And Jehovah said to Joshua, Fear not, neither be dismayed. Take with thee all the people of war, and arise, go up to Ai. See, I have given into thy hand the king of Ai, and his people, and his city, and his land.
Israel had just lost a battle to a small town, because one man had hidden stolen goods in the camp. With that sin judged and put away, God spoke to Joshua again — with comfort instead of blame, and with the victory promised before the fighting even started.
The command to go up comes at a precise moment — after the evil in the camp had been dealt with. One writer traces the sequence from the defeat back to its cause and forward again to restoration.
Men once used for God are at times set aside by God. They go on as before in their work, but win no victories. The story of Ai unveils the cause — hidden evil is in the camp. Then these same servants rise again. After a time of defeat, they become people of power once more — with God and with people. The story of Ai lets us into that secret too: they have been before God, and have humbled themselves.
Another writer describes what changed on God's side once the matter was settled.
They had gone out in self-confidence; they had received a most serious check. But now the sin had been dealt with, and the Lord was free to act for them.
God tells Joshua that He has already given him the king, the people, the city and the land. The fight is real, but the result is not in doubt.
Now the Lord gives Joshua clear instructions for attacking Ai. How different they were from the plans Joshua used at first! God tells Joshua not to be afraid, but to take with him all the men of war, not only three thousand. It was God who would deliver them into the hand of Joshua, so there was no doubt of their gaining the victory.
Israel's own plan had been to send a few thousand men and spare the rest the climb. God's order overturns that calculation word for word.
How differently the battle was now to be fought from the way Israel had first proposed to overthrow Ai! They had said, "Do not make the whole people toil up there." The Lord said, "Take all the fighting men with you." As the thousands of Israel rose to battle, every soldier had to remember this: no enemy is too small to take seriously. Israel's strength and courage were in the Lord alone.
Sending a whole army against one small village carried its own message about the strength Israel had been proud of.
Even after faith is back in its place, God gives them victory. But He also makes them feel how wrong it was to forget Him. They had been lifted up because of their might. So when Ai was taken, God put that strength to shame. Every warrior must go, and they must set an ambush. What a display of force and strategy to take a little city! God knows how to put shame on worldly strength and confidence. He allows, and even commands, its full display, and then will not use it.
At Jericho the walls fell before a blow was struck. Here God prescribes an ambush, a feigned retreat, and exact obedience in every detail.
God demanded even more care at little Ai than at Jericho. Every detail of the preparations had to be obeyed exactly.
Writers see the two cities as pictures of two different fights.
God had given total victory over Jericho, which pictures the world as a system of evil. At Ai it was different. God was still behind everything Israel did, but now they had to fight in several ways. Ai stands for the small worldly things that slow a believer's growth. These things look small, but overcoming them makes a believer grow.
Israel had wanted to spare itself the effort. In the end the whole nation toiled up the hill, and won by pretending to run away.
Israel did "toil up there" — some to the ambush, others to the front. When we treat our mistakes lightly and sin on purpose in our service, God uses hard work to press home the lessons we ignored. He does this even after He has shown us our faults and forgiven us. Not only did Israel labour up to Ai; God made them victorious through humiliation. By apparent defeat, by fleeing before their foes, they won their success.
Because the whole army went, the victory belonged to all of them together, in varied tasks.
There is diversity in the action and service, but it is action in common. The body is one, the parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond of union. If the unity is lost sight of, defeat is the result.
- Cleared — God spoke of victory again only after the sin in the camp was dealt with. Then He was free to act for His people.
- Called — "Do not fear" is not a telling-off. It is a fresh commission. God restores the servants He had set aside, once they humble themselves before Him.
- Committed — God handed over the city, its king and its land in advance. Israel's obedience carried out a settled result; it did not gamble on one.
- Corrected — The order to bring every fighting man overturned Israel's "it's only a small place." It also put shame on the strength they had trusted.
- Costly — The way back ran through the climb up the hill and a pretended retreat. Small enemies called for more care and exact obedience than Jericho ever did.
And thou shalt do to Ai and to its king as thou didst to Jericho and to its king; only, the spoil thereof and the cattle thereof shall ye take as prey for yourselves. Set an ambush against the city behind it.
Achan's sin has been judged, and God now tells Joshua to go up against the small city that had just beaten Israel. Why must Ai fall as Jericho fell, and yet this time the plunder is Israel's to keep and the city must be taken by an ambush?
One writer ties the fresh start to the judging of Achan's sin. God acts for Israel again, but not as He acted at Jericho:
And now we have the Lord's full restitution of the people. They had gone out in self-confidence; they had received the most serious check; but, now that the sin was judged, the Lord was free to act on their behalf. Even then He had His own way. And now it was not a question of great things. This was no time to display the all-overcoming power of God. That power had brought the towering walls of the city down before a blow was struck.
Another writer sets this delay beside an earlier one, when Miriam was judged in the wilderness:
Miriam's sin and judgment had once delayed Israel's progress through the wilderness. Achan's sin and judgment must now delay Israel's progress through the land. But it is only delay. Discipline does not revoke grace; it only maintains holiness. The valley of Achor is a door of hope (Hosea 2:15).
Israel had first said Ai was too small to trouble the whole nation. God's word overturns that estimate:
But how differently was the battle to be fought from the way Israel had first proposed to overthrow the "heap of ruins," Ai! They had said, "Do not make the whole people toil up there." The Lord said, "Take all the fighting men with you." As the thousands of Israel rose to battle, each soldier had to remember not to make light of small foes, for the Lord alone was Israel's strength and courage.
Jericho fell without tactics. Ai falls by a plan. Has God swapped faith for human strategy? One commentator answers:
Are you content to use means that bring your own incapacity into full view? Such means stamp man with his total weakness. They humble him, so that his only resource is to flee before the foe. If so, all well and good. But it is not in your power to do this. In truth, at Ai they are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is this. At Jericho God ordered the arrangements so that Israel might learn His power. At Ai His object was to teach them their own weakness.
William Kelly draws a conclusion from the detailed orders that follow:
God insists on even more care and complete obedience in every detail for the attack on little Ai than He did for the capture of Jericho.
Israel leaves Ai richer than they left Jericho:
Ai falls, and its cattle and spoil belong to the people. In the same way, the gold and silver, the brass and iron of Jericho had already belonged to the Lord.
Another writer applies Ai to the believer's own life:
Ai speaks of the details of worldliness that hold back the spiritual progress of believers. When believers overcome these things, small as they seem, they gain spiritually. So Israel in this case gained through the spoils.
The ambush itself marks a harder road:
Notice in Joshua 8 how complicated everything becomes once Israel leaves the simple path of faith. The soul, humbled, finds itself once more with God, and His presence with it. But the consequences of a self-willed walk remain. God can use them in the end for blessing, yet the path no longer has the simplicity of the early days of faith. Faith's own path is very simple. The believer who follows God's guidance in humble dependence on His word is sure of victory. It was so at Jericho. The same power that brought down the walls of the accursed city is with Israel at Ai. It has not changed, though the army must manoeuvre and split into two groups — five thousand men lie in ambush, while the rest draw the defenders of Ai out of their stronghold.
- Judged, then restored — once Achan's sin was judged, God was free to act for His people again. Discipline delays progress; it does not cancel grace.
- Restored, then humbled — Ai must fall as Jericho fell, but not by walls dropping flat. The same power now works through a plan and an ambush.
- Humbled, then taught — the whole army must march against the town Israel had dismissed as too small to trouble them.
- Taught, then tested — Jericho showed Israel God's power. Ai showed them their own weakness, and the orders for the small city were stricter than those for the great one.
- Tested, then enriched — what the Lord kept for Himself at Jericho He gives to the people at Ai. Gains come to the believer through overcoming small things.
And Joshua arose, and all the people of war, to go up to Ai. And Joshua chose thirty thousand valiant men, and sent them away by night.
Israel's second attack on Ai puts the whole fighting force on the road. Thirty thousand picked men slip away in the dark to hide behind the city. Why does a town they once thought needed two or three thousand men now take the whole army and a trap?
Israel had planned to spare most of the people the climb. The Lord commanded the opposite.
How different this battle would be from the way Israel had first proposed to overthrow the "heap of ruins," Ai! They had said, "Do not make the whole people toil up there." The Lord said, "Take all the fighting men." And as the thousands of Israel rose to battle, each soldier had to remember not to make light of small enemies, for Israel's strength and courage came from the LORD alone.
Set beside the spies' earlier estimate, these numbers are a rebuke.
In Joshua 7 the spies had said in their report: "Let about two or three thousand men go up and attack Ai, for they are few." And now it takes about thirty thousand chosen mighty men of valour. What a humiliation, and how it lowered Israel in their own estimation! They had to go up by night, and while some hid, others pretended to flee before the enemy. What room for boasting after this?
Israel is right with God again, yet the plan for Ai is anything but simple.
Notice in Joshua 8 how complicated everything becomes, through not having followed the simple path of faith. The soul is humbled and finds itself once more with God, and has His presence with it again. But the consequences of a worldly walk remain. God can use even these for their blessing in the end, yet the path no longer has the simplicity of the early days of faith.
The climb the spies hoped to avoid is now the work of the whole nation.
Israel did "toil up there" — some to the ambush, others to the front. When we make mistakes carelessly and sin on purpose in our service, God presses the neglected lessons on us through toil and labour. He does this even though He has shown us our errors and pardoned our ways. And Israel did not only labour up to Ai; God made them victorious through humiliation. By apparent defeat, by fleeing before their enemies, they won their success. Falls and failures teach the believer to walk without self-confidence.
Ai took an ambush, a pretended retreat and a night march. Had Israel swapped faith for tactics?
If you are content to use means that put your own incapacity on display, well and good. Such means leave on man the mark of his total weakness. They humble him, so that his only resource is to flee before the enemy. But it is not in your power to do this. In truth, at Ai they are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is that there God arranged things so that Israel might learn His power, while at Ai His object was to teach them their own weakness.
The size of the force says something about Israel, not about Ai.
They had grown proud of their might. God put dishonour on it at the taking of Ai. Every warrior must go, and they must lay an ambush. What an array of force and strategy to take a little city! ... God knows how to put shame on worldly strength and confidence. He allows — indeed commands — its full display, and will not use it. He gives them the city in His own way.
The plan for Ai was not the plan that took Jericho.
Here He says, "Lay an ambush against the city, behind it" ... God insists on even more care and complete obedience in every detail in the preparations against little Ai than in the capture of Jericho.
Joshua's name stands beside the people's at every stage of this chapter, not just at the start.
Throughout this scene the presence of Joshua blessedly marks the activity of the people. When they were going to war, we read: "So Joshua and all the fighting men arose." (v. 3) On the eve of battle: "Joshua stayed that night among the people." (v. 9) ... And finally, when the victory was decided in their favour: "Joshua did not draw back his hand ... until he had utterly destroyed all the inhabitants of Ai." (v. 26)
- All. Israel had said "not all the people." God says take all the fighting men. No enemy is small enough to face with a smaller force.
- Humbled. Thirty thousand picked men, a night march and a pretended retreat left Israel nothing to boast about.
- Weakness. God arranged Jericho to teach Israel His power. He arranged Ai to teach them their own weakness. The power behind both was the same.
- Detail. Little Ai called for closer obedience than great Jericho. Being right with God again does not remove the extra toil a careless step created.
- Leader. From the first rising to the last stroke, Joshua is with the people. The victory follows their leader, not the size of their army.
And he commanded them, saying, See, ye shall be in ambush against the city, behind the city go not very far from the city, and be all of you ready.
Israel has just dealt with the sin in the camp, and now God sends the whole army back against the little town that had beaten them. Why does the God who used no human means at Jericho now give His people an ambush, a night march and a pretended retreat?
The orders are exact: where to hide, how far to stay from the city, be ready. One writer sets this plan beside the one God used at Jericho.
He next lays down a plan. It is not the plan that brought in the ark and the priests. There it was above all a question of following His own word and the power of the LORD's holy presence… That is, the preparations against little Ai call for even more care and unquestioning obedience in every detail than was used in the capture of Jericho.
At Jericho there were no tactics. Now there is an ambush. One commentator answers the obvious objection.
But you may say: you have shown us that at Jericho it was not a question of human means, and now here are all sorts of schemes for beating the enemy. I reply… in truth at Ai they are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is this. At Jericho God ordered the arrangements so that Israel might learn His power. At Ai His aim was to teach them their own weakness.
The same writer traces this longer road back to the earlier failure.
Notice in Joshua 8 how complicated everything becomes, because they had not followed the simple path of faith… The consequences of a fleshly walk remain. God can use them in the end for their blessing, but the path no longer has the simplicity of the early days of faith.
Compare the numbers before and after the failure.
In Joshua 7 the spies had said in their report: "Let about two or three thousand men go up and attack Ai, for they are few." And now it takes about thirty thousand chosen mighty men of valour. What a humiliation, and how it lowered Israel in their own estimation! They had to go up by night, and while some hid, others pretended to flee before the enemy. What room for boasting after this?
Another writer sees two purposes served by making so much of so small a target.
What we see here is that it is quite an affair to take this small city. In this manner of proceeding there was a double motive: first, to put an end to the discouragement; second, to make all the people feel what the question was.
Israel had wanted to spare most of the people the climb. God's answer gave everyone a task.
All Israel had to "toil up there" — some to the ambush, others to the front. When we make errors carelessly, and sin deliberately in our service, God presses those neglected lessons on us by toil and hard work, even though He has shown us our errors and pardoned our ways. Israel did not only toil up to Ai. God also made them victorious through humiliation: by seeming defeat, by fleeing before their enemies, they won their success.
Hidden behind the city, those men were invisible to the enemy — and so was the change God had worked in Israel.
God's ways with His people baffle all human calculations… We see this principle in the way the king of Ai came out against Israel. He saw no change in them. To his eye they were the same people who had fled before him a day or two earlier. So he imagined they would fall into his hands as easily as before. He did not know that the Lord was among them.
The army splits in two, but the victory is one.
The ambush take Ai and set it on fire. The twenty-five thousand men flee before their enemies, until the smoke of the city tells them to turn back on them… So there is variety in the action and service, but it is one action in common. The body is one. The parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond of union. Lose sight of that unity, and defeat follows.
- All the people. The first plan spared most of Israel the climb. Now everyone goes up — some to the ambush, some to the front — so that the whole nation would feel what was at stake.
- All the detail. Little Ai called for more care and exact obedience than great Jericho. Where they had been careless, God made them careful.
- All the weakness. Jericho taught Israel God's power. Ai taught them their own weakness. The hiding and the pretended flight left them nothing to boast in.
- All unseen. The ambush lay hidden behind the city, and so did God's work in Israel. The king of Ai saw the same beaten army, and did not know the Lord was among them.
- All together. Two divisions, two tasks, one battle, one victory — Joshua's spear held them as one.
And I and all the people that are with me will approach to the city; and it shall come to pass when they come out against us, as at the first, that we will flee before them.
Joshua's plan for the second attack on Ai is play-acting: Israel will march up, let the defenders rush out, then run away on purpose. Why would God's own battle plan make His people act out the defeat that had shamed them?
The plan is not Joshua's own military instinct. One writer notes that the Lord lays it down Himself. It is nothing like Jericho, where the ark and the priests led the way.
First He summons Joshua to take all the people of war; then He promises to give everything into Joshua's hand. He next lays down a plan — not the one that brought in the ark and the priests, where the main point was following His own word and the power of the Lord's holy presence... The preparations against little Ai call for even more care and complete obedience in every detail than the capture of Jericho did.
Joshua counts on the men of Ai remembering their earlier win. The flight is pretend; the shame is real.
Joshua and most of his army must pretend to flee, and so draw the city's "few people" away from it. Thirty-five thousand men to take a town that three thousand were enough for! Pretending to run away as before was no honour, and no heroism. It shamed them as soldiers. This is no example of the mighty power of faith. God knows how to put shame on worldly strength and confidence. He allows, even commands, its full display, and will not use it. He gives them the city in His own way, and uses Israel's power only as He pleases. It plainly says: I can do without you. It proves to them that the strength they boasted in was useless in itself.
At Jericho the walls fell. Here there are night marches, an ambush and a staged rout. One writer answers the objection that Ai looks like human cleverness.
If you are happy to use methods that put your own inability on display, all well and good. Such methods stamp man with his total weakness, and humble him until his only option is to run from the enemy. But it is not in your power to do this. In truth, at Ai the means were no more human than at Jericho. The difference is this: at Jericho God arranged things so that Israel might learn His power, while at Ai His aim was to teach them their own weakness.
The numbers tell the same story.
In Joshua 7 the spies had said in their report: "Let about two or three thousand men go up and attack Ai... for they are few." And now about thirty thousand chosen fighting men are needed. What a humiliation, and how it lowered Israel in their own eyes! They had to go up by night, and while some hid, others pretended to flee before the enemy. What room for boasting after this?
Israel had judged the sin and put it away, and God promised victory. Even so, the road back was not straight.
This shows that God was gracious to His people once they had judged the evil. It also shows that their failure brought needless and unwanted complications into their battles.
The hard work itself becomes the lesson.
"Toil up there" all Israel did — some to the ambush, others to the front. This is because when we make mistakes carelessly, and sin on purpose in our service, God uses toil and hard work to press home the lessons we neglected. He does so even though He has shown us our errors and pardoned our ways. And Israel did not only labour up to Ai. God made them victorious through humiliation: by apparent defeat, by fleeing before their enemies, they won their success.
The king of Ai read the retreat just as Joshua expected. He read the wrong thing.
God's ways with His people baffle all human calculations. The enemy counts only on human might. We see this in the way the king of Ai came out against Israel. He saw no change in them. To his eye they were the very same people who had fled from him a day or two before. So he thought they would fall into his hands as easily as last time. He did not know that the Lord was among them.
- Ordered. The staged flight was God's plan, not Joshua's tactic. It called for closer obedience in detail than Jericho ever did.
- Shamed. Pretending to run was no heroism. It shamed them as soldiers, and God used it to shame the strength Israel had boasted in.
- Weakness. Jericho taught Israel God's power. Ai taught them their own weakness.
- Costly. God forgives sin that is judged. Failure still leaves a harder road: thirty thousand men, a night march, and toil for a small town.
- Hidden. The enemy saw the same men who had fled before. He could not see the Lord among them, and that was the whole difference.
And they will come out after us till we have drawn them from the city; for they will say, They flee before us, as at the first; and we will flee before them.
Joshua tells his men to stage a defeat. They will run, and the men of Ai will chase them, because they remember chasing Israel once before. So why does the God who flattened Jericho's walls now need His people to fake a retreat?
At Jericho, Israel walked and the walls fell. Here the army splits, hides, and lures. One writer answers the obvious objection. Does this not look like human cleverness taking the place of God's power?
You may say: You have shown us that at Jericho it was not a question of human means, and now here are all kinds of tricks for beating the enemy. I reply: suppose you are happy to use methods that put your own inability on display. They stamp man with his total weakness. They humble him, so that his only way out is to run from the enemy. If so, all well and good. But you have no power to do this. In truth, at Ai these are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is this: at Jericho God arranged things so that Israel would learn His power. At Ai His aim was to teach them their own weakness.
The complicated method is itself part of the lesson. God is with His people again, but the road back is not the road they left.
Notice in Joshua 8 how complicated everything becomes, because they did not follow the simple path of faith. The humbled soul finds itself with God once more, and His presence with it. But the consequences of a worldly walk remain. God can use them for blessing in the end, yet the path no longer has the simplicity of the early days of faith.
The words "just as before" point back to a real defeat. Israel's bait is the memory of their own shame, and the size of the operation says the rest:
Thirty-five thousand men to take a town for which three thousand were enough! Pretending to run away as they had the first time was no honour, and there was no heroism in it. It was no instance of the mighty power of faith. God knows how to put shame upon worldly strength and confidence. He allows, indeed commands, its full display, and will not use it. He gives them the city in His own way, and will only use the power of Israel as He pleases. It is plainly saying, I can do without you — proving to them that the strength in which they boasted was in itself a useless thing.
Joshua predicts exactly what the men of Ai will say. Their confidence is not stupidity. They draw it from experience, and it is what destroys them:
The enemy is never so self-confident as when his hour has come. So men will cry, Peace and safety, when sudden destruction comes upon them.
God's instructions here are detailed: where to hide, how far from the city, when to rise. The smaller target called for more exactness, not less.
God demands even more care and complete obedience in every detail in the preparations against the little city of Ai than Israel used in the capture of Jericho.
The retreat was God's idea, not a scheme Joshua invented. That distinction is the point of the whole episode for anyone in conflict today:
Where Christians bring their own plans into the difficulty, they defeat themselves instead of the enemy. They may be completely upright in the main. Even so, the Lord has a quarrel with the self-sufficiency that trusts plans instead of submitting to His will... When we stand on the Lord's ground, we know we are called all the more to obedience, because we have to face the enemy's most cunning tricks. And then He arranges the most unexpected combination of circumstances in our favour. He knows exactly how to time everything for us.
- Cause. Self-confidence lost the first battle at Ai. God shaped the second one to cure it. The strategy fits the patient, not just the enemy.
- Cost. Being back with God does not erase consequences. The simple path of faith gives way to a complicated one, and every step of this plan shows it.
- Contrast. Jericho taught Israel God's power; Ai taught them their own weakness. The same power was at work in both.
- Bait. The pretended flight works because the enemy trusts his last victory. He is never more sure of himself than at the hour of his ruin.
- Cure. Victory comes back through exact obedience, not clever planning. God can do without our strength, and He says so by refusing to use it.
And ye shall rise up from the ambush and take possession of the city; and Jehovah your God will deliver it into your hand.
Israel had lost a battle at Ai, and God had judged the hidden sin in their camp. Now He sends them back to the same city with a plan: a hidden force behind it, and a pretended retreat in front of it. Verse 7 is the hinge: God tells the men in hiding when to move, and gives the reason they will win — not a clever trap, but His promise.
The order of God's words to Joshua matters. He commits Himself to the outcome first, and only then describes how it will happen.
So the LORD adds at this point, and such instructions might surprise some. First He summons Joshua to take all the people of war; then He promises to give all into Joshua's hand. He next lays down a plan. It is not the plan that brought in the ark and the priests. There the main thing was following His own word and the power of the LORD's holy presence.
God's orders for taking this small town are exact in every detail. A small enemy does not mean a lower standard.
That is, God calls for even more care and full obedience in every detail in the preparations against little Ai than He called for in the capture of Jericho. All of this is set out in the finest detail for our instruction.
Israel had once said three thousand men were enough for Ai. Now the whole army marches, and its soldiers must run away on purpose.
Thirty-five thousand men to take a town for which three thousand were enough! To pretend to run away as at the first was no honour: no heroism in this. It was to their shame as soldiers. This is no instance of the mighty power of faith. God knows how to put shame upon worldly strength and confidence. He allows, and even commands, its full display, and will not use it. He gives them the city in His own way, and will only use the power of Israel as He pleases. All this plainly says, "I can do without you." It proves to them that the strength they boasted in was in itself a useless thing.
The promise at the end of verse 7 rests on God's power, not on the trap. That power has not changed, but the road to victory has.
Notice in Joshua 8 how complicated everything becomes, because the simple path of faith was not followed. The humbled soul finds itself with God once more, and His presence with it. But the consequences of a walk in the flesh remain. God can in the end use them for their blessing, yet the path no longer has the simplicity of the early days of faith. The path itself is very simple. The believer who follows God's guidance in humble dependence on His word is sure of victory. It was so at Jericho. The same power that brought down the walls of that cursed city is with Israel at Ai. It has not changed, even though the army must now manoeuvre and split into two parts — five thousand men lying in ambush, while the rest lure the defenders of Ai out of their stronghold.
The men in ambush could only rise up because the camp was clean again. The same pattern repeats in lives that lose their power and then get it back.
Men once used for God are at times set aside by God. They go on with their work as before, but they win no victories... The story of Ai uncovers the cause — hidden evil is in the camp. Then these same servants rise up again. After a time of defeat, they become vessels of power once more, with God and with men. The story of Ai again lets us into the secret: they have been before God, and have humbled themselves.
An ambush works because it stays out of sight. So does the work God does in a person's heart.
The world does not see hidden work, the work that goes on in the heart with God. God's ways with His people baffle all human calculations. The enemy counts only on human strength... We see this principle in the way the king of Ai came out against Israel. He saw no change in them. To his eye, they were the very same people who had fled from him a day or two earlier. So he thought they would fall into his hands just as easily as before. He did not know that the Lord was among them.
- Cleared — strength for the fight came back only after God judged the hidden evil in the camp and the people humbled themselves.
- Promised — God gave the city into their hand before He described a single move. The ambush only collected a victory He had already granted.
- Humbled — the whole army, the pretended retreat, an elaborate trap for a small town: God shamed the strength Israel had boasted in.
- Obeyed — little Ai called for closer obedience in every detail than the fall of Jericho did.
- Unseen — the king of Ai saw the same beaten men and marched out. He could not see that the Lord was now among them.
And it shall be when ye have taken the city, that ye shall set the city on fire; according to the word of Jehovah shall ye do. See, I have commanded you.
Joshua's battle orders for Ai end with a command about obedience: burn the city, and do it exactly as the LORD said. Why would the capture of one small town need such careful instructions?
The plan for Ai is different from the plan for Jericho, where the ark and the priests led the way. One writer follows the new orders down to their last line:
He next lays down a plan. It is not the plan that brought in the ark and the priests, where it was above all a question of following His own word and the power of the Lord's holy presence. But here He says, "Lay an ambush for the city behind it"… "Then you shall rise up from the ambush and seize the city, for the LORD your God will deliver it into your hand. And as soon as you have taken the city, you shall set the city on fire. You shall do according to the word of the LORD." That is, the preparations against little Ai call for even more care and complete obedience in every detail than the capture of Jericho did.
Israel had treated Ai as too small to trouble the whole nation. The new plan answers that presumption:
And now, with the hindrance to God's power acting for them removed, Joshua is encouraged to go up again against Ai. But their former presumption still needs rebuke, and so they are made to labour in the capture of the city, despite its smallness. All the people take part in it. An ambush is placed behind the city, and they are made to pretend that they are fleeing as they fled before. All this is clearly humiliation for their pride. How much in the work that we do for God has to conform itself to the need there is in us! God shapes His instruments, even while He works with them.
The pretended flight was not only a trick on the enemy. It was a lesson to the men carrying it out.
Why did Jericho need no tactics, while Ai needs an ambush and a pretended flight? One writer answers the objection:
Are you content to use means that put your own inability on display? Such means stamp on man the mark of his total weakness. They humble him, so that his only resource is to flee before the foe. If you are, all well and good. But it is not in your power to do this. In truth at Ai they are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is this. At Jericho God ordered the arrangements so that Israel might learn His power. At Ai His object was to teach them their own weakness.
The same writer adds what all the manoeuvring cost them in self-esteem. Where two or three thousand had once seemed enough, thirty thousand are now called out:
What a humiliation, and how it lowered Israel in their own estimation! They had to go up by night, and while some hid, others pretended to flee before the enemy. What room for boasting after this?
The men in hiding had one task: take the city and set it on fire. The rest of the army ran away. Both moves belonged to one battle:
The men in ambush take Ai and set it on fire. Meanwhile the twenty-five thousand flee before their enemies, until the smoke of the city tells them to turn back on them. Just as they begin to fight, the men in ambush come out of the city and join the battle. Then all the Israelites return to Ai and strike it with the edge of the sword. So there is diversity in the action and service, but it is an action in common. The body is one; the several parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond of union. Lose sight of the unity, and defeat follows.
The instruction to burn Ai was a one-off order for one city. The principle behind it was not:
What a lesson all this discipline was for Israel, and for us too! … Israel had to learn, as we have, that the secret of divine power for them lay in closely following God's word. … But the question is: how are we to conduct ourselves down here? Are we to settle down and rest, thinking that because we are saved we are all right, and can live as we please? This is a fatal mistake.
- Command — the plan ends with the rule that governs it: do everything by the word of the LORD. The small city called for stricter obedience than the great one.
- Correction — Israel had thought Ai too small to trouble the whole nation. Now the whole nation had to labour over it, and the humbling was part of the work.
- Contrast — the means at Ai were no more human than at Jericho. Jericho taught Israel God's power; Ai taught them their own weakness.
- Cooperation — some hid and lit the fire, others fled on purpose. The service differed, but the action was one, held together by Joshua.
- Continuation — the lesson still stands for us. Closely following God's word remains the secret of divine power.
And Joshua sent them forth; and they went to lie in ambush, and abode between Bethel and Ai, on the west of Ai. And Joshua lodged that night among the people.
Verse 9 is the quiet hinge of the second attack on Ai. The ambush slips away by night to hide west of the city. Joshua himself stays in the camp — a small detail that commentators treat as anything but small.
The night march only happens because Israel has already judged the hidden sin of Joshua 7. One writer marks the change in their standing before God.
And now we have the Lord's full restoration of the people. They had gone out in self-confidence; they had received a most serious check; but now that the sin was judged, Jehovah was free to act on their behalf. Even then He had His own way.
The scale of the operation is out of all proportion to the target. Israel had once said a few thousand men would do.
In Joshua 7 the spies had said in their report: "Let about two or three thousand men go up and attack Ai, for they are few." And now about thirty thousand chosen mighty men of valour are needed. What a humiliation, and how it lowered Israel in their own estimation! They had to go up by night, and while some hid, others pretended to flee before the enemy. What room for boasting after this?
The same writer answers the obvious objection — that Jericho fell without human tactics, while Ai needs a scheme.
In truth at Ai they are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is that there God ordered the arrangements so that Israel might learn His power, while at Ai His object was to teach them their own weakness.
In verse 9 the men do exactly what Joshua told them: they go where he sends them and lie in wait.
God insisted on even more care and exact obedience in every detail for the attack on little Ai than for the capture of Jericho.
The same writer sums up what that night taught.
Now they felt how much depended on heeding the Lord and His word. Recovery after haste is sure, but it must be humbling.
Verse 9 fixes the ambush between two towns. Their names pull in opposite directions.
Next we hear of Ai. It is beside Beth-aven, the "house of vanity," and in front of Bethel, the "house of God." In Abram's time, when he first came into the land, Bethel and Ai lay on either side of him. So the two stand opposed to one another. (Gen. 12) You can tell what Ai is by what it joins itself to and what it stands against, and the world's stamp is plain on it.
Ai had looked negligible the first time round. Its very name invited contempt.
Israel looked at Ai as contemptible. Its name — "a heap of ruins" — suggests it was not like Jericho, a city mighty and fortified. If it had been a powerful place, maybe Israel would have sought God about its overthrow. But the words of the spies, "Do not make the whole people toil up there, for they are few," show confidence in their own strength instead of trust in God for Ai's destruction. If we truly recognise God as our only strength, we depend on Him as much for the small enemies as for the great. Do we not know in practice how little enemies cause great defeats?
Verse 9 ends with the commander in the camp, not with the picked force. One writer traces this through the whole chapter.
Israel is now restored to communion with God. Throughout this scene the presence of Joshua marks the activity of the people. When they were going to war: "Joshua and all the fighting men arose." (v. 3) On the eve of battle: "Joshua spent that night among the people." (v. 9) When the march was about to begin: "Joshua spent that night in the valley." (v. 13) And when the victory went their way: "Joshua did not draw back his hand... until he had devoted all the inhabitants of Ai to destruction." (v. 26)
The king of Ai had no idea what God had been doing in Israel.
The world does not see hidden work — what goes on in the heart with God. God's ways with His people baffle all human calculation... He saw no change in them. To his eye they were the very same people who had fled before him a day or two earlier; so he imagined they would fall into his hands as easily as before. He did not know that the Lord was among them.
- Judged — Israel could set the ambush only because the sin in the camp had been judged. With that settled, God was free to act for them again.
- Humbled — Israel had despised Ai as too small to bother with. Thirty thousand men, a night march and a pretended retreat left them no room for boasting.
- Obedient — little Ai called for more exact obedience than mighty Jericho. Recovery after haste is sure, but it humbles.
- Accompanied — Joshua spent that night with the people. That is the first link in a chain: their leader is with them at every stage, right to the final victory.
- Hidden — the king of Ai saw the same beaten army he had chased before. He did not know the Lord was among them. God's secret work in His people stays out of sight until the result shows.
And Joshua rose early in the morning, and inspected the people, and went up, he and the elders of Israel, before the people to Ai.
Israel had just judged the hidden sin in their camp, and now they march back to the small town that once beat them. The verse marks a fresh start, and it raises the question of what changes when God restores a people after failure — and what still costs them.
The first attempt on Ai used a few thousand men because scouts judged the town too small to be worth the trouble. Now Joshua musters the entire fighting force. One commentator sets the two orders side by side:
But this battle would be fought very differently from the way Israel had first proposed to overthrow the "heap of ruins," Ai! They had said, "Do not make the whole people toil up there." The Lord said, "Take all the fighting men." Israel's strength and courage came from the Lord alone. So as the thousands rose to battle, every soldier had to remember that small enemies must never be taken lightly.
Being told to bring everyone was no compliment. The size of the force humbled Israel, and the same writer then sets Ai beside Jericho:
In Joshua 7 the spies reported: "Let about two or three thousand men go up and strike Ai, for they are few." Now about thirty thousand chosen, brave fighting men are required. What a humiliation, and how it lowered Israel in their own estimation! They had to go up by night, and while some hid, others pretended to flee before the enemy. What room for boasting after this? … In truth, the means used at Ai are no more human than the means used at Jericho. The difference is this: at Jericho God arranged things so that Israel might learn His power, while at Ai His aim was to teach them their own weakness.
Joshua's early start fits a people who now weigh every word from the Lord. One writer sums up the change:
They felt now how vital it was to heed the Lord and His word. Recovery after acting in haste must be humbling, however sure it is.
Joshua does not send the army; he goes up before it, with the elders. That pattern runs through the whole chapter, and one commentator traces it verse by verse:
Israel is now restored to communion with God. Throughout this scene the presence of Joshua puts a blessed mark on everything the people do. When they were going to war, we read: "Joshua arose, and all the people" (v. 3). On the eve of battle: "Joshua lodged that night among the people" (v. 9). When the march was about to begin: "Joshua went that night into the middle of the valley" (v. 13). When it was a question of luring the enemy: "Joshua and all Israel acted as if they were beaten" (v. 15). When they had put the enemy to flight: "Joshua and all Israel … killed the men of Ai" (v. 21).
None of this could happen if Israel had left the sin buried. Their confidence to go up a second time rests on what happened in the previous chapter:
Sin confessed, judged and put away restored communion with the Lord. If any burden remained on Joshua's mind, the repeated words of comfort and cheer removed it: "Do not fear and do not be dismayed." The failure never comes up again. Instead there is comfort, assurance and a promise of victory. He deals in the same gracious way with us whenever we have failed and humbled ourselves before Him in self-judgment.
The word the scouts used was "toil" — they wanted the nation spared it. In the end everyone toiled. One commentator reads this as God's way of teaching a lesson they had skipped:
"Toil up there" all Israel did — some to the ambush, others to the front. For when we make careless mistakes, and sin on purpose in our service, God presses on us by toil and labour those lessons we neglected. He does this even though He has shown us our errors and pardoned our ways.
Yet the delay did not wreck God's plan. Another writer looks back on the whole episode and finds the fault not only punished but blotted out:
We may note here that, as God's dealings worked out, the fault committed before the attack on Ai seems blotted out, and had even contributed to the unfolding of His purposes. At the time it had held them back, and it was punished. But God set Himself to restore Israel morally, back to the confidence of faith. Nothing hindered the great object of His dealings. This is no excuse; but it is a sweet and strong consolation.
- Cleared — Israel confessed the sin, judged it and put it away. Only then could the camp move, and God stopped mentioning the failure.
- Counted — scouts once spared the nation the trouble. Now Joshua musters every fighting man, because small enemies are never safe to take lightly.
- Early — the dawn start matches the new temper of the camp, which now weighs every word from the Lord.
- Costly — the toil they tried to avoid became the lesson they had to learn, and the humbling left no room for boasting.
- Restored — Joshua goes up at the head of his people, and God blots out the earlier fault without letting it hinder His purpose.
And all the people of war that were with him went up, and drew near, and came before the city; and they encamped on the north of Ai; and the valley was between them and Ai.
Israel returns to the small town that had beaten them. This time the whole army marches up and camps in full view, with a ravine between them and the city. Why does a place so small now need every soldier and a hidden ambush?
Israel had first planned to spare most of the people the climb. God told Joshua to take the whole fighting force instead, and the camp on the north side is the result.
The Lord had turned from the fierceness of His anger against His people Israel. Now He encouraged Joshua to go forward: "Do not be afraid, and do not be discouraged. Take all the people of war with you, and go up to Ai." God's words gave real reassurance. They recalled His first gracious call and encouragement. Victory was certain. But this battle would be fought very differently from the plan Israel first proposed for destroying Ai, that "heap of ruins"! They had said, "Do not make all the people toil up there." The Lord said, "Take all the people of war." As the thousands of Israel rose to battle, each soldier had to remember never to make light of a small foe, for Israel's strength and courage came from the LORD alone.
Calling out the entire fighting force was not overkill. It was Israel's normal pattern, and the one time they broke it, they lost.
In the days of the nation's moral prosperity under Joshua, all Israel went up to battle whenever war came. This showed the unity of the people in a striking way. The first conflict at Ai (Joshua 7:1-5) was the only exception to this rule, and it ended in the defeat of those who took part in it.
That oneness runs through the whole story, not just the winning part of it.
The people were one. They were one in their victory, one in their failure, one in their defeat, one in the judgment of the evil, one in their restoration.
Jericho fell without any of this. Here the army must split in two and take up positions, and commentators read that added complication as a lasting cost of the earlier sin.
Notice how complicated everything becomes in Joshua 8, because Israel did not follow the simple path of faith. The humbled soul finds itself with God again, and His presence with it. But the consequences of walking in the flesh remain. God can use them for blessing in the end, yet the path no longer has the simplicity of the early days of faith. That path is very simple: the believer who follows God's guidance in dependence on His word is sure of victory. It was so at Jericho. The same power that brought down the walls of that accursed city is with Israel at Ai. It has not changed, even though the army must now manoeuvre and split into two forces — five thousand men lying in ambush, while the rest draw the defenders of Ai out of their stronghold.
Rossier raises the objection himself, then answers it.
You may say: you have shown us that at Jericho human means were not the question, and now here are all sorts of devices for beating the enemy. I reply: if you are content to use means that show up your own incapacity, all well and good. Such means leave on man the mark of his total weakness, and humble him until his only resource is to run from the enemy. But it is not in your power to do this. In truth, at Ai they are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is this. At Jericho God arranged things so that Israel might learn His power. At Ai His aim was to teach them their own weakness.
The whole nation now labours over one small town. That labour is itself part of God's discipline.
Their former presumption still needs rebuke, and so God makes them labour to capture the city, small as it is. All the people take part in it. They set an ambush behind the city, and God makes them pretend to flee, just as they had fled before. All this humbles their pride. How much in the work we do for God has to shape itself to the need there is in us! God shapes His instruments, even while He works with them.
- Sin costs. The complications of this second campaign — a divided army, a staged retreat, hard labour for a small town — trace back to the simple path of faith that Israel left.
- Restoration is real. God's presence and power are with Israel at Ai just as at Jericho. Only the simplicity of the road changed, not the strength behind it.
- All are called. A town once thought easy now needs every fighting man. No enemy is small enough to make light of.
- Unity holds. Israel is one in victory, failure, defeat, judgment of evil, and recovery. The one time part of the nation acted alone, it lost.
- Weakness is the lesson. Jericho taught Israel God's power. Ai taught them their own weakness. God shapes His instruments even while He uses them.
Now he had taken about five thousand men, and set them in ambush between Bethel and Ai, on the west of the city.
Israel is back at Ai, the small town that had beaten them while sin lay buried in the camp. This time God gives the battle plan Himself. Verse 12 records a second hidden group: about five thousand men west of the city.
The ambush was not clever soldiering. God chose the plan and gave the orders Himself.
Here He says, "Lay an ambush for the city behind it." So Joshua and all the fighting men went up against Ai... "And when you have taken the city, you shall set the city on fire. You shall do according to the word of the LORD." That is, God asks for even more care and complete obedience in every detail in the preparations against little Ai than was needed to capture Jericho.
At Jericho the walls came down. Here the army splits in two, some hiding, some pretending to run. One writer traces that difference back to Israel's earlier failure.
Notice in Joshua 8 how complicated everything becomes, because they did not follow the simple path of faith. The soul, humbled, finds itself once more with God, and His presence with it, but the consequences of a self-pleasing walk remain... The same power that brought down the walls of the accursed city is with Israel at Ai. It has not changed, although the army must use tactics and split into two groups. Five thousand men lie in ambush, while the rest lure the defenders of Ai out of their stronghold.
Someone may object: Jericho used no human means, yet Ai is full of them. The same writer answers that objection.
In truth, the means used at Ai are no more human than those used at Jericho. The difference is this. At Jericho God arranged things so that Israel would learn His power. At Ai His aim was to teach them their own weakness.
Israel had once thought three thousand men would be enough for Ai. Now thirty thousand hide behind the city, five thousand more lie to the west, and the whole army marches.
What an array of force and trickery to take a little city! Joshua and most of his army must pretend to run away, to draw the city's "few people" out after them. Thirty-five thousand men to take a town for which three thousand were enough! Pretending to run as they had the first time was no honour. There was no heroism in it. It was to their shame as soldiers... God knows how to put shame upon worldly strength and confidence.
The verse names the ground between two towns. One writer reads Ai's character from those names.
Next we hear of Ai. It is beside Beth-aven, the "house of vanity," and in front of Bethel, the "house of God." In Abram's time, when he first comes into the land, Bethel and Ai lie on either side of him, set against each other. You can tell what Ai is by what it joins itself to and by what it stands against. The mark of the world is clearly on it.
The ambush was hidden. So was something else.
Hidden work, that which goes on in the heart with God, the world does not see. God's ways with His people baffle all human calculations... We see this in the way the king of Ai came out against Israel. He saw no change in them. To his eye, they were the same people who had fled before him a day or two earlier; therefore he imagined they would fall into his hands as easily as before. He did not know that the Lord was among them.
- Failure first. Israel's defeat at Ai came from leaving the simple path of faith. The humbled soul finds God again, but the complications remain.
- Plan given. God Himself places the five thousand in ambush, and the small city calls for stricter obedience in detail than the great one did.
- Weakness taught. Jericho showed Israel God's power. Ai showed them their own weakness. The power behind both was the same.
- Shame accepted. Thirty-five thousand men, a pretend retreat, and hidden troops to take one small town. God puts shame on self-confidence before He gives victory.
- Hidden work. The king of Ai saw the same army as before. He never saw what God had done in their hearts, and that is why he lost.
And when they had set the people, the whole camp on the north of the city, and their ambush on the west of the city, Joshua went that night into the midst of the valley.
Israel is about to attack Ai a second time, and this verse shows where each part of the army stood the night before. One man is not resting with the troops: Joshua goes down into the valley, the lowest and most exposed ground in the whole scene.
One writer lays out where each part of the army stood:
Early the next morning Joshua mustered his army and brought them to the north side of Ai, where they encamped (v.11). He also set about 5,000 men in ambush on the west side of the city. So there were 30,000 lying in wait behind the city and 5,000 on the west side, and a large army with Joshua at the front of the city.
Ai was a small place, and Israel's first attack on it had ended in defeat. The orders for the second attack go the other way:
So the preparations against little Ai call for even more care and complete obedience in every detail than the capture of Jericho did.
The same writer notes what Israel now felt:
Now they felt how vital it was to heed the Lord and His word. Recovery after acting in haste is certain, but it must be humbling.
At Ai there are ambushes and a pretended retreat, and it can look as if human tactics have replaced trust. One writer answers that objection:
If you are happy to use methods that put your own inability on display, that stamp a man with the mark of his total weakness, and that humble him until his only option is to run from the enemy, then fine. But you have no power to do that. In truth, the means used at Ai are no more human than those used at Jericho. The difference is this. At Jericho God arranged things so that Israel might learn His power. At Ai His aim was to teach them their own weakness.
Another writer links the whole labour of this attack to Israel's pride:
Now that what hindered God's power from acting for them had been removed, Joshua is encouraged to go up against Ai again. But their earlier presumption still needs rebuke, so they have to work hard to capture the city, small as it is. All the people take part in it. An ambush is set behind the city, and they have to pretend to flee, as they fled before. All of this is humiliation for their pride. How much in the work that we do for God has to conform itself to the need there is in us! God shapes His instruments, even while He works with them.
Joshua going into the valley fits a pattern. Wherever the people are, he is there too:
Israel is now restored to communion with God. Throughout this scene, the presence of Joshua marks everything the people do. When they were going to war we read, "Joshua and all the fighting men arose" (v. 3). On the eve of battle, "Joshua spent that night among the people" (v. 9). When the march was about to begin, "Joshua spent that night in the valley" (v. 13). When it was a question of drawing out the enemy, "Joshua and all Israel pretended to be beaten" (v. 15).
The same writer asks what holds three separated groups together:
Diversity is not division, because it shows itself in unity. The men in ambush take Ai and set it on fire, while the twenty-five thousand flee from their enemies. Then the smoke of the city tells them to turn back on the enemy... So there is diversity in the action and service, but it is an action in common. The body is one; the several parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond of union. Lose sight of that unity, and defeat follows.
One writer reads the three positions in this chapter as three ways a believer stands against evil:
(1) Entrenched against evil — those camped on the north side of Ai (v.11). Compare Ephesians 6:13. (2) Watching against evil — those who lay in ambush (v.12). Compare 1 Corinthians 16:13. (3) Appearing against evil — Joshua's group going into the midst of the valley (v.13). Compare Ephesians 5:11.
- Judged. Israel deals with the sin in the camp first. Only then is Joshua encouraged to go up against Ai again.
- Humbled. The huge force, the night march and the pretended retreat were not military necessity. They were a rebuke to Israel's earlier pride.
- Taught. Jericho showed Israel God's power. Ai showed them their own weakness. Neither victory came by human means.
- Accompanied. Joshua is with the people at every stage. He camps among them, goes down into the valley, and runs with them in the pretended retreat.
- United. Three separate groups, one action. Joshua is the bond that holds them together, and where that unity is lost, defeat follows.
And it came to pass when the king of Ai saw it, that the men of the city hasted and rose early, and went out against Israel to battle, he and all his people, at the appointed place before the plain. But he knew not that there was an ambush against him behind the city.
The king of Ai saw Israel in the open ground before him and ran out to fight at first light, sure he was repeating an easy win. He did not know that armed men were waiting behind his city.
The king was sure of himself. One writer states the rule his confidence illustrates:
The enemy is never so self-confident as when his hour has come. So men will cry, "Peace and safety," when sudden destruction comes upon them.
The king attacked on the strength of what he could see.
The world does not see hidden work, the kind that goes on in the heart with God. God's ways with His people baffle all human calculations. The enemy counts only on human strength. The world takes no interest in the secret things that turn God's hand against His people in their path of service and warfare. We see this principle in the way the king of Ai came out against Israel. He saw no change in them. To his eye they were the very same people who had fled before him a day or two before. So he imagined they would fall into his hands just as easily as before. He did not know that the Lord was among them.
What had changed was invisible from the city wall. The same writer says where that change came from:
The pagan king never dreamed what God's secret work in the camp had produced. God did that work through His dealings with them in government and in rebuke. Israel was a different people from what they had been a few days earlier; their hands were clean and their hearts were strong.
Taking Ai turned into a complicated business. One writer explains where the complication came from:
Notice in Joshua 8 how complicated everything becomes through not having followed the simple path of faith. The soul, humbled, finds itself once more with God, and His presence with it, but the consequences of a careless walk remain. Although God can in the end use these for their blessing, the path no longer has the simplicity of the early days of faith.
The plan cost Israel in effort and in pride.
All Israel laboured up to Ai — some to the ambush, others to the front. That is because when we make careless mistakes and sin deliberately in our service, God presses the neglected lessons on us through toil and labour. He does this even after He has shown us our errors and pardoned our ways. And Israel did not only labour up to Ai; God made them victorious through humiliation. By apparent defeat, by fleeing before their enemies, they won their success.
Ai's men did the one thing that made the trap work: they left the city. One writer contrasts them with Jericho:
The king of Ai at once led his army out of the gates to attack Israel as he had before. He knew nothing of the ambushes waiting for him (v.14)… All the army of Ai joined the pursuit of Israel, leaving the city without defence (vs.15-17). They were not like the men of Jericho, who kept their city shut tight against Israel. They felt strong in taking the offensive, no doubt encouraged because they had done so before and won.
There is a warning here for anyone facing a fight of their own:
Where Christians bring their own plans into the difficulty, they defeat themselves instead of the enemy… Dependence and trust in Him is the wisdom of those engaged in conflict with the enemy… When we are on the Lord's ground, we know we are called all the more to obedience, because we have to face the subtlest tricks of the enemy. Then He arranges the most unexpected combination of circumstances in our favour. He knows exactly how to time everything for us.
- Unseen sin. Careless service and deliberate sin leave consequences. The path loses the simplicity of the early days of faith, and God presses the neglected lessons home through toil.
- Unseen cost. An ambush, real toil, a pretended defeat — God gave Israel victory through humiliation.
- Unseen ambush. The king went out to the appointed place and never knew men were waiting behind him. Unlike Jericho, Ai opened its gates and doomed itself.
- Unseen change. He saw the same people who had fled before. God's work in the heart is invisible to the world, which counts only on human strength.
- Unseen hand. The enemy is never so sure of himself as when his hour has come. God times everything, so His people are to depend on Him and not on their own plans.
And Joshua and all Israel let themselves be beaten before them; and they fled by the way of the wilderness.
Israel's soldiers had already run from Ai once, in a real defeat. This time they run on purpose. Commentators ask why God took this small city by a staged retreat, when at Jericho He had shown His power openly.
The flight was not a last-minute idea on the battlefield. God gave Joshua the plan before the army moved, and the retreat was part of it.
He next lays down a plan. It is not the plan that brought in the ark and the priests. There it was above all a question of following His own word and the power of the Lord's holy presence. But here He says, "Lay an ambush against the city, behind it." … "When they come out against us just as before, we shall flee before them… Then you shall rise up from the ambush and seize the city." That is, the preparations against little Ai call for even more care and exact obedience in every detail than the capture of Jericho did.
Israel wins, but the win leaves them nothing to boast about. One writer counts what this little city cost them in pride.
Their own might had lifted them up. God put dishonour on it at the taking of Ai. Every warrior must go, and they must lay an ambush. What a display of force and trickery to take a little city! Joshua and the bulk of his army must pretend to flee, and so draw its "few people" away from the city. Thirty-five thousand men to take a town for which three thousand were enough! To pretend to flee as at the first was no honour: no heroism in this. It was to their shame as soldiers.
Some say God won Jericho, while clever tactics won Ai. One writer answers that the means at Ai were no more human than at Jericho. Only the lesson changed.
In truth at Ai they are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is this. At Jericho God arranged things so that Israel might learn His power. At Ai His object was to teach them their own weakness.
The same writer follows Joshua's name through the chapter. Joshua is named in the pretend flight, as well as in the killing that followed.
When it was a question of luring the enemy: "Joshua and all Israel pretended to be beaten before them." (v. 15). When they had put the enemy to flight: "Joshua and all Israel… struck down the men of Ai." (v. 21)
Israel is back on the winning side. Even so, the road back runs through all this trouble, and one writer counts the cost.
Success is now certain. But all the people must go up against this small city, which two or three thousand men could have taken, by human reckoning. This is a sharp rebuke to pride and false confidence. What trouble Joshua must now take! Lay an ambush, pretend to flee: all this to take a small city, and not much glory after all. It costs more effort to return into the path of blessing than it would have taken to avoid the evil. But the simplicity of faith and its natural vigour can be regained no other way.
The men of Ai chased a beaten-looking Israel out of their city. One writer finds a pattern in it.
The enemy, as we shall see, is never so self-confident as when his hour has come. So men will cry, "Peace and safety," when sudden destruction comes upon them.
There is a difference between a plan we are given and a plan we think up for ourselves.
This shows God making everything work together. It comes about where we do not trust in our own manoeuvring, but keep our hearts subject to His word. First the evil had to be seen and judged, for it had made it impossible for God's presence to be with His people in power. Where Christians bring their own plans into the difficulty, they defeat themselves instead of the enemy. Even though they may be thoroughly upright in the main, the Lord has a controversy with the self-sufficiency that trusts plans instead of being subject to His will.
- Commanded — The pretend retreat was God's plan, not Israel's cleverness. It called for closer obedience in every detail than Jericho did.
- Costly — Getting back costs more effort than avoiding the failure would have. There is no other road back to simple, vigorous faith.
- Humbling — Thirty-five thousand men, an ambush and a pretend flight, all for a town three thousand could have taken. God left them no room to boast.
- Weakness — At Jericho God taught Israel His power. At Ai He taught them their own weakness. The same hand arranged both.
- Victory — The enemy is most sure of himself just before his hour comes. Ai chased a beaten-looking Israel, left the city open, and lost it.
And all the people that were in the city were called together to pursue after them; and they pursued after Joshua, and were drawn away from the city.
Ai's whole fighting force pours out of the gate, chasing an army that is only pretending to run. The trap works — but why did Israel need a trap at all, when Jericho fell without human means?
Ai's men did not stay behind their walls. An earlier win pulled them out into the open.
The king of Ai at once led his army out of the gates to attack Israel as he did before. He did not know about the ambushes. Joshua and his army retreated then, fleeing from Ai. All the army of Ai joined in pursuit of Israel, leaving the city without defence. They were not like the men of Jericho, who kept their city shut tight against Israel. They felt strong in taking the offensive, no doubt encouraged because they had attacked before and won.
Ai is surest of itself at the very moment of its ruin. One writer sees a pattern here that reaches far past this battle.
The enemy is never so self-confident as when his hour has come. So people will be saying, "There is peace and security," when sudden destruction comes upon them.
Israel wins, but the way they win is humbling.
Every warrior must go, and an ambush must be laid. What an array of force and trickery to take a little city! Joshua and the bulk of his army must pretend to flee, and so draw away from the city its "few people." Thirty-five thousand men to take a town for which three thousand were enough! To pretend to run away as at the first was no honour: no heroism in this. It was to their shame as soldiers. This is no instance of the mighty power of faith. God knows how to put shame on worldly strength and confidence.
Israel had already been beaten once at Ai. This is what recovery looked like.
Success is now certain. But all the people must go up against this small city — by human strength, two or three thousand men might have taken it. This is a sharp rebuke to pride and false confidence. How much trouble Joshua must now take! Lay an ambush, pretend to flee: all this to take a small city, and not much glory after all. It costs more effort to return to the path of blessing than it would have cost to avoid the evil. But there is no other way to regain the simplicity of faith and its natural vigour.
Does the ambush at Ai look like mere human tactics next to Jericho? One writer answers that both plans came from God, and each taught something different.
You may say: you have shown us that at Jericho it was not a question of human means, and now here are all sorts of contrivances for conquering the enemy. I reply: if you are content to use means which make your incapacity stand out, all well and good. Such means leave on man the mark of his total weakness. They humble him, so that his only resource is to flee before the enemy. But it is not in your power to do this. In truth at Ai they are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is this. At Jericho God ordered the arrangements so that Israel might learn His power. At Ai His object was to teach them their own weakness.
The army is split — some hiding, the rest running. Yet both halves do one work.
Diversity is not division; for it shows itself in unity. The men in ambush take Ai and set it on fire. Meanwhile the twenty-five thousand men flee before their enemies, until the smoke of the city tells them to turn back on them. Just as they begin to fight, the men in ambush come out of the city and join the battle. Then all the Israelites return to Ai and strike it with the edge of the sword. So there is diversity in the action and service, but it is an action in common. The body is one. Its parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond of union. Lose sight of that unity, and the result is defeat.
- Drawn out by pride. An earlier win made Ai's king bold. He emptied the city and gave chase — and his hour had come.
- Drawn back by shame. There was no heroism in the pretended flight. It took thirty-five thousand men and an ambush to win a town three thousand were enough to take.
- Drawn home the hard way. Getting back on the path of blessing cost more than avoiding the evil would have. There is no other road back.
- Drawn to the right lesson. Jericho taught Israel God's power; Ai taught them their own weakness. Both plans came from Him.
- Drawn into one. Hidden men and fleeing men did one work. Joshua's spear held them together. Lose sight of that unity, and defeat follows.
And not a man remained in Ai and Bethel that went not out after Israel; and they left the city open, and pursued after Israel.
Every fighting man in Ai, along with the men of nearby Bethel, chases Israel out of the city. They leave the gates wide open behind them. This is the moment the trap closes. It also raises a question: why did God's people need a trap at all to take so small a town?
Every man goes out. Nobody stays behind to guard the walls. One writer sees a pattern in that:
The enemy is never so self-confident as when his hour has come. So men will cry, Peace and safety, when sudden destruction comes upon them.
Ai had beaten Israel once already. That win makes them bold enough to come out from behind their walls:
The whole army of Ai joined the chase after Israel, leaving the city with no defence (vs.15-17). They were not like the men of Jericho, who kept their city shut tight against Israel. They felt strong enough to attack, no doubt because they had attacked Israel before and won.
Israel wins here by pretending to run away. One writer sees that clumsy method as deliberate:
Success is now certain. But all the people must go up against this small city. Judging by human strength, two or three thousand men could have taken it. This is a sharp rebuke to pride and false confidence. How much trouble Joshua must now take! Lay an ambush, pretend to run away: all this to take a small city, and not much glory after all. It costs more effort to come back into the path of blessing than it would have cost to avoid the evil.
The same plan has a second edge. God calls out the whole army, then wins by a trick that leaves the soldiers nothing to boast about:
Thirty-five thousand men to take a town that three thousand were enough for! To pretend to run away, as they had the first time, was no honour: there is no heroism in this. It was to their shame as soldiers. This is no example of the mighty power of faith. God knows how to put shame on worldly strength and confidence. He allows it — no, He commands it — to be fully displayed, and then will not use it. He gives them the city in His own way, and will use the power of Israel only as He pleases. He is saying openly, I can do without you. He proves to them that the strength they boasted in was in itself a useless thing.
The verse names two towns, and their names carry weight. Ai lies beside a place whose name means vanity, and faces the town whose name means the house of God:
Next we hear of Ai. It lies beside Beth-aven, the "house of vanity," and in front of Bethel, the "house of God." When Abram first comes into the land, Bethel and Ai lie on either side of him, set against each other. (Gen. 12.) You can tell what Ai is by the company it keeps and by what it stands against, and the stamp of the world is clearly on it.
The same writer notes that the name Ai means "a heap," and reads it as "the world seen in its ruin as faith sees it, which yet apart from God's presence with us we are not able to overcome."
Ai empties its gates, and the ambush rises at just the right moment. One writer sees the Lord's hand behind timing like that:
This is how the Lord works by His Spirit at just the right moment. He stirs people into action who may not even know why. At the set time something drives them forward. They think they are acting on reasons of their own, while it is the Lord who directs all their steps to match what He is doing elsewhere.
- Confidence — The men of Ai are never bolder than at the hour of their ruin; the open gate is the measure of how sure they felt.
- Precedent — Their earlier win over Israel is what draws them out. A past win can be the very thing that destroys an enemy.
- Cost — Israel takes a small town by ambush and pretended flight. Returning to the path of blessing costs far more effort than not leaving it would have.
- Shame — God calls out every soldier, then wins without their strength. The power they boasted in proved useless on its own.
- Control — Both armies move at a moment neither chose. The Lord is the hidden spring, stirring people to act who do not know why.
And Jehovah said to Joshua, Stretch out the javelin that is in thy hand toward Ai; for I will give it into thy hand. And Joshua stretched out the javelin that he had in his hand toward the city.
Israel has just judged the hidden sin that cost them their first attack on Ai. Now, mid-battle, God tells Joshua to hold out his spear toward the city — but was that a signal to the men in ambush, or something more?
The men in ambush were far away and hidden. And Joshua's hand stayed out until the fighting was over.
Here the mere sight of the eyes could hardly have helped men so far away and also in hiding: was it not God Himself? Did not He cause Joshua to stretch out his spear? More than a signal is meant, as we read a little later: "Joshua did not draw back his hand with which he stretched out the javelin until he had devoted all the inhabitants of Ai to destruction." If it had been merely a signal for men, why keep his hand stretched out like that? But no; it appears to be a sign on God's part, a meaningful token, calling them to the taking of the city. It seems meant to give them certainty that the LORD was with them now — the LORD taking the lead, the LORD prospering everything in the very place where they had been put to shame. He would retrieve the glory of His own name.
The ambush never saw the spear. So what moved them was not a message but God working at the right moment.
At last, at God's command, Joshua stretches out the spear that was in his hand toward the city. It does not appear that the ambush saw it, or that it was an agreed signal. But as soon as he stretched it out, the ambush rose, entered the city, and set fire to it. This is how the Lord, working by His Spirit at the right moment, produces activity even in those who may not know why. At a given time He moves them forward, and they think they are acting on their own motives. But it is the Lord who directs all their steps in harmony with what He is doing elsewhere.
Moses once held up his hands while Israel fought Amalek. Joshua's raised arm matches that, with one difference.
The Lord commanded Joshua to stretch out the spear toward Ai. This matches the uplifted hands of Moses in the war against Amalek in Exodus 17. It was a token of the presence of divine power securing the complete victory. We read nothing of Joshua's arm with the spear growing weak, as happened with the uplifted hands of Moses... It was an act of faith, and divine power supported the outstretched arm.
Israel had run from this same city once. What changed is that they had removed the accursed thing, the hidden sin among them.
Yet when the accursed thing is removed, and though the whole army is there, Joshua (the Spirit of Christ) stretches out his spear... The principle was recovered — the presence of God. It is beautiful to see how the goodness of the Lord entirely repaired the faults at Ai and at Jericho.
Some fled, some burned the city, some turned and fought. The account treats it all as one action with one centre.
Diversity is not division; it shows itself within unity. The ambush take Ai and set it on fire. Meanwhile the twenty-five thousand men flee before their enemies, until the smoke of the city tells them to turn back on their pursuers... So there is diversity in the action and the service, but it is one action shared together. The body is one; the several parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond of union. If they lose sight of that unity, defeat follows.
The king of Ai charged out because Israel looked to him like the same beaten people as a few days before.
He saw no change in them. To his eye they were the same people who had fled from him a day or two earlier. So he imagined they would fall into his hands as easily as before. He did not know that the Lord was among them. On he came, only to meet his doom and to complete the destruction of his city. Joshua's outstretched javelin was the signal to Israel, and the sign of a war that cannot stop until every foe is cast down and destroyed.
- Cleared — The spear goes out only after Israel removes the hidden sin. God's presence returns to His people on the very ground of their defeat.
- Given — God promises the city before Joshua lifts his arm. So the raised arm is an act of faith, and divine power holds it up.
- Reaching — Men who never saw the spear moved the moment it went out. God stirs His people at the right time, and they act without knowing why.
- Uniting — Fleeing, burning, fighting: different tasks, one battle. Joshua's spear is the bond that holds them together.
- Unbroken — Joshua never drew his hand back until the work was done. This war does not stop while one enemy still stands.
And the ambush arose quickly from their place, and they ran when he stretched out his hand, and came into the city, and took it, and hasted and set the city on fire.
Israel's second attack on Ai turns on one raised arm: Joshua lifts it, and hidden men rush the city and burn it. Was that arm a signal agreed in advance, or was God Himself at work?
The men in ambush were far off and out of sight, which makes a simple visual cue hard to imagine. One writer argues that the clue lies in how long the arm stayed up. (The writers call the weapon in Joshua's hand a spear.)
The sight of the eyes could hardly have been enough here. These men were far away and in hiding. Was it not of God Himself? Did not He cause Joshua to stretch out his spear? ... If it had only been a signal for men, why keep his hand stretched out like that? Stretching out the spear and drawing it back soon after would have been quite enough. A pre-arranged act would have done its work already. But no; it appears to be a sign on God's part, a meaningful token, that called them to the taking of the city.
The verse stresses speed: they rose quickly and hurried to burn the city. If they never saw the spear, what moved them at that exact moment came from elsewhere.
It does not appear that the ambush saw it, or that it was an agreed signal. But as soon as Joshua stretched it out, the ambush rose, entered the city, and set fire to it. This is how the Lord, working by His Spirit at the right moment, produces activity even in those who may not know why. At a given time He pushes them onwards. They think they are acting from motives of their own, while the Lord directs all their steps in harmony with what He is doing elsewhere.
The king of Ai had beaten these same men days earlier. He looked at them and saw no reason to expect anything different.
The enemy counts only on human strength. The world pays no attention to the secret things that turn God's hand against His saints in their path of service and warfare. We see this principle in the way the king of Ai came out against Israel. He saw no change in them. To his eye they were the very same people who had fled from him a day or two earlier. So he imagined they would fall into his hands as easily as last time. He did not know that the Lord was among them. On he came, only to meet his doom and to complete the destruction of his city.
At Ai, Israel used hidden men and a fake retreat. Does that mean clever tactics took the place of faith this time?
In truth at Ai they are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is this: at Jericho God arranged things so that Israel might learn His power. At Ai His object was to teach them their own weakness.
While the ambush burns the city, the main body is running the other way. The two movements look unrelated.
The men in ambush take Ai and set it on fire. Meanwhile the twenty-five thousand flee before their enemies, until the smoke of the city tells them to turn back on them. So there is diversity in the action and service, but it is an action in common. The body is one; the several parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond of union. If the unity is lost sight of, defeat is the result.
Ai burns. Its very name means what it became. One writer links its earlier victory over Israel to Achan, whose hidden sin had cost them the battle.
Ai, in its meaning, a "heap" — to this day known as Et-Tell, "the heap" ... Ai is the world seen in its ruin as faith sees it, which yet, apart from God's presence with us, we are not able to overcome. Unjudged evil in us will make the world too strong for us, and this is what Achan's sin does for Israel.
- Cleansed — Israel judged the hidden evil among them, and the city that had beaten them fell. Unjudged evil makes the world too strong for us.
- Commanded — God Himself moved Joshua to raise the spear. It was a sign from Him, not a clever plan of Israel's own.
- Carried — the men in ambush moved at the right moment without seeing the spear. The Spirit still stirs people who do not know why they act.
- Combined — one group flees while the other burns the city. The service differs, the action is one, and Joshua with his spear joins them.
- Concealed — the king of Ai saw the same beaten people and marched out confident. He could not see that the Lord was among them again.
And the men of Ai turned and saw, and behold, the smoke of the city went up to heaven, and they had no power to flee this way or that way; and the people that fled to the wilderness turned upon the pursuers.
The men of Ai are chasing what looks like a beaten enemy. Then they look back, see their own city burning, and find there is nowhere left to run.
The turn in this verse is not the fighting but the discovery. One writer describes the moment the men of Ai saw what had been done to them.
We see the men of Ai in all their distress when they looked behind and saw the trap that had caught them. The ambush was rushing in on one side, and those who seemed to flee from them were now advancing to attack them on the other. The matter was soon settled, whatever the pains and trouble He demanded for it.
This is not only about Ai. The same writer turns the moment into a rule.
The enemy is never so self-confident as when his hour has come. So men will cry, Peace and safety, when sudden destruction comes upon them.
The king of Ai judged Israel by what he had seen a few days earlier. He expected the same result. What had changed was hidden from him.
The world does not see the hidden work, the work that goes on in the heart with God. God's ways with His people baffle all human calculations. The enemy counts only on human might... We see this principle in the way the king of Ai came out against Israel. He saw no change in them. To his eye, they were the same people who had fled from him a day or two earlier. So he imagined they would fall into his hands as easily as before. He did not know that the Lord was among them. On he came, only to meet his doom and to complete the destruction of his city.
Israel's army was split, and the parts were doing opposite things. The smoke tied them into one action.
Diversity is not division; it shows itself in unity. The men in ambush take Ai and set it on fire. Meanwhile the twenty-five thousand men flee before their enemies, until the smoke of the city tells them to turn back on them. So there is diversity in the action and service, but it is an action in common. The body is one; the several parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond of union. If the unity is lost sight of, defeat is the result.
The men in ambush rose at the exact moment Joshua stretched out his spear. One writer doubts they ever saw it.
It does not appear that the ambush saw it, or that it was an agreed signal. But as soon as it was stretched out, the ambush rose, entered the city, and set fire to it. This is how the Lord works by His Spirit at the right moment. He produces activity even in those who may not know why. At a given time they are pushed onwards, and think they act from motives of their own. All the while it is the Lord who directs all their steps in harmony with what He is doing elsewhere. So He brings about the success of the whole thing.
Israel won this battle by hard work and by running away. One writer explains why God taught them that way.
When we make errors lightly, and sin on purpose in our service, God drives home by toil and labour the lessons we neglected. He does this even though He has shown us our errors and pardoned our ways. Israel had to labour their way up to Ai, and God also made them victorious through humiliation. By apparent defeat, by fleeing before their foes, they won their success. Falls and failures teach the believer to walk without self-confidence. Anyone who is not of a chastened spirit after a fall or a failure has not fully repented of the sin, and God is not truly with such a person, "for our God is a consuming fire" (Hebrews 12:29).
after-note-none:
- Confidence — the enemy is never so sure of himself as in the hour of his ruin. People cry peace and safety just before sudden destruction.
- Blindness — the king saw no change in Israel, because the change was hidden work done with God. The world counts only on outward strength.
- Signal — smoke and a raised spear moved men who could not see each other. The Lord timed every part.
- Unity — different tasks, one action. Joshua was the bond holding the parts together, and losing sight of that unity means defeat.
- Humbling — the win came through fleeing and hard work. God was teaching a people who had just failed, and He taught them to walk with a chastened spirit.
When Joshua and all Israel saw that the ambush had taken the city, and that the smoke of the city went up, they turned again, and slew the men of Ai.
Israel had already run from Ai once in real defeat; now they run on purpose, and the smoke behind the city tells them when to turn. Why did God give this small town to His people by such a slow, humbling route?
Israel's first attack on Ai failed because of hidden sin. One writer finds the secret of their new strength in what happened before the army moved.
Men once used for God are at times set aside by God; they keep working as they always did, but win no victories... The story of Ai unveils the cause — hidden evil is in the camp. Again these same servants arise, and, after a period of defeat, become once more vessels of power with God and with men. The story of Ai again lets us into the secret: they have been before God, and have humbled themselves.
Here the army must hide, pretend to flee, and wait for a fire — nothing like the victory at Jericho. Commentators see the difference as deliberate.
In truth, the means used at Ai were no more human than those used at Jericho. The difference is this. At Jericho God arranged things so that Israel might learn His power. At Ai His aim was to teach them their own weakness.
Another writer counts the cost of that lesson in plain numbers.
Thirty-five thousand men to take a town for which three thousand were enough! To pretend to run away as they had the first time was no honour: there is no heroism in this... He gives them the city in His own way, and will only use the power of Israel as He pleases. It is plainly saying, I can do without you — proving to them that the strength they boasted in was in itself a useless thing.
The men of Ai were chasing a fleeing enemy when their own city went up in flames behind them.
When they saw their city on fire, they found themselves caught in the middle. Those they pursued turned back and struck down the men of Ai (v.21). Those who had set fire to the city came out and attacked from behind, so in a short time they destroyed the whole army of Ai.
Two forces, out of sight of each other, acted in step. One writer makes this a rule for anyone who has to face the enemy.
We are on the Lord's ground. We know we are called all the more to obedience, because we have to face the cleverest tricks of the enemy. And where that is so, He orders the most unexpected turn of events in our favour. He knows how precisely to time everything for us.
The signal to turn came to men doing the opposite job from the men who lit the fire. Rossier reads the two halves of the army as a picture of varied service held together by one leader.
The men in ambush take Ai and set it on fire. Meanwhile the twenty-five thousand men flee before their enemies, until the smoke of the city tells them to turn back on them. Just as they begin to fight, the men in ambush come out of the city and join the battle (v. 22)... So there is diversity in the action and service, but it is an action in common. The body is one; the several parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond of union. If they lose sight of that unity, defeat follows.
The king of Ai charged out because Israel looked exactly like the beaten army he had chased days earlier.
He saw no change in them. To his eye, they were the same people who had fled from him a day or two earlier. So he imagined they would fall into his hands as easily as last time. He did not know that the Lord was among them. On he came, but only to meet his doom and to complete the destruction of his city. Joshua's outstretched spear was the signal to Israel, and the sign of a war that cannot stop until every enemy is thrown down and destroyed.
- Sin judged. Defeat at Ai came from hidden evil. Strength returned only after the people humbled themselves before God.
- Strength humbled. Thirty-five thousand men, an ambush and a fake retreat to take one small town. God gave the city in His own way, and used their strength only as He pleased.
- Power unchanged. The same power won Jericho and Ai. At Jericho God taught Israel His strength; at Ai He taught them their own weakness.
- Timing given. The smoke rose just as the fleeing army needed it. He knows exactly how to time everything for His people.
- Victory shared. Hidden men and fleeing men did opposite jobs in one action, held together by Joshua and his spear. Lose that unity, and defeat follows.
And the others went out of the city against them; so they were in the midst of Israel, some on this side, and some on that side; and they smote them, until they let none of them escape or flee away.
The fight for Ai turns in a moment. The men chasing Israel find Israel in front of them and the ambush behind. Commentators read the verse as the end of a story that began with a hidden sin and a shameful defeat, and they ask why God gave the victory in this strange way.
A pretended retreat had drawn the men of Ai out of their city. One writer describes the moment they saw it.
We see the men of Ai in all their distress. They looked behind and saw the trap that had caught them. The ambush was rushing in on one side. Those who seemed to be fleeing from them were now advancing to attack on the other. The case was soon decided now, whatever the pain and trouble God had demanded for it.
The king of Ai attacked because he had beaten these same men days before. He could not see what had changed in Israel's camp.
The world does not see the hidden work that goes on in the heart with God. God's ways with His people baffle all human calculations. The enemy counts only on human might. The world takes no interest in the secret things that turn God's hand against His saints in their path of service and warfare. We see this principle in the way the king of Ai came out against Israel. He saw no change in them. To his eye they were the same people who had fled before him a day or two earlier. So he imagined they would fall into his hands as easily as before. He did not know that the Lord was among them. On he came, only to meet his doom and to complete the destruction of his city. Joshua's outstretched spear was the signal to Israel, and the sign of a war that cannot stop until every enemy is thrown down and destroyed.
Israel was split into two forces doing opposite things — one hiding, one running away. In this verse the two meet.
Diversity is not division, because it shows itself in unity. The men in ambush take Ai and set it on fire. Meanwhile the twenty-five thousand men flee before their enemies, until the smoke of the city tells them to turn back on them. Just as they begin to fight, the ambush comes out of the city and joins the battle (v. 22)... So there is diversity in the action and service, but it is an action in common. The body is one; the several parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond of union. If they lose sight of that unity, the result is defeat.
At Jericho the walls fell on their own. Ai cost Israel the whole army, a fake retreat and a hidden ambush. Commentators read that elaborate plan not as clever soldiering but as a rebuke.
Even after faith resumes its place, God, while giving victory, makes them feel the evil of forgetting Him. They had been lifted up because of their might. God put dishonour on it at the taking of Ai... What an array of force and cunning to take a little city! Joshua and the bulk of his army must pretend to flee... To pretend to run away as at the first was no honour; there is no heroism in this. It was to their shame as soldiers. This is no instance of the mighty power of faith. God knows how to put shame on worldly strength and confidence. He allows, and even commands, its full display, and then will not use it. It is plainly saying: I can do without you.
It is fair to ask whether all this planning made Ai a victory won by human means. One writer says no.
In truth, at Ai they are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is this. At Jericho God ordered the arrangements so that Israel might learn His power. At Ai His object was to teach them their own weakness.
This verse ends in total victory. It came only after Israel judged the sin behind the first defeat.
In the end God gave Israel the victory over Ai (ch. 8). But it was not simple or triumphant, as it had been at Jericho. Joshua had to take all his fighting men up to Ai. Then Israel had to pretend to flee before the men of Ai. Then, with the help of an ambush, they took the city. This shows that God was gracious to His people once they had judged the evil. It also shows that their failure brought unnecessary and unwanted complications into the fight.
- Hidden first. The decisive work happened in the camp, not on the battlefield. The enemy attacked a people he no longer knew.
- Caught next. The returning army and the ambush closed on the men of Ai from both sides, just when they felt surest of winning.
- Together always. Two opposite jobs, hiding and fleeing, made one action. Joshua's spear held them together.
- Humbled still. The trick was no credit to Israel as soldiers. God gave the city in a way that shamed their self-confidence.
- Complete at last. None survived or escaped. Grace restored the victory once Israel judged the evil, though the failure made the fight harder than it needed to be.
And the king of Ai they took alive, and brought him to Joshua.
Ai has fallen, and every person in the city dies by the sword. The king alone survives, and Israel's soldiers march him to Joshua. Why keep him alive, and what does this captured king mean for us?
Israel had already lost one battle at this same town. The king of Ai judged the second attack by what he could see.
He saw no change in them. To his eye, they were the same people who had fled before him a day or two before; so he imagined they would fall into his hands as easily as last time. He did not know that the Lord was among them. On he came, but only to meet his doom and to complete the destruction of his city.
Ai fell only after Israel had judged Achan's sin in the camp. One writer draws a rule from that order.
The assembly must clear the evil out from among its own people before it can silence and bring to nothing the evil outside. Where an assembly tolerates evil, decision and firmness vanish completely. Firmness like that treats the enemy as an enemy. It makes no deal with him. It puts him from the start in the only place God assigns him.
Taken alive, he is not spared. Joshua hangs him on a tree, and that detail carries the passage straight to the cross.
The gallows of the king of Ai was the place of judgment and curse for Israel's enemy. But Israel themselves had to stand on Mount Ebal, where God pronounced His curse on them. That was the terrible end of the law, and Israel could not escape it. God has brought it to nothing by the cross of Christ. On the gallows at Ai, Israel could see in picture what we see in the cross of Christ: Satan, our chief enemy, defeated and brought to nothing. And we see more. The whole curse we lay under at Ebal is gone for ever, because Christ took that place for us and bore the judgment Himself. "Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us—for it is written, 'Cursed is everyone who is hanged on a tree.'" This is the hanging of the king of Ai.
One writer looks past both fallen cities to an end not yet reached.
Jericho and Ai each represent the world. Their conquest by Joshua represents Christ's victory and kingdom. The overthrow of their kings represents the final overthrow of the power of Satan. Our Joshua's victory is complete. Soon the "sun" of this day of rebellion against the Lord will go "down," and the end of the god of this world will come.
Israel took the king's body down before sunset. They were keeping a command God gave long before they crossed the Jordan.
God brought back to mind the word He had laid down about these very matters... This was not a command He had just given. He had laid it down on the other side of the Jordan. They remembered it now, because the circumstances first called for it at this time. The land was God's, and they must not defile it. They must treat it according to the rights of divine holiness. He had forbidden them to leave anyone hanged on a tree after the sun went down. They must never forget what was due to Him and to His land.
A heap of stones covered Achan in the valley. Another now covers this king at the city gate. One writer compares the two.
Like the memorial heap in the valley of Achor, it spoke without words of the sure judgment of evil. The first was a witness that judgment begins in the house of God. The second testified that the ungodly and the sinner will not escape... But Achan came from the line of Abraham, the blessed of God, while the king of Ai came from the line of Canaan, cursed long ago.
- Judgment begins within. Israel judged Achan in the camp first. Only then could they judge the king of Ai at the gate. A people who tolerate evil inside cannot face the enemy outside.
- Judgment falls on the foe. The king walked into battle seeing no change in Israel and not knowing the Lord was among them, and met his doom.
- Judgment on a tree. Hanging on a tree, this king pictures the man God has cursed. So he points to Christ, made a curse for us, and to Satan, defeated at the cross.
- Judgment still to come. The fall of these kings previews the final overthrow of the ruler of this world. The sun of this day of rebellion will go down.
- Judgment keeps the land clean. Israel took the body down before nightfall. In their hour of victory they still obeyed a word God gave beyond the Jordan.
And it came to pass when Israel had ended slaying all the inhabitants of Ai in the field, in the wilderness wherein they had chased them, and they had all fallen by the edge of the sword, until they were consumed, that all Israel returned to Ai, and smote it with the edge of the sword.
Israel chases the men of Ai into open country, kills them there, then marches back to finish the city itself. Two questions press here. Why did God want a destruction this complete? And what can a believer learn from one small town wiped out?
One commentator gives the full outcome of the day:
Israel took the king of Ai alive. When the army of Ai had fallen, the armies of Israel returned into the city and finished the destruction. That day 12,000 died — the whole population of Ai.
Israel fought in separate groups: men hidden in ambush, others in open flight, all under one leader. One writer draws a lesson from how the parts worked together:
The men in ambush take Ai and set it on fire. The twenty-five thousand men flee before their enemies, until the smoke of the city tells them to turn back on them. Just as they begin to fight, the ambush comes out of the city and joins in the battle (v. 22). Then all the Israelites return to Ai and strike it with the edge of the sword. (v. 24) So there is diversity in the action and the service, but it is an action in common. The body is one; the several parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond of union. If they lose sight of that unity, defeat follows.
A town this small could look like a footnote in the conquest. One commentator finds the opposite:
So the taking of this little city becomes weighty and most needed instruction for the people of God, because of what we are here below. We see the men of Ai in all their distress. They looked behind and saw the trap they had been caught in — the ambush rushing in on one side, and those who seemed to be fleeing from them now advancing to attack them on the other. The matter was soon settled, whatever pains and trouble He had asked of them for it.
That same smallness is what made Israel careless in the first place:
Israel looked at Ai as contemptible. Its name, "a heap of ruins," suggests that it was not like Jericho — a mighty, fortified city. Had it been a powerful place, Israel might have sought God about its overthrow. But the spies went up and viewed the country, and then said, "Do not make the whole people toil up there, for they are few." That language shows confidence in their own strength instead of trust in God for Ai's destruction. If we truly recognise God as our only strength, we depend on Him as much for small enemies as for great ones. Do we not know in practice how little enemies cause great defeats?
The killing here is not Israel acting on its own appetite. One writer explains why God handed this work to Israel, and what it warned Israel about:
They were completely to destroy the Canaanite inhabitants out of the land, showing them no mercy, making no covenant or alliance with them. The reason has been explained over and over again. They were a people whose iniquity was now full, as it was not yet in Abraham's time. The land itself was spitting them out for their abominations. In this respect Israel was only the executioner of divine judgment, not of their own passion or greed for gain. He could have destroyed them by plague or famine. Instead He chose Israel to carry out this office. In this way He gave His people the most solemn lesson He could give them, about the holiness of His own nature and about what sin is before Him. They themselves would face similar judgments if they followed the Canaanites in their sin. Their loathsome gods of lust and murder were the full outcome and expression of that sin.
One commentator reads these doomed cities as a picture of an enemy believers still face:
Considered as a picture, the Canaanites stand for the agents of Satan — the spiritual wickedness in heavenly places. They are the rulers of the darkness of this world, and we are called to wrestle with them now. They are precisely the powers of evil that keep turning every link of religion into a means of deliberate and ruinous dishonour to God. With enemies like these there can be no terms, no compromise, no pause in the fight — at any time, under any circumstances. There ought to be none.
- Small. Ai means "a heap of ruins," and its smallness is what made Israel careless. Little enemies cause great defeats.
- Whole. The city the spies thought too small to trouble the whole nation took the whole army, the ambush and the march back. Strength for small enemies comes from God too.
- One. Separate groups, separate services, one action under one leader. Lose sight of that unity and defeat follows.
- Just. The unsparing sword falls on a people whose guilt was full; Israel was the executioner of God's judgment, not of its own greed.
- Uncompromising. Read as a picture, the doomed city teaches a war with the powers of evil that allows no terms and no truce.
And so it was, that all who fell that day, men as well as women, were twelve thousand, all the people of Ai.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And Joshua did not draw back his hand, which he had stretched out with the javelin, until they had utterly destroyed all the inhabitants of Ai.
Joshua's second attack on Ai ends with one steady posture. His arm stays stretched out toward the city until the last of its people has fallen. The detail is easy to skip. Commentators treat it as the key to the whole battle: why hold the arm out at all, and why hold it out so long?
Many read the outstretched spear as a prearranged sign to the men lying in ambush behind the city. One writer argues that the length of time the arm stayed up rules this out.
Simply seeing him could hardly have helped men who were so far away and hidden. Was this not from God Himself? Did He not cause Joshua to stretch out his spear? If it had been only a signal for men, why keep his hand stretched out like that? Stretching out the spear and then drawing it back soon would have been quite enough. If it had been just a prearranged act, the work was already done. But no; it appears to be a sign on God's part, a meaningful token, that called them to the taking of the city. It seems clearly intended to give them the certainty that the LORD was with them now.
The men in hiding moved without seeing him. Another writer points to what was really moving them.
This is how the Lord works. By His Spirit, at the right moment, He stirs action even in people who may not know why. At a given time they are pushed onwards. They think they act from their own motives, while the Lord directs all their steps to fit with what He is doing elsewhere. In this way He brings the whole thing to success.
Israel had seen a raised arm decide a battle before. Moses held up his hands in the fight against Amalek, and they grew weak. One writer draws both the comparison and the difference.
This corresponds to the uplifted hands of Moses in the warfare against Amalek in Exodus 17. It was a token of the presence of divine power in securing the complete victory. We read nothing about Joshua's arm with the spear growing weak, as the hands of Moses did… It was an act of faith, and divine power supported the outstretched arm.
Jericho fell without human plans. Ai took an ambush and careful tactics. Had God stepped back and left Israel to its own skill? One writer answers that the difference lies in what God meant to teach, not in the power He supplied.
In truth at Ai they are no more human means than at Jericho. The difference is this: at Jericho God arranged everything so that Israel might learn His power, while at Ai His aim was to teach them their own weakness… The power of God had not changed. Israel won the victory at Ai by that power. Joshua was there, Joshua with the spear in his hand… It remained stretched out all through the conflict.
The fighting that day came in pieces. Some men fled on purpose, some burned the city, some turned and struck. The held-out spear made the scattered movements one action.
The men in ambush take Ai and set it on fire. Meanwhile the twenty-five thousand flee before their enemies, until the smoke of the city tells them to turn back on them… So there is diversity in the action and service, but it is an action in common. The body is one. The several parts are joined together, and Joshua with his spear is the bond that unites them. Lose sight of that unity, and defeat follows.
Why did the fighting go on until no one in Ai was left? One writer reads the raised weapon as the mark of the whole war's character.
Joshua's outstretched javelin was the signal to Israel. It was also the sign of a war that cannot stop until every enemy is thrown down and destroyed.
Another writer turns that same thoroughness on the believer.
The sword had finished its work of destruction, as the LORD had commanded. Seen spiritually, faithfulness will lead the believer to spare nothing that belongs to man: it can have no part in the land of promise.
- Sign, not signal. The arm stayed out far longer than any signal needed. That marks it as God's token that He was with them, not a human arrangement.
- Held, not heavy. Unlike Moses' hands in the fight against Amalek, this arm never weakened. Divine power held it up, and faith held the spear.
- Held for everyone. Men who could not see the arm still moved in step. The Spirit stirs people to act at the right moment without their knowing why.
- Held over one body. Scattered tasks — the flight, the fire, the counter-attack — became one action. One leader's spear bound them together. Lose that unity, and defeat follows.
- Held to the end. The word "until" sets the measure. The war does not pause until every enemy is down, and faithfulness still spares nothing that belongs to man.
Only, the cattle and the spoil of the city Israel took as prey to themselves, according to the word of Jehovah which he had commanded Joshua.
Ai has fallen, yet Israel carries off its livestock and goods. The striking part is that they take the plunder by God's own word, when at Jericho they could keep nothing.
One writer turns the fall of this small city into a lesson for God's people, and ties the new permission back to Jericho:
So the taking of this little city becomes weighty and much needed instruction for God's people, since we are what we are here on earth. … They are allowed the plunder now, having been tested at Jericho.
Why was Jericho different? One commentator explains what God taught there, and what Israel normally did afterwards:
At Jericho the Lord had already shown two things. First, His might alone gave the victory — or rather, His might alone made everything fall before Israel, for the prince of this world has no power against Him. Second, the gold and silver belonged to the Lord, so the people were not to seek the treasures of the conquered world or enrich themselves with its spoils. In general, however, once Israel had destroyed their enemies, they took possession of everything, as they took the promised land.
Israel had failed at Ai before. Another writer reads this second victory, and the goods that come with it, as the mark of a restored people:
It is a happy thing to know that a restored soul is always a blessed soul. So it is here. The camp goes a second time against Ai, and takes it. Israel does not win with the ease and honour of Jericho, but they win. It is the same in the experience of our own souls. The soul is pardoned and restored, and set on the way to even richer, higher blessings. Yet it still finds some new elements in its history. It has trials to go through that it might have been spared, had it walked more evenly. But in the end, most surely, Israel is blessed. Ai falls, and its cattle and spoil belong to the people, just as the gold, silver, brass and iron of Jericho had belonged to the Lord.
What Israel kept, they kept because God said so. One writer sets Ai beside the law for an Israelite town that turned to other gods, where the command ran the other way:
The judgment on "one of your cities," where worthless men had gone out to seduce others in the same way … was to be even more severe than the judgment on some of the cities of the Canaanites. Israel had to destroy not only all the inhabitants and cattle, but "all the spoil," "every bit" of it. They had to gather it and burn it with fire in the city. The cattle and spoil of Ai, for instance, "Israel took as their plunder, according to the word of the LORD" (Joshua 8:27).
One writer reads Ai as a picture of the small things that hinder a believer, and the spoil as what overcoming them brings:
God had given the total victory over Jericho, which symbolizes the world as a system of evil. But Ai was different. God was behind all that Israel did, yet they had to fight in various ways. Ai speaks of the details of worldliness that hinder the spiritual progress of believers. In overcoming these things, small as they seem, believers will gain spiritually. So Israel in this case gained through the spoils.
Another writer, writing on a later battle, says what that gain is:
The victory is not just driving the enemy back. It is a real gain of fresh stores. Faith, no doubt, always gathers fresh riches from every conflict. The spoil of the enemy does not rightly belong to them, but to those who overcome them. This spoil may well remind us of the fresh views of Christ we gain from the very conflict we have entered for Him.
- Tested first. God allows the plunder at Ai, having tested Israel first at Jericho, where they were to touch nothing.
- Withheld there. At Jericho the victory was God's might alone. The silver and gold were His, so Israel was to take nothing for itself.
- Granted here. Once Israel learned that lesson, they took possession of what they conquered, as they took the promised land.
- By word, not by wanting. God's command settles what may be kept and what must be burned. In another case, every bit of the spoil had to go into the fire.
- Gained, not grabbed. Ai pictures the small details of worldliness. Overcoming them enriches the believer, and the spoil belongs to the one who overcomes.
And Joshua burned Ai, and made it an everlasting heap of desolation to this day.
Ai was the city that had just defeated Israel. Now it is a burnt heap, which raises two questions: why did the second attack win, and what does that lasting ruin mean?
The city's own name carried its end. Writers tie that name to Jericho, and read the ruin as what faith sees in the world.
Ai, in its meaning, a "heap" — known to this day as Et-Tell, "the heap" — naturally connects it with Jericho, which had just become one. Ai is the world seen in its ruin as faith sees it, which yet, apart from God's presence with us, we are not able to overcome. Unjudged evil in us will make the world too strong for us, and this is what the sin of Achan does for Israel.
The difference between the earlier rout and the burning in this verse was not mainly military. It came from judging hidden sin.
Ai is a very solemn lesson for us, and we have to learn it with God, so as to get back to the point where we started wrong. Remember, there is no difference between little and great with God. He takes care of a sparrow that falls, and He will burn up the earth. The question is what is right in His sight. So at Ai it was not merely a matter of power, but of judging evil. And where evil is not judged, God will not use power.
Israel had first said the whole nation need not go up. God told Joshua to bring every fighting man. The size of the force was itself part of the lesson.
How different this battle was from the way Israel first planned to overthrow the "heap of ruins," Ai! They had said, "Do not make all the people toil up there." The Lord said, "Take all the fighting men." So the thousands of Israel rose to battle. Each soldier had to remember not to take small foes lightly. Israel's strength and courage came from the Lord alone.
Commentators read Jericho and Ai as two pictures of one enemy: the world. Jericho stands for the whole system; Ai stands for the smaller things that trip a believer up day by day. Here Israel also kept the spoil.
God had given total victory over Jericho, which symbolises the world as a system of evil. But at Ai they had to fight in various ways, though God was behind all that Israel did. This is because Ai speaks of the details of worldliness that hinder the spiritual progress of believers. In overcoming these things, small as they seem, believers gain spiritually. So Israel in this case gained through the spoils.
One writer sees a conscience shaped by God's word in what Joshua did next.
As soon as the sun went down, Joshua commanded them to take the king's body down from the tree. To all human appearance this would be a detail of no importance, but a heart fed by the word of God could not overlook it. To ignore it would have been to lose sight of the holiness of God. Joshua would then have failed in the very point that brought chastening on the people... In a word, a holy God could not dwell in the middle of defilement. This was the blessed lesson Joshua received from the Lord of hosts before Jericho. He learnt it with tears in the valley of Achor. Now, with a conscience trained in the school of God, he worked it out in the day of victory.
The ruin lasted, and travellers can still walk the site. "To this day" points to a heap still visible long after the battle. Yet the name turns up again in later books, so a settlement seems to have risen nearby.
A royal city of Canaan. Abraham knew it and pitched his tent between Hai and Bethel (Genesis 12:8). Joshua conquered it by a clever plan — after a defeat caused by the sin of Achan — then burned it and made it a "heap"... It lay near Bethel, in Benjamin's portion, and was later rebuilt, it seems, for Ezra 2:28 and Nehemiah 7:32 mention it... Travellers say that on the spot you can picture the biblical account of the capture of Ai clearly.
- Ruin named. Ai means "a heap," and the verse turns the name into the city's end — a picture of what faith already sees the world to be.
- Ruin delayed. The heap came only after Israel judged Achan's sin. Where evil is not judged, God will not use power. Small things are not small to Him.
- Ruin costly. The city Israel thought a small force could take called out every fighting man. Small foes cannot be taken lightly, and the strength to beat them came from the Lord alone.
- Ruin profitable. Israel kept the spoil of Ai. Overcoming the world in its small details brings real gain to the believer.
- Ruin holy. The victory ends with obedience over one small detail at sunset. A holy God will not live among defilement.
And the king of Ai he hanged on a tree until the evening; and at the going down of the sun Joshua commanded, and they took his carcase down from the tree, and threw it down at the entrance of the gate of the city, and raised upon it a great heap of stones, [which remains] to this day.
Ai's king hangs on a tree at the close of the battle. The record spends as much space on the handling of his body as on the victory itself. A command given before Israel crossed the Jordan governs the moment, and a man hanged on a tree means far more here than the fall of one city.
Nobody gave Joshua a fresh order that day. He acted on something already written.
God brought to mind the word He had laid down about these very matters. Is this not intentional instruction for us here? Joshua roused the conscience of Israel to the most careful attention to the will of the Lord. It was not a command just given at that moment, but one laid down on the other side of the Jordan. It was remembered now, when the circumstances first called for it.
The timing looks trivial. It tested whether Joshua had learned the lesson behind God's chastening of Israel.
To all human appearance this would be a detail of no importance, but a heart fed by the word of God could not overlook it. To neglect it would have been to lose sight of the holiness of God. Joshua would then have failed in the very point that brought chastening on the people. "His body shall not remain all night on the tree… for a hanged man is cursed by God. You shall not defile your land that the LORD your God is giving you for an inheritance."
Ai had only just fallen. Yet the care taken over one corpse treats the whole country as already the Lord's property.
Though Satan still holds the contested land, by right it is the Lord's. Joshua showed this by two actions. One was taking the king of Ai's body down from the tree as soon as the sun was down. Israel's victory was complete. The curse hung over their enemies, who were also God's enemies. They were made a curse, and declared to be so. Now, according to Joshua's faith, the land was so entirely Israel's, as the gift of God, that it ought not to be defiled.
Two men end up under a heap of stones: Achan in chapter 7, and this king in chapter 8.
Ai is taken and destroyed, her king hanged on a tree, then taken down, and a heap raised over him, as before with Achan. They had indeed been partners in evil, and Achan was a worse trouble than the king of Ai could have been. Evil tolerated among the people of God is the ally of the foe outside. It is the only real hindrance to steady progress.
Rossier draws out the practical consequence:
Where evil is tolerated in the assembly, decision and firmness vanish. Firmness deals with the enemy as an enemy. It makes no terms with him. It puts him from the start in the only place God assigns him.
Death on a tree carried a curse under the law. The reason stayed hidden until Christ came.
Many people in ancient days read Deuteronomy 21:23 and may have wondered. Why did the curse attach to death on a tree, and not to death by some other means, such as stoning or the sword? Now we know. In due time the Redeemer was to bear the curse for others, honouring the law by hanging on a tree.
In the same chapter Israel stands at Mount Ebal, under the law's curse themselves.
The gallows at Ai showed Israel in picture what the cross of Christ shows us: Satan, our chief enemy, defeated and destroyed. But we see more. All the curse we lay under at Ebal is gone forever in the actual judgment of the One who took that place for us. Paul adds: "Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us — for it is written, 'Cursed is everyone who is hanged on a tree.'" This is the hanging of the king of Ai.
The sun going down over Ai becomes a picture of an end still to come.
Jericho and Ai each represent the world. Their conquest by Joshua pictures Christ's victory and kingdom. The overthrow of their kings pictures the final overthrow of the power of Satan. Our Joshua's victory is complete. Soon the sun of this day of rebellion against the Lord will go down, and the god of this world will come to his end.
- Remembered. Joshua obeyed a command given long before, the first moment it applied. Scripture stored up is Scripture ready.
- Holiness. The body came down at sunset because the land belonged to God and must not be defiled. That small detail tested whether Joshua had learned from defeat.
- Order. Achan under a heap of stones, then the king of Ai under a heap. Judge the evil inside first, then face the enemy outside without compromise.
- Curse. Hanging on a tree marked a man as cursed by God — the very sign the Redeemer would later bear, "becoming a curse for us."
- End. The king's gallows pictures the final overthrow of the enemy, when the sun sets on this day of rebellion.