John 15:4–5

John 15:4 · Darby

Abide in me and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit of itself unless it abide in the vine, thus neither [can] ye unless ye abide in me.

The Lord pictures Himself as a vine and His disciples as its branches. Two things need explaining: what it means to abide in Him, and why a branch's own effort produces nothing.

What "Abide" Means

The word behind "abide" is not a special religious term. It runs through John's Gospel and is translated in several ways, all pointing to the same plain idea of staying put.

The word 'abide' is used by John very frequently. It is rendered in different ways. Sometimes it is 'remain' and at other times it is 'continue', but all having the same basic meaning.

Modernised from George BellOriginal wording

Put into everyday language, the command asks for nearness and reliance — the same word used elsewhere of sticking close to the Lord with settled purpose.

Fruitfulness is promoted by abiding in Christ. What does it really mean to do this? It may be more easily understood if we say, "Keep close to the Lord! Draw all your resources from Him." In the book of Acts 11:23 one of the Lord's servants, Barnabas by name, urged the believers "to remain faithful to the Lord with steadfast purpose." The word "remain faithful" [older versions: "cleave"] is the same word as "abide" in the original.

Modernised from George BellOriginal wording

The Order Of The Two Clauses

The verse joins a command to a promise, and the order matters.

First, we see what alone is enough for the fruit required. It is what the very nature of a branch implies — to abide in the vine. Apart from Christ we can do nothing. If the branch does not abide in the vine, the vine — the vine-sap — cannot abide in the branch. That is why the Lord's words come in this order: "Abide in Me, and I in you." "Abide in Me" — that is the command, the responsibility; "and I in you" — that will be the assured result.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Dependence, Not Effort

A branch does no work. It stays attached, and life flows in. The same holds for the disciple, and it holds when life turns hard.

Here the Lord insists on more. We must depend on Him and be close to Him. This is to abide in Christ… He, and He only, is the dwelling-place for the soul in this world of traps and danger, in this desert where there is no water. Make Him the resource, make Him the object. Then the sap, as it were, flows without hindrance, and the branch bears fruit. Without Him no teaching works, and all religious excitement fails. Bring Him in, trust Him, and He sustains the heart, and fruit-bearing follows — no matter what the difficulty, the pain, the shame, the opposition or the slander.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Not A Question Of Safety

Does the word "unless" mean a believer's salvation hangs by a thread?

No — that is not the meaning of these words. What they teach is that the only possible way of fruit-bearing is to abide in Christ, as a branch abides in the vine. And the one evidence of abiding in Christ is fruit-bearing… It is not a question of a branch abiding in Christ today and not tomorrow. It is a question of two sorts of branches: the fruit-bearing branches and the non-fruit-bearing branches. It is a question of what claims to be for the Lord on earth, and in that sense everyone who claims His name is a branch. But if there is no living union with Him there will be no fruit, and such a branch will in the end be cast out, as Judas was.

Modernised from J. T. MawsonOriginal wording

Scripture also uses a different picture: the Church as one body joined to Christ its Head.

Heavenly grace forms that one body by the one Spirit, united to the glorified Head. There we do not hear of tearing, wounding, or cutting off… Responsibility on earth under divine government is another thing. The Vine and its branches teach that, not the unfailing heavenly relationship of the Church.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

How Abiding Works

So where does abiding start? With the question of what fills your thoughts.

Is it your fruit-bearing or Christ? If it is your fruit-bearing, it is self-occupation, and as a result the fruit will be poor in both quantity and quality. But if you have learnt what He means when He says, "Apart from ME you can do nothing," and so have turned wholly to Him — the Source of your life, strength and energy — fruit will not be lacking. You abide in Him when you realise that you can't do without Him, and when you know that all you need is in Him. Two words cover it. He is INDISPENSABLE to you, and He is ALL-SUFFICIENT.

Modernised from J. T. MawsonOriginal wording

What makes abiding a habit rather than a mood?

You will abide in Him HABITUALLY when you know His love as greater than all other loves, Himself better than the brightest and best below… The secret of constant abiding in Him is simply the knowledge of His love.

Modernised from J. T. MawsonOriginal wording

Summary

- Stay — To abide is to keep close to the Lord and draw all your resources from Him.

- Order — "Abide in Me" is the command and our responsibility; "and I in you" is the assured result that follows.

- Sap — A branch bears nothing by effort. It stays attached, life flows in, and fruit comes even under opposition.

- Fruit, not safety — The vine teaches fruit and responsibility on earth, not the fear of being lost. The body joined to its Head speaks of a heavenly relationship that never fails.

- Love — Constant abiding grows from knowing His love. Watching your own fruit only shrinks the harvest.

John 15:5 · Darby

I am the vine, ye [are] the branches. He that abides in me and I in him, *he* bears much fruit; for without me ye can do nothing.

Jesus uses a picture from a vineyard to show His disciples where fruit for God comes from. Everything depends on staying joined to Him. It raises two questions the commentators keep returning to. What is this "fruit," and what does it mean to abide?

The Vine That Takes Israel's Place

The disciples already knew a vine — their own nation. Commentators read this verse as Christ taking its place.

The disciples were used to thinking of Israel as the vine the Lord had planted. He brought it out of Egypt and planted it in the land He had chosen... Here the Lord sets Israel aside altogether and puts Himself in the place of that fruitless vine. Christ is the True Vine, and His Father is the gardener who tends it. This is not His work in heaven as Advocate (John 13). Nor is it His coming as our Hope, to place us with Himself in the Father's house (John 14). It is His relation to His own people on earth, for bearing fruit. Christ is all.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Branches on Earth, Not the Body in Heaven

Writers warn against mixing this picture up with another one — the church as a body joined to Christ its Head. The two teach different things.

The relation of head and body serves quite another purpose in Scripture, and we must keep the two completely separate... There it is the church seen as the object of Christ's unfailing love, until He presents it to Himself in glory. Responsibility on earth, under God's rule, is another thing. The Vine and its branches teach that responsibility, not the unfailing heavenly relationship of the Church.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

What the Fruit Is

If "much fruit" meant sermons, converts or visible activity, the verse would belong to a talented few. Commentators point somewhere else.

Fruit is the character of Christ reproduced in the lives of His disciples. We read in Galatians 5:22 that "the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control." These are the very qualities that marked Christ in His life here on earth... Fruit, then, is not preaching and teaching, or different forms of service. In this passage it is not even souls won for Christ through preaching. It is the beautiful qualities of Christ seen in the people who are won. Yet a person can be very active in Christian service and still show little of the character of Christ.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

That definition changes who can bear fruit.

If service and work were fruit, then only those with gift and ability could bear it. But if fruit is the character of Christ, then every believer can bear fruit, from the oldest to the youngest — and it is a privilege to do so.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Abiding: Dependence That Comes First

The verse joins two things — our abiding in Him, and His abiding in us. Writers note that one follows the other.

All the resources of the Father are in the Son, and we can only draw on those resources as we abide in Him. The Son's abiding in us is the consequence of our abiding in Him.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Another writer spells out what abiding leans on, and what pulls against it.

To abide in Him supposes not merely distrust of ourselves, but clinging to Him and counting on Him. Every influence around us is against this; every natural feeling no less so... We need Him, and we cannot do without Him for the smallest things any more than the greatest. But there is more — He also draws us by His own excellence.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

"Apart from Me You Can Do Nothing"

The last words of the verse leave no exceptions. Commentators show how little separation it takes to prove them true.

Take any branch in the whole vine, however impressive or wide-spreading it looks. Cut it off from the main stem by no more than the thickness of a sheet of gold leaf, and it cannot produce the smallest atom of fruit. We must keep a living sense of our union with Christ. That means abiding in Him by faith in a practical way — day by day, hour by hour, moment by moment. Only then can we bear fruit that God accepts.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

There is also a warning against turning fruit itself into the goal.

Fruit is not produced by making fruit an object, or by thinking about fruit; it is the outcome of having Christ as an object, of thinking of Him. Christ comes before fruit.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Summary

- Vine. Israel was God's vine on earth and bore nothing. Christ now stands in that place, with the Father as the gardener.

- Branch. This picture is about responsibility and fruit on earth. That is not the same as the church's unfailing union with Christ in glory.

- Fruit. Not gift, service or results, but the character of Christ formed in us. That puts fruit within reach of every believer, young or old.

- Abiding. Clinging to Him and counting on Him; His abiding in us follows ours in Him, never the reverse.

- Nothing. Separation as thin as gold leaf ends all fruit — so the aim is never fruit itself, but Christ, from whom the fruit comes.