John 9:3–4

John 9:3 · Darby

Jesus answered, Neither has this [man] sinned nor his parents, but that the works of God should be manifested in him.

The disciples looked at a man blind from birth and asked whose fault it was — his or his parents'. Jesus refuses both options. His answer raises the question every sufferer asks: is my trouble a punishment, or is God at work in it?

The Question Behind the Question

The disciples were not being cruel. They were working from a principle they had been taught about how God deals with His people on earth.

John 9 opens with the case of a man who prompts a question from the disciples about the government of God in Israel. Was it his parents' sin that brought this trouble on their child, following the principles God had given them in Exodus? Or was it his own sin, known to God though not seen by men, that had earned him this judgment? The Lord replies that the man's condition did not depend on God's government dealing with the sin of the man or of his parents. His case was simply the misery that made room for the mighty work of God in grace.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

What Jesus Is Not Saying

The Lord is not declaring this family innocent. He is saying that their sins do not explain this blindness.

God's ways are not like man's. When He makes them known, they stand against the Jewish idea that suffering pays back sin. The reason lay deeper than what his parents deserved, or than God's foresight of the wrong the man would do. It is not that the man and his parents were not sinners. But when Jesus looked at the man's blindness from birth, His eye saw beyond nature, law and government… The case was completely beyond human help, and that is just what made it the occasion for Jesus to do the works of God.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Affliction Without Punishment

Trouble can come with no punishment in it. And God can show His work in two very different ways. One of them leaves the trouble in place.

The Lord's reply shows that suffering can come with no punishment in it at all. It can come only so that God may show His work. Here He showed it by delivering the man from the affliction completely. He can show it just as powerfully by delivering someone from the weight and depression of an affliction while the affliction itself stays; and that is often seen today… this blind man was a fit subject for the work of God, though he never asked for it, as far as the record goes.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Grace That Needs No Reason Outside Itself

The Lord looked at the same blindness and saw something else. Not a case to settle, but a place for grace to start.

The meaning of blindness from birth is too plain to need comment. But the Lord, dealing with the faithful remnant in Israel, did not count it as sin, nor treat it as a case of sin being charged to anyone. He treated it as an occasion for grace. This is how sovereign grace views such a case… the work done in him was definite and effective. It was grace that looked at his condition, and knew no cause but itself and the fruit it was going to produce.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Words in Chapter 8, Works in Chapter 9

Writers point out that this chapter follows a chapter of speech with a chapter of action, and that "the works of God" has a definite content.

The Lord treats it as a case that shows God's ways in grace rather than in government… It always comes back to this, if a person is to be happy before Him — to the works of God: the great atoning work of the cross for him, and the work of the Spirit of God in him. Let us hold on to the words of verse 3, "the works of God might be displayed in him" (older translations read "manifested in him"). This is not about merely saying you believe, and even less about man's works. It is about God's work, done and displayed in a man.

Modernised from R. EvansOriginal wording

A Portrait of Everyone

Commentators read the man's condition as more than a medical fact.

The man blind from birth is surely a picture of Israel, and indeed of all mankind by nature. The root of this is of course sin — but not, as the disciples supposed, one particular sin… Sin, the root of all sins, has infected the very nature we all share as children of Adam. That is the reason for all sickness, and for spiritual blindness from birth too.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Summary

- Wrong question. The disciples asked whose sin caused the blindness. The Lord answers that it did not come from the man's sin or his parents' sin at all.

- Not innocence. Jesus does not call the family sinless. He says the reason lay deeper than anything they deserved.

- Occasion, not verdict. The case was beyond all human help. That is what made it the moment for the works of God.

- Grace without a cause. The man never asked. Grace here knew no cause but itself, and the work done in him was definite and effective.

- Two ways it shows. God's work may show as full deliverance from the trouble. Or it may show as full deliverance from its weight while the trouble stays. In the end, the works of God are the cross for a person and the Spirit of God at work in him.

John 9:4 · Darby

I must work the works of him that has sent me while it is day. [The] night is coming, when no one can work.

The disciples had asked whose sin caused a man's blindness. Jesus refused that question. He put a different one in its place: not who is to blame, but who is at work. His answer sets His whole ministry inside a deadline — a day that is running out, and a night in which working stops.

From Blame to Work

The disciples looked at the blind man and searched backwards for a cause. The Lord looked at him and saw an occasion.

His disciples ask, "Who has sinned?" It was all wrong. The question now was, "Who is at work?" God was there in the person of the Son, at work to bring men out of darkness into light. There was no time to lose. The night was coming, when no one can work.

Modernised from James BoydOriginal wording

The case lay far beyond any human remedy. That is what made it the right occasion for God to act:

In God's goodness, the deepest and truest reason — God's own reason — was to give Christ an occasion to work the works of God on the earth. How wonderfully grace works in a hopeless case, and how rightly it judges one! That it was wholly outside the resources of man made it just the occasion for Jesus, for the works of God.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The Works of Him Who Sent Me

Christ does not call them His own works. They belong to the One who sent Him, and this marks a shift in the story:

The eighth chapter has presented the testimony of the Lord's words. He spoke to the world those things which He had heard of the Father. The ninth chapter presents the testimony of His works. Before, He had spoken the words of the Father. Now He says, "I must work the works of Him that sent Me." The Lord brings the light into the world and makes known the heart of God. He also works in grace to open blind eyes to see the truth.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The Force of "Must"

The world had already rejected Christ. That might have ended His labour. Instead it drove it on.

He had to do this. The world had rejected Him, and He might have turned aside because of that rejection. Still He had to work the works of the One who sent Him. The work of grace all remained... He had to work, and He had to work while it is day. The day is the time of the presence of the light. But while Christ was in the world He was its Light. The night is His absence.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Day and Night Redefined

These are not ordinary hours. A Person sets this clock.

Notice how day and night take on a new meaning once we look at them in relation to Christ's stay and work on this earth.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

And His presence could never be idle time:

It was the day of His presence in the world in active grace. The night of His absence was coming, when no one can work. As long as Christ was in the world, He was the Light of the world. While He was here He had to work. Love could not rest where there was sorrow, and light could not rest in the presence of sin. When Christ departs, all is over with the world until His return. Yet because of His death and ascension, a testimony still goes out to the world declaring the grace of God.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

"I" or "We"?

Some translations read "We must work" here; others read "I must work," as several writers quoted above do. One writer objected to the change:

There is little to note in the revisers' work on John 9, except that they accepted "us" in verse 4 in place of the first "me" — without even a word of caution in the margin.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Our Own Short Day

Writers have long turned the verse on the reader, and on the work of telling others about Christ:

The duty of evangelising always remains... Let us work, dearly beloved, while it is day; the night comes, when no man can work. The love of Christ is the best guide for our daily duties.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Yet service itself carries a trap:

But the most blessed service has its snares. Let us be careful. We can be busy telling others about Him while our own hearts are cold to His love. Christ is not first. Instead of judging ourselves for it and confessing it, so that communion is restored, the heart feels the distance and throws itself into more and more service. But that only keeps the distance in place, because it hides the soul's real condition.

Modernised from J. A. TrenchOriginal wording

Summary

- Question — The disciples asked who sinned; Christ answered who is working. A hopeless case becomes an opportunity, not a puzzle about blame.

- Sender — The works are not His own. They are the works "of Him who sent Me." John 8 gave the Father's words; John 9 gives the Father's works.

- Must — Rejection did not cancel the work; it pressed it on. Love could not rest where sorrow was.

- Day — Christ's presence, not the sun, marks the day and the night. His being here made it daytime.

- Now — The verse turns the same urgency on us: work while it is day — but let the love of Christ, not mere busyness, be the motive.