John 10:20–21

John 10:20 · Darby

but many of them said, He has a demon and raves; why do ye hear him?

Jesus has just spoken of laying down His life and taking it up again. The crowd now splits over what they heard: some write Him off as demon-possessed and mad, while others cannot fit that verdict with what He has done.

The third division

This was not the first crowd to break apart over Jesus. One writer tracks three such divisions in this Gospel, each over a different side of Christ.

While we long for the day of His glory, we recall that three times over men divided because of Him. In John 7:43, "So there was a division among the people over him." In John 9:16, when He opened the eyes of a man born blind, "there was a division among them." In John 10:19, after He had presented Himself as the Shepherd of the sheep and spoken of His intimacy with the Father, "There was again a division among the Jews because of these words." They divided over His Person, His work, and His Word. These three considerations are the touchstone for everyone today.

Modernised from Norman AndersonOriginal wording

An old accusation brought back

The crowd was reaching for an old charge.

So "there was again a division among the Jews because of these words." On the one hand they repeat the old blasphemy, that He had a demon and was raving. Others object to such a verdict, yet seem to go no further than perplexity. The matter ends, for now, in nothing but sorrowful indecision.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Their question "Why listen to Him?" was aimed at the bystanders.

It made a division among them. "Many said, He has a demon, and is insane; why listen to Him?" All the grace He had unfolded was lost on them.

Modernised from C E StuartOriginal wording

Why the richest teaching met the sharpest rejection

It seems backward that the deepest words drew the ugliest response. One writer says the natural mind always works this way.

The greater the grace, and the deeper the truth, the less the natural mind appreciates Christ. He is, in fact, the test of every soul that hears His word. Some blamed a demon for what was infinitely above man, and called His words the raving that comes with such possession. Others felt how far His words were from those of a man with a demon. They bowed to the divine power that sealed them. To their consciences His words and His works had a different character and meaning altogether.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Hatred wearing the mask of a diagnosis

One writer sets the charge beside David and the day he faked madness to escape.

Unfaithfulness brought David to a place where his enemies called him mad. He gave them reason to say it. Faithfulness and truth brought the same reproach on the Lord Jesus, mixed with blasphemy. His enemies said, "He has a demon, and is insane." What a contrast between the type and the One it pictures! And why be surprised? Here is the Perfect One; there is a failing saint. Here is Christ in all the power of grace and truth; there is a saint overcome with fear, faking madness in order to escape. Achish had reason for what he said. The Pharisees knew better. They blasphemed because they hated.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

What the charge costs those who follow Him

Anyone who takes the Shepherd's side should expect this hatred to come round again.

These verses show the effect of the Lord's teaching on those who were not His sheep. They "did not understand what he was saying to them" (verse 6). On one side, His words stirred up a violent hatred. That hatred could only hear in them the ravings of a man with a demon. On the other side, some were puzzled. Common sense told them that neither His words nor His works could come from a demon. A later Scripture warns us about this. If we follow the Lord's teaching and go outside the camp to Him, we may have to bear His reproach. The religious world will view such a path as madness or worse.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

That warning came true early. When Paul spoke of a risen Christ to a Roman named Festus, he got the same word thrown at him.

To the pagan mind of the Roman the idea of resurrection was simply unbelievable... so the mention of Christ risen from the dead moved Festus to a loud exclamation. How often through the centuries has the Christian been charged with madness! Here is the first recorded instance of the taunt being flung by the man of the world.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Summary

- Word divides. Chapter 7 divided men over His Person, chapter 9 over His work, chapter 10 over His Word. Those three still test us today.

- Grace divides deepest. The richer the truth spoken, the less the natural mind can receive it; Christ is the test of every soul that hears Him.

- Hatred divides, not doubt. David's enemies had grounds to call him mad. His accusers knew better, and blasphemed because they hated.

- Indecision is not neutrality. The other side objected to the slander, but got no further than being puzzled. The matter closed in sorrowful indecision.

- Division follows the flock. Going outside the camp to Him looks like madness to the religious world. Festus said it to Paul, and men have said it to Christians ever since.

John 10:21 · Darby

Others said, These sayings are not [those] of one that is possessed by a demon. Can a demon open blind people's eyes?

Jesus had just called Himself the Shepherd who lays down His life for the sheep, and His words split the crowd. Some called Him a madman with a demon; others pointed to a blind man's eyes that He had opened.

A division caused by His words

This was not the first time the crowd around Jesus split in two. John's Gospel records the same break three times, and each time over something different.

While we long for the day of His glory, we recall that three times over men divided because of Him. In John 7:43 there was a division among the people because of Him. In John 9:16, when He opened the eyes of a man born blind, there was a division among them. In John 10:19, after He had presented Himself as the Shepherd of the sheep and spoken of His closeness to the Father, there was again a division among the Jews because of these words. They divided over His Person, His work, and His Word. These three blessed considerations are the touchstone for all today.

Modernised from Norman AndersonOriginal wording

Why grace sounded like madness

The charge of demon possession did not come because Jesus had said something small. It came because He had said something enormous.

The greater the grace, and the deeper the truth, the less the natural mind appreciates Christ. He is, indeed, the test of every soul that hears His word. Some attributed to a demon what was infinitely above man, and to the raving that follows such possession. But others felt how far His words were from those of a demon-possessed man, and they bowed to the Divine power that sealed them. In their consciences His words and His works had a completely different character and meaning.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The healed man they could not explain

The objectors do not argue theology. They point at a fact standing in front of them — the beggar of the previous chapter, born blind and now seeing.

The miracle worked on the beggar carried weight with some. Their question proves it. No one working by demon power had ever worked such a miracle. These men admitted that One stood there who was above demons, and who had shown it. The Lord declared that the Shepherd of the sheep stood there. He was about to die for them, would rise again, and would serve their blessing in every way while they remained on earth.

Modernised from C. E. StuartOriginal wording

Scripture had already marked out sight for the blind as a sign of the promised Messiah.

The prophets had testified beforehand that opening the eyes of the blind was a characteristic work of the Messiah (Psalm 146:8; Isaiah 29:18; 35:5; 42:7). The Lord did this both in the temple (Matthew 21:14) and by the roadside (Luke 18:35). What He did for natural sight was only a foretaste of what He would do for spiritual eyes.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

A defence that stops short of faith

Being right about the evidence is not the same as trusting the One it points to. This second group never gets past hesitation.

On the one hand they repeat the old blasphemy, that He had a demon and was raving. Others object to such a verdict, and yet seem to go no further than perplexity. The matter ends for now in nothing but sorrowful indecision.

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

Instead of believing, they reason and demand plainer proof.

Here again, instead of faith we have reasonings and divisions among the people. We cannot arrive at the truth by our reasonings. They appeal to Him: "How long will You keep us in suspense? If You are the Christ, tell us plainly." But what assurance would that give them? A man may say a great many fine things about himself, but why should anyone believe him? Had He not told them very plainly? And yet they had not believed.

Modernised from James BoydOriginal wording

Sharing the verdict of madness

The same split reaction still meets those who follow Him.

On the one hand, His words stirred up a violent hatred that could see in what He said only the ravings of a demon-possessed man. On the other hand, some were perplexed, since common sense knew that neither His words nor His works could be those of a demon. A later Scripture warns us that if we follow the Lord's teaching and go outside the camp to Him, we may have to bear His reproach. The religious world will view such a path as madness or worse.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Summary

- Divided — Three times in John the crowd splits over Christ: over His Person, His work, and His Word. Here it is His words.

- Deeper — The richer the grace He speaks, the less the natural mind can take it in; He is the test of every soul that hears Him.

- Evidence — Opened eyes were a promised mark of the Messiah. No demon's power could copy that work.

- Indecision — Defending Jesus with good sense is not faith. These objectors end in perplexity, then ask Him for plainer proof.

- Reproach — The verdict "He is mad" still falls on those who follow His teaching outside the camp.