife, and again and again the Midianites cross paths with the chosen people. In the wilderness the LORD spoke to Moses — who had married Zipporah, daughter of the priest of Midian — and said, "Harass the Midianites and strike them down, for they have harassed you with their wiles." (Num. 25:16-18; Num. 31:1-12.) But now they are in the land itself, though they had never followed the ark across the Jordan… How solemn the warning!
Commentators read the name as a picture of what the world does once it is let in among God's people.
Midian stands for the world, as its history has shown it. The name matches this: it means "strife." "The corruption that is in the world" is "because of sinful desire" (2 Peter 1:4). And "What causes quarrels and what causes fights among you? Is it not this, that your passions are at war within you?" (James 4:1.)… These Midianites were Arab raiders. They wandered and plundered, devouring like locusts what they had no will to produce, as the story here shows. This is what the world is when the professing church lets it in: it has no shared interest with the church, but the reverse, and the effect is simply desolation.
Each oppression in this book has its own character. Under Midian, Israel loses its food.
Under Jabin, Israel had no weapons (Judges 5:8). Under the yoke of Midian he was starving. This is what our unfaithfulness costs us, and we always suffer it when we seek our portion with the world. It drags us down and takes away our weapons. Our strength leaves us, and we lose every means of resisting… We notice it by the barrenness that invades the soul when, in our folly, we leave the rich food of the house of God for harvests that are only a mirage of the desert.
- Cause — Israel's evil comes first in the verse, Midian second. No enemy holds power over God's people except what their own unfaithfulness hands him.
- Rod — Midian is a tool, not a master. God lifts the rod, and when He has finished with it He can break it.
- Kin — The oppressor descended from Abraham, and God had already marked him out as a danger. The trouble came from a relative, not a stranger.
- Strife — The name means strife. That is what the world brings once God's people let it in: raiding, not building, and desolation as the result.
- Famine — Seven years of Midian left Israel starving in caves. That is the opposite of the army that walked over the ruins of Jericho. Their one strength was God's presence, and that presence will not stay where evil is allowed.
And the hand of Midian prevailed against Israel. Because of the Midianites the children of Israel made for themselves the dens that are in the mountains, and the caves, and the strongholds.
Israel lives in the land God gave them, yet they are the ones hiding underground. The verse raises two questions: how could an enemy bring God's people this low, and what did they lose by hiding?
Israel's safety had never rested on their own numbers.
Israel's power and glory consisted simply in having the presence of God with them. Without that, they were like water spilled on the ground, like the autumn leaf before the wind. But they could not enjoy God's presence while they allowed evil among them. So when Israel forgot their Lord and wandered into the forbidden paths of idolatry, He had to bring them back to their senses. He stretched out His governmental rod and made them feel the crushing power of one or another of the nations around them.
The strength of Midian was never the real issue:
This was not because the Midianites were more powerful than the children of Israel. When God was among them and fighting for them, the size of the enemy did not matter. The battle was already decided... The reason for their condition was their own unfaithfulness. They disobeyed God's plain, clear word: have nothing to do with idolatry, and give Him the place in your affections.
Set the verse beside what this nation once was.
What a humiliating picture! What a contrast to the conquering army that had crossed the Jordan and walked across the ruins of Jericho! How sad to think of Israel crouching and hiding in the dens and caves of the mountains, in terror of the pagan Midianites!
One writer looks past Israel's shame to what the discipline cost God Himself:
They had never sunk so low. To live like wanderers and fugitives in the land of God, in their own land, was a burning disgrace to Israel... Gideon felt this, and he felt it all the more because he knew their slavery under Midian was the Lord's doing. Israel's moral state left Him no choice but to reduce His people to such a shameful condition. What must God have felt, to deal so with those He loved!
God put Israel in that land for a reason. People hiding in holes cannot serve it.
In short, they hid themselves in the earth. God had set them in that land to be a witness for Himself. If they had walked in His ways, their light would have kept shining, and other nations would have learnt how good it was to have Israel's God. But they were no witness for God while they hid in the dens and caves of the earth. It is the same today. God's people whose souls are under the power of earthly things shine no light for Him. Their light is hidden instead of set on the lampstand for all to see.
Commentators read Midian's name as "strife" in two directions. Some see worldliness starting a civil war inside a believer:
Midian means "strife," a fitting name for that spirit of the world which brings the strife of desires into the soul... Look at that happy young Christian: the things of God are his delight, and fellowship with the people of God his only pleasure. But he wanders in heart, and the world finds an entrance. It will not take some blatantly immoral form. He indulges some "harmless pleasure" or forms some "agreeable companionship". Mark the results. Strife with divine things follows.
Others read it of quarrelling among God's people, which leaves them with nothing to feed on:
The food set before the saints is strife and sorrow and backbiting and misrepresentation and cruelties of different kinds. No one can grow spiritually on this food. This was the condition Israel was in. There was no family life, the business life of the nation broke down, and food supply ran very low. In that condition the people were very distressed. It is a very good thing when people do get distressed and cry aloud to God.
The oppression itself taught a lesson about who is fit to rule.
Their enemies ruled over them for a complete period, because they had rebelled against the rule of God. So God teaches them, in the land of blessing and privilege, the contrast between His rule and the rule of man. We are always ruled by someone or something. If not by God, then by that power which is hostile to God and His people. We are often brought under that power so that we may learn how much better God's rule is. Under Him our passions are controlled; under the other our very nature is worn out and harassed. This is a discipline that all God's people can come under.
- Cause: Midian did not overpower Israel. Israel's own unfaithfulness handed them over, because their whole strength was God's presence.
- Cost: the nation that walked over the ruins of Jericho now crouched in caves, like fugitives in their own land. God felt that shame too.
- Concealment: hidden people make poor witnesses. A light in a cave tells the nations nothing about Israel's God.
- Character: Midian means "strife." Some read it as worldliness at war inside one soul, others as quarrelling that starves a whole company.
- Cure: God lets an enemy rule so His people learn how much better His rule is. The distress does its work when it makes them cry out to Him.
And it came to pass when Israel sowed, that Midian came up, and Amalek, and the children of the east, and came up against them.
This verse shows a routine, not a single raid: Israel plants, and three enemy peoples come up together. Why did a nation living in its own land end up farming for its enemies?
The verse ties the raids to the farming year: Midian let Israel sow, then came for what the sowing produced. The cause, though, lay inside Israel.
Those were very dark days in Israel. The land was suffering badly because of the evil of God's people. They sowed their grain, but reaped no harvest. The Midianites came up at harvest time with their cattle and tents, as many as grasshoppers, and destroyed the produce of the land.
Midian and Amalek appear often in Israel's story. "The people of the East" is vaguer, and one Bible dictionary traces the name back to Genesis.
One of the ancient peoples who held the land promised to Abraham, Genesis 15:19. Probably the same as bene-Kedem, "children of the east." Judges 6:3.
So who really beat Israel? One writer points away from Midian's strength.
"And the hand of Midian prevailed against Israel." Nothing could have prevailed against them, had they been faithful to the Lord.
Commentators differ on what Midian pictures. Several start from the meaning of the name, and hear a warning about quarrelling among God's people.
The name Midian means "strife" or "contention"… How often we have seen normal conditions in assembly life disrupted among the people of God because of strife and contention. People seek their own way. Strong-willed people make demands about things that ought never to be considered among the people of God… There is very little worship of the Father and the Son. There is very little testimony to the Lord or to the unconverted. And there is precious little food supply.
Midian does not come alone. One writer treats the partners as a pattern.
When crops had been sown, the Midianites would come. Amalekites and others from the east came with them, destroying the produce of the earth (vv. 3-4). Amalek speaks of the lusts of the flesh, which we may always expect to accompany an attitude of strife (Midian). The result of such an attack will also always be to destroy all spiritual growth and prosperity.
Others read the raid as a picture of ordinary earthly things taking over a believer's life. On this reading the invaders are not gross wickedness at all.
Now the things of earth are not necessarily bad and grossly sinful. They are things which may be right and proper when kept in their right place, and they may include God's temporal mercies to us. But if they become our object in life they crowd out the things of Christ and heaven. As a result the sunshine leaves the life, the song leaves the lips, and soul prosperity is at an end.
Israel's land was rich, which made the loss bitter. One writer sees the same hunger in Christians who find nothing in their Bibles.
Midian devours or destroys all the fruits of the earth. Canaan was famous, as parts of it still are today, for its wonderful fertility. God could call it "the glory of all lands," and He promised them they should eat their bread without scarcity. How many of the Lord's people have to complain of their leanness. They find so little food, the Bible is a closed book to them, their souls are suffering a famine. The world has devoured the food. You cannot enjoy the world and enjoy Christ. It is impossible.
Sowing for others to reap is the dark background of a later promise. One writer sets this verse beside days of quiet peace for the same people.
How often had their fathers sown for others to reap! How often had the enemy invaded the land and carried off the produce of the soil! (Judges 6:3, 11.) Their affairs will prosper. God's blessing will be known in their families… "The Lord will bless you out of Zion. May you see the good of Jerusalem all the days of your life. May you see your children's children, and peace upon Israel."
- Harvest stolen — Israel sowed, and Midian came at harvest. The work fed the enemy, not the workers.
- Harvest lost — the raiders were not too strong. Nothing could have beaten Israel while they stayed faithful to the Lord.
- Harvest attacked twice — Midian never came alone. Commentators read Amalek as the lusts of the flesh, the companion strife always brings.
- Harvest crowded out — others read the invaders as earthly things. They are right in their place, but ruinous once they become life's object.
- Harvest restored — God promises the same nation days when its own work feeds it, with blessing out of Zion.
And they encamped against them, and destroyed the produce of the land, until thou come to Gazah, and they left no sustenance in Israel, neither sheep, nor ox, nor ass.
Raiders swept in each year and stripped Israel's fields bare, leaving nothing to eat and nothing to farm with. Two questions press: how did God's people starve in the land God gave them, and what famine does this picture?
The stripping of the land was not bad luck. Commenting on the whole passage, one writer fixes the blame before describing the damage.
"And the hand of Midian prevailed against Israel." Nothing could have prevailed against them, had they been faithful to the Lord.
Midian was not a stranger. The nation descended from Abraham through his second wife Keturah, which makes their presence in Canaan all the more painful.
But now they are in the land itself, though they had never followed the ark across the Jordan; "and Israel was greatly impoverished because of the Midianites." How solemn the warning!
The picture in the verse is of plunderers, not settlers. They had no interest in building anything up.
These Midianites — some think "Midian" is really connected with the modern word "Bedouin" — were Arab raiders, wandering pillagers, devouring like locusts what they had no will to produce, as the story here shows. This is what the world is when it is let into the professing church: it has no shared interest with it, but the opposite; the effect is simply desolation.
The verse marks how far the ruin reached. That place name may carry more weight than a map reference.
Notice, too, the connection with the Philistines, whose name we have seen means "wanderers"… "As far as Gaza" is no mere geographical limit. "In those days, as in later times, Gaza was the great market for stolen goods, brought there by the Bedouins from their raids." It would be natural for Philistines to join Israel's enemies.
One writer draws a straight line from the meaning of the name Midian to an empty table.
The name Midian means 'strife' or 'contention'… How often we have seen strife and contention disrupt normal life among God's people, with people seeking their own way… There is very little worship of the Father and the Son, very little testimony to the Lord or to the unconverted, and precious little food supply. What the saints are asked to feed on is strife and sorrow and backbiting and misrepresentation and cruelties of different kinds. No spiritual growth is possible on this food.
One writer turns "no sustenance" on the believer who goes looking for life in the world.
Under the yoke of Midian, Israel went hungry — the result of our unfaithfulness, which we always suffer from when we seek our portion with the world. It drags us down and takes away our weapons. Our strength leaves us, and we lose every means of standing firm. Even the sources of life are missing, for the world never feeds anyone. We see it in the barrenness that invades the soul. In our folly we leave the richness of the house of God for harvests that are only a mirage of the desert. This was Israel's experience; Midian "left no sustenance" for him (v. 4).
Canaan was rich land, which makes this emptiness sharper. Another writer finds the same emptiness in Christians who cannot explain their own leanness.
Canaan was known for its wonderful fertility, as parts of it still are today. God could call it "the most glorious of all lands," and He promised them they would eat their bread without scarcity. How many of the Lord's people have to complain of their leanness! They find so little food, the Bible is a closed book to them, their souls are suffering a famine. The world has devoured the food. You cannot enjoy the world and enjoy Christ. It is impossible.
Israel's hunger was not the end of the story. The same writer traces what their cry produced.
The people of Israel cried out for help to the LORD… First, the Lord sent a prophet to bring their sin home to their conscience, and then He sent an angel to raise up a deliverer. He finds Gideon threshing wheat by the winepress to hide it from the Midianites.
- Cause — The harvest was not stolen by an unstoppable force. Faithfulness would have kept Midian out; unfaithfulness let the raiders in.
- Character — Midian devoured what it never planted. That is what the world does wherever the church lets it in: it gives nothing and leaves desolation.
- Cost — Strife empties the table. Where contention rules among God's people, worship, witness and food all dry up.
- Condition — "No sustenance" is the believer's own symptom: a closed Bible, a lean soul, a lost appetite. You cannot feed on the world and on Christ at once.
- Cure — The famine drove Israel to cry out, and God answered: a prophet for the conscience, then a deliverer. Emptiness is meant to end in that cry.
For they came up with their cattle and their tents, and they came as locusts for multitude; both they and their camels were without number; and they entered into the land to destroy it.
Judges 6:5 pictures an invasion as a locust swarm. Who were these raiders, why could God's own nation not stop them, and what does their stripping of the land still picture?
These invaders were not strangers. They came from the same family line as Israel.
Midian was a close relative of Israel, descended from Abraham through Keturah, his second wife. Again and again they come into contact with the chosen people. In the wilderness the Lord spoke to Moses. Moses had married Zipporah, daughter of the priest of Midian. The Lord said, "Harass the Midianites and strike them down, for they have harassed you with their wiles." (Num. 25:16-18; Num. 31:1-12.) But now they are in the land itself, though they had never followed the ark across the Jordan. "And Israel was brought very low because of Midian." How solemn the warning!
Even the name of these raiders carries a warning for God's people.
The name Midian means "strife" or "contention." How often we have seen normal conditions among God's people disrupted by strife and contention. People seek their own way. Strong-willed people make demands about things that ought never to be considered among God's people. There are personal or family animosities, parties forming, and strife among the saints of God. There is very little worship of the Father and the Son, very little testimony to the Lord or to the unconverted, and certainly precious little food supply.
So why could Israel not hold them off? The problem was not the size of the swarm.
"And the hand of Midian overpowered Israel." Nothing could have prevailed against them, had they been faithful to the Lord.
Verse 5 mentions tents and livestock — the equipment of settlers, not of a passing raid. The reach of the occupation is measured by the text itself.
Scripture describes the oppression in great detail. This helps us see clearly who these Midianites are spiritually. For fear of them the children of Israel are driven to dig dens and caves for shelter. They settled down on the land. With them came the Amalekites and a mixed crowd of eastern tribes. Like a plague of locusts, they destroyed all food and provision. Unlike the Moabites, they did not settle on the borders of the land at Jericho. They swept like a destructive plague over the whole territory, "as far as Gaza," the stronghold of the Philistines.
Locusts strip a field they never sowed. One writer carries that picture over into the church.
These Midianites were Arab raiders and wandering plunderers. Some think the name "Midian" is really connected with the modern word "Bedouin." Like locusts, they devoured what they had no will to produce, as the story here shows. This is what the world is when it is let into the professing church. It has no shared interest there, but the opposite. The effect is simply desolation.
These raiders never stayed still. That restless energy is the warning.
There is an energy in these hordes that marks an enemy constantly on the move. He is always looking for new points of attack. We hardly need reminding how active Satan is to bring people under the power of the world. Before we know it, some small opening has made a way, and the enemy has come in like a flood. Let us not think of the spirit of worldliness as something slow-moving. It is cunning and active, and its name is legion.
The same stripping still happens quietly. One writer names three losses that follow.
Oh, it is pitiful! This is the sad case of thousands of once-flourishing Christians. They have been overcome not by gross sinfulness, nor even by worldliness, but by the "things of earth"! "The family, the business, the things of this life must be attended to," they say. So they neglect the things of Christ, which are their true and proper portion as God's people. Note carefully the threefold result: (1) No fruit for God. (2) No light for others. (3) No provision for themselves.
- Kin. Midian came from Abraham through Keturah. The enemy was born inside the family — close enough to know Israel, hostile enough to strip it.
- Cause. Numbers did not defeat Israel; unfaithfulness did. Nothing could have prevailed against them had they stayed faithful to the Lord.
- Settlement. The tents and livestock show an occupation, not a raid. The swarm settled down and swept the land as far as Gaza.
- Appetite. Like locusts, they devoured what they had no will to produce. That is the world let into the church: it gives nothing and leaves desolation.
- Cost. The harvest is stripped before it feeds anyone. The same loss today: no fruit for God, no light for others, no provision for yourself.
And Israel was greatly impoverished because of Midian. And the children of Israel cried to Jehovah.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And it came to pass when the children of Israel cried to Jehovah because of Midian,
Midian's raids had stripped Israel bare, and at last the people cried to God. What came back was not a rescuer but a preacher, and that delay carries the lesson.
The cry mattered because Israel at last admitted what it had become. One writer turns the same lesson on the church:
The sin of the church has brought it into desolation. Yet little real cry has gone up to the Lord; and why? We are not aware of how far we have departed from our original standing. We have gained so much of the world's dignity, influence and riches! These things, though they do not hide us from God or from Satan, are hiding our real poverty from ourselves. If we only knew our destitution, if we only cried to the Lord, He would deliver and raise up, "when He sees that their power is gone and there is none remaining, bond or free." Whether for Israel, for one person, or for the church, the lesson to be learned is the same: its own poverty and destitution. No matter how poor we are, if we are aware of our poverty; for there is all fullness in Christ.
Yet the cry was not yet repentance. It was the groan of people who wanted their circumstances changed:
When Israel finally cried out to the LORD (v. 7), they cried simply because of their misery. So the Lord did not relieve them at once. He sent a prophet to press on Israel that their own guilt was responsible for these troubles.
God sends two messengers to Israel, and the order matters.
Notice the twofold process of the Lord. He sends first a prophet, then an angel. The prophet brings their sin home to their conscience. The angel raises up a deliverer. He loves to rescue His people from the wretched consequences of their failure, but He will have the evil owned first.
The delay is not coldness. It sets a rule for how we handle others in trouble:
The people suffer bitter oppression, and they cry to God. But instead of sending relief at once, He deepens in their souls the sense of the evil of their course. Our first thought is to escape the consequences of our folly and disobedience. God wants us to judge fully what led us into it. His patience and His pity combine in divine proportions, so that we may get the profit of the lesson. Let us not rush to pull His people out of an awkward position. Let us first see that they have been to the bottom of the matter with God.
Who was this prophet? The commentators say the question misses the point:
God answered their cry by working a fresh revival, in which He sought to probe the conscience of this poor people more deeply than in the past. "The LORD sent a prophet to the people of Israel." His name is not given, and it does not matter. This man simply carried the word of God, to bring the people into His presence. God has a means by which to bless us: His word, which meets every requirement and ought to be quite enough for us.
The message ends by settling one question: whose fault was this?
God had been faithful to Israel, but Israel had not been faithful to God. This was the point of the prophet's testimony. He always proves His own conduct right: "If we are faithless, He remains faithful—for He cannot deny Himself." If we walked as He wants us to walk, nothing could prevail against us — not the world, not the flesh, not the devil. Whenever we find ourselves under the power of our enemies, we must be sure to charge the fault on ourselves, and not on God.
The prophet delivers no plan of escape. He simply goes.
Not a word about how they might be delivered; He did not yet open the way for their return to Him. The prophet disappeared, leaving them under the weight of their responsibility in the presence of grace. God had carried them in His arms and on His heart; He had fought for them. "Have I failed you in any way?" He asks. "But what have you done?" This silence would touch their conscience far more than any reproach. They were impressed, if not convicted. But the word of grace did not yet give the unfaithful people what they needed, and Israel remained powerless before the enemy.
- Cry — Recovery starts when God's people feel their own poverty. Until then the cry is only about the pain.
- Delay — The cry does not bring instant relief. We want out of the consequences; God wants us to judge the cause.
- Word — His answer is an unnamed man carrying His word, because the word itself is the means by which He blesses.
- Verdict — God had been faithful; Israel had not. When enemies get the upper hand, the fault is ours, never His.
- Silence — The prophet leaves with no remedy. That silence works on the conscience harder than any rebuke. Then God raises up the deliverer.
that Jehovah sent a prophet to the children of Israel, who said to them, Thus saith Jehovah the God of Israel I brought you up from Egypt, and brought you forth out of the house of bondage;
Israel cried out to the Lord in their misery, and God answered — but not first with a rescuer. He sent an unnamed prophet. The message begins not with Israel's trouble, but with what God had done for them long before.
The cry that went up was the cry of people in pain, not yet people in repentance. One writer notes how God answered.
When Israel at last cried out to the Lord (v. 7), they cried only because of their misery. So the Lord did not relieve them at once. He sent a prophet to press home to Israel that their own guilt was to blame for these troubles.
God sends a second messenger after the prophet, and the order matters.
Notice the Lord's twofold way of working. He sends first a prophet, then an angel. The prophet brings their sin home to their conscience; the angel raises up a deliverer. He loves to rescue His people from the miserable results of their failure, but He will have the evil owned first.
The man has no name and predicts nothing. That is no gap in the story. The word covers more than prediction.
So a prophet does not only mean someone who can predict future events. The messenger of God who rebuked Israel in the days of Gideon (Judges 6:8) was a prophet.
The prophet's first words point back to the rescue out of slavery. That backward look is the point: the God who acted then has not changed.
They could not have been poorer than they were. But when they felt that poverty and cried to the Lord in their distress, He met them — and He met them as the God of deliverances. He carried their thoughts back to what He had done for them in the past. He had brought them out of their captivity by a great deliverance... and had planted them in a rich inheritance, driving out all their enemies before them. He wanted them to know that He was the same God He had always been. They had changed, but He remained the everlasting God, whose strength cannot fade or fail.
The words "house of slavery" are more than background. One writer says that being bought out of slavery is the strongest motive God gives for obedience.
The fact is that redemption, even when it is only a picture of the greater redemption to come, is a stronger motive to obedience than creation itself... If the aim of all this part of Deuteronomy is to press obedience, then nothing keeps obedience alive like redemption. And if that was true when the deliverance was only an outward one, how much more when it is eternal?
The prophet's message does more than recall the past. It uncovers the cause of Israel's present trouble.
He first shows them their sin, as He did when they could not take the city of Ai. That is where the secret of their poverty comes to light. "You are crying to me now," He says in effect, "because you feel how poor you are. But the real cause of your poverty is this — you have sinned against me." They had no one to blame but themselves.
Another writer turns the same point on us.
God had been faithful to Israel, but Israel had not been faithful to God. This was the point of the prophet's testimony... Whenever we find ourselves under the power of our enemies, we must be careful to lay the blame on ourselves, and not on God.
- Cry — Israel cried out of misery, not repentance. So God did not relieve them at once. He sent a messenger to press their guilt home first.
- Word — God's first answer is a prophet, His second a deliverer. He rescues His people from the results of their failure, but He will have the evil owned first.
- Reminder — the message opens with Egypt because God is still the God of deliverances. Israel had changed; He had not.
- Claim — the house of slavery is the ground of God's claim. Nothing keeps obedience alive like the memory of being redeemed.
- Verdict — Israel's own sin, not any change in God, caused their poverty. When we find ourselves under the power of our enemies, the fault is ours.
and I delivered you out of the hand of the Egyptians, and out of the hand of all that oppressed you, and drove them out from before you, and gave you their land,
Midian had crushed Israel, and at last the people cried to the Lord. God's first answer was not a deliverer but an unnamed prophet. He pointed them back to the rescue God had already given them.
The chapter has two messengers, and the order matters.
Mark the twofold process of the Lord. He sends first a prophet, then an angel; the one to bring their sin home to their conscience, the other to raise up a deliverer. He loves to rescue His people from the wretched consequences of their failure, but He will have the evil owned first.
The delay between the cry and the rescue is not coldness. It carries a lesson for anyone trying to help others out of trouble.
What holy wisdom we have here. The people are bitterly oppressed, and they cry to God, but instead of sending relief at once, He deepens in their souls the sense of the evil of their course. Our first thought is to get out of the consequences of our folly and disobedience: God's desire is that we should thoroughly judge what led us into it. His patience and His pity combine in divine proportions, so that we may get the profit of the lesson. Let us not be too eager to deliver His people from an awkward position, but rather to see that they have been to the bottom of the matter with God.
Israel assumed the problem was Midian. The prophet's list of past rescues removes that excuse.
He first of all shows them their sin, as He did when they could not take Ai. There the secret of their impoverishment is found out. He in effect says: "You are crying to Me now because you feel your impoverishment. But the real cause of your impoverishment is this — you have sinned against Me." They had none to blame but themselves.
Another writer puts it the other way round: the enemy's size was never the deciding factor.
God is a faithful God and He sends a nameless prophet, and he tells the people the reason why they are in this condition. As we have said in previous lectures, this was not because the Midianites were more powerful than Israel. When Israel had God among them, and God fighting for them, it did not matter how great the enemy was. The battle was a foregone conclusion. God was with His people helping them.
The prophet's message defends God, not Israel.
God had been faithful to Israel, but Israel had not been faithful to God. This was the point of the prophet's testimony. He always vindicates His own conduct: "if we are faithless, He remains faithful — for He cannot deny Himself." If we were walking as He would have us, neither the world, nor the flesh, nor the devil could prevail against us. Whenever we find ourselves under the power of our enemies, we must be sure to charge the fault on ourselves, and not on God.
God starts where He always starts: with the rescue from Egypt.
He goes back, as He always does, to the redemption from Egypt — the pledge and the power for all other deliverances — and recalls to them what He had done. He had brought them into this land, had driven the enemy out of it, and told His people not to fear the false gods that the Amorites had served. How simple all this was. How impossible, we might say, ever to fear the powers of evil which had been overthrown. Yet they — and are they alone? — had not obeyed His voice.
The reminder was meant to produce a response.
As He had done many times before, He reminded them through the prophet that He had brought Israel up from Egypt, out of the house of slavery. He brought them to their present land and drove out their enemies before them. The amazing wonder of all this had failed to impress Israel enough to make them cling firmly to the Lord... How little effect God's Word had in their hearts: they did not obey His voice. This message should certainly have brought them down in repentant confession of their guilt, and it may have been so in some measure, for it was this that God was seeking.
- Cry — Misery drove Israel to call on God. The cry alone did not bring relief. God first deepened their sense of what had led them there.
- Cause — Their poverty came from their own sin, not from Midian's strength. With God among them, no enemy was too big.
- Record — God lists His own past rescues one by one. His faithfulness is plain, so the blame falls on Israel.
- Pledge — The rescue from Egypt is the guarantee of every later rescue. Fearing powers God has already beaten makes no sense.
- Confession — Mercy remembered is meant to lead to repentance. God sent the prophet before the deliverer, because He will have the evil owned first.
and I said to you, I am Jehovah your God; fear not the gods of the Amorites, in whose land ye dwell. But ye have not hearkened to my voice.
Israel is crying out under Midian's raids, and God answers — but not yet with a rescuer. Through an unnamed prophet He names Himself as their God, recalls all He has done, and ends with the charge that explains their misery.
Most of the prophet's message is kindness. Only at the end does it turn, and even then He offers no cure.
In a way full of grace, God applied His word to the conscience of the Israelites. He told them all that He had done for them. He led them out, gave them deliverance and victory, and brought them in. Then, having spread out all His goodness before them, He adds one word: "But you have not obeyed My voice." He said nothing about how He would deliver them. He did not yet open the way for their return to Him. The prophet disappeared. He left them under the weight of their responsibility, in the presence of grace... "Have I failed you in any way," He says, "but what have you done?" This silence would touch their conscience far more than any reproach could.
The command He recalls is specific: do not fear the gods of the people whose land you now live in. Those gods belonged to a beaten enemy.
He goes back, as He always does, to the redemption from Egypt. That rescue is the pledge and the power for every other deliverance. He reminds them of what He had done. He had brought them into this land and driven the enemy out of it. He told His people not to fear the false gods that the Amorites had served. How simple all this was. How impossible, we might say, ever to fear powers of evil that God had already overthrown. Yet they — and are they the only ones? — had not obeyed His voice.
The order matters. Before any deliverer appears in the story, a word arrives that shows the people what they are.
The deliverer has not yet come on the scene. First the Lord answers that cry. Through the mouth of a prophet He shows the people how they had departed from Him. The first great dealing of the Lord with the soul is to show it its failure and its abandonment of Him. The word of God pierces to the division of soul and of spirit, and discerns the thoughts and intentions of the heart. Its great work is to reveal to the soul its own condition. In the earlier age, the prophets did what the word does now.
The trouble did not come from the enemy's power. It came from something inside Israel.
The reason for their condition was their own unfaithfulness. They had disobeyed God's plain and clear word: have nothing to do with idolatry, and keep Him enshrined in their affections. The last word of John's first letter is, "Little children, keep yourselves from idols." That is not a negative statement. It is a very positive one. It simply means, "I want the affections of My people for Myself; I do not want interference from any other source."
The verse sets two records side by side: God's dealings, and Israel's response. Only one of them changed.
God had been faithful to Israel, but Israel had not been faithful to God. That was the point of the prophet's testimony. He always vindicates His own conduct. "If we are faithless, he remains faithful — for he cannot deny himself." If we walked as He would have us walk, the world, the flesh and the devil could not prevail against us. Whenever we find ourselves under the power of our enemies, we must charge the fault to ourselves, not to God... Nothing can weaken our hands but sin; "he who is in you is greater than he who is in the world."
The closing clause of the verse is treated as a diagnosis that reaches far past Midian.
But notice the solemn words at the end of verse 10: "But you have not obeyed my voice." Here lies the secret of the poverty and distress that had overwhelmed Israel, and here lies the secret of every difficulty and defeat, of all lack of spiritual prosperity and power. If we have to mourn today the poverty of the church generally, or the lack of freshness and blessing in our own souls, we may trace that condition back to disobedience to the Word of God.
- Grace first. God opens by listing what He gave — rescue from Egypt, victory, a land. Only after that goodness does the charge land.
- Then the claim. "I am the LORD your God" is the ground of the one command He recalls: do not fear gods that He had already defeated for them.
- Then the silence. The prophet names the failure, offers no cure, and leaves. The word reveals their condition before relief comes.
- Then the blame. Their poverty traces to their own disobedience, never to a change in God, who remains faithful and cannot deny Himself.
- Then us. God still wants His people's affections for Himself, and nothing but sin can weaken our hands.
And an angel of Jehovah came and sat under the terebinth that was in Ophrah, that [belonged] to Joash the Abi-ezrite. And his son Gideon threshed wheat in the winepress, to secure [it] from the Midianites.
Midian had overrun Israel, and Gideon was reduced to hiding grain from them. Then God moved. He sent no army — He sent a visitor to one man at work. Who is this visitor? Why is Gideon threshing in a winepress? And why did God's choice fall on him?
The cry of an oppressed people is met in two stages, and the second stage begins here.
First, the Lord sent a prophet to bring their sin home to their conscience. Then He sent an angel to raise up a deliverer. And He finds Gideon threshing wheat by the winepress to hide it from the Midianites.
Set this scene beside Joshua's conquest and Israel's fall is plain. Yet the comparison turns out in God's favour.
Joshua could place his foot on the necks of the kings of Canaan. Gideon had to thresh his wheat in a corner to hide it from the Midianites. The day of Joshua was marked by splendid victories; the day of Gideon was a day of small things. But the day of small things for man is the day of great things for God. So Gideon found it... His was a day of barley cakes and broken pitchers, not of astounding miracles and brilliant achievements. But God was with him; and this was enough.
The visitor under the tree is more than a messenger. The work He interrupts also carries a picture.
The angel of the Lord, who is the Lord Himself, came to the home of Gideon the son of Joash. He sat down and appeared to Gideon as he was threshing wheat by the winepress. There he could stay hidden from the Midianites (v.11). Gideon's threshing wheat is a picture of one studying the Word of God, separating the chaff of one's own ideas from the pure seed of the truth of God.
The verse names what Gideon was threshing, and that detail carries weight.
We may name this first qualification — feeding on Christ in secret. Wheat is surely a figure of Christ (see John 12:24; John 6:35). It was a time of great difficulty. Idols had taken the place of the Lord. So those who stayed faithful while everything fell apart could only worship the Lord alone and in private. It was the same with Gideon. Baal had an altar in his father's house. But this "mighty man of valor" threshed wheat alone to find food, despite the watchful eye of the Midianites. Alone in his family, and alone in threshing wheat, he gathered strength from communion with the Lord.
A winepress was the last place a raider would look for grain. The picture goes deeper.
The winepress reminds us of the blood of the grape, and of His blood which cleanses from all sin. It may well then suggest the cross, the winepress for Him. And the cross is a real shelter and hiding place for faith from all the power of the world. We take our place by the cross, and no Midianite dare dispute our position.
The verse records the names Joash and Abiezer. One writer reads them for their meaning.
His father was Joash, the son of Abiezer — "despairing," the son of "my father is help." The one who despairs of any other help, and knows his own weakness, will turn to the Father. In Him alone our help is found.
Nothing about the scene suggests a national deliverer. That is the point.
Nothing could have been more wretched than Gideon's condition here. He was threshing wheat in secret, for fear of the Midianites, to feed his family! But here is one whom the Spirit of God delights to mention; whose name, unrecorded by men, is thought worthy to be recorded by Him (Hebrews 11:32-34). The Spirit of God writes to magnify the grace of God, not to exalt man. He would have us remember small incidents like this one in the history of the soldiers of faith. Then we may see by what weak and insignificant instruments God works. His mightiest victories have always been won by such, and not by those who had resources in themselves.
- Hidden — God finds His deliverer in a winepress, doing in secret work that no one sees.
- Fed — The wheat he saved pictures Christ. Feeding on Him in secret is the first qualification for service.
- Sheltered — The winepress that hid him speaks of the cross. There faith takes a place the world cannot dispute.
- Weak — Nothing in Gideon's situation qualified him. The Spirit records the small details so the glory lands on God.
- Found — The Lord Himself came and sat down beside that hidden work. Man's day of small things became God's day of great things.
And the Angel of Jehovah appeared to him, and said to him, Jehovah is with thee, thou mighty man of valour.
Gideon is beating out wheat inside a winepress, hiding it from Midianite raiders, when a visitor greets him with a title that fits nobody in the scene. Who is speaking, and how can a man in hiding be called mighty?
The one who speaks is called "the angel of the LORD," but writers point out that He speaks and acts as God Himself:
An angel of the LORD (Jehovah) appeared to Gideon. He was a young man threshing wheat by the winepress, hiding it from the raiding Midianites. The Angel of the LORD, Jehovah Himself, astonished the young man by saying, "The LORD is with you, you mighty man of valour." At once He commissioned him to be the deliverer of Israel from the yoke of Midian.
The greeting lands in the poorest possible setting. One writer sets Gideon beside Joshua, who had once conquered this same land:
Joshua could put his foot on the necks of the kings of Canaan. Gideon had to thresh his wheat in a corner to hide it from the Midianites. The day of Joshua was marked by splendid victories; the day of Gideon was a day of small things. But the day of small things for man is the day of great things for God. So Gideon found it... His was a day of barley cakes and broken pitchers, not of astonishing miracles and brilliant achievements. But God was with him; and this was enough.
Nothing in the scene justified the title. But God saw courage in the very work that looked like fear:
At first sight he might seem like anything but a man of valour. He is in hiding. A man of valour would be facing the enemy, leading the people against them, and driving them from the land. But God does not see as man sees. He sees the valour in that determination to get the wheat at any cost. He knows the purposes of heart that are forming, even if Gideon himself does not know it. And He sees that it is all bound up with that lowly work of beating out the wheat.
The title was not praise for what Gideon already was. Nothing about him or his family pointed that way:
What a remarkable greeting! Secretly threshing wheat to hide it from the enemy did not look like valour! To the human eye everything about him showed a crushed spirit. But God's "mighty men" have always been complete cowards in themselves, men who distrusted their own strength and wisdom in facing the enemy — "out of weakness made strong." Nobody is a "mighty man of valour" except those to whom it has been said, "The Lord is with you." When God calls a person by a name, He makes that person what the name means; but He takes the lowest man of a lowly tribe to make him His "mighty man of valour."
Where, then, was the strength? Writers place it outside Gideon altogether:
"You mighty man of valour!" How hard it was for Gideon to take such astonishing words in! How difficult to apply them to himself! Where was the might, or where was the valour? Certainly not in himself or in his surroundings. Where then? In the living God; exactly where Joshua found his might and his valour.
Because the strength was God's, Gideon's smallness was beside the point:
Gideon's family might be the poorest in Manasseh, and he himself the least in his father's house. But what did Gideon's poverty or his weakness matter, if the Lord, who is rich and mighty, was for him and with him?
Gideon answers with a question about the whole nation, not about himself:
Gideon said to him, "Oh my Lord, if Jehovah is with us" — that is where he takes his stand. He says "if Jehovah is with us", not just "with me". He ties the people to the name of Jehovah, not just to himself. That is always the mark of true faith and love.
Gideon was slow to take that word for himself, and we are no different:
And yet Gideon was slow to make these words his own — slow to grasp them with that lovely appropriating power of faith which so delights the heart of God... We are prone to reason about ourselves and our situation, instead of believing God. We fail to rest quietly in His perfect love and unfailing faithfulness.
- Presence first. The Lord tells Gideon He is with him before He gives any command. The commission rests on that, not on Gideon's resources.
- Presence names. When God calls a person by a name, He makes that person what the name means.
- Presence sees. God read valour in a man secretly saving wheat, because He does not see as man sees.
- Presence supplies. The might is borrowed. It lies in the living God, where Joshua also found his, so Gideon's poverty counts for nothing.
- Presence must be believed. Gideon was slow to make the words his own. We face the same choice: reason about ourselves, or rest in His unfailing faithfulness.
And Gideon said to him, Ah my Lord, if Jehovah be with us, why then is all this befallen us? and where are all his miracles that our fathers told us of, saying, Did not Jehovah bring us up from Egypt? And now Jehovah hath cast us off, and given us into the hand of Midian.
A stranger greets Gideon as a mighty man of valour and tells him the LORD is with him. Gideon answers with a protest — the question every believer knows: if God is with us, why does everything look like He has left?
God's word to Gideon carried no conditions. Gideon answered it with one small word.
Here Gideon reasons from his surroundings. That is where the "if" comes from — that little word of unbelief. His surroundings were of the gloomiest kind. But one bright ray shone in on his depressed spirit. It came from the very heart of God, carried in one short but complete sentence: "The LORD is with you." There was no "if" in this — no doubt, no difficulty, no reserve, no condition. It needed only one thing to become a spring of joy, strength and victory in Gideon's soul: Gideon had to mix it with faith. But "if" is not faith. True faith never answers God with ifs, for the simplest of reasons: it looks only at God, and there are no ifs with Him.
Gideon asks why all this has happened, as if no one could say. His nation's own past held the answer.
If Gideon had looked back over his nation's history, he might have found plenty of reason for the sad and humbling state he was in. Those stained pages would have given a full answer to his question, "Why then has all this happened to us?" But had Israel's behaviour dimmed the brightness of the LORD's mighty wonders? Not in the sight of faith. God had done great and glorious things for His people, and the record of those deeds lay always under the eye of faith to sustain the soul. Israel had failed — failed shamefully — and the record of that failure lay under the eye of faith too. Faith recognises God's government as well as His grace. It bows in awe before every stroke of His governing rod.
The greeting was personal — the LORD is with you. Gideon refuses to keep it personal.
Gideon said to him, "Please, my lord, if the LORD is with us" — for on that he takes his stand — "if the LORD is with us" — not merely "with me." He binds the people together with the name of the LORD, and not merely with himself — the unfailing mark of true faith and love. "But now the LORD has forsaken us and given us into the hand of Midian." Both were true. It was the LORD who had blessed them. It was the LORD who had handed them over to Midian. That very fact, overwhelming as it is, is exactly what gives confidence. If the Midianites had simply got the better of Israel, that would be nothing for faith.
There is a right way to measure the state of God's people, and a wrong one.
He has a deep sense of Israel's condition on his soul, though he has no power to help them. He has been comparing that condition with the LORD's title and power. This is the way of faith. It is not for us to compare ourselves with each other; we should compare our condition with the LORD's title and will to bless.
Gideon drew his conclusion about God from the wrong starting point.
Gideon had much to learn. His faith was very weak, for he did not count on the goodness of God. Humble, no doubt, but looking at himself, he decided what God must be towards him from what he himself was. "Now," he said, "the LORD has forsaken us." The situation is hopeless, because it is the result of our unfaithfulness. That was Gideon's reasoning — but did God reason like that? "The LORD is with you, you mighty man of valour." How little he knew what was in the heart of God, and how many there are who reason like Gideon.
Gideon's protest is not weakness. It is what made him strong.
What was Gideon's might? It was his awareness that things were not what they ought to be. Things were different from what they used to be, and he wanted in his heart to do something to put them right. Suppose we see that things in our own lives, and in the shared testimony, are not as good as they used to be. That will make us ask why. Once we know, we will be very concerned, and we will spend prayer and energy to make it better. But if we go along quite comfortably saying, "Well, everything is all right," and are not much concerned, I do not think things will get better.
- The "if" exposes the eye. Gideon reasons up from his circumstances. Faith reasons down from God, who set no condition on "The LORD is with you."
- The "why" had an answer. Israel's own history explained the trouble. Faith bows before God's government as it rests in His grace.
- The "us" proves the man. He would not take the promise alone. Tying the whole people to God's name is the mark of true faith and love.
- The "forsaken" was a misreading. Gideon judged what God would be to him by what he was himself — the mistake of a humble man with weak faith.
- The ache became the might. The sense that things are wrong was Gideon's strength. If we are not concerned, things do not get better.
And Jehovah looked upon him, and said, Go in this thy might, and thou shalt save Israel from the hand of Midian. Have not I sent thee?
Gideon is saving wheat from raiders when God calls him a mighty man of valour and sends him to save Israel. The strength God points him to is a strength he cannot feel. The verse turns on two things: a look from God, and a question that ends all argument.
Some translations render the opening words as "the Lord looked upon him." The command to go is not the first thing in the verse. God turns toward Gideon first.
Here we have the true secret of strength: "The Lord looked upon him." There was divine power in this look, if Gideon could only have taken it in. But sadly, he was still full of questions.
That look is God taking sides. It puts God's own resources behind a man who has none.
Gideon sees the Lord's hand upon His people, and that it is because of sin. But he identifies himself with the people... The Lord looked upon him. That is the first thing. The man who is really strong and mighty is the one who has come into the secret of Israel's poverty in this way. The Lord has looked upon him. The Lord has identified Himself with him, and shown His heart to be towards him. There is no limit to the might of such a man.
God does not hand Gideon a new power. He points back to what Gideon was already doing: getting his own food at real risk.
It is such a man that God can use as His instrument to deliver Israel. Notice, He does not give him fresh might, but counts the might he had already shown as enough to deliver Israel... God emphasizes the courage of a faith that gets its own food at all hazards.
Where that might sits matters. It is not something Gideon owns.
Gideon, whose name means "a great warrior" (an overcomer), seeks to preserve the wheat from the enemy... The exercises of the threshing floor are plain to see. Self-importance, self-confidence and self-seeking have gone. His faith in what God has done and can do is clear. His "might" (v.14) is not connected with what he is in himself, but with his faith in God, and his obedience to God's command.
In the next verse Gideon lists his disadvantages: a poor family, and the smallest place in it. God's question does not answer that list. It ends it.
His family is poor in Manasseh, and like David, he is the least in his father's house. Yet, what of all this? "Have not I sent you?" withers up all such thoughts, and places a living reality before the soul.
The size of the instrument is not the question. The one who uses it is.
Unbelief turns the eye in upon self, or out upon our surroundings. It leads us to compare our visible resources with the work God is calling us to... It made very plain that the might he would deliver Israel with was not in himself or in his father's house. It was in the God of Israel. It mattered little whether his family was rich or poor; whether he was little or great. It was God who was about to use him. What was wealth or greatness to Him? He could use a barley cake or a broken pitcher.
Gideon feels smaller after the call than before it. For faith's soldiers that is normal, not failure.
So it always is with the soldiers of faith. They have never felt their own weakness so much as when they are called to be God's mighty men of valour... People often say, "I want to feel that I am strong." What we need is to feel that we are weak; this brings in Omnipotence. We shall have a life of feeling later on in the glory. Now we are called to live a life of faith.
What God saw in Gideon was not confidence but care for a beaten people.
Gideon might well wonder what might the Lord was speaking of, for Gideon only felt weakness. But Gideon had strength he was not aware of. He had a heart of true concern for his people, even while he felt his own helplessness. In God's eyes that was strength. Paul later learned this valuable lesson — "when I am weak, then I am strong" (2 Cor. 12:10).
- Look first. God turns toward Gideon before He commands him. The call carries its weight because God identifies Himself with the man.
- Might already shown. God gives no new power. He counts the courage Gideon has already shown as enough.
- Not in himself. His might lies in his faith in God and his obedience, not in his family, his rank or his resources.
- Sending settles it. God's question — "do not I send you?" — ends the list of disadvantages. He is the one using the instrument, and He can work with a barley cake or a broken pitcher.
- Weakness admits Omnipotence. Faith's soldiers feel weakest when God calls them. A heart burdened for God's people is strength in His eyes.
And he said to him, Ah Lord, wherewith shall I save Israel? behold, my thousand is the poorest in Manasseh, and I am the least in my father's house.
God has just told Gideon to go and save Israel. Gideon answers by measuring the job against his family record: his clan is the weakest, and he is the least in it. Does a man's sense of his own nothingness rule him out of God's service, or is it the very thing that makes him useful?
Gideon is not exaggerating. One writer lays out the details side by side.
He himself was even weaker than his people. He had no confidence in front of the enemy, for he was "beating out wheat in the winepress to hide it from the Midianites" (v. 11). He had no resources among his relatives, for his family was the poorest in Manasseh. He had no power in himself, for he was the least in his father's house (v. 15). That was the man God visited and chose as His servant — a man who knew how utterly weak he was... When it comes to the work of God in this world, we meet a first great principle: God never asks what man can offer Him.
Writers do not treat this confession as a setback. They call it a qualification, and it moves the question away from Gideon altogether.
Here we get another very important qualification — a sense of his own nothingness... And all the Lord's servants must learn this lesson sooner or later. There is nothing in themselves, in their position, or in their circumstances that God can use. In a word, all our resources and all our strength lie outside of ourselves, in Him. Our sufficiency is of God. It is then no longer a question of what the Midianites are, but of what God is, for we go to meet them in His strength.
God lets Gideon feel his poverty at the very moment He sends him. The reason concerns who gets the credit for the victory.
When God is about to use a man, He makes that man keenly aware that he is nothing in himself. If He delivers by Gideon's hand, He must have the glory, not Gideon. The strength must be His, not Gideon's. Strong in the Lord, we are weakest in ourselves. Can we not nearly always trace our failures back to self-confidence?
Not every writer treats the reply as pure humility. Gideon asks what he has to save Israel with, and that question points him the wrong way.
Unbelief turns the eye in on self, or out on our surroundings. It leads us to compare the resources we can see with the work God is calling us to... God's word left no room for Gideon's "how?" It made it very plain that the might he was to deliver Israel with was not in himself or in his father's house, but in the God of Israel. It mattered little whether his family was rich or poor, whether he was small or great. It was God who was about to use him.
Another writer puts it more sharply still — a low view of yourself can be as much a hindrance as a high one.
But Gideon, like Moses and many another servant of God, has to come right to the end of himself. He must be done with his humility as well as his pride... He speaks of the poverty of his family, and of how small he is in his father's house. But what have these to do with the living God?
God never disputes the facts Gideon lists. He answers with two things: a commission and a promise of His presence.
First, we have God's commission, wrapped up in those weighty words, "Do not I send you?" Second, we have the assurance of God's presence, set out in these encouraging words, "But I will be with you."
Once those two are in place, the size of Gideon's clan stops counting. The same pattern shows up later in Israel's history.
Gideon's family might be the poorest in Manasseh, and he himself the least in his father's house. But what did Gideon's poverty or his weakness matter, if the Lord, who is rich and mighty, was for him and with him? So, in a later day, Jonathan and his armour-bearer could face a huge army in the might of the Lord. As Jonathan said, "nothing can hinder the LORD from saving by many or by few" (1 Samuel 14:6).
- Least is true. Gideon's account of himself is honest at every level: hiding from the enemy, poorest clan, smallest man in the house.
- Least is the qualification. Writers call his sense of his own nothingness a qualification for service, not a disqualification.
- Least protects the glory. God makes a man feel he is nothing, so that God gets the glory for the rescue and the man does not.
- Least can still be unbelief. His "how?" turned his eye inward. One writer says he had to finish with his humility as well as his pride.
- Least plus God is enough. God's reply is a commission and a promise: "Do not I send you?" and "But I will be with you." Poverty stops counting when the Lord who is rich and mighty is the one sending.
And Jehovah said to him, I will certainly be with thee; and thou shalt smite Midian as one man.
Gideon has just answered God's call by pointing to his poor clan and his own low place in it. The reply never argues with him: it promises God's own presence, and a whole army falling as if it were one man.
Gideon asked what he was supposed to fight with. God's answer names no weapon. It names His presence, and the victory follows from that. (Older translations read "Surely I will be with you"; the ESV has "But I will be with you.")
As with David in another fight of faith, there was no sword in Gideon's hand, nothing at all to go against the Midianites with. But what does that matter? "If God is for us, who can be against us?" He does not go out unarmed. "Surely I will be with you [and as a consequence of that], you shall strike the Midianites as one man."
The call stands whether Gideon feels ready or not.
The Lord allows Gideon no excuse. He has called Gideon and Gideon must obey. But He encourages Gideon by His Word.
The promise comes only after Gideon sees himself as nothing. That emptiness is not a delay in the story. It is the preparation.
He was now in the place where God's power could come upon and use him. The same was true of the apostle Paul. The thorn in the flesh searched his heart. It brought him face to face with his own complete powerlessness, and with his lack of any natural fitness for the Lord's service. Only then could the Lord say to him, "My grace is sufficient for you." Every servant of the Lord must learn this lesson sooner or later. There is nothing in ourselves, in our position, or in our circumstances that God can use. In a word, all our resources and strength lie outside ourselves, in Himself.
Commentators differ on how to read Gideon's protest. Dennett hears humility that fitted him for service. Ridout hears "humble pride" — a fault, though one word from God was enough to remove it.
Believing that all power belongs to God is not the same as seeing that power move on your behalf. Without the second, the first can crush a person.
There is a great difference between owning that all power belongs to God, and seeing that power act on our behalf. Often the first conviction only makes us feel our own powerlessness more. And unless we can rest on God acting for us and through us, that feeling will produce despondency. Gideon cannot see how a link can be formed between God and man, so that a man carries out God's power and will. So he pleads how small and unfit he is. To form this link in his soul, the Lord gives him a promise.
God's promise does not reduce the number of Midianites. It changes how faith counts them.
See with what grace God rebukes this bit of humble pride in Gideon. It clearly was not deep-seated: one word was enough to displace it. "Surely I will be with you, and you shall strike the Midianites as one man." After all, the enemy is, for faith, but a single one. He is a whole army when he oppresses and terrifies. But the moment faith asserts itself, there is only one man, as when David met the giant.
If all the strength is God's, the size or ability of the person He sends stops mattering. That truth kills two opposite errors at once.
The humbler the instrument, the more we see the power of God. What difference does it make to the Almighty God whether His instrument is left-handed or right-handed — a man or a woman — a dwarf or a giant? The instrument is nothing. God is all in all... Let us remember these things, so that we may walk humbly and lean always and only on the mighty arm of the living God. This keeps the soul well balanced. It is free from self-confidence and the excitement of the flesh on one side, and from gloom and depression on the other. If we can do nothing, self-confidence is the height of presumption. If God can do everything, despondency is the height of folly.
- Emptied. Gideon's sense of being the least is not an obstacle God has to work around. It is the place where God's power can rest on a man, as it rested on Paul.
- Promised. God answers that emptiness with no argument and no weapon. He answers with Himself, and one word forms the link between His power and a weak man.
- Consequence. The victory hangs on the first half of the sentence. Because He is with Gideon, and only because of that, Midian falls.
- Shrunken. The moment faith stirs, a terrifying army counts as one man. David saw the same thing when he faced the giant.
- Balanced. We can do nothing, so self-confidence is presumption. God can do everything, so gloom is folly. His presence removes both.
And he said to him, If now I have found favour in thine eyes, shew me a sign that it is thou who talkest with me.
The Lord has just promised Gideon His presence and victory over Midian. Gideon's answer is to ask for proof that the speaker under the oak is who He says He is. So is this a weak believer's fear, or a real faith reaching out — and why does God give the sign instead of rebuking him?
Gideon asks for a sign after God has already given His word. One writer names both the weakness in that and the one thing Gideon truly wanted.
There is weakness here, no doubt; he should have had simple confidence and not needed a sign. Still, all he really cares for is having the Lord with him.
Another writer puts Gideon beside others who asked God to say more than He had already said.
Unbelief then draws its plea from the Lord. It assumes, as it were, that there was something unclear in the revelation God has just given. "If you are the Christ, tell us plainly." Gideon was in this frame of mind in Judges 6:17; and John the Baptist, in his measure, in Matthew 11:3.
One writer admits the weakness in Gideon's asking, then points to what came after it.
He asks for a sign, it is true; and the Lord answers. I am far from denying that there was weakness in Gideon's faith. Nor am I saying there was no drawback here, as with all the others we have looked at. But even allowing all this, we must admit what followed. After the Lord stooped in grace to his weakness, we find the power of God at work in his heart and in his ways.
Gideon also wants to bring the visitor a gift. One writer sees in that wish how much Gideon still had to learn about himself.
His faith was very weak, because he did not count on the goodness of God. He was humble, no doubt, but he looked at himself, and from what he was he decided what God must be to him. Even with his humility, there had not yet been true self-judgment. He wanted to offer something, to "bring forth his present" to the Lord (v. 18). He was not trying to do something great for God. He thought that all would be well if God accepted his gift.
The Lord's reply changes what the gift is. He tells Gideon to lay it on the rock.
We have already seen that Gideon wanted to offer something to the Lord, but He can accept nothing from man as such. "Take the flesh and the unleavened cakes," He said, "and lay them on this rock, and pour out the broth" (v. 20). The only offering God can accept is Christ. If He did not receive what Gideon offered Him, He accepted what represented Christ in it.
Another writer looks at what Gideon laid on the rock and at the fire that took it up. In that, he says, the sign itself becomes a picture of Christ.
All is put on the rock, another figure of Christ, and fire carries it all up to God. So we might say he brought nothing but Christ, whom God always accepts. What better sign could he, or we, want than that? Suppose we have nothing but Christ, His work and His person. Then God's acceptance of Him is our fullest assurance and pledge that we shall be "more than conquerors through him who loved us."
The sign leads to a discovery Gideon had not asked for. Seeing the angel face to face terrifies him, and God's reply settles him.
Gideon cried "alas!" and the Lord answered, "Peace; do not fear." Then he was ready to begin. The Lord had brought him face to face with the angel of God. There he learned that his family was poor in Manasseh and that he was the least in his father's house. He learned more than that: in himself he had no power at all, and all his resources must come from the living God.
Peace is not only relief for Gideon. Another writer counts it as part of what fits a person for service.
From the Lord he gets a further qualification for service: a soul at liberty, at peace before God... Everyone will understand that there can be no true or effective service for the Lord while the soul is taken up with its own condition. It must first be free and at home in God's presence.
- Word first. God had already promised His presence; the request for a sign came after the promise, not before it.
- Weakness met. God stooped to Gideon's weak faith instead of rebuking it. His power then worked in Gideon's heart and ways.
- Gift refused. God could not accept Gideon's gift from him as he was. He took only what represented Christ in it.
- Sign given. Fire from the rock burned up the offering. The answer was God's acceptance of Christ, not just a proof of who was speaking.
- Peace produced. The encounter ended in "peace, do not fear," and that freed soul — not the sign itself — was what made him ready to serve.
Depart not hence, I pray thee, until I come unto thee, and bring forth my present, and set it before thee. And he said, I will tarry until thou come again.
God has just promised Gideon that he will strike down Midian. Instead of moving out, Gideon asks his visitor to wait while he fetches something to set before Him. The verse holds two things at once: a man who still needs proof, and a Lord who is willing to wait for him.
Gideon asks for a sign right after a direct promise. Commentators call that weak faith — and still point to what he wants most.
There is weakness here, no doubt; he should have had simple confidence, and not have needed a sign. Still, all he really cares about is having Jehovah with him.
God had already given the promise. Gideon needed something else before he could act on it.
Great as this promise was, Gideon could not yet take it as his own. However wonderful and fitting it was, he could not embrace it. First he had to feel in his own soul the link between himself and God, and know that God accepted him... He had asked for a sign so that his soul could trust the help God promised — in a word, so that he might depend on Him in the great service given to him.
Gideon wants to bring "my present" to his visitor. One writer asks what that impulse says about the man.
Moreover, despite his humility, he had not yet truly judged himself. He wanted to offer something, to "bring out his present" to Jehovah (v. 18). It was surely not with the idea of doing something great for God, but with the thought that all would be well if God accepted his present.
Gideon already has God's word, and still asks Him to stay. The answer he gets is a kindness.
But Gideon wants more confirmation, as though he needed it once God had given him His word! Yet the Lord graciously answered Gideon's request and stayed until Gideon brought an offering (v. 18). To Gideon's credit, the offering was very fitting. The young goat is a picture of Christ as the Substitute for the sinner — and Gideon knew he needed a Substitute.
Gideon brings his present. God never takes it from his hands as a gift. He sends it to the rock instead.
We have already seen that Gideon wanted to offer something to Jehovah, but He can accept nothing from man as man. "Take the flesh and the unleavened cakes," He said, "and lay them on this rock, and pour the broth over them" (v. 20). The only offering God can accept is Christ. He did not receive what Gideon offered Him, but He accepted what represented Christ in it.
Gideon wanted proof that he was speaking with God. What he brought to the rock turned out to be the proof.
More than that, Gideon wants to bring an offering; he will be a worshipper. So he brings a young goat, flour and unleavened cakes. All these speak of Christ... It is all put on the rock, another figure of Christ, and fire carries it all up to God. So we might say he brought nothing but Christ, whom God always accepts. What better sign could he — or we — want than that? If we have nothing but Christ, His work and His person, we may be sure that God's acceptance of Him is the fullest assurance and pledge that we shall be "more than conquerors through Him who loved us."
Gideon asked for a sign. What he got was a lesson about himself.
His "Alas!" was followed by the Lord's "Peace; do not fear," and then he was ready to begin. He had been brought face to face with the angel of God. There he learned that his family was poor in Manasseh and he the least in his father's house. He also learned that in himself he was completely powerless, and that he must find all his resources in the living God.
- Ask. Gideon's plea for a sign was weak faith. He should have rested on the word already given. Yet what he wanted was the Lord's presence, not an excuse.
- Wait. "I will stay till you return." God grants what He does not owe, and meets a man where his faith stands.
- Bring. The "present" exposed a heart that still thought all would be well if God accepted his gift. Gideon had not yet judged himself.
- Exchange. God takes nothing from man as man. He moves the gift onto the rock and accepts only what pictures Christ in it.
- Send. The sign and the worship are one act. Face to face with God, Gideon learns he is powerless, hears "Peace; do not fear," and is ready to begin.
And Gideon went in, and made ready a kid of the goats, and an ephah of flour in unleavened cakes the flesh he put in a basket, and he put the broth in a pot, and brought it out to him under the terebinth, and presented it.
God has just told Gideon to go and save Israel. Gideon asks the visitor under the tree to wait while he goes home and prepares a meal. Was this food for a guest, or an offering to God?
Gideon had already been given God's word and God's promise. Bringing out his present was his way of finding out whether the one speaking to him was who he seemed to be.
Gideon would prove, then, his visitor with an offering, and significantly brings him Abraham's offering of an ephah — that is, three measures — of flour; but Abraham's gift is of fine flour; and instead of Abraham's calf he brings a kid. Though less full a type than that in Genesis, Gideon's offering still speaks of Christ.
There was something unfinished in the impulse. One writer reads Gideon's request in verse 18 as the mark of a man who had not yet stopped measuring God by himself:
Yet despite his humility, he had not yet truly judged himself. He wanted to offer something, to bring out his present to the LORD (v. 18). He did not mean to do some great thing for God. He was thinking, no doubt, that all would be well if God accepted his present.
The items are not random. Each one is a familiar element of Israel's sacrifices, and commentators read them together as a picture of Christ.
More than that, Gideon wants to bring an offering. He will be a worshiper. So he brings the familiar sacrifice — a kid, an ephah of flour and unleavened cakes. All these speak of Christ. The kid here seems to be a peace-offering, yet it also brings sin to mind, since it was the animal most often used for sin in the offerings of the law. It reminds us of Christ made sin for us, and also of the One who is fully acceptable to God. The unleavened cakes and the fine flour belong with the kid. They recall the spotless person of Christ, as the kid pictured His work... If we have nothing but Christ, His work and His person, we can be sure that God's acceptance of Him is the fullest pledge that we shall be "more than conquerors through Him who loved us."
The amount of flour matters. The same measure turns up at only two other meetings with God.
Three measures is the same amount as an ephah. Only three other passages in Scripture speak of this quantity of flour, and in every one it is without leaven. Abraham offered cakes of this quantity to the three visitors at his tent door, and he recognised one of them to be his Lord. Gideon did the same when the Angel of the LORD appeared to him as he threshed wheat. Hannah brought this much flour as her offering when she presented Samuel to the Lord at the tabernacle at Shiloh (Gen. 18:1–8; Jdg. 6:19; 1 Sam. 1:24).
Commentators differ over the broth. One takes it as evidence of how little Gideon grasped:
This man of God understood very little of the value of the sacrifices the LORD had commanded Israel. The broth in the pot showed how little he knew. But God saw what was real underneath this feeble faith, and accepted the offering when Gideon laid it on the rock.
Another writer reads the broth in Gideon's favour:
To Gideon's credit, the offering was very fitting. The young goat is typical of Christ as the Substitute for the sinner, and Gideon knew that he needed a Substitute. The broth seems to show how much the offerer valued the sacrifice, since broth is easy to take in.
Gideon brought food to eat. The visitor told him to put it on a rock instead.
We have already seen that Gideon wished to offer something to the LORD, but He can accept nothing from man as such. "Take the meat and the unleavened cakes, and put them on this rock, and pour the broth over them," He said (v. 20). The only offering which God can accept is Christ. If He did not receive what Gideon offered Him, He accepted what represented Christ in it. The fire of judgment rose up out of the rock and consumed the meat and the unleavened cakes. The proof of God's interest in him was, in figure, the judgment that fell on Christ.
The fire left Gideon in terror. One writer shows what took the terror away:
God had revealed Himself to His servant, and the effect was terror. But the terror passed away when the LORD spoke peace to him. We need not say more about this, since it is the story of every soul that God brings into His presence... While the soul is taken up with its own condition, there can be no true or effective service for the Lord. That service comes only when the soul is set free and at home in God's presence.
- Brought. Gideon was humble, yet he still hoped that all would be well if God accepted his present.
- Christ. The goat, the unleavened cakes and the flour all speak of Christ — the goat of His work, the flour of His spotless person.
- Measured. Abraham and Hannah brought this same ephah of flour, each time without leaven, each time to God.
- Refused. God took nothing from Gideon's hands. Fire consumed the food on the rock, and God accepted it only for what it stood for: Christ.
- Freed. After the fire the LORD spoke peace to Gideon, and only a soul at rest in God's presence can serve God.
And the Angel of God said to him, Take the flesh and the unleavened cakes, and lay them upon this rock, and pour out the broth. And he did so.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And the Angel of Jehovah put forth the end of the staff that was in his hand, and touched the flesh and the unleavened cakes; and there rose up fire out of the rock, and consumed the flesh and the unleavened cakes. And the Angel of Jehovah departed out of his sight.
Gideon had asked for a sign that it was really the LORD speaking to him. He brought out a meal — a young goat, unleavened cakes and broth. What came back was not power over Midian, but fire on an offering. Commentators see the cross in that moment.
The angel refused the meal as a meal. He told Gideon to lay the meat and the cakes on the rock and pour the broth away. Henri Rossier sees in that God's refusal of anything a man brings on his own:
We have already seen that Gideon wanted to offer something to the LORD, but He can accept nothing that comes from man himself. "Take," He said, "the flesh and the unleavened cakes, and lay them upon this rock, and pour out the broth" (v. 20). The only offering God can accept is Christ. He did not receive what Gideon offered Him, but He accepted what represented Christ in it.
Each part of the meal is a picture. The goat, the cakes and even the rock they lie on point one way. Samuel Ridout says the sign Gideon was given is the sign we still rest on:
The kid here seems to be a peace offering, but it also suggests sin, since that is what it was most often used for in Israel's sacrifices. So it reminds us of Christ made sin for us, and also of the One who is perfectly acceptable to God. The unleavened cakes and the fine flour belong with the kid, and recall the spotless person of Christ, as the kid recalled His work. It all goes on the rock, another figure of Christ, and fire carries it all up to God. So we might say he brought nothing but Christ, whom God always accepts. What better sign could he, or we, want than that?
The fire does not fall from the sky. It comes up out of the rock the offering rests on. Rossier calls that fire judgment. He notes that Gideon's pot of broth showed how little he understood:
This man of God understood very little of the value of the sacrifices the LORD had commanded Israel. "The broth in the pot" showed his ignorance. But God saw what was real under this weak faith, and He accepted the offering when Gideon laid it "on the rock." The fire of judgment rose up out of the rock and consumed the flesh and the unleavened cakes. The proof that God cared for him was, in picture, the judgment that fell on Christ.
The angel does not eat the meal. He touches it, and then He leaves. One writer compares the scene with Abraham's visitor in Genesis:
Gideon's offering is a less full picture than the one in Genesis, but it still speaks of Christ. The angel holds back more here than there, but there is still acceptance. At his direction Gideon places the offering on the rock. The angel touches it with his staff, and it goes up in fire as an accepted offering. Then the angel himself leaves. There is no power here for lasting communion, as there was with Abraham. Yet Christ, as Representative of His people, accepted in sacrifice on the cross, is declared the ground on which God can be with them to deliver them. And this is the true assurance of ability for the Gideons of any generation.
God had already called Gideon and given him a promise. But one writer says the sign met a deeper need first:
Great as this promise was, Gideon could not yet make it his own. He could not take hold of it until he felt in his own soul the link between himself and God, and was sure of his own acceptance. So the Lord accepts the offering, has it consumed by a miracle, and disappears from Gideon's sight. In this way He gives him unquestionable proof not only of His own presence and power, but also of His servant's acceptance with Him.
Another writer turns this into a warning for anyone busy in God's work:
Faith has something to bring to God that He can accept. Whatever our own failure, Jesus is the same, and the value of His work is unchanged... God never says to a soul, "Peace be to you, fear not," because of service. We are in danger of putting service in the place of the burnt offering.
- Brought — Gideon brought a meal; God would only take a sacrifice. What He accepted was not Gideon's gift but what represented Christ in it.
- Laid — kid, unleavened cakes and rock are all read as figures of Christ, so that Gideon effectively "brought nothing but Christ, whom God ever accepts."
- Burned — the fire came up out of the rock, a picture of judgment falling on Christ instead of on the man who brought it.
- Accepted — the broth showed how little Gideon understood. Yet "God saw what was real under this weak faith." Faith that is weak but rests on Christ is still accepted.
- Sent — the sign proved "His servant's acceptance with Him." Service never earns the words "Peace be to you"; it follows them.
And Gideon perceived that he was an angel of Jehovah; and Gideon said, Alas, Lord Jehovah! for because I have seen an angel of Jehovah face to face ...
Fire has just leapt from the rock and burned up the meal Gideon prepared. His visitor then vanished, and only then does the truth hit him. His cry is not joy but alarm. He now knows who had been standing in front of him, and he expects that meeting to cost him his life.
Gideon does not say he saw "an angel" in general terms. The title he uses is far weightier. It explains why he feared for his life — and also what he did not actually see.
It troubled Gideon to realise how great this person was whom he had seen — the Angel of the Lord, not just "an angel" (v. 22). For God had said to Moses, "man shall not see me and live" (Ex. 33:20). It is true that God's glory is too great for us to take in. But the Angel (the Lord Jesus) had appeared to Gideon in the form of a man. So Gideon did not see the greatness of God's glory, but only a very limited showing of God.
What changed here was not the visitor, but what Gideon understood — and the dread did not last.
Gideon does not seem to realise that he has been face to face with the angel of the Lord until He has departed. Then he is overwhelmed with the solemn fact, and dreads the consequences. But grace quickly reassures him, and he builds an altar to the Lord — Jehovah-Shalom, "Jehovah is Peace."
This dread was not a one-off panic. Meeting this visitor had the same effect on others in the Old Testament. And it had to happen before Gideon could fight anyone.
The presence of God withered him up, and he knew it. That is the usual effect, seen again and again in the Old Testament, of meeting the one called there the angel of Jehovah. The very thing that passed the sentence of death on his nature also strengthened him. So Gideon builds an altar, trusting the word given to him... This is the prime necessity — peace, then work; but no service is safe until the person is secure and at peace.
Commentators differ on how to read Gideon's alarm. Some see the normal effect of God drawing near. One writer compares Gideon with Abraham, and calls his fear weakness.
This is another mark of weakness. We do not see this fear in Abraham, in similar circumstances. But Jehovah will give Gideon the confidence to stand before Him.
Gideon's instinct — that being this close to God should finish him — was not superstition. One writer takes it as an accurate verdict on human nature, and as the very thing that fits a person for battle.
He is now certain that he has seen the angel of Jehovah face to face. That very certainty makes him afraid, until His word calms him: he will not die. For us too, whenever we grasp that the Lord is present, we also feel the sentence passed on the flesh. This is where the power to walk rightly comes from, and the energy for the warfare we are called to. "Now my eye sees you; therefore I despise myself." Christ crucified confirms this sentence, and He is also our deliverance from ourselves. So, "crucified with Christ," we may still live — no longer we, but Christ living in us.
One meeting did two things to Gideon at the same time.
Gideon had spoken to Him with a secret sense that it was Jehovah. Now he knows for certain: he has seen the angel of Jehovah, of God, face to face. It was a real revelation. It was enough to reduce him to nothing in himself, and that is what it did. But it was also enough to make him strong in his walk among others, who had not known Jehovah in the same way.
- Face — The one Gideon met was the Angel of the Lord, whom one writer names as the Lord Jesus. His terror fits who was standing there.
- Fear — The dread only broke over him once the visitor had gone, and it rested on a known word: no one sees God and lives.
- Flesh — That fear is an accurate sentence on human nature. Anyone brought near to God feels it, and Scripture says: "now my eye sees you; therefore I despise myself."
- Freedom — The sentence of death on self is not the end of Gideon. It is the start of his usefulness. Reduced to nothing in himself, he is made strong to stand among people who had never met God like this.
- First things first — Peace comes before work. No service is safe while the servant is unsettled with God. Commentators differ on whether Gideon's alarm was weakness or the right response.
And Jehovah said to him, Peace be unto thee fear not; thou shalt not die.
Gideon has just realised who his visitor was, and he is sure the sight will cost him his life. God answers with a word of peace, and commentators treat it as the moment Gideon became fit for service.
His fear was not superstition. It rested on a word God had already spoken.
Gideon was troubled when he realised the greatness of the person he had seen. It was the Angel of the Lord, not simply "an angel" (v. 22). For God had said to Moses, "man shall not see me and live" (Ex. 33:20). It is true that God's glory is so great that we cannot take it in. But the Angel (the Lord Jesus) had appeared to Gideon in the form of a man. So Gideon did not see the greatness of God's glory, but only a very limited showing of God.
Nothing Gideon does changes him. God's word does the work, and the same pattern runs through Scripture.
Now Gideon knows that he had seen an angel of the Lord face to face, and he is filled with fear. But the Lord said to him, "Peace be to you. Do not fear; you shall not die." So he receives from the Lord a further qualification for service — a soul at liberty, at peace before God. God had revealed Himself to His servant, and the effect was terror. But the terror passed away when the Lord spoke peace. We need not enlarge on this, as it is the history of every soul brought into the presence of God (see Isa. 6; Job 42; Luke 5).
God speaks peace right after fire consumed the offering on the rock. That order matters.
The fire of judgment consumed the offering, and the result for Gideon was peace. To be a servant of God, you must know the work of Christ for yourself, and the peace that flows from it. You must be sure that peace has been made, because of what has passed between God and Christ. You must be sure of what God, and not Gideon, thought of the sacrifice. Such is the foundation of all Christian service — how much it has been forgotten! If we have not peace ourselves, how can we proclaim it to others?
One writer turns this into a warning about service.
Whatever our own failure, Jesus is still the same, and the value of His work is unchanged. God never says to a soul, "Peace be to you. Do not fear," because of service. We are in danger of putting service in the place of the burnt offering.
The same answer of peace appears again later in Scripture.
Here we have the answer that produces peace, and, with peace, worship. It is the same with the risen Jesus. After suffering death, He reveals Himself to His disciples with the same words God uses here, and lays the foundation of the Church gathered together in worship. In Luke 7 we find the same experiences in the woman who was a sinner. She believed in the person of Jesus. His grace had made Him her all; but she did not yet know that someone like her was pardoned and saved, and might go in peace.
This meeting left its mark on Gideon in two opposite ways.
It was a real revelation. It was enough to reduce him to nothing in himself, and it did. But it was also enough to strengthen him greatly in his walk among others who had not known the Lord in the same way. God may not use visions like this now, but it is always like this when He raises up a special instrument to deliver His people.
Gideon takes God at His word and acts on it.
The very thing that put the sentence of death on his nature made Gideon strong. He builds an altar, trusting the word given him, and calls it Jehovah-shalom. So he lays hold of the word of peace and acts on it at once… There is no ground for deliverance in God's way. There is no proper basis for His intervention, except the removal of all barriers between God and our souls. This is the prime necessity — peace, then work; no service is safe until the person himself is settled and at peace.
- Fear. Gideon expects to die. He has seen the Angel of the Lord face to face, and God had said, "man shall not see me and live."
- Word. The terror does not fade on its own. God's spoken word of peace ends it.
- Ground. Peace came after the fire consumed the offering. It rests on the accepted sacrifice, never on the servant's work.
- Reach. The risen Christ greets His disciples with the same words, and a sinful woman in Luke 7 learned that someone like her could go in peace.
- Order. Peace first, then worship, then work: no service is safe until the servant himself is at rest before God.
And Gideon built there an altar to Jehovah, and called it Jehovah-shalom. To this day it is yet in Ophrah of the Abi-ezrites.
Gideon has just met the angel of the LORD, feared he would die for it, and been told instead that peace was his. He does not march out against Midian. He builds. The name he gives the altar, "The LORD Is Peace," raises two questions: what peace does God give, and why would a man on the edge of war set it in stone?
The name is not a report on Gideon's feelings. It is a statement about God Himself. One writer says the name says more than "we have peace with God" — and that such an altar leaves no room for Baal's.
Gideon, therefore, builds an altar, and calls it Jehovah-shalom — "Jehovah is peace." It is not just that there is peace with God. That would not even be the way to say it, since Jehovah is already the covenant name. No; Jehovah is peace. Peace is found in Him. He has produced it and given it. Whatever the fear, the soul takes shelter in Him. And since this is so, the altar itself is now a challenge to the idols. Jehovah's altar cannot stand beside Baal's, and Israel cannot be delivered with a divided faith.
The name is also an echo. Gideon took the very word God had spoken over him and wrote it above an altar.
A man who is humbled by the presence of God receives strength from God, if that presence is in blessing. Gideon recognises and lays hold of this for himself: Jehovah is with him in peace and in blessing. The word Shalom, translated "Peace be to you," is the same as that used in the name of the altar.
The altar follows an offering. In the verses just before, fire consumed it on a rock.
Then he built an altar and called it "Jehovah-shalom" — the LORD is peace. All is full of meaning. The offering he brought typifies Christ; so does the rock upon which it was brought. The fire consumed it all, carried it upward to God. And upon that the assurance of peace is given. Even so He is our peace... So we need not fear, for He has made peace through the blood of His cross, and He is our peace.
Gideon was called to fight. Yet his first act was to build a place of worship. Writers say that order still holds.
The immediate consequence in Gideon's case was — and this gives us a further qualification — that he became a worshipper. He worships God in the character in which He had revealed Himself — as Jehovah who had spoken peace to his soul. The sequence is very instructive. First peace, then worship. The lesson is that only those who have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ can worship... The true servant must first be a worshipper. To go out in service before we are worshippers is to go out knowing nothing of the character of the One we claim to serve.
Another writer applies the order to us.
The first result of what Gideon had just learned was not to press him into service, but to make him a worshipper. Christians today have completely lost sight of this fact... The believer should enter the presence of God as a worshipper before engaging in service.
Nothing in Gideon's circumstances had changed when he named the altar. The fighting was still ahead of him.
Gideon does not seem to realise that he has been face to face with the angel of the LORD until He has departed. Then he is overwhelmed with the solemn fact, and dreads the consequences. But grace quickly reassures him, and he builds an altar to the LORD — Jehovah-Shalom, "Jehovah is Peace." Tumult raged all around him, and dreadful conflicts were soon to come. Yet there was one place where all was perfect peace, one Person with whom there was no conflict — Jehovah Himself.
Gideon knew his own weakness, and his people's.
He felt the ruin and the weakness of all around him. He felt the fallen and humiliating condition of his beloved people. He felt his own littleness, yes, his own emptiness and nothingness. How could he come forward? How could he strike the Midianites? How could he save Israel?
- Peace given. The name means Jehovah is peace — peace is found in Him, produced and given by Him, and the fearful soul shelters in Him.
- Peace grounded. It rests on the offering the fire consumed on the rock, a picture of Christ, who made peace by the blood of His cross.
- Peace worshipped. First peace, then worship: only those at peace with God can worship, and the altar came before the army.
- Peace held. With Midian still in the land and battle ahead, there was one Person with whom there was no conflict.
- Peace remembered. Gideon marked the spot, and the altar still stood at Ophrah — a fearful man's memorial to the word that stilled him.
And it came to pass the same night, that Jehovah said to him, Take the young bullock, which thy father hath, even the second bullock of seven years old, and throw down the altar of Baal that thy father hath, and cut down the Asherah that is by it;
The word comes to Gideon on the same night he built his altar to the Lord. It sends him not against Midian but against his own father's household. Before he can face a nation's enemy, he must face the idol standing on his family's land.
The first thing God asks of Gideon is not public bravery but honesty at home:
Here we see that Gideon had to begin at home. God called him to raise the flag of testimony in the very heart of his family — in the very centre of his father's house. This is intensely interesting and deeply practical. Testimony must begin at home. It will never do to rush out into public work while our private and domestic ways are anything but what they ought to be. It is useless to set about throwing down the altar of Baal in public while the very same altar remains standing at home.
The word translated "grove" in older Bibles does not mean a stand of trees. What people did to it shows what it was made of:
The word "grove" naturally suggests a row of trees. But that cannot be the meaning, since people set groves up "under every green tree." Manasseh put a carved image of the grove that he had made in the temple. Josiah later removed it, burnt it, and ground it to powder. That image was no doubt made of metal. But the groves were of wood, as we learn from the fact that people cut them down and burned them. One passage speaks of planting groves, another of making them, and another of building them. They always go together with idols and images.
Gideon had just built an altar to the Lord. That act itself made Baal's altar intolerable:
The altar itself is now a challenge to the idols. The Lord's altar cannot stay in the company of Baal's, and Israel cannot be delivered while its faith is divided. So on the same night — the night of the day when the Lord had appeared — the Lord told him to throw down Baal's altar and cut down the asherah. The asherah was a pillar of wood, the symbol of the Ashtaroth worship that went with Baal's. Then Gideon was to build an altar to the Lord on top of the stronghold where Israel used to retreat from the Midianites, and to offer on it his father's second bull, with the wood of the asherah he had cut down.
Another writer ties the demand to Gideon's own name:
God will not share His glory with Baal. One altar or the other must be thrown down. Gideon is to make good his name, "the cutter down," and to show the vigour of his faith and the reality of his obedience.
God's peace does not leave the idols standing:
There judgment begins. We must "cease to do evil" before we "learn to do good." The Lord comes to us as "the God of peace." Still the call is, "Down with the idols in your father's house." … And what is more, if God says, "Pull down the altar of Baal," He will give strength to do it.
The wood of the felled image became the wood of the sacrifice:
The positive duty of anyone who would be a testimony for God is, before everything else, to cast down his idols. Why are there so few true servants among Christians, walking in the power of a testimony for Christ? It is because they have not the two altars. And why have they not the second? Because they have not provided themselves wood for the sacrifice. The idols are the wood. Let us overthrow them; let nothing of them remain. Let us begin in the innermost circle of the family. If we do not do this, where will our testimony be? The overthrowing of the idols is the secret of power. The Spirit of the Lord only came upon Gideon when he had done this. We do not now have Baals of stone and groves of wood, as he did, but we have many other idols. Unlike him, we often prefer them to the power of a faithful walk with God.
Obedience came, but not yet in daylight:
Gideon obeys, but he does it by night, fearing to do it by day. Here nature breaks in. His faith was not yet strong enough to let him testify openly and boldly; but what his faith did enable him to do, that he did.
- Home first. God sends Gideon against the idol on his father's land before He sends him against Midian.
- Judgment first. God greets Gideon in peace, then tells him to pull the idols down. We must stop doing evil before we learn to do good.
- One altar. God will not share His glory with Baal, so one altar or the other must fall. Divided faith never wins a deliverance.
- Fuel. The wood of the felled image feeds the fire of the new sacrifice. The idols supply what worship burns.
- Then power. The Spirit came on Gideon only after the idols came down. What God commands, He gives strength to do — even to a man who can only manage it at night.
and build an altar to Jehovah thy God upon the top of this strong place in the ordered manner, and take the second bullock, and offer up a burnt-offering with the wood of the Asherah that thou shalt cut down.
Gideon has just met God and built an altar called "The LORD is Peace." That same night God tells him to tear down his father's altar to Baal and raise the LORD's altar in its place, with the idol for firewood.
God does not send Gideon against the raiders from Midian first. He sends him against the altar in his own yard.
Here we see that Gideon had to begin at home. He was called to unfurl the banner of testimony in the very heart of his family — in the very centre of his father's house... Testimony must begin at home. It will never do to rush out into public work while our private and family ways are anything but what they ought to be. It is useless to set about throwing down the altar of Baal in public, while that same altar remains standing at home.
Another writer asks how far one man's obedience has to reach.
Does he worship and obey God for himself? Then that same obedience must be claimed for the whole circle of his responsibilities. Is a man going to be a deliverer for all Israel, while his own family is in bondage?... How many are tempted to invert this order. They may be jealous enough for God's altar for all Israel, and yet have never set it up in their own homes.
The verse does not ask Gideon to add the LORD's altar alongside Baal's. Tearing down the one and building the other is a single command.
He is to cast down his father's altar of Baal, cut down the wooden image, or column, and offer a bull on an altar to the LORD. After all, this is only the natural enlargement of the worship he had just enjoyed. God will not share His glory with Baal. One altar or the other must be thrown down. Gideon is to make good his name, "the cutter down," and to show the vigour of his faith and the reality of his obedience.
The offering must burn on wood cut from the Asherah — the wooden column beside Baal's altar. Nothing of the false worship survives it.
The positive duty of anyone who would be a testimony for God is, before anything else, to cast down his idols. Why are there so few true servants among Christians, walking in the power of a testimony for Christ? It is because they have not the two altars. And why do they not have the second? Because they have not provided themselves with wood for the sacrifice. The idols are the wood (v. 26). Let us overthrow them, and let nothing of them remain. Let us begin in the innermost circle of the family... The overthrowing of the idols is the secret of power; the Spirit of the LORD only came upon Gideon when he had done this.
God fixes the altar's shape and site, not Gideon. The ESV has the stones "laid in due order"; other translations read "in the ordered place." Writers take that phrase as the end of self-chosen worship.
It is of the essence of self-will to say, "I have a right to worship God how I like." Obedience to God is the saint's rule and liberty. No power in the world has any right to interfere with this. And what is more, if God says, "Pull down the altar of Baal," He will give strength to do it.
But Israel's own altar stood at the tabernacle in Shiloh. So how could a new altar on this rock be right? One writer answers that God's command alone settled it.
Gideon worshipped according to a new revelation of God, despite Shiloh and the tabernacle. His rock became the ordered place, or the anointed altar, only because of this revelation and command of God.
So Gideon obeyed. One writer points out what had to come first, and what could only come after.
Gideon was associated with evil in his father's house. As another has said, "faithfulness within comes before outward strength: evil must be put away from Israel before the enemy can be driven out. Obedience first, and then strength: this is God's order."
What if courage falls short of open testimony?
Though the flesh may hinder testimony, it cannot prevent obedience, if there is faith... The stirrings of the flesh are no excuse for failing to obey what we have faith to do. So it was with Gideon. From the start he learned how hostile his own people were to faithfulness for the truth. The world does not realise that its opposition always draws out of God's witness more than enough power to crush it.
- Home first. The altar you tear down in public is worthless while the same altar stands in your own house.
- One altar. God will not share His glory; Baal's altar must come down for His to go up.
- Idols as fuel. The wood of the cut-down image feeds the fire — the thing removed becomes the means of worship.
- God's order. God fixed the place. Obedience, not preference, is the believer's rule and freedom.
- Then power. Obedience first, strength second — the Spirit came on Gideon only after the idol fell.
And Gideon took ten men of his servants, and did as Jehovah had said to him. And it came to pass, because he feared his father's house, and the men of the city, if he did it by day, that he did it by night.
Gideon's first task is not to fight Midian but to tear down the altar in his own family's yard. He does it at night, with ten servants, because he is afraid — so does obedience mixed with fear still count as obedience?
God's first order sent Gideon against the altar in his own home, not against the enemy camp.
Now the Lord calls Gideon to act; but he must first begin at home… Here we get obedience. Gideon was linked with evil in his father's house. As someone else has said, "faithfulness at home comes before strength outside: evil must go from Israel before the enemy can be driven out. Obedience first, and then strength: this is God's order."… So with Gideon: God could not send him to strike the Midianites until he had pulled down the idol in his father's house… Satan is helpless in the presence of an obedient man. The devil resisted in obedience is the devil defeated.
Gideon was afraid, and he obeyed anyway. One writer calls that the real meaning of courage.
Gideon obeyed, taking ten men who were his servants to do this serious work. They did it at night, because Gideon feared what the men of the city would think. There was timidity in his faith, but faith still acted. True courage does not mean having no fear. It shows itself in doing right despite fear.
Obeying God and speaking out about it are not the same thing. One can fall short while the other goes ahead.
Even where a person receives and obeys the word of God, the testimony often falls short. Many a true soul is not ready to speak out as openly as he might. It is better when obedience and testimony go together. The flesh may hold back testimony, but it cannot stop obedience, if there is faith… The feelings of the flesh are no excuse for not obeying what we have faith to do. Because of them we may give up the higher place of testimony, but nothing must stop obedience to God's word.
What Gideon did in the dark was no token gesture.
This is what we may call striking at the very root of the matter. The worship of Baal is completely overturned. This was no small thing. We have little idea what it cost the son of Joash to do this; but by the grace of God, he did it. True, it may have been with fear and trembling — still he did it… No half measures would have worked. There was no use picking a stone out of the idol's altar here and there. The whole structure had to come down from its very foundation.
God never told Gideon to do the work in daylight. He knew the man He had called.
Gideon obeyed at once, without compromise or holding back. For him the idols were nothing compared with the God he knew. This "mighty man of valour" had been short of courage. Fear of the enemy (v. 11), fear of God (v. 23), fear of his father's house (v. 27) were some of his marks. He did his work at night, afraid to do it by day. He still did it, because God had commanded him. Only in the morning did the people of the city see what had been done. The One who knew Gideon's character had not told him: Do this work by day. Let us too, weak as we are, destroy our idols quietly, when no eye is watching… The world will soon see that we have a new altar it does not know, and that the grove is worth nothing to us except as wood to burn.
Gideon still had to face the morning. One writer turns that wait into a question for the reader.
We can imagine how anxiously Gideon may have waited for the next day. Or how calmly, if he simply had God before him… Has anyone been trembling and hesitating to take some plain step of faith? Let them learn from Gideon, and take courage. The consequences you dread would fail to happen. The very people whose opposition you fear will approve.
- Home first. Evil had to go from his father's house before God could send him against Midian — obedience first, then strength.
- Night still counts. Fear may hold back your testimony, but it cannot stop obedience, if there is faith.
- Fear obeyed. Courage is not the absence of fear; it is acting rightly while afraid.
- Half measures fail. The whole structure came down, not a stone here and there.
- Morning vindicates. The consequences he dreaded did not come; the very people he feared came round.
And when the men of the city arose early in the morning, behold, the altar of Baal was broken down, and the Asherah was cut down that was by it, and the second bullock was offered up upon the altar that was built.
The town wakes to a scene it cannot explain away. The altar it had prayed at is rubble, the wooden pole beside it is gone, and a bull has been offered on a new altar built to the God of Israel. What Gideon did in the dark is now the first thing every man in the town sees. A private act of obedience has become public testimony.
Gideon did the work after dark because he was afraid. The timing changed nothing about the result. By morning the deed stood in full daylight for the whole town to see.
He did his work at night, because he was afraid to do it by day. He did it all the same, for God had commanded him to. Only in the morning did the people of the city see what he had done... Let us, too, weak as we are, destroy our idols in silence, when no one is watching. Let us not talk loudly about it. Let us do this hard work with fear and trembling, looking to God alone, in the silence of the night. The world will soon see that we have a new altar which it does not know.
The altar Gideon pulled down belonged to his own family, not to some stranger's town. One writer finds God's order in that.
Faithfulness within comes before outward strength: Israel must put away evil before driving out the enemy. Obedience first, and then strength: this is God's order.
Another writer weighs what the night cost Gideon, and why the idol at home could not be left standing.
Gideon had nothing but death to expect, if it had not been the will of the Lord; but, come what may, "whoever does the will of God abides forever," and Gideon was content to face whatever followed... It would have been a huge inconsistency for a man to go out and deal with the pagan enemies of Israel while his own father's house worshipped Baal... For nothing wounds people more than something that treats their religion as nothing.
The men of the town found the altar broken down — not damaged, not half taken apart. That thoroughness is the point.
This is what we may call striking at the very root of the matter. The worship of Baal is completely overturned... There would have been no use in picking out a stone here and there from the idol's altar. The whole structure had to be torn down from its very foundation, and the idol itself shamed in front of the very worshippers it had deceived.
The wooden pole beside the altar came down too. The ESV calls it the Asherah; some older translations call it "the grove." One writer notes what God's altar does without:
The grove might add beauty to the altar of Baal, but God's altar must be set up in its own plain simplicity.
The town saw more than an absence. It saw a replacement — a new altar, fuelled by the idol that came down.
The positive duty of one who would be a testimony for God is, before all else, to cast down his idols. Why is it that there are so few true servants among Christians, walking in the power of a testimony for Christ? It is because they have not the two altars. And why have they not the second? Because they have not provided themselves wood for the sacrifice. The idols are the wood... Let us begin in the innermost circle of the family. If we do not do this, where will our testimony be?
The town's outrage is not a sign that Gideon got it wrong. It shows where the town had been resting its confidence.
The action of faith always stirs up the flesh. Israel did not know where their strength was; they thought it was in Baal. Gideon had learned that it was in God. These are testing times... How many think the strength of Christians lies in the things they see around them! The soul taught by God knows it is only in Jehovah Jesus.
Gideon's dreaded morning came, and the disaster he feared did not.
Is anyone trembling and hesitating to take some plain step of faith? Let them learn from Gideon, and take courage. How all the results you dread would fail to happen! The very people whose opposition you fear will approve. Or if not, what can happen?
- Home first. Pull down the idol in your own family before you face the enemy outside — obedience, then strength.
- All the way down. Not a stone picked out here and there. The whole structure comes down, and the pole beside it too.
- Replaced, not just removed. The morning shows two things — an altar gone and an altar built, the old idol burned as fuel for the new sacrifice.
- Daylight comes. Quiet work, done in fear, still ends up in plain view. The world soon notices the new altar it does not recognise.
- Then the noise. Opposition shows that faith has touched what people trusted in. The disaster you dread usually never comes.
And they said one to another, Who has done this thing? And when they inquired and asked, they said, Gideon the son of Joash has done this thing.
Gideon tore down Baal's altar at night. By morning the whole town stood in front of the ruins, asking who did it. The search that follows raises two questions commentators keep coming back to: why God asked for this act first, and what happens when quiet obedience is found out.
God sent Gideon against the idol in his own father's yard before He sent him against Israel's enemies. The town even names him by his father: Gideon the son of Joash. Commentators see a fixed order here.
Gideon was tied to evil in his father's house. As someone else has said, "faithfulness at home comes before strength outside: evil must be put out of Israel before the enemy can be driven out. Obedience first, and then strength: this is God's order." … So it was with Gideon. Until he had pulled the idol down in his father's house, God could not send him to strike the Midianites. There is plenty here to make all of us search our own hearts. How often have we grieved over our lack of power in the Lord's service, when we could have traced the cause to some lack of obedience?
The townsmen woke to an obvious ruin because Gideon left nothing standing. A half-done job would have been useless.
We have little idea what it cost the son of Joash to do this. But by the grace of God, he did it. True, he may have done it with fear and trembling, but he still did it. He struck one strong blow at the whole system of Baal, and it crumbled to dust under his feet. Half measures would have been no use. Picking out a stone here and there from the idol's altar would have achieved nothing. The whole structure had to come down from its very foundation.
Gideon worked after dark because he feared these very men. His fear did not cancel his obedience.
His faith was timid, but faith still acted. True courage does not mean having no fear. It shows itself in doing right despite fear.
Gideon never announced what he had done. The city found him by asking around, because the act spoke for him.
It is better when obedience and testimony go together. But though the flesh may hold back our testimony, it cannot stop obedience, if there is faith… The stirrings of the flesh are no excuse for not obeying what we have faith to do… And if we are faithful, even without strong feeling, our acts will speak for themselves. So testimony will follow, even though it did not go with them. That is what happened with Gideon.
Once his name was spoken, his private obedience became public. It cost him, and it gave him a new name.
Only in the morning did the people of the city see what he had done… Let us, too, weak as we are, destroy our idols in silence, when no eye is watching us… The world will soon see that we have a new altar it does not know, and that the grove is worth nothing to us except as wood to burn. Then the world, which has supported us until now, will hate us. It was the altar of testimony that drew everyone's hatred onto Gideon. Hated — but what did it matter? He was given the name Jerubbaal (let Baal plead), and in front of everyone he became the living witness that the things he had once worshipped were worthless.
The men asking this question were Israelites, not foreigners. One writer sees their anger as a pattern, not a one-off.
The action of faith always stirs up the flesh. Israel did not know where their strength was; they thought it was in Baal. Gideon had learned it was in God. These are sifting times. In the Lord's day everything looked to be in beautiful order. But because He was setting aside men's traditions, everyone was against Him. It is the same now. How many people think the strength of Christians lies in the things they see around them! The soul taught by God knows it is only in Jehovah Jesus.
The crowd's question ended in a demand for Gideon's death. One writer notes who answered it.
And from the start, he learns how hostile his own people are to faithfulness for the truth. But how little the world knows that its evil opposition always draws out of God's witness more power than enough to put it down! The people's cry for Gideon's execution is met by Joash's challenge to let Baal plead for himself, if he is a god.
- Home first. Gideon had to clear the evil out of his own home before God could send him against the enemy outside. Obedience first, then strength.
- Whole, not partial. Gideon pulled the altar down from its foundation. Half measures would have been useless, and would have left nothing for the city to find.
- Fear allowed, disobedience not. Gideon worked at night because he was afraid. Courage is doing right despite fear, not the absence of fear.
- Acts declare themselves. He said nothing, yet the search found him out. When testimony does not go with obedience, it follows after it.
- Discovery costs. Once named, Gideon faced the town's hatred and a call for his death. It made him a public witness that his old god was worthless.
And the men of the city said to Joash, Bring out thy son, that he may die, because he has broken down the altar of Baal, and because he has cut down the Asherah that was by it.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And Joash said to all that stood near him, Will *ye* contend for Baal? or will *ye* save him? he that contends for him, let him be put to death whilst it is yet morning. If he be a god, let him plead for himself, because they have broken down his altar.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And on that day they called him Jerubbaal, saying, Let Baal plead with him, because he has broken down his altar.
Gideon had pulled down the altar of Baal in his own father's yard, and the men of the town came for his life. His father's reply turned the trial around. The nickname it produced — Jerubbaal, "let Baal contend against him" — stuck to Gideon for life. It was a standing dare to the idol he had insulted.
The name puts the burden of proof where it belongs. A god who cannot defend his own altar has already lost the case. Older translations word it "Let Baal plead against him," and the writers quoted here follow that wording.
This was very simple reasoning: "If he is a god, let him plead for himself." Gideon's decided course had brought matters to a point. Baal was either a reality or a most complete delusion. If the former, let him plead for himself. If the latter, who would think of pleading for him? Nothing could be simpler. Gideon's action was a complete success. The worship of Baal was overturned, and the worship of Jehovah Elohim set up instead.
Joash never weighed the pros and cons of Baal worship. One writer turns that refusal on anyone tempted to argue a case for evil.
It was of no use to argue the case, except to show the people the folly of pleading for Baal. If the things set aside were Baal's, and if Baal was a god, surely he would arise and take their part. It was of no use to debate. And do not let us suppose that all the arguments of all the good men in the world can make that which is evil, good. It is sad indeed to see the arguments that are devised by the wit of men in defence of evil. The binding duty of the saint is to separate from evil, however much long tradition or anything else supports it.
The altar Gideon smashed stood on his own family's land. God told him to pull it down before he went out against Israel's enemies.
The will of Jehovah was explicitly declared to Gideon. Apart from the will of the Lord, he had nothing but death to expect. But come what may, "he who does the will of God abides forever," and Gideon was content to accept all the consequences… It would have been a glaring inconsistency for a man to go out against the pagan enemies of Israel while Baal was worshipped in his own father's house.
Writers draw the same order out of the story as a general rule for service.
As another has remarked, "Faithfulness within precedes outward strength. Evil must be put away from Israel before the enemy can be driven out. Obedience first and then strength. This is God's order."
Joash had owned that altar. Now the man who kept the idol takes his son's side.
Not to be interrupted by the unbelief of those around, he did it by night, and the next morning the challenge to Baal was plain for all to see. So Gideon had to "add virtue" to his faith — the boldness needed by every good soldier of Christ. This boldness is God's means to awaken and embolden others, so that Joash, his father, steps into the ranks.
Another writer traces the same cause and effect back to how far Gideon went:
There is nothing, we repeat, like plain decision — bold, uncompromising faithfulness for Christ, whatever it costs. Had Gideon been less decided, had his line of action been less thorough, his father Joash would not have been so completely won over. It needed just such a way of dealing with Baal to convince a reasonable person that the worship of such a god was a sham and a falsehood.
The new name looks like protection: the crowd goes home and Gideon lives. It did the opposite.
The name "Jerubbaal" was no defence. On the contrary, it brought up the question whether there was power in Satan now that faith was in exercise.
One writer traces Joash's answer through to the title it gave Gideon.
He answers that the man who pleads for Baal deserves death: it is for Baal himself to avenge the insult. The sarcasm knocks the opposition down at once, and leaves Gideon with the title of idol-challenger, "Let Baal contend!" In the fight that is beginning, the very existence of the man of faith is a sign of victory already won, a pledge of one to come.
Later Scripture found the word "Baal" too shameful to keep and swapped it for a word meaning shame.
Ishbosheth means "man of shame"… We know from Chronicles (1 Chron. 8:33) that his original name was Esh-baal. The same change happened to Jerubbaal, turned into Jerubbesheth (2 Sam. 11:21). In Hosea 9:10 Baal himself is called "that shame." It is hard to doubt that people made these substitutions because they felt how shameful idolatry was.
- Obedience first. Gideon had to clear evil out of his own home before God would send him against Israel's enemies — "obedience first and then strength."
- No debate. Joash refused to argue the merits of Baal; no amount of clever reasoning can make an evil thing good.
- A plain dare. "Let Baal contend against him" — the name forces the idol either to act or stand exposed as nothing.
- Courage spreads. Gideon's boldness brought the very father who had owned the altar into the ranks. Boldness is God's way of stirring up others.
- A banner, not a shelter. Jerubbaal gave Gideon no protection. It raised the question whether Satan still had power where faith was at work.
And all Midian and Amalek and the children of the east were gathered together, and went over, and encamped in the valley of Jezreel.
Gideon has just pulled down his father's altar to Baal. The answer comes fast. The whole eastern coalition crosses the Jordan and camps in Israel's richest plain. Why does the storm break just when a man starts to obey? And what does God do with a valley full of enemies?
Commentators read the timing as no accident. As long as Israel put up with Baal, Midian stayed away. The trouble starts when the compromise ends.
When we mix with the world, Satan has no reason to disturb us. Let him be alarmed, and up come Midianites, Amalekites, and the rest.
These enemies are also read as a picture of what a believer fights inside. Amalek stands for the flesh.
The Midianites, with their allies the Amalekites (a figure of the flesh), came out to fight against Gideon. This was natural, and it is so today. You may be sure of this. If your heart is drawn heavenward, you will have to fight these combined powers. The flesh does not love the things of Christ. It finds its satisfaction in the things of earth.
Gideon had already faced hostility from his own townspeople over the altar. That anger was held back; this army was not.
At first Gideon met hostility from those who bore the name of the people of God. For a time, the sincerity of his testimony held that hostility in check. Midian and Amalek (v. 33), however, were not held back in that way. The men of the city, in their folly, tried to hinder their own deliverance. The world, for its part, made a determined effort to crush the revival that was to free Israel from bondage.
They camped on the standing battlefield of the land. Its history runs from Israel's early victories to the last battle of prophecy.
The wide valley or plain around Jezreel, in southern Galilee. It has been called the battlefield of Palestine. Barak won there, and Josiah was defeated there (Judges 5:19; 2 Chronicles 35:22). Megiddo is in the same area. It is also perhaps the place where the great battle of Armageddon will be fought, Revelation 16:16. It is a very fertile plain.
The order of the record matters. The army gathers only after God has finished preparing His man. The gathering serves God's purpose, not Midian's.
Gideon is now a vessel set apart and fit for the Master's use. So we get the crowning qualification of power… Satan can never get ahead of God. While God is preparing Gideon, the Midianites and the rest stay still; when Gideon is ready, God gathers them together for destruction. They marshal their forces to destroy Israel; but the Spirit of the Lord comes upon Gideon, and now it is God Himself against the Midianites.
A huge enemy camp can be read the other way round. Its size measures the power that is coming to silence it.
God's purpose is to assure the soul of this. Christ has triumphed over every power of evil. Just as surely, every display of evil is a guarantee to us that a far greater power is close at hand. And further, the greater the evil opposition, the plainer the power that overcomes and silences it. In every circumstance of life we should comfort ourselves with this: "when the enemy comes in like a flood, the Spirit of the Lord raises up a standard against him."
The Bible Treasury (the writer quotes Isaiah 59:19 in an older translation)
Darby marks the same moment as a change of stage in the story:
The Midianites come up against Israel. All is ready for the Lord's intervention… This is a new phase in the history; not only faithfulness, but power.
The altar came before the army. Writers press this as the rule, not the exception.
Again let us note, faithfulness does not begin with the Midianites; it begins at home. This is a great principle, whether for an individual soul or for the Church of God. Gideon must attack the evil inside his father's house, and in Israel itself. Only then does the Lord use him to save Israel out of the hands of the Midianites.
Darby ties the Spirit's power to that same faith:
The Midianites come up against Israel. All is ready for the Lord's intervention… The power of the Spirit, which sways the minds of men, is with the faith that acknowledges God, that acknowledges Him in His relationship to His people, and faithfully puts away the evil that does not fit that relationship.
- Home first — the altar in his father's house had to fall before the army in the valley could. Usefulness for God starts where you already live.
- Then hostility — an untroubled life can mean an undisturbed enemy. Opposition comes when compromise goes, from religious neighbours and open enemies alike.
- Then the gathering — the enemy musters only when God's man is ready. What looks like Israel's ruin is the enemy collected for destruction.
- Then the power — the size of the camp in Jezreel measures the help. The greater the flood, the plainer the standard God raises.
- Then the victory — the fight is no longer Gideon against Midian. It is God Himself against Midian, on the field where Israel has always fought.
And the Spirit of Jehovah came upon Gideon, and he blew the trumpet, and the Abi-ezrites were gathered after him.
Midian and its allies have camped in the Valley of Jezreel, and Israel's answer is one man who had been threshing wheat in hiding. What changes him is not new courage but the Spirit of the LORD taking hold of him.
The order of events matters. Gideon had already destroyed the idols at home before any power came on him.
The overthrowing of the idols is the secret of power; the Spirit of the LORD only came upon Gideon when he had done this. We do not have, as he did, Baals of stone and groves of wood. But we have many other idols, and, unlike him, we often prefer them to the power of a faithful walk with God.
The same writer brings this into daily life.
Unqualified obedience to the word of God is the path of power. At certain periods of our lives power has marked our service, at other times it has been missing. Let us then ask ourselves whether we have rebuilt some idol we had destroyed. All public service for the Christian must begin with faithfulness in the small circle where he is called to live.
The wording here is unusual, and one writer explains it by reversing the picture we expect.
In the case of three men (Gideon, for instance: Judges 6:34) the expression is a peculiar one. It means that the Spirit of the Lord clothed Himself with the man. He took full possession of him for a purpose, and until that purpose was achieved.
Gideon was not the only man used this way.
There were others like Gideon, Amasai and Zechariah, with whom the Spirit clothed Himself for the time being, so that He might witness through them… But in all these cases the Spirit acted upon men from the outside. He used men for His purpose without reference to their inward moral character.
Compare what Gideon's hands were doing before with what his lips do now.
The Spirit of the LORD comes upon Gideon, and he blew a trumpet. This is the same Gideon who was threshing wheat to hide it from the Midianites. Now he puts a trumpet to his lips and sounds out defiance in the face of the enemy. In the same way, Peter had trembled before a servant girl. Once the Spirit clothed him with power, he charged the rulers with the sin of crucifying Christ. The apostles too, being filled with the Holy Spirit, spoke the word of God with boldness (Acts 4:31).
The first thing the Spirit's power produces is not an attack but a gathering. Trumpets in Israel had a set list of uses.
They were the voice of God, telling the people His mind on four important occasions. They gave the signal for gathering the people together; for the moving of the camps; for battle; and also for the solemn feasts, or worship… Gideon began where God begins (Num. 10). "He sounded the trumpet, and the Abiezrites were called out to follow him." He carried the voice of God, gathering Israel together again after their own failure had scattered them.
Abiezer was Gideon's own clan — the very men who had just called for his death. Their change of mind is part of the miracle.
The Spirit of God equips him for special work. In response the men of Abiezer, who had demanded his death not long before, join his standard, and so do Manasseh, Asher and Zebulun. Truly, when the enemy comes in like a flood, the Spirit of God lifts up a standard against him. Let there be the first work of God in a soul, and he will find that others long for freedom from bondage too. They will follow his lead, as he follows Christ.
The armies gather at the exact moment the man is ready.
Satan can never get ahead of God. While Gideon is being prepared, the Midianites and the others stay still. When Gideon is ready, God gathers them together for destruction. They line up their forces to destroy Israel. But the Spirit of the LORD comes upon Gideon, and now it is God Himself against the Midianites. Let us make sure we never move forward against the enemy except in the power of the Spirit of God.
- Altar first. The idol at home came down before the Spirit came on Gideon. Obedience in the small circle opens the door to power in the large one.
- Clothed. The wording means the Spirit clothed Himself with Gideon. He took full possession of him for a purpose, until that purpose was done.
- From outside. In the Old Testament the Spirit acted on such men from the outside, for a time. Their inward moral character had nothing to do with it.
- Trumpet. The first act of that power was not a blow struck but a call sounded — the voice of God gathering a scattered people.
- Standard. The clan that had demanded his death now follows him. When the enemy comes in like a flood, the Spirit lifts up a standard — and it is God Himself against Midian.
And he sent messengers throughout Manasseh, and they also were gathered after him; and he sent messengers to Asher, and to Zebulun, and to Naphtali; and they came up to meet them.
Gideon has just pulled down Baal's altar in his own father's yard. Now the Spirit of the Lord is on him, he blows a trumpet, and four tribes leave home to follow a man who had been threshing wheat in hiding.
Gideon could not have rallied Israel against Midian while an idol still stood at home.
Here is Gideon with his own people against him, and the enemies of Israel gathered and camped in Jezreel. But he has peace with God, and the Lord is (so to speak) bound to appear on his side. How does he act? The Spirit of the Lord comes upon him, and he blows the trumpet. Had Gideon been serving Baal, he could not have blown the trumpet like this. But Baal is down, and the altar of God is set up in the ordered place. He sends messengers throughout all Manasseh, and they gather to him too, along with Asher, Zebulun, and Naphtali. All these gather around the man who is least in his father's house, the poorest of the tribe of Manasseh — the man to whom the Lord has said, "Go in this your might."
The men of his own clan had recently wanted him dead for what he did to their altar. The Spirit changed their minds, not Gideon's persuasion.
Everything is ready for the Lord's intervention. The Spirit of the Lord comes upon Gideon. This is a new phase in the history; not only faithfulness, but power. Gideon blows the trumpet, and those who shortly before would have killed him now follow in his train. He sends messengers to all his tribe, and Zebulun, Asher, and Naphtali come up too. The Spirit's power sways the minds of men. It goes with the faith that acknowledges God, and acknowledges Him in His relationship to His people. That faith is faithful to put away the evil that cannot stand with that relationship.
Israel's trumpets had fixed uses, laid down in the law long before Gideon picked one up. Gideon's first act with the Spirit's power was not an attack but a summons.
We find the use of the trumpets detailed in Numbers 10:1-10. They were the voice of God, telling His mind to the people on four important occasions. They gave the signal to gather the people together. They gave the signal for the camps to move, for battle, and for the solemn feasts or worship... Most of God's children think that Christianity is only about taking the gospel to people who don't believe. Gideon understood the testimony of faith in another way. He began where God begins. "He blew the trumpet, and Abiezer was gathered after him." He carried God's voice, calling Israel together again after their own failure had scattered them.
The response was not a handful of volunteers. It was a whole country waking up.
In short, there was a thorough awakening. The tide of spiritual energy rose high and carried hundreds and thousands along with it. The work that had begun in Gideon's heart was spreading far and wide, across the whole land. The Spirit of the Lord was displaying His mighty energy, stirring up multitudes to gather round the standard that the hand of faith had raised.
Some writers find a lesson in the names of the tribes that answered.
The Spirit of the Lord now clothes Gideon. No mere human wisdom or strength is enough in this fight. We are safe only when we depend on Him. He blows the trumpet, and Abiezer, then all Manasseh, gather behind him. Manasseh's fitness for this place is plain in Gideon, himself a Manassite. The world can only be overcome by the man whose goal lies beyond it, and this is what Manasseh represents. Then Asher, the "happy," Zebulun, the "dweller in relationship," and Naphtali, the "struggler" who overcomes, follow after Manasseh. So Israel's army of victory comes together.
Two of these tribes had answered a call like this once before, in the days of Deborah and Barak.
We are very glad to see our friends Zebulun and Naphtali here again. They stood out in the revival in Deborah's and Barak's day. They risked their lives in the high places, ready to die to defend what belonged to God. Here they are in the front line again. This is a very fine thing to see — consistency in the desire to maintain what belongs to the Lord. Now this trumpet call led to this army of 32,000 that was going to meet the Midianites.
- Cleared — the idol came down at home before the trumpet went up in public. Peace with God came first; the call to others came second.
- Clothed — the Spirit came on Gideon, and the same neighbours who had wanted him dead now marched behind him. The power that sways men's minds is the Spirit's, and it goes with faith that puts evil away.
- Called — God gave the trumpet first to gather scattered people, not to start a fight. Gideon began where God begins.
- Carried — a work begun in one hidden heart spread through the whole land. Thousands rallied to a standard that faith had raised.
- Consistent — Zebulun and Naphtali had answered such a call before, and they answered again. This trumpet call raised an army of 32,000 to meet Midian.
And Gideon said to God, If thou wilt save Israel by my hand, as thou hast said,
Gideon has sounded the trumpet and gathered the tribes. Yet before he marches he goes back to God for proof. He asks God to soak a fleece of wool on the threshing floor with dew while the ground around it stays dry. Two questions follow. Was this faith or unbelief? And what did the wet fleece and dry ground mean?
God had already told Gideon that He would use him. The words "as you have said" show Gideon knew it. That is why writers treat the opening "if" as a step backwards.
Perhaps his spirit was overawed when he saw the huge pagan army massing in front of him. For a moment his courage failed, and his heart longed for a fresh sign from the Lord. "Then Gideon said to God, If You will save Israel by my hand, as You have said" — alas, the poor heart can place its unbelieving "if" right in front of the word of God who cannot lie.
Other writers judge the same act more kindly. Gideon wants a sign he can see, and God met that same desire in others without complaint.
The boldness of faith, even when it seems to need confirmatory signs, never offends our gracious God. When He promised all blessing to Abraham, and that he would inherit the land of Canaan, Abraham asks, "How am I to know that I shall possess it?" Is God offended that His word is not enough? Ah, no, but He gives the wonderful night vision of the furnace and the flaming torch.
Commentators differ on how much blame Gideon deserves. None of them says God withheld the answer.
What Gideon gets back is not correction but kindness.
But oh, the matchless grace of God! His love that never reproaches! His tender thoughtfulness! He graciously meets the weakness of His poor servant... What condescending grace! Instead of harshly rebuking Gideon's unbelieving "if," He confirms his wavering faith with evidence beyond measure.
Writers also read the picture as a map of God's dealings with His people. The wool sits in the middle of the open floor, just as one nation sits among many.
The fleece in the middle of the ground is the type of Israel in the middle of the nations. The dew is the symbol of divine grace and mercy. It is the Lord who forsakes and who refreshes Israel. Israel today is like the fleece without the dew, while the ground, the Gentiles, have the grace of God. But before long the dew will fall upon Israel again and the time of their blessing and fullness will come.
On the second night the fleece stayed dry and the floor was wet. Writers read that sign the same way, but for a different time.
When the dew is seen upon the floor and not the fleece, it suggests the blessing that has come to the Gentiles during the period of Israel's rejection. We might say the present time.
One writer sees the wet fleece on dry ground as a portrait of one Man in a world that had nothing for God.
In Himself He was always that. In God's eyes He was beautiful beyond compare, and every thought, word and action was completely delightful to His Father. He was indeed like the fleece wet with the dew of heaven, in the middle of the barren dryness — the moral desert of Sahara — that ruled on every side.
Another writer turns the picture into a prayer for ourselves: to carry a character the world cannot produce.
Are we prepared to say to God, "Let the dew be upon the fleece; let us be saturated, baptised, entirely marked by what the earth does not have"? That is Christ. Only as our hearts and minds feed on Him will we bear the heavenly character and stand out from what belongs to the earth.
Many treat this chapter as permission to ask God for a visible sign before making a decision. One writer answers that.
But let believers remember that the Spirit of God lives in us. We can depend on God's Word together with the leading of the Spirit. So we need no confirming signs — only real communion with the Lord and faith in His Word.
- Dew asked. Gideon puts an "if" in front of a promise God had already spoken. The heart wants something it can see, not just God's bare word.
- Dew given. God does not rebuke the "if". He answers it twice, giving weak faith more evidence than Gideon asked for.
- Dew on the fleece. Wet wool on a dry floor pictures grace and mercy resting on Israel among the nations.
- Dew on the ground. The reversed sign pictures blessing reaching the nations while Israel is set aside. That is the present time. Israel's refreshing is still to come.
- Dew in us. Christ is the true fleece, wet with heaven in a dry world. Believers now have the Spirit and the Word. So the call is to soak in Him, not to look for signs.
behold, I put a fleece of wool on the threshing-floor; if dew shall be on the fleece only, and it be dry upon all the ground, then shall I know that thou wilt save Israel by my hand, as thou hast said.
The armies of Midian are camped in the valley, and Gideon is about to lead Israel out against them. First he asks God for a sign overnight: wool laid on the threshing floor, wet with dew while the ground around it stays dry.
God had already promised to save Israel by Gideon's hand. So his "if" stands in front of a word that needed no proving. One writer sees here the instinct of every human heart:
How remarkable! And yet we need not be surprised if we know anything of our own hearts. Anything for the poor human heart except the bare word of the living God. A sign, a token, something the eye can see. The word of God is not enough for unbelieving nature.
Commentators differ on the request. Some call it distrust; others say God is never offended when faith asks for confirmation. Both agree on how He answered:
But oh, the matchless grace of God! His love that never scolds! His tender thoughtfulness! He graciously meets the weakness of His poor servant... What grace, that He should stoop so low! He does not rebuke Gideon's unbelieving "if." Instead He confirms his wavering faith with more evidence than Gideon asked for.
Another writer sets Gideon beside Abraham:
The boldness of faith, even when it seems to need confirming signs, never offends our gracious God. God promised Abraham every blessing, and that he would inherit the land of Canaan. Abraham asks, "How am I to know that I shall possess it?" Is God offended that His word is not enough? No — He gives the wonderful night vision of the furnace and the flaming torch.
Dew carried a settled meaning in Israel's life and language:
Dew was the familiar sign of God's favour. It was largely the source of the land's fertility. Without it the land would have been parched and barren. Isaac uses this figure when he pronounces the blessing on Jacob. Moses repeats it in his closing blessing on the tribes. Elijah shows God's judgment on the land by declaring that no dew would fall... All refreshing, for Israel or for the Church, comes by the Holy Spirit. The divine dew is His blessed influence, bringing refreshing and help. Just as the land bears no fruit without dew, nothing grows where the Spirit's work is hindered.
A fleece is the wool cut off a sheep. That matched the nation's condition under Midian:
And how the people had been sheared, we might say, by the Midianites, until nothing was left but the fleece, a remnant.
Writers have also read the fleece and the ground as a sketch of a longer history:
The fleece in the middle of the ground is a picture of Israel in the middle of the nations. The dew is the symbol of divine grace and mercy. It is the Lord who forsakes and who refreshes Israel. Israel today is like the fleece without the dew, while the ground, the Gentiles, has the grace of God. But before long the dew will fall on Israel again, and the time of their blessing and fullness will come.
One writer looks at the wet fleece and sees more than a sign for Gideon:
His first sign was a fleece of wool soaked with dew, while everything around it was dry. Is this not a picture of the Lord Jesus in this world? Everything in this world (apart from God acting by His Spirit) was dry and lifeless as far as God was concerned.
One writer turns Gideon's request into a prayer for the reader:
Gideon's request was that the fleece should be soaked with what the earth knew nothing of... Are we prepared to say to God: "Let the dew be on the fleece; let us be soaked, baptized, entirely marked out by what the earth does not have?" That is Christ, surely. Only as our hearts and minds feed on Him will we carry the heavenly character and stand out from what is of the earth... Your own efforts will always be fruitless. You cannot perform a miracle. Only the power of God can bring this about.
This passage is often used as a method for finding God's will:
Today some Christians use this history as an excuse. They expect a material sign from God about what His will may be in a given matter. But let believers remember that we have the Spirit of God living in us. We can fully depend on God's Word together with the leading of the Spirit. So we need no confirming signs — only genuine communion with the Lord and faith in His Word.
- Doubt. Gideon's "if" stands in front of a promise God had already made. The human heart wants something the eye can see, not the bare word of God.
- Grace. God meets weak faith with kindness and gives more proof than Gideon asked for.
- Dew. Dew is the familiar sign of God's favour and stands for the Spirit's refreshing. Where it is withheld, the land is barren.
- Israel. The sheared fleece on the floor pictures Israel among the nations — dry now, but the dew of God's favour will fall on them again.
- Christ. The fleece soaked with dew in a dry world pictures the Lord Jesus. The believer's prayer is to be marked out by that same heavenly character.
And it was so. And when he rose up early on the morrow, he pressed the fleece together, and wrung dew out of the fleece, a bowl-full of water.
Gideon had asked for a sign: a fleece of wool left out overnight, wet while the ground around it stayed dry. By morning it held a bowlful of dew — which raises two questions: why did a called man need proof, and what does the fleece picture?
God had already given Gideon His word. One writer points to the small word Gideon set in front of it.
The poor heart can place its unbelieving "if" right in front of the word of God who cannot lie... Anything for the poor human heart but the naked word of the living God. A sign, a token, something that the eye can see. The word of God is not enough for unbelieving nature.
God could have rebuked His servant. Instead He answered with more than Gideon asked.
But oh, the matchless grace of God! His love that never scolds! His tender care! He graciously meets the weakness of His poor servant... What grace, that stoops so low! Instead of sharply rebuking Gideon's unbelieving "if," He confirms his wavering faith with overflowing evidence.
One writer measures the answer against ordinary dew.
To see how fully God answered, he wrung the water out of the fleece and found a bowl full of water! Those of us who have left clothes outside overnight may have found them damp in the morning. But there was never a bowl full of water in them from the dew.
So why grant Gideon a sign, when God refused the Jews who asked for one?
It is one thing to seek a sign in order to believe in God. It is quite another to seek one that confirms us in the rightness of the path we have entered, and in God's support of us in it. The first the Lord will not grant or allow. "No sign will be given to this generation," He says to the Jews... The divine path must be begun and entered in faith, without signs. But the Lord keeps giving evidence to confirm the soul that is in the right path.
One writer reads the wool as Israel and the dew as God's grace.
The fleece in the midst of the ground is the type of Israel in the midst of the nations. The dew is the symbol of divine grace and mercy. It is the Lord who forsakes and who refreshes Israel. Israel today is like the fleece without the dew, while the ground, the Gentile nations, shares in the grace of God. But before long the dew will fall upon Israel again and the time of their blessing and fulness will come.
Read that way, the present dryness is not abandonment.
His very chastenings are a pledge of future mercy. The Jews are dry now, while blessing has come to the Gentiles. That very dryness is sure proof that God will one day step in for His beloved earthly people.
One writer sees the soaked fleece in a dry world as a picture of Christ.
His first sign was that of a fleece of wool saturated with dew, while all around was dry. Is this not a picture of the Lord Jesus in this world? All in this world (apart from God's acting by His Spirit) was dry and lifeless as far as God was concerned. There was not a drop of refreshing moisture for God in the world.
Another writer follows that picture to the cross.
There He was made a curse when He took our sins upon Himself. There the dew was wrung from Him. He cried out: "I thirst." ... But now the dew is on all the ground. The ground that sin cursed can now receive the blessing of God! Everyone can now receive the "dew of heaven!"
One writer turns Gideon's request into a question for us.
Are we ready to say to God: "Let the dew be on the fleece. Let us be soaked, baptized, completely marked by what the earth does not have"? ... You may tell me that this is your desire, but that all your efforts have been in vain. And let me assure you that your efforts always will be fruitless. You cannot perform a miracle.
- Cause — Gideon set an unbelieving "if" in front of a promise God had already spoken. The eye wanted what the word had already given.
- Gift — God did not scold the weakness. He gave more than Gideon asked — a fleece yielding a bowlful.
- Limit — God does not give signs to start faith. He gives them to steady a soul already walking in the path He appointed.
- Reach — the fleece pictures Israel among the nations. Israel is dry today while the nations receive grace, but the dew will fall on Israel again.
- Result — the dew wrung out is what reaches the dry ground; no effort of ours produces it, only God.
And Gideon said to God, Let not thine anger be hot against me, and I will speak but this once! Let me prove, I pray thee, but this once with the fleece; let it, I pray thee, be dry upon the fleece only, and upon all the ground let there be dew.
Gideon has already asked God for a sign with the fleece, and God gave it. Now he asks for the same test in reverse, and he starts by begging God not to be angry — which raises the question readers still bring here: is this faith, or unbelief?
Gideon had proof enough, and still he asked for more. Commentators dwell less on his weakness than on the God who answers him anyway.
And yet all this was not enough. Gideon seeks still further confirmation… Such is the abounding grace and endless patience of the God we have to deal with. Who would not trust Him, and love Him, and serve Him?
Gideon himself expects a rebuke for asking:
God gives another proof of how graciously He stoops to us. He grants a sign to strengthen the weak but real and sincere faith of Gideon. As he repeats his request (v. 39), Gideon feels that God might well discipline him for his lack of faith. Still, the Lord grants what he asks.
Commentators differ on how to read the second request. One view treats it as a low point: Gideon tests a God who had already spoken clearly.
All God's orders to Gideon were clear and simple. But when Gideon asked God for signs, everything became unclear and complicated… Having tested God, Gideon now put Him to a test in return. What poor faith! What feeble confidence in Him! But the God of grace patiently did what His servant asked.
Others see the same request as bold faith, not failure:
The boldness of faith, even when it seems to need confirming signs, never offends our gracious God. When He promised Abraham every blessing, and the land of Canaan, Abraham asked how he could know he would inherit it. Is God offended that His word is not enough? No — He gives him the wonderful night vision of the furnace and the flaming torch.
The sign works because dew already carried a settled meaning in Israel.
Dew was the familiar sign of God's favour. Much of the land's fertility came from it, and without it the land would have been parched and barren… And Hosea, describing the restoration of the nation when God will bless them again, describes Him as saying, "I will be like the dew to Israel; he shall blossom like the lily; he shall take root like the trees of Lebanon."
The same writer draws the line from dew to the Holy Spirit:
We know that all refreshing, whether for Israel or the Church, is by the Holy Spirit, and that the divine dew is His blessed influence bringing refreshing and help. Just as without the dew the land would stop being fruitful, so without the Spirit's unhindered work there can be no fruit. Barrenness will be the result.
Commentators read the wool on the threshing floor, with open ground all round it, as a picture of Israel among the nations.
The fleece of the shorn sheep pictures desolate Israel, which will be filled with the dew of God's blessing while drought lies on the nations around. But the reverse may also be of God: while His mercies refresh the nations around, Israel for her sins may be left dry. Either way, this is no mere natural event… To see His hand in every condition, however opposite, and to own His power and rule everywhere — this is the secret of wisdom, and of strength no less.
Read that way, the dry fleece with wet ground speaks of the present stretch of history:
The dew on the floor and not on the fleece suggests the blessing that has come to the nations during the time of Israel's rejection. We might say the present time.
One writer sees the cross of Christ in the reversal.
This time the fleece of wool was dry, while all around was dew. How movingly this reminds us of the cross of Christ. God forsook Him who was as the dew of the morning, so that the dew of God's grace might rest on the dry and barren waste of humanity.
The chapter is often used to justify "putting out a fleece." One writer draws a careful line through it.
Seeking a sign to establish belief in God is one thing. Seeking one to confirm that the path we have entered is right, and that God supports us in it, is quite another. The first the Lord will not grant or allow… The divine path must be begun in faith, without signs. But the Lord keeps on giving evidence to confirm the soul that is in the right path.
- Dew — the settled sign of God's favour and fruitfulness. Where it falls there is blessing; where God holds it back, barrenness.
- Dew on the fleece — God's favour resting on His own people while all around them stays dry.
- Dew on the ground — the reversal Gideon asks for here: blessing reaching the nations while Israel stays dry.
- Dryness borne — blessing for the barren ground came at a cost: God forsook the One who was as the morning dew.
- Dew for the doubter — God did not rebuke Gideon for asking twice. He answered him, and confirmed a servant already on the right path.
And God did so that night, and it was dry upon the fleece only, but on all the ground there was dew.
Gideon has already seen the wool soaked with dew on dry ground, and now he asks God to run the test backwards — dry wool, wet earth. God gives him what he asks, which raises two questions: why a second sign, and what does the reversal picture?
Gideon already had God's word, yet he asked for one more sign. One commentator sees what that reveals about the human heart:
How remarkable! And yet we need not be surprised if we know anything of our own hearts. Anything for the poor human heart but the plain word of the living God. A sign, a token, something the eye can see. The word of God is not enough for unbelieving nature.
God answers the same night, and without a word of rebuke. One commentator sees the character of God in that reply:
And yet all this was not enough. Gideon seeks still further confirmation... Such is the abounding grace and endless patience of the God we have to deal with. Forever praised be His holy name! Who would not trust Him, and love Him, and serve Him?
So why does God refuse signs elsewhere and grant one here? One writer draws a line between two kinds of asking:
It is one thing to seek a sign in order to believe in God. It is a very different thing to seek one that confirms we are on the right path, and that God supports us in it. The first the Lord will not grant or allow. "No sign will be given to you," He says to the Jews, when they asked for a sign as a ground of belief. We must enter God's path by faith, without signs. But the Lord keeps giving evidence to confirm the soul that is on the right path, and that it will succeed there.
One writer reads the wool as Israel and the bare ground as the nations around them. On that reading, the two signs mark two eras:
When Gideon asks for the dew on the fleece, it speaks of God giving His blessing to His persecuted people. This is true not only of that time, but of the last days, when He will be as the dew to Israel. When the dew appears on the floor and not on the fleece, it suggests the blessing that has come to the Gentiles during the period of Israel's rejection. We might say the present time.
The same writer adds that a dry season is not abandonment:
But whether He gives or withholds blessing, God is showing Himself for His people. His very chastenings are a pledge of future mercy. The Jews are dry now, while blessing has come upon the Gentiles. That very dryness is a sure proof that God will one day step in for His beloved earthly people.
Another writer sees the second sign pointing forward to Christ — one dry thing in a world covered with dew:
And this brings us to Gideon's second sign. This time the fleece of wool was dry, while all around was dew. How movingly this reminds us of the cross of Christ. God forsook Him who was as the dew of the morning, so that the dew of God's grace might rest on the dry and barren waste of humanity... "my strength is dried up like a potsherd." (Ps. 22:15)
The dryness, on this view, had a purpose beyond itself:
God forsook His Son so that His attitude toward this world might be one of grace and blessing, so that the dew of His goodness might rest on it.
A dry fleece in a soaked field is a picture of not absorbing your surroundings. One writer turns the sign into a request a believer can make:
Gideon had one more request to make before he took the field; it was that the fleece might be dry and all the earth wet. Here we have the negative side of the matter, which naturally follows the positive. For us it means this: let us be free in heart and character from what soaks the earth. Let its maxims, principles, ways, hopes and ambitions have no place in our lives. They can only spoil our enjoyment of Him.
- Doubt asks. Gideon had God's word and still wanted something his eye could see. The word of God is not enough for unbelieving nature.
- Grace answers. God does not scold. He gives the sign that same night — "abounding grace and endless patience."
- Confirmation, not proof. God refuses a sign asked as a ground for believing. He gives one to steady a soul already walking in the right path.
- The dew moves. Wet fleece on dry ground pictures blessing on Israel. Dry fleece on wet ground pictures blessing reaching the nations while Israel waits. The dry season is itself a pledge that mercy will return.
- The dry One. At the cross Christ was dried up so that the dew of God's grace could fall on a barren world. Now we are called to stay dry of what soaks that world.